Just Accepted
Assessing the Spatial-Temporal Causal Impact of COVID-19 Related Policies on Epidemic Spread
Accepted on 18 September 2024
Abstract
Analyzing the causal impact of various government-related policies on the epidemic spread is of critical importance. This paper aims to investigate the problem of assessing the causal effects of different COVID-19 related policies on the USA epidemic spread in different counties at any given time period, while eliminating biased interference from unobserved confounders (e.g., the vigilance of residents). However, the infection outcome of each region is influenced not only by its own confounding factors but also by policy interventions implemented in neighboring regions. Furthermore, the government policy index may exhibit a time-delay influence on outbreak dynamics. To this end, we implement observational data about different COVID-19 related policies (treatment) and outbreak dynamics (outcome) across different U.S. counties over time, and develop a causal framework that learns the representations of time-varying confounders to tackle the aforementioned issues. More specifically, we employ one recurrent structure to capture the accumulative effects stemming from the policy history and then utilize hypergraph neural network to model the interactions among spatial regions. Our experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed framework in quantifying the causal impact of different policy types on epidemics. Compared with baseline methods, our assessment provides valuable insights for future policy-making endeavors.
References
[1]
Alberto Abadie. 2005. Semiparametric difference-in-differences estimators. The Review of Economic Studies 72, 1 (2005), 1–19.
[2]
Clement Adebamowo, Oumou Bah-Sow, Fred Binka, Roberto Bruzzone, Arthur Caplan, Jean-François Delfraissy, David Heymann, Peter Horby, Pontiano Kaleebu, Jean-Jacques Muyembe Tamfum, et al. 2014. Randomised controlled trials for Ebola: practical and ethical issues. The Lancet 384, 9952 (2014), 1423–1424.
[3]
Song Bai, Feihu Zhang, and Philip HS Torr. 2021. Hypergraph convolution and hypergraph attention. Pattern Recognition 110 (2021), 107637.
[4]
Alessandro Basurto, Herbert Dawid, Philipp Harting, Jasper Hepp, and Dirk Kohlweyer. 2023. How to design virus containment policies? A joint analysis of economic and epidemic dynamics under the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of Economic Interaction and Coordination 18, 2 (2023), 311–370.
[5]
Abel Brodeur, David Gray, Anik Islam, and Suraiya Bhuiyan. 2021. A literature review of the economics of COVID-19. Journal of Economic Surveys 35, 4 (2021), 1007–1044.
[6]
Giliberto Capano, Michael Howlett, Darryl SL Jarvis, M Ramesh, and Nihit Goyal. 2020. Mobilizing policy (in) capacity to fight COVID-19: Understanding variations in state responses. Policy and Society 39, 3 (2020), 285–308.
[7]
Francesco Casella. 2020. Can the COVID-19 epidemic be controlled on the basis of daily test reports? IEEE Control Systems Letters 5, 3 (2020), 1079–1084.
[8]
Thomas C Chalmers, Harry Smith Jr, Bradley Blackburn, Bernard Silverman, Biruta Schroeder, Dinah Reitman, and Alexander Ambroz. 1981. A method for assessing the quality of a randomized control trial. Controlled clinical trials 2, 1 (1981), 31–49.
[9]
Cindy Cheng, Joan Barceló, Allison Spencer Hartnett, Robert Kubinec, and Luca Messerschmidt. 2020. COVID-19 government response event dataset (CoronaNet v. 1.0). Nature human behaviour 4, 7 (2020), 756–768.
[10]
Matthew A Cole, Robert JR Elliott, and Bowen Liu. 2020. The impact of the Wuhan Covid-19 lockdown on air pollution and health: a machine learning and augmented synthetic control approach. Environmental and Resource Economics 76, 4 (2020), 553–580.
[11]
Anthony Constantinou, Neville K Kitson, Yang Liu, Kiattikun Chobtham, Arian Hashemzadeh Amirkhizi, Praharsh A Nanavati, Rendani Mbuvha, and Bruno Petrungaro. 2023. Open problems in causal structure learning: A case study of COVID-19 in the UK. Expert Systems with Applications 234 (2023), 121069.
[12]
Sahraoui Dhelim, Liming Chen, Sajal K Das, Huansheng Ning, Chris Nugent, Gerard Leavey, Dirk Pesch, Eleanor Bantry-White, and Devin Burns. 2023. Detecting mental distresses using social behavior analysis in the context of COVID-19: A survey. Comput. Surveys 55, 14s (2023), 1–30.
[13]
Pinsheng Duan, Yang Miang Goh, and Jianliang Zhou. 2023. The impact of COVID-19 pandemic on construction safety in China and the US: A comparative study. Safety science 161 (2023), 106076.
[14]
Zeynep Ertem, Ozgur M Araz, and Mayteé Cruz-Aponte. 2022. A decision analytic approach for social distancing policies during early stages of COVID-19 pandemic. Decision Support Systems 161 (2022), 113630.
[15]
Navid Feroze. 2020. Forecasting the patterns of COVID-19 and causal impacts of lockdown in top five affected countries using Bayesian Structural Time Series Models. Chaos, Solitons & Fractals 140 (2020), 110196.
[16]
Oguzhan Gencoglu and Mathias Gruber. 2020. Causal modeling of twitter activity during covid-19. Computation 8, 4 (2020), 85.
[17]
Salah Ghamizi, Renaud Rwemalika, Maxime Cordy, Lisa Veiber, Tegawendé F Bissyandé, Mike Papadakis, Jacques Klein, and Yves Le Traon. 2020. Data-driven simulation and optimization for Covid-19 exit strategies. In Proceedings of the 26th ACM SIGKDD international conference on knowledge discovery & data mining. 3434–3442.
[18]
Andrew Goodman-Bacon and Jan Marcus. 2020. Using difference-in-differences to identify causal effects of COVID-19 policies. (2020).
[19]
Lawrence O Gostin, Eric A Friedman, Sara Hossain, Joia Mukherjee, Saman Zia-Zarifi, Chelsea Clinton, Umunyana Rugege, Paulo Buss, Miriam Were, and Ames Dhai. 2023. Human rights and the COVID-19 pandemic: a retrospective and prospective analysis. The Lancet 401, 10371 (2023), 154–168.
[20]
Ruocheng Guo, Jundong Li, and Huan Liu. 2020. Learning individual causal effects from networked observational data. In Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining. 232–240.
[21]
Thomas Hale, Noam Angrist, Rafael Goldszmidt, Beatriz Kira, Anna Petherick, Toby Phillips, Samuel Webster, Emily Cameron-Blake, Laura Hallas, Saptarshi Majumdar, et al. 2021. A global panel database of pandemic policies (Oxford COVID-19 Government Response Tracker). Nature human behaviour 5, 4 (2021), 529–538.
[22]
Daniel T Halperin, Norman Hearst, Stephen Hodgins, Robert C Bailey, Jeffrey D Klausner, Helen Jackson, Richard G Wamai, Joseph A Ladapo, Mead Over, Stefan Baral, et al. 2021. Revisiting COVID-19 policies: 10 evidence-based recommendations for where to go from here. BMC public health 21, 1 (2021), 1–12.
[23]
David Heckerman, Christopher Meek, and Gregory Cooper. 2006. A Bayesian approach to causal discovery. Innovations in Machine Learning: Theory and Applications (2006), 1–28.
[24]
Solomon Hsiang, Daniel Allen, Sébastien Annan-Phan, Kendon Bell, Ian Bolliger, Trinetta Chong, Hannah Druckenmiller, Luna Yue Huang, Andrew Hultgren, Emma Krasovich, et al. 2020. The effect of large-scale anti-contagion policies on the COVID-19 pandemic. Nature 584, 7820 (2020), 262–267.
[25]
Yimin Huang and Marco Valtorta. 2012. Pearl’s calculus of intervention is complete. arXiv preprint arXiv:1206.6831 (2012).
[26]
Renhe Jiang, Zhaonan Wang, Zekun Cai, Chuang Yang, Zipei Fan, Tianqi Xia, Go Matsubara, Hiroto Mizuseki, Xuan Song, and Ryosuke Shibasaki. 2021. Countrywide origin-destination matrix prediction and its application for covid-19. In Machine Learning and Knowledge Discovery in Databases. Applied Data Science Track: European Conference, ECML PKDD 2021, Bilbao, Spain, September 13–17, 2021, Proceedings, Part IV 21. Springer, 319–334.
[27]
Song Jiang and Yizhou Sun. 2022. Estimating Causal Effects on Networked Observational Data via Representation Learning. In Proceedings of the 31st ACM International Conference on Information & Knowledge Management. 852–861.
[28]
Kourtney Koebel and Dionne Pohler. 2020. Labor markets in crisis: The causal impact of Canada’s COVD19 economic shutdown on hours worked for workers across the earnings distribution. Technical Report. Working Paper Series.
[29]
Edward Kong and Daniel Prinz. 2020. Disentangling policy effects using proxy data: Which shutdown policies affected unemployment during the COVID-19 pandemic? Journal of Public Economics 189 (2020), 104257.
[30]
Werner Kristjanpoller, Kevin Michell, and Marcel C Minutolo. 2021. A causal framework to determine the effectiveness of dynamic quarantine policy to mitigate COVID-19. Applied Soft Computing 104 (2021), 107241.
[31]
Haoran Li, Zhiqiang Lv, Jianbo Li, Zhihao Xu, Yue Wang, Haokai Sun, and Zhaoyu Sheng. 2023. Traffic flow forecasting in the covid-19: A deep spatial-temporal model based on discrete wavelet transformation. ACM Transactions on Knowledge Discovery from Data 17, 5 (2023), 1–28.
[32]
Lili Li, Araz Taeihagh, and Si Ying Tan. 2023. A scoping review of the impacts of COVID-19 physical distancing measures on vulnerable population groups. Nature communications 14, 1 (2023), 599.
[33]
Xinshu Li and Lina Yao. 2022. Contrastive individual treatment effects estimation. In 2022 IEEE International Conference on Data Mining (ICDM). IEEE, 1053–1058.
[34]
Christos Louizos, Uri Shalit, Joris M Mooij, David Sontag, Richard Zemel, and Max Welling. 2017. Causal effect inference with deep latent-variable models. Advances in neural information processing systems 30 (2017).
[35]
Jing Ma, Yushun Dong, Zheng Huang, Daniel Mietchen, and Jundong Li. 2022. Assessing the causal impact of COVID-19 related policies on outbreak dynamics: A case study in the US. In Proceedings of the ACM Web Conference 2022. 2678–2686.
[36]
Jing Ma, Ruocheng Guo, Chen Chen, Aidong Zhang, and Jundong Li. 2021. Deconfounding with networked observational data in a dynamic environment. In Proceedings of the 14th ACM International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining. 166–174.
[37]
Jing Ma, Mengting Wan, Longqi Yang, Jundong Li, Brent Hecht, and Jaime Teevan. 2022. Learning causal effects on hypergraphs. In Proceedings of the 28th ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining. 1202–1212.
[38]
Andrea Riccardo Migone. 2020. The influence of national policy characteristics on COVID-19 containment policies: a comparative analysis. Policy Design and Practice 3, 3 (2020), 259–276.
[39]
Aaron Miller, Mac Josh Reandelar, Kimberly Fasciglione, Violeta Roumenova, Yan Li, and Gonzalo H Otazu. 2020. Correlation between universal BCG vaccination policy and reduced morbidity and mortality for COVID-19: an epidemiological study. MedRxiv (2020), 2020–03.
[40]
Evan M Mistur, John Wagner Givens, and Daniel C Matisoff. 2023. Contagious COVID-19 policies: Policy diffusion during times of crisis. Review of Policy Research 40, 1 (2023), 36–62.
[41]
Timo Mitze, Reinhold Kosfeld, Johannes Rode, and Klaus Wälde. 2020. Face masks considerably reduce COVID-19 cases in Germany. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117, 51 (2020), 32293–32301.
[42]
Caicheng Niu and Wenjia Zhang. 2023. Causal effects of mobility intervention policies on intracity flows during the COVID-19 pandemic: The moderating role of zonal locations in the transportation networks. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems 102 (2023), 101957.
[43]
Marco Pangallo, Alberto Aleta, R Maria del Rio-Chanona, Anton Pichler, David Martín-Corral, Matteo Chinazzi, François Lafond, Marco Ajelli, Esteban Moro, Yamir Moreno, et al. 2024. The unequal effects of the health–economy trade-off during the COVID-19 pandemic. Nature Human Behaviour 8, 2 (2024), 264–275.
[44]
Imalka Wasana Rathnayaka, Rasheda Khanam, and Mohammad Mafizur Rahman. 2023. The economics of COVID-19: a systematic literature review. Journal of Economic Studies 50, 1 (2023), 49–72.
[45]
Donald B Rubin. 2005. Bayesian inference for causal effects. Handbook of statistics 25 (2005), 1–16.
[46]
Souvika Sarkar, Biddut Sarker Bijoy, Syeda Jannatus Saba, Dongji Feng, Yash Mahajan, Mohammad Ruhul Amin, Sheikh Rabiul Islam, and Shubhra Kanti Karmaker. 2023. Ad-hoc monitoring of covid-19 global research trends for well-informed policy making. ACM Transactions on Intelligent Systems and Technology 14, 2 (2023), 1–28.
[47]
Anindya Sen, John David Baker, Qihuang Zhang, Rishav Raj Agarwal, and Jean-Paul Lam. 2023. Do more stringent policies reduce daily COVID-19 case counts? Evidence from Canadian provinces. Economic Analysis and Policy 78 (2023), 225–242.
[48]
Uri Shalit, Fredrik D Johansson, and David Sontag. 2017. Estimating individual treatment effect: generalization bounds and algorithms. In International Conference on Machine Learning. PMLR, 3076–3085.
[49]
Yudong Tao, Chuang Yang, Tianyi Wang, Erik Coltey, Yanxiu Jin, Yinghao Liu, Renhe Jiang, Zipei Fan, Xuan Song, Ryosuke Shibasaki, et al. 2022. A survey on data-driven covid-19 and future pandemic management. ACM computing surveys 55, 7 (2022), 1–36.
[50]
Petar Veličković, Guillem Cucurull, Arantxa Casanova, Adriana Romero, Pietro Lio, and Yoshua Bengio. 2017. Graph attention networks. arXiv preprint arXiv:1710.10903 (2017).
[51]
Yuping Wang, Chen Ling, and Gianluca Stringhini. 2023. Understanding the use of images to spread COVID-19 misinformation on Twitter. Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction 7, CSCW1 (2023), 1–32.
[52]
Shuai Xiao, Junchi Yan, Xiaokang Yang, Hongyuan Zha, and Stephen Chu. 2017. Modeling the intensity function of point process via recurrent neural networks. In Proceedings of the AAAI conference on artificial intelligence, Vol. 31.
[53]
Wenbin Zha, Qian Ye, Jian Li, and Kaan Ozbay. 2023. A social media Data-Driven analysis for transport policy response to the COVID-19 pandemic outbreak in Wuhan, China. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 172 (2023), 103669.
[54]
Ruochi Zhang, Yuesong Zou, and Jian Ma. 2019. Hyper-SAGNN: a self-attention based graph neural network for hypergraphs. arXiv preprint arXiv:1911.02613 (2019).
[55]
Weiguang Zhang, Saike He, Peijie Zhang, and Daniel Dajun Zeng. 2023. Dynamic Causal Modelling and Predictive Analysis for the COVID-19 Pandemic. In 2023 IEEE International Conference on Intelligence and Security Informatics (ISI). IEEE, 1–6.
[56]
Weiwei Zhang, Shiyong Liu, Nathaniel Osgood, Hongli Zhu, Ying Qian, and Peng Jia. 2023. Using simulation modelling and systems science to help contain COVID-19: A systematic review. Systems research and behavioral science 40, 1 (2023), 207–234.
[57]
Wenjia Zhang and Kexin Ning. 2023. Spatiotemporal heterogeneities in the causal effects of mobility intervention policies during the COVID-19 outbreak: A spatially interrupted time-series (SITS) analysis. Annals of the American Association of Geographers 113, 5 (2023), 1112–1134.
Index Terms
- Assessing the Spatial-Temporal Causal Impact of COVID-19 Related Policies on Epidemic Spread
Recommendations
Assessing the Causal Impact of COVID-19 Related Policies on Outbreak Dynamics: A Case Study in the US
WWW '22: Proceedings of the ACM Web Conference 2022Analyzing the causal impact of different policies in reducing the spread of COVID-19 is of critical importance. The main challenge here is the existence of unobserved confounders (e.g., vigilance of residents) which influence both the presence of ...
Demographics and topics impact on the co-spread of COVID-19 misinformation and fact-checks on Twitter
AbstractCorrecting misconceptions and false beliefs are important for injecting reliable information about COVID-19 into public discourse, but what impact does this have on the continued proliferation of misinforming claims? Fact-checking ...
Highlights- The relation between misinformation and fact-checking during COVID-19 is studied.
Co-spread of Misinformation and Fact-Checking Content During the Covid-19 Pandemic
Social InformaticsAbstractIn the context of the Covid-19 pandemic, the consequences of misinformation are a matter of life and death. Correcting misconceptions and false beliefs are important for injecting reliable information about the outbreak. Fact-checking ...
Comments
Information & Contributors
Information
Published In
EISSN:1556-472X
Table of ContentsCopyright © 2024 Copyright held by the owner/author(s).
Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. Copyrights for components of this work owned by others than the author(s) must be honored. Abstracting with credit is permitted. To copy otherwise, or republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission and/or a fee. Request permissions from [email protected].
Publisher
Association for Computing Machinery
New York, NY, United States
Publication History
Online AM: 26 September 2024
Accepted: 18 September 2024
Revised: 04 July 2024
Received: 19 September 2023
Check for updates
Author Tags
Qualifiers
- Research-article
Contributors
Other Metrics
Bibliometrics & Citations
Bibliometrics
Article Metrics
- 0Total Citations
- 27Total Downloads
- Downloads (Last 12 months)27
- Downloads (Last 6 weeks)27
Reflects downloads up to 04 Oct 2024
Other Metrics
Citations
View Options
Get Access
Login options
Check if you have access through your login credentials or your institution to get full access on this article.
Sign in