The Power of the Combined Basic Linear Programming and Affine Relaxation for Promise Constraint Satisfaction Problems

In the field of constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs), promise CSPs are an exciting new direction of study. In a promise CSP, each constraint comes in two forms: “strict” and “weak,” and in the associated decision problem one must distinguish between being able to satisfy all the strict constraints versus not being able to satisfy all the weak constraints. The most commonly cited example of a promise CSP is the approximate graph coloring problem-which has recently seen exciting progress [Bulín, Krokhin, and Oprs̆al, Proceedings of the Symposium on Theory of Computing, 2019, pp. 602--613 and Wrochna and Živný, Proceedings of the Symposium on Discrete Algorithms, 2020, pp. 1426--1435] benefiting from a systematic algebraic approach to promise CSPs based on “polymorphisms,” operations that map tuples in the strict form of each constraint to tuples in the corresponding weak form. In this work, we present a simple algorithm which in polynomial time solves the decision problem for all promise CSPs that admit infinitely many symmetric polymorphisms, which are invariant under arbitrary coordinate permutations. This generalizes previous work of the first two authors [Brakensiek and Guruswami, Proceedings of the Symposium on Discrete Algorithms, 2019, pp. 436--455]. We also extend this algorithm to a more general class of block-symmetric polymorphisms. As a corollary, this single algorithm solves all polynomial-time tractable Boolean CSPs simultaneously. These results give a new perspective on Schaefer's classic dichotomy theorem and shed further light on how symmetries of polymorphisms enable algorithms. Finally, we show that block symmetric polymorphisms are not only sufficient but also necessary for this algorithm to work, thus establishing its precise power.