The article is devoted to the study of the phenomena of the State language and the
constitutiona... more The article is devoted to the study of the phenomena of the State language and the
constitutional identity of Ukraine in their interrelation. First of all, the author analyzes the nature of constitutional identity and key approaches to understanding its essence; then she examines the interrelation of such categories as constitutional identity, and national identity and the relation of the State language to them; finally, she finds out the nature of such interrelations and their impact on the status of the State language under the Constitution of Ukraine.
Applying a rational approach, the author establishes that constitutional identity, despite its prevailing negative attitude in Western doctrine, can have a completely positive meaning due to the need to protect national identity. It is established that national identity, as the identity of a community that is the source of constituent power, is the foundation of constitutional identity. The constituent power is realized in the constitution, and thus the elements of national identity (such as language, culture, traditions, symbols, etc.) become components of the constitutional identity. The procedure for adopting a constitution, involving representatives of different groups of the population in the process of its development, discussion, and adoption, makes it an act of constituent power of the political community. However, the identity of the state-forming nation is the fundamental source of constitutional identity. Constitutional identity is the identity of the community that is the subject of constituent power reflected in the constitution (the constitutional text, as well as the values and principles on which it is based). This community is political in nature, but is based on the national identity of the state-forming entity, the exercise of which right to self-determination made possible the existence of a sovereign state in which such a constitution is in force. The state language is part of the constitutional identity because it is an important part of the national identity. Therefore, given the history of the Ukrainian language (not only complicated, due to numerous attempts to forbid, destroy, and eradicate it, but also often tragic), the provisions on it as the only State language have fallen into the category of those provisions of the Constitution that form its core, are under special protection and are part of the constitutional identity.
Despite the fact that the body of constitutional justice has been functioning in Ukraine for quit... more Despite the fact that the body of constitutional justice has been functioning in Ukraine for quite a long period of time, the question of the nature and essence of constitutional jurisprudence (official constitutional doctrine) is still a subject of debate for the domestic scientific community. At the same time, the world discourse on this issue revolves around the fact that modern constitutional courts create law, and constitutional jurisprudence, as a result of their activity, significantly affects the development of national socio-political systems. In this article, we tried to analyze what constitutional jurisprudence is today, what is its nature and the main problems of its development in Ukraine. The search for answers to these questions required the analysis of several related questions of a methodological nature: regarding the essence of the constitution, the system of sources of constitutional law and the place of constitutional jurisprudence in it. Since the concept of official constitutional doctrine is quite actively developing in Lithuania, we devoted special attention to the analysis of the Lithuanian experience, where the constitution is understood as “constitutional law”, which includes, in addition to the official constitutional text, interpretative acts of the Constitutional Court. Considering the isolated properties of constitutional jurisprudence, we tried to look at its formation in Ukraine through the prism of national characteristics. As a result, it was found that its formation was negatively affected, first of all, by long-standing approaches in academic doctrine, in particular, the “Soviet” approach to understanding the sources of constitutional law, which led to the downplaying of the role of constitutional jurisprudence. In addition, we analyzed some defects in the formation of the domestic official constitutional doctrine. Characterizing the current stage of the development of the official constitutional doctrine in Ukraine, it can be stated that, in general, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine has formed the methodological and axiological foundations of its jurisprudence. Particularly valuable from the point of view of axiological content are the latest decisions adopted by the Court already after the beginning of Russia’s full-scale armed aggression against Ukraine, which clearly articulate constitutional values and their fundamental nature.
Конституційні засади консолідації та розвитку україн- ської нації, її історичної свідомості, традиції та культури (до 25-річчя Основного закону України) : матеріали загально- української наук. конф., Київ–Львів 18 червня 2021 р., 2022
За матеріалами виступу на конференції 21.-2.2021 р.
The right to a fair trial is one of the essential elements of the rule of law – a fundamental val... more The right to a fair trial is one of the essential elements of the rule of law – a fundamental value of the modern constitutional state. Among the systems of institutional, organisational, and substantive guarantees for ensuring this right, which stem from the European Court of Human Rights case law, there is 'a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal established by law'. This requirement is organically linked to the principle of the separation of powers, which is a central tenet of constitutionalism and provides for the functioning of the judiciary as a separate, independent branch of power. Therefore, any changes in the judicial systems of modern constitutional states, or, moreover, judicial reforms, should not only avoid contradicting these principles but, on the contrary, should be aimed at ensuring the right to a fair trial. However, the experience of such reforms in a number of Eastern European countries, despite the declaration of their perfect...
Конституціоналізм як єдність ідеології, доктрини та практики конституційно обмеженого правління п... more Конституціоналізм як єдність ідеології, доктрини та практики конституційно обмеженого правління потребує відповідного інструментарію, завдяки якому він стає реальністю. Причому набір таких інструментів є особливим для кожної моделі конституціоналізму: англійської, американської, європейської. В умовах європейської моделі конституціоналізму одним із основних її елементів є конституційна юрисдикція, яка не просто забезпечує юридичне верховенство конституції, а й приводить у дію конституційні обмеження щодо діяльності вищих органів державної влади, збалансовує всю конституційну систему правління, гарантуючи її несвавільність. Поряд із цим протягом останнього десятиліття конституційна юрисдикція у Євро пі, точніше – у східній її частині, переживає складні часи. Низка постсоціалістичних країн (як їх називають органи Ради Європи, країн “молодої демократії”) демонструють нетерпимість до діяльності органів конституційної юрисдикції, втручаються у неї, порушують незалежність чи навіть блокую...
Цей підручник був розроблений за підтримки Координатора проектів ОБСЄ в Україні і буде корисним д... more Цей підручник був розроблений за підтримки Координатора проектів ОБСЄ в Україні і буде корисним для викладачів права, а також практикуючих юристів, а також студентів правничих шкіл. У підручнику презентовано сучасний підхід до конституціоналізму, прав людини, демократії, реалізації і охорони конституції та інших важливих тем. Підручник допоможе покращити якість правничої освіти загалом та, зокрема, якість викладання Конституційного права.
Poland.-2.1. Position of the Constitutional Tribunal (as a starting point).-2.2. Changes in the C... more Poland.-2.1. Position of the Constitutional Tribunal (as a starting point).-2.2. Changes in the Constitutional Judiciary introduced in 2015 and in the Following Years.-2.3. Conclusion to Part I.-3. Crises of Constitutional Justice in Ukraine.-3.1. Position of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine (short overview).-3.2. The Crisis Situation of 2020-2021.-3.3. Conclusion to Part II.-4. Common Features and Di erent Approaches to Resolving Crisis Situations in Poland and Ukraine.-5. Conclusions.
The right to a fair trial is one of the essential elements of the rule of law-a fundamental value... more The right to a fair trial is one of the essential elements of the rule of law-a fundamental value of the modern constitutional state. Among the systems of institutional, organisational, and substantive guarantees for ensuring this right, which stem from the European Court of Human Rights case law, there is 'a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal established by law'. This requirement is organically linked to the principle of the separation of powers, which is a central tenet of constitutionalism and provides for the functioning of the judiciary as a separate, independent branch of power. Therefore, any changes in the judicial systems of modern constitutional states, or, moreover, judicial reforms, should not only avoid contradicting these principles but, on the contrary, should be aimed at ensuring the right to a fair trial. However, the experience of such reforms in a number of Eastern European countries, despite the declaration of their perfectly legitimate and positive goals, raises questions about their true direction. As a result, not only does the institutional mechanism for the protection of human rights (which is the immediate goal of proclaiming the right to a fair trial) suffer, but also the constitutional systems of the countries concerned become unbalanced and unable to respond adequately to political challenges. This paper examines the essence of judicial reforms in a number of Eastern European countries (Serbia, Northern Macedonia, Poland, Hungary, Romania, Moldova, and Ukraine) and analyses them in terms of their impact on ensuring the right to a fair trial and the functioning of constitutional systems. Keywords: judicial reform, the right to a fair trial, independence of the judiciary, separation of powers.
The article is devoted to the study of the phenomena of the State language and the
constitutiona... more The article is devoted to the study of the phenomena of the State language and the
constitutional identity of Ukraine in their interrelation. First of all, the author analyzes the nature of constitutional identity and key approaches to understanding its essence; then she examines the interrelation of such categories as constitutional identity, and national identity and the relation of the State language to them; finally, she finds out the nature of such interrelations and their impact on the status of the State language under the Constitution of Ukraine.
Applying a rational approach, the author establishes that constitutional identity, despite its prevailing negative attitude in Western doctrine, can have a completely positive meaning due to the need to protect national identity. It is established that national identity, as the identity of a community that is the source of constituent power, is the foundation of constitutional identity. The constituent power is realized in the constitution, and thus the elements of national identity (such as language, culture, traditions, symbols, etc.) become components of the constitutional identity. The procedure for adopting a constitution, involving representatives of different groups of the population in the process of its development, discussion, and adoption, makes it an act of constituent power of the political community. However, the identity of the state-forming nation is the fundamental source of constitutional identity. Constitutional identity is the identity of the community that is the subject of constituent power reflected in the constitution (the constitutional text, as well as the values and principles on which it is based). This community is political in nature, but is based on the national identity of the state-forming entity, the exercise of which right to self-determination made possible the existence of a sovereign state in which such a constitution is in force. The state language is part of the constitutional identity because it is an important part of the national identity. Therefore, given the history of the Ukrainian language (not only complicated, due to numerous attempts to forbid, destroy, and eradicate it, but also often tragic), the provisions on it as the only State language have fallen into the category of those provisions of the Constitution that form its core, are under special protection and are part of the constitutional identity.
Despite the fact that the body of constitutional justice has been functioning in Ukraine for quit... more Despite the fact that the body of constitutional justice has been functioning in Ukraine for quite a long period of time, the question of the nature and essence of constitutional jurisprudence (official constitutional doctrine) is still a subject of debate for the domestic scientific community. At the same time, the world discourse on this issue revolves around the fact that modern constitutional courts create law, and constitutional jurisprudence, as a result of their activity, significantly affects the development of national socio-political systems. In this article, we tried to analyze what constitutional jurisprudence is today, what is its nature and the main problems of its development in Ukraine. The search for answers to these questions required the analysis of several related questions of a methodological nature: regarding the essence of the constitution, the system of sources of constitutional law and the place of constitutional jurisprudence in it. Since the concept of official constitutional doctrine is quite actively developing in Lithuania, we devoted special attention to the analysis of the Lithuanian experience, where the constitution is understood as “constitutional law”, which includes, in addition to the official constitutional text, interpretative acts of the Constitutional Court. Considering the isolated properties of constitutional jurisprudence, we tried to look at its formation in Ukraine through the prism of national characteristics. As a result, it was found that its formation was negatively affected, first of all, by long-standing approaches in academic doctrine, in particular, the “Soviet” approach to understanding the sources of constitutional law, which led to the downplaying of the role of constitutional jurisprudence. In addition, we analyzed some defects in the formation of the domestic official constitutional doctrine. Characterizing the current stage of the development of the official constitutional doctrine in Ukraine, it can be stated that, in general, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine has formed the methodological and axiological foundations of its jurisprudence. Particularly valuable from the point of view of axiological content are the latest decisions adopted by the Court already after the beginning of Russia’s full-scale armed aggression against Ukraine, which clearly articulate constitutional values and their fundamental nature.
Конституційні засади консолідації та розвитку україн- ської нації, її історичної свідомості, традиції та культури (до 25-річчя Основного закону України) : матеріали загально- української наук. конф., Київ–Львів 18 червня 2021 р., 2022
За матеріалами виступу на конференції 21.-2.2021 р.
The right to a fair trial is one of the essential elements of the rule of law – a fundamental val... more The right to a fair trial is one of the essential elements of the rule of law – a fundamental value of the modern constitutional state. Among the systems of institutional, organisational, and substantive guarantees for ensuring this right, which stem from the European Court of Human Rights case law, there is 'a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal established by law'. This requirement is organically linked to the principle of the separation of powers, which is a central tenet of constitutionalism and provides for the functioning of the judiciary as a separate, independent branch of power. Therefore, any changes in the judicial systems of modern constitutional states, or, moreover, judicial reforms, should not only avoid contradicting these principles but, on the contrary, should be aimed at ensuring the right to a fair trial. However, the experience of such reforms in a number of Eastern European countries, despite the declaration of their perfect...
Конституціоналізм як єдність ідеології, доктрини та практики конституційно обмеженого правління п... more Конституціоналізм як єдність ідеології, доктрини та практики конституційно обмеженого правління потребує відповідного інструментарію, завдяки якому він стає реальністю. Причому набір таких інструментів є особливим для кожної моделі конституціоналізму: англійської, американської, європейської. В умовах європейської моделі конституціоналізму одним із основних її елементів є конституційна юрисдикція, яка не просто забезпечує юридичне верховенство конституції, а й приводить у дію конституційні обмеження щодо діяльності вищих органів державної влади, збалансовує всю конституційну систему правління, гарантуючи її несвавільність. Поряд із цим протягом останнього десятиліття конституційна юрисдикція у Євро пі, точніше – у східній її частині, переживає складні часи. Низка постсоціалістичних країн (як їх називають органи Ради Європи, країн “молодої демократії”) демонструють нетерпимість до діяльності органів конституційної юрисдикції, втручаються у неї, порушують незалежність чи навіть блокую...
Цей підручник був розроблений за підтримки Координатора проектів ОБСЄ в Україні і буде корисним д... more Цей підручник був розроблений за підтримки Координатора проектів ОБСЄ в Україні і буде корисним для викладачів права, а також практикуючих юристів, а також студентів правничих шкіл. У підручнику презентовано сучасний підхід до конституціоналізму, прав людини, демократії, реалізації і охорони конституції та інших важливих тем. Підручник допоможе покращити якість правничої освіти загалом та, зокрема, якість викладання Конституційного права.
Poland.-2.1. Position of the Constitutional Tribunal (as a starting point).-2.2. Changes in the C... more Poland.-2.1. Position of the Constitutional Tribunal (as a starting point).-2.2. Changes in the Constitutional Judiciary introduced in 2015 and in the Following Years.-2.3. Conclusion to Part I.-3. Crises of Constitutional Justice in Ukraine.-3.1. Position of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine (short overview).-3.2. The Crisis Situation of 2020-2021.-3.3. Conclusion to Part II.-4. Common Features and Di erent Approaches to Resolving Crisis Situations in Poland and Ukraine.-5. Conclusions.
The right to a fair trial is one of the essential elements of the rule of law-a fundamental value... more The right to a fair trial is one of the essential elements of the rule of law-a fundamental value of the modern constitutional state. Among the systems of institutional, organisational, and substantive guarantees for ensuring this right, which stem from the European Court of Human Rights case law, there is 'a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal established by law'. This requirement is organically linked to the principle of the separation of powers, which is a central tenet of constitutionalism and provides for the functioning of the judiciary as a separate, independent branch of power. Therefore, any changes in the judicial systems of modern constitutional states, or, moreover, judicial reforms, should not only avoid contradicting these principles but, on the contrary, should be aimed at ensuring the right to a fair trial. However, the experience of such reforms in a number of Eastern European countries, despite the declaration of their perfectly legitimate and positive goals, raises questions about their true direction. As a result, not only does the institutional mechanism for the protection of human rights (which is the immediate goal of proclaiming the right to a fair trial) suffer, but also the constitutional systems of the countries concerned become unbalanced and unable to respond adequately to political challenges. This paper examines the essence of judicial reforms in a number of Eastern European countries (Serbia, Northern Macedonia, Poland, Hungary, Romania, Moldova, and Ukraine) and analyses them in terms of their impact on ensuring the right to a fair trial and the functioning of constitutional systems. Keywords: judicial reform, the right to a fair trial, independence of the judiciary, separation of powers.
Цей підручник був розроблений за підтримки Координатора проектів ОБСЄ в Україні і буде корисним д... more Цей підручник був розроблений за підтримки Координатора проектів ОБСЄ в Україні і буде корисним для викладачів права, а також практикуючих юристів, а також студентів правничих шкіл. У підручнику презентовано сучасний підхід до конституціоналізму, прав людини, демократії, реалізації і охорони конституції та інших важливих тем. Підручник допоможе покращити якість правничої освіти загалом та, зокрема, якість викладання Конституційного права.
Монографія присвячена європейській моделі конституціоналізму, її ціннісній основі та структу... more Монографія присвячена європейській моделі конституціоналізму, її ціннісній основі та структурі. У книзі досліджуються витоки європейської моделі конституціоналізму, ключові етапи її формування, аналізуються базові конституційні цінності та структурні елементи. Окрема увага приділена конституційним кризам у сучасних європейських державах. Сучасні виклики європейської моделі конституціоналізму проектуються на українські реалії та робляться висновки щодо врахування закономірностей її розвитку в національній практиці державотворення. Дослідження виконане на основі використання широкого кола доктринальних джерел, конституцій та законодавства європейських держав, документів органів Ради Європи, Європейського союзу, практики ЄсПЛ. Книга адресована науковцям, викладачам і студентам юридичних ЗВО, а також політологам, службовцям органів публічної влади, практикуючим юристам.
Книга присвячена проблемам децентралізації, місцевого самоврядування, територіальної організації ... more Книга присвячена проблемам децентралізації, місцевого самоврядування, територіальної організації публічної влади.
Монографія присвячена європейській моделі конституціоналізму, її ціннісній основі та структурі. У... more Монографія присвячена європейській моделі конституціоналізму, її ціннісній основі та структурі. У книзі досліджуються витоки європейської моделі конституціоналізму, ключові етапи її формування, аналізуються базові конституційні цінності та структурні елементи. Окрема увага приділена конституційним кризам у сучасних європейських державах. Сучасні виклики європейської моделі конституціоналізму проектуються на українські реалії та робляться висновки щодо врахування закономірностей її розвитку в національній практиці державотворення. Дослідження виконане на основі використання широкого кола доктринальних джерел, конституцій та законодавства європейських держав, документів органів Ради Європи, Європейського Союзу, практики ЄсПЛ. Книга адресована науковцям, викладачам і студентам юридичних ЗВО, а також політологам, службовцям органів публічної влади, практикуючим юристам.
Доктринальні підходи в діяльності Конституційного Суду України: зб. матеріалів і тез наук.-практ. онлайн-конфер. (м. Київ., 28 жовтня 2020 р.). Київ: Ваіте, 2020
Сьогодні серед конституційних держав найбільш поширеними є два підходи до розуміння природи та су... more Сьогодні серед конституційних держав найбільш поширеними є два підходи до розуміння природи та сутності соціальних прав, які імплементуються, з одного боку, в ліберальних, а з іншого - в соціальнихдержавах.Залежно від обраної концепції соціального захисту, в ліберальних та соціальних державах присутнє різне бачення природи й сутності соціальних прав та ролі держави в їхньому гарантуванні, проте, так чи інакше, взаємозв’язок таких прав із людською гідністю є незаперечним. Більше того, людська гідність є відправною точкою конституційної інтерпретації таких прав.
Uploads
constitutional identity of Ukraine in their interrelation. First of all, the author analyzes the nature of constitutional identity and key approaches to understanding its essence; then she examines the interrelation of such categories as constitutional identity, and national identity and the relation of the State language to them; finally, she finds out the nature of such interrelations and their impact on the status of the State language under the Constitution of Ukraine.
Applying a rational approach, the author establishes that constitutional identity, despite its prevailing negative attitude in Western doctrine, can have a completely positive meaning due to the need to protect national identity. It is established that national identity, as the identity of a community that is the source of constituent power, is the foundation of constitutional identity. The constituent power is realized in the constitution, and thus the elements of national identity (such as language, culture, traditions, symbols, etc.) become components of the constitutional identity. The procedure for adopting a constitution, involving representatives of different groups of the population in the process of its development, discussion, and adoption, makes it an act of constituent power of the political community. However, the identity of the state-forming nation is the fundamental source of constitutional identity. Constitutional identity is the identity of the community that is the subject of constituent power reflected in the constitution (the constitutional text, as well as the values and principles on which it is based). This community is political in nature, but is based on the national identity of the state-forming entity, the exercise of which right to self-determination made possible the existence of a sovereign state in which such a constitution is in force. The state language is part of the constitutional identity because it is an important part of the national identity. Therefore, given the history of the Ukrainian language (not only complicated, due to numerous attempts to forbid, destroy, and eradicate it, but also often tragic), the provisions on it as the only State language have fallen into the category of those provisions of the Constitution that form its core, are under special protection and are part of the constitutional identity.
revolves around the fact that modern constitutional courts create law, and constitutional jurisprudence, as a result of their activity, significantly affects the development of national socio-political systems. In this article, we tried to analyze what constitutional jurisprudence is today, what is its nature and the main problems of its development in
Ukraine. The search for answers to these questions required the analysis of several related questions of a methodological nature: regarding the essence of the constitution, the system of sources of constitutional law and the place of constitutional jurisprudence in it.
Since the concept of official constitutional doctrine is quite actively developing in Lithuania, we devoted special attention to the analysis of the Lithuanian experience, where the constitution is understood as “constitutional law”, which includes, in addition to the official constitutional text, interpretative acts of the Constitutional Court.
Considering the isolated properties of constitutional jurisprudence, we tried to look at its formation in Ukraine through the prism of national characteristics. As a result, it was found that its formation was negatively affected, first of all, by long-standing approaches in academic doctrine, in particular, the “Soviet” approach to understanding the sources of
constitutional law, which led to the downplaying of the role of constitutional jurisprudence.
In addition, we analyzed some defects in the formation of the domestic official constitutional doctrine. Characterizing the current stage of the development of the official constitutional doctrine in Ukraine, it can be stated that, in general, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine has formed the methodological and axiological foundations of its
jurisprudence. Particularly valuable from the point of view of axiological content are the latest decisions adopted by the Court already after the beginning of Russia’s full-scale armed aggression against Ukraine, which clearly articulate constitutional values and their fundamental nature.
constitutional identity of Ukraine in their interrelation. First of all, the author analyzes the nature of constitutional identity and key approaches to understanding its essence; then she examines the interrelation of such categories as constitutional identity, and national identity and the relation of the State language to them; finally, she finds out the nature of such interrelations and their impact on the status of the State language under the Constitution of Ukraine.
Applying a rational approach, the author establishes that constitutional identity, despite its prevailing negative attitude in Western doctrine, can have a completely positive meaning due to the need to protect national identity. It is established that national identity, as the identity of a community that is the source of constituent power, is the foundation of constitutional identity. The constituent power is realized in the constitution, and thus the elements of national identity (such as language, culture, traditions, symbols, etc.) become components of the constitutional identity. The procedure for adopting a constitution, involving representatives of different groups of the population in the process of its development, discussion, and adoption, makes it an act of constituent power of the political community. However, the identity of the state-forming nation is the fundamental source of constitutional identity. Constitutional identity is the identity of the community that is the subject of constituent power reflected in the constitution (the constitutional text, as well as the values and principles on which it is based). This community is political in nature, but is based on the national identity of the state-forming entity, the exercise of which right to self-determination made possible the existence of a sovereign state in which such a constitution is in force. The state language is part of the constitutional identity because it is an important part of the national identity. Therefore, given the history of the Ukrainian language (not only complicated, due to numerous attempts to forbid, destroy, and eradicate it, but also often tragic), the provisions on it as the only State language have fallen into the category of those provisions of the Constitution that form its core, are under special protection and are part of the constitutional identity.
revolves around the fact that modern constitutional courts create law, and constitutional jurisprudence, as a result of their activity, significantly affects the development of national socio-political systems. In this article, we tried to analyze what constitutional jurisprudence is today, what is its nature and the main problems of its development in
Ukraine. The search for answers to these questions required the analysis of several related questions of a methodological nature: regarding the essence of the constitution, the system of sources of constitutional law and the place of constitutional jurisprudence in it.
Since the concept of official constitutional doctrine is quite actively developing in Lithuania, we devoted special attention to the analysis of the Lithuanian experience, where the constitution is understood as “constitutional law”, which includes, in addition to the official constitutional text, interpretative acts of the Constitutional Court.
Considering the isolated properties of constitutional jurisprudence, we tried to look at its formation in Ukraine through the prism of national characteristics. As a result, it was found that its formation was negatively affected, first of all, by long-standing approaches in academic doctrine, in particular, the “Soviet” approach to understanding the sources of
constitutional law, which led to the downplaying of the role of constitutional jurisprudence.
In addition, we analyzed some defects in the formation of the domestic official constitutional doctrine. Characterizing the current stage of the development of the official constitutional doctrine in Ukraine, it can be stated that, in general, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine has formed the methodological and axiological foundations of its
jurisprudence. Particularly valuable from the point of view of axiological content are the latest decisions adopted by the Court already after the beginning of Russia’s full-scale armed aggression against Ukraine, which clearly articulate constitutional values and their fundamental nature.
Книга адресована науковцям, викладачам і студентам юридичних ЗВО, а також політологам, службовцям органів публічної влади, практикуючим юристам.
Книга адресована науковцям, викладачам і студентам юридичних ЗВО, а також політологам, службовцям органів публічної влади, практикуючим юристам.