United Airlines Group4

United Airline’s Service-
Recovery Challenge After

Reputation Meltdown
Group 4:
Hemant Gupta
P Chandra Priyan
Rohit Yadav
Sreekar JP
Few things about United Airlines
• World’s third largest carrier: measurement of revenue & passenger miles flown
• Met various operational key performance indicators; 25 zero cancellation days
• Embedded sustainability into operations
• Source of many controversies
About Aviation Industry

• Highly competitive
• Price-sensitive industry
• Operational efficiency of top priority
• Overselling & overbooking a norm
• Department of Transportation (US):
a) Allowed overbooking
b) If excess passengers, volunteer passengers can rebook + compensation
c) Allowed airlines to randomly deny boarding & compensate
What happened on United Flight 3411? : The Issue
• Date: April 9, 2017 : Chicago-Lousville
• Last Ditch Emergency: Needed to fly 4 staff members to a connecting destination
• 4 passengers on Flight 3411 needed to be bumped to another flight to free-up 4 seats
What was done?

• After boarding plane, crew announced that they want 4 passengers to deboard voluntarily
• Incentives For them: a) $400 in voucher for future travel, later revised to $800
b) Hotel Stay
c) Seat on plane leaving more than 21 hours later
• No passenger was willing to deplane
• Hence, computer algorithm would randomly select four passengers to leave flight (apart
from frequent fliers and premium price payers)
The Aftermath
• This stunt was within the law
• One of the victims: Mr. Dao needed to attend several patient the next day
• He refused to deplane, was forcefully deplaned bloody & bruised
• Incident created backlash across social media

• Passengers began to boycott United, especially in China
• Impact on stock prices: $250 million dip in market value • Worked to optimised its network
• Considered to be a “brand suicide” & a “PR failure” potential
• Cost structure improvements
• Competitors leveraged the incident: • Decrease Costs related to delays
- “We beat competition. Not You”
and cancellations
- “We would like to remind you that drags on our flights are strictly prohibited”
- “shame for airline industry as a whole”

Statements Made by Munoz
5:07 AM: Non-committal

9:27 AM: Apologised for “re-accommodation” of passengers, assured a
personal meeting with affected passenger
To employees: Acknowledged employees’ following of protocol in
handling situation
“Reluctant to offer complete apology for fear of lawsuits & attempt to downplay incident”
“No willingness to rectify incident”
After 27 hrs:
• Called incident “truly horrific” & accepted responsibility
Service Failure
• A service failure, simply defined, is service performance that fails to
meet a customer's expectations
Root Causes For Service Failure here:

a) Little/No provisions for Service Recovery
b) Lack of value based & need based approach segmentation
c) Over-emphasis on achieving efficiency
c) In-efficient existing CRM systems
Explanation
• Failure to understand that:
Cost of Replacing Customers >> Cost of Retaining them (~5 times more)
• “Quality-Control Movement” inhibits recovery skills:

Airline companies have spent past few decades in making service delivery systems
EFFICIENT & STREAMLINED
• Too much emphasis on providing “standard service” and doing everything to ensure
that – “the protocol”
• Working towards “zero defects”: Failure to understand that “zero defects” in

services is a myth; Variability a norm
• Sophisticated technologies introduced to enact strict policies to control employee

behaviour
• Fair treatment
• Over-compensate for incurred hidden
costs (since mistake was on United)
• Expect Sensitive & willingness to rectify
problem
• How did they develop over time?
• Steep Drop in Reputation
• 79% of prospective consumers AWARE of
incident chose to fly with competitors
• 44% of these didn’t mind paying more
(crucial in a price sensitive industry)
• Maintained operational efficiency
• Completely lacked facility for service
recovery
NO GAP: Followed
Standard • Poorly handled PR
Procedure • Statements made by Mr. Munoz
Approx Price in Dollars
• Severely failed to understand or Cost of Flight (CHI
to Louisville) 108
measure the HIDDEN COSTS involved Per Appointment
(in this case of Mr. Dao) Fee 60 + Test Charges
Bad Reputation due to no-
• Didn’t go extra yard to cover costs show; loss of clients in
• Poor tone of response future; decreased client
Hidden Costs lifetime value
Importance of CRM for Airlines
• Intense competition, “fast follower approach” &
technology-> led to operational improvements & hence, • Frequent Flier Programs
cost cutting
• Existing CRM systems a result of “catching up” rather • Site Personalisation
than for differentiation • Kiosks
• CRM has been commoditised: indistinguishable services • Web-Based Customer Services
• Self-Service Provisions
• Manage customer relationships to optimize customer • Internet Check-ins
loyalty and revenues
• Online Baggage Tracking
• Flight notification systems
Changes in CRM approaches needed (for Airlines)
• Customer segmentation—
- Need to move towards value-based and needs-based approaches can help
guide investment decisions and drive greater insight into the needs of high-
value customers.
• CRM initiative development—
- Abandon a “fast follower” approach to CRM initiative development, in
favour of investing in initiatives with a high return, which respond to the
needs and desires of their own customers.
• Organizational design and management—
- Airlines need to instil a service mentality in their employees, empowering
them with a complete view of the customer and clearly articulating the
employee’s role in the CRM strategy.
Source: IBM Institute for Business Value
Road to Service Recovery
• Listen closely to complaints
• Anticipate needs for recovery
• Train employees
• Empower the front line
• Closing the customer feedback loop
Anticipating the needs for recovery in United
• Identify staff transport prior to the boarding of passengers
• Over booking issue:
• Minimize over booking through better demand forecasting methods
• In case of overbooking,
• Notify passengers about the overbooking prior to entering the flight (i.e. at the gate or while
providing boarding pass)
• More authority to the front-line staff (especially the staff at the gate) to identify and persuade the
potential volunteers
• If no volunteers, Identify potential passengers who are low on priority list and persuade them with
lucrative services/offers, thus creating a win-win situation
• Use customer value to differentiate the services – key to effective CRM
Training and empowering front-line employees
• Training the front line employees to both adhere to the standard
operating procedure and at the same time open to breaking rules for
customer at the time of crisis
• Programs with innovative methods to encourage staff to empathize with
customers should be conducted
• Communicate the importance of customer value
• Transparency among staff at different points of customer interaction for
consistent and seamless service
• Appropriate incentives to encourage the deepening of customer
relations
Rebuilding Brand Image
• Cultural shift – Training and encouraging staff to be more customer centric
through allowances, incentives and training programs
• Encourage customers to share their experience with the staff on social
media
• Address customer needs through out the cycle
• Closing the customer feedback loop – acknowledging and responding
• For expensive product service problem

costs(>$100),
- 54% maintain brand loyalty if problem
resolved
- Only 19% repeat purchase if NOT
resolved
Source: Profitable Art of Service Recovery
Concluding Remarks…
• Surest Way to recover from service mishap: Workers front front-line
to identify & solve problem
- Requires decision making & rule-breaking (exactly what employees
have been conditioned against)
• Service Recovery is an oppurtunity
• Compliment production oriented systems with equal facility for
service recovery
• Emphasis on creating customer lifetime value (charge premium later)

United Airlines Group4

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

United Airlines Group4

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

United Airlines Group4

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

United Airline’s Service-

Recovery Challenge After

About Aviation Industry

What was done?

• Incident created backlash across social media

- “shame for airline industry as a whole”

5:07 AM: Non-committal

Root Causes For Service Failure here:

• “Quality-Control Movement” inhibits recovery skills:

• Working towards “zero defects”: Failure to understand that “zero defects” in

• Sophisticated technologies introduced to enact strict policies to control employee

• For expensive product service problem

You might also like