Empowering Visual Artists with Tokenized Digital Assets with NFTs

Artwork can be categorized in numerous ways, offering multiple windows through which to appreciate and understand artistic expression. One of the most relevant and detailed categories is the medium of creation. This category focuses on the materials and techniques used in the production of an artwork, which can influence its appearance, texture, and emotional impact. Medium-based categorization encompasses various forms such as painting, drawing, sculpture, printmaking, photography, and certainly, the digital art (made by computing services, while not NFT-based).

Paintings, for instance, can be rendered in oils, watercolors, acrylics, or tempera, each bringing distinct qualities and challenges. Oil paintings are renowned for their rich textures and depth, allowing artists to build up layers and create detailed, vibrant compositions[56]. Watercolors, are celebrated for their fluidity and translucence, often used to capture delicate light and atmosphere[43]. Acrylics are versatile and fast-drying, making them ideal for modern and abstract works, while tempera, with its quick-drying and durable properties, has been used for centuries in religious and iconographic art. Sculpture is another prominent medium, encompassing a variety of materials such as stone, metal, wood, and clay[151]. Stone sculptures, like those from ancient Greece and Rome, are lauded for their permanence and classical beauty. Metal sculptures, often seen in contemporary art, allow for bold, dynamic forms and intricate details. Wood offers a warm, organic quality, while clay provides flexibility and is often used for both functional pottery and expressive, detailed figurative work. Printmaking includes techniques such as lithography, etching, and screen printing, each allowing artists to produce multiple copies of a single image, expanding the reach and accessibility of their work[3]. On the other hand, photography and digital art represent more modern mediums. Photography captures moments in time with precision and can be manipulated in darkrooms or digitally to create a wide range of effects[55]. Digital art, encompassing everything from digital painting to 3D modeling, leverages technology to push the boundaries of creativity and realism[150].

In addition to medium, artwork is often categorized by style or movement. This includes broad aesthetic and philosophical movements such as Renaissance[134], Baroque[130], Impressionism[65], Expressionism[209], Surrealism[27], Cubism[71], Abstract Art[159], Pop Art[123], and Contemporary Art[175]. Each of these styles is characterized by specific techniques, themes, and historical contexts, reflecting the evolving nature and psychology of artistic expression. Historical period is another significant category, spanning from prehistoric art[17] to ancient civilizations like Egyptian, Greek, and Roman[215], through to Medieval[140], Renaissance, Baroque, and into modern and contemporary times. These periods reflect the changing cultural, social, and political landscapes throughout history. Subject matter also plays a crucial role in categorizing art, with common themes including portraits, landscapes, still life, abstract compositions, historical scenes, religious motifs, and mythological tales[105, 125, 148]. Each subject matter can provide insights into the artist’s intentions and the cultural context of the work. Lastly, regional or cultural distinctions offer another layer of understanding. Western art, Eastern art (including Chinese, Japanese, and Indian), African art, and Indigenous art each encompass unique traditions, techniques, and narratives, reflecting the diverse heritage of human creativity, differentiated by geographic regions though modern art tends to be globalised.

Artwork production has a series of steps and processes that artists normally follow to create their works. The production process can be significantly different depending on the medium and the individual artist’s techniques and style.

The creation of artwork begins with inspiration, which can come from nature, literature, other artworks, and personal experiences. After finding inspiration, artists need to study the theme, style, techniques, and historical background related to their artwork. The next stage is planning and sketching drafts, where artists create preliminary sketches and plan the composition, color scheme, and overall design of their artwork. This phase is crucial for the final artwork because it allows artists to experiment with different elements and make adjustments before the final creation. Finally, the production process varies depending on the medium used, as each medium requires its own specific techniques and approaches. The Table 1 shows the medium specific processes.

The final stage is getting the artwork ready for display, which may include framing, mounting, or employing other presentation methods to showcase it effectively. Following this, its important to document details about the artwork, such as the title, creation date, materials used, and any relevant notes or context. This documentation provides valuable insight into the artwork and is crucial for potential buyers and viewers. Finally, the artwork is displayed in different venues, such as galleries, museums, online platforms, or other public spaces. At the same time, the artwork is available for sale during this stage.

Typically, trading and monetizing artwork involves various methods, platforms, and strategies that artists and collectors use to buy, sell, and earn revenue from this work. Prior to the advent of NFTs, the art trading industry had already been considered as a multifaceted industry, incorporating certain methods to connect artists with collectors. Historically, galleries have been the cornerstone of the art market, providing artists with representation, organizing exhibitions, and taking commissions from sales[166]. Art fairs further expand these opportunities, allowing galleries and independent artists to rent booths, display their works, and network with a broad audience of collectors, curators, and peers[185]. Auction houses like Sotheby’s [176] and Christie’s [36] offer high-profile avenues for the sale of artwork through a competitive bidding process, often achieving significant price escalations for coveted pieces[28]. Private sales also play a crucial role in this off-line domain, enabling direct transactions between artists, collectors, and through art advisors who facilitate these exchanges discreetly.

Online platforms are facilitating new opportunities for artwork trading. E-commerce sites such as Etsy [59], Saatchi Art [14], and Artfinder enable artists to sell directly to consumers, while digital galleries provide virtual spaces for exhibitions. Social media platforms, such as Instagram [87], Facebook [62], TikTok [187], and Canva [30], have become powerful tools for artists to showcase their work. They engage with and make sales to a global audience in an online space. Until now, this combination of conventional methods has helped artists to reach potential buyers while enabling collectors to discover new talent and work with somewhat ease.

In the above-mentioned pre-blockchain environment, the monetization of artwork encompasses a variety of strategies that assist artists to generate income from their creations via face-to-face and online sales. Limited editions of analog work, for example, allow artists to produce a finite number of prints maintaining an element of exclusivity[21]. Each print is often accompanied by a certificate of authenticity to verify its edition number and originality. Licensing offers another lucrative pathway, where artists grant rights to reproduce their work across a range of products such as apparel, home decor, and stationery, thereby earning royalties from these sales[81]. Commissions provide artists with opportunities to create custom work tailored to the preferences of individual clients or for large-scale projects in corporate and public spaces[141]. Merchandising further expands an artist’s revenue streams, with products like t-shirts, mugs, and posters featuring their designs sold through physical market stalls and online shops[133]. Crowdfunding platforms like Kickstarter [103] and Patreon [149] allow artists to generate funding for projects through direct support from patrons, often offering exclusive content and perks to subscribers who commit to regular contributions[45]. Additionally, artists can share their expertise and connect with a broader audience by offering workshops and classes through online and in-person, by platforms like Skillshare [174] and Udemy [192]. These educational courses not only exalt income but also help to build a community of followers and supporters. Together, these monetization strategies provide artists with multiple channels to sustain their creative practices and reach a wider audience. Having said this, we assert the addition of blockchain technology to any one of the above mentioned tactics offers practitioners, enterprises, and dealers new opportunities for achieving their immediate and long-term goals.

What follows next is a technical discussion of highly relevant elements of the blockchain ecosystem, which represents the minutia of this evolving space.

Blockchain architecture is a decentralized system that enables the secure and transparent recording of transactions across a network of computers. A blockchain architecture includes a series of components as follows.

• •

  Nodes: Individual computers or devices which are connected to the blockchain network are nodes. Each node stores a copy of the entire blockchain ledger.

• •

  Blocks: Transactions are grouped together into blocks, which are then added to the blockchain in a sequential and immutable fashion. Each block typically contains a cryptographic hash of the previous block, creating a chain of blocks, hence interpreting the term blockchain.

• •

  Consensus mechanism: This is a type of protocol or algorithm used to achieve agreement among nodes on the validity of transactions and also the order in which they are added to the blockchain. Common consensus mechanisms typically include Proof of Work (PoW), Proof of Stake (PoS), Practical Byzantine Fault Tolerance (PBFT)[31], and etc.

• •

  Smart contracts: These are self-executing contracts with the terms of the agreement directly written into code. Smart contracts automatically enforce and execute the terms of the agreement when predefined conditions are met[108].

• •

  Cryptographic hashing: Hash functions are used extensively in blockchain to ensure the integrity and security of data. Each block contains a cryptographic hash of the previous block to resist tamper.

Blocks are linked together in a linear sequence. This chronological approach forms a chain. The linking mechanism is achieved through referencing the hash of the previous block in each subsequent block’s header. This creates a continuous chain of blocks, with each block containing the hash of the block that came prior to it. This ensures that any attempt to modify a previous block’s data would invalidate all subsequent blocks in the chain. Since each block’s hash is based on the data of the block itself and the hash of the previous block, even a small change in any block would cause a ripple effect. This linking mechanism ensures the immutability and integrity of the blockchain. Once a block is added to the chain, it becomes extremely difficult to modify any of its data without being detected by the network, which making blockchain a secure and reliable method for recording and verifying transactions. A blockchain typically consists of three key components, namely, block header, transactions, and block hash. Figure 2 shows the whole details for the block structure[234].

• •

  Block header: This contains metadata about the block, including information such as the block’s unique identifier (hash), timestamp of when the block was created, a nonce (a number used in mining to find a valid hash), and a reference to the previous block’s hash.

• •

  Transactions: These are the actual data that the block contains. Transactions can include various types of data depending on the blockchain’s purpose of use. For example, in a cryptocurrency blockchain, transactions would include sender and recipient addresses, transaction amounts, and digital signatures for verification.

• •

  Block hash: This is a unique cryptographic hash[162] generated by running the entire block’s contents through a hashing algorithm. The hash serves as the block’s unique identifier and is crucial for ensuring the integrity of the block’s data.

There are many consensus algorithms for blockchains, and every consensus algorithm has its advantages and trade-offs, making them suitable for different use cases and blockchain implementations. The most well known consensus algorithms are PoW, PoS, Delegated Proof of Stake (DPoS),PBFT and RAFT[137]. The Table 2 shows different Consensus Algorithms’ properties[235, 137].

• •

  PoW: PoW is the original consensus algorithm used in blockchain networks like Bitcoin. In PoW, miners compete to solve complex mathematical puzzles to validate transactions and create new blocks. The first miner to solve the puzzle broadcasts the solution to the network, and if validated, the block is added to the blockchain. PoW requires a significant amount of computational resources, making it secure but also energy-intensive.

• •

  PoS: PoS selects validators to create new blocks based on the amount of cryptocurrency that they hold and are willing to "stake" as collateral. Validators are chosen pseudo-randomly, often higher chances are given if they stake more cryptocurrency. PoS is considered more energy-efficient than PoW since it doesn’t require massive computation. Ethereum has transitioned to PoS with its Ethereum 2.0 upgrade.

• •

  DPoS: DPoS is a variation of PoS where token holders vote for a limited number of delegates to validate transactions and produce blocks on their behalf. These delegates are usually known as witnesses or delegated nodes. DPoS is designed to improve scalability and efficiency by reducing the number of participants involved in the consensus process. For example, EOS[88] and TRON [191] are using DPoS.

• •

  PBFT: PBFT is designed to tolerate Byzantine faults/corruptions, where a malicious node in a network may fail or behave maliciously. PBFT works in a way by having a leader node to propose a block, which is then validated by two-thirds of the nodes. If an enough number of nodes agree on the validity of the block, it is added as the newest block in the blockchain. PBFT’s valuable properties are its high throughput and low latency, making it suitable for permissioned blockchain networks[49].

• •

  RAFT: RAFT is designed for fault-tolerant distributed systems. It works by electing a leader among the nodes, which is responsible for producing the new block. RAFT achieves consensus consistency by a leader-based approach, where the leader coordinates the agreement among the validator nodes. RAFT has higher consensus consistency than PBFT, but it may have slightly higher latency

Smart contracts are central to blockchain technology because they bring programming capabilities to the blockchain. These self-executing digital contracts have terms and conditions written in code and are stored on a blockchain network. Smart contracts represent a transformative innovation, offering a decentralized solution to traditional contractual agreements. Their integration into blockchain networks introduces new attributes such as trust and efficiency, which can drive the application of blockchain across various industries and use cases. These smart contracts operate within the framework of blockchain with its inherent characteristics, such as immutability, transparency, and decentralization, utilizing these characteristics to ensure the integrity and security of transactions[143, 119].

Smart contracts are validated through consensus mechanisms, where network nodes collectively agree on the validity of transactions and the execution of contract code. This consensus ensures tamper-proof execution, because each transaction is validated and recorded across all nodes in the network.

One of the most notable blockchains for deploying smart contracts is Ethereum, which introduced the concept of a Turing-complete blockchain with its Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM)[218]. The EVM enables developers to deploy and interact with smart contracts written in languages like Solidity and Vyper, which allowing for the creation of a wide range of dApps on the Ethereum platform.

However, the adoption of smart contracts on blockchains faces several challenges, including scalability, interoperability, legal compliance, and security vulnerabilities. These issues require careful consideration and innovative solutions[234]. Despite these challenges exist, the potential of blockchain smart contracts continues to motivate researchers, developers, and industry leaders to explore new possibilities and try to expand the boundaries of decentralized technology[188, 197, 120].

In blockchain technology, hash and signature algorithms are crucial for maintaining security and integrity. SHA-256 [74] is a widely used hash algorithm in blockchains, generating a 256-bit hash for each block. This hash ensures consistency and immutability[186]. In Ethereum, Ethash algorithm [58] is used as the PoW consensus algorithm. Ethash combines SHA-3 [54] with a memory-hard design, increasing mining difficulty and preventing centralization. Additionally, Ethereum employs Keccak-256 (SHA-3) to compute the hash for each block, enhancing security. For transaction verification, both Bitcoin and Ethereum use digital signatures. The most common signature algorithm is Elliptic Curve Digital Signature Algorithm (ECDSA)[131], which employs elliptic curve cryptography to verify the authenticity and integrity of transactions. These hashing and signature algorithms collectively help blockchains ensure data integrity, transaction authenticity, and resistance to tampering.

In the blockchain world, a blockchain wallet is the entrance for users to manage, store, operate with the cryptocurrencies and digital assets securely[33, 180]. Unlike traditional wallets, which hold physical cash or cards, blockchain wallets are also digital interfaces that allow users to access their funds on blockchain networks. A blockchain wallet consists of two main components: a public address and a private key. The public address is the destination for receiving funds in the blockchain world and it can be shared openly with others. In addition, the public address has similar function to a bank account number in traditional finance. On the other hand, the private key is a secret code that controls access to the wallet and allows the owner to authorize transactions. The private key act as the password to unlock and manage the funds stored in the wallet. The Table 3 shows different Digital Wallets’ properties.

Blockchain wallets have four different types as below.

• •

  Software wallets: Software wallets are apps that users can use on the computer, phone, or Web browser. They’re really convenient because they let users manage their funds from anywhere as long as users have an internet connection. For example, some mobile wallets include Trust Wallet [196] and MetaMask [136], while desktop wallets include Exodus [61] and Atomic Wallet [195].

• •

  Hardware wallets: Hardware wallets are physical devices that securely store the private keys offline in the encrypted chip, which provides an extra layer of security against hacking and malicious attacks. Users can connect the hardware wallet to a computer or mobile device by cable or Bluetooth when they needed to authorize transactions. For example, some popular hardware wallets include Ledger Nano S Plus [114], Trezor [190], and KeepKey [99].

• •

  Paper wallets: A paper wallet is a physical document that prints or writes the public address and private key on paper. Paper wallets are considered one of the most secure forms of storage since they are immune to online hacking. However, they require careful handling and protection from physical damage or theft.

• •

  Multi-sig wallets: Multi-sig wallets is one kind of software wallets. The wallet requires multiple private keys to authorize transactions, adding an extra layer of security and reducing the risk of unauthorized access[80]. These wallets are suitable for organizations or individuals who want to control funds among multiple parties distributively.

For creating a new wallet, there are some wallet standards from the Bitcoin Improvement Proposal (BIP), which define the technical specifications and best practices for wallet implementation. Common Bitcoin wallet standards include BIP-39 (Mnemonic code for generating deterministic keys)[129], BIP-32 (Hierarchical Deterministic Wallets)[157], and BIP-44 (Multi-Account Hierarchy for Deterministic Wallets)[128].

Blockchain wallets play a crucial role in facilitating the adoption, and use of cryptocurrencies and digital assets. They empower individuals to take control of their financial assets, enabling peer-to-peer transactions, investment in DeFi and NFT platforms, and participation in blockchain-based ecosystems.

As already mentioned at the start of this study, Bitcoin, Ethereum, Cosmos, Polkadot, Optimism, Arbitrum and Solana are state-of-the-art mainstream blockchain platforms. Herewith we provide detailed explanations and summarise them with different properties [8], as shown in Table 4.

Bitcoin was introduced in 2009 [23] by an anonymous individual or group under the pseudonym Satoshi Nakamoto. It is the world’s first and most well-known cryptocurrency[138]. It operates on a decentralized peer-to-peer network, allowing users to transact directly without the need for intermediaries like banks or payment processors. Bitcoin’s primary use case is a digital currency or store of value, with transactions recorded on a public ledger. One of Bitcoin’s key features is its decentralized nature, maintained by a distributed network of miners who validate and secure transactions through a process called mining. Bitcoin uses a PoW consensus mechanism, where miners compete to solve complex mathematical puzzles to add new blocks to the blockchain and receive rewards in the form of newly minted bitcoins. On the other hand, Bitcoin has a a maximum supply capped at 21 million coins, which causes Bitcoin’s scarcity. Moreover, this Bitcoin’s scarcity is also from its decentralized architecture and fixed supply schedule. Due to Bitcoin’s scarcity, it has been viewed as a hedge against inflation and store of value similar to gold[111].

Ethereum was launched in 2015 by Vitalik Buterin and a team of developers. It is a decentralized blockchain platform that enables the creation of smart contracts and dApps[218]. Ethereum serves as a programmable blockchain platform that allows developers to build and deploy dApps, which differentiates it from Bitcoin that focuses on digital currency. One of Ethereum’s most significant innovations is the introduction of smart contracts, self-executing contracts with the terms of the agreement directly written into code. Smart contracts enable a wide range of use cases, including DeFi, NFT, tokenization, digital identity, gaming, and more. Ethereum uses a different consensus mechanism compared to Bitcoin, transitioning from PoW to PoS with the upcoming Ethereum 2.0 upgrade. PoS aims to improve scalability, security, and energy efficiency by allowing validators to create new blocks and secure the network based on the amount of tokens they hold and are willing to "stake" as collateral[169].

Cosmos is a decentralized network of independent blockchains, each powered by Byzantine Fault Tolerant (BFT) consensus algorithms like Tendermint. The Cosmos Network aims to create an "Internet of Blockchains," where diverse blockchains can connect and exchange assets and data seamlessly. This approach enhances scalability by allowing multiple blockchains to run in parallel while maintaining sovereignty and security[171].

Polkadot is a multi-chain network that enables interoperability between different blockchains. This architecture enhances scalability by allowing transactions to be processed in parallel across multiple chains[29]. Polkadot also introduces the concept of "bridges" to connect external blockchains, enabling seamless cross-chain communication and asset transfers.

Optimism processes multiple transactions independently on Optimism, instead of Ethereum. After the transactions are finalized, a single "optimistic" proof is submitted to the Ethereum mainnet. This mechanism processes transactions significantly faster and with cheaper gas fees compared to executing them directly on the Ethereum network. Optimism blockchain can balance between scalability and security, leveraging Ethereum’s security guarantees while reducing its congestion issues[116].

Arbitrum blockchain works similar to Optimism, Arbitrum employs Optimistic Rollups protocol, called Arbitrum Rollup, to process transactions in Arbitrum blockchain and then submit the proof to the Ethereum mainnet. However, Arbitrum’s AVM is designed to be compatible with Ethereum’s existing smart contracts, which makes it easier for dApp developers to migrate their applications to Arbitrum blockchain. Through the seamless experiences for smart contract developers, Arbitrum aims to improve the scalability of the Ethereum ecosystem and accelerate the adoption of layer-2 scaling solutions.

Solana distinguishes itself from others by offering fast transaction speeds, low fees, and high throughput. Their properties are making it an attractive option for developers seeking to build scalable and efficient dApps. Solana is using a different consensus mechanism called PoH. PoH is a cryptographic clock that timestamps each transaction before it enters the network, ensuring a secure and immutable record of transactions while enabling fast transaction processing. By combining PoH with PoS consensus mechanism, Solana can achieve high throughput and low latency and process thousands of transactions per second. Solana’s architecture focus on horizontal scaling through its multi-threaded transaction processing approach. This allows Solana to handle a large number of transactions simultaneously[156], making it well-suited for applications that require high-speed and high-volume transaction processing, such as decentralized exchanges, gaming platforms, and financial applications.

Examples of all the above mainstream blockchain platforms can be found in the evolution of NFTs, which is discussed below.

The first NFT, “Quantum,” [132] was minted in 2014 on the Namecoin blockchain[96] by Kevin McCoy, but the full potential of NFTs was realized with the Ethereum blockchain, which offered a more reliable and accessible platform for launching NFT projects. Over time, NFTs have been used to represent a variety of assets, including real estate, digital art, and gaming tokens. In 2015, EverdreamSoft created “Spells of Genesis,” [60] the first blockchain trading card game, on top of Bitcoin, pioneering true ownership of digital assets in gaming. The same year saw the creation of Etheria [6], a so-called blocky realm where players could become real estate tycoons. In 2017, Larva Labs launched CryptoPunks [42], one of the earliest NFT generative art collections, which influenced popular projects like Bored Ape Yacht Club. Dapper Labs’ CryptoKitties [40], also from 2017, was one of the first blockchain games on Ethereum and inspired the ERC-721 standard. Axie Infinity [86], created by Sky Mavis in 2018, became a popular blockchain game where players collect and trade digital creatures called Axies. Decentraland [50], launched in 2020, allows users to buy and sell virtual land and items. NBA Top Shot [46] transformed sports footage into digital collectibles, while Art Blocks [15] , also from 2020, streamlined the creation of generative art NFTs. Bored Ape Yacht Club, founded in 2021 by Yuga Labs, became a critically acclaimed PFP NFT collection. Azuki [16], which emerged in early 2022, quickly became a front runner in the PFP-centric NFT market. In 2024, Pandora [147] introduced the ERC-404 standard, where tokens can be regenerated with new characteristics when moved between wallets, blending the uniqueness of NFT technology with the liquidity traits of fungible tokens.

An upsurge in NFT activities expanded beyond the Ethereum ecosystem to include the Bitcoin ecosystem[104] through a technique known as inscription[117]. Due to significant structural and architectural differences, Bitcoin-based NFTs require additional development efforts [202, 203], particularly because of limitations inherent in the UTXO model. Additionally, trading NFTs on the Bitcoin network often incurs higher transaction (i.e. gas) fees. The Figure 3 shows the timeline for NFT history, NFT standards and NFT markets.

Next, we focus on the general concept of NFTs, which encompasses, and is applicable to, the Bitcoin and Ethereum ecosystems. Doing so, clarifies the significant technological affordances of NFTs and their links to visual art and artists in the pre-blockchain environment.

The lifecycle of an NFT involves several stages[225]. Figure 5 illustrates their processes.

Five steps to create or tokenize an NFT:

• •

  Deployer stores the artwork files in off-chain storage, such as AWS S3 [11], Google Cloud [75] or IPFS, and acquires the artwork’s URL.

• •

  Deployer builds the metadata for the NFT collections, stores the metadata files in off-chain storage and acquires the metadata’s URL.

• •

  Deployer deploys the smart contract for the NFT collection. One NFT Smart contract actually is one NFT collection and there are many NFTs inside. Each NFT has its own unique token ID. And for the NFT collection, the unique ID is the smart contract address. Deployer needs to set metadata URL for each NFT according NFT token ID, which is devised to build relationship between metadata and NFT.

• •

  Deployer publicises this NFT Smart Contract address to the public through the project’s website and social media, such as Twitter (now rebranded as X) [219], Telegram [184], Discord  [51], etc.

• •

  Users can mint their own NFT after they acquire an NFT Smart Contract address. They can mint one or many NFTs depending on the limitation settings in the NFT Smart Contract established by the deployer. There are two primary ways to mint a digital asset. First, users can mint by themselves. Second, the deployer mints and then airdrops an NFT to one or more users.

  Specific details regarding the actual minting process are discussed shortly. Suffice it to say that ownership, storage and display, transfer, and destruction are key elements in the NFT ecosystem.

  {minted}

  solidity function mint(address to) external;

• {minted}

  [breaklines] solidity function ownerOf(uint256 _tokenId) external view returns (address);

• {minted}

  [breaklines] solidity function transferFrom(address _from, address _to, uint256 _tokenId) external;

Next, we discuss NFT standards, which offer good interoperability, standardized interfaces, higher security, increased liquidity, and management efficiency.

• {minted}

  solidity function burn(uint256 tokenId) external;

The Table 5 summarizes the properties of the NFT standards.

Now we advance the discussion by focusing on the actual process involved in making an NFT.

NFTs are unique digital assets that are traded on various online marketplaces [212, 94]. Here’s a general overview of how NFT trading typically works in Figure 6:

• •

  Creation. An artist or creator produces a digital asset, such as artwork, music, videos, virtual real estate, or other digital collectibles. They then mint this asset into an NFT on a compatible blockchain platform. This process essentially turns the digital file into a one-of-a-kind token, making it unique and verifiable. Creator need to list the NFT Smart Contract in their project website or NFT marketplace to show it to public users.

• •

  Mint. User can mint their NFT from the project website or NFT marketplace. Some NFT marketplace have friendly tools to help creators deploy a new NFT.

  

• •

  Listing on Marketplaces. Once minted, the NFT is listed for sale on a marketplace, which can be one of the decentralized platforms like OpenSea, Rarible, or Foundation, or they can be centralized platforms like Nifty Gateway or NBA Top Shot. Each platform may have its own requirements and procedures for listing NFTs.

• •

  Ownership Transfer. When someone purchases an NFT, the ownership of that digital asset is transferred to their digital wallet. The transaction is recorded on the blockchain, providing a transparent and immutable record of ownership.

• •

  Payment. Buyers typically pay for NFTs using cryptocurrency, usually via Ethereum (ETH) on Ethereum-based NFT platforms. Some platforms may also support other cryptocurrencies. The cryptocurrency will be paid to seller through NFT marketplace smart contract. The transaction fee or marketplace fee is charged directly by the charge logic designed by creator in the NFT marketplace smart contract.

• •

  NFT Smart Contracts. NFT contracts, which are self-executing contracts with the terms of the agreement directly written into code, govern the transfer of NFT ownership and the distribution of proceeds from sales. These contracts ensure that the creator receives royalties for subsequent resales of the NFT, typically a percentage of the sale price.

• •

  Market Dynamics. NFT prices can fluctuate based on demand, perceived value, and the reputation of the creator. Factors such as rarity, uniqueness, and the creator’s reputation can all influence the price of an NFT[135].

• •

  Storage and Display. After purchasing an NFT, owners can store them in compatible digital wallets. Some platforms also offer ways to display NFTs in virtual galleries[89] or digital environments.

It is important to research and understand the specific marketplace and blockchain platform before participating in NFT trading to ensure security, authenticity, and compliance with any applicable regulations.

The rapid proliferation of NFTs market is facing with challenges in cybersecurity that pose significant risks to artists and collectors alike, encompassing both human and technological issues. Figure 8 shows most of the security issues for NFT trading.

On the human front, artists and collectors face threats from fraud, theft, and scams[167]. Phishing attacks are particularly prevalent, where scammers deceive users into revealing sensitive information or performing actions that compromise their digital wallets. By impersonating legitimate services or using deceptive messages, scammers can trick users into confirming on-chain operations that transfer NFTs and other tokens directly to the attackers. This can result in substantial financial losses and the unauthorized transfer of valuable digital assets.

Technological vulnerabilities are common because of the complex nature of smart contracts and the intricate design of NFTs. Smart contracts, which are self-executing contracts with the terms of the agreement directly written into code[101], are foundation to the operation of NFTs. However, they are not immune to security flaws. Identity verification issues might allow malicious attackers to impersonate legitimate users and lead to unauthorized transactions. The verifiability of NFT contracts is another critical issue. NFT contract is authentic and has not been tampered with is essential for maintaining trust in the system. Smart contract vulnerabilities, such as reentrancy, transaction order dependence, integer overflows, and unhandled exceptions, all highlight the shared security challenges between NFTs and broader DeFi ecosystems[26, 68, 76, 92, 97, 122].

Tampering with NFT metadata presents another significant risk. Metadata can be altered if proper security measures are not in place. This can lead to losing connection between the digital asset and its provenance. Invalid caching, where outdated or incorrect data is stored and used, can further complicate the matters by providing false information about the NFT[48].

In addition to these technological issues, the NFT market suffers from a lack of transparency[38], particularly in off-chain trades where transactions occur outside the blockchain. This opacity can facilitate fraudulent activities and make it difficult to verify the authenticity and ownership history of an NFT. Fairness in bidding processes is another concern, with practices such as shill bidding and bid shielding undermining the integrity of auctions. Royalty and marketplace fee evasion pose financial risks to artists and platforms, while cross-platform issues and non-enforcement of contractual terms can further exacerbate financial risks.

Traditional Web2 security issues, such as Denial of Service (DoS) attacks[139], also persist in the NFT ecosystem, threatening the availability and reliability of NFT marketplace platforms. With substantial funds flowing into DeFi applications, the allure of scams and cyber attacks has grown. Cryptoeconomic strategies, such as transaction reordering[100, 118], flash loan abuse[164], arbitrage opportunities[44], and pump-and-dump schemes[221, 98], have been adapted to exploit vulnerabilities in the NFT market.

This intricate web of human and technological vulnerabilities underscores the urgent need for robust security measures to protect artists and their digital assets in the burgeoning NFT marketplace. Ensuring the verifiability of token contracts and implementing the principle of least privilege in smart contracts can address several technological vulnerabilities[223]. Transparency in transactions, fairness in bidding, and robust enforcement of contractual terms are essential for maintaining trust and integrity in the NFT ecosystem[48]. As the market continues to grow, ongoing efforts to identify and mitigate security risks will be crucial in safeguarding the interests of all participants in the NFT space.

At the current stage, entering the NFT world presents significant challenges due to the complexity of websites and tools, such as digital wallets and related concepts, which differ fundamentally from traditional wallets and banking systems. These new concepts are entirely unfamiliar to the general public. Additionally, Web3 dApps require users to learn and practice new mechanisms [198] related to NFTs, creating barriers for both regular artists and users. Traditional notions and concepts do not translate well into the NFT world, necessitating the development of new tools with lower entry barriers and simplified concepts to enhance user experience within the NFT ecosystem.

To improve user experience, it is essential to streamline the onboarding process [228]. This can begin with developing user-friendly interfaces that guide users through the setup of digital wallets and explain their function in an accessible manner. Tutorials and intuitive design are more clear to users and can help the process of creating and managing NFTs. Integrating familiar elements from traditional finance into wallets, such as simplified transaction overviews and clear, straightforward instructions, can help users execute the transition quickly and smoothly. Moreover, using ideas and tools from traditional systems in a way that fits with the NFT world can help bridge the gap.

The development of all-in-one platforms that integrate various aspects of NFT operations, such as NFT creation and trading, can also enhance the user experience. These platforms should offer seamless interoperability with different blockchains and marketplaces by reducing the need for users to navigate multiple sites and services. Some features can make the NFT ecosystem more approachable, for example, automatic wallet setup, integrated educational resources, and user-friendly dashboards.

The NFT ecosystem benefits from the inherent transparency provided by blockchain technology. However, this transparency also raises potential issues. Smart contract audits by security teams can identify and prevent exploits. In addition, stronger authentication methods, such as multi-factor authentication (MFA), can significantly reduce the unauthorized access issues. For high value NFTs, cold storage, which means storing them in hardware wallets, can minimize hacking risks. Educating users about phishing scams and implementing anti-phishing measures are also crucial to protecting against attacks. Moreover, education should teach users to avoid giving away their private keys or other sensitive information. Implementing decentralized identity (DID)[165] solutions can ensure secure and verifiable identities without relying on centralized entities, preventing identity theft and fraud. Regular security updates for NFT platforms and tools are necessary to patch vulnerabilities and stay ahead of the latest security threats and best practices[35].

While blockchain transparency is a key feature, it can also compromise privacy. For artists and NFT users, maintaining privacy is crucial [10]. Zero-knowledge proofs (ZKPs)[32] can verify transactions without revealing underlying details, ensuring that transactions are transparent and verifiable while keeping the identities of the parties involved private. Confidential transaction mechanisms[201] can hide transaction amounts and other sensitive details from the public while still ensuring validity. Creating private NFTs with privacy features, achieved through encryption and selective disclosure techniques, can ensure that only authorized parties can view metadata and ownership details. Off-chain privacy solutions, where sensitive information is stored off-chain (e.g., using trusted hardware [120]) while the blockchain is used only for validation, help maintain privacy by leveraging blockchain security while keeping private data off the public ledger. Developing and promoting the use of privacy-focused wallets with features like transaction mixing [183] and address obfuscation can help users maintain their anonymity.

The continuous involvement and collaboration of artists, users, governors, and developers are essential for the ecological perfection of the NFT ecosystem. Encouraging active community participation can lead to the early identification of issues and collaborative problem-solving. Bug bounty programs can incentivize security researchers to find and report vulnerabilities. Offering education and resources about best practices for security can help users and artists protect themselves and their assets. Moreover, rules are needed to protect users and encourage innovation from regulators which can help make the NFT space more secure and trustworthy.

Artwork remixing involves adding user’s own ideas to an original artwork to create a new version. It’s an interesting topic that benefits both artists and the NFT market. Artists can earn ongoing royalties whenever their work is resold as an NFT remix. It also lets users modify and create new NFTs based on their own ideas, effectively turning them into new artists. Theoretically, this remixing process can potentially attract increasing numbers of active artists, as well as a variety of new creative outputs. In turn, this is likely toexpand the NFT market in ways that have yet to be considered.

Artwork remixing [106] is highly promising in the NFT world as blockchain technology ensuring artists receive payment for every resale of their artwork. This means that original artists can keep earning money and get more recognition if more of their NFTs are traded. The continuous royalty payments incentivize artists to enter and engage in the NFT market.

For users, remixing and creating new versions of NFTs allow for personal expression and creativity. By turning existing artwork into new, unique pieces, users become co-creators and contribute to the diversity of the digital art world. This open approach to art creation means that anyone with interest and creativity can join the art community, potentially bringing in a lot of new talents and innovation to the art industry.

The marketplace also benefits because an increase in remixed artwork means an increased variety and volume of NFTs for trading. This variety can attract more buyers and collectors, making the market more lively and exciting. Original works can lead to many new derivative pieces, each with its own unique value. This ongoing process of creating and recreating helps build a strong and ever-evolving art ecosystem[208].