Electrical Equipment in Hazardous Areas - Upload
Electrical Equipment in Hazardous Areas - Upload
Electrical Equipment in Hazardous Areas - Upload
Elstan A Fernandez
for free distribution
Objectives
Fuel
Gas,
vapours or
powder
Chain
Reaction
Ignition Oxidiser
Source Air or O2
Thermal or
Electric
The Dust Explosion Pentagon
el Ig
nit
Fu ion
ent
Dust
Disp
finem
Explosion
Pentagon
ersio
Con
n
Oxygen
Read
Details
The Incipient Flame Sphere
The Incipient Flame Sphere must reach a critical diameter if
combustion is to become a self-propagating explosion.
the
The Incipient Flame Sphere
If the initial spark is not large enough, (i.e. does not possess enough
energy), the combustion zone will not have enough energy to self
propagate. It will just collapse upon itself, and fizzle out.
This means a small spark can occur in a potentially explosive air/gas
mixture, with no danger of an explosion.
The maximum amount of energy of this “safe” spark varies with the
specific air/gas mixture present.
Extract from ABS Rules for Building and Classing Steel Vessels - 2005
Part 4 Vessel Systems and Machinery
Chapter 1 General
Section 1 Classification of Machinery
Quote
1.9.4 Hazardous Area 4-1-1/1.9.4
Areas where flammable or explosive gases, vapors, or dust are normally
present or likely to be present are known as hazardous areas. Hazardous areas
are however more specifically defined for certain machinery installations, storage
spaces and cargo spaces that present such hazard, e.g.:
helicopter refueling facilities, see 4-8-4/27.3.3;
paint stores, see 4-8-4/27.3.3;
cargo oil tanks and other spaces of oil carriers; see 5-1-7/31.5;
ro-ro cargo spaces; see 5-10-4/3.9.2.
Unquote
Classification of Hazardous Materials
(The American System)
Class 1 : Flammable gases or vapours
Class 2 : Combustible dusts
Class 3 : Fibres or flyings (particles normally suspended in air)
Class 1: The following groups are listed in the most dangerous to
the least dangerous ones:
Group A : Acetylenes
Group B : Hydrogen, Hydrogen mixtures
Group C : Ethylene, Ethers, Some Aldehydes
Group D: Alkanes (Butane, Ethane, Methane, Octane, Propane),
Hydrocarbon mixtures (Diesel oil, Kerosene, Petroleum mixtures,
Gasoline), Alcohol, Ketones, Esters, Amines, Alkenes, Benzoids
Class 2 (Combustible Dusts):
Group E : Metallic Dusts (resistivity < 100 kΩ/cm)
Group F, Group G : Non-conductive dusts (agri, plastic, chemical
and textile dusts – resistivity > 100 kΩ/cm).
Hazardous Areas Onboard Ships
When a ship is involved in its normal operational functions there will be some
areas and zones where flammable gases can accumulate in the atmosphere and
present a hazard to the ship, its crew and other personnel who may be onboard.
Such areas are defined as hazardous and classified in terms of the risks involved.
For example, IEC Publication 79-10 defines three such categories:
Zone 0: The flammable mixture is continuously present or present for long
periods.
Zone 1: The flammable mixture is not continuously present, but will be present
during normal operations.
Zone 2: The flammable mixture would not normally be present, but if it is, it would
be present for a short period only.
(Note: Zones 0 and 1 is also known as Division 1 while Zone 2 is known as
Division 2) Continued…
Hazardous Areas Onboard Ships
Hydrocarbon gases or vapours from crude oil form highly flammable mixtures
with air when they are present in the proportion between 1% and 10%
hydrocarbon with 99% down to 90% normal air.
Below the lower explosive limit (LEL) the mixture is too lean to burn rapidly,
although a lean mixture will burn slowly in the presence of a naked flame or a
spark, as is proved by the operation of explosimeters in this range.
Over-rich mixtures exist when the level of the hydrocarbon exceeds 10%.
Read
Details
Class I Certified Equipment Comparison Chart
Cargo Tanks
General Tanker Arrangement showing Hazardous Areas and Normally Safe Areas
Potential Sources of Ignition
Switch C V Switch L V
Hazardous Hazardous
Safe Area Area Safe Area
Area
Switch V
Hazardous
Area Safe Area
Potential Sources of Ignition
Explosion Possible!
Conventional equipment and cables are suitable for areas that are considered safe.
Continued…
Potential Sources of Ignition
Continued…
Potential Sources of Ignition
There are several ways in which this sufficient charge becomes a hot spark
– capable of igniting a flammable mixture. This might involve the
introduction of metal objects into a tank. Objects which may have caused a
spark include:
Hand-held metal ullage tapes
Metal sample cans
Metal sounding rods
Ungrounded portable washing machines
! Do not introduce metal objects into the tank, other than a grounded washing machine.
Nameplate for Equipment used in Hazardous Areas
BS 5501 Pt 5 d IIB T4 Group I is gas encountered in coal mining where methane and
coal dust constitute the risks.
BASEEFA No. Ex 2833010 Group II comprises gases such as cellulose vapour, petrol,
benzene, amyl acetate. Group II may be further sub-divided
into:
Flame Path
Joint
Inside
Flame Path
Inside
Click on the image for animation Click on the image for animation
Flame Path
Glass
Flame-proof (Ex d) Equipment
Advantages
1. Explosion Containment
2. No Electronics
3. Low Maintenance
4. No Moving Parts
5. High-Powered Equipment
Disadvantages
1. No warning mechanism for containment failure
2. Danger to Equipment After Explosions
3. Possibility of Installation/Maintenance Errors
4. Cost of Protection per ft3 Increases with Enclosure Size
5. Windows are Limited
6. Condensation build-up is common
7. Few sizes to choose from
8. Cumbersome, Limited Access
9. Bulky Designs
10. Causes Harmful Heat Build up
11. Excessive Weight
Pressurised (Ex p) Equipment
Zone 2 (Non Hazardous Area) Zone 1 (Hazardous area) Zone 2 (NHA)
1 2 3 2 4 2 5 6
Over Pressure
0
External Pressure
(1) Protective Gas Inlet (2) Ducting (3) Fan (4) Enclosure (5) Manometer (6) Solenoid Valve
1 2 3 2 4 2 5 6
Over Pressure
0
B
External Pressure
(1) Protective Gas Inlet (2) Ducting (3) Fan (4) Enclosure (5) Manometer (6) Solenoid Valve
Pressurised (Ex p) Equipment with Leakage Compensation
Rotating Electrical Machine with an Internal fan
Pressurised (Ex p) Equipment
1 2 3 2 4 2 5 6
Over Pressure
0
External Pressure
(1) Protective Gas Inlet (2) Ducting (3) Fan (4) Enclosure (5) Manometer (6) Solenoid Valve
• Intrinsic safety removes the ignition side from the fire triangle.
1) Zener barrier:
This works on the principle of diverting hazardous energy to the
ground safely before it can reach the hazardous area. Zener diodes
limit the fault voltage to the hazardous area. There are two such
diodes for redundancy. The series resistor limits the current to the
hazardous area.
The zener barrier is a loop which can restrict the current by the
resistor.
At the same time it must allow the loop to function normally by
allowing the required values of current to flow in normal operation to
enable the instrument in the safe area to operate to full range.
Intrinsic Safety (Ex i) Barriers
1) Zener barrier:
The series resistor limits the current to the hazardous area.
The zener barrier is a loop which can restrict the current by the
resistor.
At the same time it must allow the loop to function normally by
allowing the required values of current to flow in normal operation to
enable the instrument in the safe area to operate to full range.
Intrinsically Safe (Ex i) Barriers
Intrinsic Safety (Ex i) Barriers
Intrinsically Safe (Ex i) Barriers
Field Device
HAZARDOUS AREA
Intrinsic Safety (Ex i) Barriers
2) Active Barrier:
The active barrier uses transformers, opto isolators and relays to
provide the isolation between the safe and unsafe areas.
It does not require an intrinsically safe ground connection.
This is the safest barrier to use if a high quality intrinsically safe
ground connection is not available.
The active barrier can drive a higher power load as compared to a
zener barrier.
Intrinsic Safety (Ex i) Barriers
Intrinsically Safe (Ex i) Barriers
Advantages:
4. The cost of replacing the Zener barrier exceeds the cost of TIB.
1. Any device which does not fall into the category of a simple
apparatus must be certified. This includes transmitters, solenoids,
etc which store energy .
2. A barrier cannot be used to make an uncertified device in the
hazardous area safe. If the field device is uncertified it can have
energy storing components. In the event of a fault this energy can
be released to ignite the flammable gases.
3. The barrier only protects the hazardous area from the energy
released from the safe area’s uncertified devices.
4. An intrinsic safety barrier thus enables a non certified device in the
safe area to be connected to a simple device or a certified device in
the hazardous area and is an energy limiting device.
Certification
Cable capacitance
and inductance
Ignition Curves
Since the relays require very little power they do not affect the
operation of other equipment connected.
Intrinsically Safe Relays
• Diodes are connected in series with the hazardous area input / and
or output terminals to make them electrically equivalent to ‘simple
apparatus’, ie, they can be included in any IS lop without any IS
certification.
Intrinsically Safe Relays
• These relays present volt free contacts to the Safe area in response
to the Hazardous area coils.
Programmable Relays
Intrinsically Safe Relays
Programmable Relays
Intrinsically Safe Relays
Programmable Relays
Other Ex Equipment