Hartmann, Margaret (October 5, 2022). "Bonkers Revelations From Maggie Haberman's Trump Book, Ranked". New York. Retrieved October 11, 2022.
Content
editThe first half of the book covers Trump's career before his candidacy for the presidency. Sean Wilentz observes that the book "places special emphasis on Trump’s ascent in a late 1970s and 1980s New York demimonde of hustlers, mobsters, political bosses, compliant prosecutors and tabloid scandalmongers." The book covers Trump's close relationships with figures of that era including Ed Koch George Steinbrenner, Roger Stone, Rupert Murdoch, Roger Ailes, Rudy Giuliani, Robert Morgenthau and especially his mentor, Roy Cohn. According to Joe Klein, "Trump managed to gin his divorce from his first wife, Ivana, into a war between competing gossip columnists, Liz Smith and Cindy Adams," leading to coverage in the New York Daily News for 12 days straight.
Haberman portrays Trump as president as childlike, easily influenced by flattery, obsessed with trivialities, unwilling to engage with the details, and dismissive of advice. Accordingly the executive branch was "subject to the president’s whims and moods, his ideas about friends and enemies," and that he "reoriented an entire country to react to his moods and emotions." LA Times Haberman concludes that Trump is "a narcissistic drama-seeker who covered a fragile ego with a bullying impulse".Slate
Writing for Slate, reviewer Laura Miller
concludes. "What Confidence Man offers its readers, as much of the pre-publication heralding of the book explains, is an in-depth portrait of Trump himself from a reporter who has covered him for years and who hails from the same New York City that formed him. The result is less a series of scoops and more an authoritative biography, a portrait of the man who transformed American politics."[1]
In The Guardian, reviewer Peter Conrad wrote: "Haberman’s book is chockablock with scoops, comprehensively leaked to the press before publication, but what singles it out from the competition is its perceptiveness about Trump’s character and the way his private vices became public menaces. Officiating as a harassed shrink, Haberman diagnostically reviews Trump’s early life, when his manias and self-delusions were already blatantly evident."[2]
Eric Alterman's review in The American Prospect expressed surprise at the book's quality: "But lo and behold, Confidence Man: The Making of Donald Trump and the Breaking of America turns out to be a pleasant surprise. It’s not merely a primary source for future historians but also, as both Sean Wilentz and Joe Klein noted in their respective reviews, a contextually reported story of Trump’s rise that actually helps make sense of Trump, and shows how he bent both the Republican Party and the mainstream media to his will."[3]
- ^ Miller, Laura (October 6, 2022). "What Maggie Haberman's Big Trump Book Misses: She's spent the past half-decade with one man occupying her entire field of vision. What a waste of her talents". Slate. Retrieved October 10, 2022.
- ^ Conrad, Peter (October 9, 2022). "Confidence Man: The Making of Donald Trump and the Breaking of America by Maggie Haberman review – the vain sadist and his 'shrink': The New York Times reporter's eagerly awaited book on the ex-US president scathingly exposes the toxic mix of egotism, bigotry and delusion behind his cynical rise". The Guardian. Retrieved October 10, 2022.
- ^ Alterman, Eric (October 7, 2022). "Altercation: Maggie Haberman's New Book Puts Trump in Context: The surprisingly good 'Confidence Man' actually makes sense of Trump's rise and his ability to twist the media to his will". American Prospect. Retrieved October 10, 2022.