Chapter 3
Chapter 3
Chapter 3
1
Ethics and Accounting
The word “ethics” is derived from the Greek
word of “ethos” which means the character,
spirit and attitudes of a group of people or
culture.
Ethics relate to morals & treating of morals
questions. Ethics also indicate a philosophical
reflections on moral beliefs & practices.
Accounting is an area of human activity
which tends to be considered as neutral &
value free.
This means that when preparing accounting
information certain requirements will be
applied but no moral adherence.
2
Ethics and Accounting
As a result, accountants do not
consider their social roles as moral
agents, because accounting has no
substantial moral dimensions.
How do you see this point of view?
Do you agree that accounting activities
to be value-free?
3
Ethics and Accounting
Ethics should be implanted into
accounting practices, because “ethics”
distinguish right from wrong, or good
from bad, justice from injustice.
Muslim accountants are expected to
behave religiously and ethically during
their professional practices.
Muslim accountants have the Islamic
obligation to: shareholders, creditors,
employees, suppliers, the state, and
the public.
4
Ethics and Accounting
Accountants are also considered as
gatekeepers of financial markets.
7
AAOIFI’s code of ethics for
accountants
Shariah foundation of accounting
ethics are:
• Integrity,
• Vicegerency,
• Sincerity
• Piety
• Righteousness
• Allah’s fearing, and
• Accountability to ALLAH
8
AAOIFI’s code of ethics for
accountants
Ethical principles of accounting are
include:
• Trustworthiness
• Legitimacy
• Objectivity
• Professional competence & diligence
• Faith-driven conduct, and
• Professional conduct & technical
standards.
From the shariah foundation & the
principles, rules are developed. See
pages 43-45. 9
Incorporating Islamic ethics in
accounting education
It is not enough to have an ethical
code of ethics.
Ethical code of conduct is only an
operational guide to give awareness
to the accounting students.
AAOIFI code of conduct serves as a
collection of Islamic ethical concepts
and principles but lacks operational
guide on how to impart the Islamic
ethical principles into the Islamic
financial institutions.
10
Incorporating Islamic ethics in
accounting education
AAOIFI tried to develop professional
code of conduct to set a filter
mechanism to resolve the accounting
challenges.
It is suggested that professional ethics
should be incorporated into the
curriculum of tertiary and professional
education.
There are 3 models of ethics education
in degree programs.
Incorporating Islamic ethics in
accounting education
Devote half a semester of
introduction to business course to
general ethics.
Integrate ethics into each & every
accounting course throughout the
program.
Develop a capstone course at the
senior level that deals with critical
issues of social responsibility.
Incorporating Islamic ethics in
accounting education
The author suggested to introduce the
capstone course for the final year students
of accounting.
This capstone course will cover the main
aspects of Islamic Worldview such as:
• Tawhid
• The role of INSAN in this world as a vicegerent.
• That the success of the hereafter depend on
the success of this worldly life.
13
Incorporating Islamic ethics in
accounting education
According to the author, a well
designed ethics education is essential
to deal with the current critical issues
of the accounting failure in the capital
markets.
In addition, ethical commitment of
the accounting practitioners is
necessary.
14
Islamic ethical principles of Maslaha
and Accounting ethics
The principle objective of the shariah
is the realization of benefits to the
people.
There are 3 areas of the primary
shariah objectives:
• To educate individuals
• To establish justice
• To realize maslaha to the people.
15
Islamic ethical principles of Maslaha
and Accounting ethics
Maslaha as a principle of legal
reasoning to argue that “good” is
lawful and that “lawful” must be
good.
Thus, maslaha concerns:
• Substance of human life.
• Completion of human livelihood
• Protection of interests which is classified
into:
Essentials
Complementary, and
Embellishment 16
وما ارسلناك اال رحمة للعالمين
“And We have sent you (O Muhammad) not
but a mercy to the whole universe”
(Al-Ambiya:107)
Alleviate Hardship Eliminate Prejudice
Establish Justice
Essentials
Maqasid as-Shari’ah
(The Objectives of
Shari’ah)
Religion
Wealth
Intellect
Life Posterity
18
Islamic ethical principles of Maslaha
and Accounting ethics
19
Islamic ethical principles of Maslaha
and Accounting ethics
Generally, the principle of maslaha
gives a guidelines to the accountants
and the professionals to enable them
for making decision relating
accounting information.
But the decision and judgments on
accounting information should be
shariah-based.
These principles should also be
practiced.
20