-
Polar orbits around the newly formed Earth-Moon binary system
Authors:
Stephen Lepp,
Rebecca G. Martin,
Stanley A. Baronett
Abstract:
We examine the dynamics and stability of circumbinary particles orbiting around the Earth-Moon binary system. The moon formed close to the Earth (semi-major axis $a_{EM}\approx 3\, R_\oplus$) and expanded through tides to its current day semi-major axis ($a_{ EM}= 60\, R_\oplus$). Circumbinary orbits that are polar or highly inclined to the Earth-Moon orbit are subject to two competing effects: (i…
▽ More
We examine the dynamics and stability of circumbinary particles orbiting around the Earth-Moon binary system. The moon formed close to the Earth (semi-major axis $a_{EM}\approx 3\, R_\oplus$) and expanded through tides to its current day semi-major axis ($a_{ EM}= 60\, R_\oplus$). Circumbinary orbits that are polar or highly inclined to the Earth-Moon orbit are subject to two competing effects: (i) nodal precession about the Earth-Moon eccentricity vector and (ii) Kozai-Lidov oscillations of eccentricity and inclination driven by the Sun. While we find that there are no stable polar orbits around the Earth-Moon orbit with the current day semi-major axis, polar orbits were stable immediately after the formation of the Moon, at the time when there was a lot of debris around the system, up to when the semi-major axis reached about $a_{ EM}\approx 10\, R_\oplus$. We discuss implications of polar orbits on the evolution of the Earth-Moon system and the possibility of polar orbiting moons around exoplanet-moon binaries.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Relativistic Effects on Circumbinary Disk Evolution: Breaking the Polar Alignment around Eccentric Black Hole Binary Systems
Authors:
Anna C. Childs,
Rebecca G. Martin,
C. J. Nixon,
Aaron M. Geller,
Stephen H. Lubow,
Zhaohuan Zhu,
Stephen Lepp
Abstract:
We study the effects of general relativity (GR) on the evolution and alignment of circumbinary disks around binaries on all scales. We implement relativistic apsidal precession of the binary into the hydrodynamics code {\sc phantom}. We find that the effects of GR can suppress the stable polar alignment of a circumbinary disk, depending on how the relativistic binary apsidal precession timescale c…
▽ More
We study the effects of general relativity (GR) on the evolution and alignment of circumbinary disks around binaries on all scales. We implement relativistic apsidal precession of the binary into the hydrodynamics code {\sc phantom}. We find that the effects of GR can suppress the stable polar alignment of a circumbinary disk, depending on how the relativistic binary apsidal precession timescale compares to the disk nodal precession timescale. Studies of circumbinary disk evolution typically ignore the effects of GR which is an appropriate simplification for low mass or widely separated binary systems. In this case, polar alignment occurs providing that the disks initial misalignment is sufficiently large. However, systems with a very short relativistic precession timescale cannot polar align and instead move toward coplanar alignment. In the intermediate regime where the timescales are similar, the outcome depends upon the properties of the disk. Polar alignment is more likely in the wavelike disk regime (where the disk viscosity parameter is less than the aspect ratio, $α<H/r$) since the disk is in good radial communication. In the viscous disk regime disk breaking is more likely. Multiple rings can destructively interact with one another resulting in short disk lifetimes, and the disk moving towards coplanar alignment. Around main-sequence star or stellar mass black hole binaries, polar alignment may be suppressed far from the binary but in general the inner parts of the disk can align to polar. Polar alignment may be completely suppressed for disks around supermassive black holes for close binary separations.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Retrograde discs around one component of a binary are unstable to tilting
Authors:
Madeline Overton,
Rebecca G. Martin,
Stephen H. Lubow,
Stephen Lepp
Abstract:
With hydrodynamic simulations we show that a coplanar disc around one component of a binary can be unstable to global tilting when the disc orbits in a retrograde direction relative to the binary. The disc experiences the largest inclination growth relative to the binary orbit in the outermost radii of the disc, closest to the companion. This tilt instability also occurs for test particles. A retr…
▽ More
With hydrodynamic simulations we show that a coplanar disc around one component of a binary can be unstable to global tilting when the disc orbits in a retrograde direction relative to the binary. The disc experiences the largest inclination growth relative to the binary orbit in the outermost radii of the disc, closest to the companion. This tilt instability also occurs for test particles. A retrograde disc is much larger than a prograde disc since it is not tidally truncated and instead spreads outwards to the orbit of the companion. The coplanar retrograde disc remains circular while a coplanar prograde disc can become eccentric. We suggest that the inclination instability is due to a disc resonance caused by the interaction of the tilt with the tidal field of the binary. This model is applicable to Be/X-ray binaries in which the Be star disc may be retrograde relative to the binary orbit if there was a sufficiently strong kick from the supernova that formed the neutron star companion. The accretion on to the neutron star and the resulting X-ray outbursts are weaker in the retrograde case compared to the prograde case.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Mergers of black hole binaries driven by misaligned circumbinary discs
Authors:
Rebecca G. Martin,
Stephen Lepp,
Bing Zhang,
C. J. Nixon,
Anna C. Childs
Abstract:
With hydrodynamical simulations we examine the evolution of a highly misaligned circumbinary disc around a black hole binary including the effects of general relativity. We show that a disc mass of just a few percent of the binary mass can significantly increase the binary eccentricity through von-Zeipel--Kozai-Lidov (ZKL) like oscillations provided that the disc lifetime is longer than the ZKL os…
▽ More
With hydrodynamical simulations we examine the evolution of a highly misaligned circumbinary disc around a black hole binary including the effects of general relativity. We show that a disc mass of just a few percent of the binary mass can significantly increase the binary eccentricity through von-Zeipel--Kozai-Lidov (ZKL) like oscillations provided that the disc lifetime is longer than the ZKL oscillation timescale. The disc begins as a relatively narrow ring of material far from the binary and spreads radially. When the binary becomes highly eccentric, disc breaking forms an inner disc ring that quickly aligns to polar. The polar ring drives fast retrograde apsidal precession of the binary that weakens the ZKL effect. This allows the binary eccentricity to remain at a high level and may significantly shorten the black hole merger time. The mechanism requires the initial disc inclination relative to the binary to be closer to retrograde than to prograde.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Black hole mergers driven by a captured low-mass companion
Authors:
Stephen Lepp,
Rebecca G. Martin,
Bing Zhang
Abstract:
Increased eccentricity of a black hole binary leads to reduced merger times. With n-body simulations and analytic approximations including the effects of general relativity (GR), we show that even a low mass companion orbiting a black hole binary can cause significant eccentricity oscillations of the binary as a result of the Kozai-Lidov mechanism. A companion with a mass as low as about 1% of the…
▽ More
Increased eccentricity of a black hole binary leads to reduced merger times. With n-body simulations and analytic approximations including the effects of general relativity (GR), we show that even a low mass companion orbiting a black hole binary can cause significant eccentricity oscillations of the binary as a result of the Kozai-Lidov mechanism. A companion with a mass as low as about 1% of the binary mass can drive the binary eccentricity up to >~ 0.8, while a mass of a few percent can drive eccentricities greater than 0.98. For low mass companions, this mechanism requires the companion to be on an orbit that is closer to retrograde than to prograde to the binary orbit and this may occur through capture of the third body. The effects of GR limit the radial range for the companion for which this mechanism works for the closest binaries. The merger timescale may be reduced by several orders of magnitude for a captured companion mass of only a few percent of the binary mass.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Coplanar circumbinary planets can be unstable to large tilt oscillations in the presence of an inner polar planet
Authors:
Anna C. Childs,
Rebecca G. Martin,
Stephen Lepp,
Stephen H. Lubow,
Aaron M. Geller
Abstract:
Mutually misaligned circumbinary planets may form in a warped or broken gas disc or from later planet-planet interactions. With numerical simulations and analytic estimates we explore the dynamics of two circumbinary planets with a large mutual inclination. A coplanar inner planet causes prograde apsidal precession of the binary and the stationary inclination for the outer planet is higher for lar…
▽ More
Mutually misaligned circumbinary planets may form in a warped or broken gas disc or from later planet-planet interactions. With numerical simulations and analytic estimates we explore the dynamics of two circumbinary planets with a large mutual inclination. A coplanar inner planet causes prograde apsidal precession of the binary and the stationary inclination for the outer planet is higher for larger outer planet orbital radius. In this case a coplanar outer planet always remains coplanar. On the other hand, a polar inner planet causes retrograde apsidal precession of the binary orbit and the stationary inclination is smaller for larger outer planet orbital radius. For a range of outer planet semi-major axes, an initially coplanar orbit is librating meaning that the outer planet undergoes large tilt oscillations. Circumbinary planets that are highly inclined to the binary are difficult to detect -- it is unlikely for a planet to have an inclination below the transit detection limit in the presence of a polar inner planet. These results suggest that there could be a population of circumbinary planets that are undergoing large tilt oscillations.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Polar circumtriple planets and disks can only form close to a triple star
Authors:
Stephen Lepp,
Rebecca G. Martin,
Stephen H. Lubow
Abstract:
Observations of protoplanetary disks around binary and triple star systems suggest that misalignments between the orbital plane of the stars and the disks are common. Motivated by recent observations of polar circumbinary disks, we explore the possibility for polar circumtriple disks and therefore polar circumtriple planets that could form in such a disk. With n-body simulations and analytic metho…
▽ More
Observations of protoplanetary disks around binary and triple star systems suggest that misalignments between the orbital plane of the stars and the disks are common. Motivated by recent observations of polar circumbinary disks, we explore the possibility for polar circumtriple disks and therefore polar circumtriple planets that could form in such a disk. With n-body simulations and analytic methods we find that the inclusion of the third star, and the associated apsidal precession, significantly reduces the radial range of polar orbits so that circumtriple polar disks and planets can only be found close to the stellar system. Outside of a critical radius, that is typically in the range of 3-10 times the outer binary separation depending upon the binary parameters, the orbits behave the same as they do around a circular orbit binary. For some observed systems that have shorter period inner binaries, the critical radius is considerably larger. If polar circumtriple planets can form, we suggest that it is likely that they form in a disk that was subject to breaking.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Formation of super-Earths in icy dead zones around low-mass stars
Authors:
David Vallet,
Anna C. Childs,
Rebecca G. Martin,
Mario Livio,
Stephen Lepp
Abstract:
While giant planet occurrence rates increase with stellar mass, occurrence rates of close-in super-Earths decrease. This is in contradiction to the expectation that the total mass of the planets in a system scale with the protoplanetary disc mass and hence the stellar mass. Since the snow line plays an important role in the planet formation process we examine differences in the temperature structu…
▽ More
While giant planet occurrence rates increase with stellar mass, occurrence rates of close-in super-Earths decrease. This is in contradiction to the expectation that the total mass of the planets in a system scale with the protoplanetary disc mass and hence the stellar mass. Since the snow line plays an important role in the planet formation process we examine differences in the temperature structure of protoplanetary gas discs around stars of different mass. Protoplanetary discs likely contain a dead zone at the midplane that is sufficiently cold and dense for the magneto-rotational instability to be suppressed. As material builds up, the outer parts of the dead zone may be heated by self-gravity. The temperature in the disc can be below the snow line temperature far from the star and in the inner parts of a dead zone. The inner icy region has a larger radial extent around smaller mass stars. The increased mass of solid icy material may allow for the in situ formation of larger and more numerous planets close to a low-mass star. Super-Earths that form in the inner icy region may have a composition that includes a significant fraction of volatiles.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Fast nodal precession of the disc around Pleione requires a broken disc
Authors:
Rebecca G. Martin,
Stephen Lepp
Abstract:
Pleione is a Be star that is in a 218 day orbit with a low-mass binary companion. Recent numerical simulations have shown that a Be star disc can be subject to breaking when material is actively being fed into the inner parts of the disc. After breaking, the disc is composed of two rings: an inner ring that is anchored to the stellar equator and an outer ring that is free to nodally precess. A dou…
▽ More
Pleione is a Be star that is in a 218 day orbit with a low-mass binary companion. Recent numerical simulations have shown that a Be star disc can be subject to breaking when material is actively being fed into the inner parts of the disc. After breaking, the disc is composed of two rings: an inner ring that is anchored to the stellar equator and an outer ring that is free to nodally precess. A double ring disc may explain some of the observed variability in Pleione. We model the nodal precession of the outer disc ring that is driven by the companion on an observed timescale of $80.5\,\rm yr$. We find that the outer ring of a broken disc in a binary with an eccentricity of $e_{\rm b}= 0.6$ can precess on the observed timescale and have an outer radius that is in rough agreement with the observed disc size. An unbroken disc model cannot fit both the observed precession rate and disc size. Suppression of Kozai-Lidov driven disc eccentricity is more likely for a high binary eccentricity if the disc extends to the tidal truncation radius.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
A radial limit on polar circumbinary orbits from general relativity
Authors:
Stephen Lepp,
Rebecca G. Martin,
Anna C. Childs
Abstract:
A particle orbiting a misaligned eccentric orbit binary undergoes nodal precession either around the binary angular momentum vector (a circulating orbit) or around a stationary inclination (a librating orbit). In the absence of general relativity, the stationary inclination is inclined by 90 degrees to the binary angular momentum vector (aligned with the binary eccentricity vector) and does not de…
▽ More
A particle orbiting a misaligned eccentric orbit binary undergoes nodal precession either around the binary angular momentum vector (a circulating orbit) or around a stationary inclination (a librating orbit). In the absence of general relativity, the stationary inclination is inclined by 90 degrees to the binary angular momentum vector (aligned with the binary eccentricity vector) and does not depend on the particle semi-major axis. General relativity causes apsidal precession of the binary orbit. Close to the binary, the behaviour of the particle is not significantly affected, a librating particle precesses with the binary. However, we find that the stationary inclination and the minimum inclination required for libration both increase with the particle semi-major axis. There is a critical radius beyond which there are no librating orbits, only circulating orbits, and therefore there is a maximum orbital radius for a stationary polar orbiting body. The critical radius is within planet forming regions around binaries with semi-major axis <= 1 au. This has implications for the search for misaligned circumbinary planets and the radial extent of polar circumbinary disks.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Circumbinary disk evolution in the presence of an outer companion star
Authors:
Rebecca G. Martin,
Stephen Lepp,
Stephen H. Lubow,
Matthew A. Kenworthy,
Grant M. Kennedy,
David Vallet
Abstract:
We consider a hierarchical triple system consisting of an inner eccentric binary with an outer companion. A highly misaligned circumbinary disk around the inner binary is subject to two competing effects: (i) nodal precession about the inner binary eccentricity vector that leads to an increase in misalignment (polar alignment) and (ii) Kozai-Lidov (KL) oscillations of eccentricity and inclination…
▽ More
We consider a hierarchical triple system consisting of an inner eccentric binary with an outer companion. A highly misaligned circumbinary disk around the inner binary is subject to two competing effects: (i) nodal precession about the inner binary eccentricity vector that leads to an increase in misalignment (polar alignment) and (ii) Kozai-Lidov (KL) oscillations of eccentricity and inclination driven by the outer companion that leads to a reduction in the misalignment. The outcome depends upon the ratio of the timescales of these effects. If the inner binary torque dominates, then the disk aligns to a polar orientation. If the outer companion torque dominates, then the disk undergoes KL oscillations. In that case, the highly eccentric and misaligned disk is disrupted and accreted by the inner binary, while some mass is transferred to the outer companion. However, when the torques are similar, the outer parts of the circumbinary disk can undergo large eccentricity oscillations while the inclination remains close to the polar orientation. The range of initial disk inclinations that evolve to a polar orientation is smaller in the presence of the outer companion. Disk breaking is also more likely, at least temporarily, during the polar alignment process. The stellar orbits in HD 98800 have parameters such that polar alignment of the circumbinary disk is expected. In the absence of the gas, solid particles are unstable at much smaller radii than the gas disk inner tidal truncation radius because KL driven eccentricity leads to close encounters with the binary.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Generalised warped disk equations
Authors:
Rebecca G. Martin,
Stephen H. Lubow,
J. E. Pringle,
Alessia Franchini,
Zhaohuan Zhu,
Stephen Lepp,
Rebecca Nealon,
C. J. Nixon,
David Vallet
Abstract:
The manner in which warps in accretion disks evolve depends on the magnitude of the viscosity. For small viscosity $(α< H/R)$ the warp evolves in a wave-like manner; for large viscosity $H/R<α\ll 1$ it evolves diffusively. Here $α$ is the viscosity parameter and $H/R$ the disk aspect ratio. Currently there is no simple set of equations which describes the evolution in both regimes. In this paper w…
▽ More
The manner in which warps in accretion disks evolve depends on the magnitude of the viscosity. For small viscosity $(α< H/R)$ the warp evolves in a wave-like manner; for large viscosity $H/R<α\ll 1$ it evolves diffusively. Here $α$ is the viscosity parameter and $H/R$ the disk aspect ratio. Currently there is no simple set of equations which describes the evolution in both regimes. In this paper we describe a possible solution to this problem and introduce a set of one-dimensional equations that describe the evolution of a warped disk that are applicable in both high and low viscosity regimes for arbitrary tilts, but small warps.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Asteroid impacts on terrestrial planets: The effects of super-Earths and the role of the $ν_6$ resonance
Authors:
Jeremy L. Smallwood,
Rebecca G. Martin,
Stephen Lepp,
Mario Livio
Abstract:
With N-body simulations of a planetary system with an asteroid belt we investigate how the asteroid impact rate on the Earth is affected by the architecture of the planetary system. We find that the $ν_6$ secular resonance plays an important role in the asteroid collision rate with the Earth. Compared to exoplanetary systems, the solar system is somewhat special in its lack of a super-Earth mass p…
▽ More
With N-body simulations of a planetary system with an asteroid belt we investigate how the asteroid impact rate on the Earth is affected by the architecture of the planetary system. We find that the $ν_6$ secular resonance plays an important role in the asteroid collision rate with the Earth. Compared to exoplanetary systems, the solar system is somewhat special in its lack of a super-Earth mass planet in the inner solar system. We therefore first consider the effects of the presence of a super-Earth in the terrestrial planet region. We find a significant effect for super-Earths with a mass of around $10\,\rm M_\oplus$ and a separation greater than about $0.7\,\rm AU$. For a super-Earth that is interior to the Earth's orbit, the number of asteroids colliding with Earth increases the closer the super-Earth is to the Earth's orbit. This is the result of multiple secular resonance locations causing more asteroids to be perturbed onto Earth-crossing orbits. When the super-Earth is placed exterior to Earth's orbit, the collision rate decreases substantially because the $ν_6$ resonance no longer exists in the asteroid belt region. We also find that changing the semi-major axis of Saturn leads to a significant decrease in the asteroid collision rate, while increasing its mass increases the collision rate. These results may have implications for the habitability of exoplanetary systems.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Cosmological Recombination of Lithium and its Effect on the Microwave Background Anisotropies
Authors:
P. C. Stancil,
A. Loeb,
M. Zaldarriaga,
A. Dalgarno,
S. Lepp
Abstract:
The cosmological recombination history of lithium, produced during Big--Bang nucleosynthesis, is presented using updated chemistry and cosmological parameters consistent with recent cosmic microwave background (CMB) measurements. For the popular set of cosmological parameters, about a fifth of the lithium ions recombine into neutral atoms by a redshift $z\sim 400$. The neutral lithium atoms scat…
▽ More
The cosmological recombination history of lithium, produced during Big--Bang nucleosynthesis, is presented using updated chemistry and cosmological parameters consistent with recent cosmic microwave background (CMB) measurements. For the popular set of cosmological parameters, about a fifth of the lithium ions recombine into neutral atoms by a redshift $z\sim 400$. The neutral lithium atoms scatter resonantly the CMB at 6708 Åand distort its intensity and polarization anisotropies at observed wavelengths around $\sim 300 μ$m, as originally suggested by Loeb (2001). The modified anistropies resulting from the lithium recombination history are calculated for a variety of cosmological models and found to result primarily in a suppression of the power spectrum amplitude. Significant modification of the power spectrum occurs for models which assume a large primordial abundance of lithium. While detection of the lithium signal might prove difficult, if offers the possibility of inferring the lithium primordial abundance and is the only probe proposed to date of the large-scale structure of the Universe for $z\sim 500-100$.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2002; v1 submitted 11 January, 2002;
originally announced January 2002.
-
Rate coefficients for rovibrational transitions in H_2 due to collisions with He
Authors:
N. Balakrishnan,
M. Vieira,
J. F. Babb,
R. C. Forrey,
A. Dalgarno,
S. Lepp
Abstract:
We present quantum mechanical and quasiclassical trajectory calculations of cross sections for rovibrational transitions in ortho- and para-H_2 induced by collisions with He atoms. Cross sections were obtained for kinetic energies between 10^-4 and 3 eV, and the corresponding rate coefficients were calculated for the temperature range 100<T<4000 K. Comparisons are made with previous calculations…
▽ More
We present quantum mechanical and quasiclassical trajectory calculations of cross sections for rovibrational transitions in ortho- and para-H_2 induced by collisions with He atoms. Cross sections were obtained for kinetic energies between 10^-4 and 3 eV, and the corresponding rate coefficients were calculated for the temperature range 100<T<4000 K. Comparisons are made with previous calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 1999;
originally announced April 1999.
-
Search for Interstellar Water in the Translucent Molecular Cloud toward HD 154368
Authors:
Marco Spaans,
David Neufeld,
Stephen Lepp,
Gary J. Melnick,
John Stauffer
Abstract:
We report an upper limit of 9 x 10^{12} cm-2 on the column density of water in the translucent cloud along the line of sight toward HD 154368. This result is based upon a search for the C-X band of water near 1240 Åcarried out using the Goddard High Resolution Spectrograph of the Hubble Space Telescope. Our observational limit on the water abundance together with detailed chemical models of tran…
▽ More
We report an upper limit of 9 x 10^{12} cm-2 on the column density of water in the translucent cloud along the line of sight toward HD 154368. This result is based upon a search for the C-X band of water near 1240 Åcarried out using the Goddard High Resolution Spectrograph of the Hubble Space Telescope. Our observational limit on the water abundance together with detailed chemical models of translucent clouds and previous measurements of OH along the line of sight constrain the branching ratio in the dissociative recombination of H_3O+ to form water. We find at the $3σ$ level that no more than 30% of dissociative recombinations of H_3O+ can lead to H_2O. The observed spectrum also yielded high-resolution observations of the Mg II doublet at 1239.9 Åand 1240.4 Å, allowing the velocity structure of the dominant ionization state of magnesium to be studied along the line of sight. The Mg II spectrum is consistent with GHRS observations at lower spectral resolution that were obtained previously but allow an additional velocity component to be identified.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 1998;
originally announced March 1998.
