-
Standardization of chemically selective atomic force microscopy for metal-oxide surfaces
Authors:
Philipp Wiesener,
Stefan Förster,
Milena Merkel,
Bertram Schulze Lammers,
Harald Fuchs,
Saeed Amirjalayer,
Harry Mönig
Abstract:
The complex atomic structures and defects of metal-oxide surfaces are vital for a variety of applications in material science and chemistry. While scanning probe microscopy allows accessing atomic-scale structures in real space, elemental discrimination and defect characterization usually rely on indirect assumptions and extensive theoretical modelling. By investigating a variety of different samp…
▽ More
The complex atomic structures and defects of metal-oxide surfaces are vital for a variety of applications in material science and chemistry. While scanning probe microscopy allows accessing atomic-scale structures in real space, elemental discrimination and defect characterization usually rely on indirect assumptions and extensive theoretical modelling. By investigating a variety of different sample systems with increasing structural complexity and inherent defects, we demonstrate that noncontact atomic force microscopy with an O-terminated copper tip allows imaging metal-oxide surfaces with a clear elemental contrast. This universal approach provides not only immediate access to the metal- and oxygen sub-lattices, but also to the chemical and structural configuration of atomic-scale defect structures. The observed contrast can be explained by purely electrostatic interactions between the negatively charged tip apex and the strongly varying electrostatic potential between metal- and oxygen surface sites. These results offer a standardized methodology for the direct structural characterization of even most-complex metal-oxide surfaces, which is highly relevant for a fundamental understanding of atomic-scale processes on these material systems.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Molecular Simulation of a Zn-Triazamacrocyle Metal-Organic Frameworks Family with Extraframework Anions
Authors:
Marta De Toni,
François-Xavier Coudert,
Selvarengan Paranthaman,
Pluton Pullumbi,
Anne Boutin,
Alain H. Fuchs
Abstract:
We report an investigation by means of adsorption experiments and molecular simulation of the behavior of a recently synthesized cationic metal-organic framework. We used a combination of quantum chemistry calculations and classical forcefield-based Grand Canonical Monte Carlo simulations to shed light onto the localization of extra-framework halogenide anions in the material. We also studied the…
▽ More
We report an investigation by means of adsorption experiments and molecular simulation of the behavior of a recently synthesized cationic metal-organic framework. We used a combination of quantum chemistry calculations and classical forcefield-based Grand Canonical Monte Carlo simulations to shed light onto the localization of extra-framework halogenide anions in the material. We also studied the adsorption of small gas molecules into the pores of the material using molecular simulation and investigated the coadsorption of binary gas mixtures.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
The Behavior of Flexible MIL-53(Al) upon CH4 and CO2 Adsorption
Authors:
Anne Boutin,
François-Xavier Coudert,
Marie-Anne Springuel-Huet,
Alexander V. Neimark,
Gérard Férey,
Alain H. Fuchs
Abstract:
The use of the osmotic thermodynamic model, combined with a series of methane and carbon dioxide gas adsorption experiments at various temperatures, has allowed shedding some new light on the fascinating phase behavior of flexible MIL-53(Al) metal-organic frameworks. A generic temperature-loading phase diagram has been derived; it is shown that the breathing effect in MIL-53 is a very general phen…
▽ More
The use of the osmotic thermodynamic model, combined with a series of methane and carbon dioxide gas adsorption experiments at various temperatures, has allowed shedding some new light on the fascinating phase behavior of flexible MIL-53(Al) metal-organic frameworks. A generic temperature-loading phase diagram has been derived; it is shown that the breathing effect in MIL-53 is a very general phenomenon, which should be observed in a limited temperature range regardless of the guest molecule. In addition, the previously proposed stress model for the structural transitions of MIL-53 is shown to be transferable from xenon to methane adsorption. The stress model also provides a theoretical framework for understanding the existence of lp/np phase mixtures at pressures close to the breathing transition pressure, without having to invoke an inhomogeneous distribution of the adsorbate in the porous sample.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Thermodynamics of Guest-Induced Structural Transitions in Hybrid Organic-Inorganic Frameworks
Authors:
François-Xavier Coudert,
Marie Jeffroy,
Alain H. Fuchs,
Anne Boutin,
Caroline Mellot-Draznieks
Abstract:
We provide a general thermodynamic framework for the understanding of guest-induced structural transitions in hybrid organic-inorganic materials. The method is based on the analysis of experimental adsorption isotherms. It allows the determination of the free energy differences between host structures involved in guest-induced transitions, especially hard to obtain experimentally. We discuss the g…
▽ More
We provide a general thermodynamic framework for the understanding of guest-induced structural transitions in hybrid organic-inorganic materials. The method is based on the analysis of experimental adsorption isotherms. It allows the determination of the free energy differences between host structures involved in guest-induced transitions, especially hard to obtain experimentally. We discuss the general case of adsorption in flexible materials and show how a few key quantities, such as pore volumes and adsorption affinities, entirely determine the phenomenology of adsorption, including the occurrence of structural transitions. On the basis of adsorption thermodynamics, we then propose a taxonomy of guest-induced structural phase transitions and the corresponding isotherms. In particular, we derive generic conditions for observing a double structural transition upon adsorption, often resulting in a two-step isotherm. Finally, we show the wide applicability and the robustness of the model through three case studies of topical hybrid organic-inorganic frameworks: the hysteretic hydrogen adsorption in Co(1,4-benzenedipyrazolate), the guest-dependent gate-opening in Cu(4,4'-bipyridine)(2,5-dihydroxybenzoate)2 and the CO2-induced "breathing" of hybrid material MIL-53.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
What makes zeolitic imidazolate frameworks hydrophobic or hydrophilic? The impact of geometry and functionalization on water adsorption
Authors:
Aurélie U. Ortiz,
Alexy P. Freitas,
Anne Boutin,
Alain H. Fuchs,
François-Xavier Coudert
Abstract:
We demonstrate, by means of Grand Canonical Monte Carlo simulation on different members of the ZIF family, how topology, geometry, and linker functionalization drastically affect the water adsorption properties of these materials, tweaking the ZIF materials from hydrophobic to hydrophilic. We show that adequate functionalization of the linkers allows one to tune the host-guest interactions, even f…
▽ More
We demonstrate, by means of Grand Canonical Monte Carlo simulation on different members of the ZIF family, how topology, geometry, and linker functionalization drastically affect the water adsorption properties of these materials, tweaking the ZIF materials from hydrophobic to hydrophilic. We show that adequate functionalization of the linkers allows one to tune the host-guest interactions, even featuring dual amphiphilic materials whose pore space features both hydrophobic and hydrophilic regions. Starting from an initially hydrophobic material (ZIF-8), various degrees of hydrophilicity could be obtained, with a gradual evolution from a type V adsorption isotherm in the liquid phase to a type I isotherm in the gas phase. This behavior is similar to what was described earlier in families of hydrophobic all-silica zeolites, with hydrophilic "defects" of various strength, such as silanol nests or the presence of extra-framework cations.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Interplay between Defects, Disorder and Flexibility in Metal-Organic Frameworks
Authors:
Thomas D. Bennett,
Anthony K. Cheetham,
Alain H. Fuchs,
François-Xavier Coudert
Abstract:
Metal-organic frameworks are a novel family of chemically diverse materials, which are of interest across engineering, physics, chemistry, biology, and medicine-based disciplines. Since the development of the field in its current form more than two decades ago, priority has been placed on the synthesis of new structures. However, more recently, a clear trend has emerged in shifting the emphasis fr…
▽ More
Metal-organic frameworks are a novel family of chemically diverse materials, which are of interest across engineering, physics, chemistry, biology, and medicine-based disciplines. Since the development of the field in its current form more than two decades ago, priority has been placed on the synthesis of new structures. However, more recently, a clear trend has emerged in shifting the emphasis from material design to exploring the chemical and physical properties of those already known. In particular --- while such nanoporous materials were traditionally seen as rigid crystalline structures --- there is growing evidence that large-scale flexibility, the presence of defects and long-range disorder, are not the exception, but rather the norm, in metal-organic frameworks. Here we offer some perspective into how these concepts are perhaps inescapably intertwined, highlight recent advances in our understanding, and discuss how a consideration of the interfaces between them may lead to enhancements of the materials' functionalities.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
On the use of the IAST method for gas separation studies in porous materials with gate-opening behavior
Authors:
Guillaume Fraux,
Anne Boutin,
Alain H. Fuchs,
François-Xavier Coudert
Abstract:
Highly flexible nanoporous materials, exhibiting for instance gate opening or breathing behavior, are often presented as candidates for separation processes due to their supposed high adsorption selectivity. But this view, based on "classical" considerations of rigid materials and the use of the Ideal Adsorbed Solution Theory (IAST), does not necessarily hold in the presence of framework deformati…
▽ More
Highly flexible nanoporous materials, exhibiting for instance gate opening or breathing behavior, are often presented as candidates for separation processes due to their supposed high adsorption selectivity. But this view, based on "classical" considerations of rigid materials and the use of the Ideal Adsorbed Solution Theory (IAST), does not necessarily hold in the presence of framework deformations. Here, we revisit some results from the published literature and show how proper inclusion of framework flexibility in the osmotic thermodynamic ensemble drastically changes the conclusions, in contrast to what intuition and standard IAST would yield. In all cases, the IAST method does not reproduce the gate-opening behavior in the adsorption of mixtures, and may overestimates the selectivity by up to two orders of magnitude.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
The complete micromagnetic characterization of asymmetrically sandwiched ferromagnetic films
Authors:
M. Kopte,
U. K. Rößler,
R. Schäfer,
T. Kosub,
A. Kákay,
O. Volkov,
H. Fuchs,
E. Y. Vedmedenko,
F. Radu,
O. G. Schmidt,
J. Lindner,
J. Faßbender,
D. Makarov
Abstract:
The magnetic properties of ferromagnetic thin films down to the nanoscale are ruled by the exchange stiffness, anisotropies and the effects of magnetic fields. As surfaces break inversion symmetry, an additional effective chiral exchange is omnipresent in any magnetic nanostructure. These so-called Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions (DMI) affect all inhomogeneous magnetic states either subtly or s…
▽ More
The magnetic properties of ferromagnetic thin films down to the nanoscale are ruled by the exchange stiffness, anisotropies and the effects of magnetic fields. As surfaces break inversion symmetry, an additional effective chiral exchange is omnipresent in any magnetic nanostructure. These so-called Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions (DMI) affect all inhomogeneous magnetic states either subtly or spectacularly. E.g., DMIs cause a chirality selection of the rotation sense and can fix the local rotation axis for the magnetization in domain walls (DW). But, they can stabilize also entirely different twisted magnetic structures. The chiral skyrmions a two-dimensional particle-like topological soliton is the ultimately smallest of these objects, which currently is targetted as a possible information carrier in novel spintronic devices. Observation and quantification of the chiral exchange effects provide for the salient point in understanding magnetic properties in ultrathin films and other nanostructures. An easy and reliable method to determine the DMI constant as materials parameter of asymmetric thin films is the crucial problem. Here, we put forth an experimental approach for the determination of the complete set of the micromagnetic parameters. Quasi-static Kerr microcopy observations of DW creep motion and equilibrium sizes of circular magnetic objects in combination with standard magnetometry are used to derive a consistent set of these materials parameters in polycrystalline ultrathin film systems, namely CrOx/Co/Pt stacks. The quantified micromagnetic model for these films identifies the circular magnetic objects, as seen by the optical microscopy, as ordinary bubble domains with homochiral walls. From micromagnetic calculations, the chiral skyrmions stabilized by the DMI in these films are shown to have diameters in the range 40-200nm, too small to be observed by optical microscopy.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2017; v1 submitted 28 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Topologically stable magnetization states on a spherical shell: curvature stabilized skyrmions
Authors:
Volodymyr P. Kravchuk,
Ulrich K. Rößler,
Oleksii M. Volkov,
Denis D. Sheka,
Jeroen van den Brink,
Denys Makarov,
Hagen Fuchs,
Hans Fangohr,
Yuri Gaididei
Abstract:
Topologically stable structures include vortices in a wide variety of matter, such as skyrmions in ferro- and antiferromagnets, and hedgehog point defects in liquid crystals and ferromagnets. These are characterized by integer-valued topological quantum numbers. In this context, closed surfaces are a prominent subject of study as they form a link between fundamental mathematical theorems and real…
▽ More
Topologically stable structures include vortices in a wide variety of matter, such as skyrmions in ferro- and antiferromagnets, and hedgehog point defects in liquid crystals and ferromagnets. These are characterized by integer-valued topological quantum numbers. In this context, closed surfaces are a prominent subject of study as they form a link between fundamental mathematical theorems and real physical systems. Here we perform an analysis on the topology and stability of equilibrium magnetization states for a thin spherical shell with easy-axis anisotropy in normal directions. Skyrmion solutions are found for a range of parameters. These magnetic skyrmions on a spherical shell have two distinct differences compared to their planar counterpart: (i) they are topologically trivial, and (ii) can be stabilized by curvature effects, even when Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions are absent. Due to its specific topological nature a skyrmion on a spherical shell can be simply induced by a uniform external magnetic field.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2016; v1 submitted 8 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
Area confined position control of molecular aggregates
Authors:
Hong Wang,
Oleg Buller,
Wenchong Wang,
Andreas Heuer,
Dequin Zhang,
Harald Fuchs,
Lifeng Chi
Abstract:
We report an experimental approach to control the position of molecular aggregates on surfaces by vacuum deposition. The control is accomplished by regulating the molecular density on the surface in a confined area. The diffusing molecules are concentrated at the centre of the confined area, producing a stable cluster when reaching the critical density for nucleation. Mechanistic aspects of that c…
▽ More
We report an experimental approach to control the position of molecular aggregates on surfaces by vacuum deposition. The control is accomplished by regulating the molecular density on the surface in a confined area. The diffusing molecules are concentrated at the centre of the confined area, producing a stable cluster when reaching the critical density for nucleation. Mechanistic aspects of that control are obtained from kinetic Monte Carlo simulations. The dimensions of the position can further be controlled by varying the beam flux and the substrate temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2016; v1 submitted 11 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Computational characterization and prediction of metal-organic framework properties
Authors:
François-Xavier Coudert,
Alain H. Fuchs
Abstract:
In this introductory review, we give an overview of the computational chemistry methods commonly used in the field of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), to describe or predict the structures themselves and characterize their various properties, either at the quantum chemical level or through classical molecular simulation. We discuss the methods for the prediction of crystal structures, geometrical…
▽ More
In this introductory review, we give an overview of the computational chemistry methods commonly used in the field of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), to describe or predict the structures themselves and characterize their various properties, either at the quantum chemical level or through classical molecular simulation. We discuss the methods for the prediction of crystal structures, geometrical properties and large-scale screening of hypothetical MOFs, as well as their thermal and mechanical properties. A separate section deals with the simulation of adsorption of fluids and fluid mixtures in MOFs.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2015; v1 submitted 26 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Building the Chessboard-like Supramolecular Structure on Au (111) Surfaces
Authors:
Ruifen Dou,
Yu Yang,
Ping Zhang,
Dingyong Zhong,
Harald Fuchs,
Yue Wang,
Lifeng Chi
Abstract:
We investigate an anthracene derivative, 3(5)-(9-anthryl) pyrazole (ANP), self-assembled on the Au (111) surface by means of scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. A chessboard-like network structure composed of ANP molecules is found, covering the whole Au (111) substrate. Our STM results and DFT calculations reveal that the formation of chessboard-l…
▽ More
We investigate an anthracene derivative, 3(5)-(9-anthryl) pyrazole (ANP), self-assembled on the Au (111) surface by means of scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. A chessboard-like network structure composed of ANP molecules is found, covering the whole Au (111) substrate. Our STM results and DFT calculations reveal that the formation of chessboard-like networks originates from a basic unit cell, a tetramer structure, which is formed by four ANP molecules connected through C-H-N hydrogen-bonds. The hydrogen bonds inside each tetramer and the molecular adsorption interaction are fundamentally important in providing a driving force for formation of the supramolecular networks.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Understanding Adsorption-Induced Structural Transitions in Metal-Organic Frameworks: From the Unit Cell to the Crystal
Authors:
Carles Triguero,
François-Xavier Coudert,
Anne Boutin,
Alain H. Fuchs,
Alexander V. Neimark
Abstract:
Breathing transitions represent recently discovered adsorption-induced structural transformations between large-pore and narrow-pore conformations in bistable metal-organic frameworks, such as MIL-53. We present a multiscale physical mechanism of the dynamics of breathing transitions. We show that due to interplay between host framework elasticity and guest molecule adsorption, these transformatio…
▽ More
Breathing transitions represent recently discovered adsorption-induced structural transformations between large-pore and narrow-pore conformations in bistable metal-organic frameworks, such as MIL-53. We present a multiscale physical mechanism of the dynamics of breathing transitions. We show that due to interplay between host framework elasticity and guest molecule adsorption, these transformations on the crystal level occur via layer-by-layer shear. We construct a simple Hamiltonian that describes the physics of host-host and host-guest interactions on the level of unit cells and reduces to one effective dimension due to the long-range elastic cell-cell interactions. We then use this Hamiltonian in Monte Carlo simulations of adsorption-desorption cycles to study how the behavior of unit cells is linked to the transition mechanism at the crystal level through three key physical parameters: the transition energy barrier, the cell-cell elastic coupling, and the system size.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2015; v1 submitted 5 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Anisotropic Elastic Properties of Flexible Metal-Organic Frameworks: How Soft are Soft Porous Crystals?
Authors:
Aurélie U. Ortiz,
Anne Boutin,
Alain H. Fuchs,
François-Xavier Coudert
Abstract:
We performed ab initio calculations of the elastic constants of five flexible metal-organic frameworks: MIL-53(Al), MIL-53(Ga), MIL-47 and the square and lozenge structures of DMOF-1. Tensorial analysis of the elastic constants reveal a highly anisotropic elastic behavior, some deformation directions exhibiting very low Young's modulus and shear modulus. This anisotropy can reach a 400:1 ratio bet…
▽ More
We performed ab initio calculations of the elastic constants of five flexible metal-organic frameworks: MIL-53(Al), MIL-53(Ga), MIL-47 and the square and lozenge structures of DMOF-1. Tensorial analysis of the elastic constants reveal a highly anisotropic elastic behavior, some deformation directions exhibiting very low Young's modulus and shear modulus. This anisotropy can reach a 400:1 ratio between the most rigid and weakest directions, in stark contrast with the case of non-flexible MOFs such as MOF-5 and ZIF-8. In addition, we show that flexible MOFs can display extremely large negative linear compressibility (NLC). These results uncover the microscopic roots of stimuli-induced structural transitions in flexible MOFs, by linking the local elastic behavior of the material and its multistability.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2014; v1 submitted 27 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Frictional Duality Observed during Nanoparticle Sliding
Authors:
Dirk Dietzel,
Claudia Ritter,
Tristan Monninghoff,
Harald Fuchs,
Andre Schirmeisen,
Udo D. Schwarz
Abstract:
One of the most fundamental questions in tribology concerns the area dependence of friction at the nanoscale. Here, experiments are presented where the frictional resistance of nanoparticles is measured by pushing them with the tip of an atomic force microscope. We find two coexisting frictional states: While some particles show finite friction increasing linearly with the interface areas of up…
▽ More
One of the most fundamental questions in tribology concerns the area dependence of friction at the nanoscale. Here, experiments are presented where the frictional resistance of nanoparticles is measured by pushing them with the tip of an atomic force microscope. We find two coexisting frictional states: While some particles show finite friction increasing linearly with the interface areas of up to 310,000nm^2, other particles assume a state of frictionless sliding. The results further suggest a link between the degree of surface contamination and the occurrence of this duality.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2008; v1 submitted 16 May, 2008;
originally announced May 2008.
-
Nanoscopic Study of the Ion Dynamics in a LiAlSiO$_4$ Glass Ceramic by means of Electrostatic Force Spectroscopy
Authors:
Bernhard Roling,
André Schirmeisen,
Hartmut Bracht,
Ahmet Taskiran,
Harald Fuchs,
Sevi Murugavel,
Frank Natrup
Abstract:
We use time-domain electrostatic force spectroscopy (TD-EFS) for characterising the dynamics of mobile ions in a partially crystallised LiAlSiO$_4$ glass ceramic, and we compare the results of the TD-EFS measurements to macroscopic electrical conductivity measurements. While the macroscopic conductivity spectra are determined by a single dynamic process with an activation energy of 0.72 eV, the…
▽ More
We use time-domain electrostatic force spectroscopy (TD-EFS) for characterising the dynamics of mobile ions in a partially crystallised LiAlSiO$_4$ glass ceramic, and we compare the results of the TD-EFS measurements to macroscopic electrical conductivity measurements. While the macroscopic conductivity spectra are determined by a single dynamic process with an activation energy of 0.72 eV, the TD-EFS measurements provide information about two distinct relaxation processes with different activation energies. Our results indicate that the faster process is due to ionic movements in the glassy phase and at the glass-crystal interfaces, while the slower process is caused by ionic movements in the crystallites. The spatially varying electrical relaxation strengths of the fast and of the slow process provide information about the nano- and mesoscale structure of the glass ceramic.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2004;
originally announced December 2004.
-
Probing ion transport at the nanoscale: Time-domain electrostatic force spectroscopy on glassy electrolytes
Authors:
A. Schirmeisen,
A. Taskiran,
H. Fuchs,
B. Roling,
S. Murugavel,
H. Bracht,
F. Natrup
Abstract:
We have carried out time--domain electrostatic force spectroscopy on two different ion conducting glasses using an atomic force microscope. We compare the electrostatic force spectroscopic data obtained at different temperatures with macroscopic electrical data of the glasses. The overall consistency of the data shows that electrostatic force spectroscopy is capable of probing the ion dynamics a…
▽ More
We have carried out time--domain electrostatic force spectroscopy on two different ion conducting glasses using an atomic force microscope. We compare the electrostatic force spectroscopic data obtained at different temperatures with macroscopic electrical data of the glasses. The overall consistency of the data shows that electrostatic force spectroscopy is capable of probing the ion dynamics and transport in nanoscopic subvolumes of the samples.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2004;
originally announced May 2004.
-
Markov chain analysis of random walks on disordered medium
Authors:
Sonali Mukherjee,
Hisao Nakanishi,
Norman H. Fuchs
Abstract:
We study the dynamical exponents $d_{w}$ and $d_{s}$ for a particle diffusing in a disordered medium (modeled by a percolation cluster), from the regime of extreme disorder (i.e., when the percolation cluster is a fractal at $p=p_{c}$) to the Lorentz gas regime when the cluster has weak disorder at $p>p_{c}$ and the leading behavior is standard diffusion. A new technique of relating the velocity…
▽ More
We study the dynamical exponents $d_{w}$ and $d_{s}$ for a particle diffusing in a disordered medium (modeled by a percolation cluster), from the regime of extreme disorder (i.e., when the percolation cluster is a fractal at $p=p_{c}$) to the Lorentz gas regime when the cluster has weak disorder at $p>p_{c}$ and the leading behavior is standard diffusion. A new technique of relating the velocity autocorrelation function and the return to the starting point probability to the asymptotic spectral properties of the hopping transition probability matrix of the diffusing particle is used, and the latter is numerically analyzed using the Arnoldi-Saad algorithm. We also present evidence for a new scaling relation for the second largest eigenvalue in terms of the size of the cluster, $|\lnλ_{max}|\sim S^{-d_w/d_f}$, which provides a very efficient and accurate method of extracting the spectral dimension $d_s$ where $d_s=2d_f/d_w$.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 1993;
originally announced November 1993.