-
Constraining the formation of WASP-39b using JWST transit spectroscopy
Authors:
N. Khorshid,
M. Min,
J. Polman,
L. B. F. M. Waters
Abstract:
Understanding the formation history of planets is one of the goals of studying exoplanet atmospheres. The atmospheric composition of planets can provide insights into the formation pathways of planets. Even though the mapping of the atmospheric composition onto a formation pathway is not unambiguous, with the increasing sensitivity of modern instruments, we can derive promising constraints. In thi…
▽ More
Understanding the formation history of planets is one of the goals of studying exoplanet atmospheres. The atmospheric composition of planets can provide insights into the formation pathways of planets. Even though the mapping of the atmospheric composition onto a formation pathway is not unambiguous, with the increasing sensitivity of modern instruments, we can derive promising constraints. In this work, we aim to understand the formation pathway of WASP-39b. We discuss whether the detection of SO2 in its atmosphere would impact our understanding of the formation of the planet and whether it enables us to determine the formation pathway of the planet with greater accuracy. We used the JWST transit observation of the planet together with the available HST and Spitzer observations. We used a formation model coupled with a radiative transfer retrieval model to derive the planet's atmospheric characteristics and formation history. Furthermore, we used a photochemical model to derive the impact of photochemistry on the atmosphere of the planet. In this work, we show that the planet is most likely to have initiated beyond the CO2 ice line of its natal disk. Furthermore, the planet is likely to have have accreted some planetesimals during its formation. We show that the sulfur abundance in the atmosphere of the planet is probably lower than $2.27 \times 10^{-4}$. This abundance indicates that the planet is likely to exhibit a lower metallicity than suggested by the retrievals. Furthermore, such an abundance for sulfur is more likely if WASP-39b had been formed beyond the CO ice line of its natal disk.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Retrieving planet formation parameters of WASP-77Ab using SimAb
Authors:
N. Khorshid,
M. Min,
J. M. Désert
Abstract:
The atmospheric compositions of planets offer a unique view into their respective formation processes. State-of-the-art observatories and techniques are finally able to provide high-precision data on atmospheric composition that can be used to constrain planet formation. In this context, we focus on the formation of WASP-77Ab based on previous observations of its atmosphere, which have provided pr…
▽ More
The atmospheric compositions of planets offer a unique view into their respective formation processes. State-of-the-art observatories and techniques are finally able to provide high-precision data on atmospheric composition that can be used to constrain planet formation. In this context, we focus on the formation of WASP-77Ab based on previous observations of its atmosphere, which have provided precise C/O and metallicity measurements. We use the SimAb planet formation simulation to model the formation of WASP-77Ab. We assume two compositions for the disk WASP-77Ab was formed within: one of a solar composition and one that represents the composition of WASP-77A. In addition, we considered two different scenarios regarding the migration of the planet and we study the possible planet formation paths that reproduce the composition of WASP-77Ab. This work shows that the planet is expected to have formed in a disk where not many planetesimals could be accreted. Moreover, we demonstrate that the most likely migration scenario is disk-free migration, whereby the planet initiates its Type II migration within the CO ice line and ends it beyond the water ice line.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
A strong H- opacity signal in the near-infrared emission spectrum of the ultra-hot Jupiter KELT-9b
Authors:
Bob Jacobs,
Jean-Michel Désert,
Lorenzo Pino,
Michael R. Line,
Jacob L. Bean,
Niloofar Khorshid,
Everett Schlawin,
Jacob Arcangeli,
Saugata Barat,
H. Jens Hoeijmakers,
Thaddeus D. Komacek,
Megan Mansfield,
Vivien Parmentier,
Daniel Thorngren
Abstract:
We present the analysis of a spectroscopic secondary eclipse of the hottest transiting exoplanet detected to date, KELT-9b, obtained with the Wide Field Camera 3 aboard the Hubble Space Telescope.
We complement these data with literature information on stellar pulsations and Spitzer/Infrared Array Camera and Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite eclipse depths of this target to obtain a broadban…
▽ More
We present the analysis of a spectroscopic secondary eclipse of the hottest transiting exoplanet detected to date, KELT-9b, obtained with the Wide Field Camera 3 aboard the Hubble Space Telescope.
We complement these data with literature information on stellar pulsations and Spitzer/Infrared Array Camera and Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite eclipse depths of this target to obtain a broadband thermal emission spectrum.
Our extracted spectrum exhibits a clear turnoff at 1.4$μ$m. This points to H$^{-}$ bound-free opacities shaping the spectrum.
To interpret the spectrum, we perform grid retrievals of self-consistent 1D equilibrium chemistry forward models, varying the composition and energy budget.
The model with solar metallicity and C/O ratio provides a poor fit because the H$^{-}$ signal is stronger than expected, requiring an excess of electrons. This pushes our retrievals toward high atmospheric metallicities ($[M/H]=1.98^{+0.19}_{-0.21}$) and a C/O ratio that is subsolar by 2.4$σ$. We question the viability of forming such a high-metallicity planet, and therefore provide other scenarios to increase the electron density in this atmosphere.
We also look at an alternative model in which we quench TiO and VO. This fit results in an atmosphere with a slightly subsolar metallicity and subsolar C/O ratio ($[M/H]=-0.22^{+0.17}_{-0.13}$, log(C/O)$=-0.34^{+0.19}_{-0.34}$). However, the required TiO abundances are disputed by recent high-resolution measurements of the same planet.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
H2S and SO2 detectability in Hot Jupiters: Sulfur species as indicator of metallicity and C/O ratio
Authors:
J. Polman,
L. B. F. M. Waters,
M. Min,
Y. Miguel,
N. Khorshid
Abstract:
The high cosmic abundance and the intermediate volatility and chemical properties of sulfur allow the use of sulfur-bearing species as a tracer of the chemical processes in the atmospheres of hot Jupiter exoplanets. Nevertheless, despite its properties and relevance as a tracer of the giant planets' formation history, little attention has been paid to this species in the context of hot Jupiter atm…
▽ More
The high cosmic abundance and the intermediate volatility and chemical properties of sulfur allow the use of sulfur-bearing species as a tracer of the chemical processes in the atmospheres of hot Jupiter exoplanets. Nevertheless, despite its properties and relevance as a tracer of the giant planets' formation history, little attention has been paid to this species in the context of hot Jupiter atmospheres. Here we provide an overview of the abundances of sulfur-bearing species in hot Jupiter atmospheres under different conditions and explore their observability. We use the photochemical kinetics code VULCAN to model hot Jupiter atmospheric disequilibrium chemistry. Transmission spectra for these atmospheres are created using the modelling framework ARCiS. We vary model parameters such as the diffusion coefficient, and we study the importance of photochemistry on the resulting mixing ratios. Furthermore, we vary the chemical composition of the atmosphere by increasing the metallicity from solar to ~10 times solar. We also explore different C/O ratios. We find that H2S and SO2 are the best candidates for detection between 1 and 10 micron, using a spectral resolution that is representative of the instruments on board the JWST. H2S is easiest to detect at an equilibrium temperature of ~1500 K and C/O ratios between 0.7 and 0.9, with the ideal value increasing slightly for increasing metallicity. SO2 is most likely to be detected at an equilibrium temperature of ~1000 K at low C/O ratios and high metallicities. Nevertheless, among these two molecules, we expect SO2 detection to be more common, as it is detectable in scenarios more favoured by formation models. We conclude that H2S and SO2 will most likely be detected in the coming years with the JWST and that the detection of these species will provide information on atmospheric processes and planet formation scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2022; v1 submitted 31 July, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
SimAb: A simple, fast and flexible model to assess the effects of planet formation on the atmospheric composition of gas giants
Authors:
N. Khorshid,
M. Min,
J. M. Désert,
P. Woitke,
C. Dominik
Abstract:
We present a basic, fast, and flexible planet formation model, called SimAb (Simulating Abundances), to form giant planets and study their primary atmospheric composition soon after their formation. In SimAb we introduce parameters to simplify the assumptions about the complex physics involved in the formation of a planet. This approach allows us to trace and understand the influence of complex ph…
▽ More
We present a basic, fast, and flexible planet formation model, called SimAb (Simulating Abundances), to form giant planets and study their primary atmospheric composition soon after their formation. In SimAb we introduce parameters to simplify the assumptions about the complex physics involved in the formation of a planet. This approach allows us to trace and understand the influence of complex physical processes on the formed planets. We focus on the C/O ratio and the metallicity of the planetary atmosphere as an indicator of their compositions. We show that the initial protoplanet core mass does not influence the final composition of the planetary atmosphere in the context of our model. The initial orbital distance affects the C/O ratio due to the different C/O ratios in the gas phase and the solid phase at different orbital distances. Additionally, the initial orbital distance together with the amount of accreted planetesimals cause the planet to have sub-solar or super-solar metallicity. Furthermore, the C/O ratio is affected by the dust grain fraction and the planetesimal fraction. Planets that accrete most of their heavy elements through dust grains will have a C/O ratio close to the solar C/O ratio, while planets that accrete most of their heavy elements from the planetesimals in the disk will end up with a C/O ratio closer to the C/O ratio in the solid phase of the disk. By using the C/O ratio and metallicity together we can put a lower and upper boundary on the initial orbital distance where super-solar metallicity planets are formed. We show that planetesimals are the main source for reaching super-solar metallicity planets. On the other hand, planets that mainly accrete dust grains will show a more solar composition. Super-solar metallicity planets that initiate their formation farther than the CO ice line have a C/O ratio closer to the solar value.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.