1. Introduction
Soil is a vital component of the ecosystem. It plays a crucial role in the structure and operation of the land ecosystem [
1,
2]. However, the degradation of soil resources has emerged as one of the world’s most pressing ecological concerns. Soil salinization has already become a significant symptom of soil degradation that affects 10% of the world’s agricultural land [
3,
4]. The search for a reliable monitoring index and precise regression method for soil salinity is essential to globally assess soil salinization and its severe implications for agriculture and food security.
Ecological parameter measurement and airborne/satellite remote sensing (RS) monitoring technologies are two commonly utilized soil salinity assessment methods. Traditional methods rely on field surveys and electrical conductivity measurements, which are accurate but time and labor-intensive [
5,
6], and do not allow for monitoring of the spatial distribution pattern of soil salinity content. Multi- and hyperspectral satellite RS technology has been used in soil salinity monitoring since the 1990s [
7,
8]. Azabdaftari et al. (2016), for instance, computed vegetation indexes in the Adana region of Turkey using Landsat multispectral images from four different times [
9]. Morgan et al. (2018) forecasted soil salinity in Cairo, Egypt using Sentinel-2 multispectral data [
10]. Hyperspectral images such as EO-1 and HJ-1A were also employed as data sources to accurately detect soil salinity [
11,
12]. Different from the satellite RS means, the Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV)-borne spectral sensors are highly maneuverable and have been used to monitor soil salinity since the 2010s. Hu et al. (2019) used electromagnetic induction equipment and a hyperspectral camera mounted on a UAV platform to evaluate and estimate field-scale soil salinity [
13]. Ivushkin (2019) looked into the use of UAVs to measure salt stress in quinoa plants [
14]. Wang et al. (2019) extracted the salt content of extremely salty soil in China’s Yellow River Estuary and compared the retrieval findings with the inverse distance weighted interpolation results to achieve more accurate saline soil extraction [
15]. To boost the spectral resolution to retrieve soil salinity, Ma (2020) combined Sentinel-2A and UAV multispectral images to increase the spectral resolution to inverse regional soil salinity [
16]. Satellite RS imagery-based soil salinity studies have indicated that the index in the visible to infrared spectrum may better measure soil salinity, which can increase the accuracy of soil salinity retrieval [
17,
18,
19]. The majority of vegetation indexes can indirectly indicate soil salinity [
20]. However, few studies focused on the detection of UAV band information sensitive to soil salinity, which is essential for the construction of a reliable soil salinity monitoring index to help efficiently predict the soil salinity conditions.
For the soil salinity regression method, several approaches such as partial least square (PLS), BP Neural Network (BPNN), Support Vector Machines (SVM), and random forest (RF) were introduced and applied [
15,
21]. For instance, Ma (2018) increased the accuracy of soil salinization retrieval by combining numerous mathematical changes on soil surface reflectance with regression analysis of collected soil data [
12]. Machine learning algorithms were used by Yao et al. (2019) to infer agriculture soil salt concentration from UAV multispectral RS images [
22]. The determination coefficients for validation were more than 0.69. To improve regional retrieval precision, Chen et al. (2021) presented a differentiated fusion method for calculating satellite and ground spectral variables of soil salinity based on sample differences [
23]. Spectral parameters and correlation salinity indexes have been converted and filtered to retrieve soil salinity. In resource management and allocation, the river delta region has a high degree of social-ecological interdependence and competition. In China, the Yellow River Delta (YRD) features shallow groundwater levels (0–2 m), significant salinity, and surface salinity. Soil salinization affects over 70% of YRD’s land, making the region’s biological ecosystem severely vulnerable [
24]. Soil salinization has long been a major source of soil degradation in the YRD, limiting local agricultural productivity. Precise monitoring of soil salinity is essential to assess soil salinization. However, screening and design of sensitive parameters, as well as a suitable retrieval method, is, nevertheless, unknown.
This study thus strived to explore the sensitive parameter and construct an optimal method for soil salinity retrieval. The Yellow River Delta (YRD) in China was selected as the study area to experiment. UAV RS image and ground truth data collected during the spring season were used as the data source. Sensitive bands and spectral parameters of soil salinity were identified using grey correlation analysis and Pearson correlation coefficient approaches. PLSR, MLR, BPNN, SVM, and RF modeling methods were used to create soil salt retrieval models based on reflectance, vegetation index, and salinity index. The accuracies were evaluated quantitatively to find the optimal retrieval model. This study is expected to serve as a guide for the selection of sensitive criteria and the optimal soil salinity prediction algorithms, which can be used in other regions to retrieve soil salinity efficiently.
4. Discussions
The sensitive parameter and optimal retrieval method for soil salinity monitoring using UAV multispectral imagery were investigated in this study. The proposed soil salinity retrieval index (SSRI) based RF method was found to show the best accuracy in predicting soil salinity. The modeling R2 and RMSE were 0.724 and 1.764, respectively; and the validation R2, RMSE, and RPD were 0.745, 1.879, and 2.211, respectively, which were the highest among all the models built using the five prediction approaches based on SSRI, vegetation index, and salinity index.
Compared to existing soil salinity retrieval studies using UAV imagery, this study screened sensitive band information and combined them to form a feasible index to help retrieve soil salinity. The retrieval values of soil salinity in the whole test area using the SSRI-based RF model (
Figure 3) ranged from 0.323 to 21.210 g/kg, with an average value of 6.871 g/kg, which was close to the descriptive statistical results of the soil samples (
Table 3). The test area can be divided into five grades based on the saline soil grading standard (Wang et al., 2019), namely extremely saline soil (salt content greater than 10.0 g/kg), severely saline soil (salt content 6.0–10.0 g/kg), moderately saline soil (salt content 4.0–6.0 g/kg), slightly saline soil (salt content 2.0–4.0 g/kg), and non-saline soil (
Figure 3). According to the area statistical figures, the extremely saline soil occupied the lowest share of 5.3 percent of the five grades. Severely and moderately saline soil zones accounted for 15.5 and 13.6 percent of the overall test area, respectively. The proposal of slightly saline soil was 65.4 percent, the highest of the five categories. This pattern of soil salinity distribution is consistent with the observation in
Figure 2, i.e., more than half of the sample locations were in the slightly saline region. The non-saline region encompassed 10.2 percent of the left test area. The geographical analysis demonstrated that soil salinization is widespread in the test area, with the majority of test sites belonging to the saline soil grade.
Visible and NIR bands displayed significant correlation links with soil salinity according to the results of two spectral screening analysis methodologies. The main minerals involved in the salinization of the soil of the YRD are rock salt and gypsum, with the main anions being Cl
− and SO
42− and the main cations being Na
+ and Ca
2+ [
11,
43]. Previous research found that although NaCl has no spectral characteristics in the visible and near-infrared bands, NaCl is correlated with gypsum [
44]. Gypsum possesses absorption qualities in the visible and near-infrared bands, which can help reveal soil salinity spectral information. Xu et al. (2018) found that gypsum has molecular vibration absorption spectrum features in the NIR band, visible and NIR band can collect SO
42− spectral information [
45]. Furthermore, studies have shown that salinized soil has higher reflectance in the visible and NIR bands than non-salinized soil [
15,
46]. Hence, spectral information of salinized soil retrieved from RS data can be used to estimate soil salinity in visible and near-infrared bands.
This study explored the sensitive parameters and optimal method to retrieve soil salinity, while soil samples were collected in the surface layer of soil (0–10 cm). For agriculture and food security, more attention should be paid to the indirect approach to a salinization assessment of root-zone (0–100 cm) [
47]. Besides, the soil sample collection and measurement were conducted in one site. The proposed SSRI and the findings need more examination to test the reliability in further research. Furthermore, UAV multispectral image and the SSRI-based RF method can efficiently predict soil salinity with acceptable accuracy, whereas the UAV’s battery duration time prevents it from being used in large regional-scale soil salinity assessment. Recently, studies have fused satellite RS data with UAV images to derive regional-scale soil salinity, which is useful for estimating soil salinity across wide areas. However, it should be noted the variations in band wavelengths, meteorological conditions at the time of acquisition, and sensor compatibility between aviation and aerospace platforms are distinctly different. How to eliminate these uncertainties is a direction where further endeavors should be made in.