-
Therapy as an NLP Task: Psychologists' Comparison of LLMs and Human Peers in CBT
Authors:
Zainab Iftikhar,
Sean Ransom,
Amy Xiao,
Jeff Huang
Abstract:
Wider access to therapeutic care is one of the biggest challenges in mental health treatment. Due to institutional barriers, some people seeking mental health support have turned to large language models (LLMs) for personalized therapy, even though these models are largely unsanctioned and untested. We investigate the potential and limitations of using LLMs as providers of evidence-based therapy b…
▽ More
Wider access to therapeutic care is one of the biggest challenges in mental health treatment. Due to institutional barriers, some people seeking mental health support have turned to large language models (LLMs) for personalized therapy, even though these models are largely unsanctioned and untested. We investigate the potential and limitations of using LLMs as providers of evidence-based therapy by using mixed methods clinical metrics. Using HELPERT, a prompt run on a large language model using the same process and training as a comparative group of peer counselors, we replicated publicly accessible mental health conversations rooted in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) to compare session dynamics and counselor's CBT-based behaviors between original peer support sessions and their reconstructed HELPERT sessions. Two licensed, CBT-trained clinical psychologists evaluated the sessions using the Cognitive Therapy Rating Scale and provided qualitative feedback. Our findings show that the peer sessions are characterized by empathy, small talk, therapeutic alliance, and shared experiences but often exhibit therapist drift. Conversely, HELPERT reconstructed sessions exhibit minimal therapist drift and higher adherence to CBT methods but display a lack of collaboration, empathy, and cultural understanding. Through CTRS ratings and psychologists' feedback, we highlight the importance of human-AI collaboration for scalable mental health. Our work outlines the ethical implication of imparting human-like subjective qualities to LLMs in therapeutic settings, particularly the risk of deceptive empathy, which may lead to unrealistic patient expectations and potential harm.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Thermal properties of the superconductor-quantum Hall interfaces
Authors:
Lingfei Zhao,
Trevyn F. Q. Larson,
Zubair Iftikhar,
John Chiles,
Kenji Watanabe,
Takashi Taniguchi,
Francois Amet,
Gleb Finkelstein
Abstract:
An important route of engineering topological states and excitations is to combine superconductors (SC) with the quantum Hall (QH) effect, and over the past decade, significant progress has been made in this direction. While typical measurements of these states focus on electronic properties, little attention has been paid to the accompanying thermal responses. Here, we examine the thermal propert…
▽ More
An important route of engineering topological states and excitations is to combine superconductors (SC) with the quantum Hall (QH) effect, and over the past decade, significant progress has been made in this direction. While typical measurements of these states focus on electronic properties, little attention has been paid to the accompanying thermal responses. Here, we examine the thermal properties of the interface between a type-II superconducting electrodes and graphene in the QH regime. We use the thermal noise measurement to probe the local electron temperature of the biased interface. Surprisingly, the measured temperature raise indicates that the superconductor provides a significant thermal conductivity, which is linear in temperature. This suggests electronic heat transport and may be unexpected, because the number of the quasiparticles in the superconductor should be exponentially suppressed. Instead, we attribute the measured electronic heat conductivity to the overlap of the normal states in the vortex cores.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Loss and decoherence at the quantum Hall - superconductor interface
Authors:
Lingfei Zhao,
Zubair Iftikhar,
Trevyn F. Q. Larson,
Ethan G. Arnault,
Kenji Watanabe,
Takashi Taniguchi,
Francois Amet,
Gleb Finkelstein
Abstract:
We perform a systematic study of Andreev conversion at the interface between a superconductor and graphene in the quantum Hall (QH) regime. We find that the probability of Andreev conversion from electrons to holes follows an unexpected but clear trend: the dependencies on temperature and magnetic field are nearly decoupled. We discuss these trends and the role of the superconducting vortices, who…
▽ More
We perform a systematic study of Andreev conversion at the interface between a superconductor and graphene in the quantum Hall (QH) regime. We find that the probability of Andreev conversion from electrons to holes follows an unexpected but clear trend: the dependencies on temperature and magnetic field are nearly decoupled. We discuss these trends and the role of the superconducting vortices, whose normal cores could both absorb and dephase the individual electrons in a QH edge. Our study may pave the road to engineering future generation of hybrid devices for exploiting superconductivity proximity in chiral channels.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2023; v1 submitted 10 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Graphene-based quantum Hall interferometer with self-aligned side gates
Authors:
Lingfei Zhao,
Ethan G. Arnault,
Trevyn F. Q. Larson,
Zubair Iftikhar,
Andrew Seredinski,
Tate Fleming,
Kenji Watanabe,
Takashi Taniguchi,
Francois Amet,
Gleb Finkelstein
Abstract:
The vanishing band gap of graphene has long presented challenges for making high-quality quantum point contacts (QPCs) -- the partially transparent p-n interfaces introduced by conventional split-gates tend to short the QPC. This complication has hindered the fabrication of graphene quantum Hall Fabry-Pérot interferometers, until recent advances have allowed split-gate QPCs to operate utilizing th…
▽ More
The vanishing band gap of graphene has long presented challenges for making high-quality quantum point contacts (QPCs) -- the partially transparent p-n interfaces introduced by conventional split-gates tend to short the QPC. This complication has hindered the fabrication of graphene quantum Hall Fabry-Pérot interferometers, until recent advances have allowed split-gate QPCs to operate utilizing the highly resistive $ν=0$ state. Here, we present a simple recipe to fabricate QPCs by etching a narrow trench in the graphene sheet to separate the conducting channel from self-aligned graphene side gates. We demonstrate operation of the individual QPCs in the quantum Hall regime, and further utilize these QPCs to create and study a quantum Hall interferometer.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2023; v1 submitted 11 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Emission of photon multiplets by a dc-biased superconducting circuit
Authors:
G. C. Ménard,
A. Peugeot,
C. Padurariu,
C. Rolland,
B. Kubala,
Y. Mukharsky,
Z. Iftikhar,
C. Altimiras,
P. Roche,
H. le Sueur,
P. Joyez,
D. Vion,
D. Esteve,
J. Ankerhold,
F. Portier
Abstract:
We observe the emission of bunches of $k \geqslant 1$ photons by a circuit made of a microwave resonator in series with a voltage-biased tunable Josephson junction. The bunches are emitted at specific values $V_k$ of the bias voltage, for which each Cooper pair tunneling across the junction creates exactly k photons in the resonator. The latter is a micro-fabricated spiral coil which resonates and…
▽ More
We observe the emission of bunches of $k \geqslant 1$ photons by a circuit made of a microwave resonator in series with a voltage-biased tunable Josephson junction. The bunches are emitted at specific values $V_k$ of the bias voltage, for which each Cooper pair tunneling across the junction creates exactly k photons in the resonator. The latter is a micro-fabricated spiral coil which resonates and leaks photons at 4.4~GHz in a measurement line. Its characteristic impedance of 1.97~k$Ω$ is high enough to reach a strong junction-resonator coupling and a bright emission of the k-photon bunches. We show that a RWA treatment of the system accounts quantitatively for the observed radiation intensity, from $k=1$ to $6$, and over three orders of magnitude when varying the Josephson energy $E_J$. We also measure the second order correlation function of the radiated microwave to determine its Fano factor $F_k$, which in the low $E_J$ limit, confirms with $F_k=k$ the emission of $k$ photon bunches. At larger $E_J$, a more complex behavior is observed in quantitative agreement with numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2022; v1 submitted 18 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Fractional entropy of multichannel Kondo systems from conductance-charge relations
Authors:
Cheolhee Han,
Zubair Iftikhar,
Yaakov Kleeorin,
Anne Anthore,
Frédéric Pierre,
Yigal Meir,
Andrew K. Mitchell,
Eran Sela
Abstract:
Fractional entropy is a signature of nonlocal degrees of freedom, such as Majorana zero modes or more exotic non-Abelian anyons. Although direct experimental measurements remain challenging, Maxwell relations provide an indirect route to the entropy through charge measurements. Here we consider multichannel charge-Kondo systems, which are predicted to host exotic quasiparticles due to a frustratio…
▽ More
Fractional entropy is a signature of nonlocal degrees of freedom, such as Majorana zero modes or more exotic non-Abelian anyons. Although direct experimental measurements remain challenging, Maxwell relations provide an indirect route to the entropy through charge measurements. Here we consider multichannel charge-Kondo systems, which are predicted to host exotic quasiparticles due to a frustration of Kondo screening at low temperatures. In the absence of experimental data for the charge occupation, we derive relations connecting the latter to the conductance, for which experimental results have recently been obtained. Our analysis indicates that Majorana and Fibonacci anyon quasiparticles are well-developed in existing two- and three-channel charge-Kondo devices, and that their characteristic $k_{\rm{B}}\log\sqrt{2}$ and $k_{\rm{B}}\log\frac{1+\sqrt{5}}{2}$ entropies are experimentally measurable.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2022; v1 submitted 29 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Circuit Quantum Simulation of a Tomonaga-Luttinger Liquid with an Impurity
Authors:
A. Anthore,
Z. Iftikhar,
E. Boulat,
F. D. Parmentier,
A. Cavanna,
A. Ouerghi,
U. Gennser,
F. Pierre
Abstract:
The Tomonaga-Luttinger liquid (TLL) concept is believed to generically describe the strongly-correlated physics of one-dimensional systems at low temperatures. A hallmark signature in 1D conductors is the quantum phase transition between metallic and insulating states induced by a single impurity. However, this transition impedes experimental explorations of real-world TLLs. Furthermore, its theor…
▽ More
The Tomonaga-Luttinger liquid (TLL) concept is believed to generically describe the strongly-correlated physics of one-dimensional systems at low temperatures. A hallmark signature in 1D conductors is the quantum phase transition between metallic and insulating states induced by a single impurity. However, this transition impedes experimental explorations of real-world TLLs. Furthermore, its theoretical treatment, explaining the universal energy rescaling of the conductance at low temperatures, has so far been achieved exactly only for specific interaction strengths. Quantum simulation can provide a powerful workaround. Here, a hybrid metal-semiconductor dissipative quantum circuit is shown to implement the analogue of a TLL of adjustable electronic interactions comprising a single, fully tunable scattering impurity. Measurements reveal the renormalization group `beta-function' for the conductance that completely determines the TLL universal crossover to an insulating state upon cooling. Moreover, the characteristic scaling energy locating at a given temperature the position within this conductance renormalization flow is established over nine decades versus circuit parameters, and the out-of-equilibrium regime is explored. With the quantum simulator quality demonstrated from the precise parameter-free validation of existing and novel TLL predictions, quantum simulation is achieved in a strong sense, by elucidating interaction regimes which resist theoretical solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Tunable Quantum Criticality and Super-ballistic Transport in a `Charge' Kondo Circuit
Authors:
Z. Iftikhar,
A. Anthore,
A. K. Mitchell,
F. D. Parmentier,
U. Gennser,
A. Ouerghi,
A. Cavanna,
C. Mora,
P. Simon,
F. Pierre
Abstract:
Quantum phase transitions are ubiquitous in many exotic behaviors of strongly-correlated materials. However the microscopic complexity impedes their quantitative understanding. Here, we observe thoroughly and comprehend the rich strongly-correlated physics in two profoundly dissimilar regimes of quantum criticality. With a circuit implementing a quantum simulator for the three-channel Kondo model,…
▽ More
Quantum phase transitions are ubiquitous in many exotic behaviors of strongly-correlated materials. However the microscopic complexity impedes their quantitative understanding. Here, we observe thoroughly and comprehend the rich strongly-correlated physics in two profoundly dissimilar regimes of quantum criticality. With a circuit implementing a quantum simulator for the three-channel Kondo model, we reveal the universal scalings toward different low-temperature fixed points and along the multiple crossovers from quantum criticality. Notably, an unanticipated violation of the maximum conductance for ballistic free electrons is uncovered. The present charge pseudospin implementation of a Kondo impurity opens access to a broad variety of strongly-correlated phenomena.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2018; v1 submitted 8 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Primary thermometry triad at 6 mK in mesoscopic circuits
Authors:
Z. Iftikhar,
A. Anthore,
S. Jezouin,
F. D. Parmentier,
Y. Jin,
A. Cavanna,
A. Ouerghi,
U. Gennser,
F. Pierre
Abstract:
Quantum physics emerge and develop as temperature is reduced. Although mesoscopic electrical circuits constitute an outstanding platform to explore quantum behavior, the challenge in cooling the electrons impedes their potential. The strong coupling of such micrometer-scale devices with the measurement lines, combined with the weak coupling to the substrate, makes them extremely difficult to therm…
▽ More
Quantum physics emerge and develop as temperature is reduced. Although mesoscopic electrical circuits constitute an outstanding platform to explore quantum behavior, the challenge in cooling the electrons impedes their potential. The strong coupling of such micrometer-scale devices with the measurement lines, combined with the weak coupling to the substrate, makes them extremely difficult to thermalize below 10 mK and imposes in-situ thermometers. Here we demonstrate electronic quantum transport at 6 mK in micrometer-scale mesoscopic circuits. The thermometry methods are established by the comparison of three in-situ primary thermometers, each involving a different underlying physics. The employed combination of quantum shot noise, quantum back-action of a resistive circuit and conductance oscillations of a single-electron transistor covers a remarkably broad spectrum of mesoscopic phenomena. The experiment, performed in vacuum using a standard cryogen-free dilution refrigerator, paves the way toward the sub-millikelvin range with additional thermalization and refrigeration techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Controlling charge quantization with quantum fluctuations
Authors:
S. Jezouin,
Z. Iftikhar,
A. Anthore,
F. D. Parmentier,
U. Gennser,
A. Cavanna,
A. Ouerghi,
I. P. Levkivskyi,
E. Idrisov,
E. V. Sukhorukov,
L. I. Glazman,
F. Pierre
Abstract:
In 1909, Millikan showed that the charge of electrically isolated systems is quantized in units of the elementary electron charge e. Today, the persistence of charge quantization in small, weakly connected conductors allows for circuits where single electrons are manipulated, with applications in e.g. metrology, detectors and thermometry. However, quantum fluctuations progressively reduce the disc…
▽ More
In 1909, Millikan showed that the charge of electrically isolated systems is quantized in units of the elementary electron charge e. Today, the persistence of charge quantization in small, weakly connected conductors allows for circuits where single electrons are manipulated, with applications in e.g. metrology, detectors and thermometry. However, quantum fluctuations progressively reduce the discreteness of charge as the connection strength is increased. Here we report on the full quantum control and characterization of charge quantization. By using semiconductor-based tunable elemental conduction channels to connect a micrometer-scale metallic island, the complete evolution is explored while scanning the entire range of connection strengths, from tunnel barrier to ballistic contact. We observe a robust scaling of charge quantization as the square root of the residual electron reflection probability across a quantum channel when approaching the ballistic critical point, which also applies beyond the regimes yet accessible to theory. At increased temperatures, the thermal fluctuations result in an exponential suppression of charge quantization as well as in a universal square root scaling, for arbitrary connection strengths, in agreement with expectations. Besides direct applications to improve single-electron functionalities and for the metal-semiconductor hybrids emerging in the quest toward topological quantum computing, the knowledge of the quantum laws of electricity will be essential for the quantum engineering of future nanoelectronic devices.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Line shapes and time dynamics of the Förster resonances between two Rydberg atoms in a time-varying electric field
Authors:
E. A. Yakshina,
D. B. Tretyakov,
I. I. Beterov,
V. M. Entin,
C. Andreeva,
A. Cinins,
A. Markovski,
Z. Iftikhar,
A. Ekers,
I. I. Ryabtsev
Abstract:
The observation of the Stark-tuned Förster resonances between Rydberg atoms excited by narrowband cw laser radiation requires usage of a Stark-switching technique in order to excite the atoms first in a fixed electric field and then to induce the interactions in a varied electric field, which is scanned across the Förster resonance. In our experiments with a few cold Rb Rydberg atoms we have found…
▽ More
The observation of the Stark-tuned Förster resonances between Rydberg atoms excited by narrowband cw laser radiation requires usage of a Stark-switching technique in order to excite the atoms first in a fixed electric field and then to induce the interactions in a varied electric field, which is scanned across the Förster resonance. In our experiments with a few cold Rb Rydberg atoms we have found that the transients at the edges of the electric pulses strongly affect the line shapes of the Förster resonances, since the population transfer at the resonances occurs on a time scale of $\sim$100 ns, which is comparable with the duration of the transients. For example, a short-term ringing at a certain frequency causes additional radio-frequency-assisted Förster resonances, while non-sharp edges lead to asymmetry. The intentional application of the radio-frequency field induces transitions between collective states, whose line shape depends on the interaction strengths and time. Spatial averaging over the atom positions in a single interaction volume yields a cusped line shape of the Förster resonance. We present a detailed experimental and theoretical analysis of the line shape and time dynamics of the Stark-tuned Förster resonances ${\rm Rb}(nP_{3/2} )+{\rm Rb}(nP_{3/2} )\to {\rm Rb}(nS_{1/2} )+{\rm Rb}([n+1]S_{1/2} )$ for two Rb Rydberg atoms interacting in a time-varying electric field.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2016; v1 submitted 20 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
First-forbidden $\mathbfβ$-decay rates, energy rates of $β$-delayed neutrons and probability of $β$-delayed neutron emissions for neutron-rich nickel isotopes
Authors:
Jameel-Un Nabi,
Necla Cakmak,
Zafar Iftikhar
Abstract:
First-forbidden (FF) transitions can play an important role in decreasing the calculated half-lives specially in environments where allowed Gamow-Teller (GT) transitions are unfavored. Of special mention is the case of neutron-rich nuclei where, due to phase-space amplification, FF transitions are much favored. We calculate the allowed GT transitions in various pn-QRPA models for even-even neutron…
▽ More
First-forbidden (FF) transitions can play an important role in decreasing the calculated half-lives specially in environments where allowed Gamow-Teller (GT) transitions are unfavored. Of special mention is the case of neutron-rich nuclei where, due to phase-space amplification, FF transitions are much favored. We calculate the allowed GT transitions in various pn-QRPA models for even-even neutron-rich isotopes of nickel. Here we also study the effect of deformation on the calculated GT strengths. The FF transitions for even-even neutron-rich isotopes of nickel are calculated assuming the nuclei to be spherical. Later we take into account deformation of nuclei and calculate GT + unique FF transitions, stellar $β$-decay rates, energy rate of $β$-delayed neutrons and probability of $β$-delayed neutron emissions. The calculated half-lives are in excellent agreement with measured ones and might contribute in speeding-up of the $r$-matter flow.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
First-forbidden transitions and stellar $β$-decay rates of Zn and Ge isotopes
Authors:
Jameel-Un Nabi,
Necla Cakmak,
Sabin Stoica,
Zafar Iftikhar
Abstract:
First-forbidden (FF) charge-changing transitions become relatively important for nuclei as their proton number increases. This is because the strength of allowed Gamow-Teller (GT) transitions decreases with increasing Z. The FF transitions play an important role in reducing the half-lives as against those calculated from taking the GT transitions alone into account. In this paper we calculate allo…
▽ More
First-forbidden (FF) charge-changing transitions become relatively important for nuclei as their proton number increases. This is because the strength of allowed Gamow-Teller (GT) transitions decreases with increasing Z. The FF transitions play an important role in reducing the half-lives as against those calculated from taking the GT transitions alone into account. In this paper we calculate allowed GT as well as $0^{+} \rightarrow 0^{-}$ and $0^{+} \rightarrow 2^{-}$ transitions for neutron-rich Zn and Ge isotopes. Two different pn-QRPA models were used with a schematic separable interaction to calculate GT and FF transitions. Half-lives calculated after inclusion of FF transitions were in excellent agreement with the experimental data. Our calculations were also compared to previous QRPA calculations and were found to be in better agreement with measured data. Stellar $β$-decay rates were calculated for these nuclei including allowed GT and unique FF transitions for astrophysical applications. $^{86,88}$Ge has a sizeable contribution to the total stellar rate from unique FF transitions.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Two-channel Kondo effect and renormalization flow with macroscopic quantum charge states
Authors:
Z. Iftikhar,
S. Jezouin,
A. Anthore,
U. Gennser,
F. D. Parmentier,
A. Cavanna,
F. Pierre
Abstract:
Many-body correlations and macroscopic quantum behaviors are fascinating condensed matter problems. A powerful test-bed for the many-body concepts and methods is the Kondo model which entails the coupling of a quantum impurity to a continuum of states. It is central in highly correlated systems and can be explored with tunable nanostructures. Although Kondo physics is usually associated with the h…
▽ More
Many-body correlations and macroscopic quantum behaviors are fascinating condensed matter problems. A powerful test-bed for the many-body concepts and methods is the Kondo model which entails the coupling of a quantum impurity to a continuum of states. It is central in highly correlated systems and can be explored with tunable nanostructures. Although Kondo physics is usually associated with the hybridization of itinerant electrons with microscopic magnetic moments, theory predicts that it can arise whenever degenerate quantum states are coupled to a continuum. Here we demonstrate the previously elusive `charge' Kondo effect in a hybrid metal-semiconductor implementation of a single-electron transistor, with a quantum pseudospin-1/2 constituted by two degenerate macroscopic charge states of a metallic island. In contrast to other Kondo nanostructures, each conduction channel connecting the island to an electrode constitutes a distinct and fully tunable Kondo channel, thereby providing an unprecedented access to the two-channel Kondo effect and a clear path to multi-channel Kondo physics. Using a weakly coupled probe, we reveal the renormalization flow, as temperature is reduced, of two Kondo channels competing to screen the charge pseudospin. This provides a direct view of how the predicted quantum phase transition develops across the symmetric quantum critical point. Detuning the pseudospin away from degeneracy, we demonstrate, on a fully characterized device, quantitative agreement with the predictions for the finite-temperature crossover from quantum criticality.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
