Food
Processing & Technology
Sharoba et al., J Food Process Technol 2012, 3:8
http://dx.doi.org/10.4172/2157-7110.1000170
Research Article
Open Access
Effect of Addition Some Hydrocolloids and Sweeteners on Flow Behavior
and Sensory Properties of Papaya-Apricot Nectar Blends
Sharoba AM*, El-Desouky AI and Mahmoud MH
Food Science Department, Moshtohor Faculty of Agriculture, Benha University, Egypt
Abstract
In this study, rheological properties of several food hydrocolloids (guar gum, xanthan gum and arabic gum) and
sweeteners (aspartame and stevioside) were evaluated using a rotational viscometer at concentrations of (0.5% and
1.2g/L for hydrocolloids and sweeteners, respectively), Hydrocolloids and sweeteners concentrations were selected
depending on preliminary sensory evaluation. The rheological properties for nectar samples were measured at
four temperatures (5, 25, 50 and 75°C). The low behavior of the nectars was characterized as non-Newtonian
(pseudoplastic with yield stress). The pseudoplasticity increased due to hydrocolloids addition, while it decreased
due to sweeteners addition. Herschel-Bulkley and Bingham rheological models were used to describe the low
behavior of papaya–apricot nectars samples. Addition of aspartame and stevioside reduced the viscosity of nectar
samples compared to control nectar samples. Nectar sample contains hydrocolloids had a higher and best sensory
and rheological characteristic. Papaya-apricot nectar containing guar gum, xanthan gum or arabic gum had high
score in overall all acceptability.
Keywords: Hydrocolloids, Sweeteners, Papaya-Apricot nectar,
Flow behavior, Rheological characteristics, Activation energy for low,
Sensory properties
Nomenclature:
Symbol
ATH
B1 to B12
Ea
HB
K
n
R
r
r2
PAN
LSD
S.E.
T
t
τ
τ0
γ
η
η∞
Term
hixotropy
Blend nectar numbers
Activation energy for low
Herschel-Bulkley Model
Consistency index
Flow behaviour index
Gas constant
Correlation coeicients
Determination coeicient
Papaya-apricot nectar
Least signiicant diference
Standard error
Temperature
Temperature
Shear stress
Yield stress
Shear rate
Viscosity
Constant in eqn (3)
Unit or deinition
Pa/s
KJ/mol
Pa.sn
Dimensionless
8.314 kJ/kg mol. K
K
°C
Pa
Pa
s-1
Pa.s
Pa.s
Introduction
Papaya ranks highest per serving among fruit for carotenoids,
potassium, iber, and ascorbic acid content [1,2]. Papaya contains 108
mg ascorbic acid per 100 g of fresh fruit, which is higher than oranges
67 mg/100 g [3].
he papaya industry capacity is underutilized. First, fresh whole
papaya fruit does not transport well; bruising due to a sot skin, a short
shelf life. Fruit is oten sot, wrinkled and/or bruised, signiicantly
decreasing consumer acceptance in an environment where unblemished
J Food Process Technol
ISSN:2157-7110 JFPT, an open access journal
fruit is expected. Second, a processed papaya product that maintains its
fresh lavor does not currently exist. Research on processing of papaya
fruit has resulted in a sweet (non-bitter), stable product; traditional
pasteurization treatment leads to cooked lavor development [4]. Other
heat processed fruits, including apples, oranges and tomatoes, do not
sufer such an extreme alteration from their fresh fruit lavor ater
processing. his has led to papaya products that are mixed with other
fruits to dilute or mask the of-lavors [5].
In order to improve the cloudy stability of juices for prolonged
periods, hydrocolloids have been added [6,7].
Gum arabic is the dried gummy exudate from the stems and
branches of Acacia Senegal Willdenow or of other related species of
Acacia (Fam. Leguminosae) [8]. Gum arabic is approved for use as food
additives by the US Food and Drug Administration and is on the list of
substances that is a generally recognized as safe (GRAS) with speciic
limitations [9]. Gum arabic is the oldest and best known of all the tree
gum exudates from certain species of Acacia, family leguminosae.
he chemical and physicochemical properties of this gum can vary
signiicantly depending on the source, tree age, time of exudation, type
of storage and climatic conditions [10].
Gum arabic is widely used in the food industry, mainly to impart
desirable qualities through its inluence over viscosity, body and texture.
In aqueous systems, it is used as an emulsiier, stabilizer, thickener,
adhesive, and to prevent crystallization of sugar and the formation of
ice crystals. Other hydrocolloids are also used for these purposes [11].
*Corresponding author: Dr. Sharoba AM, Food Science Department, Moshtohor
Faculty of Agriculture, Benha University, Egypt, Fax:+20132467786; Tel: +2 012
21463079; E-mail: ashraf_sharoba@yahoo.com
Received June 05, 2012; Accepted July 25, 2012; Published July 29, 2012
Citation: Sharoba AM, El-Desouky AI, Mahmoud MH (2012) Effect of Addition
Some Hydrocolloids and Sweeteners on Flow Behavior and Sensory Properties of
Papaya-Apricot Nectar Blends. J Food Process Technol 3:170. doi:10.4172/21577110.1000170
Copyright: © 2012 Sharoba AM, et al. This is an open-access article distributed
under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the
original author and source are credited.
Volume 3 • Issue 8 • 1000170
Citation: Sharoba AM, El-Desouky AI, Mahmoud MH (2012) Effect of Addition Some Hydrocolloids and Sweeteners on Flow Behavior and Sensory
Properties of Papaya-Apricot Nectar Blends. J Food Process Technol 3:170. doi:10.4172/2157-7110.1000170
Page 2 of 7
Xanthan gum has been used in a wide variety of foods for a number
of important reasons, including emulsion stabilization, temperature
stability, compatibility with food ingredients, and its pseudoplastic
rheological properties [12].
Guar gum is used as a gelling and thickening agent in many food
products such as sauces, syrups, ice cream, instant foods, beverages,
and confectionaries [13,14]. Guar gum and its derivatives are also
extensively used in various industries such as mining, paper, textile,
ceramic, paint, cosmetic, pharmaceutical and explosives [14].
Stevia rebaudiana Bertoni, belonging to the Compositae family, is
a sweet herb native to Brazil and Paraguay. Stevia sweeteners, extracts
from the leaves of this herb, are commercially available in Japan, Korea,
China, South-East Asia and South America, where they have been used
for some decades to sweeten a variety of foods including beverages,
confectionery, pickled vegetables and seafoods. Recently, stevia extracts
have been extensively used as the dietary supplements in USA [15].
he high-intensity sweetener aspartame has been consumed
in more than 6000 products by hundreds of millions of people
in countries around the world [16]. Aspartame and mixtures of
aspartame+acesulfame K are used instead of sucrose to sweeten many
beverages and dairy products aimed at weight-conscious consumers.
Many authors have studied the sensory properties of these high
intensity sweeteners, especially with respect to their atertaste [17].
In fruit juice and beverage, sensory properties and organoleptic
attributes of the inal products are inluenced by the several factors
such as type and amount of acids and sweeteners [18].
Flow properties of fruit purees are of considerable interest in the
development of fruit products for technological and marketing reasons.
Together with others, they provide the information necessary for the
optimum design of unit processes; contribute to the quality control in
both manufacturing processes and inal product; limit the acceptability
and the ield of application of a new product; and inally, they are a
powerful tool into understanding molecular structure changes [19-21].
Blendes of papaya and apricot nectar appear that the nectar blends
Blends No
B* (1)
Control
B (2)
B (3)
*
Mixed papaya puree+apricot juice
containing equal percentage of papaya puree and apricot juice had the
higher score in all attributes and acceptable to panelists due to better
consistency and lavor [22]. Accordingly, this work was carried out to
study the efect of addition of some hydrocolloids and sweeteners on
sensory and rheological properties of papaya-apricot nectar.
Materials and Methods
Materials
Apricot fruits (Prunus armeniaca) variety Amar were picked at the
ripe stage from Amar village, Qalyoubia Governorate, Egypt. he fruits
weight ranged from 60 to 65g.
Papaya fruits (Carica papaya L.cv. Sunrise Solo) are usually
collected green mature from the farm of Moshtohor Faculty of
Agriculture, Benha University, Egypt. he fruits weight ranged from
750 to 1750g. he fruit surface was treated by H2O2 5% as disinfectant.
It ripened under storage at room temperature for 3-4 days.
Sweeteners: Aspartame was obtained from Hortimex, 62-510
Konin, Poland. Stevioside was obtained from Jining Yunhe Stevioside
Co., Ltd, Shandong, China.
Hydrocolloids: Guar gum and Xanthan gum were obtained from
CP Kelco Germany GmbH, 23755 Grossenbrode, Germany. Arabic
gum was obtained from Hortimex, 62-510 Konin, Poland.
Methods
Processing:
•
Preparation of papaya-apricot nectar samples: he papaya
puree and apricot juice (1:1) were mixed together as recommended
[22]. his mixture was used to prepare the formulas indicated in
Table (A).
Nectars pH was adjusted to 3.5 by adding citric acid solution (50%
w/v), [23,24].
Methods:
•
Sensory evaluation: Sensory evaluation was carried out by
Sugar solution or water
º
Hydrocolloids
Sweeteners
25% mixed papaya puree+apricot juice
75% sugar solution (18 ± 0.5 brix)
-
-
25% mixed papaya puree+apricot juice
75% water
-
1.2 g/L
aspartame**
25% mixed papaya puree+apricot juice
75% water
-
1.2 g/L
stevioside
B (4)
25% mixed papaya puree+apricot juice
75% sugar solution (17.5 ± 0.5 º brix)
0.5% guar gum
-
B (5)
25% mixed papaya puree+apricot juice
75% sugar solution (17.5 ± 0.5 º brix)
0.5% arabic gum
-
B (6)
25% mixed papaya puree+apricot juice
75% sugar solution (17.5 ± 0.5 º brix)
0.5% xanthan gum
-
B (7)
25% mixed papaya puree+apricot juice
74.5% water
0.5% guar gum
1.2 g/L
aspartame
B (8)
25% mixed papaya puree+apricot juice
74.5% water
0.5% arabic gum
1.2 g/L
aspartame
B (9)
25% mixed papaya puree+apricot juice
74.5% water
0.5% xanthan gum
1.2 g/L
aspartame
B (10)
25% mixed papaya puree+apricot juice
74.5% water
0.5% guar gum
1.2 g/L
stevioside
B (11)
25% mixed papaya puree+apricot juice
74.5% water
0.5% arabic gum
1.2 g/L
stevioside
B (12)
25% mixed papaya puree+apricot juice
74.5% water
0.5% xanthan gum
1.2 g/L
stevioside
B =Blend
**
Sweeteners were added 1.2g/L of inal prepared nectar
Table A: formulas of papaya-apricot nectar samples.
J Food Process Technol
ISSN:2157-7110 JFPT, an open access journal
Volume 3 • Issue 8 • 1000170
Citation: Sharoba AM, El-Desouky AI, Mahmoud MH (2012) Effect of Addition Some Hydrocolloids and Sweeteners on Flow Behavior and Sensory
Properties of Papaya-Apricot Nectar Blends. J Food Process Technol 3:170. doi:10.4172/2157-7110.1000170
Page 3 of 7
a properly well trained panel of 12 panelists. hey were selected if
their individual scores in 10 diferent tests showed a reproducibility
of 90%. he 12 member internal panel evaluated the diferent
papaya and apricot nectar blends for color, texture, taste, lavor,
mouth feel (smoothness, consistency, spread ability) and overall
acceptability. Mineral water was used by the panelists to rinse the
mouth between samples, according [25].
he sensory evaluation of papaya-apricot nectar was carried out at
two phase. he irst phase was done to select the best concentration
of adding each hydrocolloids or sweeteners in papaya-apricot
nectar. he second phase was done to know the best blends of
hydrocolloids and sweeteners in papaya-apricot nectar.
•
Selection of the best concentration of hydrocolloid
and sweeteners: Many samples of papaya-apricot nectars were
prepared containing diferent concentration of guar gum, xanthan
gum and arabic gum as hydrocolloid and aspartame and stevioside
as sweeteners. Each additive was added alone in papaya-apricot
nectar. All samples of papaya-apricot nectar were subjected for
sensory evaluation to know the best concentration of additives
had high acceptability in sensory attributes. he concentration of
additives which had high score in sensory evaluation was used for
preparing inished papaya-apricot nectars samples which used to
complete this study.
•
Rheological measurements: Viscosity measurement was
carried out by the Brookield Digital Viscometer Model DV-II+
(USA) with 18 rotational speeds for comprehensive data gathering
(0.3, 0.5, 0.6, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 10, 12, 20, 30, 50, 60 and
100 rpm). he Brookield small sample adapter spindle was used.
Data was analyzed by using Universal Sotware US200, PhysicaGermany. Each value of rheological parameters is the average
of three replicates. Herschel-Bulkley and Bingham plastic math
models provide a numerically and graphically analyze the behavior
of data sets.
•
Herschel-Bulkley model: It describes the low curve of a
material with a yield stress and shear thinning or shear thickening
behavior at stresses above the yield to calculate the viscosity and
yield point of ideal-viscous luids.
τ = τOHB + K
γ
n
(1)
where:
τ = Shear stress (Pa) τOHB= Yield stress, shear stress at zero shear
rate, (Pa)
K = Consistency index (Pa.sn)
γ
= Shear rate (sec-1)
n = Flow index (dimensionless)
he calculated parameters for this model are: Herschel-Bulkley
yield stress (τOHB), Consistency index (K) and Flow index (n).
τ = τOB + ηB γ
Bingham Plastic: he Bingham equation is
(2)
where:
τ = Shear stress (Pa) τOB=Yield stress, shear stress at zero shear rate,
(Pa)
ηB = Plastic viscosity (Pa.s) = Shear rate (sec-1)
γ
J Food Process Technol
ISSN:2157-7110 JFPT, an open access journal
he calculated parameters for this model are: Plastic (apparent)
viscosity (ηB) and Bingham yield stress (τOB).
he efect of temperature on viscosity and low activation energy:
Activation energy was calculated using Arrhenius-type equation as
mentioned [26,27]
η = η∞ exp (Ea/ RT)
Where η is the viscosity, η∞ is a constant, Ea is the activation energy
of low (J/mol) R is the gas constant, and T is the absolute temperature
in K.
•
hixotropic area: hixotropic area calculates the area
between two curves, commonly the up and down curves of a shear
rate sweep (the gab area between the ascending and descending
rheogram curves). his area is given in (Pas-1) and is oten used
as a measure of a sample’s thixotropy. Also the thixotropic area
is a measure for the destruction (viscosity decrease at thixotropic
samples) or construction (at rheopectic samples) of structures at
inclining and declining load.
Statistical Analysis
Data for the sensory evaluation of all nectar preparations were
subjected to the analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by multiple
comparisons using least signiicant diference, (L.S.D.0.05) [28].
Results and Discussion
Efect of mixing some sweeteners and hydrocolloid blends in
sensory properties of apricot-papaya nectar:
Organoleptic parameters are good indicating the possibility of
nectar for acceptability. In this study we used (aspartame and stevioside)
to produce low-calorie fruit nectars; aspartame has a clean, sugar-like
taste, enhances fruit and can be safely used under heat with some loss
of sweetness at higher temperatures. It is primarily responsible for the
growth of the low-calorie and reduced-calorie product market in the
past two decades and is today an important component of thousands
of foods and beverages. Because aspartame helps impart a good, sweettasting lavor to low-calorie and reduced-calorie foods and beverages,
it is helpful to diabetics and beneicial in weight control by managing
caloric intake while still maintaining a healthful diet. In the other hand
stevioside is a low-calorie sweetener derived from Stevia rebaudiana,
is 300 times sweeter than sucrose. he plant leaves have been used for
centuries in Paraguay to sweeten bitter beverages and to make tea.
Stevioside is highly soluble in water, very sweet in taste, and synergistic
with other sweeteners [29]. Color, texture, taste, lavor, mouth feel and
overall acceptability of papaya-apricot nectar with diferent blends of
sweetness and hydrocolloid were organoleptically evaluated; the results
are indicated in Table (1).
Non tabulated results for sensory evaluation of papaya-apricot
nectar indicated that the best percentage additive of hydrocolloids
for enhanced the texture of nectar was 0.5% for either guar, arabic or
xanthan gum. Concerning for sweeteners, the best percentage additive
of sweeteners was 1.2g/l for either aspartame or stevoside. Nearly, the
acceptable percentages of adding hydrocolloids and sweeteners were
in agreement with those obtained, whom were used hydrocolloids and
sweeteners in other fruits and vegetables products [30-32]. So, samples
of papaya-apricot nectar were prepared containing each acceptable
percentage of hydrocolloids and sweeteners or blends of some of them.
Volume 3 • Issue 8 • 1000170
Citation: Sharoba AM, El-Desouky AI, Mahmoud MH (2012) Effect of Addition Some Hydrocolloids and Sweeteners on Flow Behavior and Sensory
Properties of Papaya-Apricot Nectar Blends. J Food Process Technol 3:170. doi:10.4172/2157-7110.1000170
Page 4 of 7
Sensory evaluation of papaya-apricot nectar
Data in Table (1) indicated that papaya-apricot nectar containing
guar gum, xanthan gum or arabic gum had high score in overall all
acceptability. All papaya-apricot nectar containing hydrocolloids
were acceptable more than control papaya-apricot nectar which free
from hydrocolloids. Also from the data for overall all acceptability,
can grouped the papaya-apricot nectar to four groups as statically
analyzed and indicated by letter in the table as follow: group one which
mentioned before had letter (a) which contained hydrocolloid only,
second group which had letter between (b to d) which had hydrocolloid
with sweetener, or control and hired group had letter (e) containing
sweetener. All nectar samples including control had high average score
in overall all acceptability more than eighty except nectar samples
containing sweetener alone. So, can conclude to use hydrocolloid alone
or and sweetener when prepare nectar fruits. Mouth feel is important
properties in sensory evaluation. Data in Table (1) indicated that all
nectar samples can divided to two groups as follow: irst group, included
control nectar sample and nectars containing each hydrocolloid.
Second, group other nectars containing hydrocolloid with sweetener
or sweetener only. Neutrally, the papaya-apricot nectar (control) had
high score in color, lavor and taste among all nectar samples. On the
other hand all nectars samples containing hydrocolloids had score in
texture more than control samples. It’s worthy that the papaya-apricot
nectar containing any sweetener without adding hydrocolloids had the
lowest score in sensory properties between all papaya-apricot nectar.
purees containing particles with non uniform sizes and shapes, stability
may sometimes be diicult to achieve at either very low or high shear
rates. At high shear rates, turbulent low conditions are likely to be
induced by the dispersed particles, resulting in structural breakdown of
the sample. Even with these complexities, most purees generally exhibit
non-Newtonian low patterns.
herefore, the non-Newtonian models in Eqs. (1) and (2) were
considered for their suitability in describing the low of papaya-apricot
nectar. he Herschel-Bulkley model has been used extensively in
studies on handling and heating/cooling of foods because it gives good
description of luid low behavior in the shear rate range that is easily
measured by most rheological instruments.
Most fruit purees and nectars show shear-thinning behavior
(0<n<1), a situation that may be regarded as an indication of breakdown
of structural units in a food due to the hydrodynamic forces generated
during shear [34]. Quantiication of low parameters within some
deined shear rate ranges may be a good way of studying these changes
in product structure. If the foodstuf has a inite yield stress, the yield
term can be included in the Power Law model to yield the HerschelBulkley (HB) model: he yield stress can be determined experimentally,
graphically as explained [35], or calculated by a separate model.
Selection of rheology models
he HB model is convenient because Newtonian, Power law
and Bingham Fluids can be considered as special cases obeying this
generalized model [36]. However, the yield stress obtained by itting
the three parameter HB model is strongly dependent on the selected
shear rate range [35].
As mentioned that choice of an appropriate model to relate
product viscosity to brix number and shear rate depends essentially
on the intended application and use of a suitable instrument to
determine the model parameters [33]. During experiments, laminar
low conditions are necessary for accurate measurements; and for fruit
he Correlation coeicients was used to determine how good
the models it the data. Based on Correlation coeicients and overall
suitability of the models considered, the Herschel-Bulkley and
Bingham models were selected to describe the rheological behavior of
papaya-apricot nectar samples.
Sensory attributes (max. score)
Products
(Nectar Blends)
Color
(20)
Texture
(20)
Taste
(20)
Flavor
(20)
Mouthfeel
(20)
Overall acceptability
(100)
Papaya-apricot nectar (control)
(B1)
19.81a±0.38
16.92c±0.64
18.07a±0.54
19.48a±0.34
18.21a±0.28
83.17cd±2.45
PAN with aspartame (B2)
11.27e±0.08
8.22d±0.86
10.15d±0.47
11.08e±0.83
13.65b±0.84
71.16e±1.07
PAN with stevioside (B3)
11.64e±0.42
8.34d±0.99
9.63d±0.83
10.39e±0.71
13.84b ±0.57
69.10e±2.08
PAN with guar gum (B4)
18.57b±0.39
19.41a±0.14
17.64ab±1.23
17.82b±0.35
18.94a±0.61
96.14a±1.83
PAN with arabic gum (B5)
18.31b±0.48
17.86abc±0.53
16.81ab±0.85
17.21b±0.96
18.04a±0.34
93.18a±0.97
PAN with xanthan gum (B6)
18.94b±0.24
18.87ab±0.67
17.52ab±0.62
17.91b±0.67
19.01a±0.81
95.53a±0.84
PAN with (aspartame + guar gum)
(B7)
15.41cd±0.19
18.60abc±1.04
15.99bc±0.97
15.86c±0.96
14.58b±0.70
88.17b±1.27
PAN with (aspartame + arabic
gum) (B8)
14.87d±0.54
17.39bc±0.82
14.86c±1.28
15.44d±0.51
14.33b±0.93
83.11cd±1.36
PAN with (aspartame + xanthan
gum) (B9)
15.68c±0.61
18.12abc±0.32
15.64bc±0.25
15.91c±0.28
14.61b±0.82
86.17bc±1.57
PAN with (stevioside + guar gum)
(B10)
15.36cd±0.27
18.43abc±0.55
15.68bc±0.31
14.79d±0.37
14.47b±0.71
84.75bcd±1.25
PAN with (stevioside + arabic
gum) (B11)
14.81d±0.69
17.11bc±0.36
14.77c±0.52
14.68d±0.68
14.32b±0.68
81.17d±2.04
PAN with (stevioside + xanthan
gum) (B12)
15.54c±0.40
18.04abc±0.75
15.65bc±0.61
14.89d±0.72
14.58b±0.94
83.19cd±1.67
0.67
1.81
1.76
0.81
1.64
4.57
L.S.D at P<0.05
a,b
There is no signiicant different ( P > 0.05) between any two means, within the same attribute have the same letter.
Table 1: Sensory properties of papaya and apricot nectar (PAN) blends.
J Food Process Technol
ISSN:2157-7110 JFPT, an open access journal
Volume 3 • Issue 8 • 1000170
Citation: Sharoba AM, El-Desouky AI, Mahmoud MH (2012) Effect of Addition Some Hydrocolloids and Sweeteners on Flow Behavior and Sensory
Properties of Papaya-Apricot Nectar Blends. J Food Process Technol 3:170. doi:10.4172/2157-7110.1000170
Page 5 of 7
Efect of mixing some sweeteners and hydrocolloid blends on
rheological characterization of apricot-papaya nectar
he rheological behavior of hydrocolloids is of special importance
when they are used to modify low behavior. It is also well recognized
that rheological properties play a role in process design, evaluation
and modeling. hese properties are sometimes measured as an
indicator of product quality (e.g. indication of total solids or change
in molecular size). Rheological data are required for calculation in any
process involving luid low (e.g. pump sizing, extraction, iltration,
extrusion, puriication) and play an important role in the analyses of
low conditions in food processes such as pasteurization, evaporation,
drying and aseptic processing.
In this study three hydrocolloids (guar gum, xanthan gum and
arabic gum) were used in papaya-apricot nectar due to improve the
rheological properties.
Shear rate – shear stress curves (recorded by Brookield Digital
Viscometer) and data in Tables (2-3) for nectar samples showed
non-Newtonian pseudoplastic with yield stress luids as the apparent
viscosity decreases with increasing shear rate, therefore they exhibit a
shear-thinning behavior.
Several models have been used to characterize the low behavior
of papaya-apricot nectars mixed with gum and sweeteners and among
them Herschel-Bulkley model has been frequently used for the
determination of rheological properties of the fruit juices and nectars.
In addition, Bingham model has been also used for the characterization
of luid foods such as fruit juices and nectars.
he parameters obtained for the Herschel-Bulkely and Bingham
models are summarized in Tables (2–3). he Correlation coeicients,
Nectar
samples
Papaya-apricot
nectar
(control) (B1)
PAN with aspartame
(B2)
PAN with stevioside
(B3)
PAN with Guar gum
(B4)
PAN with Arabic gum
(B5)
PAN with Xanthan
gum (B6)
t
C
for all cases, were higher than 0.964. Higher measure temperatures
showed slightly lower values (K, ηB τ0HB and τ0B), this trend of results
are in according to references [35,37].
Higher yield stress values were observed due to addition of gums
and lower temperatures. his is in agreement .It has been recognized
that the yield stress is a useful property of gums when they are used
as binders, because it helps keep various components of the food
formulation in place [37].
Gums addition showed that guar gum had generally higher
synergistic efect than xanthan and arabic gum when used with papayaapricot, this trend is similar with the fond guar gum had high low
behavior parameters than arabic gum [38]. It could be concluded in
the view of the results that guar gum particularly was more efective
in increasing “K” values of papaya-apricot nectar. In the case of guar
its molecular mass and galactose:mannose ratio strongly depended
on the origin of the gum. In addition, the branching degree of the
hydrocolloid, which is higher for guar, can also play an important part
in the galactomannan-nectar compound interactions according [38].
Similar trends were observed for other nectars content gums. he
“K” values were increased with adding gum suggesting better synergy
when they used to combine with papaya-apricot nectar. Combination
of papaya-apricot nectar and guar gum may help attaining desired
consistency. Guar gum is used in food industry for thickening purpose
since it is more economical compared to other stabilizers. Since the
synergy between guar and papaya-apricot nectar in terms of increasing
the consistency of nectars was found better in this study, therefore the
combined of guar- papaya-apricot nectar mix could be recommended
in diferent fruit nectars formulations. Flow behavior index of nectar
samples decreased with temperature.
Parameters for different rheology models
Herschel-Bulkley
°
Thixotropy
(Pa.s-1)
Bingham
τ0HB
K
n
r
ηB
τ0B
r
5
4.89
4.79
0.159
0.999
22.31
4.83
0.996
138.01
25
4.14
4.55
0.153
0.999
19.11
4.24
0.996
124.15
50
3.82
4.28
0.148
0.999
15.87
3.94
0.992
116.81
75
3.51
3.96
0.139
0.998
12.12
3.75
0.990
107.46
5
0.91
2.33
0.122
0.984
13.46
1.21
0.984
38.11
25
0.63
2.09
0.121
0.986
10.83
1.05
0.986
31.67
50
0.42
1.93
0.119
0.975
9.14
0.91
0.976
25.08
75
0.19
1.77
0.120
0.972
7.25
0.78
0.971
18.40
5
0.68
2.28
0.113
0.996
13.27
0.89
0.988
38.45
25
0.49
2.04
0.112
0.997
10.75
0.74
0.982
31.27
50
0.32
1.86
0.112
0.991
9.21
0.65
0.965
25.19
75
0.17
1.65
0.109
0.985
7.34
0.55
0.966
18.15
5
8.12
15.83
0.603
0.999
49.83
8.96
0.995
74.34
25
7.54
14.77
0.582
0.999
46.81
8.40
0.997
71.81
50
5.84
12.46
0.531
0.997
44.31
8.03
0.991
68.50
75
5.12
9.11
0.485
0.990
42.10
7.79
0.990
64.39
5
7.15
11.65
0.335
0.999
43.12
7.74
0.999
81.07
25
6.28
8.93
0.333
0.999
41.08
7.09
0.996
75.45
50
5.20
7.58
0.321
0.999
38.91
6.73
0.991
70.29
75
4.06
6.42
0.310
0.999
35.67
6.14
0.979
66.49
5
7.78
13.08
0.589
0.999
46.34
8.41
0.993
78.64
25
6.34
10.67
0.551
0.999
44.09
8.12
0.991
74.38
50
5.83
10.11
0.501
0.998
42.33
7.76
0.991
71.12
75
5.04
8.63
0.480
0.999
40.46
7.31
0.988
67.34
Table 2: Effect of addition some sweetness and hydrocolloids on rheological parameters of papaya and apricot nectar.
J Food Process Technol
ISSN:2157-7110 JFPT, an open access journal
Volume 3 • Issue 8 • 1000170
Citation: Sharoba AM, El-Desouky AI, Mahmoud MH (2012) Effect of Addition Some Hydrocolloids and Sweeteners on Flow Behavior and Sensory
Properties of Papaya-Apricot Nectar Blends. J Food Process Technol 3:170. doi:10.4172/2157-7110.1000170
Page 6 of 7
Nectar
samples
aspartame with Guar
gum (B7)
aspartame with
Arabic gum (B8)
aspartame with
Xanthan gum (B9)
Stevioside with Guar
gum (B10)
Stevioside with
Arabic gum (B11)
Stevioside with
Xanthan gum (B12)
Parameters for different rheology models
t
C
Herschel-Bulkley
°
Thixotropy
(Pa.s-1)
Bingham
τ0HB
K
n
r
ηB
τ0B
r
5
6.63
12.54
0.491
0.999
42.10
7.33
0.998
68.15
25
5.46
11.29
0.443
0.999
39.89
6.79
0.973
65.47
50
4.62
10.74
0.399
0.998
37.82
6.27
0.968
61.33
75
3.95
10.06
0.379
0.995
34.43
5.76
0.967
58.94
5
4.92
10.11
0.294
0.999
36.84
5.68
0.999
78.19
25
3.98
8.24
0.259
0.999
35.01
5.13
0.998
70.01
50
3.35
6.71
0.244
0.999
32.54
4.65
0.991
67.87
75
2.96
5.94
0.225
0.996
28.49
4.18
0.986
64.28
5
5.51
11.37
0.479
0.999
40.22
6.28
0.997
75.28
25
4.43
9.14
0.431
0.997
37.85
5.81
0.992
71.14
50
3.89
8.58
0.397
0.994
34.99
5.34
0.988
69.34
75
3.05
7.86
0.374
0.990
32.41
4.79
0.964
66.11
5
6.43
12.21
0.474
0.999
41.35
7.26
0.995
69.74
25
5.37
11.03
0.431
0.995
39.15
6.73
0.994
65.96
50
4.51
10.40
0.394
0.995
37.14
6.16
0.987
62.14
75
3.86
9.81
0.368
0.991
33.74
5.71
0.976
59.81
5
4.79
9.86
0.287
0.999
36.16
5.65
0.988
78.37
25
3.88
8.06
0.253
0.993
34.57
5.09
0.983
73.15
50
3.13
6.63
0.235
0.995
31.90
4.54
0.971
70.13
75
2.74
5.71
0.213
0.987
27.61
4.11
0.972
67.81
5
5.21
11.08
0.461
0.999
40.01
6.22
0.985
77.11
25
4.17
9.02
0.417
0.991
37.28
5.73
0.982
73.21
50
3.66
8.34
0.391
0.989
34.32
5.22
0.982
71.14
75
2.89
7.56
0.366
0.990
31.74
4.71
0.979
68.27
Table 3: Effect mixing of sweetness and hydrocolloids on rheological parameters of papaya and apricot nectar.
Ea
(kJ/mol.)
η∞
(mPa.s)
Correlation coeficient (r2)
Temperature range
(°C)
Papaya-apricot nectar (control) (B1)
9.34
3.11
0.999
5-75
PAN with aspartame (B2)
5.84
1.95
0.956
5-75
PAN with stevioside (B3)
5.13
1.87
0.943
5-75
PAN with guar gum (B4)
16.48
4.20
0.999
5-75
PAN with arabic gum (B5)
14.39
4.12
0.999
5-75
PAN with xanthan gum (B6)
15.96
4.16
0.999
5-75
PAN with (aspartame+ guar gum) (B7)
11.23
6.24
0.994
5-75
PAN with (aspartame+ arabic gum) (B8)
10.55
6.08
0.995
5-75
PAN with (aspartame+xanthan gum) (B9)
10.98
6.13
0.991
5-75
PAN with (Stevioside+guar gum) (B10)
11.01
6.19
0.986
5-75
PAN with (Stevioside+arabic gum) (B11)
10.37
5.91
0.968
5-75
PAN with (Stevioside+xanthan gum) (B12)
10.63
5.64
0.974
5-75
Nectar sample
Table 4: Parameters for the Arrhenius equation to predict the variation of viscosity of papaya-apricot nectar blended with some sweeteners and hydrocolloids.
Addition of sweeteners to the papaya-apricot nectar caused a
decreased in values (K, ηB τ0HB and τ0B). he “n” values increased sharply
with adding gums to papaya-apricot nectar, while they decreased with
adding sweeteners. Both demonstrated non-Newtonian low.
hixotropy behavior of papaya-apricot nectar and efect of
addition of some hydrocolloids and sweeteners
From the shear rate-shear stress curves, nectar samples exhibited
thixotropy, exhibit time dependent properties, which mean that
the apparent viscosity or consistency will decrease with time. he
area enclosed by the hysteresis loop signiies the degree of structural
breakdown during steady shearing. he upper curve of the rheogram
was found to be higher compared to the down ward curve which
indicated a thinning of nectar samples with shearing. Similar behavior
was observed [26,27,39-42]. he thixotropy (Pa/s) values increased
J Food Process Technol
ISSN:2157-7110 JFPT, an open access journal
with increasing total solids nectar samples. All hydrocolloid decrease
the thixotropy.
Efect of temperature on low behavior of nectar samples
Temperature has an important inluence on the low behavior of
nectar samples content hydrocolloids. Since diferent temperatures
are usually encountered during processing of hydrocolloids, their
rheological properties are studied as a function of temperature.
he efect of temperature on the apparent viscosity at a speciied
shear rate is generally expressed by an Arrhenius-type model. he
Arrhenius equation to a great extent explains the relationship
between the temperature and viscosity. he viscosity is dependent
up on the intermolecular distances. As the temperature is increased,
the intermolecular distances increase and therefore the viscosity
will decrease for these main reasons. he viscosity is a function of
temperature and the dissolved solid concentration.
Volume 3 • Issue 8 • 1000170
Citation: Sharoba AM, El-Desouky AI, Mahmoud MH (2012) Effect of Addition Some Hydrocolloids and Sweeteners on Flow Behavior and Sensory
Properties of Papaya-Apricot Nectar Blends. J Food Process Technol 3:170. doi:10.4172/2157-7110.1000170
Page 7 of 7
Results presented in Table (4) showed the variation in viscosity
with temperature described by an Arrhenius-type. he activation
energy of nectar samples ranged between 5.13 to 16.48 kJ/mol. he
activation energy increased with addition hydrocolloids and decreased
with addition sweeteners. he same trend was observed for η∞ factors
were increasing with increasing total solids and increased with addition
hydrocolloids while decreased with addition sweeteners. From the
obtained results it can be concluded that the hydrocolloids were the
most efective to improve the viscosity of nectar samples.
he efective and best increased of the viscosity was done by
addition guar gum.
Conclusions
From the obtained data, thickened nectars showed a shear-thinning
behavior, and their viscosity increased with adding thickeners with
sugar, rheology models are recommended that adequately described
the stress-rate relationships for the thickened luids. he parameters of
the models can be used to estimate the viscosity of fruits nectar.
References
1. Liebman B (1992). Fresh fruit: A papaya a day? Nutrition Action Healthletter
10-11.
2. USDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference (2008).
3. Lim YY, Lim TT, Tee JJ, (2007) Antioxidant properties of several tropical fruits:
A comparative study. Food Chem 103: 1003-1008.
4. Argaiz A, Lopez-Malo A (1995) Kinetics of irst change on lavour, cooked
lavour development and pectinesterase inactivation on mango and papaya
nectars and purees. Revista Espanola de Ciencia y Tecnologia de Alimentos
35: 92-100.
5. Tiwari RB (2000) Studies on blending of guava and papaya pulp for RTS
beverage. Indian Food Packer 54: 68–72.
6. Koksoy A, Kilic M (2004) Use of hydrocolloids in textural stabilization of a
yoghurt drink, ayran. Food Hydrocoll 18: 593-600.
7. Paraskevopoulou A, Boskou D, Kiosseoglou V (2005). Stabilization of olive oil–
lemon juice emulsion polysaccharides. Food Chem 90: 627-634.
8. Dondain G, Phillips GO (1999) The regulatory journey of gum arabic. Foods
Food Ingredients J Jpn 179: 38-56.
9. FDA (1974) Proposed afirmation of GRAS status for gum arabic. Federal
Register 39: 34203–34208.
10. Islam AM, Phillips GO, Sljivo A, Snowden MJ, Willians PA (1997) A review
of recent developments on the regulatory, structural and functional aspects of
gum arabic. Food Hydrocoll 11: 493-505.
11. Mothe CG, Rao MA, (1999) Rheological behavior of aqueous dispersions
of cashew gum and gum arabic: effect of concentration and blending. Food
Hydrocoll 13: 501-506.
12. Garcia-Ochoa F, Santos VE, Casas JA, Gomez E (2000) Xanthan gum:
production, recovery, and properties. Biotechnol Adv 18: 549-579.
13. Dogan M, Kayacier A, Ic E (2007) Rheological characteristics of some food
hydrocolloids processed with gamma irradiation. Food Hydrocoll 21: 392-396.
19. Mizrahi S (1979) A review of the physicochemical approach to the analysis of
the structural viscosity of luid fruit products. J Texture Stud 10: 67-82.
20. Holdsworth SD (1993) Rheological models used for the prediction of the
low properties of food products: A literature review. Food and Bioproducts
Processing 71c: 139-179.
21. Guerrero SN, Alzamora SM (1998) Effects of pH, temperature and glucose
addition on low behaviour of fruit purees: II. Peach, papaya and mango purees.
J Food Eng 37: 77-101.
22. Sharoba AM, Bahlol HEM, El-Desouky AI (2007) Establishing a schedule to
determine the optimal thermal process time for some canned fruit product.
Annals of Agriculture Science, Moshtohor, 45: 125-145.
23. Tressler DK, Joslyn MA (1961) Fruit and vegetable juice processing technology.
AVI Publishing Company, INC, New York, U.S.A.
24. Brekke JE, Cavaletto CG, Nakayama TOM, Suehisa RH, (1976) Effects of
storage temperature and container lining on some quality attributes of papaya
nectar. J Agric Food Chem 24: 341-343.
25. Onweluzo JC, Vijayalakshmi MR, Vijayanand P, Eipeson WE, (1999) Detarium
microcarpum polysaccharide as a stabilizer in processed fruit products.
Lebenson Wiss Technol 32: 521- 526.
26. El-Mansy HA, Bahlol HEM, Mahmoud MHM, Sharoba AMA (2000) Rheological
properties of juice and concentrates of some tomato varieties. Annals of
Agriculture Science, Moshtohor 38: 1521-1538.
27. El-Mansy HA, Bahlol HEM, Mahmoud MHM, Sharoba AMA, (2000)
Comparative study on chemical and rheological properties of orange juice and
its concentrates. Annals of Agriculture Science, Moshtohor 38: 1557-1574.
28. Gomez KA, Gomez AA (1984) Statistical procedures for agricultural research,
2nd edition. John Wiliy and Sons , Inc. USA.
29. Saulo AA (2005) Sugars and sweeteners in foods. Food Safety and Technology
FST-16: 1-7.
30. Askar A, EL-Zoghbi M (1991) Relative sweetness and synergism of fructose or
xylotol with aspartame or acesulfame-k. Fluessiges Obst 58: 298-300.
31. Matysiak NL, Noble AC (1991) Comparison of temporal perception of fruitiness
in model systems sweetened with aspartame, an aspartame+acesulfame-K
blend, or sucrose. J Food Sci 56: 823-826.
32. Pastor MV, Costell E, Duran L (1996) Effects of hydrocolloids and aspartame
on sensory viscosity and sweetness of low calorie peach nectars. J Texture
Stud 27: 61-79.
33. Nindo CI, Tang J, Powers JR, Takhar PS (2007) Rheological properties of
blueberry puree for processing applications. LWT 40: 292-299 .
34. Rao MA (1999). Rheology of luids and semi-solid foods. Gaithersburg: Aspen
publishers.
35. Steffe J F (1996) Rheological methods in food process engineering. East
Lansing, MI: East Freeman Press, USA.
36. Ditchiield C, Tadini CC, Singh R, Toledo RT (2004) Rheological properties of
banana puree at high temperatures. International Journal of Food Properties
7: 571-584.
37. Marcotte M, Hoshahili ART, Ramaswamy HS (2001) Rheological properties of
selected hydrocolloids as a function of concentration and temperature. Food
Res Int 34: 695-703.
14. Miyazawa T, Funazukuri T (2006) Noncatalytic hydrolysis of guar gum under
hydrothermal conditions. Carbohydr Res 341: 870-877.
38. Juszczak L, Witczak M, Fortuna T, Banachowicz A (2004) Effect of some
hydrocolloids on the rheological properties of rye starch. Food Sci Technol Int
10: 125-131.
15. Koyama E, Kitazawa K, Ohori Y, Izawa O, Kakegawa K, et al. (2003) In vitro
metabolism of the glycosidic sweeteners, stevia mixture and enzymatically
modiied stevia in human intestinal microlora. Food Chem Toxicol 41: 359-374.
39. Bhattacharya S (1999) Yield stress and time-dependent rheological properties
of mango pulp. J Food Sci 64: 1029-1033.
16. Butchko HH, Stargely WW (2001) Aspartame: Scientiic evaluation in the post
marketing period. Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology 34: 221–233.
17. King BM, Arents P, Duineveld CAA (2003) A comparison of aspartame and
sucrose with respect to carryover effects in yogurt. Food Qual Prefer 14: 75-81.
18. Mirhosseini H, Tan CP, Hamid NSA, Yusof S (2008). Effect of Arabic gum,
xanthan gum and orange oil on lavor release from diluted orange beverage
emulsion. Food Chem 107: 1161-1172.
J Food Process Technol
ISSN:2157-7110 JFPT, an open access journal
40. Singh NI, Eipeson WE (2000) Rheological behavior of clariied mango juice
concentrates. J Texture Stud 31: 287-295.
41. Nindo CI, Tang J, Powers JR, Singh P (2005) Viscosity of blueberry and
raspberry juices for processing applications. J Food Eng 69: 343-350 .
42. Ahmed J, Ramaswamy HS, Hiremath N (2005) The effect of high pressure
treatment on rheological characteristics and colour of mango pulp .Int J Food
Sci Technol 40: 885-895.
Volume 3 • Issue 8 • 1000170