10 DMAIC Tools
10 DMAIC Tools
10 DMAIC Tools
Capability
Process sigma
Process sigma calculation
calculation
©Triumph DMAIC, EL OTMANI Hicham 2
Define
• One page report which define the reasons of undertaking the project, business
Project case, objectives, constraints and team
charter • In scope and out of scope items and data collection plan
3
• Summarize causes, actions, deadlines and results
• Structures the project via the DMAIC approach including major milestones
Waste walk • Physical observation of the flow to identify and eliminate waste
Benchmarking • Compare and find best practice from other similar processes or companies
• Achieve Zero Defects, Zero Breakdown and Zero accidents in all functional
areas of the organization.
TPM
• Involve people at all levels of organization.
• Form different teams to reduce defects and drive Self Maintenance.
• Control the measure that is being put in place its impact and continuity
Control plan • Define measures and their frequency
Control chart • Determine if a manufacturing or business process is in a state of statistical
control
Process sigma
• Statistical calculation to audit and control result
calculation
5 Ws
•Who is it about?
• Line efficiency
•What happened?
• Efficiency drop down
• “How?”
• Daily average drop down
o Each question should have a factual answer — facts necessary to include for a report
to be considered complete.
o Importantly, none of these questions can be answered with a simple "yes" or "no
SIPOC:Supplier/Input/Process/Output/Customers
SIPOC
A tool used to identify and categorize the parts of a process as relating to
either the suppliers, inputs, process, outputs, or customers.
Counting
Work Study AD
Assembly operations
VOC :
Collective insight into customer needs, wants, perceptions, and preferences gained
through direct and indirect questioning. These discoveries are translated into meaningful
objectives that help in closing the gap between customer expectations and the firm's
offerings.
CTQ tree Aspect CTQ Definition Spec
VOC Quality
97%
Service OTIF
General Specific
Not© easy to measure Easy to measure
Triumph DMAIC, EL OTMANI Hicham 11
Define Measure Analyse Improve Control
Seam w idth
Soiling Defects improvement
Current Issues-
Delays AQL improvement
Nos. of Hand offs Rew ork/Yield improvement
Rolled Yield Process Metrics
% Defect Scrap Rework
RM Handwork Environment
Root cause 1
Effect Root cause 2
3. ANALYSIS Root cause 3
Business Metrics
Hard($) Soft($) Others(eg C.sat.)
Missing label in
finished good
Key Changes-
6. LEARNINGS
1. OBJECTIVES
©Triumph
Machine / Tools Method
DMAIC, EL OTMANI Hicham 12
Define Measure Analyse Improve Control
Stakeholder analysis
Managerial step taken to identify each stockholder's level of interest or
involvement in a given project and how that involvement can influence the
project. Based on this analysis, project managers may alter how a project will be
executed or decide the necessary steps that must be taken in order to limit a
stockholder's influence over the project.
→
StakeHolder Analysis
Lines Sup
Influence / Power of stakeholders Mecanic
HR
Method
Controllers
Packaging
WBS
Deliverable oriented decomposition of a project into smaller components.
1-
Project : efficiency
drop down
TRANSPORT
(Too much / too fast)
STOCK
(Excessive stock)
REWORK
(Rework / Repair)
WAITING
(Idle-Time)
OVER-PROCESSING
(Not adding to value)
MOTION
(Inefficient movement)
7 Wastes
©Triumph DMAIC, EL OTMANI Hicham 15
Define Measure Analyse Improve Control
Prioritization matrix
These are used in process improvement to help prioritize decisions. The
Prioritization Matrix is used to sort a list of items into an order of importance
Prioritization matrices are especially useful if problem-solving resources, such
as people, time or money, are limited, or if the identified problem-solving
actions or CTQ s are strongly interrelated.
→
Prioritization Matrix
Importance (revenue, cost-saving, risk of not doing…)
Increasing
Ensure the AD operators
reliability flexibility
Training and
monitoring of
Workstation
sewing operators
arrangement
Motivation of
operators
Checking the
level of difficulty
Periodic of each operation
maintenance of
machine
Process mapping
Sewing execution
This process is done to execute sewing operations by operators.
N
Monitor
Verify machin with Monitor Operator
Method Description New Show operator * sew a batch Finished
Operator Method & operation /
(Setting + Accessories + operation / how to perform * Write operator’s Number in
Sew some Quality
Sewing Dept
N
Y
N
Quality
VSM
CUSTOMERS
PLANNING
400 products
ROLLING FORECASTS
MRPII + 40,000 ca./ month
4 week leadtime
MANUAL SYSTEMS
PURCHASE FIRM 50% service level !
ORDERS ORDERS
SUPPLIERS
Measure Definition Calculation mode Sources Data collection Who ? When Frequency
Y Efficiency Produced mins/Presence mins-minutes HR IT Prod Estelle IT prod employe Feb 2013 monthly
X1 OEE Produced minutes/ ( presence+absence) Controlling Estelle Sara Feb 2013 monthly
Time Between preparation and expedition
X2 Leadtime of commission Planning Estelle Planning employe Feb 2013 monthly
Check sheet
A document used to collect data, such as machine performance statistics, during
the troubleshooting process. It is generally a simple form that can be filled out
on the shop floor.
Check sheet
Name of data recorder : NF
Location : Sewing Lines Fez
Data collection dates : Week 9……………………………………………………….
Dates
Event occurrence Monday Tuesday Wednsday Thursday Friday Saturday Total
Total 21 21 24 22 20 10 118
Benchmarking
Compare and find best practice from other similar processes or companies
Capability
Measure of the ability of a process to achieve its objectives, KPIs...
Affinity diagram
Idea n°1 Idea n°2 Idea n°3 Idea n°4
Data
Training Machine errors Workstation
arrangement
breakdown
Demonstration Missing
motivation
Operator
competences
Flexibility
Operators
Turn Over
Flow analysis
The performance is used to chart a process flow from “dock to dock”
using ASME symbols (American Society of Mechanical Engineers).
Process Flow Step Measure Process Waste Identified Lean Manufacture Potential
Nº Qty. Time Dist. Description & Category of waste Man M/c Mat'ls. Meth. Envir. Maint.
Brainstorming
Brainstorming is a group or
individual creativity technique by which
efforts are made to find a conclusion for
a specific problem by gathering a list of
ideas spontaneously contributed by its
member(s).
Progress :
Enunciate topic
Establish a Rememb One by one
and display it on
working er golden team members
the board as
group rules gives ideas
©Triumph
question
DMAIC, EL OTMANI Hicham 26
Define Measure Analyse Improve Control
5 Whys
The 5 Whys is an iterative question-asking technique used to explore the cause-and-
effect relationships underlying a particular problem. (The "5" in the name derives from
an empirical observation on the number of iterations typically required to resolve the
problem.)
Ishikawa diagram
Handwork Machine
Training Labours Turn Over
Spareparts
reworks Machine breakdown
Flexibility Maintenance
Communication
AD
Bonus
Missing motivation
Efficiency drop down
Arrangement
workstation
Quality Supplier Design Technical Data Errors
Internal
Novelties
Fabric
Environment
process
Detection
Failure root after the
The loss of an causes implementation of
intended function the countermeasure
Immediate
of a device under
consequences Occurrence
stated conditions
of a failure RPN after the
=SxOxD implementation of
the countermeasure
Severity
after the
implementation of
the countermeasure
Histogram
A graphical representation, similar to a bar chart in structure, that organizes a group
of data points into user-specified ranges. The histogram condenses a data series into
an easily interpreted visual by taking many data points and grouping them into logical
ranges or bins.
Histogram : % Efficiency
25
20
15
10
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Pareto
This is also called the Pareto principle or the 80/20 rule and is used the Vital few Xs
Cut-off level to be decided by team consensus based on
Process knowledge
Resource availability
600
500
400
300
200
100
er
n
rs
s
es
ks
n
es
ts
y
or
ow
io
ilit
ov
rro
en
or
lt i
nc
at
at
ib
ve
kd
ew
rn
em
le
er
te
tim
ex
ea
No
Tu
pe
a
p
ng
Fl
es
O
ic
br
rs
ra
rs
ed
er
ch
co
ne
to
to
ar
in
ov
Te
ra
hi
ra
rs
tr a
n
pe
ac
s
pe
t io
to
in
Un
ra
O
M
ta
M
pe
ks
O
or
W
©Triumph DMAIC, EL OTMANI Hicham 31
Define Measure Analyse Improve Control
Scatter plot
A graph of plotted points that show the relationship
between two sets of data. Average Quality
efficiency after defect
In this example, each dot represents the defect rate 6 months rate
versus their % efficiency. 65% 3%
45% 6%
35% 5%
Scatter chart 66% 3%
25% 8%
9% 20% 5%
8%
95% 1%
41% 5%
7% 32% 6%
6% 33% 2%
50% 1%
Quality
5% 24% 8%
4% 21% 6%
3%
2%
1%
0%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
Efficiency
Future state
Standardize work
By documenting the current best practice,
standardized work forms the baseline for
kaizen or continuous improvement.
5S
Organize workspace for efficiency and effectiveness basis for discipline
Sort Straighten
5D analysis
Define containment then identify potential correctives and preventives actions
Efficiency drop What? The efficiency Double workstations to •More •Training and
Down drop down avoid bottlenecks demonstration of monitoring of sewing
* Machine breakdown
Where? Sewing lines operation. operators
* Untrained Operators
• Periodic
* Operators competences maintenance of
How many? -10 % •Checking the level
*Operators Turn over of difficulty of machine
* Reworks each operation
When? 2012 * Operators Flexibility • Ensure the AD •Increasing operators
reliability flexibility
* Technical errors
* Workstation arrangements
• Workstation •Motivation of
arrangement operators
Control plan
A document that sets the limits within which the process should operate. This
tool lists specific process activities and then states the variables or risks
affecting them, as well as their specifications.
% Efficiency 2012
100,00
90,00
80,00
70,00
60,00
%
50,00
40,00
30,00
20,00
10,00
0,00
e
r
in
t
il
e
ai
re
e
s
ie
ie
ille
oû
br
vr
br
ar
br
Ju
M
ob
vr
nv
em
A
Ju
em
M
m
Fé
Ja
ct
te
ov
éc
O
ep
D
S
Months
Defects improvement
AQL improvement
Rew ork/Yield improvement
Process Metrics
% Defect Scrap Rework
Business Metrics
Hard($) Soft($) Others(eg C.sat.)
Control Chart
Process audit
Evaluation of an organization, system, process, enterprise,
project or product.
WP
Quick Change Total
Cutural Organization Standardized Flexible Continuous Material Level
Error Proofing Over Productive
Awareness & Visual Work Operations Improvement Control Production
Capability Maintenance
Management
Supplier - Level 2
Ford - Level 2 6,8 8,4 7,8 7,5 3,6 3,4 7,5 5,0 5,8 10,0
Cutural Awareness
10,0
6,0
4,0
Material Control Standardized Work
2,0
0,0
Error Proofing
©Triumph DMAIC, EL OTMANI Hicham Supplier - Level 2 43
Ford - Level 2
We are in to win together