-
Illustrating an Effective Workflow for Accelerated Materials Discovery
Authors:
Mrinalini Mulukutla,
A. Nicole Person,
Sven Voigt,
Lindsey Kuettner,
Branden Kappes,
Danial Khatamsaz,
Robert Robinson,
Daniel Salas,
Wenle Xu,
Daniel Lewis,
Hongkyu Eoh,
Kailu Xiao,
Haoren Wang,
Jaskaran Singh Saini,
Raj Mahat,
Trevor Hastings,
Matthew Skokan,
Vahid Attari,
Michael Elverud,
James D. Paramore,
Brady Butler,
Kenneth Vecchio,
Surya R. Kalidindi,
Douglas Allaire,
Ibrahim Karaman
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Algorithmic materials discovery is a multi-disciplinary domain that integrates insights from specialists in alloy design, synthesis, characterization, experimental methodologies, computational modeling, and optimization. Central to this effort is a robust data management system paired with an interactive work platform. This platform should empower users to not only access others data but also inte…
▽ More
Algorithmic materials discovery is a multi-disciplinary domain that integrates insights from specialists in alloy design, synthesis, characterization, experimental methodologies, computational modeling, and optimization. Central to this effort is a robust data management system paired with an interactive work platform. This platform should empower users to not only access others data but also integrate their analyses, paving the way for sophisticated data pipelines. To realize this vision, there is a need for an integrative collaboration platform, streamlined data sharing and analysis tools, and efficient communication channels. Such a collaborative mechanism should transcend geographical barriers, facilitating remote interaction and fostering a challenge-response dynamic. In this paper, we present our ongoing efforts in addressing the critical challenges related to an accelerated Materials Discovery Framework as a part of the High-Throughput Materials Discovery for Extreme Conditions Initiative. Our BIRDSHOT Center has successfully harnessed various tools and strategies, including the utilization of cloud-based storage, a standardized sample naming convention, a structured file system, the implementation of sample travelers, a robust sample tracking method, and the incorporation of knowledge graphs for efficient data management. Additionally, we present the development of a data collection platform, reinforcing seamless collaboration among our team members. In summary, this paper provides an illustration and insight into the various elements of an efficient and effective workflow within an accelerated materials discovery framework while highlighting the dynamic and adaptable nature of the data management tools and sharing platforms.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Phase-Field Model of Silicon Carbide Growth During Isothermal Condition
Authors:
Elias J. Munoz,
Vahid Attari,
Marco Martinez,
Matthew B. Dickerson,
Miladin Radovic,
Raymundo Arroyave
Abstract:
Silicon carbide (SiC) emerges as a promising ceramic material for high-temperature structural applications, especially within the aerospace sector. The utilization of SiC-based ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) instead of superalloys in components like engine shrouds, combustors, and nozzles offers notable advantages, including a 25% improvement in fuel efficiency, over 10% enhanced thrust, and the…
▽ More
Silicon carbide (SiC) emerges as a promising ceramic material for high-temperature structural applications, especially within the aerospace sector. The utilization of SiC-based ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) instead of superalloys in components like engine shrouds, combustors, and nozzles offers notable advantages, including a 25% improvement in fuel efficiency, over 10% enhanced thrust, and the capability to withstand up to 500$^{\circ}$C higher operating temperatures. Employing a CALPHAD-reinforced multi-phase-field model, our study delves into the evolution of the SiC layer under isothermal solidification conditions. By modeling the growth of SiC between liquid Si and solid C at 1450$^{\circ}$C, we compared results with experimental microstructures and quantitatively examined the evolution of SiC thickness over time. Efficient sampling across the entire model space mitigated uncertainty in high-temperature kinetic parameters, allowing us to predict a range of growth rates and morphologies for the SiC layer. The model accounts for parameter uncertainty stemming from limited experimental knowledge and successfully predicts relevant morphologies for the system. Experimental results validated the kinetic parameters of the simulations, offering valuable insights and potential constraints on the reaction kinetics. We further explored the significance of multi-phase-field model parameters on two key outputs, and found that the diffusion coefficient of liquid Si emerges as the most crucial parameter significantly impacting the SiC average layer thickness and grain count over time. This study provides valuable insights into the microstructure evolution of the Si-C binary system, offering pertinent information for the engineering of CMCs in industrial applications.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
On the Effect of Nucleation Undercooling on Phase Transformation Kinetics
Authors:
José Mancias,
Vahid Attari,
Raymundo Arróyave,
Damien Tourret
Abstract:
We carry out an extensive comparison between Johnson-Mehl-Avrami-Kolmogorov (JMAK) theory of first-order phase transformation kinetics and phase-field (PF) results of a benchmark problem on nucleation. To address the stochasticity of the problem, several hundreds of simulations are performed to establish a comprehensive, statistically-significant analysis of the coincidences and discrepancies betw…
▽ More
We carry out an extensive comparison between Johnson-Mehl-Avrami-Kolmogorov (JMAK) theory of first-order phase transformation kinetics and phase-field (PF) results of a benchmark problem on nucleation. To address the stochasticity of the problem, several hundreds of simulations are performed to establish a comprehensive, statistically-significant analysis of the coincidences and discrepancies between PF and JMAK transformation kinetics. We find that PF predictions are in excellent agreement with both classical nucleation theory and JMAK theory, as long as the original assumptions of the latter are appropriately reproduced - in particular, the constant nucleation and growth rates in an infinite domain. When deviating from these assumptions, PF results are at odds with JMAK theory. In particular, we observe that the size of the initial particle radius $r_0$ relative to the critical nucleation radius $r^*$ has a significant effect on the rate of transformation. While PF and JMAK agree when $r_0$ is sufficiently higher than $r^*$, the duration of initial transient growth stage of a particle, before it reaches a steady growth velocity, increases as $r_0/r^*\to 1$. This incubation time has a significant effect on the overall kinetics, e.g. on the Avrami exponent of the multi-particle simulations. In contrast, for the considered conditions and parameters, the effect of interface curvature upon transformation kinetics - in particular negative curvature regions appearing during particle impingement, present in PF but absent in JMAK theory - appears to be minor compared to that of $r_0/r^*$. We argue that rigorous benchmarking of phase-field models of stochastic processes (e.g. nucleation) need sufficient statistical data in order to make rigorous comparisons against ground truth theories. In these problems, analysis of probability distributions is clearly preferable to a deterministic approach.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Uncertainty Propagation in a Multiscale CALPHAD-Reinforced Elastochemical Phase-field Model
Authors:
Vahid Attari,
Pejman Honarmandi,
Thien Duong,
Daniel J Sauceda,
Douglas Allaire,
Raymundo Arroyave
Abstract:
ICME approaches provide decision support for materials design by establishing quantitative process-structure-property relations. Confidence in the decision support, however, must be achieved by establishing uncertainty bounds in ICME model chains. The quantification and propagation of uncertainty in computational materials science, however, remains a rather unexplored aspect of computational mater…
▽ More
ICME approaches provide decision support for materials design by establishing quantitative process-structure-property relations. Confidence in the decision support, however, must be achieved by establishing uncertainty bounds in ICME model chains. The quantification and propagation of uncertainty in computational materials science, however, remains a rather unexplored aspect of computational materials science approaches. Moreover, traditional uncertainty propagation frameworks tend to be limited in cases with computationally expensive simulations. A rather common and important model chain is that of CALPHAD-based thermodynamic models of phase stability coupled to phase field models for microstructure evolution. Propagation of uncertainty in these cases is challenging not only due to the sheer computational cost of the simulations but also because of the high dimensionality of the input space. In this work, we present a framework for the quantification and propagation of uncertainty in a CALPHAD-based elasto-chemical phase field model. We motivate our work by investigating the microstructure evolution in Mg$_2$(Si$_x$Sn$_{1-x}$) thermoelectric materials. We first carry out a Markov Chain Monte Carlo-based inference of the CALPHAD model parameters for this pseudobinary system and then use advanced sampling schemes to propagate uncertainties across a high-dimensional simulation input space. Through high-throughput phase field simulations we generate 200,000 time series of synthetic microstructures and use machine learning approaches to understand the effects of propagated uncertainties on the microstructure landscape of the system under study. The microstructure dataset has been curated in the Open Phase-field Microstructure Database (OPMD), available at \href{http://microstructures.net}{http://microstructures.net}.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Probing discontinuous precipitation in U-Nb
Authors:
Thien Duong,
Robert E. Hackenberg,
Vahid Attari,
Alex Landa,
Patrice E. A. Turchi,
Raymundo Arroyave
Abstract:
U-Nb's discontinuous precipitation, $γ^{bcc}_{matrix} \rightarrow α^{orth}_{cellular} + γ'^{bcc}_{cellular}$, is intriguing in the sense that it allows formation and growth of the metastable $γ'$ phase during the course of its occurrence. Previous attempts to explain the thermodynamic origin of U-Nb's discontinuous precipitation hypothesized that the energy of $α$ forms an intermediate common tang…
▽ More
U-Nb's discontinuous precipitation, $γ^{bcc}_{matrix} \rightarrow α^{orth}_{cellular} + γ'^{bcc}_{cellular}$, is intriguing in the sense that it allows formation and growth of the metastable $γ'$ phase during the course of its occurrence. Previous attempts to explain the thermodynamic origin of U-Nb's discontinuous precipitation hypothesized that the energy of $α$ forms an intermediate common tangent with the first potential of the double-well energy of $γ$ at the $γ'$ composition. While this hypothesis is eligible and consistent with the experimental observation of gradual increase in $γ'$ composition at increasing temperature, it is in conflict with recent experiments whose results indicated a distribution of $γ'$ compositions in the vicinity of 50 at\%Nb. To shed some light onto this issue, the current work investigates the origin of U-Nb's discontinuous precipitation in view of fundamental thermodynamics and kinetics, taken from the perspective of phase-field theory. It has been showed that local misfit strain tends to play a crucial role in the formation and growth the discontinuous precipitation. Depending on the magnitude of strain developed at grain boundaries, either an increasing $γ'$ composition or a random distribution of $γ'$ composition around the equiatomic value with respect to increasing temperature could be expected.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Finite Interface Dissipation Phase Field Modeling of Ni-Nb under Additive Manufacturing Conditions
Authors:
Kubra Karayagiz,
Luke Johnson,
Raiyan Seede,
Vahid Attari,
Bing Zhang,
Xueqin Huang,
Supriyo Ghosh,
Thien Duong,
Ibrahim Karaman,
Alaa Elwany,
Raymundo Arroyave
Abstract:
During the laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) process, the built part undergoes multiple rapid heating-cooling cycles, leading to complex microstructures with nonuniform properties. In the present work, a computational framework, which weakly couples a finite element thermal model to a non-equilibrium PF model was developed to investigate the rapid solidification microstructure of a Ni-Nb alloy durin…
▽ More
During the laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) process, the built part undergoes multiple rapid heating-cooling cycles, leading to complex microstructures with nonuniform properties. In the present work, a computational framework, which weakly couples a finite element thermal model to a non-equilibrium PF model was developed to investigate the rapid solidification microstructure of a Ni-Nb alloy during L-PBF. The framework is utilized to predict the spatial variation of the morphology and size of cellular segregation structure as well as the microsegregation in single-track melt pool microstructures obtained under different process conditions. A solidification map demonstrating the variation of microstructural features as a function of the temperature gradient and growth rate is presented. A planar to cellular transition is predicted in the majority of keyhole mode melt pools, while a planar interface is predominant in conduction mode melt pools. The predicted morphology and size of the cellular segregation structure agrees well with experimental measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2020; v1 submitted 24 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Exploration of the Microstructure Space in TiAlZrN Ultra-Hard Nanostructured Coatings
Authors:
Vahid Attari,
Aitor Cruzado,
Raymundo Arroyave
Abstract:
Ti$_{1-x-y}$Al$_{x}$Zr$_{y}$N cubic alloys within the 25-70\% Al composition range have high age-hardening capabilities due to metastable phase transition pathways at high temperatures. They are thus ideal candidates for ultra-hard nano-coating materials. There is growing evidence that this effect is associated with the elasto-chemical field-induced phase separation into compositionally-segregated…
▽ More
Ti$_{1-x-y}$Al$_{x}$Zr$_{y}$N cubic alloys within the 25-70\% Al composition range have high age-hardening capabilities due to metastable phase transition pathways at high temperatures. They are thus ideal candidates for ultra-hard nano-coating materials. There is growing evidence that this effect is associated with the elasto-chemical field-induced phase separation into compositionally-segregated nanocrystaline nitride phases. Here, we studied the microstructural evolution in this pseudo-ternary system within spinodal regions at 1200 $^\circ$C by using an elasto-chemical phase field model. Our simulations indicate that elastic interactions between nitride nano-domains greatly affect not only the morphology of the microstructure but also the local chemical phase equilibria. In Al-rich regions of the composition space we further observe the onset of the transformation of AlN-rich phases into their equilibrium wurtzite crystal structure. This work points to a wide palette of microstructures potentially accessible to these nitride systems and their tailoring is likely to result in significant improvements in the performance of transition metal nitride-based coating materials.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
On the Interfacial Phase Growth and Vacancy Evolution during Accelerated Electromigration in Cu/Sn/Cu Microjoints
Authors:
Vahid Attari,
Supriyo Ghosh,
Thien Duong,
Raymundo Arroyave
Abstract:
In this work, we integrate different computational tools based on multi-phase-field simulations to account for the evolution of morphologies and crystallographic defects of Cu/Sn/Cu sandwich interconnect structures that are widely used in three dimensional integrated circuits (3DICs). Specifically, this work accounts for diffusion-driven formation and disappearance of multiple intermetallic phases…
▽ More
In this work, we integrate different computational tools based on multi-phase-field simulations to account for the evolution of morphologies and crystallographic defects of Cu/Sn/Cu sandwich interconnect structures that are widely used in three dimensional integrated circuits (3DICs). Specifically, this work accounts for diffusion-driven formation and disappearance of multiple intermetallic phases during accelerated electromigration and takes into account the non-equilibrium formation of vacancies due to electromigration. The work compares nucleation, growth, and coalescence of intermetallic layers during transient liquid phase bonding and virtual joint structure evolution subjected to accelerated electromigration conditions at different temperatures. The changes in the rate of dissolution of Cu from intermetallics and the differences in the evolution of intermetallic layers depending on whether they act as cathodes or anodes are accounted for and are compared favorably with experiments. The model considers non-equilibrium evolution of vacancies that form due to differences in couplings between diffusing atoms and electron flows. This work is significant as the point defect evolution in 3DIC solder joints during electromigration has deep implications to the formation and coalescence of voids that ultimately compromise the structural and functional integrity of the joints.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2018; v1 submitted 19 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
