Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                
Focus on German Studies 21 cultural production and German mainstream Germany and the Black Diaspora: consumption/reception and seems to be a missed Points of Contact, 1250–1914 opportunity. Instead, Göttsche maintains in his conclusion that: “the ‘postcolonial project,’ as By Mischa Honeck, Martin Bhabha puts it in The Location of Culture, of critically Klimke, and Anne Kuhlmann rereading and rewriting colonialism (has been left) Kevina King almost exclusively to white ‘mainstream’ authors University of Massachusetts, Amherst from Germany, Austria, and Switzerland” (424). While this claim may be an accurate statement in reference to historical novels, Göttsche fails to acknowledge that cultural producers of Color in Germany are contributing to the “postcolonial project” elsewhere, most often in spheres outside of this genre (as it may not be the best-equipped for conveying the polyphony of these (hi)stories and their necessary critiques), such as in academic or theoretical essays, in lyrical poetry, in theater, in spoken-word performances, musical productions, and historical exhibitions or, as is most discernible, via activist protests in the public sphere that call for a critical engagement with German cultural memory as it is tied to colonialism. Although much more analysis needs to be undertaken in this broader domain, Göttsche’s book — the first of its kind to tackle colonialism and memory politics in historical novels — is a very inviting point of departure from which future investigations of this sort can and should commence, and indeed already have. A ccording to the editors of Germany and the Black Diaspora the “historiographical negligence” in regards to Blacks in Germany before the nineteenth and twentieth century is due to Germany’s “political and academic establishment and mainstream histories in which black voices are either subdued or reduced to freak occurrences” (4). This historiographical and national amnesia was first challenged by Black Germans themselves in 1986 who drew great attention to their presence in Germany, German history and contemporary affairs with the publishing of Farbe bekennen: Afrodeutsche Frauen auf den Spuren ihrer Geschichte later published in 1992 as Showing Our Colors: Afro-German Women Speak Out. While the editors acknowledge this important work, which was of paramount significance in directing attention to the role that race played in Germany’s past, they also draw on various other scholarly works about Black Germans and understand their volume as a historiographical expansion of these studies. Peter Martin’s ground- Göttsche, Dirk. Remembering Africa: The Rediscovery of Colonialism in Contemporary German Literature. Rochester, NY: Camden House, 2013. breaking work Schwarze Teufel, edle Mohren: Afrikaner in Geschichte und Bewusstsein der Deutschen and HansWerner Debrunner’s Presence and Prestige, Africans in Europe: A History of Africans in Europe Before 1918 are of particular importance for this study, since they along with Farbe bekennen insisted that Blackness Book Reviews 106 Focus on German Studies 21 be recognized in Germany from the Middle Ages Other contributors, like Anne Kuhlmann and onward. Like those works, Germany and the Black Rashid S. Pegah, base their research on the vast Diaspora not only contributes to the field of Black and still expanding field of court history. Their German studies and enriches German history and contributions illuminate the various roles Blacks historiography, but it also advances a broader played in noble courts and principalities in the notion of the Black Diaspora. Much like Tina seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. By drawing Campt’s work Other Germans: Black Germans and the on journal entries, church, court, and military Politics of Race, Gender, and Memory in the Third Reich records, Maria Diedrich, on the other hand, and Fatima El-Tayeb’s European Others: Queering investigates the individual life stories of former Ethnicity in Postnational Europe, the editors locate Black American slaves and their families and how Germany’s positioning as central to the Black they arrived in Hesse between 1782 and 1783 in Diaspora instead of regarding it as marginal. the wake of the American Revolution. The This historical anthology aims to delineate the approach that Mischa Honeck, Kendahl Radcliffe, myriad encounters between white and Black people and Robbie Aitken take in their respective across the centuries, mainly in Germany, but some nineteenth contributors also direct their focus on the German contributions to this collection highlights the reception of Black Americans. As such Germany transatlantic and the Black Diaspora challenges the far too Europeans and antebellum Americans (white and widespread assumption about Germany’s historical Black) and their travel to Germany and Africa, and relationship with Black people, namely, that since reciprocally investigate African travel to Europe Germany colonization, and German lands. Crucial sources here are Germany’s history rarely intersected with that of newspaper, conference, and travel reports, as well Black history or itself can be viewed as a part of that as government documentation and personal letters. very history. The vast chronological span of this Germany and the Black Diaspora adds to our was a latecomer to and twentieth entanglements century-focused between white study necessitates the transnational, trans-epochal, growing interdisciplinary, and transcultural approach the experience. While specialists in the Black German editors and contributors take. This methodology is field will not find this volume tremendously not only reflected in the various contributions to groundbreaking, it should be on the reading list of this book, but is also illuminated by the sources the anyone interested in (Black) German history and contributors draw upon to shape their arguments. (Black) diaspora studies, since this anthology offers Some contributors like Paul Kaplan and Kate Lowe base their research on the cultural transfer of knowledge of the Black German the English reader a valuable first glimpse into the interlacement of both. Black images in art history via paintings and altar pieces and juxtapose the real presence of Blacks in German lands during the Middle Ages to the fictitious notion, i.e. the construction, of Blackness. Honeck, Mischa, Martin Klimke, and Anne Kuhlmann. Germany and the Black Diaspora: Points of Contact, 1250-1914. New York: Berghahn, 2013. Book Reviews 107