-
Investigating the Mass of the Black Hole and Possible Wind Outflow of the Accretion Disk in the Tidal Disruption Event AT2021ehb
Authors:
Xin Xiang,
Jon M. Miller,
Abderahmen Zoghbi,
Mark T. Reynolds,
David Bogensberger,
Lixin Dai,
Paul A. Draghis,
Jeremy J. Drake,
Olivier Godet,
Jimmy A. Irwin,
Michael C. Miller,
Brenna E. Mockler,
Richard Saxton,
Natalie Webb
Abstract:
Tidal disruption events (TDEs) can potentially probe low-mass black holes in host galaxies that might not adhere to bulge or stellar-dispersion relationships. At least initially, TDEs can also reveal super-Eddington accretion. X-ray spectroscopy can potentially constrain black hole masses, and reveal ionized outflows associated with super-Eddington accretion. Our analysis of XMM-Newton X-ray obser…
▽ More
Tidal disruption events (TDEs) can potentially probe low-mass black holes in host galaxies that might not adhere to bulge or stellar-dispersion relationships. At least initially, TDEs can also reveal super-Eddington accretion. X-ray spectroscopy can potentially constrain black hole masses, and reveal ionized outflows associated with super-Eddington accretion. Our analysis of XMM-Newton X-ray observations of the TDE AT2021ehb, around 300 days post-disruption, reveals a soft spectrum and can be fit with a combination of multi-color disk blackbody and power-law components. Using two independent disk models with properties suited to TDEs, we estimate a black hole mass at $M \simeq 10^{5.5}~M_{\odot}$, indicating AT2021ehb may expose the elusive low-mass end of the nuclear black hole population. These models offer simple yet robust characterization; more complicated models are not required, but provide important context and caveats in the limit of moderately sensitive data. If disk reflection is included, the disk flux is lower and inferred black hole masses are $\sim$ 0.35 dex higher. Simple wind formulations imply an extremely fast $v_{\mathrm{out}} = -0.2~c$ outflow and obviate a disk continuum component. Assuming a unity filling factor, such a wind implies an instantaneous mass outflow rate of $\dot{M} \simeq 5~M_{\odot}~{\rm yr}^{-1}$. Such a high rate suggests that the filling factor for the Ultra Fast Outflow (UFO) must be extremely low, and/or the UFO phase is ephemeral. We discuss the strengths and limitations of our analysis and avenues for future observations of TDEs.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Fierce Feedback in an Obscured, Sub-Eddington State of the Seyfert 1.2 Markarian 817
Authors:
Miranda K. Zak,
Jon M. Miller,
Ehud Behar,
William N. Brandt,
Laura Brenneman,
Paul A. Draghis,
Elias Kammoun,
Michael J. Koss,
Mark T. Reynolds,
Abderahmen Zoghbi
Abstract:
Markarian 817 is a bright and variable Seyfert-1.2 active galactic nucleus (AGN). X-ray monitoring of Mrk 817 with the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory in 2022 revealed that the source flux had declined to a lower level than recorded at any prior point in the then-19-year mission. We present an analysis of deep XMM-Newton and NuSTAR observations obtained in this low flux state. The spectra reveal a…
▽ More
Markarian 817 is a bright and variable Seyfert-1.2 active galactic nucleus (AGN). X-ray monitoring of Mrk 817 with the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory in 2022 revealed that the source flux had declined to a lower level than recorded at any prior point in the then-19-year mission. We present an analysis of deep XMM-Newton and NuSTAR observations obtained in this low flux state. The spectra reveal a complex X-ray wind consisting of neutral and ionized absorption zones. Three separate velocity components are detected as part of a structured ultra-fast outflow (UFO), with v/c = 0.043 (+0.007,-0.003), v/c = 0.079 (+0.003,-0.0008), and v/c = 0.074 (+0.004,-0.005). These projected velocities suggest that the wind likely arises at radii that are much smaller than the optical broad line region (BLR). In order for each component of the outflow to contribute significant feedback, the volume filling factors must be greater than f ~ 0.009, f ~ 0.003, and f ~ 0.3, respectively. For plausible, data-driven volume filling factors, these limits are passed, and the total outflow likely delivers the fierce feedback required to reshape its host environment, despite a modest radiative Eddington fraction of lambda ~ 0.008-0.016 (this range reflects plausible masses). UFOs are often detected at or above the Eddington limit; this result signals that black hole accretion has the potential to shape host galaxies even at modest Eddington fractions, and over a larger fraction of a typical AGN lifetime. We discuss our findings in terms of models for disk winds and black hole feedback in this and other AGN.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Systematically Revisiting All NuSTAR Spins of Black Holes in X-Ray Binaries
Authors:
Paul A. Draghis,
Jon M. Miller,
Elisa Costantini,
Luigi C. Gallo,
Mark Reynolds,
John A. Tomsick,
Abderahmen Zoghbi
Abstract:
We extend our recent work on black hole spin in X-ray binary systems to include an analysis of 189 archival NuSTAR observations from 24 sources. Using self-consistent data reduction pipelines, spectral models, and statistical techniques, we report an unprecedented and uniform sample of 36 stellar-mass black hole spin measurements based on relativistic reflection. This treatment suggests that prior…
▽ More
We extend our recent work on black hole spin in X-ray binary systems to include an analysis of 189 archival NuSTAR observations from 24 sources. Using self-consistent data reduction pipelines, spectral models, and statistical techniques, we report an unprecedented and uniform sample of 36 stellar-mass black hole spin measurements based on relativistic reflection. This treatment suggests that prior reports of low spins in a small number of sources were generally erroneous: our comprehensive treatment finds that those sources tend to harbor black holes with high spin values. Overall, within $1σ$ uncertainty, $\sim86\%$ of the sample are consistent with $a \geq 0.95$, $\sim94\%$ of the sample are consistent with $a\geq 0.9$, and $100\%$ is consistent with $a\geq 0.7$ (the theoretical maximum for neutron stars; $a = cJ/GM^{2}$). We also find that the high-mass X-ray binaries (those with A-, B-, or O-type companions) are consistent with $a\geq 0.9$ within the $1σ$ errors; this is in agreement with the low-mass X-ray binary population and may be especially important for comparisons to black holes discovered in gravitational wave events. In some cases, different spectra from the same source yield similar spin measurements but conflicting values for the inclination of the inner disk; we suggest that this is due to variable disk winds obscuring the blue wing of the relativistic Fe K emission line. We discuss the implications of our measurements, the unique view of systematic uncertainties enabled by our treatment, and future efforts to characterize black hole spins with new missions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2024; v1 submitted 27 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Evidence of a Massive Stellar Disruption in the X-ray Spectrum of ASASSN-14li
Authors:
J. M. Miller,
B. Mockler,
E. Ramirez-Ruiz,
P. A. Draghis,
J. J. Drake,
J. Raymond,
M. T. Reynolds,
X. Xiang,
S. -B. Yun,
A. Zoghbi
Abstract:
The proximity and duration of the tidal disruption event (TDE) ASASSN-14li led to the discovery of narrow, blue-shifted absorption lines in X-rays and UV. The gas seen in X-ray absorption is consistent with bound material close to the apocenter of elliptical orbital paths, or with a disk wind similar to those seen in Seyfert-1 active galactic nuclei. We present a new analysis of the deepest high-r…
▽ More
The proximity and duration of the tidal disruption event (TDE) ASASSN-14li led to the discovery of narrow, blue-shifted absorption lines in X-rays and UV. The gas seen in X-ray absorption is consistent with bound material close to the apocenter of elliptical orbital paths, or with a disk wind similar to those seen in Seyfert-1 active galactic nuclei. We present a new analysis of the deepest high-resolution XMM-Newton and Chandra spectra of ASASSN-14li. Driven by the relative strengths of He-like and H-like charge states, the data require [N/C] > 2.4, in qualitative agreement with UV spectral results. Flows of the kind seen in the X-ray spectrum of ASASSN-14li were not clearly predicted in simulations of TDEs; this left open the possibility that the observed absorption might be tied to gas released in prior AGN activity. However, the abundance pattern revealed in this analysis points to a single star rather than a standard AGN accretion flow comprised of myriad gas contributions. The simplest explanation of the data is likely that a moderately massive star (M ~ 3 Msun) with significant CNO processing was disrupted. An alternative explanation is that a lower mass star was disrupted that had previously been stripped of its envelope. We discuss the strengths and limitations of our analysis and these interpretations.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
An Extreme Black Hole in the Recurrent X-ray Transient XTE J2012+381
Authors:
Paul A. Draghis,
Jon M. Miller,
McKinley C. Brumback,
Andrew C. Fabian,
John A. Tomsick,
Abderahmen Zoghbi
Abstract:
The black hole candidate XTE J2012+381 underwent an outburst at the end of 2022. We analyzed 105 NICER observations and 2 NuSTAR observations of the source during the outburst. The NuSTAR observations of the $M \sim10M_\odot$ black hole indicate clear signs of relativistic disk reflection, which we modeled to measure a BH spin of $a=0.988^{+0.008}_{-0.030}$ and an inclination of $θ=68^{+6}_{-11}$…
▽ More
The black hole candidate XTE J2012+381 underwent an outburst at the end of 2022. We analyzed 105 NICER observations and 2 NuSTAR observations of the source during the outburst. The NuSTAR observations of the $M \sim10M_\odot$ black hole indicate clear signs of relativistic disk reflection, which we modeled to measure a BH spin of $a=0.988^{+0.008}_{-0.030}$ and an inclination of $θ=68^{+6}_{-11}$ degrees ($1σ$ statistical errors). In our analysis, we test an array of models and examine the effect of fitting NuSTAR spectra alone versus fitting simultaneously with NICER. We find that when the underlying continuum emission is properly accounted for, the reflected emission is similarly characterized by multiple models. We combined 52 NICER spectra to obtain a spectrum with an effective exposure of 190 ks in order to probe the presence of absorption lines that would be suggestive of disk winds, but the resulting features were not statistically significant. We discuss the implications of this measurement in relation to the overall BH spin distribution in X-ray binary systems.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
The Spin of a Newborn Black Hole: Swift J1728.9-3613
Authors:
Paul A. Draghis,
Mayura Balakrishnan,
Jon M. Miller,
Edward Cackett,
Andrew C. Fabian,
James C. A. Miller-Jones,
Mason Ng,
John C. Raymond,
Mark Reynolds,
Abderahmen Zoghbi
Abstract:
The origin and distribution of stellar-mass black hole spins are a rare window into the progenitor stars and supernova events that create them. Swift J1728.9-3613 is an X-ray binary, likely associated with the supernova remnant G351.9-0.9 (Balakrishnan et al. 2023). A NuSTAR X-ray spectrum of this source during its 2019 outburst reveals reflection from an accretion disk extending to the innermost…
▽ More
The origin and distribution of stellar-mass black hole spins are a rare window into the progenitor stars and supernova events that create them. Swift J1728.9-3613 is an X-ray binary, likely associated with the supernova remnant G351.9-0.9 (Balakrishnan et al. 2023). A NuSTAR X-ray spectrum of this source during its 2019 outburst reveals reflection from an accretion disk extending to the innermost stable circular orbit. Modeling of the relativistic Doppler shifts and gravitational redshifts imprinted on the spectrum measures a dimensionless spin parameter of $a=0.86\pm0.02$ ($1σ$ confidence), a small inclination angle of the inner accretion disk $θ<10$ degrees, and a sub-solar iron abundance in the disk $A_{\rm Fe}<0.84$. This high spin value rules out a neutron star primary at the $5\;σ$ level of confidence. If the black hole is located in a still visible supernova remnant, it must be young. Therefore, we place a lower limit on the natal black hole spin of $a>0.82$, concluding that the black hole must have formed with a high spin. This demonstrates that black hole formation channels that leave a supernova remnant, and those that do not (e.g. Cyg X-1), can both lead to high natal spin with no requirement for subsequent accretion within the binary system. Emerging disparities between the population of high-spin black holes in X-ray binaries and the low-spin black holes that merge in gravitational wave events may therefore be explained in terms of different stellar conditions prior to collapse, rather than different environmental factors after formation.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
The Black Hole Candidate Swift J1728.9$-$3613 and the Supernova Remnant G351.9$-$0.9
Authors:
Mayura Balakrishnan,
Paul A. Draghis,
Jon M. Miller,
Joe Bright,
Robert Fender,
Mason Ng,
Edward Cackett,
Andrew Fabian,
Kip Kuntz,
James C. A. Miller-Jones,
Daniel Proga,
Paul S. Ray,
John Raymond,
Mark Reynolds,
Abderahmen Zoghbi
Abstract:
A number of neutron stars have been observed within the remnants of the core-collapse supernova explosions that created them. In contrast, black holes are not yet clearly associated with supernova remnants. Indeed, some observations suggest that black holes are ``born in the dark'', i.e. without a supernova explosion. Herein, we present a multi-wavelength analysis of the X-ray transient Swift J172…
▽ More
A number of neutron stars have been observed within the remnants of the core-collapse supernova explosions that created them. In contrast, black holes are not yet clearly associated with supernova remnants. Indeed, some observations suggest that black holes are ``born in the dark'', i.e. without a supernova explosion. Herein, we present a multi-wavelength analysis of the X-ray transient Swift J1728.9$-$3613, based on observations made with Chandra, ESO-VISTA, MeerKAT, NICER, NuSTAR, Swift, and XMM-Newton. Three independent diagnostics indicate that the system likely harbors a black hole primary. Infrared imaging signals a massive companion star that is broadly consistent with an A or B spectral type. Most importantly, the X-ray binary lies within the central region of the catalogued supernova remnant G351.9$-$0.9. Our deep MeerKAT image at 1.28~GHz signals that the remnant is in the Sedov phase; this fact and the non-detection of the soft X-ray emission expected from such a remnant argue that it lies at a distance that could coincide with the black hole. Utilizing a formal measurement of the distance to Swift J1728.9$-$3613 ($d = 8.4\pm 0.8$ kpc), a lower limit on the distance to G351.9$-$0.9 ($d \geq 7.5$ kpc), and the number and distribution of black holes and supernova remnants within the Milky Way, extensive simulations suggest that the probability of a chance superposition is $<1.7\%$ ($99.7\%$ credible interval). The discovery of a black hole within a supernova remnant would support numerical simulations that produce black holes and remnants, and thus provide clear observational evidence of distinct black hole formation channels. We discuss the robustness of our analysis and some challenges to this interpretation.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
A Systematic View of Ten New Black Hole Spins
Authors:
Paul A. Draghis,
Jon M. Miller,
Abderahmen Zoghbi,
Mark Reynolds,
Elisa Costantini,
Luigi C. Gallo,
John A. Tomsick
Abstract:
The launch of NuSTAR and the increasing number of binary black hole (BBH) mergers detected through gravitational wave (GW) observations have exponentially advanced our understanding of black holes. Despite the simplicity owed to being fully described by their mass and angular momentum, black holes have remained mysterious laboratories that probe the most extreme environments in the Universe. While…
▽ More
The launch of NuSTAR and the increasing number of binary black hole (BBH) mergers detected through gravitational wave (GW) observations have exponentially advanced our understanding of black holes. Despite the simplicity owed to being fully described by their mass and angular momentum, black holes have remained mysterious laboratories that probe the most extreme environments in the Universe. While significant progress has been made in the recent decade, the distribution of spin in black holes has not yet been understood. In this work, we provide a systematic analysis of all known black holes in X-ray binary systems (XB) that have previously been observed by NuSTAR, but have not yet had a spin measurement using the "relativistic reflection" method obtained from that data. By looking at all the available archival NuSTAR data of these sources, we measure ten new black hole spins: IGR J17454-2919 -- $a=0.97^{+0.03}_{-0.17}$; GRS 1758-258 -- $a=0.991^{+0.007}_{-0.019}$; MAXI J1727-203 -- $a=0.986^{+0.012}_{-0.159}$; MAXI J0637-430 -- $a=0.97\pm0.02$; Swift J1753.5-0127 -- $a=0.997^{+0.001}_{-0.003}$; V4641 Sgr -- $a=0.86^{+0.04}_{-0.06}$; 4U 1543-47 -- $a=0.98^{+0.01}_{-0.02}$; 4U 1957+11 -- $a=0.95^{+0.02}_{-0.04}$; H 1743-322 -- $a=0.98^{+0.01}_{-0.02}$; MAXI J1820+070 -- $a=0.988^{+0.006}_{-0.028}$ (all uncertainties are at the $1σ$ confidence level). We discuss the implications of our measurements on the entire distribution of stellar mass black hole spins in XB, and we compare that with the spin distribution in BBH, finding that the two distributions are clearly in disagreement. Additionally, we discuss the implications of this work on our understanding of how the "relativistic reflection" spin measurement technique works, and discuss possible sources of systematic uncertainty that can bias our measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
The Spin and Orientation of the Black Hole in XTE J1908$+$094
Authors:
Paul A. Draghis,
Jon M. Miller,
Abderahmen Zoghbi,
Elias S. Kammoun,
Mark T. Reynolds,
John A. Tomsick
Abstract:
NuSTAR observed the black hole candidate XTE J1908$+$094 during its 2013 and 2019 outbursts. We use relativistic reflection to measure the spin of the black hole through 19 different assumptions of relxill flavors and parameter combinations. The most favored model in terms of Deviance Information Criterion (DIC) measures the spin of the black hole to be $a = 0.55^{+0.29}_{-0.45}$, and an inclinati…
▽ More
NuSTAR observed the black hole candidate XTE J1908$+$094 during its 2013 and 2019 outbursts. We use relativistic reflection to measure the spin of the black hole through 19 different assumptions of relxill flavors and parameter combinations. The most favored model in terms of Deviance Information Criterion (DIC) measures the spin of the black hole to be $a = 0.55^{+0.29}_{-0.45}$, and an inclination of $θ=27^{+2}_{-3}$ degrees ($1σ$ statistical errors). We look at the effects of coronal geometry assumptions and density of the accretion disk on the spin prediction. All 19 tested models provide consistent spin estimates. We discuss the evolution of spin measurement techniques using relativistic reflection in X-ray binaries and discuss the implications of this spin measurement in reconciling the distributions of stellar mass black hole spin measurements made through X-ray and gravitational wave observations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
A New Spin on an Old Black Hole: NuSTAR Spectroscopy of EXO 1846-031
Authors:
Paul A. Draghis,
Jon M. Miller,
Edward M. Cackett,
Elias S. Kammoun,
Mark T. Reynolds,
John A. Tomsick,
Abderahmen Zoghbi
Abstract:
The black hole candidate EXO 1846-031 underwent an outburst in 2019, after at least 25 years in quiescence. We observed the system using \textit{NuSTAR} on August 3rd, 2019. The 3--79 keV spectrum shows strong relativistic reflection features. Our baseline model gives a nearly maximal black hole spin value of $a=0.997_{-0.002}^{+0.001}$ ($1σ$ statistical errors). This high value nominally excludes…
▽ More
The black hole candidate EXO 1846-031 underwent an outburst in 2019, after at least 25 years in quiescence. We observed the system using \textit{NuSTAR} on August 3rd, 2019. The 3--79 keV spectrum shows strong relativistic reflection features. Our baseline model gives a nearly maximal black hole spin value of $a=0.997_{-0.002}^{+0.001}$ ($1σ$ statistical errors). This high value nominally excludes the possibility of the central engine harboring a neutron star. Using several models, we test the robustness of our measurement to assumptions about the density of the accretion disk, the nature of the corona, the choice of disk continuum model, and addition of reflection from the outer regions of the accretion disk. All tested models agree on a very high black hole spin value and a high value for the inclination of the inner accretion disk of $θ\approx73^\circ$. We discuss the implications of this spin measurement in the population of stellar mass black holes with known spins, including LIGO events.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2020; v1 submitted 8 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
