-
Understanding the deflection of the `Cartwheel CME': data analysis and modeling
Authors:
Abril Sahade,
Angelos Vourildas,
Laura Balmaceda,
Mariana Cecere
Abstract:
We study the low corona evolution of the `Cartwheel' coronal mass ejection (CME; 2008-04-09) by reconstructing its 3D path and modeling it with magneto-hydrodynamic simulations. This event exhibits a double-deflection that has been reported and analyzed in previous works but whose underlying cause remained unclear. The `Cartwheel CME' travels toward a coronal hole (CH) and against the magnetic gra…
▽ More
We study the low corona evolution of the `Cartwheel' coronal mass ejection (CME; 2008-04-09) by reconstructing its 3D path and modeling it with magneto-hydrodynamic simulations. This event exhibits a double-deflection that has been reported and analyzed in previous works but whose underlying cause remained unclear. The `Cartwheel CME' travels toward a coronal hole (CH) and against the magnetic gradients. Using a high-cadence, full trajectory reconstruction, we accurately determine the location of the magnetic flux rope (MFR) and, consequently, the magnetic environment in which it is immersed. We find a pseudostreamer (PS) structure whose null point may be responsible for the complex evolution of the MFR at the initial phase. From the pre-eruptive magnetic field reconstruction, we estimate the dynamic forces acting on the MFR and provide a new physical insight on the motion exhibited by the 2008-04-09 event. By setting up a similar magnetic configuration in a 2.5D numerical simulation we are able to reproduce the observed behavior, confirming the importance of the PS null point. We find that the magnetic forces directed toward the null point cause the first deflection, directing the MFR towards the CH. Later, the magnetic pressure gradient of the CH produces the reversal motion of the MFR.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2023; v1 submitted 28 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Pseudostreamer influence on flux rope evolution
Authors:
A. Sahade,
M. Cécere,
M. V. Sieyra,
G. Krause,
H. Cremades,
A. Costa
Abstract:
A critical aspect of solar activity is the coupling between eruptions and the surrounding coronal magnetic field, which determines the trajectory and morphology of the eruptive event. Pseudostreamers (PSs) are coronal magnetic structures formed by arcs of twin loops capped by magnetic field lines from coronal holes of the same polarity that meet at a central spine. They contain a single magnetic n…
▽ More
A critical aspect of solar activity is the coupling between eruptions and the surrounding coronal magnetic field, which determines the trajectory and morphology of the eruptive event. Pseudostreamers (PSs) are coronal magnetic structures formed by arcs of twin loops capped by magnetic field lines from coronal holes of the same polarity that meet at a central spine. They contain a single magnetic null point in the spine, potentially influencing the evolution of nearby flux ropes (FRs). To understand the net effect of the PS on FR eruptions is first necessary to study diverse and isolated FR-PS scenarios, which are not influenced by other magnetic structures. We performed numerical simulations in which a FR structure is in the vicinity of a PS magnetic configuration. The combined magnetic field of the PS and the FR results in the formation of two magnetic null points. We evolve this scenario by numerically solving the magnetohydrodynamic equations in 2.5D. The simulations consider a fully ionised compressible ideal plasma in the presence of a gravitational field and a stratified atmosphere. We find that the dynamic behaviour of the FR can be categorised into three different classes based on the FR trajectories and whether it is eruptive or confined. Our analysis indicates that the magnetic null points are decisive in the direction and intensity of the FR deflection and their hierarchy depends on the topological arrangement of the scenario. Moreover, the PS lobe acts as a magnetic cage enclosing the FR. We report that the total unsigned magnetic flux of the cage is a key parameter defining whether the FR is ejected or not.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Polarity relevance in flux rope deflections triggered by coronal holes
Authors:
Abril Sahade,
Mariana Cécere,
Andrea Costa,
Hebe Cremades
Abstract:
Many observations show that coronal holes (CHs) deviate coronal mass ejections (CMEs) away from them. However, there are some peculiar events reported where the opposite occurs. To contribute to a space weather forecast efforts, in relation to the prediction of CME trajectories, we study the interaction between flux ropes (FRs) and CHs through numerical simulations. We perform 2.5D numerical simul…
▽ More
Many observations show that coronal holes (CHs) deviate coronal mass ejections (CMEs) away from them. However, there are some peculiar events reported where the opposite occurs. To contribute to a space weather forecast efforts, in relation to the prediction of CME trajectories, we study the interaction between flux ropes (FRs) and CHs through numerical simulations. We perform 2.5D numerical simulations where FRs and CHs interact with different relative polarity configurations. We also reconstruct the trajectory and magnetic environment of a peculiar event occurred on 30 April 2012. The numerical simulations indicate that at low coronal levels, depending on the relative magnetic field polarity between the FR and the CH, the deflection will be attractive, i.e. the FR moves towards the CH (for anti-aligned polarities) or repulsive, i.e. the FR moves away to the CH (for aligned polarities). This is likely due to the formation of vanishing magnetic field regions or null points, located between the FR and the CH or, at the other side of the FR, respectively. The analysed observational event shows a double-deflection, first departing from the radial direction by approaching the CH and then moving away from it suggesting that the trajectory could result from a magnetic configuration with an anti-aligned polarity. We numerically reproduce the double deflection of the observed event, providing support to this conjecture.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2021; v1 submitted 14 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Analysis of large deflections of prominence-CME events during the rising phase of solar cycle 24
Authors:
M. V. Sieyra,
M. Cécere,
H. Cremades,
F. A. Iglesias,
A. Sahade,
M. Mierla,
G. Stenborg,
A. Costa,
M. West,
E. D'Huys
Abstract:
Motivated by the need to improve the ability to forecast whether a certain coronal mass ejection (CME) is to impact Earth, and by the insufficiency of statistical studies that analyze the whole erupting system with the focus on the governing conditions under CME deflections, we performed a careful analysis of 13 events along a one-year time interval showing large deflections from their source regi…
▽ More
Motivated by the need to improve the ability to forecast whether a certain coronal mass ejection (CME) is to impact Earth, and by the insufficiency of statistical studies that analyze the whole erupting system with the focus on the governing conditions under CME deflections, we performed a careful analysis of 13 events along a one-year time interval showing large deflections from their source region. We used telescopes imaging the solar corona at different heights and wavelengths on board the Project for Onboard Autonomy 2 (PROBA2), Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO), Solar TErrestrial RElations Observatory (STEREO), Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO) spacecraft and from National Solar Observatory (NSO). By taking advantage of the quadrature position of these spacecraft from October 2010 until September 2011, we inspected the 3D trajectory of CMEs and their associated prominences with respect to their solar sources by means of a tie-pointing tool and a forward model. Considering the coronal magnetic fields as computed from a potential field source surface model, we investigate the roles of magnetic energy distribution and kinematic features in the non-radial propagation of both structures. The magnetic environment present during the eruption is found to be crucial in determining the trajectory of CMEs, in agreement with previous reports.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2020; v1 submitted 28 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Influence of coronal holes on CME deflections: numerical study
Authors:
Abril Sahade,
Mariana Cécere,
Gustavo Krause
Abstract:
The understanding of the causes that produce the deflection of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) is essential for the space weather forecast. In this article, we study the effects on CMEs trajectories produced by the different properties of a coronal hole close to the ejection area. For this analysis, we perform numerical simulations of the ideal magnetohydrodynamics equations that emulate the early r…
▽ More
The understanding of the causes that produce the deflection of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) is essential for the space weather forecast. In this article, we study the effects on CMEs trajectories produced by the different properties of a coronal hole close to the ejection area. For this analysis, we perform numerical simulations of the ideal magnetohydrodynamics equations that emulate the early rising of the CME in presence of a coronal hole. We find that, the stronger the magnetic field and the wider the coronal hole area, the larger the CME deflection. This effect is reduced when the coronal hole moves away from the ejection region. To characterize this behavior, we propose a dimensionless parameter that depends on the coronal hole properties and properly quantifies the deflection. Also, we show that the presence of the coronal hole near a CME magnetic structure produces a minimum magnetic energy region which is responsible for the deflection. Thus, we find a relationship between the coronal hole properties, the location of this region and the CME deflection.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
