-
"Ultima Ratio": Simulating wide-range X-ray scattering and diffraction
Authors:
Brian R. Pauw,
Sofya Laskina,
Aakash Naik,
Glen J. Smales,
Janine George,
Ingo Breßler,
Philipp Benner
Abstract:
We demonstrate a strategy for simulating wide-range X-ray scattering patterns, which spans the small- and wide scattering angles as well as the scattering angles typically used for Pair Distribution Function (PDF) analysis. Such simulated patterns can be used to test holistic analysis models, and, since the diffraction intensity is on the same scale as the scattering intensity, may offer a novel p…
▽ More
We demonstrate a strategy for simulating wide-range X-ray scattering patterns, which spans the small- and wide scattering angles as well as the scattering angles typically used for Pair Distribution Function (PDF) analysis. Such simulated patterns can be used to test holistic analysis models, and, since the diffraction intensity is on the same scale as the scattering intensity, may offer a novel pathway for determining the degree of crystallinity.
The "Ultima Ratio" strategy is demonstrated on a 64-nm Metal Organic Framework (MOF) particle, calculated from Q < 0.01 1/nm up to Q < 150 1/nm, with a resolution of 0.16 Angstrom. The computations exploit a modified 3D Fast Fourier Transform (3D-FFT), whose modifications enable the transformations of matrices at least up to 8000^3 voxels in size. Multiple of these modified 3D-FFTs are combined to improve the low-Q behaviour. The resulting curve is compared to a wide-range scattering pattern measured on a polydisperse MOF powder. While computationally intensive, the approach is expected to be useful for simulating scattering from a wide range of realistic, complex structures, from (poly-)crystalline particles to hierarchical, multicomponent structures such as viruses and catalysts.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
The human factor: results of a small-angle scattering data analysis Round Robin
Authors:
Brian R. Pauw,
Glen J. Smales,
Andy S. Anker,
Daniel M. Balazs,
Frederick L. Beyer,
Ralf Bienert,
Wim G. Bouwman,
Ingo Breßler,
Joachim Breternitz,
Erik S Brok,
Gary Bryant,
Andrew J. Clulow,
Erin R. Crater,
Frédéric De Geuser,
Alessandra Del Giudice,
Jérôme Deumer,
Sabrina Disch,
Shankar Dutt,
Kilian Frank,
Emiliano Fratini,
Elliot P. Gilbert,
Marc Benjamin Hahn,
James Hallett,
Max Hohenschutz,
Martin Hollamby
, et al. (24 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
A Round Robin study has been carried out to estimate the impact of the human element in small-angle scattering data analysis. Four corrected datasets were provided to participants ready for analysis. All datasets were measured on samples containing spherical scatterers, with two datasets in dilute dispersions, and two from powders. Most of the 46 participants correctly identified the number of pop…
▽ More
A Round Robin study has been carried out to estimate the impact of the human element in small-angle scattering data analysis. Four corrected datasets were provided to participants ready for analysis. All datasets were measured on samples containing spherical scatterers, with two datasets in dilute dispersions, and two from powders. Most of the 46 participants correctly identified the number of populations in the dilute dispersions, with half of the population mean entries within 1.5% and half of the population width entries within 40%, respectively. Due to the added complexity of the structure factor, much fewer people submitted answers on the powder datasets. For those that did, half of the entries for the means and widths were within 44% and 86% respectively. This Round Robin experiment highlights several causes for the discrepancies, for which solutions are proposed.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Small-Angle X-ray Scattering: Characterization of cubic Au nanoparticles using Debye's scattering formula
Authors:
Jérôme Deumer,
Brian R. Pauw,
Sylvie Marguet,
Dieter Skroblin,
Olivier Taché,
Michael Krumrey,
Christian Gollwitzer
Abstract:
We propose a versatile software package in the form of a Python extension, named CDEF (Computing Debye's scattering formula for Extraordinary Formfactors), to approximately calculate scattering profiles of arbitrarily shaped nanoparticles for small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). CDEF generates a quasi-randomly distributed point cloud in the desired particle shape and then applies the open source s…
▽ More
We propose a versatile software package in the form of a Python extension, named CDEF (Computing Debye's scattering formula for Extraordinary Formfactors), to approximately calculate scattering profiles of arbitrarily shaped nanoparticles for small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). CDEF generates a quasi-randomly distributed point cloud in the desired particle shape and then applies the open source software DEBYER for efficient evaluation of Debye's scattering formula to calculate the SAXS pattern. If self-correlation of the scattering signal is not omitted, the quasi-random distribution provides faster convergence compared to a true random distribution of the scatterers, especially at higher momentum transfer. The usage of the software is demonstrated for the evaluation of scattering data of Au nanocubes with rounded edges, which were measured at the four-crystal monochromator beamline of PTB at the synchrotron radiation facility BESSY II in Berlin. Our implementation is fast enough to run on a single desktop computer and perform model fits within minutes. The accuracy of the method was analyzed by comparison with analytically known form factors and verified with another implementation, the SPONGE, based on a similiar principle with fewer approximations. Additionally, the SPONGE coupled to McSAS3 allows us to further retrieve information on the uncertainty of the size distribution using a Monte-Carlo uncertainty estimation algorithm.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2022; v1 submitted 14 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Seeds of imperfection rule the mesocrystalline disorder in natural anhydrite single crystals
Authors:
Tomasz M. Stawski,
Glen J. Smales,
Ernesto Scoppola,
Diwaker Jha,
Luiz F. G. Morales,
Alicia Moya,
Richard Wirth,
Brian R. Pauw,
Franziska Emmerling,
Alexander E. S. Van Driessche
Abstract:
In recent years, we have come to appreciate the astounding intricacy of the formation process of minerals from ions in aqueous solutions. In this context, a number of studies have revealed that nucleation in the calcium sulfate system is non-classical, involving the aggregation and reorganization of nanosized prenucleation particles. In a recent work we have shown that this particle-mediated nucle…
▽ More
In recent years, we have come to appreciate the astounding intricacy of the formation process of minerals from ions in aqueous solutions. In this context, a number of studies have revealed that nucleation in the calcium sulfate system is non-classical, involving the aggregation and reorganization of nanosized prenucleation particles. In a recent work we have shown that this particle-mediated nucleation pathway is actually imprinted in the resultant single micron-sized CaSO4 crystals. This property of CaSO4 minerals provides us with an unique opportunity to search for evidence of non-classical nucleation pathways in geological environments. In particular, we focused on the quintessential single crystals of anhydrite extracted from the Naica mine in Mexico. We elucidated the growth history from this mineral sample by mapping growth defects at different length scales. Based on these data we argue that the nano-scale misalignment of the structural sub-units observed in the initial calcium sulfate crystal seed propagate through different length-scales both in morphological, as well as strictly crystallographic aspects, eventually causing the formation of large mesostructured single crystals of anhydrite. Hence, the nanoparticle mediated nucleation mechanism introduces a 'seed of imperfection', which leads to a macroscopic single crystal, in which its fragments do not fit together at different length-scales in a self-similar manner. Consequently, anisotropic voids of various sizes are formed with very well-defined walls/edges. But, at the same time the material retains its essential single crystal nature. These findings shed new light on the longstanding concept of crystal structure.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2021; v1 submitted 22 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
An Exercise in Open Data: Triple Axis Data on Si single crystal
Authors:
Pavlo Baloh,
Lukas Bauer,
Anežka Bendová,
Petr Čermák,
Korbinian Fellner,
Madhu Ghanathe,
Octavio Emmanuel Hernández Alvarez,
Štefan Hricov,
Johanna K. Jochum,
Liliia Kotvytska,
Sonu Kumar,
Ankit Labh,
Petr Machovec,
Brian R. Pauw,
Klaudie Ramszová,
Erik Walz,
Peter Wild
Abstract:
Efforts are rising in opening up science by making data more transparent and more easily available, including the data reduction and evaluation procedures and code. A strong foundation for this is the F.A.I.R. principle, building on Findability, Accessibility, Interoperability, and Reuse of digital assets, complemented by the letter T for trustworthyness of the data. Here, we have used data, which…
▽ More
Efforts are rising in opening up science by making data more transparent and more easily available, including the data reduction and evaluation procedures and code. A strong foundation for this is the F.A.I.R. principle, building on Findability, Accessibility, Interoperability, and Reuse of digital assets, complemented by the letter T for trustworthyness of the data. Here, we have used data, which was made available by the Institute Laue-Langevin and can be identified using a DOI, to follow the F.A.I.R.+T. principle in extracting, evaluating and publishing triple axis data, recorded at IN3.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2022; v1 submitted 22 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Extending SAXS instrument ranges through addition of a portable, inexpensive USAXS module
Authors:
Brian R. Pauw,
Andrew J. Smith,
Tim Snow,
Olga Shebanova,
John P. Sutter,
Jan Ilavsky,
Daniel Hermida-Merino,
Glen J. Smales,
Nicholas J. Terrill,
Andreas F. Thünemann,
Wim Bras
Abstract:
Ultra-SAXS can enhance the capabilities of existing SAXS/WAXS beamlines and laboratory instruments. A compact Ultra-SAXS module has been developed, which extends the measurable $q$-range with $0.0015 \leq q\mathrm{(nm^{-1})} \leq 0.2$, allowing structural dimensions between $30 \leq D$(nm)$ \leq 4000$ to be probed in addition to the range covered by a high-end SAXS/WAXS instrument. By shifting the…
▽ More
Ultra-SAXS can enhance the capabilities of existing SAXS/WAXS beamlines and laboratory instruments. A compact Ultra-SAXS module has been developed, which extends the measurable $q$-range with $0.0015 \leq q\mathrm{(nm^{-1})} \leq 0.2$, allowing structural dimensions between $30 \leq D$(nm)$ \leq 4000$ to be probed in addition to the range covered by a high-end SAXS/WAXS instrument. By shifting the module components in and out on their respective motor stages, SAXS/WAXS measurements can be easily and rapidly interleaved with USAXS measurements.
In this paper, the design considerations, realization and synchrotron findings are presented. Measurements of silica spheres, an alumina membrane, and a porous carbon catalyst are provided as application examples.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
The modular SAXS data correction sequence for solids and dispersions
Authors:
Brian R. Pauw,
Andrew J. Smith,
Tim Snow,
Nick J. Terrill,
Andreas F. Thünemann
Abstract:
Data correction is probably the least favourite activity amongst users experimenting with small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS): if it is not done sufficiently well, this may become evident during the data analysis stage, necessitating the repetition of the data corrections from scratch. A recommended, comprehensive sequence of elementary data correction steps is presented here to alleviate the diff…
▽ More
Data correction is probably the least favourite activity amongst users experimenting with small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS): if it is not done sufficiently well, this may become evident during the data analysis stage, necessitating the repetition of the data corrections from scratch. A recommended, comprehensive sequence of elementary data correction steps is presented here to alleviate the difficulties associated with data correction. When applied in the proposed order, the resulting data will provide a high degree of accuracy for both solid samples and dispersions. The solution here can be applied without modification to any pinhole-collimated instruments with photon-counting, direct detection area detectors.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Nanoparticle Size Distribution Quantification: Results of a SAXS Inter-Laboratory Comparison
Authors:
Brian R. Pauw,
Claudia Kästner,
Andreas F. Thünemann
Abstract:
We present the first world-wide inter-laboratory comparison of small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) for nanoparticle sizing. The measurands in this comparison are the mean particle radius, the width of the size distribution and the particle concentration. The investigated sample consists of dispersed silver nanoparticles, surrounded by a stabilizing polymeric shell of poly(acrylic acid). The silver…
▽ More
We present the first world-wide inter-laboratory comparison of small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) for nanoparticle sizing. The measurands in this comparison are the mean particle radius, the width of the size distribution and the particle concentration. The investigated sample consists of dispersed silver nanoparticles, surrounded by a stabilizing polymeric shell of poly(acrylic acid). The silver cores dominate the X-ray scattering pattern, leading to the determination of their radii size distribution using: i) Glatter's Indirect Fourier Transformation method, ii) classical model fitting using SASfit and iii) a Monte Carlo fitting approach using McSAS. The application of these three methods to the collected datasets produces consistent mean number- and volume-weighted core radii of R$_n$ = 2.76 nm and R$_v$ = 3.20 nm, respectively. The corresponding widths of the log-normal radii distribution of the particles were $σ_n$ = 0.65 nm and $σ_v$ = 0.71 nm. The particle concentration determined using this method was 3.00 $\pm$ 0.38 g/L (4.20 $\pm$ 0.73 $\times$ 10$^{-6}$ mol/L). We show that the results are slightly biased by the choice of data evaluation procedure, but that no substantial differences were found between the results from data measured on a very wide range of instruments: the participating laboratories at synchrotron SAXS beamlines, commercial and home-made instruments were all able to provide data of high quality. Our results demonstrate that SAXS is a qualified method for revealing particle size distributions in the sub-20 nm region (at least), out of reach for most other analytical methods.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
McSAS: A package for extracting quantitative form-free distributions
Authors:
Ingo Breßler,
Brian R. Pauw,
Andreas Thünemann
Abstract:
A reliable and user-friendly characterisation of nano-objects in a target material is presented here in the form of a software data analysis package for interpreting small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) patterns. When provided with data on absolute scale with reasonable uncertainty estimates, the software outputs (size) distributions in absolute volume fractions complete with uncertainty estimates…
▽ More
A reliable and user-friendly characterisation of nano-objects in a target material is presented here in the form of a software data analysis package for interpreting small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) patterns. When provided with data on absolute scale with reasonable uncertainty estimates, the software outputs (size) distributions in absolute volume fractions complete with uncertainty estimates and minimum evidence limits, and outputs all distribution modes of a user definable range of one or more model parameters. A multitude of models are included, including prolate and oblate nanoparticles, core-shell objects, polymer models (Gaussian chain and Kholodenko worm) and a model for densely packed spheres (using the LMA-PY approximations). The McSAS software can furthermore be integrated as part of an automated reduction and analysis procedure in laboratory instruments or at synchrotron beamlines.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Characterisation of precipitates formed in high-pressure torsion treated Mg-3.4at.%Zn alloy
Authors:
Brian R. Pauw,
Julian M. Rosalie,
Fanqiang Meng,
Hiroaki Mamiya,
Hideaki Kitazawa,
Koichi Tsuchiya
Abstract:
Microstructural analysis of a Mg-Zn alloy deformed at room temperature by high-pressure torsion (HPT) indicates that fine-scale precipitation occurs even without post-deformation heat treatment. Small-angle X-ray scattering detects precipitates with radii between 2.5-20 nm after one rotation, with little increase in particle size or volume fraction after 20 rotations. High resolution electron micr…
▽ More
Microstructural analysis of a Mg-Zn alloy deformed at room temperature by high-pressure torsion (HPT) indicates that fine-scale precipitation occurs even without post-deformation heat treatment. Small-angle X-ray scattering detects precipitates with radii between 2.5-20 nm after one rotation, with little increase in particle size or volume fraction after 20 rotations. High resolution electron micrographs identify grain boundary precipitates of monoclinic Mg$_4$Zn$_7$ phase after three rotations and MgZn$_2$ after 20 rotations.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2014; v1 submitted 23 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Everything SAXS: Small-angle scattering pattern collection and correction
Authors:
Brian Richard Pauw
Abstract:
For obtaining reliable nanostructural details of large amounts of sample --- and if it is applicable --- Small-Angle Scattering (SAS) is a prime technique to use. It promises to obtain bulk-scale, statistically sound information on the morphological details of the nanostructure, and has thus led to many a researcher investing their time in it over the last eight decades of development. Due to pres…
▽ More
For obtaining reliable nanostructural details of large amounts of sample --- and if it is applicable --- Small-Angle Scattering (SAS) is a prime technique to use. It promises to obtain bulk-scale, statistically sound information on the morphological details of the nanostructure, and has thus led to many a researcher investing their time in it over the last eight decades of development. Due to pressure both from scientists requesting more details on increasingly complex nanostructures, as well as the ever improving instrumentation leaving less margin for ambiguity, small-angle scattering methodologies have been evolving at a high pace over the last few decades.
As the quality of any results can only be as good as the data that goes into these methodologies, the improvements in data collection and all imaginable data correction steps are reviewed here. This work is intended to provide a comprehensive overview of all data corrections, to aid the small-angle scatterer to decide which are relevant for their measurement and how these corrections are performed. Clear mathematical descriptions of the corrections are provided where feasible. Furthermore, as no quality data exists without a decent estimate of its precision, the error estimation and propagation through all these steps is provided alongside the corrections. With these data corrections, the collected small-angle scattering pattern can be made of the highest standard allowing for authoritative nanostructural characterisation through its analysis. A brief background of small-angle scattering, the instrumentation developments over the years, and pitfalls that may be encountered upon data interpretations are provided as well.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
2D anisotropic scattering pattern fitting using a novel Monte Carlo method: Initial results
Authors:
Brian R. Pauw,
Masato Ohnuma,
Kenji Sakurai,
Enno A. Klop
Abstract:
Recently, a Monte Carlo method has been presented which allows for the form-free retrieval of size distributions from isotropic scattering patterns, complete with uncertainty estimates linked to the data quality. Here, we present an adaptation to this method allowing for the fitting of anisotropic 2D scattering patterns. The model consists of a finite number of non-interacting ellipsoids of revolu…
▽ More
Recently, a Monte Carlo method has been presented which allows for the form-free retrieval of size distributions from isotropic scattering patterns, complete with uncertainty estimates linked to the data quality. Here, we present an adaptation to this method allowing for the fitting of anisotropic 2D scattering patterns. The model consists of a finite number of non-interacting ellipsoids of revolution (but would work equally well for cylinders), polydisperse in both dimensions, and takes into account disorientation in the plane parallel to the detector plane. The method application results in three form-free distributions, two for the ellipsoid dimensions, and one for the orientation distribution. It is furthermore shown that a morphological restriction is needed to obtain a unique solution.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
Form-free size distributions from complementary stereological TEM/SAXS on precipitates in a Mg-Zn alloy
Authors:
Julian M. Rosalie,
Brian R. Pauw
Abstract:
This work describes a multidisciplinary research methodology for quantifying the size distribution of nanoscale precipitates in polycrystalline alloys. Complementary transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and small-angle x-ray scattering (SAXS) are employed in a study of precipitate growth in an isothermally aged Mg-Zn alloy. TEM is used to identify the precipitate phases as rod-shaped β' particle…
▽ More
This work describes a multidisciplinary research methodology for quantifying the size distribution of nanoscale precipitates in polycrystalline alloys. Complementary transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and small-angle x-ray scattering (SAXS) are employed in a study of precipitate growth in an isothermally aged Mg-Zn alloy. TEM is used to identify the precipitate phases as rod-shaped β' particles and to determine their radii and aspect ratio. Subsequently, SAXS data obtained from bulk quantities of the alloy is interpreted via a novel Monte-Carlo method to obtain accurate, form-free size distributions. Good agreement was obtained between particle radii distributions measured by both methods, exemplifying the applicability of this complementary methodology to study precipitation in textured alloys containing particles anisotropic with well-defined orientation-relationships to the matrix.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2013; v1 submitted 19 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
The optimal division between sample and background measurement time for photon counting experiments
Authors:
Brian Richard Pauw,
Samuel Tardif
Abstract:
Usually, equal time is given to measuring the background and the sample, or even a longer background measurement is taken as it has so few counts. While this seems the right thing to do, the relative error after background subtraction improves when more time is spent counting the measurement with the highest amount of scattering. As the available measurement time is always limited, a good division…
▽ More
Usually, equal time is given to measuring the background and the sample, or even a longer background measurement is taken as it has so few counts. While this seems the right thing to do, the relative error after background subtraction improves when more time is spent counting the measurement with the highest amount of scattering. As the available measurement time is always limited, a good division must be found between measuring the background and sample, so that the uncertainty of the background-subtracted intensity is as low as possible.
Herein outlined is the method to determine how best to divide measurement time between a sample and the background, in order to minimize the relative uncertainty. Also given is the relative reduction in uncertainty to be gained from the considered division. It is particularly useful in the case of scanning diffractometers, including the likes of Bonse-Hart cameras, where the measurement time division for each point can be optimized depending on the signal-to-noise ratio.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Improvements and considerations for size distribution retrieval from small-angle scattering data by Monte-Carlo methods
Authors:
Brian Richard Pauw,
Jan-Skov Pedersen,
Samuel Tardif,
Masaki Takata,
Bo Brummersted Iversen
Abstract:
Monte-Carlo (MC) methods, based on random updates and the trial-and-error principle, are well suited to retrieve particle size distributions from small-angle scattering patterns of dilute solutions of scatterers. The size sensitivity of size determination methods in relation to the range of scattering vectors covered by the data is discussed. Improvements are presented to existing MC methods in wh…
▽ More
Monte-Carlo (MC) methods, based on random updates and the trial-and-error principle, are well suited to retrieve particle size distributions from small-angle scattering patterns of dilute solutions of scatterers. The size sensitivity of size determination methods in relation to the range of scattering vectors covered by the data is discussed. Improvements are presented to existing MC methods in which the particle shape is assumed to be known. A discussion of the problems with the ambiguous convergence criteria of the MC methods are given and a convergence criterion is proposed, which also allows the determination of uncertainties on the determined size distributions.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
