-
A thermodynamic basis for prebiotic amino acid synthesis and the nature of the first genetic code
Authors:
Paul G. Higgs,
Ralph E. Pudritz
Abstract:
Of the twenty amino acids used in proteins, ten were formed in Miller's atmospheric discharge experiments. The two other major proposed sources of prebiotic amino acid synthesis include formation in hydrothermal vents and delivery to Earth via meteorites. We combine observational and experimental data of amino acid frequencies formed by these diverse mechanisms and show that, regardless of the s…
▽ More
Of the twenty amino acids used in proteins, ten were formed in Miller's atmospheric discharge experiments. The two other major proposed sources of prebiotic amino acid synthesis include formation in hydrothermal vents and delivery to Earth via meteorites. We combine observational and experimental data of amino acid frequencies formed by these diverse mechanisms and show that, regardless of the source, these ten early amino acids can be ranked in order of decreasing abundance in prebiotic contexts. This order can be predicted by thermodynamics. The relative abundances of the early amino acids were most likely reflected in the composition of the first proteins at the time the genetic code originated. The remaining amino acids were incorporated into proteins after pathways for their biochemical synthesis evolved. This is consistent with theories of the evolution of the genetic code by stepwise addition of new amino acids. These are hints that key aspects of early biochemistry may be universal.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.
-
The Mechanisms of Codon Reassignments in Mitochondrial Genetic Codes
Authors:
Supratim Sengupta,
Xiaoguang Yang,
Paul G. Higgs
Abstract:
Many cases of non-standard genetic codes are known in mitochondrial genomes. We carry out analysis of phylogeny and codon usage of organisms for which the complete mitochondrial genome is available, and we determine the most likely mechanism for codon reassignment in each case. Reassignment events can be classified according to the gain-loss framework. The gain represents the appearance of a new…
▽ More
Many cases of non-standard genetic codes are known in mitochondrial genomes. We carry out analysis of phylogeny and codon usage of organisms for which the complete mitochondrial genome is available, and we determine the most likely mechanism for codon reassignment in each case. Reassignment events can be classified according to the gain-loss framework. The gain represents the appearance of a new tRNA for the reassigned codon or the change of an existing tRNA such that it gains the ability to pair with the codon. The loss represents the deletion of a tRNA or the change in a tRNA so that it no longer translates the codon. One possible mechanism is Codon Disappearance, where the codon disappears from the genome prior to the gain and loss events. In the alternative mechanisms the codon does not disappear. In the Unassigned Codon mechanism, the loss occurs first, whereas in the Ambiguous Intermediate mechanism, the gain occurs first. Codon usage analysis gives clear evidence of cases where the codon disappeared at the point of the reassignment and also cases where it did not disappear. Codon disappearance is the probable explanation for stop to sense reassignments and a small number of reassignments of sense codons. However, the majority of sense to sense reassignments cannot be explained by codon disappearance. In the latter cases, by analysis of the presence or absence of tRNAs in the genome and of the changes in tRNA sequences, it is sometimes possible to distinguish between the Unassigned Codon and Ambiguous Intermediate mechanisms. We emphasize that not all reassignments follow the same scenario and that it is necessary to consider the details of each case carefully.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2007;
originally announced March 2007.
-
The response of amino acid frequencies to directional mutation pressure in mitochondrial genome sequences is related to the physical properties of the amino acids and to the structure of the genetic code
Authors:
Daniel Urbina,
Bin Tang,
Paul G. Higgs
Abstract:
The frequencies of A, C, G and T in mitochondrial DNA vary among species due to unequal rates of mutation between the bases. The frequencies of bases at four-fold degenerate sites respond directly to mutation pressure. At 1st and 2nd positions, selection reduces the degree of frequency variation. Using a simple evolutionary model, we show that 1st position sites are less constrained by selection…
▽ More
The frequencies of A, C, G and T in mitochondrial DNA vary among species due to unequal rates of mutation between the bases. The frequencies of bases at four-fold degenerate sites respond directly to mutation pressure. At 1st and 2nd positions, selection reduces the degree of frequency variation. Using a simple evolutionary model, we show that 1st position sites are less constrained by selection than 2nd position sites, and therefore that the frequencies of bases at 1st position are more responsive to mutation pressure than those at 2nd position. We define a similarity measure between amino acids that is a function of 8 measured physical properties. We define a proximity measure for each amino acid, which is the average similarity between an amino acid and all others that are accessible via single point mutations in the genetic code. We also define a responsiveness for each amino acid, which measures how rapidly an amino acid frequency changes as a result of mutation pressure acting on the base frequencies. There is a strong correlation between responsiveness and proximity, and both these quantities are also correlated with the mutability of amino acids estimated from the mtREV substitution rate matrix. We also consider the variation of base frequencies between strands and between genes on a strand. These trends are consistent with the patterns expected from analysis of the variation among genomes
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2005;
originally announced September 2005.
-
A Unified Model of Codon Reassignment in Alternative Genetic Codes
Authors:
Supratim Sengupta,
Paul G. Higgs
Abstract:
Many modified genetic codes are found in specific genomes in which one or more codons have been reassigned to a different amino acid from that in the canonical code. We present a model that unifies four possible mechanisms for reassignment, based on the observation that reassignment involves a gain and a loss. The loss could be the deletion or loss of function of a tRNA or release factor. The ga…
▽ More
Many modified genetic codes are found in specific genomes in which one or more codons have been reassigned to a different amino acid from that in the canonical code. We present a model that unifies four possible mechanisms for reassignment, based on the observation that reassignment involves a gain and a loss. The loss could be the deletion or loss of function of a tRNA or release factor. The gain could be the gain of a new type of tRNA for the reassigned codon, or the gain of function of an existing tRNA due to a mutation or a base modification. In the codon disappearance mechanism, the codon disappears from the genome during the period of reassignment. In the other mechanisms, the codon does not disappear. In the ambiguous intermediate mechanism, the gain precedes the loss; in the unassigned codon mechanism, the loss precedes the gain; and in the compensatory change mechanism, the loss and gain spread through the population simultaneously. We present simulations of the gain-loss model and demonstrate that all four mechanisms are possible. The frequencies of the different mechanisms are influenced by selection strengths, number of codons undergoing reassignment, directional mutation pressure and the possibility of selection for reduced genome size.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2005; v1 submitted 19 October, 2004;
originally announced October 2004.
-
RNA-based Phylogenetic Methods: Application to Mammalian Mitochondrial RNA Sequences
Authors:
Cendrine Hudelot,
Vivek Gowri-Shankar,
Howsun Jow,
Magnus Rattray,
Paul G. Higgs
Abstract:
The PHASE software package allows phylogenetic tree construction with a number of evolutionary models designed specifically for use with RNA sequences that have conserved secondary structure. Evolution in the paired regions of RNAs occurs via compensatory substitutions, hence changes on either side of a pair are correlated. Accounting for this correlation is important for phylogenetic inference…
▽ More
The PHASE software package allows phylogenetic tree construction with a number of evolutionary models designed specifically for use with RNA sequences that have conserved secondary structure. Evolution in the paired regions of RNAs occurs via compensatory substitutions, hence changes on either side of a pair are correlated. Accounting for this correlation is important for phylogenetic inference because it affects the likelihood calculation. In the present study we use the complete set of tRNA and rRNA sequences from 69 complete mammalian mitochondrial genomes. The likelihood calculation uses two evolutionary models simultaneously for different parts of the sequence: a paired-site model for the paired sites and a single-site model for the unpaired sites. We use Bayesian phylogenetic methods and a Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm is used to obtain the most probable trees and posterior probabilities of clades. The results are well resolved for almost all the important branches on the mammalian tree. They support the arrangement of mammalian orders within the four supra-ordinal clades that have been identified by studies of much larger data sets mainly comprising nuclear genes. Groups such as the hedgehogs and the murid rodents, which have been problematic in previous studies with mitochondrial proteins, appear in their expected position with the other members of their order. Our choice of genes and evolutionary model appears to be more reliable and less subject to biases caused by variation in base composition than previous studies with mitochondrial genomes.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2004;
originally announced April 2004.
-
Comparison of tRNA and rRNA Phylogenies in Proteobacteria: Implications for the Frequency of Horizontal Gene Transfer
Authors:
Bin Tang,
Philippe Boisvert,
Paul G. Higgs
Abstract:
The current picture of bacterial evolution is based largely on studies of 16S rRNA. However, this is just one gene. It is known that horizontal gene transfer can occur between bacterial species, although the frequency and implications of this are not fully understood. If horizontal transfer were frequent, there would be no single evolutionary tree for bacteria because each gene would follow a di…
▽ More
The current picture of bacterial evolution is based largely on studies of 16S rRNA. However, this is just one gene. It is known that horizontal gene transfer can occur between bacterial species, although the frequency and implications of this are not fully understood. If horizontal transfer were frequent, there would be no single evolutionary tree for bacteria because each gene would follow a different tree. We carried out phylogenetic analyses of rRNA and tRNA genes from Proteobacteria (a diverse group for which many complete genome sequences are available) using RNA-specific phylogenetic methods that account for the conservation of the secondary structure. We compared trees for 16S rRNA and 23S rRNA with those derived from concatenated alignments of 29 tRNA genes that are found in all the genomes studied. The tRNA genes are scattered throughout the genomes, and would not follow the same evolutionary history if horizontal transfer were frequent. Nevertheless, the tRNA tree is consistent with the rRNA tree in most respects. Minor differences can almost all be attributed to uncertainty or unreliability of the phylogenetic method. We therefore conclude that tRNA genes give a coherent picture of the phylogeny of the organisms, and that horizontal transfer of tRNAs is too rare to obscure the signal of the organismal tree. Some tRNA genes are not present in all the genomes. We discuss possible explanations for the observed patterns of presence and absence of genes: these involve gene deletion, gene duplication, and mutations in the tRNA anticodons.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2004;
originally announced April 2004.
-
The Evolution of tRNA-Leu Genes in Animal Mitochondrial Genomes
Authors:
P. G. Higgs,
D. Jameson,
H. Jow,
M. Rattray
Abstract:
Animal mitochondrial genomes usually have two transfer RNAs for Leucine: one, with anticodon UAG, translates the four-codon family CUN, whilst the other, with anticodon UAA, translates the two-codon family UUR. These two genes must differ at the third anticodon position, but in some species the genes differ at many additional sites, indicating that these genes have been independent for a long ti…
▽ More
Animal mitochondrial genomes usually have two transfer RNAs for Leucine: one, with anticodon UAG, translates the four-codon family CUN, whilst the other, with anticodon UAA, translates the two-codon family UUR. These two genes must differ at the third anticodon position, but in some species the genes differ at many additional sites, indicating that these genes have been independent for a long time. Duplication and deletion of genes in mitochondrial genomes occurs frequently during the evolution of the Metazoa. If a tRNA-Leu gene were duplicated and a substitution occurred in the anticodon, this would effectively turn one type of tRNA into the other. The original copy of the second tRNA type might then be lost by a deletion elsewhere in the genome. There are several groups of species in which the two tRNA-Leu genes occur next to one another (or very close) on the genome, which suggests that tandem duplication has occurred. Here we use RNA-specific phylogenetic methods to determine evolutionary trees for both genes. We present evidence that the process of duplication, anticodon mutation and deletion of tRNA-Leu genes has occurred at least five times during the evolution of the Metazoa - once in the common ancestor of all Protostomes, once in the common ancestor of Echinoderms and Hemichordates, once in the hermit crab, and twice independently in Molluscs.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2003;
originally announced October 2003.
-
Food Web Structure and the Evolution of Ecological Communities
Authors:
Christopher Quince,
Paul G. Higgs,
Alan J. McKane
Abstract:
Simulations of the coevolution of many interacting species are performed using the Webworld model. The model has a realistic set of predator-prey equations that describe the population dynamics of the species for any structure of the food web. The equations account for competition between species for the same resources, and for the diet choice of predators between alternative prey according to a…
▽ More
Simulations of the coevolution of many interacting species are performed using the Webworld model. The model has a realistic set of predator-prey equations that describe the population dynamics of the species for any structure of the food web. The equations account for competition between species for the same resources, and for the diet choice of predators between alternative prey according to an evolutionarily stable strategy. The set of species present undergoes long-term evolution due to speciation and extinction events. We summarize results obtained on the macro-evolutionary dynamics of speciations and extinctions, and on the statistical properties of the food webs that are generated by the model. Simulations begin from small numbers of species and build up to larger webs with relatively constant species number on average. The rate of origination and extinction of species are relatively high, but remain roughly balanced throughout the simulations. When a `parent' species undergoes speciation, the `child' species usually adds to the same trophic level as the parent. The chance of the child species surviving is significantly higher if the parent is on the second or third trophic level than if it is on the first level, most likely due to a wider choice of possible prey for species on higher levels. Addition of a new species sometimes causes extinction of existing species. The parent species has a high probability of extinction because it has strong competition with the new species. Non-parental competitors of the new species also have a significantly higher extinction probability than average, as do prey of the new species. Predators of the new species are less likely than average to become extinct.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2001;
originally announced May 2001.
-
The Influence of Predator-Prey Population Dynamics on the Long-term Evolution of Food Web Structure
Authors:
Barbara Drossel,
Paul G. Higgs,
Alan J. McKane
Abstract:
We develop a set of equations to describe the population dynamics of many interacting species in food webs. Predator-prey interactions are non-linear, and are based on ratio-dependent functional responses. The equations account for competition for resources between members of the same species, and between members of different species. Predators divide their total hunting/foraging effort between…
▽ More
We develop a set of equations to describe the population dynamics of many interacting species in food webs. Predator-prey interactions are non-linear, and are based on ratio-dependent functional responses. The equations account for competition for resources between members of the same species, and between members of different species. Predators divide their total hunting/foraging effort between the available prey species according to an evolutionarily stable strategy (ESS). The ESS foraging behaviour does not correspond to the predictions of optimal foraging theory. We use the population dynamics equations in simulations of the Webworld model of evolving ecosystems. New species are added to an existing food web due to speciation events, whilst species become extinct due to coevolution and competition. We study the dynamics of species-diversity in Webworld on a macro-evolutionary timescale. Coevolutionary interactions are strong enough to cause continuous overturn of species, in contrast to our previous Webworld simulations with simpler population dynamics. Although there are significant fluctuations in species diversity because of speciation and extinction, very large scale extinction avalanches appear to be absent from the dynamics, and we find no evidence for self-organised criticality.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2000;
originally announced February 2000.
-
Modelling coevolution in multispecies communities
Authors:
Guido Caldarelli,
Paul G. Higgs,
Alan J. McKane
Abstract:
We introduce the Webworld model, which links together the ecological modelling of food web structure with the evolutionary modelling of speciation and extinction events. The model describes dynamics of ecological communities on an evolutionary timescale. Species are defined as sets of characteristic features, and these features are used to determine interaction scores between species. A simple r…
▽ More
We introduce the Webworld model, which links together the ecological modelling of food web structure with the evolutionary modelling of speciation and extinction events. The model describes dynamics of ecological communities on an evolutionary timescale. Species are defined as sets of characteristic features, and these features are used to determine interaction scores between species. A simple rule is used to transfer resources from the external environment through the food web to each of the species, and to determine mean population sizes. A time step in the model represents a speciation event. A new species is added with features similar to those of one of the existing species and a new food web structure is then calculated. The new species may (i) add stably to the web, (ii) become extinct immediately because it is poorly adapted, or (iii) cause one or more other species to become extinct due to competition for resources. We measure various properties of the model webs and compare these with data on real food webs. These properties include the proportions of basal, intermediate and top species, the number of links per species and the number of trophic levels. We also study the evolutionary dynamics of the model ecosystem by following the fluctuations in the total number of species in the web. Extinction avalanches occur when novel organisms arise which are significantly better adapted than existing ones. We discuss these results in relation to the observed extinction events in the fossil record, and to the theory of self-organized criticality.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 1998; v1 submitted 16 January, 1998;
originally announced January 1998.