-
Verifying Lock-free Search Structure Templates
Authors:
Nisarg Patel,
Dennis Shasha,
Thomas Wies
Abstract:
We present and verify template algorithms for lock-free concurrent search structures that cover a broad range of existing implementations based on lists and skiplists. Our linearizability proofs are fully mechanized in the concurrent separation logic Iris. The proofs are modular and cover the broader design space of the underlying algorithms by parameterizing the verification over aspects such as…
▽ More
We present and verify template algorithms for lock-free concurrent search structures that cover a broad range of existing implementations based on lists and skiplists. Our linearizability proofs are fully mechanized in the concurrent separation logic Iris. The proofs are modular and cover the broader design space of the underlying algorithms by parameterizing the verification over aspects such as the low-level representation of nodes and the style of data structure maintenance. As a further technical contribution, we present a mechanization of a recently proposed method for reasoning about future-dependent linearization points using hindsight arguments. The mechanization builds on Iris' support for prophecy reasoning and user-defined ghost resources. We demonstrate that the method can help to reduce the proof effort compared to direct prophecy-based proofs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
On the calibration of compartmental epidemiological models
Authors:
Nikunj Gupta,
Anh Mai,
Azza Abouzied,
Dennis Shasha
Abstract:
Epidemiological compartmental models are useful for understanding infectious disease propagation and directing public health policy decisions. Calibration of these models is an important step in offering accurate forecasts of disease dynamics and the effectiveness of interventions. In this study, we present an overview of calibrating strategies that can be employed, including several optimization…
▽ More
Epidemiological compartmental models are useful for understanding infectious disease propagation and directing public health policy decisions. Calibration of these models is an important step in offering accurate forecasts of disease dynamics and the effectiveness of interventions. In this study, we present an overview of calibrating strategies that can be employed, including several optimization methods and reinforcement learning (RL). We discuss the benefits and drawbacks of these methods and highlight relevant practical conclusions from our experiments. Optimization methods iteratively adjust the parameters of the model until the model output matches the available data, whereas RL uses trial and error to learn the optimal set of parameters by maximizing a reward signal. Finally, we discuss how the calibration of parameters of epidemiological compartmental models is an emerging field that has the potential to improve the accuracy of disease modeling and public health decision-making. Further research is needed to validate the effectiveness and scalability of these approaches in different epidemiological contexts. All codes and resources are available on \url{https://github.com/Nikunj-Gupta/On-the-Calibration-of-Compartmental-Epidemiological-Models}. We hope this work can facilitate related research.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Planning Multiple Epidemic Interventions with Reinforcement Learning
Authors:
Anh Mai,
Nikunj Gupta,
Azza Abouzied,
Dennis Shasha
Abstract:
Combating an epidemic entails finding a plan that describes when and how to apply different interventions, such as mask-wearing mandates, vaccinations, school or workplace closures. An optimal plan will curb an epidemic with minimal loss of life, disease burden, and economic cost. Finding an optimal plan is an intractable computational problem in realistic settings. Policy-makers, however, would g…
▽ More
Combating an epidemic entails finding a plan that describes when and how to apply different interventions, such as mask-wearing mandates, vaccinations, school or workplace closures. An optimal plan will curb an epidemic with minimal loss of life, disease burden, and economic cost. Finding an optimal plan is an intractable computational problem in realistic settings. Policy-makers, however, would greatly benefit from tools that can efficiently search for plans that minimize disease and economic costs especially when considering multiple possible interventions over a continuous and complex action space given a continuous and equally complex state space. We formulate this problem as a Markov decision process. Our formulation is unique in its ability to represent multiple continuous interventions over any disease model defined by ordinary differential equations. We illustrate how to effectively apply state-of-the-art actor-critic reinforcement learning algorithms (PPO and SAC) to search for plans that minimize overall costs. We empirically evaluate the learning performance of these algorithms and compare their performance to hand-crafted baselines that mimic plans constructed by policy-makers. Our method outperforms baselines. Our work confirms the viability of a computational approach to support policy-makers
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2023; v1 submitted 30 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Forgetful Forests: high performance learning data structures for streaming data under concept drift
Authors:
Zhehu Yuan,
Yinqi Sun,
Dennis Shasha
Abstract:
Database research can help machine learning performance in many ways. One way is to design better data structures. This paper combines the use of incremental computation and sequential and probabilistic filtering to enable "forgetful" tree-based learning algorithms to cope with concept drift data (i.e., data whose function from input to classification changes over time).
The forgetful algorithms…
▽ More
Database research can help machine learning performance in many ways. One way is to design better data structures. This paper combines the use of incremental computation and sequential and probabilistic filtering to enable "forgetful" tree-based learning algorithms to cope with concept drift data (i.e., data whose function from input to classification changes over time).
The forgetful algorithms described in this paper achieve high time performance while maintaining high quality predictions on streaming data. Specifically, the algorithms are up to 24 times faster than state-of-the-art incremental algorithms with at most a 2% loss of accuracy, or at least twice faster without any loss of accuracy. This makes such structures suitable for high volume streaming applications.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Classification Under Ambiguity: When Is Average-K Better Than Top-K?
Authors:
Titouan Lorieul,
Alexis Joly,
Dennis Shasha
Abstract:
When many labels are possible, choosing a single one can lead to low precision. A common alternative, referred to as top-$K$ classification, is to choose some number $K$ (commonly around 5) and to return the $K$ labels with the highest scores. Unfortunately, for unambiguous cases, $K>1$ is too many and, for very ambiguous cases, $K \leq 5$ (for example) can be too small. An alternative sensible st…
▽ More
When many labels are possible, choosing a single one can lead to low precision. A common alternative, referred to as top-$K$ classification, is to choose some number $K$ (commonly around 5) and to return the $K$ labels with the highest scores. Unfortunately, for unambiguous cases, $K>1$ is too many and, for very ambiguous cases, $K \leq 5$ (for example) can be too small. An alternative sensible strategy is to use an adaptive approach in which the number of labels returned varies as a function of the computed ambiguity, but must average to some particular $K$ over all the samples. We denote this alternative average-$K$ classification. This paper formally characterizes the ambiguity profile when average-$K$ classification can achieve a lower error rate than a fixed top-$K$ classification. Moreover, it provides natural estimation procedures for both the fixed-size and the adaptive classifier and proves their consistency. Finally, it reports experiments on real-world image data sets revealing the benefit of average-$K$ classification over top-$K$ in practice. Overall, when the ambiguity is known precisely, average-$K$ is never worse than top-$K$, and, in our experiments, when it is estimated, this also holds.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Verifying Concurrent Multicopy Search Structures
Authors:
Nisarg Patel,
Siddharth Krishna,
Dennis Shasha,
Thomas Wies
Abstract:
Multicopy search structures such as log-structured merge (LSM) trees are optimized for high insert/update/delete (collectively known as upsert) performance. In such data structures, an upsert on key $k$, which adds $(k,v)$ where $v$ can be a value or a tombstone, is added to the root node even if $k$ is already present in other nodes. Thus there may be multiple copies of $k$ in the search structur…
▽ More
Multicopy search structures such as log-structured merge (LSM) trees are optimized for high insert/update/delete (collectively known as upsert) performance. In such data structures, an upsert on key $k$, which adds $(k,v)$ where $v$ can be a value or a tombstone, is added to the root node even if $k$ is already present in other nodes. Thus there may be multiple copies of $k$ in the search structure. A search on $k$ aims to return the value associated with the most recent upsert. We present a general framework for verifying linearizability of concurrent multicopy search structures that abstracts from the underlying representation of the data structure in memory, enabling proof-reuse across diverse implementations. Based on our framework, we propose template algorithms for a) LSM structures forming arbitrary directed acyclic graphs and b) differential file structures, and formally verify these templates in the concurrent separation logic Iris. We also instantiate the LSM template to obtain the first verified concurrent in-memory LSM tree implementation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Robotic Room Traversal using Optical Range Finding
Authors:
Cole Smith,
Eric Lin,
Dennis Shasha
Abstract:
Consider the goal of visiting every part of a room that is not blocked by obstacles. Doing so efficiently requires both sensors and planning. Our findings suggest a method of inexpensive optical range finding for robotic room traversal. Our room traversal algorithm relies upon the approximate distance from the robot to the nearest obstacle in 360 degrees. We then choose the path with the furthest…
▽ More
Consider the goal of visiting every part of a room that is not blocked by obstacles. Doing so efficiently requires both sensors and planning. Our findings suggest a method of inexpensive optical range finding for robotic room traversal. Our room traversal algorithm relies upon the approximate distance from the robot to the nearest obstacle in 360 degrees. We then choose the path with the furthest approximate distance. Since millimeter-precision is not required for our problem, we have opted to develop our own laser range finding solution, in lieu of using more common, but also expensive solutions like light detection and ranging (LIDAR). Rather, our solution uses a laser that casts a visible dot on the target and a common camera (an iPhone, for example). Based upon where in the camera frame the laser dot is detected, we may calculate an angle between our target and the laser aperture. Using this angle and the known distance between the camera eye and the laser aperture, we may solve all sides of a trigonometric model which provides the distance between the robot and the target.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
BugDoc: Algorithms to Debug Computational Processes
Authors:
Raoni Lourenço,
Juliana Freire,
Dennis Shasha
Abstract:
Data analysis for scientific experiments and enterprises, large-scale simulations, and machine learning tasks all entail the use of complex computational pipelines to reach quantitative and qualitative conclusions. If some of the activities in a pipeline produce erroneous outputs, the pipeline may fail to execute or produce incorrect results. Inferring the root cause(s) of such failures is challen…
▽ More
Data analysis for scientific experiments and enterprises, large-scale simulations, and machine learning tasks all entail the use of complex computational pipelines to reach quantitative and qualitative conclusions. If some of the activities in a pipeline produce erroneous outputs, the pipeline may fail to execute or produce incorrect results. Inferring the root cause(s) of such failures is challenging, usually requiring time and much human thought, while still being error-prone. We propose a new approach that makes use of iteration and provenance to automatically infer the root causes and derive succinct explanations of failures. Through a detailed experimental evaluation, we assess the cost, precision, and recall of our approach compared to the state of the art. Our experimental data and processing software is available for use, reproducibility, and enhancement.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
MultiRI: Fast Subgraph Matching in Labeled Multigraphs
Authors:
Giovanni Micale,
Vincenzo Bonnici,
Alfredo Ferro,
Dennis Shasha,
Rosalba Giugno,
Alfredo Pulvirenti
Abstract:
The Subgraph Matching (SM) problem consists of finding all the embeddings of a given small graph, called the query, into a large graph, called the target. The SM problem has been widely studied for simple graphs, i.e. graphs where there is exactly one edge between two nodes and nodes have single labels, but few approaches have been devised for labeled multigraphs, i.e. graphs having possibly multi…
▽ More
The Subgraph Matching (SM) problem consists of finding all the embeddings of a given small graph, called the query, into a large graph, called the target. The SM problem has been widely studied for simple graphs, i.e. graphs where there is exactly one edge between two nodes and nodes have single labels, but few approaches have been devised for labeled multigraphs, i.e. graphs having possibly multiple labels on nodes in which pair of nodes may have multiple labeled edges between them. Here we present MultiRI, a novel algorithm for the Sub-Multigraph Matching (SMM) problem, i.e. subgraph matching in labeled multigraphs. MultiRI improves on the state-of-the-art by computing compatibility domains and symmetry breaking conditions on query nodes to filter the search space of possible solutions. Empirically, we show that MultiRI outperforms the state-of-the-art method for the SMM problem in both synthetic and real graphs, with a multiplicative speedup between five and ten for large graphs, by using a limited amount of memory.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Debugging Machine Learning Pipelines
Authors:
Raoni Lourenço,
Juliana Freire,
Dennis Shasha
Abstract:
Machine learning tasks entail the use of complex computational pipelines to reach quantitative and qualitative conclusions. If some of the activities in a pipeline produce erroneous or uninformative outputs, the pipeline may fail or produce incorrect results. Inferring the root cause of failures and unexpected behavior is challenging, usually requiring much human thought, and is both time-consumin…
▽ More
Machine learning tasks entail the use of complex computational pipelines to reach quantitative and qualitative conclusions. If some of the activities in a pipeline produce erroneous or uninformative outputs, the pipeline may fail or produce incorrect results. Inferring the root cause of failures and unexpected behavior is challenging, usually requiring much human thought, and is both time-consuming and error-prone. We propose a new approach that makes use of iteration and provenance to automatically infer the root causes and derive succinct explanations of failures. Through a detailed experimental evaluation, we assess the cost, precision, and recall of our approach compared to the state of the art. Our source code and experimental data will be available for reproducibility and enhancement.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Go with the Flow: Compositional Abstractions for Concurrent Data Structures (Extended Version)
Authors:
Siddharth Krishna,
Dennis Shasha,
Thomas Wies
Abstract:
Concurrent separation logics have helped to significantly simplify correctness proofs for concurrent data structures. However, a recurring problem in such proofs is that data structure abstractions that work well in the sequential setting are much harder to reason about in a concurrent setting due to complex sharing and overlays. To solve this problem, we propose a novel approach to abstracting re…
▽ More
Concurrent separation logics have helped to significantly simplify correctness proofs for concurrent data structures. However, a recurring problem in such proofs is that data structure abstractions that work well in the sequential setting are much harder to reason about in a concurrent setting due to complex sharing and overlays. To solve this problem, we propose a novel approach to abstracting regions in the heap by encoding the data structure invariant into a local condition on each individual node. This condition may depend on a quantity associated with the node that is computed as a fixpoint over the entire heap graph. We refer to this quantity as a flow. Flows can encode both structural properties of the heap (e.g. the reachable nodes from the root form a tree) as well as data invariants (e.g. sortedness). We then introduce the notion of a flow interface, which expresses the relies and guarantees that a heap region imposes on its context to maintain the local flow invariant with respect to the global heap. Our main technical result is that this notion leads to a new semantic model of separation logic. In this model, flow interfaces provide a general abstraction mechanism for describing complex data structures. This abstraction mechanism admits proof rules that generalize over a wide variety of data structures. To demonstrate the versatility of our approach, we show how to extend the logic RGSep with flow interfaces. We have used this new logic to prove linearizability and memory safety of nontrivial concurrent data structures. In particular, we obtain parametric linearizability proofs for concurrent dictionary algorithms that abstract from the details of the underlying data structure representation. These proofs cannot be easily expressed using the abstraction mechanisms provided by existing separation logics.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
A Collaborative Approach to Computational Reproducibility
Authors:
Fernando Chirigati,
Rebecca Capone,
Dennis Shasha,
Remi Rampin,
Juliana Freire
Abstract:
Although a standard in natural science, reproducibility has been only episodically applied in experimental computer science. Scientific papers often present a large number of tables, plots and pictures that summarize the obtained results, but then loosely describe the steps taken to derive them. Not only can the methods and the implementation be complex, but also their configuration may require se…
▽ More
Although a standard in natural science, reproducibility has been only episodically applied in experimental computer science. Scientific papers often present a large number of tables, plots and pictures that summarize the obtained results, but then loosely describe the steps taken to derive them. Not only can the methods and the implementation be complex, but also their configuration may require setting many parameters and/or depend on particular system configurations. While many researchers recognize the importance of reproducibility, the challenge of making it happen often outweigh the benefits. Fortunately, a plethora of reproducibility solutions have been recently designed and implemented by the community. In particular, packaging tools (e.g., ReproZip) and virtualization tools (e.g., Docker) are promising solutions towards facilitating reproducibility for both authors and reviewers. To address the incentive problem, we have implemented a new publication model for the Reproducibility Section of Information Systems Journal. In this section, authors submit a reproducibility paper that explains in detail the computational assets from a previous published manuscript in Information Systems.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
SafePredict: A Meta-Algorithm for Machine Learning That Uses Refusals to Guarantee Correctness
Authors:
Mustafa A. Kocak,
David Ramirez,
Elza Erkip,
Dennis E. Shasha
Abstract:
SafePredict is a novel meta-algorithm that works with any base prediction algorithm for online data to guarantee an arbitrarily chosen correctness rate, $1-ε$, by allowing refusals. Allowing refusals means that the meta-algorithm may refuse to emit a prediction produced by the base algorithm on occasion so that the error rate on non-refused predictions does not exceed $ε$. The SafePredict error bo…
▽ More
SafePredict is a novel meta-algorithm that works with any base prediction algorithm for online data to guarantee an arbitrarily chosen correctness rate, $1-ε$, by allowing refusals. Allowing refusals means that the meta-algorithm may refuse to emit a prediction produced by the base algorithm on occasion so that the error rate on non-refused predictions does not exceed $ε$. The SafePredict error bound does not rely on any assumptions on the data distribution or the base predictor. When the base predictor happens not to exceed the target error rate $ε$, SafePredict refuses only a finite number of times. When the error rate of the base predictor changes through time SafePredict makes use of a weight-shifting heuristic that adapts to these changes without knowing when the changes occur yet still maintains the correctness guarantee. Empirical results show that (i) SafePredict compares favorably with state-of-the art confidence based refusal mechanisms which fail to offer robust error guarantees; and (ii) combining SafePredict with such refusal mechanisms can in many cases further reduce the number of refusals. Our software (currently in Python) is included in the supplementary material.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2017; v1 submitted 21 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Constellation Queries over Big Data
Authors:
Fabio Porto,
Amir Khatibi,
João R. Nobre,
Eduardo Ogasawara,
Patrick Valduriez,
Dennis Shasha
Abstract:
A geometrical pattern is a set of points with all pairwise distances (or, more generally, relative distances) specified. Finding matches to such patterns has applications to spatial data in seismic, astronomical, and transportation contexts. For example, a particularly interesting geometric pattern in astronomy is the Einstein cross, which is an astronomical phenomenon in which a single quasar is…
▽ More
A geometrical pattern is a set of points with all pairwise distances (or, more generally, relative distances) specified. Finding matches to such patterns has applications to spatial data in seismic, astronomical, and transportation contexts. For example, a particularly interesting geometric pattern in astronomy is the Einstein cross, which is an astronomical phenomenon in which a single quasar is observed as four distinct sky objects (due to gravitational lensing) when captured by earth telescopes. Finding such crosses, as well as other geometric patterns, is a challenging problem as the potential number of sets of elements that compose shapes is exponentially large in the size of the dataset and the pattern. In this paper, we denote geometric patterns as constellation queries and propose algorithms to find them in large data applications. Our methods combine quadtrees, matrix multiplication, and unindexed join processing to discover sets of points that match a geometric pattern within some additive factor on the pairwise distances. Our distributed experiments show that the choice of composition algorithm (matrix multiplication or nested loops) depends on the freedom introduced in the query geometry through the distance additive factor. Three clearly identified blocks of threshold values guide the choice of the best composition algorithm. Finally, solving the problem for relative distances requires a novel continuous-to-discrete transformation. To the best of our knowledge this paper is the first to investigate constellation queries at scale.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
A model project for reproducible papers: critical temperature for the Ising model on a square lattice
Authors:
M. Dolfi,
J. Gukelberger,
A. Hehn,
J. Imriška,
K. Pakrouski,
T. F. Rønnow,
M. Troyer,
I. Zintchenko,
F. Chirigati,
J. Freire,
D. Shasha
Abstract:
In this paper we present a simple, yet typical simulation in statistical physics, consisting of large scale Monte Carlo simulations followed by an involved statistical analysis of the results. The purpose is to provide an example publication to explore tools for writing reproducible papers. The simulation estimates the critical temperature where the Ising model on the square lattice becomes magnet…
▽ More
In this paper we present a simple, yet typical simulation in statistical physics, consisting of large scale Monte Carlo simulations followed by an involved statistical analysis of the results. The purpose is to provide an example publication to explore tools for writing reproducible papers. The simulation estimates the critical temperature where the Ising model on the square lattice becomes magnetic to be Tc /J = 2.26934(6) using a finite size scaling analysis of the crossing points of Binder cumulants. We provide a virtual machine which can be used to reproduce all figures and results.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Locality Optimization for Data Parallel Programs
Authors:
Eric Hielscher,
Alex Rubinsteyn,
Dennis Shasha
Abstract:
Productivity languages such as NumPy and Matlab make it much easier to implement data-intensive numerical algorithms. However, these languages can be intolerably slow for programs that don't map well to their built-in primitives. In this paper, we discuss locality optimizations for our system Parakeet, a just-in-time compiler and runtime system for an array-oriented subset of Python. Parakeet dyna…
▽ More
Productivity languages such as NumPy and Matlab make it much easier to implement data-intensive numerical algorithms. However, these languages can be intolerably slow for programs that don't map well to their built-in primitives. In this paper, we discuss locality optimizations for our system Parakeet, a just-in-time compiler and runtime system for an array-oriented subset of Python. Parakeet dynamically compiles whole user functions to high performance multi-threaded native code. Parakeet makes extensive use of the classic data parallel operators Map, Reduce, and Scan. We introduce a new set of data parallel operators,TiledMap, TiledReduce, and TiledScan, that break up their computations into local pieces of bounded size so as better to make use of small fast memories. We introduce a novel tiling transformation to generate tiled operators automatically. Applying this transformation once tiles the program for cache, and applying it again enables tiling for registers. The sizes for cache tiles are left unspecified until runtime, when an autotuning search is performed. Finally, we evaluate our optimizations on benchmarks and show significant speedups on programs that exhibit data locality.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
