1. Introduction
Among abiotic stresses, salt stress is considered as the most dangerous stress that disturbs growth and yield, causes physiological disorders, and results in the death of plants [
1]. Salinity is a more limiting factor increasing from arid to semiarid regions all over the globe [
2]. Globally, approximately 2000 ha of arable land are moving towards production loss daily due to excessive salt concentrations [
3]. These production losses were estimated to be around 10–25% [
4]. The higher salt concentrations in irrigation water are the major cause of salt buildup in agricultural lands and plant root zones, inducing stunted growth [
5]. Particularly, sodium and chloride concentrations increase within plant cell compartments growing in saline conditions [
6]. Soil soluble salts and water sodium chloride are the main salinity-inducing factors in semiarid and hot regions [
7,
8]. High salt accumulations result from the salinity of irrigation water in plant cells as well as in the soil [
9]. Salt stress increases oxidative injury in plants, which further damages the photosynthetic machinery and stomata regulation [
10]. Under extreme NaCl stress conditions, the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) is enhanced, which threatens normal plants. These ROS have the ability to rupture photosynthetic pigments [
11]. The production of antioxidants, i.e., SOD, POD and CAT activities, non-enzymatic compounds, i.e., ascorbic acid, phenolic content, different sugars, MDA, H
2O
2, and osmolytes, i.e., proline, GB, and APX, were enhanced within plants under extreme saline conditions [
11]. Different antioxidants have the capability to eliminate ROS and improve plant immunity under harsh environmental conditions [
10,
12]. Different strategies, i.e., balanced nutrient application, timely irrigation, and application of different chemicals can be used to reduce the negative effects of salt stress. The application of sodium nitroprusside is considered an important nutrient element to reduce the adverse effects of abiotic stresses. Under salt stress, sodium nitroprusside can be a suitable fertilizer for improvement of the salt tolerance mechanism in plants [
13]. Foliar application could be considered the most effective method to activate the antioxidant system and regulate physiological processes in plants under stress [
14].
Nitric oxide is an important signaling molecule that is involved in different plant processes, e.g., seed dormancy, seed emergence, stomata regulation, photosynthesis, growth of pollen tubes, flowering, and fruiting [
12,
15]. Sodium nitroprusside (SNP; an NO donor) modulated the damaging effects of ROS on plant growth by improving the antioxidant enzyme activities [
16,
17]. The application of nitric oxide was also recorded in numerous crops, e.g., tomato [
18], cucumber [
19], chickpea [
20], soybean [
21], spinach [
22] and pak choi [
17], being effective in improving the salt tolerance mechanism within plants [
23]. Moreover, it was also found to be effective in the enhancement of tolerance mechanisms in higher plants growing under harsh climatic conditions [
24].
Lettuce (
Lactuca sativa L.) is an important crop rich in iron that is crucial for human healthy life; it is mainly used in salads in the daily diet [
25]. However, its cultivation faces high salinity risks [
26]. Lettuce faces very low production due to poor soil, harsh environmental conditions, and irrigation with poor-quality water. Its production can be increased via the enhancement of salt tolerance through the application of required nutrients. Soil compaction due to heavy fertilization is also a major cause of poor production.
Based on the aforementioned, foliar spray can be effective for sustainable crop production. The protective role of NO in plants was previously hypothesized to decrease the adverse effect of salt stress in lettuce without any real evidence. However, until now, little information has been available regarding the effect of exogenous application of NO on oxidative damage and antioxidant enzyme activities in lettuce under salt stress. Therefore, the present work aimed to (a) evaluate the growth and yield of lettuce plants under different levels of salinity with and without NO application, and (b) evaluate the effect of salt stress with and without NO application on relative water content (RWC), photosynthetic pigments, ascorbic acid, oxidative and non-oxidative compounds, and macro-elements of lettuce plants.
3. Discussion
Salinity-induced osmotic and ionic stresses cause oxidative damage and produce ROS, impairing photosynthesis and cellular membrane damage, and an overall reduction in plant biomass production [
14]. Salt stress affects the growth and development of plants and ultimately reduces their yield [
27,
28,
29]. The role of NO as a signaling molecule in salt stress responses has been well documented [
30,
31]. This study investigated the effect of exogenously applied NO on the growth, enzymatic activities, and physiology of lettuce under salt stress conditions.
Lettuce is considered sensitive to salinity, which reduces its growth, root and shoot length, yield and total biomass [
32]. In this study, under salt stress, the plant growth and yield of lettuce were markedly reduced. Both shoot and root length were significantly affected by the salinity exposure of lettuce plants. Similar reductions in the growth parameters were observed earlier in lettuce due to high salt concentrations in water and soil [
1,
33,
34,
35]. The higher leaf uptake of salts inhibits plant growth by reducing the nutrient supply to the plants [
36]. Our results showed that NO exogenous application to lettuce plants enhanced plant fresh weight, number of leaves, shoot dry weight and yield, and ultimately enhanced tolerance in lettuce under salt stress. Similar improvements in growth parameters such as root length and shoot fresh and dry weight were observed in basil [
37], pak choi [
17], and wheat [
30] as well as in mung bean under salt stress [
38] with NO exogenous application. NO, as a signaling molecule, plays a crucial role in the improvement of crop growth under stress and normal conditions [
37]. It is worth noting that the increases in growth traits of control (0 mM) plants were more pronounced when NO was applied. This outlines the positive impact of combining full Hoagland solution with SNP treatment, suggesting a cumulative availability of N concentrations for lettuce growth and development. The comparison between the “with NO” and “without NO” applications and the evaluated differences between them revealed that NO application significantly minimized the reduction in SL (25, 75, and 100 mM), SW (75 and 100 mM), RL (50, 75, and 100 mM), NL (100 mM), SFW (25, 50, and 100 mM), SDW (50 mM), RFW (50 and 75 mM), and RDW (all salinity levels) of salt-stressed lettuce plants compared to the control. This outlines the positive impact of NO application on the growth and yield traits of lettuce plants under salt stress; it improved the tolerance of lettuce to salinity by activating the stress tolerance mechanisms of the crop.
Salt stress negatively affected the absorption of water due to the accumulation of salts in the root zone, which decreases water potential and reduces the availability of water to plants. This decrease was more accentuated with increased salinity levels. A similar result was previously reported by Ahmed et al. [
1], who described the decrease in RWC of lettuce shoot under salt stress. The negative effect of salts on the relative water content of shoots has also been reported in many other studies [
35,
39,
40,
41]. On the other hand, our findings showed that NO application increased leaf RWC content in salt-stressed lettuce plants. Such increase was previously reported on tomato leaves [
42], rapeseed leaves [
37], and pepper leaves [
43] with NO exogenous application. However, the comparison between “with NO” and “without NO” applications and the evaluated differences between them revealed that NO application did not show any significant reduction in RWC of salt-stressed lettuce in comparison with control. This can be explained by the ability of NO to facilitate better management of water content by the plant, thus reducing its loss via transpiration, evapotranspiration, etc.
Our findings revealed a decrease in chlorophyll a, b, total chlorophyll and carotenoid contents in lettuce leaves with increased salinity levels. This decrease was previously reported in lettuce under salt stress [
44,
45,
46]. Higher salt accumulation in the leaves might have oxidized the chlorophyll and chloroplast, resulting in reduced concentrations of pigment protein [
47]. Enhanced ROS production under salt stress might have reduced the photosynthetic activity and increased the degradation of these pigments [
48]. Chlorophyll molecules are essential for photosynthesis; any reduction in leaf chlorophyll content might lead to a perturbation in the photosynthesis mechanism and ultimately a decrease in yield [
46]. Herein, the exogenous application of NO enhanced these photosynthetic pigments in both normal and salt-stressed lettuce leaves, and carotenoids in salt-stressed ones. Similar findings were observed in broccoli [
49], mung bean [
37], rapeseed [
38], tomato [
18], and wheat [
29]. The comparison between “with NO” and “without NO” applications and the evaluated differences between them revealed that NO application significantly minimized the reduction in
Chl a and
Total Chl (75 and 100 mM),
Chl b and Ct (in all salinity treatments) of salt-stressed lettuce plants compared to control. This can be explained by the fact that NO improves the stomatal conductivity, thus leading to better photosynthetic efficiency and increased carotenoid content.
Our study showed that salt stress significantly increased the activities of SOD, POD, CAT and APX antioxidant enzymes in lettuce as compared to the control. These antioxidant enzymes protect the cell membrane from oxidative damage and provide salt tolerance by scavenging ROS [
49]. ROS can provoke severe oxidation, which can be controlled with the production of enzymatic and non-enzymatic antioxidants in plants under stress [
1]. Previous studies reported the role of these antioxidant enzymes in scavenging ROS under salt stress in lettuce [
50,
51,
52]. ROS can cause lipid peroxidation and oxidative damage to lipids and nucleic acid in lettuce [
51]. A further increase in these antioxidant enzymes in lettuce under salt stress was recorded in this study with foliar application of NO. NO might have reduced the accumulation of ROS and protected cells from oxidative damage [
43,
49]. The increase in enzymatic activity responsible for ROS scavenging with NO application has been observed in various crops such as chickpea [
20], cucumber [
19], maize [
31], pak choi [
17], and tomato [
23] under salt stress. The comparison between “with NO” and “without NO” application and the evaluated differences between them revealed that NO application significantly minimized the reduction in CAT of all salt-stressed plants in comparison with control. This finding also underscores the improved ROS scavenging as mentioned earlier.
Non-enzymatic antioxidants such as ascorbic acid and total phenols are also effective in reducing cell membrane damage from oxidative stress due to their antioxidative potential in plants [
52]. In this study, the ascorbic acid content in lettuce decreased with the increase in salinity levels, whereas NO foliar application on lettuce plants enhanced ascorbic acid content. Such increases were observed earlier with the exogenous application of NO on broccoli [
49], pea [
53], and rice [
54] under salt stress. Moreover, non-oxidative compounds, i.e., proline and the MDA content, in the leaves increased in this study with the increase in salinity levels as compared to control plants. However, the exogenous application of NO showed a further decrease in H
2O
2 in the leaves of lettuce under salt stress. Earlier studies reported an increase in proline content associated with increased salinity [
12,
17,
41,
49,
55]. Under salt stress, proline protects enzymes, photosynthetic machinery and cell membranes against oxidative stress, consequently increasing tolerance to salinity in plants [
41]. Proline is a low molecular osmolyte that accumulates in plants, scavenges hydroxyl radicals, and protects protein and DNA against ROS [
41]. Previous studies reported that the exogenous application of NO enhanced the proline content under salt stress in various crops such as broccoli [
49], pepper [
43], and rice [
54]. Furthermore, NO decreases the accumulation of H
2O
2 and MDA in plants under salt stress [
29,
49]. The comparison between “with NO” and “without NO” application and the evaluated differences between them revealed that NO application significantly minimized the reduction in ascorbic acid, proline, total phenols, H
2O
2, and MDA contents of salt-stressed lettuce plants compared to the control. This can be explained by the fact that NO helps in the synthesis of ascorbic acid, acting as a signaling molecule. Additionally, such findings can be explained by the close inter-relationship between NO and proline synthesis during the full growing cycle of lettuce plants under salt stress. Further, it is known that total phenols and MDA contents vary in parallel; this shows how NO acted efficiently by increasing them and reducing the differences between salinity treatments and control. Moreover, NO may have activated the H
2O
2 circulation in lettuce plants under salt stress, which was contrasted with reduced difference in such signaling molecule amount in comparison with the control.
Salt stress generally decreased leaf nitrogen and phosphorus of lettuce as compared to the control, whereas NO application only increased leaf phosphorus content (
p < 0.01). Moreover, in general, salt stress significantly decreased (
p < 0.01) root nitrogen and root phosphorus, except in the 25 mM saline-treated plants (
p > 0.05). However, NO application increased (
p < 0.01) root nitrogen in the control and 100 mM saline-treated plants and root phosphorus in all treatments except the 25 mM saline-treated plants (
p > 0.05). This could be attributed to the role played by NO during photosynthesis, cell membrane protection against ROS, and thus, the uptake of these elements in higher amounts by leaves and roots. Furthermore, salt stress increased the concentrations of Na
+ and reduced the K
+ content in lettuce plants. The increase in Na
+ was more pronounced with the increase in salinity as compared to control plants. A similar trend was found in an earlier study on lettuce by Zhang et al. [
41], who also found an increase in Na
+ and a decrease in K
+ contents under salt stress. The excessive uptake of Na
+ by plants can cause a devastating effect on the cell membrane by lowering the amount of K
+, thus leading to an imbalance in cell homeostasis [
41,
49,
54]. K
+ deficiency in plants caused by a higher Na
+ uptake can lead to reduced growth and production in response to lower photosynthesis, stomatal closure and decreased enzymatic activities [
41]. In the current study, the exogenous application of NO enhanced the uptake of K
+ and decreased Na
+ uptake under salt stress conditions. Maintaining high K
+ and low Na
+ might facilitate the nutritional balance and protect from ion toxicity [
56]. Our results are in agreement with those of previous studies in which NO application increased K
+ and decreased Na
+ in various crops such as broccoli [
49] and wheat [
57] under salt stress. Our findings revealed that NO maintains the nutritional balance, which might have improved the overall growth of lettuce under salt stress. The comparison between “with NO” and “without NO” applications and the evaluated differences between them revealed that NO application significantly minimized the reduction in leaf P (75 and 100 mM) and root P (all treatments) of salt-stressed lettuce plants compared to control. Similarly, the reduction in leaf K
+ (75 mM), root Na
+ (50, 75, and 100 mM), and leaf Na
+ and root K
+ (all salinity treatments) was minimized with NO application in salt-stressed lettuce plants compared to control. This can be explained by the increase in nutrient uptake and ion exchange in lettuce as a result of NO application.