This document discusses extractive distillation, a leading-edge technology for recovering aromatics like benzene, toluene, and xylenes from refinery and petrochemical plant processes. Extractive distillation uses selective solvent blends to alter the relative volatility of components in a distillation column, allowing aromatics to be separated from non-aromatics. The key aspects of the extractive distillation process described are that it uses two columns, an extractive distillation column and a solvent recovery column, along with a proprietary solvent blend called Techtiv-100 that enables high recovery of aromatics. Multiple operating parameters of the extractive distillation column impact aromatic recovery, including solvent rate, feed location, solvent
This document discusses extractive distillation, a leading-edge technology for recovering aromatics like benzene, toluene, and xylenes from refinery and petrochemical plant processes. Extractive distillation uses selective solvent blends to alter the relative volatility of components in a distillation column, allowing aromatics to be separated from non-aromatics. The key aspects of the extractive distillation process described are that it uses two columns, an extractive distillation column and a solvent recovery column, along with a proprietary solvent blend called Techtiv-100 that enables high recovery of aromatics. Multiple operating parameters of the extractive distillation column impact aromatic recovery, including solvent rate, feed location, solvent
This document discusses extractive distillation, a leading-edge technology for recovering aromatics like benzene, toluene, and xylenes from refinery and petrochemical plant processes. Extractive distillation uses selective solvent blends to alter the relative volatility of components in a distillation column, allowing aromatics to be separated from non-aromatics. The key aspects of the extractive distillation process described are that it uses two columns, an extractive distillation column and a solvent recovery column, along with a proprietary solvent blend called Techtiv-100 that enables high recovery of aromatics. Multiple operating parameters of the extractive distillation column impact aromatic recovery, including solvent rate, feed location, solvent
This document discusses extractive distillation, a leading-edge technology for recovering aromatics like benzene, toluene, and xylenes from refinery and petrochemical plant processes. Extractive distillation uses selective solvent blends to alter the relative volatility of components in a distillation column, allowing aromatics to be separated from non-aromatics. The key aspects of the extractive distillation process described are that it uses two columns, an extractive distillation column and a solvent recovery column, along with a proprietary solvent blend called Techtiv-100 that enables high recovery of aromatics. Multiple operating parameters of the extractive distillation column impact aromatic recovery, including solvent rate, feed location, solvent
Download as PPT, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
Download as ppt, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 90
Aromatics Recovery
Refinery and petrochemical plant process
for recovery of benzene, toluene, and mixed xylenes
Conventional method: liquid-liquid extraction using sulfolane or glycols
Leading-edge technology: extractive distillation using selective solvent blends
Comparison of Technologies Liquid-liquid extraction:
Reliable, wide reference base in industry High capital cost, feed flexibility issues, limited potential for improvements
Extractive distillation:
Modern technology, low-cost, easy to operate Solvents used until recently, have limitations Solvent Effectiveness Solvent NC7/Benzene Techtiv-100 tm 2.44 Sulfolane 2.00 N-methyl Pyrolidone 1.95 N-formyl Morpholine 1.89 Glycol blends 1.35 None 0.57 Solvent power, solvent selectivity, ability to handle wide-boiling feedstock
Solvent blends offer better performance and high process flexibility
EDC/SRC General Flowscheme Design Features Specialized mass transfer equipment for extractive distillation and solvent recovery columns
Heat integration Extraction block - feed and extract pre-heat, EDC mid-reboiler using lean solvent
Flexibility in adjusting solvent circulation rates for varying feed quality The working principle of ED is the alteration of the relative volatility of components in the presence of a highly selective solvent. In a mixture containing aromatics and non- aromatics, the relative volatility of the non- aromatic components is enhanced over that of aromatic components in the presence of a solvent.
Extractive Distillation This enhancement allows the non-aromatics to be distilled overhead in a conventional distillation column, while the aromatics are recovered in the column bottoms. The solvent used in the GT-BTX process is the proprietary blend, Techtiv-100 tm , which makes it possible to achieve excellent process performance.
Extractive Distillation The general flow scheme of the GT- BTX SM
process is very simple and consists of two major towers: an extractive distillation column (EDC) and a solvent recovery column (SRC).
Extractive Distillation Extractive Distillation Hydrocarbon feed is preheated with hot circulating solvent and fed at mid-point into the EDC. Lean solvent is fed at an upper point and selectively extracts the aromatics into the tower bottoms, in a vapor/liquid distillation operation. The non-aromatic hydrocarbons exit the top of the column and pass through a condenser. A portion of the overhead stream is returned to the top of the column as reflux. This washes back any entrained solvent.
Extractive Distillation Rich solvent from the bottom of the EDC is routed to the SRC, where the aromatics are stripped overhead. Stripping steam is used to facilitate the stripping of the hydrocarbons. The SRC is operated under vacuum to reduce the boiling point at the base of the column. Lean solvent from the bottom of the SRC is passed through a series of heat exchangers, for heat recovery, before returning to the EDC. Extractive Distillation Aromatics overhead product from the SRC is condensed and withdrawn as product. Water from the overhead of the EDC and SRC is collected and vaporized with hot solvent, and used as stripping medium. A solvent regenerator is used to continuously process a small portion of the circulating lean solvent.
Extractive Distillation The regenerator distills the solvent away from heavy decomposition products, which are purged on a periodic basis from the regenerator bottoms. Since the basic separation in the GT-BTX process is achieved by distillation, the operation of the unit is very simple and intuitive. Control of the main process parameters can be achieved in a manner very similar to that for a regular distillation column.
Extractive Distillation The aromatic / non-aromatic separation in the Extractive Distillation Column can be divided into the following two steps: 1. Aromatic recovery from raffinate (non-aromatics) in the top section of the column 2. Stripping the non-aromatic hydrocarbons from the rich solvent in the bottom section of the column
Basic Operating Scheme
Since virtually pure extract is to be produced, the most important performance parameter is the efficient stripping of the non-aromatic from the rich solvent. In the ED process, in the presence of solvent, the heaviest non-aromatics must be more volatile than the lightest aromatics. Basic Operating Scheme
The differences from liquid extraction are: a. Recovery and purification of aromatic occur in the same column b. Higher selectivity c. Direct control of the material balance by reboiler duty and draw-off rate. d. Independent control and adjustment of the hydrocarbon and solvent rate
EDC / SRC Columns
The required solvent rate is based on: a) Achieving the desired aromatic recovery. More solvent will tend to absorb the aromatic more readily. Sufficient solvent should be used to alter the volatility such that benzene remains less volatile than the raffinate stream Solvent Circulation
C 9 Solvent Selectivity toward Petrochemical Hydrocarbons Relative Effect of Polar Solvents on Hydrocarbon Species 5 6 7 8 9 Carbon Number K - V a l u e
Solvent Circulation
b) Maintaining adequate selectivity between aromatic and non-aromatic at the bottom of the EDC. The solvent displays better selectivity at lower hydrocarbon content at the bottom of EDC relatively compared to solvent content.
Solvent Circulation
Solvent Circulation
This means that the higher the aromatic content in the feedstock is, then higher solvent / feed ratio is required to maintain the adequate selectivity. Solvent Circulation
Factors affecting Aromatic recovery The factors affecting recovery of aromatic at a given feed rate are:
1. Solvent rate and feed composition 2. ED Column feed location 3. ED Solvent temperature 4. Water Content in solvent 5. Aromatic content in solvent 6. Feed temperature 7. Reflux Ratio 8. Hydrocarbon content in lean solvent
Aromatic recovery, feed composition, and solvent/feed ratio (S/F) are closely related.
1.Solvent Rate and Feed Composition In general, as the aromatic content in the feed increases under a given solvent to feed ratio, the relative volatility between the solvent and the raffinate phases will be reduced because more aromatics dissolve in the solvent. This requires a higher solvent to feed ratio to maintain product purity and aromatics recovery
1.Solvent Rate and Feed Composition With a fixed number of total stages, the feed point can be adjusted to vary the number of stages above and below the hydrocarbon feed in actual operation in order to meet certain extract purity or aromatic recovery targets. Simply stated, the stages above the feed function to extract aromatic from the hydrocarbon phase and those below the feed to strip the non-aromatic from the rich solvent.
2. ED Column feed location In general, aromatics losses increase when there are fewer stages above the hydrocarbon feed point, while the extract purity will increase by having more stages below the hydrocarbon feed point. More trays below the feed tray are required for high aromatic feed whereas more trays above the feed tray are required for low aromatic feed.
2. ED Column feed location The selectivity ( product purity) is more critical than solvency (product recovery) for high aromatic content in feed, and it is reverse for low aromatic content in feed. As a result, high aromatic feed requires more trays below the feed tray and fewer trays above the feed tray than low aromatic feed.
2. ED Column feed location The temperature of the solvent entering the EDC is an important factor in controlling the aromatic recovery. The solvent temperature also dictates the column temperature profile because the solvent is the greatest bulk flow rate. 3. EDC Solvent Temperature In general: 1. Raising the solvent temperature will improve the recovery of aromatic, through the effect of a higher solvency and reduced viscosity, which improves mass transfer. 2. Raising the temperature slightly lowers the solvent selectivity, which may require a higher heat input (bottoms temperature) to maintain extract quality.
3. EDC Solvent Temperature In general: 3. Raising temperature increases the temperature of the raffinate and increases utility requirements slightly. It is important to control the Lean Solvent feed temperature to within +/- 1-2 degC to ensure stable operation of the EDC
3. EDC Solvent Temperature The water content of the solvent is primarily established by the temperature and pressure at the bottom of the solvent recovery column. Typical water content in the solvent is 0.6-0.8wt%. Water decreases the solubility of hydrocarbons in the solvent and therefore decreases aromatic recovery, but directionally improves the extract quality from EDC.
4. Water Content in Solvent A small amount of water can be added to the base of the EDC, if necessary to keep the EDC bottom temperature lower than 175 o C, to increase the aromatic purity. Benzene recovery versus water content in lean solvent is shown in graph no. 18. 4. Water Content in Solvent 4. Water Content in Solvent Aromatics that are not completely stripped in the SRC and remain in the solvent lead to greater aromatic losses in the EDC than would be experienced with an aromatic-free solvent. The aromatic content of the solvent is depending by the temperature in the base of the solvent recovery column and by the quality of the stripping steam.
5. Aromatic content in Solvent At higher aromatic content or higher molecular weight extract, more stripping steam or a higher bottom temperature will be required to maintain the aromatic below a few tenths of a percent in the solvent.
5. Aromatic content in Solvent Benzene recovery doesnt change rapidly with a change in feed temperature.
6. Feed Temperature 6. Feed Temperature Benzene Recovery vs. Feed Temperature 95.00 96.00 97.00 98.00 99.00 100.00 67 77 87 97 107 117 127 137 147 Feed Temperature, o C B e n z e n e
R e c o v e r y ,
w t % Reflux R/(R+D)=0.15 Reflux R/(R+D)=0.25 Reflux R/(R+D)=0.35 EDC BTM Temperature = Constant; S/F Ratio = 2.2 @ 105 C 7. Reflux Ratio The effect of reflux ratio on benzene recovery at various solvent temperature shown in graph no. 12.
At solvent design temperature, the higher reflux ratio decreases the benzene recovery. 7. Reflux Ratio Benzene Recovery vs. Reflux Ratio 95.0 96.0 97.0 98.0 99.0 100.0 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 Reflux, R/(R+D) B z .
R e c o v e r y ,
w t % Solvent Temp 95 C Solvent Temp 105C Solvent Temp 110C EDC BTM = Const; S/F Ratio = Const Design 8. Hydrocarbon content in Lean Solvent Excessively high hydrocarbon in lean solvent will affect aromatics recovery more than product purity. If the lean solvent includes too high a hydrocarbon, the hydrocarbon can be lost to the raffinate at the EDC as a aromatics reentry loss to raffinate from the lean solvent. In this case, concentration of other aromatics heavier than benzene can be higher than that of benzene in the raffinate product. 8. Hydrocarbon content in Lean Solvent A typical hydrocarbon content in lean solvent is less than 1.0 wt%. However, Hydrocarbon in lean solvent has little effect on product recovery and purity even if the hydrocarbon content in the lean solvent is as high as 5 wt%. The hydrocarbon content in lean solvent is controlled by stripping steam, which is typically 1.2 % -1.8 wt% on lean solvent flow rate for BTX feed. 8. Hydrocarbon content in Lean Solvent If the feed includes heavier components such as heavy aromatics, it will require higher stripping steam ratio than 2 3 wt%. In addition to the stripping steam rate, the followings can help reduce the hydrocarbon in the lean solvent. Decreasing SRC column pressure Increasing SRC bottom temperature ( not higher than 180 oC ) Increasing EDC Bottom temperature Increasing Solvent to feed ratio Factors affecting Aromatic Purity
The factors affecting aromatic purity at a given feed rate are: 1. Solvent flowrate 2. EDC / SRC Pressure 3. Water content in Solvent 4. ED Column Feed Temperature 5. ED Column Bottom Temperature 6. Lean Solvent Temperature 7. Reflux Ratio 1. Solvent Flowrate The selective solvent used in the GT-BTX process alters unequally the volatility of the aromatics and non-aromatics, such that non-aromatics are relatively more volatile. An increase in the amount of solvent increases the activity coefficients of non- aromatics more than those of aromatics and thus improves the separation. 2. EDC/SRC Pressure The EDC pressure must be controlled to permit condensing the overhead vapors with the water cooler, and reboiling of the bottom using the available heat. Design EDC O/H pressure is 1.2 kg/cm2 Higher pressures may result in temperature limitations at the bottom of column In general, as the EDC pressure is increased, the aromatic recovery may increase slightly, the aromatic purity decreases slightly, and the utility costs increase slightly. 2. EDC/SRC Pressure The SRC pressure is mainly determined by the requirements to have a lower bottom temperature, while effectively stripping the aromatic hydrocarbon. Design conditions are: O/H pressure -0.4 kg/cm2 Bottom Temperature 175 degC 3. Water content in Solvent
In general, water in the solvent directionally improves the extract quality, but is detrimental to the aromatic recovery in the EDC. A small amount of water can be added to the base of the EDC to help in rejecting the non-aromatic from the extract. 4. ED Column Feed temperature the benzene purity is not greatly affected up to design feed temperature, but then sharply decrease the benzene purity with increase in feed temperature there after. 4. ED Column Feed Temperature Impurities in EDC Bottoms Stream vs. Feed Temperature 1 100 10,000 67 77 87 97 107 117 127 137 147 Feed Temperature, o C I m p u r i t i e s
i n
E D C
b o t t o m s
s t r e a m ,
w p p m Reflux R/(R+D)=0.15 Reflux R/(R+D)=0.25 Reflux R/(R+D)=0.35 EDC BTM Temperature = Constant; S/F Ratio = 2.2 (by vol) @ 105 C 5. ED Column bottom Temperature
The benzene purity increases with higher than design EDC bottom temperature up to certain range. Typically the benzene purity increases with higher bottom temperature at the cost of higher aromatic content in the raffinate. 6. Lean Solvent Temperature
The effect of lean solvent temperature on benzene purity at constant S/F ratio, reflux ratio and various EDC bottom temperature is shown in graph no. 10. Higher solvent temperature at fixed EDC bottom temperature increases the benzene purity. 6. Lean Solvent Temperature Impurities in the Extract vs EDC Bottom Temperature @ various Solvent Temperatures 1 10 100 1,000 10,000 100,000 150 155 160 165 170 EDC Bottom Temperature, o C I m p u t i r y
i n
E x t r a c t ,
w p p m Solvent Temp = 95 C Solvent Temp=105C Solvent Temp=110C S/F Ratio = Constant; Reflux R/(R+D)=0.25 7. Reflux Ratio
Effect of various reflux ratios for different solvent feed temperatures on benzene purity is shown in graph no. 14. At constant reflux ratio, increase in solvent temperature helps in aromatic purity. 7. Reflux Ratio Impurities in EDC Bottoms vs. Reflux Ratio 1 10 100 1,000 10,000 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.55 Reflux (R/(R+D)) I m p u r i t i e s
i n
E D C
b o t t o m s ,
w p p m Solvent Temp. 95 C Solvent Temp. 105 C Solvent Temp. 110 C EDC BTM Temp.= Const; S/F Ratio = Const. Raffinate product at the top of the EDC could contain some solvent that must be recovered usually by contact with water. Additional fresh water can be brought to the static mixer 106ME-101 to help facilitate the removal of the solvent. The solvent will separate into the water phase and will be recycled to the water stripper.
Water Circulation
The EDC overhead water stream contains some non-aromatic hydrocarbons, which are not desired in the solvent recovery column where could affect the aromatic extract quality. Therefore, this stream needs to be processed in the water stripper by stripping out all hydrocarbon traces. Water Circulation
The water stripper is installed at the top of the steam generator; a small amount of steam is purged out at the top of the stripper together with the stripped non-aromatic hydrocarbon and is sent back to the EDC condenser.
Water Circulation
In general, very small quantity of the total water in circulation needs to be stripped overhead to assure that, when the remainder is vaporized and utilized as stripping steam in the SRC, no non-aromatic components will contaminate the extract.
Water Circulation
The water is used as stripping steam injected into the bottom of the solvent recovery column, and it helps strip aromatics more easily from solvent by reducing hydrocarbon partial pressure at the SRC bottom. The more stripping steam is injected the fewer hydrocarbons in the lean solvent loop remains.
Water Circulation
Typically, the stripping steam ratio will be 1.0 to 3.0 wt% on solvent flow rate. Heavier feed and lower solvent to feed ratio will require more stripping steam.
Water Circulation
The factors which can affect solvent losses and solvent quality are as follows: a. Degradation b. Neutralization c. Solvent losses in the raffinate d. Solvent losses in the extract
Factors affecting solvent losses and solvent quality During use, the solvent usually turns acidic, though the rate of this process differs widely according to the conditions. The pH number quoted throughout for solvent is measured after 1:1 dilution with water. On this basis, fresh solvent has a pH of approximately 6.
a) Degradation The solvent degrades due two primary functions: a. Extreme heat b. Reaction with free oxygen or oxygenates
a) Degradation In practice at temperatures up to 200 o C, there is no acid formation from solvent in an inert atmosphere. Therefore, at all temperatures practically encountered in an extraction process, acid formation has to be attributed to attack of oxygen.
a) Degradation Although the Solvent degradation is minimal up to 200 o C in an inert atmosphere, the SRC bottom temperature should not exceed 180 o C to minimize any potential degradation problem. There are several intermediates leading to polymer and acidic polymer formation, but all are ultimately related to oxygen exposure.
a) Degradation These polymers are only partly soluble in solvent and when present in higher concentration, will appear as solid material that must be removed by way of the solvent regenerator. The preferable countermeasure is to avoid oxygen ingress through the feed, solvent and water rerun systems, and vacuum leaks around the SRC.
a) Degradation In order to protect the equipment from corrosion, it is necessary to neutralize any acidic compound that may be formed. Since the intermediate degradation products are sometimes volatile, neutralization of the material in the extractive distillation and recovery columns is required from the top of the tower downward, along with neutralization of the water circulation system.
b) Neutralization MEA is one most effective neutralizing agent. Pure solvent in a 1:1 dilution with water shows a pH of 5.8, while the pH of the circulating solvent is normally maintained between 5.5 and 6.0 (in a 1:1 dilution with water).
b) Neutralization The MEA dosage can be maintained to keep the solvent pH in this range. It is important not to overdose the system with MEA as MEA could itself be corrosive. The pH of the water circulation loop should also be maintained by MEA addition, keeping the pH between approximately 6.5 and 7.5.
b) Neutralization The MEA salts formed are not completely stable and can decompose at high temperatures (e.g. in the solvent recovery column). However, since both the acidic compounds and MEA are volatile, they will recombine in the top condensing area to form neutral salts. Thus, both phases need to be considered for any pH control program.
b) Neutralization The MEA salts formed are not completely stable and can decompose at high temperatures (e.g. in the solvent recovery column). However, since both the acidic compounds and MEA are volatile, they will recombine in the top condensing area to form neutral salts. Thus, both phases need to be considered for any pH control program.
b) Neutralization The major cause of solvent degradation is the influence of oxygen. If oxygen ingress could be completely prevented, regeneration of solvent would probably be eliminated. All extraction plant corrosion, fouling, and the solvent appearance concerns can in most cases be traced back to changes in oxygen intake via a feed system or vacuum leaks.
b) Neutralization Process losses of solvent may be to the raffinate, the extract, or the regenerator bottoms. The last is related to the draw off of decomposition products, the formation of which is largely controlled by excluding air from the feed and preventing air leaks into the plant.
b) Neutralization The GT-BTX unit has been designed to have very little solvent going to the overhead of the EDC. The solvent has a low volatility and therefore goes to the tower bottoms. However, there may be a small quantity of solvent entrained into the overhead vapors.
c) Solvent Losses in the Raffinate Thus, the solvent losses to the raffinate can be controlled as follows: 1. Avoidance of solvent in the overhead by using hydrocarbon reflux and temperature adjustments. Directionally, a higher reflux rate and lower solvent temperature will reduce solvent in the raffinate.
c) Solvent Losses in the Raffinate Graph no. 3 shows the solvent losses in the raffinate at a constant EDC bottom temperature with constant S/F ratio with various feed temperatures. c) Solvent Losses in the Raffinate c) Solvent Losses in the Raffinate Graph no. 11 shows the solvent losses at various solvent temperatures with various reflux ratios (R/(R+D)).
c) Solvent Losses in the Raffinate c) Solvent Losses in the Raffinate The larger the reflux ratio is, the less solvent losses become. The solvent losses tend to decrease as the lean solvent temperature decreases. The solvent losses due to higher solvent temperature can be compensated for by properly increased reflux.
c) Solvent Losses in the Raffinate 2. Phase separation of the solvent into the water phase in the overhead accumulator system. The distribution of solvent into water is approximately 100 times greater than into non-aromatic hydrocarbons.
c) Solvent Losses in the Raffinate c) Solvent Losses in the Raffinate Wash water can be recirculated around the EDC overhead receiver, through a static mixer in order to enhance the water-hydrocarbons contact. Fresh makeup water mixed with SRC ovhd vapors as necessary and thus makeup water added to the system. The tendency of solvent losses with the ratio of H2O / HC is shown in graph no. 9. c) Solvent Losses in the Raffinate Solvent Content in the Raffinate vs. H20/HC mole ratio 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 0.12 0.24 0.36 0.48 0.60 0.72 0.84 0.96 1.08 1.20 H2O/HC mole Ratio (@ EDC Ovhd. Receiver) Solvent Content in Raffiante, wppm 10 wppm of solvent in Mixer feed 25 wppm of solvent 50 wppm of solvent 100 wppm of solvent Solvent Temp. & S/F : Constant; Reflux rate : const d) Solvent Losses in the Extract
The primary control parameter for solvent losses in the SRC overhead is the column reflux. The top tray vapor from the solvent recovery column contains pure aromatic, water, (that originated as steam in the base of the column), and potential traces of solvent. This mixture is condensed and separated into an aqueous phase and a hydrocarbon phase.
d) Solvent Losses in the Extract Part of the hydrocarbon phase is withdrawn as extract, and part is returned to the top of the column as reflux to reduce the amount of solvent in the overhead. As in the EDC, the small amount of solvent which does go overhead will distribute between aqueous and hydrocarbon phases. Any solvent in the extract will be lost in the fractionation, while any solvent in the aqueous phase will be recovered in the system. d) Solvent Losses in the Extract The solvent content of the overhead can never be reduced to zero, so the optimum loss must be based on economic considerations. The higher the reflux/extract ratio, the lower the loss and the higher the utility consumption. d) Solvent Losses in the Extract A second possibility for solvent losses in extract product is caused by entrainment from the flashing feed. The SRC column has been designed to minimize entrainment, but it is possible to further reduce this tendency by -Increasing SRC column pressure Decreasing SRC bottom temperature Lowering EDC Bottom temperature Decreasing stripping steam rate Decreasing solvent to feed ratio subject to other conditions. SUMMARY Major changes Solvent/Feed ratio Trim changes EDC bottoms temperature Reflux Maintain clean solvent SRC bottoms temperature Stripping steam Recycle to feed tank either BOTH raffinate and extract, or NONE