-
Spin evolution of Venus-like planets subjected to gravitational and thermal tides
Authors:
Alexandre Revol,
Émeline Bolmont,
Gabriel Tobie,
Caroline Dumoulin,
Yann Musseau,
Stéphane Mathis,
Antoine Strugarek,
Allan-Sacha Brun
Abstract:
The arrival of powerful instruments will provide valuable data for the characterization of rocky exoplanets. It is then crucial to accurately model the dynamical state of exoplanets. Rocky planets with sufficiently large orbits should have non-zero eccentricities and/or obliquities. Realistic models of tides for rocky planets can allow for higher spin states than the synchronization state in the p…
▽ More
The arrival of powerful instruments will provide valuable data for the characterization of rocky exoplanets. It is then crucial to accurately model the dynamical state of exoplanets. Rocky planets with sufficiently large orbits should have non-zero eccentricities and/or obliquities. Realistic models of tides for rocky planets can allow for higher spin states than the synchronization state in the presence of eccentricities or obliquities. This work explores the secular evolution of a star-planet system under tidal interactions, both gravitational and thermal, induced respectively by the quadrupolar component of the gravitational potential and the irradiation of the planet's surface. We use the formalism of Kaula associated with an Andrade rheology to model a relevant response of a rocky planet to gravitational tides and a prescription of thermal tides fitted for Venus to model the response of the atmosphere to the thermal tides. We implemented the general secular evolution equations of tidal interactions in the secular code ESPEM (French acronym for Evolution of Planetary System and Magnetism). We show the possible spin-orbit evolution and resonances for eccentric orbits and explore the possible spin orbit resonances raised by the obliquity of the planet. Our simulations have shown that the secular evolution of the spin and obliquity can lead to the retrograde spin of the Venus-like planet if the system starts from a high spin obliquity, in agreement to previous studies. Taking into account the luminosity evolution of the Sun changes the picture. We find that the planet never reaches the equilibrium: the timescale of rotation evolution is longer than the luminosity variation timescale, which suggests that Venus may never reach a spin equilibrium state but may still evolve.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2023; v1 submitted 28 February, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Gravitational atmospheric tides as a probe of Titan's interior: Application to Dragonfly
Authors:
Benjamin Charnay,
Gabriel Tobie,
Sébastien Lebonnois,
Ralph D. Lorenz
Abstract:
Context: Saturn's massive gravity is expected to causes a tide in Titan's atmosphere, producing a surface pressure variation through the orbit of Titan and tidal winds in the troposphere. The future Dragonfly mission could analyse this exotic meteorological phenomenon.
Aims: We analyse the effect of Saturn's tides on Titan's atmosphere and interior to determine how pressure measurements by Drago…
▽ More
Context: Saturn's massive gravity is expected to causes a tide in Titan's atmosphere, producing a surface pressure variation through the orbit of Titan and tidal winds in the troposphere. The future Dragonfly mission could analyse this exotic meteorological phenomenon.
Aims: We analyse the effect of Saturn's tides on Titan's atmosphere and interior to determine how pressure measurements by Dragonfly could constrain Titan's interior.
Methods: We model atmospheric tides with analytical calculations and with a 3D Global Climate Model (the IPSL-Titan GCM), including the tidal response of the interior.
Results: We predict that the Love numbers of Titan's interior should verify 1 + Re(k2 - h2) ~ 0.02-0.1 and Im(k2 - h2) < 0.04. The deformation of Titan's interior should therefore strongly weaken gravitational atmospheric tides, yielding a residual surface pressure amplitude of only ~ 5 Pa, with a phase shift of 5-20 hours. Tidal winds are very weak, of the order of 3*10^-4 m/s in the lower troposphere. Finally, constraints from Dragonfly data may permit the real and the imaginary parts of k2 - h2 to be estimated with a precision of ~0.01-0.03.
Conclusions: Measurements of pressure variations by Dragonfly over the whole mission could give valuable constraints on the thickness of Titan's ice shell, and via geophysical models, its heat flux and the density of Titan's internal ocean.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Science goals and new mission concepts for future exploration of Titan's atmosphere geology and habitability: Titan POlar Scout/orbitEr and In situ lake lander and DrONe explorer (POSEIDON)
Authors:
Sébastien Rodriguez,
Sandrine Vinatier,
Daniel Cordier,
Gabriel Tobie,
Richard K. Achterberg,
Carrie M. Anderson,
Sarah V. Badman,
Jason W. Barnes,
Erika L. Barth,
Bruno Bézard,
Nathalie Carrasco,
Benjamin Charnay,
Roger N. Clark,
Patrice Coll,
Thomas Cornet,
Athena Coustenis,
Isabelle Couturier-Tamburelli,
Michel Dobrijevic,
F. Michael Flasar,
Remco de Kok,
Caroline Freissinet,
Marina Galand,
Thomas Gautier,
Wolf D. Geppert,
Caitlin A. Griffith
, et al. (39 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
In response to ESA Voyage 2050 announcement of opportunity, we propose an ambitious L-class mission to explore one of the most exciting bodies in the Solar System, Saturn largest moon Titan. Titan, a "world with two oceans", is an organic-rich body with interior-surface-atmosphere interactions that are comparable in complexity to the Earth. Titan is also one of the few places in the Solar System w…
▽ More
In response to ESA Voyage 2050 announcement of opportunity, we propose an ambitious L-class mission to explore one of the most exciting bodies in the Solar System, Saturn largest moon Titan. Titan, a "world with two oceans", is an organic-rich body with interior-surface-atmosphere interactions that are comparable in complexity to the Earth. Titan is also one of the few places in the Solar System with habitability potential. Titan remarkable nature was only partly revealed by the Cassini-Huygens mission and still holds mysteries requiring a complete exploration using a variety of vehicles and instruments. The proposed mission concept POSEIDON (Titan POlar Scout/orbitEr and In situ lake lander DrONe explorer) would perform joint orbital and in situ investigations of Titan. It is designed to build on and exceed the scope and scientific/technological accomplishments of Cassini-Huygens, exploring Titan in ways that were not previously possible, in particular through full close-up and in situ coverage over long periods of time. In the proposed mission architecture, POSEIDON consists of two major elements: a spacecraft with a large set of instruments that would orbit Titan, preferably in a low-eccentricity polar orbit, and a suite of in situ investigation components, i.e. a lake lander, a "heavy" drone (possibly amphibious) and/or a fleet of mini-drones, dedicated to the exploration of the polar regions. The ideal arrival time at Titan would be slightly before the next northern Spring equinox (2039), as equinoxes are the most active periods to monitor still largely unknown atmospheric and surface seasonal changes. The exploration of Titan northern latitudes with an orbiter and in situ element(s) would be highly complementary with the upcoming NASA New Frontiers Dragonfly mission that will provide in situ exploration of Titan equatorial regions in the mid-2030s.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Solid tidal friction in multi-layer planets: Application to Earth, Venus, a Super Earth and the TRAPPIST-1 planets. Can a multi-layer planet be approximated as a homogeneous planet?
Authors:
Emeline Bolmont,
Sylvain N. Breton,
Gabriel Tobie,
Caroline Dumoulin,
Stéphane Mathis,
Olivier Grasset
Abstract:
With the discovery of TRAPPIST-1 and its seven planets within 0.06 au, the correct treatment of tidal interactions is becoming necessary. The eccentricity, rotation, and obliquity of the planets of TRAPPIST-1 are indeed the result of tidal evolution over the lifetime of the system. Tidal interactions can also lead to tidal heating in the interior of the planets, which can then be responsible for v…
▽ More
With the discovery of TRAPPIST-1 and its seven planets within 0.06 au, the correct treatment of tidal interactions is becoming necessary. The eccentricity, rotation, and obliquity of the planets of TRAPPIST-1 are indeed the result of tidal evolution over the lifetime of the system. Tidal interactions can also lead to tidal heating in the interior of the planets, which can then be responsible for volcanism and/or surface deformation. In the majority of studies to estimate the rotation of close-in planets or their tidal heating, the planets are considered as homogeneous bodies and their rheology is often taken to be a Maxwell rheology.
We investigate here the impact of considering a multi-layer structure and an Andrade rheology on the way planets dissipate tidal energy as a function of the excitation frequency. We use an internal structure model, which provides the radial profile of structural and rheological quantities to compute the tidal response of multi-layer bodies. We then compare the outcome to the dissipation of a homogeneous planet.
We find that for purely rocky bodies, it is possible to approximate the response of a multi-layer planet by that of a homogeneous planet. However, using average profiles of shear modulus and viscosity to compute the homogeneous planet response leads to an overestimation of the averaged dissipation. We provide fitted values of shear modulus and viscosity to be able to reproduce the response of various types of rocky planets. However, we find that if the planet has an icy layer, its tidal response can no longer be approximated by a homogeneous body because of the very different properties of the icy layers, which lead to a second dissipation peak at higher frequencies. We also compute the tidal heating profiles for the outer TRAPPIST-1 planets (e to h).
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
The Science Case for a Titan Flagship-class Orbiter with Probes
Authors:
Conor A. Nixon,
James Abshire,
Andrew Ashton,
Jason W. Barnes,
Nathalie Carrasco,
Mathieu Choukroun,
Athena Coustenis,
Louis-Alexandre Couston,
Niklas Edberg,
Alexander Gagnon,
Jason D. Hofgartner,
Luciano Iess,
Stéphane Le Mouélic,
Rosaly Lopes,
Juan Lora,
Ralph D. Lorenz,
Adrienn Luspay-Kuti,
Michael Malaska,
Kathleen Mandt,
Marco Mastrogiuseppe,
Erwan Mazarico,
Marc Neveu,
Taylor Perron,
Jani Radebaugh,
Sébastien Rodriguez
, et al. (14 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We outline a flagship-class mission concept focused on studying Titan as a global system, with particular emphasis on the polar regions. Investigating Titan from the unique standpoint of a polar orbit would enable comprehensive global maps to uncover the physics and chemistry of the atmosphere, and the topography and geophysical environment of the surface and subsurface. The mission includes two k…
▽ More
We outline a flagship-class mission concept focused on studying Titan as a global system, with particular emphasis on the polar regions. Investigating Titan from the unique standpoint of a polar orbit would enable comprehensive global maps to uncover the physics and chemistry of the atmosphere, and the topography and geophysical environment of the surface and subsurface. The mission includes two key elements: (1) an orbiter spacecraft, which also acts as a data relay, and (2) one or more small probes to directly investigate Titan's seas and make the first direct measurements of their liquid composition and physical environment. The orbiter would carry a sophisticated remote sensing payload, including a novel topographic lidar, a long-wavelength surface-penetrating radar, a sub-millimeter sounder for winds and for mesospheric/thermospheric composition, and a camera and near-infrared spectrometer. An instrument suite to analyze particles and fields would include a mass spectrometer to focus on the interactions between Titan's escaping upper atmosphere and the solar wind and Saturnian magnetosphere. The orbiter would enter a stable polar orbit around 1500 to 1800 km, from which vantage point it would make global maps of the atmosphere and surface. One or more probes, released from the orbiter, would investigate Titan's seas in situ, including possible differences in composition between higher and lower latitude seas, as well as the atmosphere during the parachute descent. The number of probes, as well as the instrument complement on the orbiter and probe, remain to be finalized during a mission study that we recommend to NASA as part of the NRC Decadal Survey for Planetary Science now underway, with the goal of an overall mission cost in the "small flagship" category of ~$2 bn. International partnerships, similar to Cassini-Huygens, may also be included for consideration.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
A Recipe for Geophysical Exploration of Enceladus
Authors:
Anton I. Ermakov,
Ryan S. Park,
Javier Roa,
Julie C. Castillo-Rogez,
James T. Keane,
Francis Nimmo,
Edwin S. Kite,
Christophe Sotin,
T. Joseph W. Lazio,
Gregor Steinbrügge,
Samuel M. Howell,
Bruce G. Bills,
Douglas J. Hemingway,
Vishnu Viswanathan,
Gabriel Tobie,
Valery Lainey
Abstract:
Orbital geophysical investigations of Enceladus are critical to understanding its energy balance. We identified key science questions for the geophysical exploration of Enceladus, answering which would support future assessment of Enceladus' astrobiological potential. Using a Bayesian framework, we explored how science requirements map to measurement requirements. We performed mission simulations…
▽ More
Orbital geophysical investigations of Enceladus are critical to understanding its energy balance. We identified key science questions for the geophysical exploration of Enceladus, answering which would support future assessment of Enceladus' astrobiological potential. Using a Bayesian framework, we explored how science requirements map to measurement requirements. We performed mission simulations to study the sensitivity of a single spacecraft and dual spacecraft configurations to static gravity and tidal Love numbers of Enceladus. We find that mapping Enceladus' gravity field, improving the accuracy of the physical libration amplitude, and measuring Enceladus' tidal response would provide critical constraints on the internal structure, and establish a framework for assessing Enceladus' long-term habitability. This kind of investigation could be carried out as part of a life search mission at little additional resource requirements.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2021; v1 submitted 6 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Photometrically-corrected global infrared mosaics of Enceladus: New implications for its spectral diversity and geological activity
Authors:
Rozenn Robinel,
Stéphane Le Mouélic,
Gabriel Tobie,
Marion Massé,
Benoît Seignovert,
Christophe Sotin,
Sébastien Rodriguez
Abstract:
Between 2004 and 2017, spectral observations have been gathered by the Visual and Infrared Mapping Spectrometer (VIMS) on-board Cassini (Brown et al., 2004) during 23 Enceladus close encounters, in addition to more distant surveys. The objective of the present study is to produce a global hyperspectral mosaic of the complete VIMS data set of Enceladus in order to highlight spectral variations amon…
▽ More
Between 2004 and 2017, spectral observations have been gathered by the Visual and Infrared Mapping Spectrometer (VIMS) on-board Cassini (Brown et al., 2004) during 23 Enceladus close encounters, in addition to more distant surveys. The objective of the present study is to produce a global hyperspectral mosaic of the complete VIMS data set of Enceladus in order to highlight spectral variations among the different geological units. This requires the selection of the best observations in terms of spatial resolution and illumination conditions. We have carried out a detailed investigation of the photometric behavior at several key wavelengths (1.35, 1.5, 1.65, 1.8, 2.0, 2.25, 2.55 and 3.6 $μ$m), characteristics of the infrared spectra of water ice. We propose a new photometric function, based on the model of Shkuratov et al. (2011). When combined, corrected mosaics at different wavelengths reveal heterogeneous areas, in particular in the terrains surrounding the Tiger Stripes on the South Pole and in the northern hemisphere around 30°N, 90°W. Those areas appear mainly correlated to tectonized units, indicating an endogenous origin, potentially driven by seafloor hotspots.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2020; v1 submitted 29 May, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Science goals and mission concepts for a future orbital and in situ exploration of Titan
Authors:
Sébastien Rodriguez,
Sandrine Vinatier,
Daniel Cordier,
Nathalie Carrasco,
Benjamin Charnay,
Thomas Cornet,
Athena Coustenis,
Remco de Kok,
Caroline Freissinet,
Marina Galand,
Wolf D. Geppert,
Ralf Jauman,
Klara Kalousova,
Tommi T. Koskinen,
Sébastien Lebonnois,
Alice Le Gall,
Stéphane Le Mouélic,
Antoine Lucas,
Kathleen Mandt,
Marco Mastrogiuseppe,
Conor A. Nixon,
Jani Radebaugh,
Pascal Rannou,
Jason M. Soderblom,
Anezina Solomonidou
, et al. (5 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
In this white paper, we present a cross-section of important scientific questions that remain partially or completely unanswered, ranging from Titan exosphere to the deep interior, and we detail which instrumentation and mission scenarios should be used to answer them. Our intention is to formulate the science goals for the next generation of planetary missions to Titan in order to prepare the fut…
▽ More
In this white paper, we present a cross-section of important scientific questions that remain partially or completely unanswered, ranging from Titan exosphere to the deep interior, and we detail which instrumentation and mission scenarios should be used to answer them. Our intention is to formulate the science goals for the next generation of planetary missions to Titan in order to prepare the future exploration of the moon. The ESA L-class mission concept that we propose is composed of a Titan orbiter and at least an in situ element (lake lander and/or drone(s)).
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Ice Giant Systems: The Scientific Potential of Orbital Missions to Uranus and Neptune
Authors:
Leigh N. Fletcher,
Ravit Helled,
Elias Roussos,
Geraint Jones,
Sébastien Charnoz,
Nicolas André,
David Andrews,
Michele Bannister,
Emma Bunce,
Thibault Cavalié,
Francesca Ferri,
Jonathan Fortney,
Davide Grassi,
Léa Griton,
Paul Hartogh,
Ricardo Hueso,
Yohai Kaspi,
Laurent Lamy,
Adam Masters,
Henrik Melin,
Julianne Moses,
Olivier Mousis,
Nadine Nettleman,
Christina Plainaki,
Jürgen Schmidt
, et al. (5 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Uranus and Neptune, and their diverse satellite and ring systems, represent the least explored environments of our Solar System, and yet may provide the archetype for the most common outcome of planetary formation throughout our galaxy. Ice Giants will be the last remaining class of Solar System planet to have a dedicated orbital explorer, and international efforts are under way to realise such an…
▽ More
Uranus and Neptune, and their diverse satellite and ring systems, represent the least explored environments of our Solar System, and yet may provide the archetype for the most common outcome of planetary formation throughout our galaxy. Ice Giants will be the last remaining class of Solar System planet to have a dedicated orbital explorer, and international efforts are under way to realise such an ambitious mission in the coming decades. In 2019, the European Space Agency released a call for scientific themes for its strategic science planning process for the 2030s and 2040s, known as Voyage 2050. We used this opportunity to review our present-day knowledge of the Uranus and Neptune systems, producing a revised and updated set of scientific questions and motivations for their exploration. This review article describes how such a mission could explore their origins, ice-rich interiors, dynamic atmospheres, unique magnetospheres, and myriad icy satellites, to address questions at the heart of modern planetary science. These two worlds are superb examples of how planets with shared origins can exhibit remarkably different evolutionary paths: Neptune as the archetype for Ice Giants, whereas Uranus may be atypical. Exploring Uranus' natural satellites and Neptune's captured moon Triton could reveal how Ocean Worlds form and remain active, redefining the extent of the habitable zone in our Solar System. For these reasons and more, we advocate that an Ice Giant System explorer should become a strategic cornerstone mission within ESA's Voyage 2050 programme, in partnership with international collaborators, and targeting launch opportunities in the early 2030s.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2020; v1 submitted 4 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Tidal heating in multilayer planets: Application to the TRAPPIST-1 system
Authors:
Sylvain Breton,
Emeline Bolmont,
Gabriel Tobie,
Stéphane Mathis
Abstract:
TRAPPIST-1 (Gillon et al. 2017) is an extremely compact planetary system: seven earth-sized planets orbit at distances lower than 0.07 AU around one of the smallest M-dwarf known in the close neighborhood of the Sun (with a mass of less than 0.09 $M_\odot$). With 3 planets within the classical habitable zone, this system represents an interesting observational target for future instruments such as…
▽ More
TRAPPIST-1 (Gillon et al. 2017) is an extremely compact planetary system: seven earth-sized planets orbit at distances lower than 0.07 AU around one of the smallest M-dwarf known in the close neighborhood of the Sun (with a mass of less than 0.09 $M_\odot$). With 3 planets within the classical habitable zone, this system represents an interesting observational target for future instruments such as the JWST (e.g. Barstow & Irwin 2016). As the planets are close-in, tidal interactions play a crucial role in the evolution of the system by controlling both orbital configurations and rotational states of the planets. For the closest planets, the associated tidal dissipation could have an influence on their internal evolution and potentially on their climate and habitability Turbet et al. (2018). Following (Tobie et al. 2005), we build multilayer models of the internal structure of the TRAPPIST-1 planets accounting for the mass and radius of Grimm et al. (2018), then we compute the tidal response and estimate the tidal heat flux of each planet as well as the profile of tidal heating with depth. Finally, we compare our results to the homogeneous model of Efroimsky (2012) and assess the impact heating rate on the thermal state of each layer of the planet.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Water and the interior structure of terrestrial planets and icy bodies
Authors:
Julien Monteux,
Gregor J. Golabek,
David C. Rubie,
Gabriel Tobie,
Edward D. Young
Abstract:
Water content and the internal evolution of terrestrial planets and icy bodies are closely linked. The distribution of water in planetary systems is controlled by the temperature structure in the protoplanetary disk and dynamics and migration of planetesimals and planetary embryos. This results in the formation of planetesimals and planetary embryos with a great variety of compositions, water cont…
▽ More
Water content and the internal evolution of terrestrial planets and icy bodies are closely linked. The distribution of water in planetary systems is controlled by the temperature structure in the protoplanetary disk and dynamics and migration of planetesimals and planetary embryos. This results in the formation of planetesimals and planetary embryos with a great variety of compositions, water contents and degrees of oxidation. The internal evolution and especially the formation time of planetesimals relative to the timescale of radiogenic heating by short-lived 26Al decay may govern the amount of hydrous silicates and leftover rock-ice mixtures available in the late stages of their evolution. In turn, water content may affect the early internal evolution of the planetesimals and in particular metal-silicate separation processes. Moreover, water content may contribute to an increase of oxygen fugacity and thus affect the concentrations of siderophile elements within the silicate reservoirs of Solar System objects. Finally, the water content strongly influences the differentiation rate of the icy moons, controls their internal evolution and governs the alteration processes occurring in their deep interiors.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Role of the global water ocean on the evolution of Titan's primitive atmosphere
Authors:
Nadejda Marounina,
Olivier Grasset,
Gabriel Tobie,
Sabrina Carpy
Abstract:
During the accretion of Titan, impact heating may have been sufficient to allow the global melting of water ice and the release of volatile compounds, mainly constituted of CO2, CH4 and NH3. The duration and efficiency of exchange between the primitive massive atmosphere and the global impact-induced water ocean likely play a key role in the chemical evolution of the early Titan's atmosphere. To i…
▽ More
During the accretion of Titan, impact heating may have been sufficient to allow the global melting of water ice and the release of volatile compounds, mainly constituted of CO2, CH4 and NH3. The duration and efficiency of exchange between the primitive massive atmosphere and the global impact-induced water ocean likely play a key role in the chemical evolution of the early Titan's atmosphere. To investigate the atmospheric composition of early Titan for a wide range of global (atmosphere + ocean) composition in volatils, we first developed a gas-liquid equilibrium model of the NH3-CO2-H2O system, where the non-ideal behavior of both gas and liquid phases, and the speciation of volatiles dissolved in the aqueous phase are taken into account. We show that the relative abundance of CO2 and NH3 determine the composition of Titan's atmosphere. For CO2/NH3 < 1, CO2 is massively dissolved in the ocean. On the contrary, for CO2/NH3 > 1, CO2 is the main constituent of Titan's primitive atmosphere while the NH3 atmospheric content is dramatically decreased. We then investigate the conditions for the formation of CH4-rich clathrates hydrates at Titan's surface that could be the main reservoir of methane for the present-day atmosphere. In absence of reliable experimental data in the CH4-CO2-NH3-H2O system, the dissolution of methane in water is included using a simplified Henry's law approach. We find that if the concentration of CH4 in Titan's building block was higher than ~0.1 mol.kg-1 and CO2/NH3 < 3, a large fraction of methane may be stored in the primordial crust, which would form at temperature below ~10°C.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Modelling climate diversity, tidal dynamics and the fate of volatiles on TRAPPIST-1 planets
Authors:
Martin Turbet,
Emeline Bolmont,
Jeremy Leconte,
Francois Forget,
Franck Selsis,
Gabriel Tobie,
Anthony Caldas,
Joseph Naar,
Michael Gillon
Abstract:
TRAPPIST-1 planets are invaluable for the study of comparative planetary science outside our Solar System and possibly habitability. First, we derive from N-body simulations possible planetary evolution scenarios, and show that each of the planets are likely to be in synchronous rotation. We then use a 3-D Global Climate Model to explore the possible climates of cool planets of the TRAPPIST-1 syst…
▽ More
TRAPPIST-1 planets are invaluable for the study of comparative planetary science outside our Solar System and possibly habitability. First, we derive from N-body simulations possible planetary evolution scenarios, and show that each of the planets are likely to be in synchronous rotation. We then use a 3-D Global Climate Model to explore the possible climates of cool planets of the TRAPPIST-1 system. In particular, we look at the conditions required for cool planets to prevent possible volatile species to be lost by permanent condensation, irreversible burying or photochemical destruction. We also explore the resilience of the same volatiles (when in condensed phase) to a runaway greenhouse process. We find that background atmospheres made of N2, CO or O2 are resistant to atmospheric collapse. However, it should be difficult for TRAPPIST-1 planets to accumulate significant greenhouse gases like CO2, CH4, or NH3. CO2 can easily condense on the nightside, forming glaciers that would flow toward the substellar region. A complete CO2 ice cover is possible on TRAPPIST-1g and h only, although CO2 ice deposits could be gravitationally unstable and get buried beneath the water ice shell in geologically short timescales. Given TRAPPIST-1 planets large EUV irradiation (at least 1000x Titan's flux), CH4 and NH3 should be photodissociated rapidly and thus be hard to accumulate in the atmosphere. Photochemical hazes could then sedimentate and form a surface layer of tholins. Regarding habitability, we confirm that few bars of CO2 would suffice to warm the surface of TRAPPIST-1f and g above the melting point of water. We also show that TRAPPIST-1e is a remarkable candidate for surface habitability. If the planet is today synchronous and abundant in water, then it should always sustain surface liquid water at least in the substellar region, whatever the atmosphere considered.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2017; v1 submitted 21 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
CO2 condensation is a serious limit to the deglaciation of Earth-like planets
Authors:
Martin Turbet,
Francois Forget,
Jeremy Leconte,
Benjamin Charnay,
Gabriel Tobie
Abstract:
It is widely believed that the carbonate-silicate cycle is the main agent to trigger deglaciations by CO$_2$ greenhouse warming on Earth and on Earth-like planets when they get in frozen state. Here we use a 3D Global Climate Model to simulate the ability of frozen planets to escape from glaciation by accumulating enough gaseous CO$_2$. We find that Earth-like planets orbiting a Sun-like star may…
▽ More
It is widely believed that the carbonate-silicate cycle is the main agent to trigger deglaciations by CO$_2$ greenhouse warming on Earth and on Earth-like planets when they get in frozen state. Here we use a 3D Global Climate Model to simulate the ability of frozen planets to escape from glaciation by accumulating enough gaseous CO$_2$. We find that Earth-like planets orbiting a Sun-like star may never be able to escape from glaciation if their orbital distance is greater than $\sim$ 1.27 AU (Flux $<$ 847 W m$^{-2}$ or 62$\%$ of the Solar constant), because CO$_2$ would condense at the poles forming permanent CO$_2$ ice caps. This limits the amount of CO$_2$ in the atmosphere and thus its greenhouse effect. The amount of CO$_2$ that can be trapped in the polar caps depends on the efficiency of CO$_2$ ice to flow laterally as well as its graviational stability relative to subsurface water ice. The flow of CO$_2$ ice from poles to equator is mostly controlled by the bottom temperature, and hence by the internal heat flux. We find that a frozen Earth-like planet located at 1.30 AU of a Sun-like star could store as much as 1.5/4.5/15 bars of dry ice at the poles, for internal heat fluxes of 100/30/10 mW m$^{-2}$. But these amounts are lower limits. For planets with a significant water ice cover, we show that CO$_2$ ice deposits should be gravitationnally unstable. They get buried beneath the water ice cover in geologically short timescales of $\sim$~10$^4$ yrs, mainly controlled by the viscosity of water ice. CO$_2$ would be permanently sequestered underneath the water ice cover, in the form of CO$_2$ liquids, CO$_2$ clathrate hydrates and/or dissolved in subglacial water reservoirs (if any). This would considerably increase the amount of CO$_2$ trapped and further reduce the probability of deglaciation.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2017; v1 submitted 14 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
New constraints on Saturn's interior from Cassini astrometric data
Authors:
Valéry Lainey,
Robert A. Jacobson,
Radwan Tajeddine,
Nicholas J. Cooper,
Carl Murray,
Vincent Robert,
Gabriel Tobie,
Tristan Guillot,
Stéphane Mathis,
Françoise Remus,
Josselin Desmars,
Jean-Eudes Arlot,
Jean-Pierre De Cuyper,
Véronique Dehant,
Dan Pascu,
William Thuillot,
Christophe Le Poncin-Lafitte,
Jean-Paul Zahn
Abstract:
Using astrometric observations spanning more than a century and including a large set of Cassini data, we determine Saturn's tidal parameters through their current effects on the orbits of the eight main and four coorbital moons. We have used the latter to make the first determination of Saturn's Love number, $k_2=0.390 \pm 0.024$, a value larger than the commonly used theoretical value of 0.341…
▽ More
Using astrometric observations spanning more than a century and including a large set of Cassini data, we determine Saturn's tidal parameters through their current effects on the orbits of the eight main and four coorbital moons. We have used the latter to make the first determination of Saturn's Love number, $k_2=0.390 \pm 0.024$, a value larger than the commonly used theoretical value of 0.341 (Gavrilov & Zharkov, 1977), but compatible with more recent models (Helled & Guillot, 2013) for which $k_2$ ranges from 0.355 to 0.382. Depending on the assumed spin for Saturn's interior, the new constraint can lead to a reduction of up to 80% in the number of potential models, offering great opportunities to probe the planet's interior. In addition, significant tidal dissipation within Saturn is confirmed (Lainey et al., 2012) corresponding to a high present-day tidal ratio $k_2/Q=(1.59 \pm 0.74) \times 10^{-4}$ and implying fast orbital expansions of the moons. This high dissipation, with no obvious variations for tidal frequencies corresponding to those of Enceladus and Dione, may be explained by viscous friction in a solid core, implying a core viscosity typically ranging between $10^{14}$ and $10^{16}$ Pa.s (Remus et al., 2012). However, a dissipation increase by one order of magnitude at Rhea's frequency could suggest the existence of an additional, frequency-dependent, dissipation process, possibly from turbulent friction acting on tidal waves in the fluid envelope of Saturn (Ogilvie & Li, 2004). Alternatively, a few of Saturn's moons might themselves experience large tidal dissipation.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2015; v1 submitted 20 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Titan's past and future: 3D modeling of a pure nitrogen atmosphere and geological implications
Authors:
Benjamin Charnay,
François Forget,
Gabriel Tobie,
Christophe Sotin,
Robin Wordsworth
Abstract:
Several clues indicate that Titan's atmosphere has been depleted in methane during some period of its history, possibly as recently as 0.5-1 billion years ago. It could also happen in the future. Under these conditions, the atmosphere becomes only composed of nitrogen with a range of temperature and pressure allowing liquid or solid nitrogen to condense. Here, we explore these exotic climates thro…
▽ More
Several clues indicate that Titan's atmosphere has been depleted in methane during some period of its history, possibly as recently as 0.5-1 billion years ago. It could also happen in the future. Under these conditions, the atmosphere becomes only composed of nitrogen with a range of temperature and pressure allowing liquid or solid nitrogen to condense. Here, we explore these exotic climates throughout Titan's history with a 3D Global Climate Model (GCM) including the nitrogen cycle and the radiative effect of nitrogen clouds. We show that for the last billion years, only small polar nitrogen lakes should have formed. Yet, before 1 Ga, a significant part of the atmosphere could have condensed, forming deep nitrogen polar seas, which could have flowed and flooded the equatorial regions. Alternatively, nitrogen could be frozen on the surface like on Triton, but this would require an initial surface albedo higher than 0.65 at 4 Ga. Such a state could be stable even today if nitrogen ice albedo is higher than this value. According to our model, nitrogen flows and rain may have been efficient to erode the surface. Thus, we can speculate that a paleo-nitrogen cycle may explain the erosion and the age of Titan's surface, and may have produced some of the present valley networks and shorelines. Moreover, by diffusion of liquid nitrogen in the crust, a paleo-nitrogen cycle could be responsible of the flattening of the polar regions and be at the origin of the methane outgassing on Titan.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Strong tidal dissipation in Saturn and constraints on Enceladus' thermal state from astrometry
Authors:
V. Lainey,
Ö. Karatekin,
J. Desmars,
S. Charnoz,
J-E. Arlot,
N. Emelyanov,
C. Le Poncin-Lafitte,
S. Mathis,
F. Remus,
G. Tobie,
J-P. Zahn
Abstract:
Tidal interactions between Saturn and its satellites play a crucial role in both the orbital migration of the satellites and the heating of their interiors. Therefore constraining the tidal dissipation of Saturn (here the ratio k2/Q) opens the door to the past evolution of the whole system. If Saturn's tidal ratio can be determined at different frequencies, it may also be possible to constrain the…
▽ More
Tidal interactions between Saturn and its satellites play a crucial role in both the orbital migration of the satellites and the heating of their interiors. Therefore constraining the tidal dissipation of Saturn (here the ratio k2/Q) opens the door to the past evolution of the whole system. If Saturn's tidal ratio can be determined at different frequencies, it may also be possible to constrain the giant planet's interior structure, which is still uncertain. Here, we try to determine Saturn's tidal ratio through its current effect on the orbits of the main moons, using astrometric data spanning more than a century. We find an intense tidal dissipation (k2/Q= (2.3 \pm 0.7) \times 10-4), which is about ten times higher than the usual value estimated from theoretical arguments. As a consequence, eccentricity equilibrium for Enceladus can now account for the huge heat emitted from Enceladus' south pole. Moreover, the measured k2/Q is found to be poorly sensitive to the tidal frequency, on the short frequency interval considered. This suggests that Saturn's dissipation may not be controlled by turbulent friction in the fluid envelope as commonly believed. If correct, the large tidal expansion of the moon orbits due to this strong Saturnian dissipation would be inconsistent with the moon formations 4.5 Byr ago above the synchronous orbit in the Saturnian subnebulae. But it would be compatible with a new model of satellite formation in which the Saturnian satellites formed possibly over longer time scale at the outer edge of the main rings. In an attempt to take into account for possible significant torques exerted by the rings on Mimas, we fitted a constant rate da/dt on Mimas semi-major axis, also. We obtained an unexpected large acceleration related to a negative value of da/dt= -(15.7 \pm 4.4) \times 10-15 au/day.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
-
Accretion of Saturn's mid-sized moons during the viscous spreading of young massive rings: solving the paradox of silicate-poor rings versus silicate-rich moons
Authors:
Sébastien Charnoz,
Aurélien Crida,
Julie C. Castillo-Rogez,
Valery Lainey,
Luke Dones,
Özgür Karatekin,
Gabriel Tobie,
Stephane Mathis,
Christophe Le Poncin-Lafitte,
Julien Salmon
Abstract:
The origin of Saturn's inner mid-sized moons (Mimas, Enceladus, Tethys, Dione and Rhea) and Saturn's rings is debated. Charnoz et al. (2010) introduced the idea that the smallest inner moons could form from the spreading of the rings' edge while Salmon et al. (2010) showed that the rings could have been initially massive, and so was the ring's progenitor itself. One may wonder if the mid-sized moo…
▽ More
The origin of Saturn's inner mid-sized moons (Mimas, Enceladus, Tethys, Dione and Rhea) and Saturn's rings is debated. Charnoz et al. (2010) introduced the idea that the smallest inner moons could form from the spreading of the rings' edge while Salmon et al. (2010) showed that the rings could have been initially massive, and so was the ring's progenitor itself. One may wonder if the mid-sized moons may have formed also from the debris of a massive ring progenitor, as also suggested in Canup (2010). However, the process driving mid-sized moons accretion from the icy debris disks has not been investigated in details. In particular, this process does not seem able to explain the varying silicate contents of the mid-sized moons (from 6% to 57% in mass). Here, we explore the formation of large objects from a massive ice-rich ring (a few times Rhea's mass) and describe the fundamental properties and implications of this new process. Using a hybrid computer model, we show that accretion within massive icy rings can form all mid-sized moons from Mimas to Rhea. However in order to explain their current locations, intense dissipation within Saturn (with Qp<2000) would be required. Our results are consistent with a satellite origin tied to the rings formation at least 2.5 Gy ago, both compatible with either a formation concurrent to Saturn or during the Late Heavy Bombardment. Tidal heating related to high-eccentricity post-accretional episodes may induce early geological activity. If some massive irregular chunks of silicates were initially present within the rings, they would be present today inside the satellites' cores which would have accreted icy shells while being tidally expelled from the rings (via a heterogeneous accretion process)while those still present in the rings are interpreted as today Saturn's rings' propellers and ring-moons (like Pan or Daphnis).
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2011;
originally announced September 2011.
-
Global circulation as the main source of cloud activity on Titan
Authors:
Sébastien Rodriguez,
Stéphane Le Mouélic,
Pascal Rannou,
Gabriel Tobie,
Kevin H. Baines,
Jason W. Barnes,
Caitlin A. Griffith,
Mathieu Hirtzig,
Karly M. Pitman,
Christophe Sotin,
Robert H. Brown,
Bonnie J. Buratti,
Roger N. Clark,
Phil D. Nicholson
Abstract:
Clouds on Titan result from the condensation of methane and ethane and, as on other planets, are primarily structured by circulation of the atmosphere. At present, cloud activity mainly occurs in the southern (summer) hemisphere, arising near the pole and at mid-latitudes from cumulus updrafts triggered by surface heating and/or local methane sources, and at the north (winter) pole, resulting fr…
▽ More
Clouds on Titan result from the condensation of methane and ethane and, as on other planets, are primarily structured by circulation of the atmosphere. At present, cloud activity mainly occurs in the southern (summer) hemisphere, arising near the pole and at mid-latitudes from cumulus updrafts triggered by surface heating and/or local methane sources, and at the north (winter) pole, resulting from the subsidence and condensation of ethane-rich air into the colder troposphere. General circulation models predict that this distribution should change with the seasons on a 15-year timescale, and that clouds should develop under certain circumstances at temperate latitudes (~40\degree) in the winter hemisphere. The models, however, have hitherto been poorly constrained and their long-term predictions have not yet been observationally verified. Here we report that the global spatial cloud coverage on Titan is in general agreement with the models, confirming that cloud activity is mainly controlled by the global circulation. The non-detection of clouds at latitude ~40\degree N and the persistence of the southern clouds while the southern summer is ending are, however, both contrary to predictions. This suggests that Titan's equator-to-pole thermal contrast is overestimated in the models and that its atmosphere responds to the seasonal forcing with a greater inertia than expected.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2009;
originally announced July 2009.
