-
The power of dynamic social networks to predict individuals' mental health
Authors:
Shikang Liu,
David Hachen,
Omar Lizardo,
Christian Poellabauer,
Aaron Striegel,
Tijana Milenkovic
Abstract:
Precision medicine has received attention both in and outside the clinic. We focus on the latter, by exploiting the relationship between individuals' social interactions and their mental health to develop a predictive model of one's likelihood to be depressed or anxious from rich dynamic social network data. To our knowledge, we are the first to do this. Existing studies differ from our work in at…
▽ More
Precision medicine has received attention both in and outside the clinic. We focus on the latter, by exploiting the relationship between individuals' social interactions and their mental health to develop a predictive model of one's likelihood to be depressed or anxious from rich dynamic social network data. To our knowledge, we are the first to do this. Existing studies differ from our work in at least one aspect: they do not model social interaction data as a network; they do so but analyze static network data; they examine "correlation" between social networks and health but without developing a predictive model; or they study other individual traits but not mental health. In a systematic and comprehensive evaluation, we show that our predictive model that uses dynamic social network data is superior to its static network as well as non-network equivalents when run on the same data.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Heterogeneous network approach to predict individuals' mental health
Authors:
Shikang Liu,
Fatemeh Vahedian,
David Hachen,
Omar Lizardo,
Christian Poellabauer,
Aaron Striegel,
Tijana Milenkovic
Abstract:
Depression and anxiety are critical public health issues affecting millions of people around the world. To identify individuals who are vulnerable to depression and anxiety, predictive models have been built that typically utilize data from one source. Unlike these traditional models, in this study, we leverage a rich heterogeneous data set from the University of Notre Dame's NetHealth study that…
▽ More
Depression and anxiety are critical public health issues affecting millions of people around the world. To identify individuals who are vulnerable to depression and anxiety, predictive models have been built that typically utilize data from one source. Unlike these traditional models, in this study, we leverage a rich heterogeneous data set from the University of Notre Dame's NetHealth study that collected individuals' (student participants') social interaction data via smartphones, health-related behavioral data via wearables (Fitbit), and trait data from surveys. To integrate the different types of information, we model the NetHealth data as a heterogeneous information network (HIN). Then, we redefine the problem of predicting individuals' mental health conditions (depression or anxiety) in a novel manner, as applying to our HIN a popular paradigm of a recommender system (RS), which is typically used to predict the preference that a person would give to an item (e.g., a movie or book). In our case, the items are the individuals' different mental health states. We evaluate four state-of-the-art RS approaches. Also, we model the prediction of individuals' mental health as another problem type - that of node classification (NC) in our HIN, evaluating in the process four node features under logistic regression as a proof-of-concept classifier. We find that our RS and NC network methods produce more accurate predictions than a logistic regression model using the same NetHealth data in the traditional non-network fashion as well as a random-approach. Also, we find that the best of the considered RS approaches outperforms all considered NC approaches. This is the first study to integrate smartphone, wearable sensor, and survey data in an HIN manner and use RS or NC on the HIN to predict individuals' mental health conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2020; v1 submitted 10 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Long-term Compliance Habits: What Early Data Tells Us
Authors:
Louis Faust,
Priscilla Jiménez,
David Hachen,
Omar Lizardo,
Aaron Striegel,
Nitesh V. Chawla
Abstract:
The rise in popularity of physical activity trackers provides extensive opportunities for research on personal health, however, barriers such as compliance attrition can lead to substantial losses in data. As such, insights into student's compliance habits could support researcher's decisions when designing long-term studies. In this paper, we examined 392 students on a college campus currently tw…
▽ More
The rise in popularity of physical activity trackers provides extensive opportunities for research on personal health, however, barriers such as compliance attrition can lead to substantial losses in data. As such, insights into student's compliance habits could support researcher's decisions when designing long-term studies. In this paper, we examined 392 students on a college campus currently two and a half years into an ongoing study. We find that compliance data from as early as one month correlated with student's likelihood of dropping out of the study (p < .001) and compliance long-term (p < .001). The findings in this paper identify long-term compliance habits and the viability of their early detection.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Gender Differences in Communication Behaviors, Spatial Proximity Patterns, and Mobility Habits
Authors:
Yang Yang,
Omar Lizardo,
Dong Wang,
Yuxiao Dong,
Aaron D. Striegel,
David Hachen,
Nitesh V. Chawla
Abstract:
The existence of gender differences in the structure and composition of social networks is a well established finding in the social and behavioral sciences, but researchers continue to debate whether structural, dispositional, or life course factors are the primary driver of these differences. In this paper we extend work on gender differences in social networks to patterns of interaction, propinq…
▽ More
The existence of gender differences in the structure and composition of social networks is a well established finding in the social and behavioral sciences, but researchers continue to debate whether structural, dispositional, or life course factors are the primary driver of these differences. In this paper we extend work on gender differences in social networks to patterns of interaction, propinquity, and connectivity captured via a social sensing platform comprised of an ensemble of individuals' phone calls, text messaging, face-to-face interactions, and traces of their mobility activities. We attempt to isolate dispositional from other factors by focusing on a relatively homogeneous population on a relatively closed setting at the same stage in the life course. Analysis across three different networks along with mobility data reveals systematic gender differences in terms of communicative, distributional, mobility, and spatial proximity tendencies. Most importantly, some patterns observed in the communication network (e.g. stronger same-gender preference for women) are found to be reversed in the spatial proximity context, with men displaying a greater tendency to spend time in a narrower (and thus more predictable) range of spaces with same-gender peers than women. These findings provide robust and novel evidence for the powerful effect of gender in structuring behavior across a wide range of communication and mobility behaviors, validating and extending recent work pointing to differences of socio-cultural and evolutionary origin in the styles of sociability and interaction characteristic of men and women.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Lessons Learned from an Experiment in Crowdsourcing Complex Citizen Engineering Tasks with Amazon Mechanical Turk
Authors:
Matthew Staffelbach,
Peter Sempolinski,
David Hachen,
Ahsan Kareem,
Tracy Kijewski-Correa,
Douglas Thain,
Daniel Wei,
Greg Madey
Abstract:
We investigate the feasibility of obtaining highly trustworthy results using crowdsourcing on complex engineering tasks. Crowdsourcing is increasingly seen as a potentially powerful way of increasing the supply of labor for solving society's problems. While applications in domains such as citizen-science, citizen-journalism or knowledge organization (e.g., Wikipedia) have seen many successful appl…
▽ More
We investigate the feasibility of obtaining highly trustworthy results using crowdsourcing on complex engineering tasks. Crowdsourcing is increasingly seen as a potentially powerful way of increasing the supply of labor for solving society's problems. While applications in domains such as citizen-science, citizen-journalism or knowledge organization (e.g., Wikipedia) have seen many successful applications, there have been fewer applications focused on solving engineering problems, especially those involving complex tasks. This may be in part because of concerns that low quality input into engineering analysis and design could result in failed structures leading to loss of life. We compared the quality of work of the anonymous workers of Amazon Mechanical Turk (AMT), an online crowdsourcing service, with the quality of work of expert engineers in solving the complex engineering task of evaluating virtual wind tunnel data graphs. On this representative complex engineering task, our results showed that there was little difference between expert engineers and crowdworkers in the quality of their work and explained reasons for these results. Along with showing that crowdworkers are effective at completing new complex tasks our paper supplies a number of important lessons that were learned in the process of collecting this data from AMT, which may be of value to other researchers.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Weighted reciprocity in human communication networks
Authors:
Cheng Wang,
Anthony Strathman,
Omar Lizardo,
David Hachen,
Zoltan Toroczkai,
Nitesh V. Chawla
Abstract:
In this paper we define a metric for reciprocity---the degree of balance in a social relationship---appropriate for weighted social networks in order to investigate the distribution of this dyadic feature in a large-scale system built from trace-logs of over a billion cell-phone communication events across millions of actors. We find that dyadic relations in this network are characterized by much…
▽ More
In this paper we define a metric for reciprocity---the degree of balance in a social relationship---appropriate for weighted social networks in order to investigate the distribution of this dyadic feature in a large-scale system built from trace-logs of over a billion cell-phone communication events across millions of actors. We find that dyadic relations in this network are characterized by much larger degrees of imbalance than we would expect if persons kept only those relationships that exhibited close to full reciprocity. We point to two structural features of human communication behavior and relationship formation---the division of contacts into strong and weak ties and the tendency to form relationships with similar others---that either help or hinder the ability of persons to obtain communicative balance in their relationships. We examine the extent to which deviations from reciprocity in the observed network are partially traceable to these characteristics.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2011; v1 submitted 13 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Predictors of short-term decay of cell phone contacts in a large scale communication network
Authors:
Troy Raeder,
Omar Lizardo,
David Hachen,
Nitesh V. Chawla
Abstract:
Under what conditions is an edge present in a social network at time t likely to decay or persist by some future time t + Delta(t)? Previous research addressing this issue suggests that the network range of the people involved in the edge, the extent to which the edge is embedded in a surrounding structure, and the age of the edge all play a role in edge decay. This paper uses weighted data from a…
▽ More
Under what conditions is an edge present in a social network at time t likely to decay or persist by some future time t + Delta(t)? Previous research addressing this issue suggests that the network range of the people involved in the edge, the extent to which the edge is embedded in a surrounding structure, and the age of the edge all play a role in edge decay. This paper uses weighted data from a large-scale social network built from cell-phone calls in an 8-week period to determine the importance of edge weight for the decay/persistence process. In particular, we study the relative predictive power of directed weight, embeddedness, newness, and range (measured as outdegree) with respect to edge decay and assess the effectiveness with which a simple decision tree and logistic regression classifier can accurately predict whether an edge that was active in one time period continues to be so in a future time period. We find that directed edge weight, weighted reciprocity and time-dependent measures of edge longevity are highly predictive of whether we classify an edge as persistent or decayed, relative to the other types of factors at the dyad and neighborhood level.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2011; v1 submitted 8 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
