Identification of 108 genomic regions significantly associated with schizophrenia risk by the Psy... more Identification of 108 genomic regions significantly associated with schizophrenia risk by the Psychiatric Genomics Consortium was a milestone for the field, and much work is now focused on determining the mechanism of risk associated with each locus. Within these regions, we investigated variability of DNA methylation, a low-level cellular phenotype closely linked to genotype, in two highly similar cellular populations sampled from the human hippocampus, to draw inferences about the elaboration of genotype to phenotype within these loci enriched for schizophrenia risk. DNA methylation was assessed with the Illumina HumanMethylation450 BeadArray in tissue laser-microdissected from the stratum oriens of subfield CA1 or CA2/3, regions having unique connectivity with intrinsic and extrinsic fiber systems within the hippocampus. Samples consisted of postmortem human hippocampus tissue from eight schizophrenia patients, eight bipolar disorder patients, and eight healthy control subjects. Within these genomic regions, we observed far greater difference in methylation patterns between circuit locations within subjects than in a single subregion between subjects across diagnostic groups, demonstrating the complexity of genotype to phenotype elaboration across the diverse circuitry of the human brain.
The RNA integrity number (RIN) is often considered to be a critical measure of the quality of pos... more The RNA integrity number (RIN) is often considered to be a critical measure of the quality of postmortem human brains. However, it has been suggested that RINs do not necessarily reflect the availability of intact mRNA. Using the Agilent bioanalyzer and qRT-PCR, we explored whether RINs provide a meaningful way of assessing mRNA degradation and integrity in human brain samples by evaluating the expression of 3'-5' mRNA sequences of the cytochrome C-1 (CYC1) gene. Analysis of electropherograms showed that RINs were not consistently correlated with RNA or cDNA profiles and appeared to be poor predictors of overall cDNA quality. Cycle thresholds from qRT-PCR analysis to quantify the amount of CYC1 mRNA revealed positive correlations of RINs with amplification of full-length transcripts, despite the variable degree of linear degradation along the 3'-5' sequence. These data demonstrate that in postmortem human brain tissue the RIN is an indicator of mRNA quantity independ...
This paper presents an overview of recent microscopic studies that have sought to define how limb... more This paper presents an overview of recent microscopic studies that have sought to define how limbic circuitry may be altered in postmortem schizophrenic brain. The discussion is organized around several basic questions regarding the manner in which interconnections within and between the anterior cingulate cortex and hippocampal formation and involving the glutamate, GABA and dopamine systems may contribute to the pathophysiology of this disorder. The answers to these questions are used to derive several conclusions. regarding circuitry changes in schizophrenia: 1 Schizophrenia is not a 'typical' degenerative disorder, but rather it is one in which. excitotoxicity may contribute to neuronal pathology, whether or not cell death occurs; 2 Three or more neurotransmitter systems may be. simultaneously altered within a single microcircuit; 3 Each transmitter system may show circuitry changes in more than one region, but. such changes may vary on a region-by-region basis; 4 The pathophysiology of schizophrenia may involve 'mis-wirings' in intrinsic ลฝ. circuits microcircuitry within a given region, but significant changes are probably also present at the level of interconnections between ลฝ. . two or more regions within a network macrocircuitry ; 5 While some microscopic findings appear to be selectively present in. schizophrenia and be related to a susceptibility gene for this disorder, others may also be present in patients with bipolar disorder; 6 Although some of the circuitry changes seen in schizophrenia and bipolar disorder seem to be associated with neuroleptic exposure, most. are not and may reflect the influence of non-specific environmental factors such as pre-andror postnatal stress; 7 Normal postnatal changes at the level of both macro-and microcircuitry within the limbic system may serve as 'triggers' for the onset of schizophrenia during adolescence. Taken together, these emerging principles can provide a framework for future postmortem studies of schizophrenic brain.
The relative distribution and cellular localization of the dopamine D, and D, receptor subtypes w... more The relative distribution and cellular localization of the dopamine D, and D, receptor subtypes were assessed in frozen sections of rat medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC). The D, and
Using a two-dimensional cell counting approach, a 1991 study in the anterior cingulate cortex (AC... more Using a two-dimensional cell counting approach, a 1991 study in the anterior cingulate cortex (ACCx) detected a reduction in the density of nonpyramidal neurons in layers II-VI of schizophrenic subjects. Schizophrenics without superimposed mood disturbances showed a 16% decrease in layer II, while schizoaffectives showed a 30% decrease, suggesting that a decreased density of nonpyramidal neurons in layer II of ACCx might vary more strongly with affective disorder than with schizophrenia. Two follow-up studies from this laboratory, one a replication of that reported in 1991 and the other an analysis of tyrosine hydroxylase immunoreactive fibers, were undertaken in ACCx of normal controls and schizophrenics. These three data sets have been combined and a meta-analysis of the density of pyramidal, nonpyramidal and glial cells was performed to explore whether changes in the density of interneurons in ACCx may be a reliable finding in the major psychoses. Not all groups have reported this finding, but several had employed a different cell counting technique (i.e. three dimensional optical dissector), which could help to explain the discrepant findings in schizophrenia and affective disorder. The data from each of three different studies (now designated as studies A, B and C, respectively) have been internally normalized, combined into a single dataset and analyzed using nonparametric statistics. Tissue blocks from a subset of cases in study B (six controls, six schizophrenics and six bipolars) were embedded in celloidin and counted using an bunbiasedQ three dimensional counting method (study D). The data from studies A and B indicate that the density of nonpyramidal neurons in layer II of ACCx in the schizoaffective and bipolar samples was significantly decreased. In the schizophrenics, the nonpyramidal neurons were also decreased, but only by 15%. All three groups also showed a decrease of pyramidal neurons in layers IV, V and VI, but this difference was significant only in layer IV of the schizophrenics. When data from study C were added, the differences in pyramidal and nonpyramidal neurons were less striking. For study D, the pattern of findings are strikingly similar to those obtained in studies A, B and C, indicating that both 2D and 3D cell counting methodologies are capable of detecting the same differences. Taken together, these results indicate that the earlier finding of a decreased density of nonpyramidal neurons in ACCx of schizophrenics is consistent across non-overlapping subjects and/or methods in four separate
Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, May 31, 2000
This chapter reviews recent postmortem studies of schizophrenic brain and discusses the potential... more This chapter reviews recent postmortem studies of schizophrenic brain and discusses the potential role of the amygdala in the induction of hippocampal abnormalities in this disorder. Based on available evidence, sectors CA4, CA3, and CA2, but not CA1, show preferential changes in schizophrenic subjects, although the most pronounced changes have been found in CA3 and CA2. It seems likely that the amygdala would contribute in some way to the induction of abnormalities along the trisynaptic pathway via its direct input to sectors CA3 and CA2, as well as an indirect one that involves the entorhinal cortex and its perforant path projection to the area dentata. The postmortem findings reported to date have been integrated into a working model in which decreases of inhibitory GABAergic modulation are invoked to explain the observation from a recent PET scan study (Heckers et al., 1999) that baseline metabolic activity in the hippocampus of schizophrenics is increased. In addition, however, the apparent inability of schizophrenics to increase metabolic activity in the hippocampus when challenged with a memory retrieval task may reflect a disturbance of disinhibitory modulation postulated herein to occur in sector CA3, a key relay point along the trisynaptic pathway. Overall, it seems plausible that an increase of excitatory activity entering the hippocampus from the basolateral complex via both direct and indirect pathways may make a significant contribution to the pathophysiology of schizophrenia.
Current hypotheses concerning the etiology of schizophrenia often invoke both an abnormal genc(s)... more Current hypotheses concerning the etiology of schizophrenia often invoke both an abnormal genc(s) and an environmental disturbance as necessar~ยข components to the vulnerahilits for this disorder. According to one model of schizophrenia presented here, the putative cn,,ironmental factor may consist of stress and require both pre-and post-natal exposure for a "'mis-wiring'" of dopaminergic inputs to GABAergic neurons of the cortex to occur Since the cortical dopaminc system continues to mature until the start of the early adult period, the normal ingrowth ofdopamme tibcrs during late adolescence and their formation of aberrant connections with abnormal intrinsic cortieolimbic circuits could "'trigger" the onset of symptoms in those who carry the constitutional vulneribility for schizophrenia, c 1997 Elsevier Science I.td.
Data generated from an earlier study have suggested a model in which greater numbers of long, ver... more Data generated from an earlier study have suggested a model in which greater numbers of long, vertical, associative axons may occur in the anterior cingulate cortex of schizophrenic patients relative to control subjects. This hypothesis has now been tested using neuron-specific antibodies raised against the 200-kilodalton neurofilament subunit, a component of neuronal cytoskeleton, to immunostain axons of human postmortem cingulate cortex. A manual method for counting axons in the region of layer II and sublamina IIIA has been designed and applied blindly to parallel control and schizophrenic immunoprocessed specimens. The results show that there are 25% more vertical axons in the schizophrenic than in the control specimens. Preferentially higher numbers of both long vertical axons (62%) and axons associated with blood vessels (52%) have also been noted in the schizophrenic specimens. By contrast, the number of large-caliber horizontal axons was the same in the two groups; therefore, the greater number of vertical axons in schizophrenic specimens does not appear to represent a nonspecific effect. When these data are corrected for the effects of several confounding variables using analysis of covariance, the overall pattern of the results persists. These findings suggest the possibility that there might be an increase of associative inputs into the anterior cingulate cortex of schizophrenic patients, although it is not clear at present whether the differences noted, if replicative, may be primarily or perhaps only secondarily related to the disorder.
The suggestion that schizophrenia may involve a neurodegenerative process has emanated from the h... more The suggestion that schizophrenia may involve a neurodegenerative process has emanated from the highly replicated finding of ventricular enlargement in brain images of patients with this disorder. These investigations have provided a direct impetus for recent histopathologic studies seeking evidence of a neurodegenerative process in the brains of subjects with schizophrenia. Whereas most postmortem studies have reported the presence of atrophy and/or neuronal loss in several corticolimbic regions of subjects with schizophrenia, no quantitative study, to date, has detected an increase in the number of glial cells. For this reason the changes observed in postmortem schizophrenic brain are not consistent with a typical adult pattern of neuronal degeneration, such as that seen in Huntington's disease. Because several studies have reported various changes in layer II of the anterior cingulate, prefrontal, and entorhinal cortices, the histopathologic findings described are compatible with the idea that schizophrenia involves a disturbance of the "inside-out" migration or differentiation of cortical neurons that normally occurs during ontogenesis. A neurodevelopmental perturbation early in life could result in discrete alterations of corticolimbic circuitry that eventually contribute to the appearance of schizophrenic symptoms during adolescence and adulthood.
Identification of 108 genomic regions significantly associated with schizophrenia risk by the Psy... more Identification of 108 genomic regions significantly associated with schizophrenia risk by the Psychiatric Genomics Consortium was a milestone for the field, and much work is now focused on determining the mechanism of risk associated with each locus. Within these regions, we investigated variability of DNA methylation, a low-level cellular phenotype closely linked to genotype, in two highly similar cellular populations sampled from the human hippocampus, to draw inferences about the elaboration of genotype to phenotype within these loci enriched for schizophrenia risk. DNA methylation was assessed with the Illumina HumanMethylation450 BeadArray in tissue laser-microdissected from the stratum oriens of subfield CA1 or CA2/3, regions having unique connectivity with intrinsic and extrinsic fiber systems within the hippocampus. Samples consisted of postmortem human hippocampus tissue from eight schizophrenia patients, eight bipolar disorder patients, and eight healthy control subjects. Within these genomic regions, we observed far greater difference in methylation patterns between circuit locations within subjects than in a single subregion between subjects across diagnostic groups, demonstrating the complexity of genotype to phenotype elaboration across the diverse circuitry of the human brain.
The RNA integrity number (RIN) is often considered to be a critical measure of the quality of pos... more The RNA integrity number (RIN) is often considered to be a critical measure of the quality of postmortem human brains. However, it has been suggested that RINs do not necessarily reflect the availability of intact mRNA. Using the Agilent bioanalyzer and qRT-PCR, we explored whether RINs provide a meaningful way of assessing mRNA degradation and integrity in human brain samples by evaluating the expression of 3'-5' mRNA sequences of the cytochrome C-1 (CYC1) gene. Analysis of electropherograms showed that RINs were not consistently correlated with RNA or cDNA profiles and appeared to be poor predictors of overall cDNA quality. Cycle thresholds from qRT-PCR analysis to quantify the amount of CYC1 mRNA revealed positive correlations of RINs with amplification of full-length transcripts, despite the variable degree of linear degradation along the 3'-5' sequence. These data demonstrate that in postmortem human brain tissue the RIN is an indicator of mRNA quantity independ...
This paper presents an overview of recent microscopic studies that have sought to define how limb... more This paper presents an overview of recent microscopic studies that have sought to define how limbic circuitry may be altered in postmortem schizophrenic brain. The discussion is organized around several basic questions regarding the manner in which interconnections within and between the anterior cingulate cortex and hippocampal formation and involving the glutamate, GABA and dopamine systems may contribute to the pathophysiology of this disorder. The answers to these questions are used to derive several conclusions. regarding circuitry changes in schizophrenia: 1 Schizophrenia is not a 'typical' degenerative disorder, but rather it is one in which. excitotoxicity may contribute to neuronal pathology, whether or not cell death occurs; 2 Three or more neurotransmitter systems may be. simultaneously altered within a single microcircuit; 3 Each transmitter system may show circuitry changes in more than one region, but. such changes may vary on a region-by-region basis; 4 The pathophysiology of schizophrenia may involve 'mis-wirings' in intrinsic ลฝ. circuits microcircuitry within a given region, but significant changes are probably also present at the level of interconnections between ลฝ. . two or more regions within a network macrocircuitry ; 5 While some microscopic findings appear to be selectively present in. schizophrenia and be related to a susceptibility gene for this disorder, others may also be present in patients with bipolar disorder; 6 Although some of the circuitry changes seen in schizophrenia and bipolar disorder seem to be associated with neuroleptic exposure, most. are not and may reflect the influence of non-specific environmental factors such as pre-andror postnatal stress; 7 Normal postnatal changes at the level of both macro-and microcircuitry within the limbic system may serve as 'triggers' for the onset of schizophrenia during adolescence. Taken together, these emerging principles can provide a framework for future postmortem studies of schizophrenic brain.
The relative distribution and cellular localization of the dopamine D, and D, receptor subtypes w... more The relative distribution and cellular localization of the dopamine D, and D, receptor subtypes were assessed in frozen sections of rat medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC). The D, and
Using a two-dimensional cell counting approach, a 1991 study in the anterior cingulate cortex (AC... more Using a two-dimensional cell counting approach, a 1991 study in the anterior cingulate cortex (ACCx) detected a reduction in the density of nonpyramidal neurons in layers II-VI of schizophrenic subjects. Schizophrenics without superimposed mood disturbances showed a 16% decrease in layer II, while schizoaffectives showed a 30% decrease, suggesting that a decreased density of nonpyramidal neurons in layer II of ACCx might vary more strongly with affective disorder than with schizophrenia. Two follow-up studies from this laboratory, one a replication of that reported in 1991 and the other an analysis of tyrosine hydroxylase immunoreactive fibers, were undertaken in ACCx of normal controls and schizophrenics. These three data sets have been combined and a meta-analysis of the density of pyramidal, nonpyramidal and glial cells was performed to explore whether changes in the density of interneurons in ACCx may be a reliable finding in the major psychoses. Not all groups have reported this finding, but several had employed a different cell counting technique (i.e. three dimensional optical dissector), which could help to explain the discrepant findings in schizophrenia and affective disorder. The data from each of three different studies (now designated as studies A, B and C, respectively) have been internally normalized, combined into a single dataset and analyzed using nonparametric statistics. Tissue blocks from a subset of cases in study B (six controls, six schizophrenics and six bipolars) were embedded in celloidin and counted using an bunbiasedQ three dimensional counting method (study D). The data from studies A and B indicate that the density of nonpyramidal neurons in layer II of ACCx in the schizoaffective and bipolar samples was significantly decreased. In the schizophrenics, the nonpyramidal neurons were also decreased, but only by 15%. All three groups also showed a decrease of pyramidal neurons in layers IV, V and VI, but this difference was significant only in layer IV of the schizophrenics. When data from study C were added, the differences in pyramidal and nonpyramidal neurons were less striking. For study D, the pattern of findings are strikingly similar to those obtained in studies A, B and C, indicating that both 2D and 3D cell counting methodologies are capable of detecting the same differences. Taken together, these results indicate that the earlier finding of a decreased density of nonpyramidal neurons in ACCx of schizophrenics is consistent across non-overlapping subjects and/or methods in four separate
Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, May 31, 2000
This chapter reviews recent postmortem studies of schizophrenic brain and discusses the potential... more This chapter reviews recent postmortem studies of schizophrenic brain and discusses the potential role of the amygdala in the induction of hippocampal abnormalities in this disorder. Based on available evidence, sectors CA4, CA3, and CA2, but not CA1, show preferential changes in schizophrenic subjects, although the most pronounced changes have been found in CA3 and CA2. It seems likely that the amygdala would contribute in some way to the induction of abnormalities along the trisynaptic pathway via its direct input to sectors CA3 and CA2, as well as an indirect one that involves the entorhinal cortex and its perforant path projection to the area dentata. The postmortem findings reported to date have been integrated into a working model in which decreases of inhibitory GABAergic modulation are invoked to explain the observation from a recent PET scan study (Heckers et al., 1999) that baseline metabolic activity in the hippocampus of schizophrenics is increased. In addition, however, the apparent inability of schizophrenics to increase metabolic activity in the hippocampus when challenged with a memory retrieval task may reflect a disturbance of disinhibitory modulation postulated herein to occur in sector CA3, a key relay point along the trisynaptic pathway. Overall, it seems plausible that an increase of excitatory activity entering the hippocampus from the basolateral complex via both direct and indirect pathways may make a significant contribution to the pathophysiology of schizophrenia.
Current hypotheses concerning the etiology of schizophrenia often invoke both an abnormal genc(s)... more Current hypotheses concerning the etiology of schizophrenia often invoke both an abnormal genc(s) and an environmental disturbance as necessar~ยข components to the vulnerahilits for this disorder. According to one model of schizophrenia presented here, the putative cn,,ironmental factor may consist of stress and require both pre-and post-natal exposure for a "'mis-wiring'" of dopaminergic inputs to GABAergic neurons of the cortex to occur Since the cortical dopaminc system continues to mature until the start of the early adult period, the normal ingrowth ofdopamme tibcrs during late adolescence and their formation of aberrant connections with abnormal intrinsic cortieolimbic circuits could "'trigger" the onset of symptoms in those who carry the constitutional vulneribility for schizophrenia, c 1997 Elsevier Science I.td.
Data generated from an earlier study have suggested a model in which greater numbers of long, ver... more Data generated from an earlier study have suggested a model in which greater numbers of long, vertical, associative axons may occur in the anterior cingulate cortex of schizophrenic patients relative to control subjects. This hypothesis has now been tested using neuron-specific antibodies raised against the 200-kilodalton neurofilament subunit, a component of neuronal cytoskeleton, to immunostain axons of human postmortem cingulate cortex. A manual method for counting axons in the region of layer II and sublamina IIIA has been designed and applied blindly to parallel control and schizophrenic immunoprocessed specimens. The results show that there are 25% more vertical axons in the schizophrenic than in the control specimens. Preferentially higher numbers of both long vertical axons (62%) and axons associated with blood vessels (52%) have also been noted in the schizophrenic specimens. By contrast, the number of large-caliber horizontal axons was the same in the two groups; therefore, the greater number of vertical axons in schizophrenic specimens does not appear to represent a nonspecific effect. When these data are corrected for the effects of several confounding variables using analysis of covariance, the overall pattern of the results persists. These findings suggest the possibility that there might be an increase of associative inputs into the anterior cingulate cortex of schizophrenic patients, although it is not clear at present whether the differences noted, if replicative, may be primarily or perhaps only secondarily related to the disorder.
The suggestion that schizophrenia may involve a neurodegenerative process has emanated from the h... more The suggestion that schizophrenia may involve a neurodegenerative process has emanated from the highly replicated finding of ventricular enlargement in brain images of patients with this disorder. These investigations have provided a direct impetus for recent histopathologic studies seeking evidence of a neurodegenerative process in the brains of subjects with schizophrenia. Whereas most postmortem studies have reported the presence of atrophy and/or neuronal loss in several corticolimbic regions of subjects with schizophrenia, no quantitative study, to date, has detected an increase in the number of glial cells. For this reason the changes observed in postmortem schizophrenic brain are not consistent with a typical adult pattern of neuronal degeneration, such as that seen in Huntington's disease. Because several studies have reported various changes in layer II of the anterior cingulate, prefrontal, and entorhinal cortices, the histopathologic findings described are compatible with the idea that schizophrenia involves a disturbance of the "inside-out" migration or differentiation of cortical neurons that normally occurs during ontogenesis. A neurodevelopmental perturbation early in life could result in discrete alterations of corticolimbic circuitry that eventually contribute to the appearance of schizophrenic symptoms during adolescence and adulthood.
Uploads
Papers by Francine Benes