The Target Study: A Conceptual Model and Framework for Measuring Disparity
Authors:
John W. Jackson,
Yea-Jen Hsu,
Raquel C. Greer,
Romsai T. Boonyasai,
Chanelle J. Howe
Abstract:
We present a conceptual model to measure disparity--the target study--where social groups may be similarly situated (i.e., balanced) on allowable covariates. Our model, based on a sampling design, does not intervene to assign social group membership or alter allowable covariates. To address non-random sample selection, we extend our model to generalize or transport disparity or to assess disparity…
▽ More
We present a conceptual model to measure disparity--the target study--where social groups may be similarly situated (i.e., balanced) on allowable covariates. Our model, based on a sampling design, does not intervene to assign social group membership or alter allowable covariates. To address non-random sample selection, we extend our model to generalize or transport disparity or to assess disparity after an intervention on eligibility-related variables that eliminates forms of collider-stratification. To avoid bias from differential timing of enrollment, we aggregate time-specific study results by balancing calendar time of enrollment across social groups. To provide a framework for emulating our model, we discuss study designs, data structures, and G-computation and weighting estimators. We compare our sampling-based model to prominent decomposition-based models used in healthcare and algorithmic fairness. We provide R code for all estimators and apply our methods to measure health system disparities in hypertension control using electronic medical records.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2024; v1 submitted 1 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
