In "Homonationalism as Assemblage," Jasbir Puar situates her theory of 'homonormative nationalism' within Palestine/Israel to reveal how sexuality is "a crucial formation in the articulation of proper citizens." As an extension to...
moreIn "Homonationalism as Assemblage," Jasbir Puar situates her theory of 'homonormative nationalism' within Palestine/Israel to reveal how sexuality is "a crucial formation in the articulation of proper citizens." As an extension to previous work, Puar clarifies that the queers seen as 'proper' by the settler nation-state are not 'gender queer.' Rather, "trans and gender nonconforming queers are not welcome" in Israeli homonationalism. While Puar's dissection of trans people from homonationalism in 2013 is justified, the common exclusion of trans people from critiques of nationalist 'exception' calls for further interrogation in 2022. Through synthesis of historical and contemporary media, this paper configures a separate analytic of transnationalism to consider how certain trans bodies "pass" into the dominant U.S. body politic, not just by gender, but by investment in the nation. Informed by readings in Queer Indigenous Studies and Scott Lauria Morgensen's theory of settler homonationalism, I argue that trans passing in the U.S. is mediated by racialized gender norms accumulated through the colonial regulation of trans indigeneity over time. While white trans people in the U.S. may experience varying degrees of marginalization, we are also settlers on stolen land. As such, our efforts to pass into the national body politic must be theorized beyond a critique of the visual to consider how passing, as settlers, involves a specific set of nationalist convictions, gestures, and actions linked to the elimination of Indigenous peoples. Transnationalist politics-whether conservative or liberal-distance the trans movement from its anti-assimilationist roots, normalize the settler state's claims to Indigenous lands, and ultimately vacate the possibility for ever-necessary linkage between trans liberation and decolonization.