-
Majorana mass generation, gravitational waves and cosmological tensions
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
A neutrino Majorana mass generation in the early universe might have left imprints in cosmological observables. It can source the production of a detectable stochastic background of primordial gravitational waves with a spectrum that combines a contribution from a first order phase transition production and from the vibration of global cosmic strings. An intriguing possibility is given by the spli…
▽ More
A neutrino Majorana mass generation in the early universe might have left imprints in cosmological observables. It can source the production of a detectable stochastic background of primordial gravitational waves with a spectrum that combines a contribution from a first order phase transition production and from the vibration of global cosmic strings. An intriguing possibility is given by the split seesaw model. In this case, in addition to the traditional high scale seesaw, a low scale neutrino Majorana mass generation can solve a potential primordial deuterium problem and ameliorate the cosmological tensions of the $Λ$CDM model. At the same time, it can also produce subdominant contribution to the NANOGrav signal of a stochastic background of gravitational waves (GWs), in addition to the astrophysical dominant contribution from supermassive black hole mergers.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Relic neutrino decay solution to the excess radio background
Authors:
P. S. Bhupal Dev,
Pasquale Di Bari,
Ivan Martínez-Soler,
Rishav Roshan
Abstract:
The excess radio background detected by ARCADE 2 represents a puzzle within the standard cosmological model. There is no clear viable astrophysical solution, and therefore, it might indicate the presence of new physics. Radiative decays of a relic neutrino $ν_i$ (either $i=1$, or $i=2$, or $i=3$) into a sterile neutrino $ν_{\rm s}$, assumed to be quasi-degenerate, provide a solution that currently…
▽ More
The excess radio background detected by ARCADE 2 represents a puzzle within the standard cosmological model. There is no clear viable astrophysical solution, and therefore, it might indicate the presence of new physics. Radiative decays of a relic neutrino $ν_i$ (either $i=1$, or $i=2$, or $i=3$) into a sterile neutrino $ν_{\rm s}$, assumed to be quasi-degenerate, provide a solution that currently evades all constraints posed by different cosmological observations and reproduces very well the ARCADE 2 data. We find a very good fit to the ARCADE 2 data with best fit values $τ_i = 1.46 \times 10^{21}\,{\rm s}$ and $Δm_i = 4.0 \times 10^{-5}\,{\rm eV}$, where $τ_i$ is the lifetime and $Δm_i$ is the mass difference between the decaying active neutrino and the sterile neutrino. On the other hand, if relic neutrino decays do not explain ARCADE 2 data, then these place a stringent constraint $Δm_i^{3/2} τ_i \gtrsim 2 \times 10^{14}\,{\rm eV}^{3/2}\,{\rm s}$ in the range $1.4 \times 10^{-5} \, {\rm eV} < Δm_i < 2.5 \times 10^{-4}\,{\rm eV}$. The solution also predicts a stronger 21 cm absorption global signal than the predicted one from the $Λ$CDM model, with a contrast brightness temperature $T_{21} = -238^{+21}_{-20}\,{\rm mK}$ ($99\%$ C.L.) at redshift $z\simeq 17$. This is in mild tension with the even stronger signal found by the EDGES collaboration, $T_{21} = - 500^{+200}_{-500}\,{\rm mK} $, suggesting that this might have been overestimated, possibly receiving a contribution from some unidentified foreground source.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2024; v1 submitted 5 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
The split majoron model confronts the NANOGrav signal and cosmological tensions
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Moinul Hossain Rahat
Abstract:
In the light of the evidence of a gravitational wave background from the NANOGrav 15yr data set, we reconsider the split majoron model as a new physics extension of the standard model able to generate a needed contribution to solve the current tension between the data and the standard interpretation in terms of inspiraling supermassive black hole massive binaries. In the split majoron model the se…
▽ More
In the light of the evidence of a gravitational wave background from the NANOGrav 15yr data set, we reconsider the split majoron model as a new physics extension of the standard model able to generate a needed contribution to solve the current tension between the data and the standard interpretation in terms of inspiraling supermassive black hole massive binaries. In the split majoron model the seesaw right-handed neutrinos acquire Majorana masses from spontaneous symmetry breaking of global $U(1)_{B-L}$ in a strong first order phase transition of a complex scalar field occurring above the electroweak scale. The final vacuum expectation value couples to a second complex scalar field undergoing a low scale phase transition occurring after neutrino decoupling. Such a coupling enhances the strength of this second low scale first order phase transition and can generate a sizeable primordial gravitational wave background contributing to the NANOGrav 15yr signal. Some amount of extra-radiation is generated after neutron-to-proton ration freeze-out but prior to nucleosynthesis. This can be either made compatible with current upper bound from primordial deuterium measurements or even be used to solve a potential deuterium problem. Moreover, the free streaming length of light neutrinos can be suppressed by their interactions with the resulting majoron background and this mildly ameliorates existing cosmological tensions. Thus cosmological observations nicely provide independent motivations for the model.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2024; v1 submitted 6 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Gravitational waves from phase transitions and cosmic strings in neutrino mass models with multiple majorons
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Stephen F. King,
Moinul Hossain Rahat
Abstract:
We explore the origin of Majorana masses within the majoron model and how this can lead to the generation of a distinguishable primordial stochastic background of gravitational waves. We first show how in the simplest majoron model only a contribution from cosmic string can be within the reach of planned experiments. We then consider extensions containing multiple complex scalars, demonstrating ho…
▽ More
We explore the origin of Majorana masses within the majoron model and how this can lead to the generation of a distinguishable primordial stochastic background of gravitational waves. We first show how in the simplest majoron model only a contribution from cosmic string can be within the reach of planned experiments. We then consider extensions containing multiple complex scalars, demonstrating how in this case a spectrum comprising contributions from both a strong first order phase transition and cosmic strings can naturally emerge. We show that the interplay between multiple scalar fields can amplify the phase transition signal, potentially leading to double peaks over the wideband sloped spectrum from cosmic strings. We also underscore the possibility of observing such a gravitational wave background to provide insights into the reheating temperature of the universe. We conclude highlighting how the model can be naturally combined with scenarios addressing the origin of matter of the universe, where baryogenesis occurs via leptogenesis and a right-handed neutrino plays the role of dark matter.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2024; v1 submitted 7 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Dark matter from sterile-sterile neutrino mixing
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
A solution to the problem of the origin of matter in the universe can be reasonably searched within extensions of the standard model that also explain neutrino masses and mixing. Models embedding the minimal seesaw mechanism can explain the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe via leptogenesis and dark matter via active-sterile neutrino mixing. In this case a keV lightest seesaw ne…
▽ More
A solution to the problem of the origin of matter in the universe can be reasonably searched within extensions of the standard model that also explain neutrino masses and mixing. Models embedding the minimal seesaw mechanism can explain the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe via leptogenesis and dark matter via active-sterile neutrino mixing. In this case a keV lightest seesaw neutrino would play the role of warm dark matter particle. This traditional solution is now constrained by various cosmological observations. I will discuss the possibility that a much heavier but yet metastable (dark) right-handed neutrino with mass in the $1\,{\rm TeV}$--$1 \, {\rm PeV}$ range can play the role of (cold) dark matter particle. The right abundance would be produced by the Higgs induced mixing with a seesaw right-handed neutrino (RHINO model), i.e., by sterile-sterile neutrino mixing. Such a mixing would necessarily require a further extension of the minimal seesaw mechanism and can be described by a dimension-five effective operator. The same mixing would also necessarily induce dark neutrino instability with lifetimes that can be much longer than the age of the universe and can escape current constraints from neutrino telescopes. On the other hand, a contribution to very high energy neutrino flux produced by dark neutrino decays could explain an anomalous excess at 100 TeV energies confirmed recently by the IceCube collaboration. I will also discuss a simple UV completion where the mediator is given by a massive fermion. Intriguingly, it comes out that the favoured scale of new physics for RHINO to satisfy the dark matter requirements coincides with the grand-unified scale: a RHINO miracle.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Completing RHINO
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Adam Murphy
Abstract:
The right-handed (RH) Higgs-induced neutrino mixing (RHINO) model explains neutrino masses and origin of matter in the universe within a unified picture. The mixing, effectively described by a dimension five operator, is responsible both for the production of dark neutrinos, converting a small fraction of seesaw neutrinos acting as source, and for their decays. We show that including the productio…
▽ More
The right-handed (RH) Higgs-induced neutrino mixing (RHINO) model explains neutrino masses and origin of matter in the universe within a unified picture. The mixing, effectively described by a dimension five operator, is responsible both for the production of dark neutrinos, converting a small fraction of seesaw neutrinos acting as source, and for their decays. We show that including the production of source neutrinos from Higgs portal interactions, their abundance can thermalise prior to the onset of source-dark neutrino oscillations, resulting into an enhanced production of dark neutrinos that thus can play the role of decaying dark matter (DM) for a much higher seesaw scale. This can be above the sphaleron freeze-out temperature and as high as $\sim 100\,{\rm TeV}$, so that strong thermal resonant leptogenesis for the generation of the matter-antimatter asymmetry is viable. We obtain a $\sim 1\,{\rm TeV}$--$1\,{\rm PeV}$ allowed dark neutrino mass range. Intriguingly, their decays can also explain a neutrino flux excess at ${\cal O}(100\,{\rm TeV})$ energies recently confirmed by the IceCube collaboration analysing 7.5yr HESE data. Our results also point to an effective scale for Higgs portal interactions nicely identifiable with the grandunified scale and many orders of magnitude below the effective scale for the mixing. We explain this hierarchy in a UV-complete model with a very heavy fermion as mediator: the first scale corresponds to the fundamental scale of new physics, while the second is much higher because of a very small coupling identifiable with a symmetry breaking parameter. Therefore, RHINO realises a simple unified model of neutrino masses and origin of matter in the universe currently under scrutiny at neutrino telescopes and potentially embeddable within a grandunified model.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2023; v1 submitted 19 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Gravitational waves from neutrino mass genesis
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
The discovery of gravitational waves opens new opportunities to test BSM physics. In particular, the production of a stochastic background of primordial gravitational waves could provide a signature of the generation of the right-right Majorana neutrino mass term necessary, within type-I seesaw mechanism, to explain lightness of neutrinos and their mixing parameters. I will discuss the possibility…
▽ More
The discovery of gravitational waves opens new opportunities to test BSM physics. In particular, the production of a stochastic background of primordial gravitational waves could provide a signature of the generation of the right-right Majorana neutrino mass term necessary, within type-I seesaw mechanism, to explain lightness of neutrinos and their mixing parameters. I will discuss the possibility that such a generation occurs during a strong first order phase transition within Majoron models [1]. As well known, this can indeed produce a stochastic background of gravitational waves. The scale of the phase transition can or cannot coincide with the seesaw scale. In the latter case a low scale phase transition, occurring in the pre-recombination era, might be tested at very low frequencies ($10^{-9}$--$10^{-6}\,{\rm Hz}$). Even though the signal can hardly reproduce the NANOGrac putative signal such new physics at low scale might help ameliorating the tensions in the $Λ$CDM cosmological model (e.g., the Hubble tension). I will also discuss how a phase transition might be responsible for the generation of dark matter in the form of dark neutrinos coupling to the seesaw neutrinos via Higgs induced right handed-right handed neutrino mixing [2].
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
On the origin of matter in the Universe
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
The understanding of the physical processes that lead to the origin of matter in the early Universe, creating both an excess of matter over anti-matter that survived until the present and a dark matter component, is one of the most fascinating challenges in modern science. The problem cannot be addressed within our current description of fundamental physics and, therefore, it currently provides a…
▽ More
The understanding of the physical processes that lead to the origin of matter in the early Universe, creating both an excess of matter over anti-matter that survived until the present and a dark matter component, is one of the most fascinating challenges in modern science. The problem cannot be addressed within our current description of fundamental physics and, therefore, it currently provides a very strong evidence of new physics. Solutions can either reside in a modification of the standard model of elementary particle physics or in a modification of the way we describe gravity, based on general relativity, or at the interface of both. We will mainly discuss the first class of solutions. Traditionally, models that separately explain either the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the Universe or dark matter have been proposed. However, in the last years there has also been an accreted interest and intense activity on scenarios able to provide a unified picture of the origin of matter in the early universe. In this review we discuss some of the main ideas emphasising primarily those models that have more chances to be experimentally tested during next years. Moreover, after a general discussion, we will focus on extensions of the standard model that can also address neutrino masses and mixing, since this is currently the only evidence of physics beyond the standard model coming directly from particle physics and it is, therefore, reasonable they might also provide a solution to the problem of the origin of matter in the universe.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2021; v1 submitted 29 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Gravitational waves from first-order phase transitions in Majoron models of neutrino mass
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Danny Marfatia,
Ye-Ling Zhou
Abstract:
We show how the generation of right-handed neutrino masses in Majoron models may be associated with a first-order phase transition and accompanied by the production of a stochastic background of gravitational waves (GWs). We explore different energy scales with only renormalizable operators in the effective potential. If the phase transition occurs above the electroweak scale, the signal can be te…
▽ More
We show how the generation of right-handed neutrino masses in Majoron models may be associated with a first-order phase transition and accompanied by the production of a stochastic background of gravitational waves (GWs). We explore different energy scales with only renormalizable operators in the effective potential. If the phase transition occurs above the electroweak scale, the signal can be tested by future interferometers. We consider two possible energy scales for phase transitions below the electroweak scale. If the phase transition occurs at a GeV, the signal can be tested at LISA and provide a complementary cosmological probe to right-handed neutrino searches at the FASER detector. If the phase transition occurs below 100 keV, we find that the peak of the GW spectrum is two or more orders of magnitude below the putative NANOGrav GW signal at low frequencies, but well within reach of the SKA and THEIA experiments. We show how searches of very low frequency GWs are motivated by solutions to the Hubble tension in which ordinary neutrinos interact with the dark sector. We also present general calculations of the phase transition temperature and Euclidean action that apply beyond Majoron models.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2021; v1 submitted 31 May, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
The $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis timely opportunity
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Rome Samanta
Abstract:
We study the connection between absolute neutrino mass and neutrino mixing parameters within $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis. We show that current favoured values of the unknown neutrino mixing parameters point toward values of the absolute neutrino mass scale that will be fully tested by cosmological observations and neutrinoless double beta decay experiments during next years. In particular, for…
▽ More
We study the connection between absolute neutrino mass and neutrino mixing parameters within $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis. We show that current favoured values of the unknown neutrino mixing parameters point toward values of the absolute neutrino mass scale that will be fully tested by cosmological observations and neutrinoless double beta decay experiments during next years. In particular, for $m_{D2}/m_{\rm charm} \leq 5$, where $m_{D2}$ is the intermediate Dirac neutrino mass, and for current best fit values of the Dirac phase $δ$ and the atmospheric neutrino mixing angle $θ_{23}$, we derive a lower bound on the neutrinoless double beta decay effective neutrino mass $m_{ee} \gtrsim 31\,{\rm meV}$ and on the sum of the neutrino masses $\sum_i m_i \gtrsim 125\,{\rm meV}$. These lower bounds hold for normally ordered neutrino masses, as currently favoured by global analyses and approximately for $δ\in [155^\circ,240^\circ]$ and $θ_{23}$ in the second octant. If values in this region will be confirmed by future planned long baseline experiments, then a signal at next generation neutrinoless double beta decay experiments is expected, despite neutrino masses being normally ordered. Outside the region, the lower bounds strongly relax but a great fraction of the allowed range of values still allows a measurement of the lightest neutrino mass. Therefore, in the the next years low energy neutrino experiments will provide a very stringent test of $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis, resulting either in severe constraints or in a strong evidence.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2020; v1 submitted 6 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Gravitational waves from neutrino mass and dark matter genesis
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Danny Marfatia,
Ye-Ling Zhou
Abstract:
We introduce a model in which the genesis of dark matter (DM) and neutrino masses is associated with a first order phase transition of a scalar singlet field. During the phase transition a source right-handed neutrino (RHN) acquires a spacetime-dependent mass dynamically, a small fraction of which is converted via resonant oscillations into a very weakly mixed dark RHN which decays to a dark matte…
▽ More
We introduce a model in which the genesis of dark matter (DM) and neutrino masses is associated with a first order phase transition of a scalar singlet field. During the phase transition a source right-handed neutrino (RHN) acquires a spacetime-dependent mass dynamically, a small fraction of which is converted via resonant oscillations into a very weakly mixed dark RHN which decays to a dark matter RHN with the observed relic abundance. Neutrino masses are generated via a traditional two RHN type-I seesaw between a fourth RHN and the source neutrino. The gravitational waves produced during the phase transition have a peak frequency that increases with the DM mass, and are detectable at future gravitational wave interferometers for DM masses above ~ 1 MeV. Since the source RHNs are heavier than the electroweak scale, successful leptogenesis is also attainable.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2020; v1 submitted 21 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Density matrix calculation of the dark matter abundance in the Higgs induced right-handed neutrino mixing model
Authors:
P. Di Bari,
K. Farrag,
R. Samanta,
Y. L. Zhou
Abstract:
We present new results on the calculation of the dark matter relic abundance within the Higgs induced right-handed (RH) neutrino mixing model, solving the associated density matrix equation. For a benchmark value of the dark matter mass $M_{\rm DM} = 220\,{\rm TeV}$, we show the evolution of the abundance and how this depends on reheat temperature, dark matter lifetime and source RH neutrino mass…
▽ More
We present new results on the calculation of the dark matter relic abundance within the Higgs induced right-handed (RH) neutrino mixing model, solving the associated density matrix equation. For a benchmark value of the dark matter mass $M_{\rm DM} = 220\,{\rm TeV}$, we show the evolution of the abundance and how this depends on reheat temperature, dark matter lifetime and source RH neutrino mass $M_{\rm S}$, with the assumption $M_{\rm S} < M_{\rm DM}$. We compare the results with those obtained within the Landau-Zener approximation, showing that the latter largely overestimates the final abundance giving some analytical insight. However, we also notice that since in the density matrix formalism the production is non-resonant, this allows source RH neutrino masses below the W boson mass, making dark matter more stable at large mass values. This opens an allowed region for initial vanishing source RH neutrino abundance. For example, for $M_{\rm S} \gtrsim 1\,{\rm GeV}$, we find $M_{\rm DM}\gtrsim 20\,{\rm PeV}$. Otherwise, for $M_{\rm S} > M_W\sim 100\,{\rm GeV}$, one has to assume a thermalisation of the source RH neutrinos prior to the freeze-in of the dark matter abundance. This results into a large allowed range for $M_{\rm DM}$, depending on $M_{\rm S}$. For example, imposing $M_{\rm S} \gtrsim 300\,{\rm GeV}$, allowing also successful leptogenesis, we find $0.5 \lesssim M_{\rm DM}/{\rm TeV} \lesssim 500$. We also discuss in detail leptogenesis with two quasi-degenerate RH neutrinos, showing a case when observed dark matter abundance and matter-antimatter asymmetry are simultaneously reproduced. Finally, we comment on how an initial thermal source RH neutrino abundance can be justified and on how our results suggest that also the interesting case where $M_{\rm DM} < M_{\rm S}$, embeddable in usual high scale two RH neutrino seesaw models, might be viable.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2020; v1 submitted 1 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Neutrino masses, leptogenesis and dark matter
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
Despite the lack of evidence of new physics at colliders, neutrino masses, dark matter and matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe require an extension of the Standard Model. After discussing some new concepts and tools in the description of seesaw neutrino models, such as motion in flavour lepton space and the introduction of the bridging matrix that nicely complements the orthogonal matrix,…
▽ More
Despite the lack of evidence of new physics at colliders, neutrino masses, dark matter and matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe require an extension of the Standard Model. After discussing some new concepts and tools in the description of seesaw neutrino models, such as motion in flavour lepton space and the introduction of the bridging matrix that nicely complements the orthogonal matrix, I discuss recent developments in the connections between neutrino data and scenarios of leptogenesis within some well motivated extensions of the Standard Model. Finally, I briefly review a simple unified picture of neutrino masses, leptogenesis and dark matter based on an extension of the seesaw Lagrangian where a non-renormalizable effective operator coupling right-handed neutrinos to the Higgs is introduced. This operator enhances the right-handed neutrino mixing between a coupled heavy right-handed neutrino and a decoupled one playing the role of dark matter. Interference between the two coupled RH neutrinos generate usual $C\!P$ violation so that one can also achieve successful leptogenesis. Although the dark matter right-handed neutrino escapes direct and collider searches, its decays produce a detectable contribution to the very high energy neutrino flux now discovered by IceCube, so that the model is predictive and can be tested at neutrino telescopes.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2019; v1 submitted 26 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Representing seesaw neutrino models and their motion in lepton flavour space
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Michele Re Fiorentin,
Rome Samanta
Abstract:
We discuss how seesaw neutrino models can be graphically represented in lepton flavour space. We examine various popular models and show how this representation helps understanding their properties and connection with experimental data showing in particular how certain texture zero models are ruled out. We also introduce a new matrix, the bridging matrix, that brings from the light to the heavy ne…
▽ More
We discuss how seesaw neutrino models can be graphically represented in lepton flavour space. We examine various popular models and show how this representation helps understanding their properties and connection with experimental data showing in particular how certain texture zero models are ruled out. We also introduce a new matrix, the bridging matrix, that brings from the light to the heavy neutrino mass flavour basis, showing how this is related to the orthogonal matrix and how different quantities are easily expressed through it. We then show how one can randomly generate orthogonal and leptonic mixing matrices uniformly covering all flavour space in an unbiased way (Haar-distributed matrices). Using the isomorphism between the group of complex rotations and the Lorentz group, we also introduce the conceptof Lorentz boost in flavour space for a seesaw model and how this has an insightful physical interpretation. Finally, as a significant application, we consider $N_2$-leptogenesis. Using current experimental values of low energy neutrino parameters, we show that the probability that at least one flavoured decay parameter of the lightest right-handed neutrino is smaller than unity is about $49\%$ (to be compared with the tiny probability that the total decay parameter is smaller than unity, $P(K_{\rm I}< 1)\sim 0.1 \%$, confirming the crucial role played by flavour effects). On the other hand when $m_1 \gtrsim 0.1\,{\rm eV}$ this probability reduces to less than $5\%$, showing how also $N_2$-leptogenesis disfavours degenerate light neutrinos.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2019; v1 submitted 18 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Future Opportunities in Accelerator-based Neutrino Physics
Authors:
Andrea Dell'Acqua,
Antoni Aduszkiewicz,
Markus Ahlers,
Hiroaki Aihara,
Tyler Alion,
Saul Alonso Monsalve,
Luis Alvarez Ruso,
Vito Antonelli,
Marta Babicz,
Anastasia Maria Barbano,
Pasquale di Bari,
Eric Baussan,
Vincenzo Bellini,
Vincenzo Berardi,
Alain Blondel,
Maurizio Bonesini,
Alexander Booth,
Stefania Bordoni,
Alexey Boyarsky,
Steven Boyd,
Alan D. Bross,
Juergen Brunner,
Colin Carlile,
Maria-Gabriella Catanesi,
Georgios Christodoulou
, et al. (118 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This document summarizes the conclusions of the Neutrino Town Meeting held at CERN in October 2018 to review the neutrino field at large with the aim of defining a strategy for accelerator-based neutrino physics in Europe. The importance of the field across its many complementary components is stressed. Recommendations are presented regarding the accelerator based neutrino physics, pertinent to th…
▽ More
This document summarizes the conclusions of the Neutrino Town Meeting held at CERN in October 2018 to review the neutrino field at large with the aim of defining a strategy for accelerator-based neutrino physics in Europe. The importance of the field across its many complementary components is stressed. Recommendations are presented regarding the accelerator based neutrino physics, pertinent to the European Strategy for Particle Physics. We address in particular i) the role of CERN and its neutrino platform, ii) the importance of ancillary neutrino cross-section experiments, and iii) the capability of fixed target experiments as well as present and future high energy colliders to search for the possible manifestations of neutrino mass generation mechanisms.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2019; v1 submitted 17 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Probing relic neutrino decays with 21 cm cosmology
Authors:
Marco Chianese,
Pasquale Di Bari,
Kareem Farrag,
Rome Samanta
Abstract:
We show how 21 cm cosmology can test relic neutrino radiative decays into sterile neutrinos. Using recent EDGES results, we derive constraints on the lifetime of the decaying neutrinos. If the EDGES anomaly will be confirmed, then there are two solutions, one for much longer and one for much shorter lifetimes than the age of the universe, showing how relic neutrino radiative decays can explain the…
▽ More
We show how 21 cm cosmology can test relic neutrino radiative decays into sterile neutrinos. Using recent EDGES results, we derive constraints on the lifetime of the decaying neutrinos. If the EDGES anomaly will be confirmed, then there are two solutions, one for much longer and one for much shorter lifetimes than the age of the universe, showing how relic neutrino radiative decays can explain the anomaly in a simple way. We also show how to combine EDGES results with those from radio background observations, showing that potentially the ARCADE 2 excess can be also reproduced together with the EDGES anomaly within the proposed non-standard cosmological scenario. Our calculation of the specific intensity at the redshifts probed by EDGES can be also applied to the case of decaying dark matter and it also corrects a flawed expression appeared in previous literature.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2018; v1 submitted 29 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Strong thermal $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis in the light of recent results from long-baseline neutrino experiments
Authors:
Marco Chianese,
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
We confront recent experimental results on neutrino mixing parameters with the requirements from strong thermal $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis, where the asymmetry is produced from next-to-lightest right-handed neutrinos $N_2$ independently of the initial conditions. There is a nice agreement with latest global analyses supporting $\sinδ< 0$ and normal ordering at $ \sim 95\%$ C.L. On the other ha…
▽ More
We confront recent experimental results on neutrino mixing parameters with the requirements from strong thermal $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis, where the asymmetry is produced from next-to-lightest right-handed neutrinos $N_2$ independently of the initial conditions. There is a nice agreement with latest global analyses supporting $\sinδ< 0$ and normal ordering at $ \sim 95\%$ C.L. On the other hand, the more stringent experimental lower bound on the atmospheric mixing angle starts to corner strong thermal $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis. Prompted and encouraged by this rapid experimental advance, we obtain a precise determination of the allowed region in the plane $δ$ versus $θ_{23}$. We confirm that for the benchmark case $α_2 \equiv m_{D2} / m_{\rm charm}= 5 \, $, where $m_{D2}$ is the intermediate neutrino Dirac mass setting the $N_2$ mass, and initial pre-existing asymmetry $N_{B-L}^{\rm p, i} = 10^{-3}$, the bulk of solutions lies in the first octant. Though most of the solutions are found outside the $95\%$ C.L. experimental region, there is still a big allowed fraction that does not require a too fine-tuned choice of the Majorana phases so that the neutrinoless double beta decay effective neutrino mass allowed range is still $m_{ee}\simeq [10,30]\,{\rm meV}$. We also show how the constraints depend on $N_{B-L}^{\rm p, i}$ and $α_2$. In particular, we show that the current best fit, ($θ_{23},δ)\simeq (47^{\circ}, -130^{\circ})$, can be reproduced for $N_{B-L}^{\rm p, i} = 10^{-3}$ and $α_2 = 6$. Such large values for $α_2$ have been recently obtained in a few realistic fits within $SO(10)$-inspired models. Finally, we also obtain that current neutrino data rule out $N_{B-L}^{\rm p, i} \gtrsim 0.1$ for $α_2 \lesssim 4.7$.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2018; v1 submitted 15 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Flavor effects in leptogenesis
Authors:
P. S. Bhupal Dev,
Pasquale Di Bari,
Bjorn Garbrecht,
Stéphane Lavignac,
Peter Millington,
Daniele Teresi
Abstract:
Flavor effects can have a significant impact on the final estimate of the lepton (and therefore baryon) asymmetry in scenarios of leptogenesis. It is therefore necessary to account fully for this flavor dynamics in the relevant transport equations that describe the production (and washout) of the asymmetry. Doing so can both open up and restrict viable regions of parameter space relative to the pr…
▽ More
Flavor effects can have a significant impact on the final estimate of the lepton (and therefore baryon) asymmetry in scenarios of leptogenesis. It is therefore necessary to account fully for this flavor dynamics in the relevant transport equations that describe the production (and washout) of the asymmetry. Doing so can both open up and restrict viable regions of parameter space relative to the predictions of more approximate calculations. In this review, we identify the regimes in which flavor effects can be relevant and illustrate their impact in a number of phenomenological models. These include type I and type II seesaw embeddings, and low-scale resonant scenarios. In addition, we provide an overview of the semi-classical and field-theoretic methods that have been developed to capture flavor effects in a consistent way.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2018; v1 submitted 8 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
A full analytic solution of $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Michele Re Fiorentin
Abstract:
Recent encouraging experimental results on neutrino mixing parameters prompt further investigation on $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis and on the associated strong thermal solution that has correctly predicted a non-vanishing reactor mixing angle, it further predicts $\sinδ\lesssim 0$, now supported by recent results at $\sim 95\%$ C.L., normally ordered neutrino masses and atmospheric mixing angle…
▽ More
Recent encouraging experimental results on neutrino mixing parameters prompt further investigation on $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis and on the associated strong thermal solution that has correctly predicted a non-vanishing reactor mixing angle, it further predicts $\sinδ\lesssim 0$, now supported by recent results at $\sim 95\%$ C.L., normally ordered neutrino masses and atmospheric mixing angle in the first octant, best fit results in latest global analyses. Extending a recent analytical procedure, we account for the mismatch between the Yukawa basis and the weak basis, that in $SO(10)$-inspired models is described by a CKM-like unitary transformation $V_L$, obtaining a full analytical solution that provides useful insight and reproduces accurately all numerical results, paving the way for future inclusion of different sources of theoretical uncertainties and for a statistical analysis of the constraints. We show how muon-dominated solutions appear for large values of the lightest neutrino mass in the range $(0.01$--$1)\,{\rm eV}$ but also how they necessarily require a mild fine tuning in the seesaw relation. For the dominant (and untuned) tauon-dominated solutions we show how, turning on $V_L \simeq V_{CKM}$, some of the constraints on the low energy neutrino parameters get significantly relaxed. In particular we show how the upper bound on the atmospheric neutrino mixing angle in the strong thermal solution gets relaxed from $θ_{23} \lesssim 41^{\circ}$ to $θ_{23} \lesssim 44^{\circ}$, an important effect in the light of the most recent NO$ν$A, T2K and IceCube results.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2019; v1 submitted 4 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Beyond the Standard Model with leptogenesis and neutrino data
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
In this short review I discuss how high energy (type I) seesaw models can be nicely embedded within grand-unified models and reproduce the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry with leptogenesis. In particular, after discussing general features and results in leptogenesis,
I focus on $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis and on a particular solution, the strong thermal $SO(10)$-inspired solution, that p…
▽ More
In this short review I discuss how high energy (type I) seesaw models can be nicely embedded within grand-unified models and reproduce the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry with leptogenesis. In particular, after discussing general features and results in leptogenesis,
I focus on $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis and on a particular solution, the strong thermal $SO(10)$-inspired solution, that provides an interesting way to understand neutrino mixing parameters: the non-vanishing reactor mixing angle, the emerging negative sign of $\sinδ$ and the slight hints favouring normally ordered neutrino masses and an atmospheric mixing angle in the first octant. I also briefly discuss leptogenesis within two right-handed seesaw neutrino models. In this case a a third decoupled right-handed neutrino can provide a candidate for very heavy cold decaying dark matter produced from right-handed neutrino mixing with a mass in the TeV-EeV range and its decays would give a contribution to the IceCube high energy neutrino events in addition to an astrophysical component.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2017; v1 submitted 22 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Unifying leptogenesis, dark matter and high-energy neutrinos with right-handed neutrino mixing via Higgs portal
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Patrick Otto Ludl,
Sergio Palomares-Ruiz
Abstract:
We revisit a model in which neutrino masses and mixing are described by a two right-handed (RH) neutrino seesaw scenario, implying a strictly hierarchical light neutrino spectrum. A third decoupled RH neutrino, $N_{\rm DM}$ with mass $M_{\rm DM}$, plays the role of cold dark matter (DM) and is produced by the mixing with a source RH neutrino, $N_{\rm S}$ with mass $M_{\rm S}$, induced by Higgs por…
▽ More
We revisit a model in which neutrino masses and mixing are described by a two right-handed (RH) neutrino seesaw scenario, implying a strictly hierarchical light neutrino spectrum. A third decoupled RH neutrino, $N_{\rm DM}$ with mass $M_{\rm DM}$, plays the role of cold dark matter (DM) and is produced by the mixing with a source RH neutrino, $N_{\rm S}$ with mass $M_{\rm S}$, induced by Higgs portal interactions. The same interactions are also responsible for $N_{\rm DM}$ decays. We discuss in detail the constraints coming from DM abundance and stability conditions, showing that in the hierarchical case ($M_{\rm DM} \gg M_{\rm S}$) there is an allowed window on $M_{\rm DM}$, which necessarily implies a contribution from DM decays to the high-energy neutrino flux recently detected by IceCube. We also show how the model can explain the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the Universe via leptogenesis in the quasi-degenerate limit. In this case, the DM mass should be within the range 300 GeV $\lesssim M_{\rm S} < M_{\rm DM} \lesssim$ 10 PeV. We discuss the specific properties of this high-energy neutrino flux and show the predicted event spectrum for two exemplary cases. Although DM decays, with a relatively hard spectrum, cannot account for all the IceCube high-energy data, we illustrate how this extra source of high-energy neutrinos could reasonably explain some potential features in the observed spectrum. In this way, this represents a unified scenario for leptogenesis and DM that could be tested during the next years with more high-energy neutrino events.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2018; v1 submitted 20 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
A White Paper on keV Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter
Authors:
R. Adhikari,
M. Agostini,
N. Anh Ky,
T. Araki,
M. Archidiacono,
M. Bahr,
J. Baur,
J. Behrens,
F. Bezrukov,
P. S. Bhupal Dev,
D. Borah,
A. Boyarsky,
A. de Gouvea,
C. A. de S. Pires,
H. J. de Vega,
A. G. Dias,
P. Di Bari,
Z. Djurcic,
K. Dolde,
H. Dorrer,
M. Durero,
O. Dragoun,
M. Drewes,
G. Drexlin,
Ch. E. Düllmann
, et al. (111 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present a comprehensive review of keV-scale sterile neutrino Dark Matter, collecting views and insights from all disciplines involved - cosmology, astrophysics, nuclear, and particle physics - in each case viewed from both theoretical and experimental/observational perspectives. After reviewing the role of active neutrinos in particle physics, astrophysics, and cosmology, we focus on sterile ne…
▽ More
We present a comprehensive review of keV-scale sterile neutrino Dark Matter, collecting views and insights from all disciplines involved - cosmology, astrophysics, nuclear, and particle physics - in each case viewed from both theoretical and experimental/observational perspectives. After reviewing the role of active neutrinos in particle physics, astrophysics, and cosmology, we focus on sterile neutrinos in the context of the Dark Matter puzzle. Here, we first review the physics motivation for sterile neutrino Dark Matter, based on challenges and tensions in purely cold Dark Matter scenarios. We then round out the discussion by critically summarizing all known constraints on sterile neutrino Dark Matter arising from astrophysical observations, laboratory experiments, and theoretical considerations. In this context, we provide a balanced discourse on the possibly positive signal from X-ray observations. Another focus of the paper concerns the construction of particle physics models, aiming to explain how sterile neutrinos of keV-scale masses could arise in concrete settings beyond the Standard Model of elementary particle physics. The paper ends with an extensive review of current and future astrophysical and laboratory searches, highlighting new ideas and their experimental challenges, as well as future perspectives for the discovery of sterile neutrinos.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2017; v1 submitted 15 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Supersymmetric $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis and a new $N_2$-dominated scenario
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Michele Re Fiorentin
Abstract:
We study the supersymmetric extension of $SO(10)$-inspired thermal leptogenesis showing the constraints on neutrino parameters and on the reheat temperature $T_{\rm RH}$ that derive from the condition of successful leptogenesis from next-to-lightest right handed (RH) neutrinos ($N_2$) decays and the more stringent ones when independence of the initial conditions (strong thermal leptogenesis) is su…
▽ More
We study the supersymmetric extension of $SO(10)$-inspired thermal leptogenesis showing the constraints on neutrino parameters and on the reheat temperature $T_{\rm RH}$ that derive from the condition of successful leptogenesis from next-to-lightest right handed (RH) neutrinos ($N_2$) decays and the more stringent ones when independence of the initial conditions (strong thermal leptogenesis) is superimposed. In the latter case, the increase of the lightest right-handed neutrino ($N_1$) decay parameters helps the wash-out of a pre-existing asymmetry and constraints relax compared to the non-supersymmetric case. We find significant changes especially in the case of large $\tanβ$ values $(\gtrsim 15)$. In particular, for normal ordering, the atmospheric mixing angle can now be also maximal. The lightest (ordinary) neutrino mass is still constrained within the range $10 \lesssim m_1/{\rm meV} \lesssim 30$ (corresponding to $75\lesssim \sum_i m_i/{\rm meV} \lesssim 120$). Inverted ordering is still disfavoured, but an allowed region satisfying strong thermal leptogenesis opens up at large $\tanβ$ values. We also study in detail the lower bound on $T_{\rm RH}$ finding $T_{\rm RH}\gtrsim 1 \times 10^{10}\,{\rm GeV}$ independently of the initial $N_2$ abundance. Finally, we propose a new $N_2$-dominated scenario where the $N_1$ mass is lower than the sphaleron freeze-out temperature. In this case there is no $N_1$ wash-out and we find $T_{\rm RH} \gtrsim 1\times 10^{9}\,{\rm GeV}$. These results indicate that $SO(10)$-inspired thermal leptogenesis can be made compatible with the upper bound from the gravitino problem, an important result in light of the role often played by supersymmetry in the quest of a realistic model of fermion masses.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2016; v1 submitted 21 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Successful $N_2$ leptogenesis with flavour coupling effects in realistic unified models
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Stephen F. King
Abstract:
In realistic unified models involving an $SO(10)$-like pattern of Dirac and heavy right-handed (RH) neutrino masses, the lightest right-handed neutrino $N_1$ is too light to yield successful thermal leptogenesis, barring highly fine tuned solutions, while the second heaviest right-handed neutrino $N_2$ is typically in the correct mass range. We show that flavour coupling effects in the Boltzmann e…
▽ More
In realistic unified models involving an $SO(10)$-like pattern of Dirac and heavy right-handed (RH) neutrino masses, the lightest right-handed neutrino $N_1$ is too light to yield successful thermal leptogenesis, barring highly fine tuned solutions, while the second heaviest right-handed neutrino $N_2$ is typically in the correct mass range. We show that flavour coupling effects in the Boltzmann equations may be crucial to the success of such $N_2$ dominated leptogenesis, by helping to ensure that the flavour asymmetries produced at the $N_2$ scale survive $N_1$ washout. To illustrate these effects we focus on $N_2$ dominated leptogenesis in an existing model, the A to Z of flavour with Pati-Salam, where the neutrino Dirac mass matrix may be equal to an up-type quark mass matrix and has a particular constrained structure. The numerical results, supported by analytical insight, show that in order to achieve successful $N_2$ leptogenesis, consistent with neutrino phenomenology, requires a "flavour swap scenario" together with a less hierarchical pattern of RH neutrino masses than naively expected, at the expense of some mild fine-tuning. These results may be relevant for other $SO(10)$-like unified models where $N_2$ leptogenesis is necessary.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2015; v1 submitted 23 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Decrypting $SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Luca Marzola,
Michele Re Fiorentin
Abstract:
Encouraged by the recent results from neutrino oscillation experiments, we perform an analytical study of $SO(10)$-inspired models and leptogenesis with hierarchical right-handed (RH) neutrino spectrum. Under the approximation of negligible misalignment between the neutrino Yukawa basis and the charged lepton basis, we find an analytical expression for the final asymmetry directly in terms of the…
▽ More
Encouraged by the recent results from neutrino oscillation experiments, we perform an analytical study of $SO(10)$-inspired models and leptogenesis with hierarchical right-handed (RH) neutrino spectrum. Under the approximation of negligible misalignment between the neutrino Yukawa basis and the charged lepton basis, we find an analytical expression for the final asymmetry directly in terms of the low energy neutrino parameters that fully reproduces previous numerical results. This expression also shows that is possible to identify an effective leptogenesis phase for these models. When we also impose the wash-out of a large pre-existing asymmetry $N^{\rm p,i}_{B-L}$, the strong thermal (ST) condition, we derive analytically all those constraints on the low energy neutrino parameters that characterise the {\rm ST}-$SO(10)$-inspired leptogenesis solution, confirming previous numerical results. In particular we show why, though neutrino masses have to be necessarily normally ordered, the solution implies an analytical lower bound on the effective neutrino-less double beta decay neutrino mass, $m_{ee} \gtrsim 8\,{\rm meV}$, for $N^{\rm p,i}_{B-L}=10^{-3}$, testable with next generation experiments. This, in combination with an upper bound on the atmospheric mixing angle, necessarily in the first octant, forces the lightest neutrino mass within a narrow range $m_1 \simeq (10$-$30)\,{\rm meV}$ (corresponding to $\sum_i \, m_i \simeq (75$-$125)\,{\rm meV}$). We also show why the solution could correctly predict a non-vanishing reactor neutrino mixing angle and requires the Dirac phase to be in the fourth quadrant, implying $\sinδ$ (and $J_{CP}$) negative as hinted by current global analyses. Many of the analytical results presented (expressions for the orthogonal matrix, RH neutrino mixing matrix, masses and phases) can have applications beyond leptogenesis.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2015; v1 submitted 20 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Radiative Inflation and Dark Energy RIDEs Again after BICEP2
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Stephen F. King,
Christoph Luhn,
Alexander Merle,
Angnis Schmidt-May
Abstract:
Following the ground-breaking measurement of the tensor-to-scalar ratio $r = 0.20^{+0.07}_{- 0.05}$ by the BICEP2 collaboration, we perform a statistical analysis of a model that combines Radiative Inflation with Dark Energy (RIDE) based on the $M^2 |Φ|^2 \ln \left(|Φ|^2/Λ^2 \right)$ potential and compare its predictions to those based on the traditional chaotic inflation $M^2|Φ|^2$ potential. We…
▽ More
Following the ground-breaking measurement of the tensor-to-scalar ratio $r = 0.20^{+0.07}_{- 0.05}$ by the BICEP2 collaboration, we perform a statistical analysis of a model that combines Radiative Inflation with Dark Energy (RIDE) based on the $M^2 |Φ|^2 \ln \left(|Φ|^2/Λ^2 \right)$ potential and compare its predictions to those based on the traditional chaotic inflation $M^2|Φ|^2$ potential. We find a best-fit value in the RIDE model of $r=0.18$ as compared to $r=0.17$ in the chaotic model, with the spectral index being $n_S=0.96$ in both models.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2014; v1 submitted 31 March, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Strong thermal leptogenesis and the absolute neutrino mass scale
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Sophie E. King,
Michele Re Fiorentin
Abstract:
We show that successful strong thermal leptogenesis, where the final asymmetry is independent of the initial conditions and in particular a large pre-existing asymmetry is efficiently washed-out, favours values of the lightest neutrino mass $m_1 \gtrsim 10\,{\rm meV}$ for normal ordering (NO) and $m_1 \gtrsim 3\,{\rm meV}$ for inverted ordering (IO) for models with orthogonal matrix entries respec…
▽ More
We show that successful strong thermal leptogenesis, where the final asymmetry is independent of the initial conditions and in particular a large pre-existing asymmetry is efficiently washed-out, favours values of the lightest neutrino mass $m_1 \gtrsim 10\,{\rm meV}$ for normal ordering (NO) and $m_1 \gtrsim 3\,{\rm meV}$ for inverted ordering (IO) for models with orthogonal matrix entries respecting $|Ω_{ij}^2| \lesssim 2$. . We show analytically why lower values of $m_1$ require a high level of fine tuning in the seesaw formula and/or in the flavoured decay parameters (in the electronic for NO, in the muonic for IO). We also show how this constraint exists thanks to the measured values of the neutrino mixing angles and can be tighten by a future determination of the Dirac phase. Our analysis also allows to place more stringent constraint for a specific model or class of models, such as $SO(10)$-inspired models, and shows that some models cannot realise strong thermal leptogenesis for any value of $m_1$. A scatter plot analysis fully supports the analytical results. We also briefly discuss the interplay with absolute neutrino mass scale experiments concluding that they will be able in the coming years to either corner strong thermal leptogenesis or find positive signals pointing to a non-vanishing $m_1$. Since the constraint is much stronger for NO than for IO, it is very important that new data from planned neutrino oscillation experiments will be able to solve the ambiguity.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2014; v1 submitted 23 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
SO(10)-inspired solution to the problem of the initial conditions in leptogenesis
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Luca Marzola
Abstract:
We show that, within SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis, there exists a solution, with definite constraints on low energy neutrino parameters, able simultaneously to reproduce the observed baryon asymmetry and to satisfy the conditions for the independence of the final asymmetry of the initial conditions (strong thermal leptogenesis). We find that the wash-out of a pre-existing asymmetry as large as O(0…
▽ More
We show that, within SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis, there exists a solution, with definite constraints on low energy neutrino parameters, able simultaneously to reproduce the observed baryon asymmetry and to satisfy the conditions for the independence of the final asymmetry of the initial conditions (strong thermal leptogenesis). We find that the wash-out of a pre-existing asymmetry as large as O(0.1) requires: i) reactor mixing angle in the range θ_13 = (2 - 20) degrees, in agreement with the experimental result θ_13 = (8 - 10) degrees; ii) atmospheric mixing angle in the range θ_23 = (16 - 41) degrees, compatible only with current lowest experimentally allowed values; iii) Dirac phase in the range δ\simeq -π/2 - π/5, with the bulk of the solutions around δ\simeq -π/5 and such that sign(J_CP)= - sign(η_B); iv) neutrino masses m_i normally ordered; v) lightest neutrino mass in the range m_1 \simeq (15 - 25) meV, corresponding to \sum_i m_i \simeq (85 - 105) meV; vi) neutrinoless double beta decay (0νββ) effective neutrino mass m_ee \simeq 0.8 m_1. All together this set of predictive constraints characterises the solution quite distinctively, representing a difficultly forgeable, fully testable, signature. In particular, the condition m_ee \simeq 0.8 m_1 \simeq 15 meV can be tested by cosmological observations and (ultimately) by 0νββexperiments. We also discuss different aspects such as theoretical uncertainties, stability under variation of the involved parameters, form of the orthogonal and RH neutrino mixing matrices.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2013; v1 submitted 5 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Dark Radiation or Warm Dark Matter from long lived particle decays in the light of Planck
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Stephen F. King,
Alexander Merle
Abstract:
Although Planck data supports the standard ΛCDM model, it still allows for the presence of Dark Radiation corresponding up to about half an extra standard neutrino species. We propose a scenario for obtaining a fractional "effective neutrino species" from a thermally produced particle which decays into a much lighter stable relic plus standard fermions. At lifetimes much longer than 1 sec, both th…
▽ More
Although Planck data supports the standard ΛCDM model, it still allows for the presence of Dark Radiation corresponding up to about half an extra standard neutrino species. We propose a scenario for obtaining a fractional "effective neutrino species" from a thermally produced particle which decays into a much lighter stable relic plus standard fermions. At lifetimes much longer than 1 sec, both the relic particles and the non-thermal neutrino component contribute to Dark Radiation. By increasing the stable-to-unstable particle mass ratio, the relic particle no longer acts as Dark Radiation but instead becomes a candidate for Warm Dark Matter with mass O(1keV - 100GeV). In both cases it is possible to address the lithium problem.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 2013; v1 submitted 25 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
The minimal scenario of leptogenesis
Authors:
Steve Blanchet,
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
We review the main features and results of thermal leptogenesis within the type I seesaw mechanism, the minimal extension of the Standard Model explaining neutrino masses and mixing. After presenting the simplest approach, the vanilla scenario, we discuss various important developments in recent years, such as the inclusion of lepton and heavy neutrino flavour effects, a description beyond a hiera…
▽ More
We review the main features and results of thermal leptogenesis within the type I seesaw mechanism, the minimal extension of the Standard Model explaining neutrino masses and mixing. After presenting the simplest approach, the vanilla scenario, we discuss various important developments in recent years, such as the inclusion of lepton and heavy neutrino flavour effects, a description beyond a hierarchical heavy neutrino mass spectrum and an improved kinetic description within the density matrix and the closed-time-path formalisms. We also discuss how leptogenesis can ultimately represent an important phenomenological tool to test the seesaw mechanism and the underlying model of new physics.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
An introduction to leptogenesis and neutrino properties
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
This is an introductory review of the main features of leptogenesis, one of the most attractive models of baryogenesis for the explanation of the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the Universe. The calculation of the asymmetry in leptogenesis is intimately related to neutrino properties so that leptogenesis is also an important phenomenological tool to test the see-saw mechanism for the generation of…
▽ More
This is an introductory review of the main features of leptogenesis, one of the most attractive models of baryogenesis for the explanation of the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the Universe. The calculation of the asymmetry in leptogenesis is intimately related to neutrino properties so that leptogenesis is also an important phenomenological tool to test the see-saw mechanism for the generation of neutrino masses and mixing and the underlying theory beyond the Standard Model.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Leptogenesis with heavy neutrino flavours: from density matrix to Boltzmann equations
Authors:
Steve Blanchet,
David A. Jones,
Pasquale Di Bari,
Luca Marzola
Abstract:
Leptogenesis with heavy neutrino flavours is discussed within a density matrix formalism. We write the density matrix equation, describing the generation of the matter-antimatter asymmetry, for an arbitrary choice of the right-handed (RH) neutrino masses. For hierarchical RH neutrino masses lying in the fully flavoured regimes, this reduces to multiple-stage Boltzmann equations. In this case we re…
▽ More
Leptogenesis with heavy neutrino flavours is discussed within a density matrix formalism. We write the density matrix equation, describing the generation of the matter-antimatter asymmetry, for an arbitrary choice of the right-handed (RH) neutrino masses. For hierarchical RH neutrino masses lying in the fully flavoured regimes, this reduces to multiple-stage Boltzmann equations. In this case we recover and extend results previously derived within a quantum state collapse description. We confirm the generic existence of phantom terms. However, taking into account the effect of gauge interactions, we show that they are washed out at the production with a wash-out rate that is halved compared to that one acting on the total asymmetry. In the N_1-dominated scenario they cancel without contributing to the final baryon asymmetry. In other scenarios they do not in general and they have to be taken into account. We also confirm that there is a (orthogonal) component in the asymmetry produced by the heavier RH neutrinos which completely escapes the washout from the lighter RH neutrinos and show that phantom terms additionally contribute to it. The other (parallel) component is washed out with the usual exponential factor, even for weak washout. Finally, as an illustration, we study the two RH neutrino model in the light of the above findings, showing that phantom terms can contribute to the final asymmetry also in this case.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2013; v1 submitted 19 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
-
Leptogenesis in the two right-handed neutrino model revisited
Authors:
S. Antusch,
P. Di Bari,
D. A. Jones,
S. F. King
Abstract:
We revisit leptogenesis in the minimal non-supersymmetric type I see-saw mechanism with two right-handed (RH) neutrinos, including flavour effects and allowing both RH neutrinos N_1 and N_2 to contribute, rather than just the lightest RH neutrino N_1 that has hitherto been considered. By performing scans over parameter space in terms of the single complex angle z of the orthogonal matrix R, for a…
▽ More
We revisit leptogenesis in the minimal non-supersymmetric type I see-saw mechanism with two right-handed (RH) neutrinos, including flavour effects and allowing both RH neutrinos N_1 and N_2 to contribute, rather than just the lightest RH neutrino N_1 that has hitherto been considered. By performing scans over parameter space in terms of the single complex angle z of the orthogonal matrix R, for a range of PMNS parameters, we find that in regions around z \sim \pm π/2, for the case of a normal mass hierarchy, the N_2 contribution can dominate the contribution to leptogenesis, allowing the lightest RH neutrino mass to be decreased by about an order of magnitude in these regions, down to M_1 \sim 1.3*10^11 GeV for vanishing initial N_2-abundance, with the numerical results supported by analytic estimates. We show that the regions around z \sim \pm π/2 correspond to light sequential dominance, so the new results in this paper may be relevant to unified model building.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2012; v1 submitted 29 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
-
Developments in Leptogenesis
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
Latest developments in leptogenesis are reviewed with a particular emphasis on the proposals to test leptogenesis. We discuss in particular the important role played by light and heavy flavour effects in the determination of the final asymmetry and the attractive features of the N_2 dominated scenario.
Latest developments in leptogenesis are reviewed with a particular emphasis on the proposals to test leptogenesis. We discuss in particular the important role played by light and heavy flavour effects in the determination of the final asymmetry and the attractive features of the N_2 dominated scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Testing SO(10)-inspired leptogenesis with low energy neutrino experiments
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Antonio Riotto
Abstract:
We extend the results of a previous analysis of ours showing that, when both heavy and light flavour effects are taken into account, successful minimal (type I + thermal) leptogenesis with SO(10)-inspired relations is possible. Barring fine tuned choices of the parameters, these relations enforce a hierarchical RH neutrino mass spectrum that results into a final asymmetry dominantly produced by th…
▽ More
We extend the results of a previous analysis of ours showing that, when both heavy and light flavour effects are taken into account, successful minimal (type I + thermal) leptogenesis with SO(10)-inspired relations is possible. Barring fine tuned choices of the parameters, these relations enforce a hierarchical RH neutrino mass spectrum that results into a final asymmetry dominantly produced by the next-to-lightest RH neutrino decays (N_2 dominated leptogenesis). We present the constraints on the whole set of low energy neutrino parameters. Allowing a small misalignment between the Dirac basis and the charged lepton basis as in the quark sector, the allowed regions enlarge and the lower bound on the reheating temperature gets relaxed to values as low as ~ 10^10 GeV. It is confirmed that for normal ordering (NO) there are two allowed ranges of values for the lightest neutrino mass: m_1 \simeq (1-5)\times 10^-3 eV and m_1\simeq (0.03-0.1) eV. For m_1\lesssim 0.01 eV the allowed region in the plane theta_13-theta_23 is approximately bounded by 44 + 3(theta_13-9) \lesssim theta_23 \lesssim 48 + 0.4 (theta_13-5), while the neutrinoless double beta decay effective neutrino mass falls in the range m_ee=(1-3)10^-3 eV for theta_13=(6 -11.5). For m_1 \gtrsim 0.01 eV, one has quite sharply m_ee\simeq m_1 and an upper bound theta_23 \lesssim 46 . These constraints will be tested by low energy neutrino experiments during next years. We also find that inverted ordering (IO), though quite strongly constrained, is not completely ruled out. In particular, we find approximately theta_23 \simeq 43 +12 log(0.2 eV/m_1), that will be fully tested by future experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2011; v1 submitted 10 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Radiative Inflation and Dark Energy
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Stephen F. King,
Christoph Luhn,
Alexander Merle,
Angnis Schmidt-May
Abstract:
We propose a model based on radiative symmetry breaking that combines inflation with Dark Energy and is consistent with the WMAP 7-year regions. The radiative inflationary potential leads to the prediction of a spectral index 0.955 \lesssim n_S \lesssim 0.967 and a tensor to scalar ratio 0.142 \lesssim r \lesssim 0.186, both consistent with current data but testable by the Planck experiment. The r…
▽ More
We propose a model based on radiative symmetry breaking that combines inflation with Dark Energy and is consistent with the WMAP 7-year regions. The radiative inflationary potential leads to the prediction of a spectral index 0.955 \lesssim n_S \lesssim 0.967 and a tensor to scalar ratio 0.142 \lesssim r \lesssim 0.186, both consistent with current data but testable by the Planck experiment. The radiative symmetry breaking close to the Planck scale gives rise to a pseudo Nambu-Goldstone boson with a gravitationally suppressed mass which can naturally play the role of a quintessence field responsible for Dark Energy. Finally, we present a possible extra dimensional scenario in which our model could be realised.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2011; v1 submitted 27 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
The problem of the initial conditions in flavoured leptogenesis and the tauon N_2-dominated scenario
Authors:
Enrico Bertuzzo,
Pasquale Di Bari,
Luca Marzola
Abstract:
We discuss the conditions to realize a scenario of strong thermal leptogenesis, where the final asymmetry is fully independent of the initial conditions, when both heavy and light flavor effects are taken into account. In particular the contribution to the final asymmetry from a residual initial pre-existing asymmetry has to be negligible. We show that in the case of a hierarchical right-handed (R…
▽ More
We discuss the conditions to realize a scenario of strong thermal leptogenesis, where the final asymmetry is fully independent of the initial conditions, when both heavy and light flavor effects are taken into account. In particular the contribution to the final asymmetry from a residual initial pre-existing asymmetry has to be negligible. We show that in the case of a hierarchical right-handed (RH) neutrino mass spectrum, the only possible way is a N_2-dominated leptogenesis scenario with a lightest RH neutrino mass M_1 << 10^9 GeV and with a next-to-lightest RH neutrino mass 10^12 GeV >> M_2 >> 10^9 GeV. This scenario necessarily requires the presence of a heaviest third RH neutrino specie. Moreover, we show that the final asymmetry has to be dominantly produced in the tauon flavour while the electron and the muon asymmetries have to be efficiently washed out by the lightest RH neutrino inverse processes. Intriguingly, such seemingly special conditions for successful strong thermal leptogenesis are naturally fulfilled within SO(10)-inspired models. Besides the tauon N_2-dominated scenario, successful strong thermal leptogenesis is also achieved in scenarios with quasi-degenerate RH neutrino masses. We also comment on the supersymmetric case. We also derive an expression for the final asymmetry produced from leptogenesis taking fully into account heavy neutrino flavour effects in the specific case $M_1\gg 10^{12}\,{\rm GeV}$ (heavy flavoured scenario), a result that can be extended to any other mass pattern.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2011; v1 submitted 9 July, 2010;
originally announced July 2010.
-
A fuller flavour treatment of N_2-dominated leptogenesis
Authors:
Stefan Antusch,
Pasquale Di Bari,
David A. Jones,
Steve F. King
Abstract:
We discuss N_2-dominated leptogenesis in the presence of flavour dependent effects that have hitherto been neglected, in particular the off-diagonal entries of the flavour coupling matrix that connects the total flavour asymmetries, distributed in different particle species, to the lepton and Higgs doublet asymmetries. We derive analytical formulae for the final asymmetry including the flavour cou…
▽ More
We discuss N_2-dominated leptogenesis in the presence of flavour dependent effects that have hitherto been neglected, in particular the off-diagonal entries of the flavour coupling matrix that connects the total flavour asymmetries, distributed in different particle species, to the lepton and Higgs doublet asymmetries. We derive analytical formulae for the final asymmetry including the flavour coupling at the N_2-decay stage as well as at the stage of washout by the lightest right-handed neutrino N_1. Moreover, we point out that in general part of the electron and muon asymmetries (phantom terms), can completely escape the wash-out at the production and a total B-L asymmetry can be generated by the lightest RH neutrino wash-out yielding so called phantom leptogenesis. However, the phantom terms are proportional to the initial N_2 abundance and in particular they vanish for initial zero N_2-abundance. Taking any of these new effects into account can significantly modify the final asymmetry produced by the decays of the next-to-lightest RH neutrinos, opening up new interesting possibilities for N_2-dominated thermal leptogenesis.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2012; v1 submitted 26 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
Flavor symmetries, leptogenesis and the absolute neutrino mass scale
Authors:
E. Bertuzzo,
P. Di Bari,
F. Feruglio,
E. Nardi
Abstract:
We study the interplay between flavor symmetries and leptogenesis in the case when the scale of flavor symmetry breaking is higher than the scale at which lepton number is violated. We show that when the heavy Majorana neutrinos belong to an irreducible representation of the flavor group, all the leptogenesis CP asymmetries vanish in the limit of exact symmetry. In the case of reducible represen…
▽ More
We study the interplay between flavor symmetries and leptogenesis in the case when the scale of flavor symmetry breaking is higher than the scale at which lepton number is violated. We show that when the heavy Majorana neutrinos belong to an irreducible representation of the flavor group, all the leptogenesis CP asymmetries vanish in the limit of exact symmetry. In the case of reducible representations we identify a general condition that, if satisfied, guarantees the same result. We then focus on the case of a model in which an $A_4$ flavor symmetry yields a drastic reduction in the number of free parameters, implying that at leading order several quantities are only a function of the lightest neutrino mass $m_l$, which in turn is strongly constrained. For normal ordering (NO) we find m_l\simeq (0.0044 ÷0.0056) eV while for inverted ordering (IO) m_l\gtrsim 0.017 eV. For the 0\nu2βdecay parameter this yields |m_{ee}|\simeq (0.006÷0.007) eV (NO) and |m_{ee}|\gsim 0.017 eV (IO). We show that the leptogenesis CP asymmetries only depend on m_l, on a single non-hierarchical Yukawa coupling y, and on two parameters that quantify the flavor symmetry breaking effects, and we argue that the unflavored regime for leptogenesis is strongly preferred in our model, thus realizing a rather predictive scenario. Performing a calculation of the matter-antimatter asymmetry we find that for NO the observed value is easily reproduced for natural values of the symmetry breaking parameters. For IO successful leptogenesis is possible for a limited choice of the parameters implying rather large reheating temperatures T_reh\gtrsim 5*10^13 GeV.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2009; v1 submitted 3 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
-
Cold Dark Matter from heavy Right-Handed neutrino mixing
Authors:
Alexey Anisimov,
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
We show that, within the see-saw mechanism, an almost decoupled RH neutrino species N_DM with mass M_DM \gtrsim 100 GeV can play the role of Dark Matter (DM). The N_DM's can be produced from non-adiabatic conversions of thermalized (source) RH neutrinos with mass M_S lower than M_DM. This is possible if a non-renormalizable operator is added to the minimal type I see-saw lagrangian. The observed…
▽ More
We show that, within the see-saw mechanism, an almost decoupled RH neutrino species N_DM with mass M_DM \gtrsim 100 GeV can play the role of Dark Matter (DM). The N_DM's can be produced from non-adiabatic conversions of thermalized (source) RH neutrinos with mass M_S lower than M_DM. This is possible if a non-renormalizable operator is added to the minimal type I see-saw lagrangian. The observed DM abundance can be reproduced for M_DM δ^{1/4} \sim 10^-13 Λ_eff ξ, where Λ_eff is a very high energy new physics scale, δ\equiv (M_DM-M_S)/M_DM and ξ\lesssim 1 is a parameter determined by the RH neutrino couplings.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2009; v1 submitted 30 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
-
Successful type I Leptogenesis with SO(10)-inspired mass relations
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari,
Antonio Riotto
Abstract:
It is well-known that thermal leptogenesis through the decays of the lightest right-handed neutrinos encounters serious difficulties when SO(10)-inspired mass conditions are imposed on the Dirac neutrino mass matrix and light neutrino masses are generated through the type I see-saw mechanism. We show that these can be circumvented when the production from the next-to-lightest right-handed neutri…
▽ More
It is well-known that thermal leptogenesis through the decays of the lightest right-handed neutrinos encounters serious difficulties when SO(10)-inspired mass conditions are imposed on the Dirac neutrino mass matrix and light neutrino masses are generated through the type I see-saw mechanism. We show that these can be circumvented when the production from the next-to-lightest right-handed neutrinos and flavor effects are properly taken into account. Some conditions on the low energy parameters have to be satisfied in order for inverse processes involving the lightest right-handed neutrino not to wash-out the asymmetry. In particular we find m_1 \gtrsim 0.001 eV, where m_1 is the mass of the lightest left-handed neutrino and that non-vanishing values of the mixing angle theta_13 are preferred in the case of a normal fully hierarchical spectrum of light neutrinos.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2008;
originally announced September 2008.
-
New aspects of leptogenesis bounds
Authors:
Steve Blanchet,
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
We present a general analysis that reveals new aspects of the leptogenesis bounds on neutrino masses and on the reheat temperature of the Universe. After revisiting a known effect coming from an unbounded term in the total CP asymmetry, we show that an unbounded term in the flavored CP asymmetries has a stronger impact. It relaxes the lower bound on the reheat temperature down to 10^8 GeV for (M…
▽ More
We present a general analysis that reveals new aspects of the leptogenesis bounds on neutrino masses and on the reheat temperature of the Universe. After revisiting a known effect coming from an unbounded term in the total CP asymmetry, we show that an unbounded term in the flavored CP asymmetries has a stronger impact. It relaxes the lower bound on the reheat temperature down to 10^8 GeV for (M_2-M_1)/M_1=O(1-100) and for a mild tuning of the parameters in the see-saw orthogonal matrix. We also consider the effect of the Higgs asymmetry, showing that it lowers the upper bound on the neutrino masses in the so-called fully flavored regime where classic Boltzmann equations can be used. Imposing independence of the initial conditions contributes to lower the upper bound on neutrino masses as well. We study the conditions for the validity of the usual N_1-dominated scenario and for the applicability of the lower bound on the lightest right-handed (RH) neutrino mass M_1. We find that except for the two effective RH neutrino scenario, recovered for M_3 >>10^14 GeV, and for values M_2 < O(10^11 GeV), the final asymmetry is more naturally dominated by the contribution from N_2-decays. Finally, we confirm in a general way that going beyond the hierarchical limit, the effect of washout addition makes the lower bound on M_1 more stringent for (M_2-M_1)/M_1=O(0.1).
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2008; v1 submitted 7 July, 2008;
originally announced July 2008.
-
Viability of Dirac phase leptogenesis
Authors:
Alexey Anisimov,
Steve Blanchet,
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
We discuss the conditions for a non-vanishing Dirac phase δand mixing angle θ_{13}, sources of CP violation in neutrino oscillations, to be uniquely responsible for the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe through leptogenesis. We show that this scenario, that we call δ-leptogenesis, is viable when the degenerate limit (DL) for the heavy right-handed (RH) neutrino spectrum is con…
▽ More
We discuss the conditions for a non-vanishing Dirac phase δand mixing angle θ_{13}, sources of CP violation in neutrino oscillations, to be uniquely responsible for the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe through leptogenesis. We show that this scenario, that we call δ-leptogenesis, is viable when the degenerate limit (DL) for the heavy right-handed (RH) neutrino spectrum is considered. We derive an interesting joint condition on \sinθ_{13} and the absolute neutrino mass scale that can be tested in future neutrino oscillation experiments. In the limit of hierarchical heavy RH neutrino spectrum (HL), we strengthen the previous result that δ-leptogenesis is only very marginally allowed, even when the production from the two heavier RH neutrinos is taken into account. An improved experimental upper bound on \sinθ_{13} and (or) an account of quantum kinetic effects could completely rule out this option in the future. Therefore, δ-leptogenesis can be also regarded as a motivation for models with degenerate heavy neutrino spectrum.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2008; v1 submitted 20 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
-
Flavor effects in thermal leptogenesis
Authors:
Steve Blanchet,
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
We review recent developments in leptogenesis on flavor effects. Their account discloses an important connection between the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the Universe and CP violation at low energies. Besides, they modify the upper bound on the neutrino masses holding in the unflavored case. In this respect, it is important to identify the exact condition for flavor effects to be relevant and…
▽ More
We review recent developments in leptogenesis on flavor effects. Their account discloses an important connection between the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the Universe and CP violation at low energies. Besides, they modify the upper bound on the neutrino masses holding in the unflavored case. In this respect, it is important to identify the exact condition for flavor effects to be relevant and for the `fully flavored' Boltzmann equations to be valid.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2007;
originally announced February 2007.
-
Quantum Zeno effect and the impact of flavor in leptogenesis
Authors:
S. Blanchet,
P. Di Bari,
G. G. Raffelt
Abstract:
In thermal leptogenesis, the cosmic matter-antimatter asymmetry is produced by CP violation in the decays N --> l + Φof heavy right-handed Majorana neutrinos N into ordinary leptons l and Higgs particles Φ. If some charged-lepton Yukawa couplings are in equilibrium during the leptogenesis epoch, the l interactions with the background medium are flavor sensitive and the coherence of their flavor…
▽ More
In thermal leptogenesis, the cosmic matter-antimatter asymmetry is produced by CP violation in the decays N --> l + Φof heavy right-handed Majorana neutrinos N into ordinary leptons l and Higgs particles Φ. If some charged-lepton Yukawa couplings are in equilibrium during the leptogenesis epoch, the l interactions with the background medium are flavor sensitive and the coherence of their flavor content defined by N --> l+Φis destroyed, modifying the efficiency of the inverse decays. We point out, however, that it is not enough that the flavor-sensitive processes are fast on the cosmic expansion time scale, they must be fast relative to the N <--> l +Φreactions lest the flavor amplitudes of l remain frozen by the repeated N <--> l+Φ``measurements''. Our more restrictive requirement is significant in the most interesting ``strong wash-out case'' where N <--> l +Φis fast relative to the cosmic expansion rate. We derive conditions for the unflavored treatment to be adequate and for flavor effects to be maximal. In this ``fully flavored regime'' a neutrino mass bound survives. To decide if this bound can be circumvented in the intermediate case, a full quantum kinetic treatment is required.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2006;
originally announced November 2006.
-
Flavor effects on leptogenesis predictions
Authors:
Steve Blanchet,
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
Flavor effects in leptogenesis reduce the region of the see-saw parameter space where the final predictions do not depend on the initial conditions, the strong wash-out regime. In this case we show that the lowest bounds holding on the lightest right-handed (RH) neutrino mass and on the reheating temperature for hierarchical heavy neutrinos, do not get relaxed compared to the usual ones in the o…
▽ More
Flavor effects in leptogenesis reduce the region of the see-saw parameter space where the final predictions do not depend on the initial conditions, the strong wash-out regime. In this case we show that the lowest bounds holding on the lightest right-handed (RH) neutrino mass and on the reheating temperature for hierarchical heavy neutrinos, do not get relaxed compared to the usual ones in the one-flavor approximation, M_1 (T_reh) \gtrsim 3 (1.5) x 10^9 GeV. Flavor effects can however relax down to these minimal values the lower bounds holding for fixed large values of the decay parameter K_1. We discuss a relevant definite example showing that, when the known information on the neutrino mixing matrix is employed, the lower bounds for K_1 \gg 10, are relaxed by a factor 2-3 for light hierarchical neutrinos, without any dependence on θ_13 and on possible phases. On the other hand, going beyond the limit of light hierarchical neutrinos and taking into account Majorana phases, the lower bounds can be relaxed by one order of magnitude. Therefore, Majorana phases can play an important role in leptogenesis when flavor effects are included.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2007; v1 submitted 31 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
-
Leptogenesis beyond the limit of hierarchical heavy neutrino masses
Authors:
Steve Blanchet,
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
We calculate the baryon asymmetry of the Universe in thermal leptogenesis beyond the usual lightest right-handed (RH) neutrino dominated scenario (N_1DS) and in particular beyond the hierarchical limit (HL), M_1 << M_2 << M_3, for the RH neutrino mass spectrum. After providing some orientation among the large variety of models, we first revisit the central role of the N_1DS, with new insights on…
▽ More
We calculate the baryon asymmetry of the Universe in thermal leptogenesis beyond the usual lightest right-handed (RH) neutrino dominated scenario (N_1DS) and in particular beyond the hierarchical limit (HL), M_1 << M_2 << M_3, for the RH neutrino mass spectrum. After providing some orientation among the large variety of models, we first revisit the central role of the N_1DS, with new insights on the dynamics of the asymmetry generation and then discuss the main routes departing from it, focusing on models beyond the HL. We study in detail two examples of `strong-strong' wash-out scenarios: one with `maximal phase' and the limit of very large M_3, studying the effects arising when delta_2=(M_2-M_1)/M_1 is small. We extend analytical methods already applied to the N_1DS showing, for example, that, in the degenerate limit (DL), the efficiency factors of the RH neutrinos become equal with the single decay parameter replaced by the sum. Both cases disprove the misconception that close RH neutrino masses necessarily lead to a final asymmetry enhancement and to a relaxation of the lower bounds on M_1 and on the initial temperature of the radiation-dominated expansion. We also explain why leptogenesis tends to favor normal hierarchy compared to inverted hierarchy for the left-handed neutrino masses.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2006; v1 submitted 15 March, 2006;
originally announced March 2006.
-
Seesaw geometry and leptogenesis
Authors:
Pasquale Di Bari
Abstract:
The representation of the seesaw orthogonal matrix in the complex plane establishes a graphical correspondence between neutrino mass models and geometrical configurations, particularly useful to study relevant aspects of leptogenesis. We first derive the CP asymmetry bound for hierarchical heavy neutrinos and then an expression for the effective leptogenesis phase, determining the conditions for…
▽ More
The representation of the seesaw orthogonal matrix in the complex plane establishes a graphical correspondence between neutrino mass models and geometrical configurations, particularly useful to study relevant aspects of leptogenesis. We first derive the CP asymmetry bound for hierarchical heavy neutrinos and then an expression for the effective leptogenesis phase, determining the conditions for maximal phase and placing a lower bound on the phase suppression for generic models. Reconsidering the lower bounds on the lightest right-handed (RH) neutrino mass M_1 and on the reheating temperature T_reh, we find that models where one of the two heavier neutrino masses is dominated by the lightest right-handed (RH) neutrinos, typically arising from connections with quark masses, undergo both phase suppression and strong wash-out such that M_1 (T_reh)\gtrsim 10^{11} (10^{10}) GeV. The window 10^9 GeV \lesssim M_1,T_reh \lesssim 10^{10}GeV is accessible only for a class of models where m_1 is dominated by the lightest RH neutrino, with no straightforward connections with quark masses. Within this class we describe a new scenario of thermal leptogenesis where the baryon asymmetry of the Universe is generated by the decays of the second lightest RH neutrino, such that the lower bound on M_1 disappears and is replaced by a lower bound on M_2. Interestingly, the final asymmetry is independent on the initial conditions. We also discuss the validity of the approximation of hierarchical heavy neutrinos in a simple analytical way.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2005; v1 submitted 8 February, 2005;
originally announced February 2005.
-
Leptogenesis, neutrino mixing data and the absolute neutrino mass scale
Authors:
P. Di Bari
Abstract:
Recent developments in thermal leptogenesis are reviewed. Neutrino mixing data favor a simple picture where the matter-anti matter asymmetry is generated by the decays of the heavy RH neutrinos mildly close to thermal equilibrium and, remarkably, in the full non relativistic regime. This results into predictions of the final baryon asymmetry not depending on the initial conditions and with minim…
▽ More
Recent developments in thermal leptogenesis are reviewed. Neutrino mixing data favor a simple picture where the matter-anti matter asymmetry is generated by the decays of the heavy RH neutrinos mildly close to thermal equilibrium and, remarkably, in the full non relativistic regime. This results into predictions of the final baryon asymmetry not depending on the initial conditions and with minimized theoretical uncertainties. After a short outline of a geometrical derivation of the CP asymmetry bound, we derive analytic bounds on the lightest RH neutrino mass and on the absolute neutrino mass scale. Neutrino masses larger than 0.1 eV are not compatible with the minimal leptogenesis scenario. We discuss how the results get just slightly modified within the minimal supersymmetric standard model. In particular a conservative lower bound on the reheating temperature, T_R \gtrsim 10^9 GeV, is obtained in the relevant effective neutrino mass range tilde{m}_1 \gtrsim 3x10^{-3} eV. We also comment on the existence of a `too-short-blanket problem' in connection with the possibility of evading the leptogenesis neutrino mass bound.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2004;
originally announced June 2004.
-
Some Aspects of Thermal Leptogenesis
Authors:
W. Buchmuller,
P. Di Bari,
M. Plumacher
Abstract:
Properties of neutrinos may be the origin of the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe. In the seesaw model for neutrino masses this leads to important constraints on the properties of light and heavy neutrinos. In particular, an upper bound on the light neutrino masses of 0.1 eV can be derived. We review the present status of thermal leptogenesis with emphasis on the theoretical uncertain…
▽ More
Properties of neutrinos may be the origin of the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe. In the seesaw model for neutrino masses this leads to important constraints on the properties of light and heavy neutrinos. In particular, an upper bound on the light neutrino masses of 0.1 eV can be derived. We review the present status of thermal leptogenesis with emphasis on the theoretical uncertainties and discuss some implications for lepton and quark mass hierarchies, CP violation and dark matter. We also comment on the `leptogenesis conspiracy', the remarkable fact that neutrino masses may lie in the range where leptogenesis works best.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2004;
originally announced June 2004.