-
The properties of FR0 radio galaxies as intermediate objects in the evolution of radio galaxies
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Chandra B. Singh,
Eddie Harmon,
Michael Williams,
Luis Rojas Castillo
Abstract:
The counter-rotation between black holes and accretion disk configuration was introduced over a decade ago to elucidate the nature of the radio loud/radio-quiet dichotomy and the jet-disk connection, but has since been applied to a plethora of observations across space and time. We briefly review the paradigm in which counter-rotation is key for the triggering of radio galaxies and its observation…
▽ More
The counter-rotation between black holes and accretion disk configuration was introduced over a decade ago to elucidate the nature of the radio loud/radio-quiet dichotomy and the jet-disk connection, but has since been applied to a plethora of observations across space and time. We briefly review the paradigm in which counter-rotation is key for the triggering of radio galaxies and its observational support, then apply it to a series of observations concerning FR0 radio galaxies. FR0 radio galaxies appear to be radio galaxies in transition, with low-spinning black holes and thus weaker but tilted jets with respect to an earlier radio quasar phase. As a result, FR0 radio galaxies are prescribed to be in an earlier phase of star formation suppression in radio galaxies, compared to a later phase that is unlikely to be less than tens of millions of years in the future if they have enough accretion fuel to evolve into more powerful FRI radio galaxies. FR0 radio galaxies will have a greater or lesser star formation suppression feedback effect depending on how long they live. Tilted jets also enhance stellar velocities in the bulge. Because FR0 jet lengths are of the same order of magnitude as the radius of the stellar bulge, FR0 jets are prescribed to have begun, more or less recently depending on their age, to affect stellar velocity dispersions as well. As a result, they will be associated with dispersion values that tend to be larger than for characteristically non-jetted active galaxies, but smaller than giant radio galaxies such as M87 that have experienced a long-term tilted and more powerful FRI jet. With these ideas it is possible to make a coarse-grained prediction for the slope of the M-σ plane for FR0 radio galaxies with values between 4 and 8.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
The massive black holes, high accretion rates, and non-tilted jet feedback, of jetted AGN triggered by secular processes
Authors:
Chandra B. Singh,
David Garofalo
Abstract:
That jetted active galactic nuclei (AGN) are also hosted in spiral galaxies is now well established. Our understanding of how such objects might fit in the radio loud AGN subclass has been described by Foschini and others over the past decade in that jets in spirals are weaker than those of radio galaxies and quasars because the black holes in spirals tend to be less massive. Recent data, however,…
▽ More
That jetted active galactic nuclei (AGN) are also hosted in spiral galaxies is now well established. Our understanding of how such objects might fit in the radio loud AGN subclass has been described by Foschini and others over the past decade in that jets in spirals are weaker than those of radio galaxies and quasars because the black holes in spirals tend to be less massive. Recent data, however, may be pointing to a different picture which we describe. Unlike powerful jetted AGN in ellipticals, we illustrate from model perspectives, features of jets in spirals responsible for limiting both their power as well as their effect on their host galaxies. AGN triggered by secular processes fail to generate jet re-orientation, a key ingredient in the jetted AGN feedback mechanism in merger-triggered ellipticals that leads to the red-and-dead radio galaxies at low redshift such as M87. As a result, jetted AGN in spirals tend to live in a separate part of the parameter space compared to radio galaxies and quasars. Because of the absence of jet reorientation and due to the relatively short-lived jet phases, jetted AGN in spirals are best compared to radio quiet or jetless AGN than any other jetted AGN subclass.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Advanced life peaked billions of years ago according to black holes
Authors:
David Garofalo
Abstract:
The link between black holes and star formation allows us to draw a connection between black holes and the places and times extraterrestrial intelligences (ETIs) had a greater chance of emerging. Within the context of the gap paradigm for black holes, we show that denser cluster environments that led to gas rich mergers and copious star formation were places less compatible on average with the eme…
▽ More
The link between black holes and star formation allows us to draw a connection between black holes and the places and times extraterrestrial intelligences (ETIs) had a greater chance of emerging. Within the context of the gap paradigm for black holes, we show that denser cluster environments that led to gas rich mergers and copious star formation were places less compatible on average with the emergence of ETIs compared to isolated elliptical galaxies by almost two orders of magnitude. The probability for ETIs peaked in these isolated environments around 6 billion years ago and cosmic downsizing shifted the likelihood of ETIs emerging to galaxies with weak black hole feedback, such as in spiral galaxies, at late times.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Counter-rotating black holes from FRII lifetimes
Authors:
David Garofalo
Abstract:
Estimates suggest that while FRII jets appear to have lifetimes constrained to hundreds of millions of years, radio galaxies with FRI jets appear to be longer lived. We illustrate the nature of this time constraint from model perspectives, showing how compatibility between theory and data match in a way suggesting a key difference between active galaxies whose engines are characterized by accretio…
▽ More
Estimates suggest that while FRII jets appear to have lifetimes constrained to hundreds of millions of years, radio galaxies with FRI jets appear to be longer lived. We illustrate the nature of this time constraint from model perspectives, showing how compatibility between theory and data match in a way suggesting a key difference between active galaxies whose engines are characterized by accretion onto co-rotating versus counter-rotating black holes. We calculate a range of timescales for counter-rotating black holes for a range of accretion rates compatible with theory which we then compare to data. The validity of these timescales constitutes the most powerful recent piece of evidence for considering counter-rotation between black holes and accretion disks in high energy astrophysics.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
M-$σ$ relations across space and time
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Damian J. Christian,
Chase Hames,
Max North,
Keegan Thottam,
Samuel Nazaroff,
Alisaie Eckelbarger
Abstract:
Feedback from active galactic nuclei (AGN) has long been invoked to explain the correlation between black hole mass and stellar velocity dispersion (M-$σ$) discovered in low redshift galaxies. We describe the time evolution of AGN in the M-$σ$ plane based on our gap model (Garofalo, Evans \& Sambruna 2010) for black hole accretion and jet formation illustrating a fundamental difference between jet…
▽ More
Feedback from active galactic nuclei (AGN) has long been invoked to explain the correlation between black hole mass and stellar velocity dispersion (M-$σ$) discovered in low redshift galaxies. We describe the time evolution of AGN in the M-$σ$ plane based on our gap model (Garofalo, Evans \& Sambruna 2010) for black hole accretion and jet formation illustrating a fundamental difference between jetted and non-jetted AGN. While the latter tend to evolve diagonally upward with black hole mass increasing along with stellar dispersion, we show that jetted AGN tend on average to move initially more upwards because their effect on velocity dispersion is weaker than for non-jetted AGN. But this initial phase is followed by a shift in the nature of the feedback, from positive to negative, a transition that is more dramatic on average in denser cluster environments. The feedback gets its kick from tilted jets which shut down star formation but increase velocity dispersion values. As this change in the nature of the feedback takes tens of millions to hundreds of millions of years, these cluster, merger-triggered jetted AGN, will evolve more upwards for up to order $10^{8}$ years, followed by an extremely long phase in which low excitation progressively slows black hole growth but dramatically affects stellar dispersion. As a result, powerful jetted AGN evolve for most of their lives almost horizontally on the M-$σ$ plane. The prediction is that strongest AGN feedback on stellar dispersion is a late universe phenomenon with M87 a good example. We show how jetted and non-jetted AGN parallel the Sersic and core-Sersic galaxy paths in the M-$σ$ plane found by Sahu et al (2019) and to a prediction that jetted quasars are not core-Sersic galaxies as found for lower redshift jetted AGN.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2023; v1 submitted 5 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Is jet re-orientation the elusive trigger for star formation suppression in radio galaxies?
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Emily Moravec,
Duccio Macconi,
Chandra B. Singh
Abstract:
Jet re-orientation associated with the time evolution of radio quasars explains the formation of X-shaped radio galaxies and their preference for isolated environments. But since X-shaped radio galaxies are generally not found in dense environments (e.g. groups/clusters), the jet re-orientation phenomenon for radio galaxies in groups and clusters has been ignored. We take a closer look at the re-o…
▽ More
Jet re-orientation associated with the time evolution of radio quasars explains the formation of X-shaped radio galaxies and their preference for isolated environments. But since X-shaped radio galaxies are generally not found in dense environments (e.g. groups/clusters), the jet re-orientation phenomenon for radio galaxies in groups and clusters has been ignored. We take a closer look at the re-orientation of FRI jets with respect to FRII jets, and find that it may constitute the as-yet unidentified trigger for star formation suppression in radio galaxies. We show how the recently explored radio "red geyser" galaxies can be interpreted in this context and ultimately reveal a deeper understanding of why FRII radio galaxies are on one side of the star formation enhancement/suppression divide compared to FRI radio galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Peculiar black hole accretion rates in AGN with highest star formation rates in the universe
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Ektoras Pouliasis
Abstract:
Pouliasis et al (2022b) explored star formation rates, black hole accretion rates, and stellar mass of active galaxies at redshift above 3.5, uncovering a leveling off of the star formation rate at high stellar mass, which they consider to be evidence of AGN feedback. Their data shows that as AGN approach the flattening of the curve in the star formation rate - stellar mass plane, the accretion ra…
▽ More
Pouliasis et al (2022b) explored star formation rates, black hole accretion rates, and stellar mass of active galaxies at redshift above 3.5, uncovering a leveling off of the star formation rate at high stellar mass, which they consider to be evidence of AGN feedback. Their data shows that as AGN approach the flattening of the curve in the star formation rate - stellar mass plane, the accretion rates begin to drop. We describe the nature of the AGN feedback responsible for this in terms of powerful FRII jets enhancing star formation rates but eventually also triggering a shift in accretion from near-Eddington rates to advection dominated. These systems are on the cusp of a dramatic transition where the active galaxy goes from strong enhancement to large suppression of star formation in a way that produces the steeper slope for radio AGN at low redshift compared to radio AGN at higher redshift and to jetless AGN. We argue, therefore, that the data of Pouliasis et al constitute the high redshift objects predicted by Singh et al (2021) that connect to the low redshift behavior of radio AGN shown in Comerford et al (2020).
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
The unusual active galaxy H1821+643 and the elusive nature of FRI quasars
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Chandra B. Singh
Abstract:
The moderate spin estimate for the black hole at the center of the cool core cluster H1821+643 motivates the completion of a story about this object's origin and evolution that was in the making since the work by Blundell and Rawlings over two decades ago as the first example of a massive black hole accreting at near Eddington rates with an FRI jet. This elusive combination of properties was expla…
▽ More
The moderate spin estimate for the black hole at the center of the cool core cluster H1821+643 motivates the completion of a story about this object's origin and evolution that was in the making since the work by Blundell and Rawlings over two decades ago as the first example of a massive black hole accreting at near Eddington rates with an FRI jet. This elusive combination of properties was explained in our 2010 model where we showed it to be part of a small parameter space that includes X shaped radio galaxies. As an accreting black hole that never experienced a counterrotating phase, H1821+643 is constrained by theory to produce a jet for spin values between 0.1 and about 0.7 and an FRI jet for a slightly smaller range. The feedback from such a black hole is not subject to a tilted jet and is why star formation rates remain high in this cluster environment. The prediction is that H1821+643 is within millions of years of becoming jetless.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
The distribution of radio quiet active galactic nuclei in the star formation-stellar mass plane
Authors:
D. Garofalo,
G. Mountrichas
Abstract:
That active galactic nuclei (AGN) with jets can alternately enhance as well as suppress star formation rates, explains the location and slope of radio loud AGN on the star formation rate-stellar mass plane. Here, we explore 860 type 1 and 2 AGN at z<0.2 from the ROSAT-2XRS survey in order to understand both different location and lower slopes for non-jetted AGN in the star formation rate-stellar m…
▽ More
That active galactic nuclei (AGN) with jets can alternately enhance as well as suppress star formation rates, explains the location and slope of radio loud AGN on the star formation rate-stellar mass plane. Here, we explore 860 type 1 and 2 AGN at z<0.2 from the ROSAT-2XRS survey in order to understand both different location and lower slopes for non-jetted AGN in the star formation rate-stellar mass plane. We describe the nature of these differences in terms of different degrees of black hole feedback, with relatively weak negative feedback from non-jetted AGN compared to both relatively strong positive and negative feedback from jetted AGN. The validity of these ideas brings us a step closer towards understanding the black hole scaling relation across space and time.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Low Frequency Quasi Periodic Oscillations and Shocks in Accretion onto Black Hole
Authors:
Chandra B. Singh,
Santanu Mondal,
David Garofalo
Abstract:
Low-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (LFQPOs) have been routinely observed in black hole X-ray binaries (BHXRBs). These LFQPOs can be explained by axisymmetric shock oscillation in accretion flow around a rotating black hole. We address the physical origin of Type-C LFQPOs in BHXRBs observed by the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer satellite considering a minimum number of free parameters, namely,…
▽ More
Low-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (LFQPOs) have been routinely observed in black hole X-ray binaries (BHXRBs). These LFQPOs can be explained by axisymmetric shock oscillation in accretion flow around a rotating black hole. We address the physical origin of Type-C LFQPOs in BHXRBs observed by the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer satellite considering a minimum number of free parameters, namely, specific energy and specific angular momentum of the infalling matter for a given set of BH mass and spin parameter. We apply the solution for a large number of BH candidates to further strengthen the scenario of an anti-correlation between the QPO frequency and the location of the shock. Our study also confirms that Compton cooling can be sufficient to explain the observed QPOs.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
The astrophysics of rotational energy extraction from a black hole
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Chandra B. Singh
Abstract:
Recent work has called into question whether nature can extract the rotational energy of a black hole via electromagnetic fields by appealing to an alleged ability to absorb current. We describe the strategies needed to properly treat the astrophysics in curved spacetime near black holes, showing that while the Blandford-Znajek effect is sound, the deeper nature of the electric nature of black hol…
▽ More
Recent work has called into question whether nature can extract the rotational energy of a black hole via electromagnetic fields by appealing to an alleged ability to absorb current. We describe the strategies needed to properly treat the astrophysics in curved spacetime near black holes, showing that while the Blandford-Znajek effect is sound, the deeper nature of the electric nature of black holes remains unresolved.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
The black hole-star formation connection over cosmic time
Authors:
Chandra B. Singh,
Nelitha Kulasiri,
Max North,
David Garofalo
Abstract:
Observations at low redshift have begun to tease out the star formation rate in active galaxies (AGN), which marks the beginning of the black hole-star formation connection over cosmic time. Star formation appears to depend on AGN type, cluster richness, and black hole accretion, but in ways that are not direct and have yet to be understood. Much of the confusion is that while some AGN appear to e…
▽ More
Observations at low redshift have begun to tease out the star formation rate in active galaxies (AGN), which marks the beginning of the black hole-star formation connection over cosmic time. Star formation appears to depend on AGN type, cluster richness, and black hole accretion, but in ways that are not direct and have yet to be understood. Much of the confusion is that while some AGN appear to enhance star formation, others seem to suppress it. By implementing simplified, yet informed assumptions about AGN feedback on star formation, we show how AGN with jets might be dominated by two phases in which star formation is first enhanced, then suppressed. With this new element incorporated into our model, we make sense of radio and quasar mode behavior in the star formation rate-stellar mass (SFR-SM) plane for AGN. Due to jet feedback on star formation, jetted AGN tend to move upwards and rightward in the SFR-SM plane and then downward and to the right, past both the star-forming main sequence (SFMS) as well as the radio-quiet AGN. This picture allows us to predict the black hole connection to star formation as a function of the environment over the history of the universe.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Powerful Jets from Radiatively Efficient Disks, a Decades-Old Unresolved Problem in High Energy Astrophysics
Authors:
Chandra B. Singh,
David Garofalo,
Benjamin Lang
Abstract:
The discovery of 3C 273 in 1963, and the emergence of the Kerr solution shortly thereafter, precipitated the current era in astrophysics focused on using black holes to explain active galactic nuclei (AGN). But while partial success was achieved in separately explaining the bright nuclei of some AGN via thin disks, as well as powerful jets with thick disks, the combination of both powerful jets in…
▽ More
The discovery of 3C 273 in 1963, and the emergence of the Kerr solution shortly thereafter, precipitated the current era in astrophysics focused on using black holes to explain active galactic nuclei (AGN). But while partial success was achieved in separately explaining the bright nuclei of some AGN via thin disks, as well as powerful jets with thick disks, the combination of both powerful jets in an AGN with a bright nucleus, such as in 3C 273, remained elusive. Although numerical simulations have taken center stage in the last 25 years, they have struggled to produce the conditions that explain them. This is because radiatively efficient disks have proved a challenge to simulate. Radio quasars have thus been the least understood objects in high energy astrophysics. But recent simulations have begun to change this. We explore this milestone in light of scale-invariance and show that transitory jets, possibly related to the jets seen in these recent simulations, as some have proposed, cannot explain radio quasars. We then provide a road map for a resolution.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
The emergence of the X-ray luminosity/cluster richness relation for radio galaxies
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Chandra B. Singh
Abstract:
The idea that mergers are more likely in dense groups or clusters coupled with the assumption that such events lead to cold gas flows onto black holes, suggests a direct relationship between the radiative efficiency of an active galactic nucleus and environmental richness. Observations, however, increasingly challenge this and other basic expectations. Mounting evidence, for example, shows an inve…
▽ More
The idea that mergers are more likely in dense groups or clusters coupled with the assumption that such events lead to cold gas flows onto black holes, suggests a direct relationship between the radiative efficiency of an active galactic nucleus and environmental richness. Observations, however, increasingly challenge this and other basic expectations. Mounting evidence, for example, shows an inverse trend between near-Eddington accreting objects and environmental richness. Broken down by radio galaxy subgroup, recent work has explored connections between low excitation radio galaxies with Fanaroff-Riley II jet morphology (FRII LERGs) and other radio galaxies. We make contact with that work by adding a discussion of the recently discovered FR0 radio galaxies and show how to fit them in a picture in which FRII LERGs are not initial nor final phases in the lifetime of a radio galaxy, but de facto transition states. We describe how to understand the observed X-ray luminosity/cluster richness relation as a fundamental correlation on the nature of the jet-disk connection.
△ Less
Submitted 26 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Evidence for radio loud to radio quiet evolution from red and blue quasars
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Katie Bishop
Abstract:
Recent work on red and blue quasi-stellar objects (QSOs) has identified peculiar number distributions as a function of radio loudness that we explore and attempt to explain from the perspective of a picture in which a subset of the population of active galaxies evolves from the radio loud to the radio quiet state. Because the time evolution is slowed down by an order of magnitude or more for the r…
▽ More
Recent work on red and blue quasi-stellar objects (QSOs) has identified peculiar number distributions as a function of radio loudness that we explore and attempt to explain from the perspective of a picture in which a subset of the population of active galaxies evolves from the radio loud to the radio quiet state. Because the time evolution is slowed down by an order of magnitude or more for the radio quiet phase, the numbers of red and blue QSOs approach each other at the extreme end of the radio quiet range of radio loudness with larger numbers. The rapid time evolution of most radio loud phases, instead, makes the numbers similar but lower at the far radio loud end. At the midpoint of radio loudness, instead, the differences between red and blue QSOs experience their largest values which results from accretion rapidly spinning black holes down but subsequently spinning them up more slowly. Recovering these basic features of the observations is evidence for rapid evolution away from radio loudness and slow evolution in radio quiet states.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Spin of the M87 black hole
Authors:
David Garofalo
Abstract:
Spin measurement of the 6.5 billion solar mass black hole in M87 from the Event Horizon Telescope image is the latest in a series that span a wide range in values, but that tend to share the feature of co-rotation between the accretion flow and black hole. The spin paradigm for black holes predicts very high black hole spin which in that framework was produced in its last significant merger. High…
▽ More
Spin measurement of the 6.5 billion solar mass black hole in M87 from the Event Horizon Telescope image is the latest in a series that span a wide range in values, but that tend to share the feature of co-rotation between the accretion flow and black hole. The spin paradigm for black holes predicts very high black hole spin which in that framework was produced in its last significant merger. High black hole spin appears to be ruled out in the gap paradigm, however, which predicts early formation with a mass already in excess of 4 billion solar masses. In this picture, the black hole experienced slow evolution as it departed from its original radio quasar phase and over billions of years not only failed to double its mass but also fell short of regaining its original high spin, such that it is now compatible with a co-rotating accreting black hole whose dimensionless spin fits best in the range 0.2 < a < 0.5.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Why radio quiet quasars are preferred over radio loud quasars regardless of environment and redshift
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Max North,
Leanne Belga,
Kenzi Waddell
Abstract:
Evidence has accumulated suggesting the clustering of radio loud quasars is greater than for radio quiet quasars. We interpret these results in a context in which the fraction of radio loud quasar formation is less than or equal to that for radio quiet quasars for all environments and redshift. Because we assume that post-merger cold gas onto large black holes produces either a radio loud or a rad…
▽ More
Evidence has accumulated suggesting the clustering of radio loud quasars is greater than for radio quiet quasars. We interpret these results in a context in which the fraction of radio loud quasar formation is less than or equal to that for radio quiet quasars for all environments and redshift. Because we assume that post-merger cold gas onto large black holes produces either a radio loud or a radio quiet quasar, we show that for largest black hole masses that live in largest dark matter halos, fRLQ approaches 0.5 from below but does not exceed it, such that in rich clusters the formation of a radio loud quasar tends to be equally likely to occur as a radio quiet quasar. In dark matter halos with smaller mass, by contrast, radio quiet quasars are more likely to form and the likelihood increases inversely with dark matter halo mass. As a result, averaging over a population of radio loud and radio quiet quasars will necessarily generate lower average black hole masses for the radio quiet subgroup. Hence, despite the fact that the formation of radio quiet quasars is preferred over radio loud quasars in any environment, at any mass scale, at any luminosity, or redshift, averaging over a range of radio loud quasars will give the appearance they are preferred in cluster environments over radio quiet quasars. We show how this also accounts for the order of magnitude difference in the total number of jetted active galaxies compared to non-jetted counterparts.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Merger signatures in low excitation radio galaxies
Authors:
David Garofalo
Abstract:
While no consensus governs our understanding of the origin of low redshift radio galaxies, the possibility that mergers may trigger accretion from hot cluster halo gas has spurred a recent search for such signatures. Evidence for mergers is at best tenuous, however, and even when found, generates more questions than answers. With scant evidence for minor mergers, some connection to major mergers i…
▽ More
While no consensus governs our understanding of the origin of low redshift radio galaxies, the possibility that mergers may trigger accretion from hot cluster halo gas has spurred a recent search for such signatures. Evidence for mergers is at best tenuous, however, and even when found, generates more questions than answers. With scant evidence for minor mergers, some connection to major mergers is found in isolated environments but not where one would expect, i.e. in clusters. We provide an explanation for these recent results by Gordon et al (2019) on the relevance of major mergers in low excitation radio galaxies (LERGs) at low redshift. While LERGs are not the direct result of a merger, we describe how they form in clusters in only a few million years while that timescale is an order of magnitude longer in field environments. As a result of these different timescales, the average lifetime of a cluster LERG is estimated at an order of magnitude greater value than for field LERGs. Observing a LERG in the cluster environment, therefore, will tend to occur when greater time has passed since the major merger event that produced its high excitation radio galaxy ancestor, such that fewer signatures of that event remain visible. We provide simple estimates for the fraction of LERGs as a function of environment that are directly related to these timescales, obtaining a probability of about 7% that field LERGs will show merger signatures and 3% for clusters, showing that theory and observation match if major merger signatures remain visible for a few hundred million years.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
A unified framework for X-shaped radio galaxies
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Ravi Joshi,
Xiaolong Yang,
Chandra B. Singh,
Max North,
Matthew Hopkins
Abstract:
We propose a radically different picture for X-shaped radio galaxies compared to existing models as transition objects between cold mode accreting low spinning retrograde black holes and low spinning prograde black holes. The model explains their smaller average black hole masses, their general aversion for cluster compared to isolated environments, the negligible difference in spectral index betw…
▽ More
We propose a radically different picture for X-shaped radio galaxies compared to existing models as transition objects between cold mode accreting low spinning retrograde black holes and low spinning prograde black holes. The model explains their smaller average black hole masses, their general aversion for cluster compared to isolated environments, the negligible difference in spectral index between primary and secondary jets despite a time difference in their formation, their absence among the most powerful radio quasars and radio galaxies, and their connection to the elusive FRI quasar class, among others. The key to their formation is cold gas accretion onto Schwarzschild black holes.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
The generalized hardness-intensity diagram for black hole and neutron star X-ray binaries
Authors:
Chandra B. Singh,
David Garofalo,
Kathryn Kennedy
Abstract:
Over the past half century, X-ray and radio observations of accreting neutron stars and stellar mass black holes have yielded a rich observational picture with common features including state transitions and jet formation, but also sharp differences. While black hole X-ray binaries overwhelmingly suppress jets in so-called soft states, accreting neutron stars are less restrictive, with a soft stat…
▽ More
Over the past half century, X-ray and radio observations of accreting neutron stars and stellar mass black holes have yielded a rich observational picture with common features including state transitions and jet formation, but also sharp differences. While black hole X-ray binaries overwhelmingly suppress jets in so-called soft states, accreting neutron stars are less restrictive, with a soft state wind observed in some sources to co-exist with a jet. We propose an explanation for these differences that leads to a generalization of a foundational element, the hardness-intensity diagram of Fender et al (2004). The inverse relation between jets and winds fits into a picture that connects to prograde accretion while the possibility of counterrotation between accretion disk and compact object accounts for observed differences in accreting neutron stars. This picture comes with a surprising twist, which is that neutron stars embody the small-scale analog of FRII quasars, an idea that allows us to complete the scale invariant picture for the jet-disk connection.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
The sub-Eddington boundary for the quasar mass-luminosity plane: A theoretical perspective
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Damian J. Christian,
Andrew M. Jones
Abstract:
By exploring more than sixty thousand quasars from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 5, Steinhardt & Elvis discovered a sub-Eddington boundary and a redshift-dependent drop-off at higher black hole mass, possible clues to the growth history of massive black holes. Our contribution to this special issue of Universe amounts to an application of a model for black hole accretion and jet format…
▽ More
By exploring more than sixty thousand quasars from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 5, Steinhardt & Elvis discovered a sub-Eddington boundary and a redshift-dependent drop-off at higher black hole mass, possible clues to the growth history of massive black holes. Our contribution to this special issue of Universe amounts to an application of a model for black hole accretion and jet formation to these observations. For illustrative purposes we include about 100,000 data points from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7 where the sub-Eddington boundary is also visible, and propose a theoretical picture that explains these features. By appealing to thin disk theory and both the lower accretion efficiency and the time evolution of jetted quasars compared to non-jetted quasars in our 'gap paradigm', we explain two features of the sub-Eddington boundary. First, we show that a drop-off on the quasar mass-luminosity plane for larger black hole mass occurs at all redshifts. But the fraction of jetted quasars is directly related to the merger function in this paradigm, which means the jetted quasar fraction drops with decrease in redshift, which allows us to explain a second feature of the sub-Eddington boundary, namely a redshift dependence of the slope of the quasar mass-luminosity boundary at high black hole mass stemming from a change in radiative efficiency with time. We are able to reproduce the mass dependence of, as well as the oscillating behavior in, the slope of the sub-Eddington boundary as a function of time. The basic physical idea involves retrograde accretion occurring only for a subset of the more massive black holes which implies that most spinning black holes in our model are prograde accretors. In short, this paper amounts to a qualitative overview of how a sub-Eddington boundary naturally emerges in the gap paradigm.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Resolving the radio loud/radio quiet dichotomy without thick disks
Authors:
David Garofalo
Abstract:
Observations of radio loud active galaxies in the XMM-Newton archive by Mehdipour & Costantini show a strong anti-correlation between the column density of the ionized wind and the radio loudness parameter, providing evidence that jets may thrive in thin disks. This is in contrast with decades of analytic and numerical work suggesting jet formation is contingent on the presence of an inner, geomet…
▽ More
Observations of radio loud active galaxies in the XMM-Newton archive by Mehdipour & Costantini show a strong anti-correlation between the column density of the ionized wind and the radio loudness parameter, providing evidence that jets may thrive in thin disks. This is in contrast with decades of analytic and numerical work suggesting jet formation is contingent on the presence of an inner, geometrically thick disk structure, which serves to both collimate and accelerate the jet. Thick disks emerge in radiatively inefficient disks which are associated with sub-Eddington as well as super-Eddington accretion regimes yet we show that the inverse correlation between winds and jets survives where it should not, namely in a luminosity regime normally attributed to radio quiet active galaxies which are modeled with thin disks. This along with other lines of evidence argues against thick disks as the foundation behind the radio loud/radio quiet dichotomy, opening up the possibility that jetted versus non jetted black holes may be understood within the context of radiatively efficient thin disk accretion.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
FR0 radio galaxies and their place in the radio morphology classification
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Chandra B. Singh
Abstract:
So-called FR0 radio galaxies have recently emerged as a family of active galaxies with all the same properties as FRI radio galaxies except for their ratio of core to total emission which is about 30 times as high compared to FRI sources. We show how their properties fit within the gap paradigm as low prograde spinning black holes whose progenitors are powerful FRII quasars that transitioned rapid…
▽ More
So-called FR0 radio galaxies have recently emerged as a family of active galaxies with all the same properties as FRI radio galaxies except for their ratio of core to total emission which is about 30 times as high compared to FRI sources. We show how their properties fit within the gap paradigm as low prograde spinning black holes whose progenitors are powerful FRII quasars that transitioned rapidly from cold mode into advection dominated accretion in a few million years. The prediction is that if sufficient fuel exists, FR0 radio galaxies will evolve into full-fledged FRI radio galaxies and the observational dearth of FRI radio galaxies compared to FR0s at low redshift tells us about the supply of gas in the low redshift FR0s. Given the model prescription, this 5 to 1 FR0 to FRI ratio implies that at low redshift the FRII quasar class of active galaxies struggles to fuel its black hole beyond 1.3 times its original mass. In addition to this, we illustrate model prescriptions for the black hole mass, black hole spin, redshift and environment distribution for FR0 radio galaxies by fitting them within a paradigm that views them as a continuous class of active galaxies that are sandwiched between FRII quasars and FRI radio galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
The distribution and lifetime of powerful radio galaxies as a function of environment and redshift
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Chandra B. Singh,
Alexa Zack
Abstract:
Correlations between jet power and active time for z < 0.1 high excitation and low excitation radio galaxies are explored as well as evidence in favor of a specific, non-random distribution for these objects including mid-infrared emitting radio galaxies as a function of environment and redshift. In addition, so-called weak line radio galaxies with FRII jet morphology have been identified as a cla…
▽ More
Correlations between jet power and active time for z < 0.1 high excitation and low excitation radio galaxies are explored as well as evidence in favor of a specific, non-random distribution for these objects including mid-infrared emitting radio galaxies as a function of environment and redshift. In addition, so-called weak line radio galaxies with FRII jet morphology have been identified as a class of active galaxies in the process of shutting down. This paper identifies common features between these seemingly disparate phenomena described above for the population of radio galaxies, and strings them together by way of a simple phenomenological framework that has shed light on the radio loud/radio quiet dichotomy, the jet-disk connection, and the distribution of all active galaxies as a function of redshift.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
The redshift distribution of BL Lacs and FSRQs
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Chandra B. Singh,
Dylan T. Walsh,
Damian J. Christian,
Andrew M. Jones,
Alexa Zack,
Brandt Webster,
Matthew I. Kim
Abstract:
Flat spectrum radio quasars (FSRQs) and BL Lacs are powerful jet producing active galactic nuclei associated with supermassive black holes accreting at high and low Eddington rates, respectively. Based on the Millennium Simulation, Gardner and Done (2014; 2018) have predicted their redshift distribution by appealing to ideas from the spin paradigm in a way that exposes a need for a deeper discussi…
▽ More
Flat spectrum radio quasars (FSRQs) and BL Lacs are powerful jet producing active galactic nuclei associated with supermassive black holes accreting at high and low Eddington rates, respectively. Based on the Millennium Simulation, Gardner and Done (2014; 2018) have predicted their redshift distribution by appealing to ideas from the spin paradigm in a way that exposes a need for a deeper discussion on three interrelated issues: (1) an overprediction of BL Lacs compared to flat spectrum radio quasars; (2) a difference in FSRQ and BL Lac distributions; (3) a need for powerful but different jets at separated cosmic times. Beginning with Gardner and Done's determination of Fermi observable FSRQs based on the distribution of thermal accretion across cosmic time from the Millennium Simulation, we connect FSRQs to BL Lacs by way of the gap paradigm for black hole accretion and jet formation to address the above issues in a unified way. We identify a physical constraint in the paradigm for the numbers of BL Lacs that naturally leads to separate peaks in time for different albeit powerful jets. In addition, we both identify as puzzling and ascribe physical significance to a tail end in the BL Lac curve versus redshift that is unseen in the redshift distribution for FSRQs.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Magnetic reconnection and Blandford-Znajek process around rotating black holes
Authors:
Chandra B. Singh,
David Garofalo,
Elisabete M. de Gouveia Dal Pino
Abstract:
We provide a semi-analytic comparison between the Blandford-Znajek (BZ) and the magnetic reconnection power for accreting black holes in the curved spacetime of a rotating black hole. Our main result is that for a realistic range of astrophysical parameters, the reconnection power may compete with the BZ power. The field lines anchored close to or on the black hole usually evolve to open field lin…
▽ More
We provide a semi-analytic comparison between the Blandford-Znajek (BZ) and the magnetic reconnection power for accreting black holes in the curved spacetime of a rotating black hole. Our main result is that for a realistic range of astrophysical parameters, the reconnection power may compete with the BZ power. The field lines anchored close to or on the black hole usually evolve to open field lines in general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations. The BZ power is dependent on the black hole spin while magnetic reconnection power is independent of it for the force-free magnetic configuration with open field lines adopted in our theoretical study. This has obvious consequences for the time evolution of such systems particularly in the context of black hole X-ray binary state transitions. Our results provide analytical justification of the results obtained in GRMHD simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Scale-invariant jet suppression across the black hole mass scale
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Chandra B. Singh
Abstract:
We provide a schematic framework for understanding observations of jet suppression in soft state black hole X-ray binaries based on the Blandford-Payne process and the net magnetic flux threading the black hole. Due to the geometrical thinness of soft state disks, mass-loading of field lines is ineffective compared to both geometrically thick disks as well as thin disks with greater black hole thr…
▽ More
We provide a schematic framework for understanding observations of jet suppression in soft state black hole X-ray binaries based on the Blandford-Payne process and the net magnetic flux threading the black hole. Due to the geometrical thinness of soft state disks, mass-loading of field lines is ineffective compared to both geometrically thick disks as well as thin disks with greater black hole threading flux, a simple physical picture that allows us to understand the weakness of jets in radiatively efficient thin disks accreting in the prograde direction around high-spinning black holes. Despite a simplicity that forbids insights into the complexity of turbulent-driven evolution or the physics of the observed short-term time variability, we show how the breadth of this framework is such that it can serve as a coarse-grained foundation for understanding black hole accretion and jet formation across the mass scale.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Possible Evolution of Supermassive Black Holes from FRI quasars
Authors:
Matthew I. Kim,
Damian J. Christian,
David Garofalo,
Jaclyn D'Avanzo
Abstract:
We explore the question of the rapid buildup of black hole mass in the early universe employing a growing black hole mass-based determination of both jet and disk powers predicted in recent theoretical work on black hole accretion and jet formation. Despite simplified, even artificial assumptions about accretion and mergers, we identify an interesting low probability channel for the growth of one…
▽ More
We explore the question of the rapid buildup of black hole mass in the early universe employing a growing black hole mass-based determination of both jet and disk powers predicted in recent theoretical work on black hole accretion and jet formation. Despite simplified, even artificial assumptions about accretion and mergers, we identify an interesting low probability channel for the growth of one billion solar mass black holes within hundreds of millions of years of the Big Bang without appealing to super Eddington accretion. This result is made more compelling by the recognition of a connection between this channel and an end product involving active galaxies with FRI radio morphology but weaker jet powers in mildly sub-Eddington accretion regimes. While FRI quasars have already been shown to occupy a small region of the available parameter space for black hole feedback in the paradigm, we further suggest that the observational dearth of FRI quasars is also related to their connection to the most massive black hole growth due to both these FRIs high redshifts and relative weakness. Our results also allow us to construct the AGN luminosity function at high redshift, that agree with recent studies. In short, we produce a connection between the unexplained paucity of a given family of active galactic nuclei and the rapid growth of supermassive black holes, two heretofore seemingly unrelated aspects of the physics of active galactic nuclei.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2016; v1 submitted 13 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Reconciling AGN-star formation, the Soltan argument, and Meier's paradox
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Matthew I. Kim,
Damian J. Christian,
Emily Hollingworth,
Aaron Lowery,
Matthew Harmon
Abstract:
We provide a theoretical context for understanding the recent work of Kalfountzou et al (2014) showing that star formation is enhanced at lower optical luminosity in radio loud quasars. Our proposal for coupling the assumption of collimated FRII quasar jet-induced star formation with lower accretion optical luminosity, also explains the observed jet power peak in active galaxies at higher redshift…
▽ More
We provide a theoretical context for understanding the recent work of Kalfountzou et al (2014) showing that star formation is enhanced at lower optical luminosity in radio loud quasars. Our proposal for coupling the assumption of collimated FRII quasar jet-induced star formation with lower accretion optical luminosity, also explains the observed jet power peak in active galaxies at higher redshift compared to the peak in accretion power, doing so in a way that predicts the existence of a family of radio quiet AGN associated with rapidly spinning supermassive black holes at low redshift, as mounting observations suggest. The relevance of this work lies in its promise to explain the observed cosmological evolution of accretion power, jet power, and star formation, in a way that is both compatible with the Soltan argument and resolves the so-called `Meier Paradox'.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Constraints on the radio loud/radio quiet dichotomy from the fundamental plane
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Matthew I. Kim,
Damian J. Christian
Abstract:
The fundamental plane for black hole activity constitutes a tight correlation between jet power, X-ray luminosity, and black hole mass. Under the assumption that a Blandford-Znajek-type mechanism, which relies on black hole spin, contributes non-negligibly to jet production, the sufficiently small scatter in the fundamental plane shows that black hole spin differences of $\mid$$Δ$a$\mid \sim$1 are…
▽ More
The fundamental plane for black hole activity constitutes a tight correlation between jet power, X-ray luminosity, and black hole mass. Under the assumption that a Blandford-Znajek-type mechanism, which relies on black hole spin, contributes non-negligibly to jet production, the sufficiently small scatter in the fundamental plane shows that black hole spin differences of $\mid$$Δ$a$\mid \sim$1 are not typical among the active galactic nuclei population. If $-$ as it seems $-$ radio loud and radio quiet objects are both faithful to the fundamental plane, models of black hole accretion in which the radio loud/radio quiet dichotomy is based on a spin dichotomy of a$\sim$1/a$\sim$0, respectively, are difficult to reconcile with the observations.
We show how recent theoretical work based on differences in accretion flow orientation between retrograde and prograde, accommodates a small scatter in the fundamental plane for objects that do have non-negligible differences in black hole spin values. We also show that the dichotomy in spin between the most radio loud and the most radio quiet involves $\mid$$Δ$a$\mid \approx$0. And, finally, we show how the picture that produces compatibility with the fundamental plane, also allows one to interpret other otherwise puzzling observations of jets across the mass scale including 1) the recently observed inverse relation between radio and X-rays at higher Eddington ratios in both black hole X-ray binaries as well as active galactic nuclei and 2) the apparent contradiction between jet power and black hole spin observed in X-ray hard and transitory burst states in X-ray binaries.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
The jet-disc connection: evidence for a reinterpretation in radio loud and radio quiet active galactic nuclei
Authors:
David Garofalo
Abstract:
To constrain models of the jet-disc connection, we explore Eddington ratios reported in Foschini (2011) and interpret them in relation to the values in Sikora et al. across the active galactic nuclei population from radio loud quasars, their flat spectrum radio quasar subclass, the recently discovered gamma-ray loud narrow-line type 1 Seyfert galaxies, Fanaroff-Riley type I (FRI) radio galaxies an…
▽ More
To constrain models of the jet-disc connection, we explore Eddington ratios reported in Foschini (2011) and interpret them in relation to the values in Sikora et al. across the active galactic nuclei population from radio loud quasars, their flat spectrum radio quasar subclass, the recently discovered gamma-ray loud narrow-line type 1 Seyfert galaxies, Fanaroff-Riley type I (FRI) radio galaxies and radio quiet quasars of the Palomar Green survey. While appeal to disc truncation in radiatively inefficient flow appears to explain the observed inverse relation between radio loudness and Eddington ratio in radio loud and radio quiet quasars, FR I objects, scale invariance and recent data on powerful jets in narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies offer compelling arguments in favour of a reinterpretaion of the jet-disc connection.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Retrograde versus prograde models of accreting black holes
Authors:
David Garofalo
Abstract:
There is a general consensus that magnetic fields, accretion disks, and rotating black holes are instrumental in the generation of the most powerful sources of energy in the known universe. Nonetheless, because magnetized accretion onto rotating black holes involves both the complications of nonlinear magnetohydrodynamics that currently cannot fully be treated numerically, and uncertainties about…
▽ More
There is a general consensus that magnetic fields, accretion disks, and rotating black holes are instrumental in the generation of the most powerful sources of energy in the known universe. Nonetheless, because magnetized accretion onto rotating black holes involves both the complications of nonlinear magnetohydrodynamics that currently cannot fully be treated numerically, and uncertainties about the origin of magnetic fields that at present are part of the input, the space of possible solutions remains less constrained. Consequently, the literature still bears witness to the proliferation of rather different black hole engine models. But the accumulated wealth of observational data is now sufficient to meaningfully distinguish between them. It is in this light that this critical paper compares the recent retrograde framework with standard "spin paradigm" prograde models.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
A Magnetohydrodynamic Model of the M87 Jet I: Superluminal Knot Ejections from HST-1 as Trails of Quad Relativistic MHD Shocks
Authors:
Masanori Nakamura,
David Garofalo,
David L. Meier
Abstract:
This is the first in a series of papers that introduces a new paradigm for understanding the jet in M87: a collimated relativistic flow in which strong magnetic fields play a dominant dynamical role. Here wefocus on the flow downstream of HST-1 - an essentially stationary flaring feature that ejects trails of superluminal components. We propose that these components are quad relativistic magnetohy…
▽ More
This is the first in a series of papers that introduces a new paradigm for understanding the jet in M87: a collimated relativistic flow in which strong magnetic fields play a dominant dynamical role. Here wefocus on the flow downstream of HST-1 - an essentially stationary flaring feature that ejects trails of superluminal components. We propose that these components are quad relativistic magnetohydrodynamic shock fronts (forward/reverse fast and slow modes) in a narrow jet with a helically twisted magnetic structure. And we demonstrate the properties of such shocks with simple one-dimensional numerical simulations. Quasi-periodic ejections of similar component trails may be responsible for the M87 jet substructures observed further downstream on 100 - 1,000 pc scales. This new paradigm requires the assimilation of some new concepts into the astrophysical jet community, particularly the behavior of slow/fast-mode waves/shocks and of current-driven helical kink instabilities. However, the prospects of these ideas applying to a large number of other jet systems may make this worth the effort.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2010;
originally announced August 2010.
-
Misconceptions About General Relativity in Theoretical Black Hole Astrophysics
Authors:
David Garofalo,
David L. Meier
Abstract:
The fundamental role played by black holes in our study of microquasars, gamma ray bursts, and the outflows from active galactic nuclei requires an appreciation for, and at times some in-depth analysis of, curved spacetime. We highlight misconceptions surrounding the notion of coordinate transformation in general relativity as applied to metrics for rotating black holes that are beginning to incr…
▽ More
The fundamental role played by black holes in our study of microquasars, gamma ray bursts, and the outflows from active galactic nuclei requires an appreciation for, and at times some in-depth analysis of, curved spacetime. We highlight misconceptions surrounding the notion of coordinate transformation in general relativity as applied to metrics for rotating black holes that are beginning to increasingly appear in the literature. We emphasize that there is no coordinate transformation that can turn the metric of a rotating spacetime into that for a Schwarzschild spacetime, or more generally, that no coordinate transformation exists that can diagonalize the metric for a rotating spacetime. We caution against the notion of "local" coordinate transformation, which is often incorrectly associated with a global analysis of the spacetime.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
-
The Evolution of Radio Loud Active Galactic Nuclei as a Function of Black Hole Spin
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Dan A. Evans,
Rita M. Sambruna
Abstract:
Recent work on the engines of active galactic nuclei jets suggests their power depends strongly and perhaps counter-intuitively on black hole spin. We explore the consequences of this on the radio-loud population of active galactic nuclei and find that the time evolution of the most powerful radio galaxies and radio-loud quasars fits into a picture in which black hole spin varies from retrograde…
▽ More
Recent work on the engines of active galactic nuclei jets suggests their power depends strongly and perhaps counter-intuitively on black hole spin. We explore the consequences of this on the radio-loud population of active galactic nuclei and find that the time evolution of the most powerful radio galaxies and radio-loud quasars fits into a picture in which black hole spin varies from retrograde to prograde with respect to the accreting material. Unlike the current view, according to which jet powers decrease in tandem with a global downsizing effect, we argue for a drop in jet power resulting directly from the paucity of retrograde accretion systems at lower redshift $z$ caused by a continuous history of accretion dating back to higher $z$. In addition, the model provides simple interpretations for the basic spectral features differentiating radio-loud and radio-quiet objects, such as the presence or absence of disk reflection, broadened iron lines and signatures of disk winds. We also briefly describe our models' interpretation of microquasar state transitions. We highlight our result that the most radio-loud and most radio-quiet objects both harbor highly spinning black holes but in retrograde and prograde configurations, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
-
Spacetime constraints on accreting black holes
Authors:
David Garofalo
Abstract:
We study the spin dependence of accretion onto rotating Kerr black holes using analytic techniques. In its linear regime, angular momentum transport in MHD turbulent accretion flow involves the generation of radial magnetic field connecting plasma in a differentially rotating flow. We take a first principles approach, highlighting the constraint that limits the generation and amplification of ra…
▽ More
We study the spin dependence of accretion onto rotating Kerr black holes using analytic techniques. In its linear regime, angular momentum transport in MHD turbulent accretion flow involves the generation of radial magnetic field connecting plasma in a differentially rotating flow. We take a first principles approach, highlighting the constraint that limits the generation and amplification of radial magnetic fields, stemming from the transfer of energy from mechanical to magnetic form. Because the energy transferred in magnetic form is ultimately constrained by gravitational potential energy or Killing energy, the spin-dependence of the latter allows us to derive spin-dependent constraints on the success of the accreting plasma to expel its angular momentum and accrete. We find an inverse relationship between this ability and black hole spin. If this radial magnetic field generation forms the basis for angular momentum transfer in accretion flows, accretion rates involving Kerr black holes are expected to be lower as the black hole spin increases in the prograde sense.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
-
Signatures of black hole spin in galaxy evolution
Authors:
David Garofalo
Abstract:
We explore the connection between black hole spin and AGN power by addressing the consequences underlying the assumption in the recent literature that the gap region between accretion disks and black holes is fundamental in producing strong, spin-dependent, horizon-threading magnetic fields. Under the additional assumption that jets and outflows in AGN are produced by the Blandford-Znajek and Bl…
▽ More
We explore the connection between black hole spin and AGN power by addressing the consequences underlying the assumption in the recent literature that the gap region between accretion disks and black holes is fundamental in producing strong, spin-dependent, horizon-threading magnetic fields. Under the additional assumption that jets and outflows in AGN are produced by the Blandford-Znajek and Blandford-Payne mechanisms, we show that maximum jet/outflow power is achieved for accretion onto black holes having highly retrograde spin parameter, an energetically excited yet unstable gravitomagnetic configuration.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
-
The spin dependence of the Blandford-Znajek effect
Authors:
David Garofalo
Abstract:
The interaction of large scale magnetic fields with the event horizon of rotating black holes (the Blandford-Znajek [1977] mechanism) forms the basis for some models of the most relativistic jets. We explore a scenario in which the central inward "plunging" region of the accretion flow enhances the trapping of large scale poloidal field on the black hole. The study is carried out using a fully r…
▽ More
The interaction of large scale magnetic fields with the event horizon of rotating black holes (the Blandford-Znajek [1977] mechanism) forms the basis for some models of the most relativistic jets. We explore a scenario in which the central inward "plunging" region of the accretion flow enhances the trapping of large scale poloidal field on the black hole. The study is carried out using a fully relativistic treatment in Kerr spacetime, with the focus being to determine the spin dependence of the Blandford-Znajek effect. We find that large scale magnetic fields are enhanced on the black hole compared to the inner accretion flow and that the ease with which this occurs for lower prograde black hole spin, produces a spin dependence in the Blandford-Znajek effect that has attractive applications to recent observations. Among these is the correlation between inferred accretion rate and nuclear jet power observed by Allen et al. (2006) in X-ray luminous elliptical galaxies. If the black hole rotation in these elliptical galaxies is in the prograde sense compared with that of the inner accretion disk, we show that both the absolute value and the uniformity of the implied jet-production efficiency can be explained by the flux-trapping model. The basic scenario that emerges from this study is that a range of intermediate values of black hole spins could be powering these AGN. We also suggest that the jets in the most energetic radio-galaxies may be powered by accretion onto {\it retrograde} rapidly-rotating black holes.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.
-
Trapping of magnetic flux by the plunge region of a black hole accretion disk
Authors:
Christopher S. Reynolds,
David Garofalo,
Mitchell C. Begelman
Abstract:
The existence of the radius of marginal stability means that accretion flows around black holes invariably undergo a transition from a MHD turbulent disk-like flow to an inward plunging flow. We argue that the plunging inflow can greatly enhance the trapping of large scale magnetic field on the black hole, and therefore may increase the importance of the Blandford-Znajek (BZ) effect relative to…
▽ More
The existence of the radius of marginal stability means that accretion flows around black holes invariably undergo a transition from a MHD turbulent disk-like flow to an inward plunging flow. We argue that the plunging inflow can greatly enhance the trapping of large scale magnetic field on the black hole, and therefore may increase the importance of the Blandford-Znajek (BZ) effect relative to previous estimates that ignore the plunge region. We support this hypothesis by constructing and analyzing a toy-model of the dragging and trapping of a large scale field by a black hole disk, revealing a strong dependence of this effect on the effective magnetic Prandtl number of the MHD turbulent disk. Furthermore, we show that the enhancement of the BZ effect depends on the geometric thickness of the accretion disk. This may be, at least in part, the physical underpinnings of the empirical relation between the inferred geometric thickness of a black hole disk and the presence of a radio jet.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
-
Sporadically Torqued Accretion Disks Around Black Holes
Authors:
David Garofalo,
Christopher S. Reynolds
Abstract:
The assumption that black hole accretion disks possess an untorqued inner boundary, the so-called zero torque boundary condition, has been employed by models of black hole disks for many years. However, recent theoretical and observational work suggests that magnetic forces may appreciably torque the inner disk. This raises the question of the effect that a time-changing magnetic torque may have…
▽ More
The assumption that black hole accretion disks possess an untorqued inner boundary, the so-called zero torque boundary condition, has been employed by models of black hole disks for many years. However, recent theoretical and observational work suggests that magnetic forces may appreciably torque the inner disk. This raises the question of the effect that a time-changing magnetic torque may have on the evolution of such a disk. In particular, we explore the suggestion that the ``Deep Minimum State'' of the Seyfert galaxy MCG--6-30-15 can be identified as a sporadic inner disk torquing event. This suggestion is motivated by detailed analyses of changes in the profile of the broad fluorescence iron line in XMM-Newton spectra. We find that the response of such a disk to a torquing event has two phases; an initial damming of the accretion flow together with a partial draining of the disk interior to the torque location, followed by a replenishment of the inner disk as the system achieves a new (torqued) steady-state. If the Deep Minimum State of MCG--6-30-15 is indeed due to a sporadic torquing event, we show that the fraction of the dissipated energy going into X-rays must be smaller in the torqued state. We propose one such scenario in which Compton cooling of the disk corona by ``returning radiation'' accompanying a central-torquing event suppresses the 0.5-10 keV X-ray flux coming from all but the innermost regions of the disk.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2005; v1 submitted 20 January, 2005;
originally announced January 2005.
-
Black Hole Spin in AGN and GBHCs
Authors:
Christopher S. Reynolds,
Laura W. Brenneman,
David Garofalo
Abstract:
We discuss constraints on black hole spin and spin-related astrophysics as derived from X-ray spectroscopy. After a brief discussion about the robustness with which X-ray spectroscopy can be used to probe strong gravity, we summarize how these techniques can constrain black hole spin. In particular, we highlight XMM-Newton studies of the Seyfert galaxy MCG-6-30-15 and the stellar-mass black hole…
▽ More
We discuss constraints on black hole spin and spin-related astrophysics as derived from X-ray spectroscopy. After a brief discussion about the robustness with which X-ray spectroscopy can be used to probe strong gravity, we summarize how these techniques can constrain black hole spin. In particular, we highlight XMM-Newton studies of the Seyfert galaxy MCG-6-30-15 and the stellar-mass black hole GX339-4. The broad X-ray iron line profile, together with reasonable and general astrophysical assumptions, allow a non-rotating black hole to be rejected in both of these sources. If we make the stronger assertion of no emission from within the innermost stable circular orbit, the MCG-6-30-15 data constrain the dimensionless spin parameter to be a>0.93. Furthermore, these XMM-Newton data are already providing evidence for exotic spin-related astrophysics in the central regions of this object. We conclude with a discussion of the impact that Constellation-X will have on the study of strong gravity and black hole spin.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2004;
originally announced October 2004.
