Aggarwal et al. Sri Lankan Journal of Anaesthesiology: 29(2): 137-140 (2021)
A Rare Case of Ball Valve Effect of Vocal Cord Papillomas in a Child:
An Anaesthetic Challenge
Reema Aggarwal1*, Gurpreet Singh2
1,2
MM institute of Medical Sciences and Research Center, Mullana, Ambala
Vocal cord papillomas are rare growths of viral etiology caused by human papillomavirus
(HPV). Large polyps are known to obstruct glottic opening and can cause acute airway
obstruction. We report a case of 4-year-old male child with progressive hoarseness of voice
and stridor posted for excision of vocal cord papillomas. Paediatric age of the patient and the
position of the growth obstructing the glottic opening at vocal cords provided an extremely
challenging environment for induction of anaesthesia.
Keywords: vocal cord papilloma, hoarseness, spontaneous ventilation, anaesthesia
Background
Vocal cord papillomas are small wart-like
growths caused by the Human Papilloma Virus
(HPV).1 The disease is also known as recurrent
respiratory papillomatosis or RRP. These polyps
are known to recur and may require repetitive
surgery. The patients are often misdiagnosed as
asthma and croup. These growths may involve a
part or whole of vocal cords. In paediatric patients
with an already narrow glottis, the initial
symptoms may be mild i.e. weak cry, inability to
phonate properly, benign cough and sore throat.
These symptoms however progress over short a
time to difficulty in breathing, stridor, total loss
of voice, difficulty in lying down and acute air
hunger. Treatment of papillomas requires
surgical removal with laser therapy or with
scalpel knife during micro laryngoscopy. We
*Correspondence: Reema Aggarwal
E mail: docreema123@gmail.com
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1082-7901
Received: 05/07/2021
Accepted: 26/09/2021
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4038/slja.v29i2i.8885
report a rare case of paediatric vocal cord
papilloma causing near complete obstruction of
vocal cords. In our case, surgeons performed the
surgery with Microdebrider using the micro
laryngoscope.
Case report
A 4-year-old male child weighing 15 kg
presented to the paediatric clinic with hoarseness
of voice for 2 months, which had worsened
gradually over the last one month to aphonia and
continuous cough. Progressive difficulty with
noisy breathing was noted by the parents in the
preceding week with low grade fever over the last
3 to 4 days. Child was initially managed with
antibiotics and nebulization considering it to be a
laryngitis or upper respiratory infection.
However, in the absence of response to treatment
given, the ENT opinion was sought. Indirect
laryngoscopy was performed by an otorhinologist
and noted multiple papillomas on both vocal
cords obstructing the laryngeal inlet. The surgical
team could not completely visualize and
comment on the extent of involvement of glottis.
However, they could convey that the posterior
part of the cords appeared free from growth and a
smaller size tube could possibly be
Aggarwal et al. Sri Lankan Journal of Anaesthesiology: 29(2): 137-140 (2021)
accommodated. Physical examination revealed
pulse rate of 120/min, respiratory rate of 30/min,
irregular and noisy breathing with chest
retractions suggestive of labored breathing.
Saturation on room air was 95%. All routine lab
investigations were within normal limits.
Echocardiography was done and was reported
normal. Procedure was explained to parents and
informed consent was taken. Considering the
potential loss of patent airway during induction of
anaesthesia, consent for emergency tracheostomy
was also obtained from the parents. It was
decided to secure airway with graded sevoflurane
inhalation while maintaining patient on
spontaneous respiration. Preoperative sedative
medications were not given. Smaller size
endotracheal tubes, tracheostomy tube, and
resuscitation cart were checked and kept ready.
Pre-induction, all standard monitors were
attached, baseline parameters recorded and noted.
Intravenous atropine 10 µg/kg was given. Patient
was induced with 100 % oxygen and sevoflurane,
concentration progressively increased from 26%. On achieving deeper plane of anaesthesia,
patient was noted to have increased chest
retractions possibly due to ball valve
phenomenon. No breath sounds heard on
auscultation of chest with loss of end tidal CO2
tracing (ETCO2) suggestive of total obstruction
of airway. Intubation was attempted using CMAC video laryngoscope D-Blade no 2. A mass
could be visualized obstructing the airway almost
completely. However, a tiny gap was visible in
the posterior part of the vocal cords, size 4 ID,
uncuffed endotracheal tube was negotiated across
and ventilation confirmed by auscultation and
return of ETCO2 tracing (Figure 1). Anaesthesia
was maintained on oxygen, nitrous oxide,
sevoflurane and intravenous atracurium and
fentanyl 30µg. Hydrocortisone 30mg was also
given intravenously.
After the excision of papillomas, the anterior
commissure and the anterior part of vocal cords
ETT
Figure 1. Laryngeal view, immediately after
intubation showing multiple vocal cord
papillomas obstructing the laryngeal inlet; vocal
cords, not clearly visible. ETT: Endotrachel tube
Figure 2. laryngeal view, after excision of vocal
cord papillomas showing wider opening
between the vocal cords.
could be visualized, and an adequate glottis
clearance was achieved (Figure 2).
Following the excision of papillomas, significant
air leak was present around the ETT and therefore
we changed the tube to a larger size
intraoperatively. Thorough suctioning of oral
cavity and ETT was done, reversed and extubated
awake in the lateral position to avoid aspiration.
The child was shifted to post anaesthesia care unit
for monitoring. Postoperatively, saturation was
maintained around 98% on room air with no
Aggarwal et al. Sri Lankan Journal of Anaesthesiology: 29(2): 137-140 (2021)
respiratory distress and the child was discharged
on 6th postoperative day.
Discussion
Papillomas can develop anywhere along the
respiratory tract, but most common sites are
larynx and vocal cords.3 Less often it can affect
oral cavity, trachea and bronchi. Most common
presentation of vocal cord papillomas is
hoarseness of voice, which can progress to lifethreatening airway obstruction. Some patients
may develop dysphonia or aphonia. Paediatric
patients may have a weak cry, episodes of
choking and failure to gain weight. Additionally,
they can have chronic cough, dysphagia and
sensation of foreign body in the throat.
Papillomas may recur after removal and then
called as recurrent respiratory Papillomatosis
(RRP).4,5 The disease is categorized into two,
juvenile-onset form and adult-onset form.
Treatment is removal of papillomas either by
surgical excision using micro laryngoscope or
with the help of CO2 laser or pulsed dye lasers.
However, there is no definite cure as recurrence
is common.5,6 Preoperatively the child should be
evaluated for the degree of obstruction. Indirect
or flexible laryngoscopic examination should be
done by an experienced otorhinologist and, the
site of papillomas and the degree of obstruction
should be noted. Heart rate, respiratory rate and
oxygen saturation should be assessed
preoperatively. An echocardiogram should be
done preoperatively as these patients can have
pulmonary hypertension.2 Airway management
becomes challenging in paediatric patients as
airway is shared by both surgeons and
anesthesiologists. All the resuscitation equipment
and difficult airway cart must be kept ready
before taking the patient to operation table.1
Endotracheal intubation should be attempted, and
tracheostomy should be used only as a last resort
as the procedure may lead to spread of the disease
further into the respiratory tract.3 We planned
intubation while maintaining the spontaneous
ventilation with inhalational technique and
avoided the use of muscle relaxants. Sedatives
were avoided preoperatively considering the
potential for loss of airway. The muscle relaxants
were avoided until intubation was confirmed as
loss of muscle tone could have caused ball valve
phenomenon leading to total obstruction.3
Atropine was given before induction to decrease
the secretions. Smaller size tubes should be used
as the airway is narrowed, and to improve the
surgical access. In our case, there was loss of
airway after the induction of anaesthesia and
immediate intubation was done to secure the
airway and restore ventilation.7 Airway can be
compromised after the induction requiring
immediate intubation or emergency surgical
airway.8 Apnoeic ventilation and jet ventilation
are alternate strategies, but carry risks of hypoxia,
hypercarbia and barotrauma making intubation as
the safest option.9 Advantages of intubation
include better control over airway and ventilation
with protection from aspiration. Disadvantages
are inadequate surgical access and risk of spread
of disease. In rare occasions, papilloma can
occlude the lumen of ETT making ventilation
difficult. Smaller size tubes are helpful but
hampers the ventilation and concentration of
volatile agents delivered. We preferred intubation
over other methods as there was difficulty in
mask ventilation due to complete obstruction of
airway possibly due to prolapsed papillomas.
Conclusions
Management of vocal cord papilloma is
challenging in the paediatric population and
anaesthesiologist should be aware of the potential
to obstruct the already narrowed paediatric
airway following induction of anaesthesia.
Avoiding sedative premedication, maintaining
spontaneous ventilation, strict monitoring,
vigilance and timely decision making are
essential prerequisites for managing airway and
ventilation safely in the perioperative period.
References
1. Andrus JG, Shapshay SM. Contemporary
management of laryngeal papilloma in adults and
children. Otolaryngol Clin North Am. 2006;
39:135–58.
Aggarwal et al. Sri Lankan Journal of Anaesthesiology: 29(2): 137-140 (2021)
2. Bo L, Wang B, Shu SY. Anesthesia
management in pediatric patients with
laryngeal
papillomatosis
undergoing
suspension laryngoscope surgery and a review
of
the
literature. Int
J
Pediatric
Otorhinolaryngology. 2011; 75:1442–5.
3. Harsh ad PL, Pujari V, Channappa NM
Anandaswamy TC. Anesthesia management in
a child with laryngeal papilloma causing near
complete airway obstruction. Saudi J Anaesth
2015; 9:86- 8.
4. Li SQ, Chen JL, Fu HB, Xu J, Chen LH.
Airway management in pediatric patients
undergoing suspension laryngoscope surgery
for severe laryngeal obstruction caused by
papillomatosis. Pediatric Anaesth 2010;
20:1084-91.
5. Pasquale K, Wiatrak B, Woolley A, Lewis L.
Microdebrider versus CO2 laser removal of
recurrent respiratory papillomatosis: a
6.
7.
8.
9.
prospective analysis. Laryngoscope 2003; 113:
139-143.
Ubale P, Mhamane R, Raju S, Pallavi G,
Sharma P. Anaesthetic Management of a child
with Laryngeal Papilloma’s. Enliven: J
Anesthesiology Crit Care Med 2(7):019.
Cohen SR, Geller KA, Seltzer S, Thompson
JW. Papilloma of the larynx and
tracheobronchial tree in children. A
retrospective study. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol
1980; 89:497-503.
Theroux MC, Grodecki V, Reilly JS, Kettrick
RG. Juvenile laryngeal papillomatosis: Scary
anaesthetic! Pediatric Anaesth. 1998; 8:35761.
Miyawaki J, Shono S, Katori K, Sakuragi T,
Higa K. Subglottic jet ventilation for pediatric
microlaryngosurgery: A case report. J Clin
Anesth. 2003; 15:363-5.