-
The impact of gravitational waveform model systematics on the measurement of the Hubble Constant
Authors:
Nina Kunert,
Jonathan Gair,
Peter T. H. Pang,
Tim Dietrich
Abstract:
Matching gravitational-wave observations of binary neutron stars with theoretical model predictions reveals important information about the sources, such as the masses and the distance to the stars. The latter can be used to determine the Hubble Constant, the rate at which the Universe expands. One general problem of all astrophysical measurements is that theoretical models only approximate the re…
▽ More
Matching gravitational-wave observations of binary neutron stars with theoretical model predictions reveals important information about the sources, such as the masses and the distance to the stars. The latter can be used to determine the Hubble Constant, the rate at which the Universe expands. One general problem of all astrophysical measurements is that theoretical models only approximate the real underlying physics, which can lead to systematic uncertainties introducing biases. However, the extent of this bias for the distance measurement due to uncertainties of gravitational waveform models is unknown. In this study, we analyze a synthetic population of 38 binary neutron star sources measured with Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo at design sensitivity. We employ a set of four different waveform models and estimate model-dependent systematic biases on the extraction of the Hubble Constant using the bright siren method. Our results indicate that systematic biases are below statistical uncertainties for the current generation of gravitational wave detectors.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
An overview of existing and new nuclear and astrophysical constraints on the equation of state of neutron-rich dense matter
Authors:
Hauke Koehn,
Henrik Rose,
Peter T. H. Pang,
Rahul Somasundaram,
Brendan T. Reed,
Ingo Tews,
Adrian Abac,
Oleg Komoltsev,
Nina Kunert,
Aleksi Kurkela,
Michael W. Coughlin,
Brian F. Healy,
Tim Dietrich
Abstract:
Through continuous progress in nuclear theory and experiment and an increasing number of neutron-star observations, a multitude of information about the equation of state (EOS) for matter at extreme densities is available. Here, we apply these different pieces of data individually to a broad set of physics-agnostic candidate EOSs and analyze the resulting constraints. Specifically, we make use of…
▽ More
Through continuous progress in nuclear theory and experiment and an increasing number of neutron-star observations, a multitude of information about the equation of state (EOS) for matter at extreme densities is available. Here, we apply these different pieces of data individually to a broad set of physics-agnostic candidate EOSs and analyze the resulting constraints. Specifically, we make use of information from chiral effective field theory, perturbative quantum chromodynamics, as well as data from heavy-ion collisions and the PREX-II and CREX experiments. We also investigate the impact of current mass and radius measurements of neutron stars, such as radio timing measurements of heavy pulsars, NICER data, and other X-ray observations. We augment these by reanalyses of the gravitational-wave (GW) signal GW170817, its associated kilonova AT2017gfo and gamma-ray burst afterglow, the GW signal GW190425, and the GRB211211A afterglow, where we use improved models for the tidal waveform and kilonova light curves. Additionally, we consider the postmerger fate of GW170817 and its consequences for the EOS. This large and diverse set of constraints is eventually combined in numerous ways to explore limits on quantities such as the typical neutron-star radius, the maximum neutron-star mass, the nuclear symmetry-energy parameters, and the speed of sound. Based on the priors from our EOS candidate set, we find the radius of the canonical 1.4 M$_\odot$ neutron star to be $R_{1.4}= 12.27_{-0.94}^{+0.83}$ km and the TOV mass $M_{\rm TOV}= 2.26_{-0.22}^{+0.45}$ M$_\odot$ at 95% credibility, when including those constraints where systematic uncertainties are deemed small. A less conservative approach, combining all the presented constraints, similarly yields $R_{1.4}= 12.20_{-0.50}^{+0.53}$ km and $M_{\rm TOV}= 2.31_{-0.20}^{+0.08}$ M$_\odot$.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Chemical Distribution of the Dynamical Ejecta in the Neutron Star Merger GW170817
Authors:
Shreya Anand,
Peter T. H. Pang,
Mattia Bulla,
Michael W. Coughlin,
Tim Dietrich,
Brian Healy,
Thomas Hussenot-Desenonges,
Theophile Jegou du Laz,
Mansi M. Kasliwal,
Nina Kunert,
Ivan Markin,
Kunal Mooley,
Vsevolod Nedora,
Anna Neuweiler
Abstract:
GW170817 and its associated electromagnetic counterpart AT2017gfo continue to be a treasure trove as observations and modeling continue. Recent precision astrometry of AT2017gfo with the Hubble Space Telescope combined with previous constraints from Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) constraints narrowed down the inclination angle to 19-25 deg (90\% confidence). This paper explores how the i…
▽ More
GW170817 and its associated electromagnetic counterpart AT2017gfo continue to be a treasure trove as observations and modeling continue. Recent precision astrometry of AT2017gfo with the Hubble Space Telescope combined with previous constraints from Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) constraints narrowed down the inclination angle to 19-25 deg (90\% confidence). This paper explores how the inclusion of precise inclination information can reveal new insights about the ejecta properties, in particular, about the composition of the dynamical ejecta of AT2017gfo. Our analysis relies on updated kilonova modeling, which includes state-of-the-art heating rates, thermalization efficiencies, and opacities and is parameterized by $\bar{Y}_{\rm e,dyn}$, the average electron fraction of the dynamical ejecta component. Using this model, we incorporate the latest inclination angle constraint of AT2017gfo into a light curve fitting framework to derive updated parameter estimates. Our results suggest that the viewing angle of the observer is pointed towards the lanthanide-poor ($Y_{\rm e,dyn}\gtrsim0.25$), squeezed polar dynamical ejecta component, which can explain the early blue emission observed in the light curve of AT2017gfo. In contrast to a recent claim of spherical ejecta powering AT2017gfo, our study indicates that the composition of the dynamical ejecta has a strong angular dependence, with a lanthanide-rich ($Y_{\rm e,dyn}\lesssim0.25$), tidal component distributed around the merger plane with a half-opening angle of $35^\circ$. The inclination angle constraint reduces $\bar{Y}_{\rm e,dyn}$ from $0.24$ to $0.22$, with values $0.17\lesssim Y_{\rm e, dyn} \lesssim0.41$ enabling the robust production of $r$-process elements up to the $3^{\rm rd}$ peak in the tidal dynamical ejecta.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Updated observing scenarios and multi-messenger implications for the International Gravitational-wave Network's O4 and O5
Authors:
R. Weizmann Kiendrebeogo,
Amanda M. Farah,
Emily M. Foley,
Abigail Gray,
Nina Kunert,
Anna Puecher,
Andrew Toivonen,
R. Oliver VandenBerg,
Shreya Anand,
Tomás Ahumada,
Viraj Karambelkar,
Michael W. Coughlin,
Tim Dietrich,
S. Zacharie Kam,
Peter T. H. Pang,
Leo P. Singer,
Niharika Sravan
Abstract:
An advanced LIGO and Virgo's third observing run brought another binary neutron star merger (BNS) and the first neutron-star black hole mergers. While no confirmed kilonovae were identified in conjunction with any of these events, continued improvements of analyses surrounding GW170817 allow us to project constraints on the Hubble Constant ($H_0$), the Galactic enrichment from $r$-process nucleosy…
▽ More
An advanced LIGO and Virgo's third observing run brought another binary neutron star merger (BNS) and the first neutron-star black hole mergers. While no confirmed kilonovae were identified in conjunction with any of these events, continued improvements of analyses surrounding GW170817 allow us to project constraints on the Hubble Constant ($H_0$), the Galactic enrichment from $r$-process nucleosynthesis, and ultra-dense matter possible from forthcoming events. Here, we describe the expected constraints based on the latest expected event rates from the international gravitational-wave network (IGWN) and analyses of GW170817. We show the expected detection rate of gravitational waves and their counterparts, as well as how sensitive potential constraints are to the observed numbers of counterparts. We intend this analysis as support for the community when creating scientifically driven electromagnetic follow-up proposals. During the next observing run O4, we predict an annual detection rate of electromagnetic counterparts from BNS of $0.43^{+0.58}_{-0.26}$ ($1.97^{+2.68}_{-1.2}$) for the Zwicky Transient Facility (Rubin Observatory).
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2023; v1 submitted 15 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Revealing the strength of three-nucleon interactions with the Einstein Telescope
Authors:
Henrik Rose,
Nina Kunert,
Tim Dietrich,
Peter T. H. Pang,
Rory Smith,
Chris Van Den Broeck,
Stefano Gandolfi,
Ingo Tews
Abstract:
Three-nucleon forces are crucial for the accurate description of nuclear systems, including dense matter probed in neutron stars. We explore nuclear Hamiltonians that reproduce two-nucleon scattering data and properties of light nuclei, but differ in the three-nucleon interactions among neutrons. While no significantly improved constraints can be obtained from current astrophysical data, we show t…
▽ More
Three-nucleon forces are crucial for the accurate description of nuclear systems, including dense matter probed in neutron stars. We explore nuclear Hamiltonians that reproduce two-nucleon scattering data and properties of light nuclei, but differ in the three-nucleon interactions among neutrons. While no significantly improved constraints can be obtained from current astrophysical data, we show that observations of neutron star mergers by next-generation detectors like the proposed Einstein Telescope could provide strong evidence to distinguish between these Hamiltonians.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
GRANDMA and HXMT Observations of GRB 221009A -- the Standard-Luminosity Afterglow of a Hyper-Luminous Gamma-Ray Burst
Authors:
D. A. Kann,
S. Agayeva,
V. Aivazyan,
S. Alishov,
C. M. Andrade,
S. Antier,
A. Baransky,
P. Bendjoya,
Z. Benkhaldoun,
S. Beradze,
D. Berezin,
M. Boër,
E. Broens,
S. Brunier,
M. Bulla,
O. Burkhonov,
E. Burns,
Y. Chen,
Y. P. Chen,
M. Conti,
M. W. Coughlin,
W. W. Cui,
F. Daigne,
B. Delaveau,
H. A. R. Devillepoix
, et al. (91 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
GRB 221009A is the brightest Gamma-Ray Burst (GRB) detected in more than 50 years of study. In this paper, we present observations in the X-ray and optical domains after the GRB obtained by the GRANDMA Collaboration (which includes observations from more than 30 professional and amateur telescopes) and the Insight-HXMT Collaboration. We study the optical afterglow with empirical fitting from GRAND…
▽ More
GRB 221009A is the brightest Gamma-Ray Burst (GRB) detected in more than 50 years of study. In this paper, we present observations in the X-ray and optical domains after the GRB obtained by the GRANDMA Collaboration (which includes observations from more than 30 professional and amateur telescopes) and the Insight-HXMT Collaboration. We study the optical afterglow with empirical fitting from GRANDMA+HXMT data, augmented with data from the literature up to 60 days. We then model numerically, using a Bayesian approach, the GRANDMA and HXMT-LE afterglow observations, that we augment with Swift-XRT and additional optical/NIR observations reported in the literature. We find that the GRB afterglow, extinguished by a large dust column, is most likely behind a combination of a large Milky-Way dust column combined with moderate low-metallicity dust in the host galaxy. Using the GRANDMA+HXMT-LE+XRT dataset, we find that the simplest model, where the observed afterglow is produced by synchrotron radiation at the forward external shock during the deceleration of a top-hat relativistic jet by a uniform medium, fits the multi-wavelength observations only moderately well, with a tension between the observed temporal and spectral evolution. This tension is confirmed when using the extended dataset. We find that the consideration of a jet structure (Gaussian or power-law), the inclusion of synchrotron self-Compton emission, or the presence of an underlying supernova do not improve the predictions, showing that the modelling of GRB22109A will require going beyond the most standard GRB afterglow model. Placed in the global context of GRB optical afterglows, we find the afterglow of GRB 221009A is luminous but not extraordinarily so, highlighting that some aspects of this GRB do not deviate from the global known sample despite its extreme energetics and the peculiar afterglow evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2023; v1 submitted 13 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Bayesian model selection for GRB 211211A through multi-wavelength analyses
Authors:
Nina Kunert,
Sarah Antier,
Vsevolod Nedora,
Mattia Bulla,
Peter T. H. Pang,
Shreya Anand,
Michael Coughlin,
Ingo Tews,
Jennifer Barnes,
Thomas Hussenot-Desenonges,
Brian Healy,
Theophile Jegou du Laz,
Meili Pilloix,
Weizmann Kiendrebeogo,
Tim Dietrich
Abstract:
Although GRB 211211A is one of the closest gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), its classification is challenging because of its partially inconclusive electromagnetic signatures. In this paper, we investigate four different astrophysical scenarios as possible progenitors for GRB~211211A: a binary neutron-star merger, a black-hole--neutron-star merger, a core-collapse supernova, and an r-process enriched core…
▽ More
Although GRB 211211A is one of the closest gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), its classification is challenging because of its partially inconclusive electromagnetic signatures. In this paper, we investigate four different astrophysical scenarios as possible progenitors for GRB~211211A: a binary neutron-star merger, a black-hole--neutron-star merger, a core-collapse supernova, and an r-process enriched core collapse of a rapidly rotating massive star (a collapsar). We perform a large set of Bayesian multi-wavelength analyses based on different models describing these scenarios and priors to investigate which astrophysical scenarios and processes might be related to GRB~211211A. Our analysis supports previous studies in which the presence of an additional component, likely related to $r$-process nucleosynthesis, is required to explain the observed light curves of GRB~211211A, as it can not solely be explained as a GRB afterglow. Fixing the distance to about $350~\rm Mpc$, namely the distance of the possible host galaxy SDSS J140910.47+275320.8, we find a statistical preference for a binary neutron-star merger scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2023; v1 submitted 5 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
An updated nuclear-physics and multi-messenger astrophysics framework for binary neutron star mergers
Authors:
Peter T. H. Pang,
Tim Dietrich,
Michael W. Coughlin,
Mattia Bulla,
Ingo Tews,
Mouza Almualla,
Tyler Barna,
Weizmann Kiendrebeogo,
Nina Kunert,
Gargi Mansingh,
Brandon Reed,
Niharika Sravan,
Andrew Toivonen,
Sarah Antier,
Robert O. VandenBerg,
Jack Heinzel,
Vsevolod Nedora,
Pouyan Salehi,
Ritwik Sharma,
Rahul Somasundaram,
Chris Van Den Broeck
Abstract:
The multi-messenger detection of the gravitational-wave signal GW170817, the corresponding kilonova AT2017gfo and the short gamma-ray burst GRB170817A, as well as the observed afterglow has delivered a scientific breakthrough. For an accurate interpretation of all these different messengers, one requires robust theoretical models that describe the emitted gravitational-wave, the electromagnetic em…
▽ More
The multi-messenger detection of the gravitational-wave signal GW170817, the corresponding kilonova AT2017gfo and the short gamma-ray burst GRB170817A, as well as the observed afterglow has delivered a scientific breakthrough. For an accurate interpretation of all these different messengers, one requires robust theoretical models that describe the emitted gravitational-wave, the electromagnetic emission, and dense matter reliably. In addition, one needs efficient and accurate computational tools to ensure a correct cross-correlation between the models and the observational data. For this purpose, we have developed the Nuclear-physics and Multi-Messenger Astrophysics framework NMMA. The code allows incorporation of nuclear-physics constraints at low densities as well as X-ray and radio observations of isolated neutron stars. In previous works, the NMMA code has allowed us to constrain the equation of state of supranuclear dense matter, to measure the Hubble constant, and to compare dense-matter physics probed in neutron-star mergers and in heavy-ion collisions, and to classify electromagnetic observations and perform model selection. Here, we show an extension of the NMMA code as a first attempt of analyzing the gravitational-wave signal, the kilonova, and the gamma-ray burst afterglow simultaneously. Incorporating all available information, we estimate the radius of a $1.4M_\odot$ neutron star to be $R=11.98^{+0.35}_{-0.40}$km.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2024; v1 submitted 17 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Quantifying modeling uncertainties when combining multiple gravitational-wave detections from binary neutron star sources
Authors:
Nina Kunert,
Peter T. H. Pang,
Ingo Tews,
Michael W. Coughlin,
Tim Dietrich
Abstract:
With the increasing sensitivity of gravitational-wave detectors, we expect to observe multiple binary neutron-star systems through gravitational waves in the near future. The combined analysis of these gravitational-wave signals offers the possibility to constrain the neutron-star radius and the equation of state of dense nuclear matter with unprecedented accuracy. However, it is crucial to ensure…
▽ More
With the increasing sensitivity of gravitational-wave detectors, we expect to observe multiple binary neutron-star systems through gravitational waves in the near future. The combined analysis of these gravitational-wave signals offers the possibility to constrain the neutron-star radius and the equation of state of dense nuclear matter with unprecedented accuracy. However, it is crucial to ensure that uncertainties inherent in the gravitational-wave models will not lead to systematic biases when information from multiple detections are combined. To quantify waveform systematics, we perform an extensive simulation campaign of binary neutron-star sources and analyse them with a set of four different waveform models. Based on our analysis with about 38 simulations, we find that statistical uncertainties in the neutron-star radius decrease to $\pm 250\rm m$ ($2\%$ at $90\%$ credible interval) but that systematic differences between currently employed waveform models can be twice as large. Hence, it will be essential to ensure that systematic biases will not become dominant in inferences of the neutron-star equation of state when capitalizing on future developments.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2022; v1 submitted 22 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.