Cantwell-Ransley technique in complete epispadias repair
Khaled A. Ismail, MD; Mohamed H. Mazhar Ashour, MD;
Akram El Batarny, MD; Mohamed Hashish, MD
Pediatric Surgery Unit-Department of General Surgery-Tanta University.
Background/Purpose: Epispadias is a rare congenital anomaly of the external genitalia
occurring in approximately one in 118 000 males and one in 400 000 females. The purpose
of this study is to evaluate the results of Cantwell-Ransley operation in the repair of complete
epispadias.
Patients & methods: Between June 2006 and June 2012, 11 patients with complete
epispadias were treated with the Cantwell-Ransley technique at the Pediatric Surgery UnitTanta University Hospital. Patients were followed up for 3 months to report any complication.
Results: 11 male cases with epispadias were admitted to the Pediatric Surgery Unit-Tanta
University Hospital in the period from June 2006 to June 2012 with history of bladder exstrophy
repair 1-2 years earlier. All cases were peno-pubic. Their age ranged from 1 7/12 years to 3
years, with a mean of 2 3/12 years. Cantwell-Ransley operation was performed to all patients
with satisfactory results. Only one case showed mild wound infection that was conservatively
managed. Another case developed urethro cutaneous fistula, which was surgically treated by
simple excision & closure after 6 months of epispadias repair.
Conclusion: The cosmetic and functional outcomes of Cantwell-Ransley epispadias repair
appear to be excellent.
Key words: Epispadias, Cantwell-Ransley operation.
Introduction:
Epispadias is a rare congenital anomaly
of the external genitalia occurring in
approximately one in 118 000 males and one
in 400 000 females.1 The defect however
is also seen in association with classic
bladder exstrophy (the exstrophy-epispadias
complex) with an incidence of approximately
one in 40 000.2 The first documented report
of epispadias dates back to AD 610-641 and
Byzantine Emperor Heraclius.1 According to
meatal position certain degrees of severity
have been described, including balanic
epispadias (the less severe and less common
grade), penile or continent epispadias (some
degree of incontinence is often present) and
peno-pubic or incontinent epispadias. In
the latter category the whole urethral plate
is widely open as well as the bladder neck,
the external sphincter is deficient, the pubic
bones are separated to various degrees, and
Ain-Shams J Surg 2014; 7(2): 393-400
the penis is short and connected to the pubis.3
In 1895, Cantwell introduced the true
urethroplasty for reconstruction of male
epispadias. He created a tube from the urethral
plate, freed it completely to its proximal base
and then transplanted it below the corpora
cavernosa. The technique was modified in
1903 by Bullitt who, after losing most of the
urethral plate, inadvertently discovered that
the preputial skin could be used for the terminal
segment. For most of the last 50 years the most
popular technique used for epispadias repair
has been the Young modification of Cantwell
technique.3 Gross and Cresson mobilized
the urethral plate from both corpora but with
a narrow attachment to the ventral penile
skin for blood supply. McIndow converted
epispadias to hypospadias by tabularizing
the urethral plate and transposing it ventrally
beneath the corpora. In 1963, Michalowski
and Modelski recommended a multi-stage
393
epispadias repair. Since then, urethral repairs
using preputial graft or bladder mucosa
graft have been described.4-9 The wide
variety of techniques reflects the generally
unsatisfactory cosmetic and functional
results from penile reconstruction. In 1989,
Ransley et al3 reported a modification of the
earlier Cantwell repair. Since then, due to
the excellent cosmetic and functional results
achieved with this technique, the CantwellRansley epispadias repair has been widely
adopted.3
Patients and methods:
Between June 2006 and June 2012, 11
patients with complete epispadias were
treated with the Cantwell-Ransley technique
at the Pediatric Surgery Unit -Tanta University
Hospital.
All cases were subjected to:
• Complete history taking.
• Thorough clinical examination.
• Complete urine analysis before
operation, to detect and manage any urinary
tract infection before surgery.
• Operative repair by using the
Cantwell-Ransley technique.
Pre operative preparation often included
treatment with testosterone to improve
the vascularity of the preputial and penile
skin and to increase the size of the penis.
Patients received 3 intra muscular injections
of 2 mg/kg testosterone at monthly intervals
preoperatively. Also topical testosterone
cream 5% was applied to the urethral plate.
With the patient lying supine, artificial
erection was performed by saline injection
at both corpora cavernosa to detect presence
of chordee and mark its site and extent. A
traction suture was placed through the ventral
aspect of the glans penis, and then a wide strip
of urethral mucosa extending for the prostatic
urethral meatus to the tip of the glans was
outlined and incised on the dorsum. Thick
glandular flaps were constructed bilaterally.
The ventral skin was taken down to the level
of the scrotum. Care was taken to preserve the
vascularity of the urethral plate, which arised
proximally and extended upward between
the corpora as a blood supply to the urethral
394
plate. The corpora were dissected ventrally
on the surface of Buck fascia. The plane was
followed closely bilaterally to the dorsum of
the penis between the corpus spongiosum and
the corporal body. The suspensory ligament
was divided in some cases with small sized
penis. The urethral plate was dissected just
on the corporal bodies to the level of the
prostate and the glans, respectively. Care was
taken to leave the most distal one centimeter
attachment of the mucosal plate to the glans
intact. The urethral strip was tabularized over
an 8 French silicon stent, and a tube was
fashioned by continuous 5/0 PDS sutures.
Afterward, the corporal bodies were closed
over the neo urethra. The now ventrally
placed urethra was secured in place between
the corpora. The glanular wings were closed
and the ventral skin sutured to the ventral
edge of the corona, while the flaps provided
coverage of the dorsum.
A silicon stent was secured and a plastic
occlusive dressing applied.
Patients were followed up for 3 months to
report any complication.
Results:
Our study included 11 cases with
epispadias, admitted to the Pediatric Surgery
Unit-Tanta University Hospital in the period
from June 2006 to June 2012. All cases were
males, with history of bladder exstrophy
repair 1-2 years earlier. All cases were penopubic type. Their age ranged from 1 7/12
years to 3 years, with a mean of 2 3/12 years.
2 cases had a history of associated bilateral
congenital inguinal hernias, which were
repaired in the same session after bladder
closure.
Testosterone was given in a dose of 2 mg/
Kg, in 3 monthly doses before operation, in
addition to topical 5% ointment applied to the
urethral plate.
Cantwell-Ransley
operation
was
performed to all patients as previously
mentioned. Artificial erection by saline
injection in both corpora was performed
in the beginning of the procedure to detect
presence or absence of dorsal chordee, which
was seen in 3 cases. The site and extent was
Ain-Shams J Surg 2014; 7(2): 393-400
Figure (1): Peno-pubic epispadias after
repair of bladder exstrophy.
Figure (2): Ventral prepuce.
Figure (3): Traction sutures applied to Glans.
Figure (4): Marking the urethral flap.
Figure (5): Degloving of Penile Skin.
Figure (6): Dissection of corpora cavernosa.
determined. Fibrous tissue in the corpora
responsible for chordee was excised, and
artificial erection was performed again to
deal with any residual chordee present.
Complete disassembly of suspensory
ligament of the penis was resorted to only 5
cases, while the remaining cases underwent
disassembly of both corpora without the
suspensory ligament.
The urethral plate was dissected till its
Ain-Shams J Surg 2014; 7(2): 393-400
395
Figure (7): Both corpora dissected and
disassembled.
Figure (8): Disassembled 3 components.
Figure (9): Neo urethra completed using
continuous 5/0 PDS sutures.
Figure (10): Suturing both corpora over neo
urethra.
Figure (11): At the end of the operation.
396
Ain-Shams J Surg 2014; 7(2): 393-400
distal end at the glans, and a tube was created
over an 8 French silicon catheter using 5/0
continuous PDS sutures. The corpora were
sutured together using interrupted sutures
over the ventrally placed neo urethra with
internal rotation to prevent occurrence of
dorsal chordee.
At the end of operation, a plastic occlusive
dressing was applied with urethral catheter
kept in place for 7-10 days.
All cases were given IV intra and post
operative broad spectrum antibiotics.
As regards post operative complications,
only one case showed mild wound infection
that was conservatively managed. Another
case developed urethro cutaneous fistula,
which was surgically treated by simple
excision & closure 6 months later.
Satisfactory reconstruction was obtained
in all cases where the penis was achieved
with a conical glans, apicoventral meatus,
with downward direction on standing.
The mothers of young patients reported
straight erections post operatively.
The results of continence could not be
evaluated as all cases were too young for
such evaluation.
Discussion:
Epispadias is a rare condition and most
commonly described as a part of the bladder
exstrophy complex.10 This study included 11
cases with epispadias associated with bladder
exstrophy in 6 years period. Lottmann
et al3 reported 40 cases in 8 years, while
Kajbafzadeh et al4 reported 180 cases in
15 years, of them, 75 cases underwent the
Cantwell-Ransley operation. Ashraf Hafez
et al11 performed 14 post pubertal epispadias
cases in 7 years. Their ages ranged from 14
to 34 years.
All our cases had previous first stage
bladder exstrophy closure, followed by
epispadias repair 1-2 years later. The age
incidence of our cases ranged from 1 7/12
years to 3 years, with a mean of 2 3/12 years.
All were males.
Two cases had a history of associated
bilateral congenital inguinal hernias that
were repaired in the first stage with closure of
Ain-Shams J Surg 2014; 7(2): 393-400
bladder exstrophy.
All cases were peno pubic type, with
evident dorsal chordee in 3 cases (27.2%).
Hammouda12 reported 42 male cases with
epispadias in 4 years period. Of them, 29 cases
had complete epispadias as a component of
bladder exstrophy.
As a rule, all our cases received 3 IM
injections of testosterone at monthly intervals
before operation, in addition to topical
application of testosterone 5% ointment. This
was performed to facilitate penile growth and
improving vascularity. Jacob Ben-Cham et
al13 & Gearhart & Jeffs14 recommended pre
operative administration of testosterone for
the same reason.
Lottmann et al3 recommended pre operative
testosterone administration to increase penile
size and blood supply, and hence facilitates
its reconstruction. Gearhart15 suggested that
testosterone application helps to enhance
the penile skin, increase vascularity of the
urethral plate and soften any area of scarring,
which may decrease the incidence of post
operative skin and urethral necrosis.15
As previously described, all our cases were
subjected to the Cantwell-Ransley procedure.
Baird et al1 performed the same technique
to 129 boys, of which 97 had classic bladder
exstrophy and 32 had primary complete
epispadias.
Artificial erection was performed to all our
cases before proceeding to penile disassembly.
Saline injection into both corpora separately
was performed to detect chordee and assess
its direction and extent. We found 3 cases
with dorsal chordee that was corrected by
excising all fibrous tissue over the corpora
that was responsible for angulations.
The neo urethra reached the glans’ tip in
a normal position without shortening as the
distal part of the urethral plate was kept intact.
The end result was an apicoventral meatus in
a conical glans.
The catheter was kept for 7-10 days then
removed. The end result was satisfactory.
Mild
post
operative
edema
&
inflammation of the skin was seen in one
case, which was conservatively treated and
completely resolved. Another case developed
397
urethra-cutaneous fistula that was surgically
treated by simple excision and closure
6 months later. No urethral stenosis or
recurrence was seen among our cases.
Baird et al1 in their large series using the
Cantwell-Ransley technique stated that any
chosen surgical technique to reconstruct peno
pubic epispadias must address four factors:
Correction of dorsal chordee, Urethral
reconstruction, Glanular reconstruction and
Closure of penile skin. They had 25 cases
having post operative fistula representing
19.3%, reduced to 15.5% after 3 months.
Kajbafzadeh et al4 who worked on 180
boys with epispadias performed their new
technique in 75 cases. The results were
much better than in any of the remaining
cases who underwent other techniques. 84%
were regarded as very satisfactory, and a
poor outcome requiring minor skin revision,
fistula excision or urethral dilatation occurred
in only 16%. Fistula occurred in only 4%
and urethral stricture occurred in 5.3%. They
had no case of urethral ballooning or skin
dehiscence.
Baird et al1 found that this technique is
reliable, and a review of published studies
has not demonstrated loss of glans or corporal
tissue as reported in other repairs. Surer et al16
showed an initial postoperative fistula rate of
23% reducing to 19% at 3 months.
Ransley et al17, Surer et al16 and Mollard
et al18 stated that the cosmetic and functional
outcomes of Cantwell-Ransley epispadias
repair appear to be excellent.
Conclusion
Any chosen surgical technique to
reconstruct peno pubic epispadias must
address four factors: Correction of dorsal
chordee, urethral reconstruction, glanular
reconstruction and closure of penile skin.
The cosmetic and functional outcomes of
Cantwell-Ransley epispadias repair appear to
be excellent.
Reference
1- Baird AD, Gearhart JP, Mathews RI:
Applications of the modified CantwellRansley epispadias repair in the exstrophyepispadias complex. Journal of Pediatric
398
Urology 2005; 1: 331–336.
2- Lancaster PAL: Epidemiology of bladder
exstrophy: A communication from the
international clearinghouse for birth defects
monitoring systems. Teratology 1987; 36:
221.
3- Lottmann HB, Yaqouti M, Melin Y: Male
Epispadias Repair: Surgical and functional
results with the Cantwell-Ransley procedure
in 40 patients. The Journal of Urology 1999;
162: 1176–1180.
4- Kajbafzadeh AM, Duffy PG, Ransley PG:
The revolution of penile reconstruction in
epispadias repair: A report of 180 cases. The
Journal of Urology 1995; 154: 858–861.
5- Jr Duckett JW: Epispadias. Urol Clin N Amer
1978; 5: 107.
6- De Sy WA, Oosterlinck W: One-stage
hypospadias repair by free full-thickness
skin graft and island flap techniques. Urol
Clin N Amer 1981; 8: 491.
7- Vyas PR, Roth DR, Perlmutter AD:
Experience with free grafts in urethral
reconstruction. J Urol 1987; 137: 471.
8- Ransley PG, Duffy PG, Oesch IL, Hoover D:
Autologous bladder mucosa graft for urethral
substitution. Brit J Urol 1987; 58: 331.
9- Hendren WH, Crooks KK: Tubed free skin
graft for construction of male urethra. J Urol
1980; 123: 858.
10- Dominic Frimberger: Diagnosis and
management of epispadias. Seminars in
Pediatric Surgery, 2011; 20: 85–90.
11- Hafez AT, Helmy T: Complete penile
disassembly for epispadias repair in post
pubertal patients. Urology, 2011; 78 (6):
1407–1410.
12- Hammouda HM: Results of complete penile
disassembly for epispadias repair in 42
patients. The Journal of Urology, 2003; 170:
1963–1965.
13- Ben-Chaim J, Peppas DS, Jeffs RD, Gearhart
JP: Complete male epispadias: Genital
reconstruction and achieving continence. The
Journal of Urology, 1995; 153: 1665–1667.
14- Gearhart JP, Jeffs RD: The use of parenteral
testosterone therapy in genital reconstructive
surgery. J Urol 1987; 138(2): 1077.
15- Gearhart JP: Evolution of epispadias repair.
Timing, techniques and results. J Urol 1998;
160: 177.
16- Surer I, Baker LA, Jeffs RD, Gearhart JP:
The modified Cantwell-Ransley repair
for exstrophy and epispadias: 10-year
experience. J Urol 2000; 164: 1040–1042.
17- Ransley PG, Duffy PG, Wollin M: Bladder
Ain-Shams J Surg 2014; 7(2): 393-400
exstrophy and epispadias. In: Spitz L, Nixon
HH, editors. Pediatric Surgery. London:
Butterworths; 1988: 620–632.
Ain-Shams J Surg 2014; 7(2): 393-400
18- Mollard P, Bassett T, Mure PY: Male
epispadias: Experience with 45 cases. J Urol
1998; 160: 55–59.
399