Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                
㬾ⴺ㬻ⴢ# ㊂㬻ⵖዂ2& ⛾⭳ⴺ㬻ⴢ# ዞ㬻ⵚᇢE0 ᙺ✂⚞.ᇷᦻ# 㭊❮⬦# 㬾ⴺⲲ/ & , , & . & & & & & & & & & & & & . & & (徇腋搢) & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 嘁烐) , & , & & & & & & & & & & & & & , & & & & , & & & & & &‘ ’ & & (鑨鑂) & & & & & & & , & & (辅徴) & & . & & , & & & & . & & & & & & & & , & & & & & , & (劇 & & & & , & . QG 㩧㑮㧒㧦G YWW_UXXUZWSG 㕂㌂㢚⬢㧒㧦G YWW_UXYU`SG Ợ㨂䢫㩫㧒㧦G YWW_UXYUXWU Ꮳ# ⑫# ␇ 69 1. ᐒᢇⷣ# 㭖⍢㬻# (functional anatomy) & & & & & & & & & & & , & & , , , & (踓鏫) & & & & (functional anatomy) & & & & & . Manfred Pockert & & & & & , & (懣趑穿) & & & (prototype) & & & & 祫) & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & (躈篠) & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & , & & (辅 & & & & & & (systems of corres & & & & & (鱙湚蓸黏胶) (驫驸劏豇穿) & & (楯黏趻, holism) & & & & (determined) & & & & & & & & & & (inductive) & & & & & (怈) & , & , & pondence) & & & & & & & & & & & & & , & & .1) , . (function) , & , & & . & & & & & & & , , & (鑎徱) & & & & & & & & & & & & & , & & . & & & (銦捝藚蕌嬑) & & . & & & & (烠刳復) & & ,2) & & 駗) & & & & & ( , & & & & 3) G XPG w–Š’Œ™›OX`^]PUG G YPG 㡞⯒G ✺㠊SG ṚἚO笇篬P㠦⓪G ⑞O聺PSG 㫆ṧO裯第PSG ⁒㥷O紨PG ❇SG 㡺䟟㩗㦒⪲G ˄⳿ O職P˅㦮G 㧧㣿SG ἽG ˄⹲㌳˅G 㧧㣿G 㦚G 䞮⓪G ₆ὖὒG 㧻₆O蟹絎PG ❇㧊G ⺆㏣♮㠊G 㧞┺U 㢧⪣㢤⪋# ⿫㢤⪿ါ2& ⑧⣜⪣㢤⪋# ၇㢤⫃ཋE & & & & , & .4) & & & & & & & & 暒) & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & (闈趑) & & & & & & & & & & (趻) & & & & 5) & & & & & & & & & & (symptom) & & & (忍疬) & & & & & & (multiple realisation) & & 6: & (崑) , & & & & &‘ & (驫驸), , & & . & .6) , & (曩 & & & & & & & & ’ , & .7) & & & & & G ZPG ⳿O職P㦮G ㎇䟻㦚G Ṗ㰚G ṚἚ⓪G ⡦䞲SG 䏶O讀P㦮G ㎇䟻㦚G 㰖┢G ゚ἚO舤篬P㢖G 㡺䟟 㩗㦒⪲G ㌗㌳㌗⁏O芴苇芴級P㦮G ὖἚ⯒G 㧊⬾ἶG 㧞┺U G [PG 㩚ῃG 䞲㦮ὒ╖䞯G ㌳Ⰲ䞯ᾦ㔺OYWW_PUG ˈ㩲G \㧻G 䞲㦮㌳Ⰲ䞯㦮G ㌞⪲㤊G 㡆ῂUˉ⯒G 㺎㫆U G \PG 㧒⹮㩗㦒⪲G 㧊⯒G ₆⓻㭒㦮Oœ•Š›–•ˆ“š”P㧊⧒ἶG 䚲䡚䞲┺UG ₆⓻㭒㦮⓪G Ⱎ㦢 㦮G ⶒ㰞㩗G ⹪䌫㦚G 㧎㩫䞲┺⓪G 㩦㠦㍲G ⶒ㰞㭒㦮O— šŠˆ“š”P⯒G 㩚㩲⪲G 䞲┺UG ṗṗ㦮G 㧊⪶㠦G ➆⯎G 㕂Ⰲ㻶䞯O—“–š–— G –G ”•‹P㦮G Ṳ὚㩗㧎G ㍺ⳛ㠦G ╖䟊 ㍲⓪G wˆ—•ŒˆœG Œ›G ˆ“UOYWWWP⯒G 㺎㫆UG G ]PG 㩚ῃG 䞲㦮ὒ╖䞯G 㰚┾䞯ᾦ㔺OYWW_PSG ]TX\㴓UG G ^PG 㧊㦮G ╖䚲㩗㧎G 㡞ṖG ☯㟧㠦㍲G ⁒╖㩗G 㦮⹎㦮G 䟊⿖䞯㧊G ⹲㌳䞮㰖G 㞠㦖G 㧊㥶㠦G ╖䞲G 䟊㍳㧊┺UG 䞲㦮䞯㦖G 㧎㼊㦮G ₆⓻㦮G ㌗ὖ㎇㠦G 㰧㭧䞾㦒⪲㖾SG 㔲ṗ㩗Ošœˆ“P 㧊ἶSG ῂ㫆㭧㕂㩗㧎G 䟊⿖䞯㧊G 䞚㣪䞮㰖G 㞠㞮┺⓪G 㭒㧻㧊┺UG zŽŒšˆG rœ™ ˆ”ˆG OX```P⓪G ㍲㟧ⶎ䢪ṖG 㔲ṗ㠦G ⹪䌫䞮ἶG 㧞㦒ⳆSG ⁎⩂䞲G 㔲ṗG 㭧㕂 㦮G 㤦⮮㠦⓪G 䝢⧒䏺㩗㧎G 㧊㎇㭧㕂㦮G ㌂㥶ṖG 㫊㨂䞮ἶSG 㧊⩂䞲G ⓻☯㩗G 㭒㼊 OˆŠ›ŒG ˆŽŒ•Š PG 㢖㦮G 㡆ὖ㎇G ⌊㠦㍲G 㑮㦮G ⁒㥷O–“œ•›ˆ™ G ”œšŠ“ŒP㦮G ₆⪳ ὒG 䌦ῂ⯒G 㭧㩦㦒⪲G ㍲㟧䟊⿖䞯㧊G ⹲╂䞮ỢG ♮㠞┺ἶG 㭒㧻䞲┺UG 䞮㰖ⰢG ㍲㟧 ⶎ䢪ṖG 㔲ṗ㦚G 㭧㕂㦒⪲G ⹲╂♮㠞┺⓪G 㭒㧻㠦G ╖䟊㍲G 㧊ἂO蝝箟P㧊G 㫊㨂䞲┺UG 䞲䘎SG 䞲㦮䞯㠦G ╖䞲G ˄ὒ䞯㎇˅㦮G 㣪ῂ㠦G ╖䞲G ⹮⪶㦒⪲㍲SG 㧊㢖G 㥶㌂䞲G 㡃䞶 㦚G 䞮ỢG ♲G Ṳ⎦㦒⪲⓪G ˄ἓ䠮˅OŒŸ—Œ™Œ•ŠŒP㧊G 㧞┺UG ἓ䠮㧊G ⁒╖G 㭧ῃ㠦㍲SG 䞲㦮䞯㦚G 䔏㰫㰩⓪G 㭧㣪䞲G 㣪㏢⪲G ❇㧻䞮ỢG ♲G ㌂䣢SG 㩫䂮㩗G ⺆ἓ㦮G ⿚㍳㠦G ╖䟊㍲⓪G ošˆ•Ž“•OYWWYP㦚G 㺎㫆U Ꮳ# ⑫# ␇ 6; & & & (鐞枠) & (entitiy) & & & & & & & & & & , & & , 20 & . , & & & ’ & & . & & & & & (鑰棕ꋙ) & & & & & & & (朂紵) & (妩臕) & & & & & & & & & & & & (bracketting) & & (decenterized) & & & & & (篠趆) & & (鐕樽穿) , & & & (proto-scientific) & & & & & & . & & & (啬樽穿) & & .8) & & , , & & & , & & & (local belief system) & (踓鏫) (蔦) , , (啢) & & . , & & & & & & ’ & & & & & & & , & & , (attribute), & & & & & &‘ &‘ & (visual) & . & & & & & & & ’ & (踓鏫) & & (魗穿) & , (role) & & & & & & , & & (static) & & , (dynamic) & & & & . & ‘ & . & & , & & & & & & & & (plural) & & & & & . (魙) (楌柯穿) & & & & (salvational & , & &‘ scientism)9) & ’ & & & & & & & , , & & G _PG 㞚Ⰲ㓺䏶䎪⩞㓺㩗㧎G 㰞⬢OŠ–•›Œ•›P㢖G 䡫㌗O–™”P㦮G Ṳ⎦㧊G 㧊㠦G 䟊╏♶㰖⓪G ⳾⯊Ỷ㰖ⰢSG 㫊㨂㧦⯒G 㫊㨂㧦㦮G 䢲☯ὒG ῂ⿚䞮㰖G 㞠㦖G ☯㟧㻶䞯㩗㧎G ὖ㩦㠦 ㍲G ⽊ⳊSG 㧊⩂䞲G ⏒㦮⓪G ┺⿚䧞G ㍲㟧㻶䞯㩗㦒⪲G ゚䀆㰞G 㑮G 㧞┺U G `PG n––‹OX``WPUG ⡦䞲G h•‹™ŒžšOX``]P⓪G X`㎎₆G ⰦG 㭧ῃ㠦G ☚㹿䞲G ㍲ῂG ㍶ᾦ㌂ ✺㠦G 㦮䞲G ⺇⌊㧻G 㔲㑶㦮G ㌗㰫㎇㦚G 㰖㩗䞮₆☚G 䞲┺UG Ṳ㞞O筛蒈P㠦G 㧞㠊G ㍲㟧 㢧⪣㢤⪋# ⿫㢤⪿ါ2& ⑧⣜⪣㢤⪋# ၇㢤⫃ཋE (agency) & & & 10) & & & & & & & . , & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & (啣) & &‘ & & & & & & & & & & & & & & , & & & & (relativism) & 6< & & & & & & & & ’ & & . 2. ₚ, 㬺ᙺⵞᐮ# ᨺⵞᐮ? (Anthropological perspectives) & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ? & & & & & & & & & ? : ? & & ?11) (嫖遜閦彳) & & , & & , & & & & & & ? & & & & (犦秀彳) & & & & & ? & , & & & & & & & & / , & (epistemological quagmire) & / & , & & & & & & & . 㦮䞯㦮G 㡃䞶㦖G ˄ῂ㤦㦮G ケOŒ•“Ž›Œ•”Œ•›P˅G ὒG ⡦䞲G ⁎㢖G 䞾℮G ☚╂䞲G ˄⁒╖˅G 㦮G 㦮⹎㠦G Ⱔ㦖G 㔲㌂㩦㦚G ▮㰚┺U XWPG zŠŒ‹OYWW\PG ⓪G h•‹™ŒžG wŠ’Œ™•Ž㦮G ˄”ˆ•Ž“ŒG –G —™ˆŠ›ŠŒ˅G 㧊⪶㠦G ⁒Ệ䞮 㡂SG 㦮㌂㦮G 㧎㔳㭒㼊G ⡦䞲SG 㰖㡃㩗㦒⪲G 䔏㑮䞮ỢG 㫊㨂䞮⓪G 㦮㌂T䢮㧦G ὖἚSG ⁎ṖG 㧊㣿䞮⓪G 㦮⬢₆ῂSG ῃṖ㦮G 㩫䂮㩗SG 㩫㺛㩗G Ṳ㧛SG ⼧㤦㧊⧒⓪G 䔏㑮䞲G ⶒ Ⰲ㩗SG ㌂䣢㩗G ㌗䢿G ❇㠦G ₆⹮G 䞮㡂SG 㺓⹲OŒ”Œ™ŽŒ•›P䞮⓪G ộ㧊⧒ἶG 㭒㧻䞲┺U XXPG ˄ⴎ˅ὒG 㡆ὖ䞮㡂G YW㎎₆G 㭧G 䤚⹮㠦G 㧊⬾㠊㰚G 㦮⬢㧎⮮䞯㩗G 㧧㠛㠦G ╖䞲G Ⰲう ⪲⓪G s–Š’OX``ZP㦚G 㺎㫆U Ꮳ# ⑫# ␇ 73 Csordas & & relation) & & & & & & & .13) & & & & & & & (鶧瞆封) & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .16) & & & & & & & & ,14) & & & & & , & & & & & & & & ,12) & & & & & & & & (social & ’(pulse diagnostics) & & & & & & & & & & & & &‘ & & (tactility) & & & 17) & (canonical medicine) & 15) & Hsu & & & & & Cashinahua & & & (embodiment) McCallum & & & & .18) & , & XYPG jš–™‹ˆšOX``ZPUG ⁎⓪G 㧊G ⏒ⶎ㠦㍲G Ṗ䏾ⰃG ⿚䕢G 㭧㦮G 䞮⋮㧎G Šˆ™š”ˆ›ŠG 䂮 ⬢㧦㦮G 㡞⯒G ┺⭂┺U XZPG tŠjˆ““œ”OX``]PUG 㧊G 㤦㭒⹒✺㠦ỢG ⴎ㠦㍲G Ṗ㧻G 㭧㣪䞲G ộ㦖G ˄䞒⿖˅㧊┺UG 㧊 ✺㦮G 㠎㠊㠦㍲G ˄␢˅⓪G 㧎㰖OŠ–Ž•›–•PG 㠦G 㧞㠊G 㭧㣪䞲G 㡃䞶㦚G 䞮㰖G 㞠⓪┺UG ⁎✺㦖G 㠒ῊSG ㏦SG ⹲㦮G 䞒⿖⯒G 䐋䟊G ˄㞞┺O’•–žPU˅G X[PG ošœOYWW\P‰UG ㏦ὒG ⹲㦮G 䚲Ⳋ㠦G 㫊㨂䞮⓪G 㰖㩦㦚G 㭧㕂㦒⪲G 㯳㎎㢖G 䂮⬢㦮G 㥚 䂮ṖG 䚲䡚♲G ⶎ䠢✺㦖G 㑲ἓO菛篏PSG 㞫䐋O蒙讅P❇㦮G 㣿㠊㠦㍲G ⽒G 㑮G 㧞❅SG 㦮 ㌂㠦G 㦮䞲G 㰗㩧㩗㧎G ˄䎆䂮˅㦮G ἓ䠮㦚G 㿪䁷䅖G 䞮⓪G Ⱔ㦖G ⼧㯳✺⪲G 㧊⬾㠊㪎G 㧞┺UG X\PG jš–™‹ˆšOX``ZPUG 㕅┺G 㦮䞯㦮G ⰻ㰚㠦㍲⓪G 㦮㌂ṖG 䢮㧦㦮G ⰻ㦚G 㰰ἶSG 㔲Ṛ㧊G 䦮⩂G 䢮㧦㦮G ⰻὒG 㦮㌂㦮G ⰻ㧊G ☯䢪SG ἽG ὋⳛO簱聝PG ♮㠞┺ἶG ⓦ⋚G ➢G 㦮㌂ ṖG 䢮㧦㦮G ㌗䌲⯒G 㞢ἶSG ἓ㤆㠦G ➆⧒㍲⓪G 䢮㧦㦮G 㯳㌗㦚G 㦮㌂ṖG ἓ䠮䞶G 㑮G 㧞┺ἶG 㡂Ỿ㰚┺UG X]PG ošœOYWW\PˆUG ⁎⎖⓪G 䂾ῂ䂮⬢㠦㍲G 㧦䂾O螮謯P㦮G 㡃䞶G 㧦㼊ṖSG 䐋㯳㦮G 㥶⹲ὒG 䞾℮SG 䢮㧦㢖G 㦮㌂G ㌂㧊㠦G 㫊㨂䞮⓪G 㭒ṳὖO褨筝籝P㦮G ἓἚ⯒G ⶊ⍞⥾⩺G ㌗䢎 Ṛ㦮G ㏢䐋㦚G 㯳ṫ㔲䋺ⳆG ⁎㢖G ▪⿞㠊G ㌂䣢㩗G ὖἚG 㞞㠦㍲G 㫊㨂䞮▮G 㯳㌗㦮G ㏢㔺㠦☚G 䂮⬢㩗㦒⪲G ὖ㡂䞲┺ἶG 㭒㧻䞲┺UG ⰻ㰚㠦G ╖䟊㍲⓪G ošœG OYWWWP㦚G 㺎㫆U X^PG r”OYWW]P☚G 䞲㦮䞯ὒG 䞲㦮㌂㠦G ╖䞲G 㣎⿖㧦㩗㧎G ὖ㺆G 㔲ṗ㠦G ㌂䣢䞯㩗G ⹿ ⻫⪶㦚G 㦧㣿䞮ἶG 㧞㦒⋮SG 㦮䞯㠦G ╖䞲G 㼊Ἒ⌊㩗㧎G ἶ㺆O•›™ˆT”Œ‹Šˆ“G —Œ™š—ŒŠ›ŒP㦮G ἆ㡂⪲G 㧎䟊SG 䞲㦮䞯㦮G 䙂὚㩗㧎G ⳾㔋㦮G ₆㑶O絽菶P㠦G 㧞㠊 ㍲⓪G 㩲G 㡃䞶㦚G ┺䞮ἶG 㧞┺ἶG Ⱖ䞮₆G 㠊⪋┺U 㢧⪣㢤⪋# ⿫㢤⪿ါ2& ⑧⣜⪣㢤⪋# ၇㢤⫃ཋE & & &‘ ’ & & & & & & & , & & & , & , (inter-subjectivity) (搘鎣) & & & & Hsu (2000) .19) & 74 & & & & & & & & & , & & .20) 3. 㬾ⴺ㬻ⴢ# ㊂㬻ⵖዂ, ⛾⭳ⴺ㬻ⴢ# ዞ㬻ⵚᇢ? (Is East Asian medicine a philosophy, and Western medicine a science?) & & & & , &‘ ’ & & & & & & & , & & & , & & & & & & , & , & X_PG 㡞⯒G ✺㠊SG oˆ•š–•G OYWWXP㦖G 㼃╖O詿織P㦮G ⋾⿖㰖⹿㦚G 㭧㕂㦒⪲G 䞲G 㡾⼧䞯 O藝膂谷P㦮G ㌂䣢G 㩫䂮㩗G ⹲㩚G ⺆ἓὒG ⁎⩂䞲G ⺆ἓ㠦G ➆⯎G ˄ⴎ˅㠦G ╖䞲G ╊⪶㦮G 㩫䂮㩗G 㡃䞯O蔦谷PG ὖἚ㠦₢㰖G ㎎⹖䞲G ⿚㍳㦚G 䟟䞮ἶG 㧞┺UG ⶒ⪶G 㡃㌂䞯SG 䔏 䧞G 㦮䞯㌂Ⱒ㦮G ⹿⻫⪶㧊G 㫊㨂䞮ἶG 㧊⓪G ⡦䞲G 䞲㦮䞯㩗G ㌂㌗G 㫆⮮O裬羦P㦮G ㎇ Ⱃ㠦G ╖䟊G 㧊䟊⯒G ἶ㟧㔲䋺⓪G ◆G Ⱔ㦖G ☚㤖㧊G ♶G ộ㧚㠦G ⿚ⳛ䞮㰖ⰢSG 㧊⩂䞲G 㡆ῂ⓪G ˄㦮䞯㩗O”Œ‹Šˆ“P˅㧎G 㦮⹎⯒G ➆㰖ỢG ♮⓪G 䞚㧦㢖G ṯ㦖G 䞲㦮ἚG ⌊⿖㦮G ㌂⧢✺㠦Ợ⓪G Ⱔ㧊G 㠊䞚䞮㰖G ⴑ䞲┺UG ⁎⩆G Ⳋ㠦㍲G zŠŒ‹OYWW\PG 㦮G ἓ㤆SG 㼊 Ἒ⌊㩗㧎G ὖ㩦₢㰖G 㑮㣿䞮㡂G 䙂὚㩗㦒⪲G 䞲㦮䞯㠦G 㩧⁒䞮⩺G 䞲┺⓪G 㩦㠦㍲ ⓪G 㧊⪶㩗㦒⪲G ⹲㩚䟞┺ἶG ⽒G 㑮G 㧞㦒⋮SG ⏒㯳㦮G ⌊㣿ὒG ㌗ὖ㠜㧊SG ˄㩫䂮㩗˅ 㦒⪲ⰢG ⏒㰖㦮G 䦦⯚㦚G 㰖㏣㔲䋺⩺G 䞲┺⓪G 㩦㠦㍲G ゚䕦㦮G 㡂㰖ṖG Ⱔ┺U X`PG q–•ŒšOX`^]P㦮G ☯㍲㟧㦮G ┺⯎G ‰Œ“ŒG š š›Œ”㠦G ╖䞲G 㧒㫛㦮G ˄Ệ╖㧊⪶˅G 㧊G 㧊㠦G 䟊╏䞲┺UG ⁎⓪G ㍲⪲G ┺⯎G ⶎ䢪ṖG ┺⯎G ⹕㦢㦮G 㼊Ἒ⯒G Ṗ㰖ἶG 㧞ἶSG ṗ ṗ㦮G ⹕㦢㦮G 㼊Ἒ⓪G ⻷䎆OŒŠ›–™P㢖G ṯ㧊G 䧮ὒG ⹿䟻㦒⪲G ἆ㩫♮ⳆG ⁎⩂䞲G ⻷ 䎆ṖG 㩖㧦ṖG 㩲㔲䞲G 㡂⩂G Ṗ㰖G Ṳ⎦㦮G 㰖☚G ⌊㠦㍲G 㠊❪㠦G 㠊⠑ỢG 㥚䂮䞮ⳆG 㫆䞿♮ⓦ⌦㠦G ➆⧒G 㰖㡃㩗㧎O“–Šˆ“P㧊ἶG ☛䔏䞲G ⹕㦢㦮G 㼊ἚṖG ⹲㌳䞲┺⓪G 㭒㧻㦚G 䘒䂲┺UG YWPG 㧊G ⁖㠦㍲SG ošœ⓪G 䡚╖㦮G ㌳Ⰲ䞯㧊G 䞒⿖㫆㰗⌊㦮G ṦṗG 㑮㣿㼊O™ŒŠŒ—›–™P㦮G ㍺ⳛ㠦G 㧞㠊SG ⴎ㠦G Ṗ䟊㰖⓪G 㡂⩂G Ṗ㰖㦮G 㧦⁏G 㭧SG 䔏䧞G 㞫⩻O—™Œššœ™ŒP⯒G ῂ⿚䞮ỢG 䟊G 㭒⓪G 㑮㣿㼊㠦G ╖䞲G 㡆ῂṖG ⹎㰚䞾㦚G 㰖㩗䞲┺UG Ꮳ# ⑫# ␇ 75 & . & & & , & & & & & & &‘ & & & & & & & , & . ’ & & & & &‘ & & & & & & & & & & & & (causality) & & & ’ & & & &‘ &‘ & (colonialism)’ & (掇勞) & &‘ & & & (膎啳) & & & & (埭徱) & & & , . & , , & (logic) & & (elitist medicine)’ & & & & & & & ‘ & . & & & (reductionism) & ‘ (modernity),’ & & & & &‘ (rational excellence)’ & & (rational) & (啬欄) & & & & , & , & & (塣 (綼穿) & .21) . & & (藥穷) & & & & & , & & & & , & (吚礣) & & & & .22) , & & , & & & & & ’ & & & , & (啤) & & (羻) ,’ ‘ & , ’ & , & & & & & & & , & & & & & . &‘ & & . & & & & & & & & & 樎) & & & (quack practice)’ (塣樎) & , (canonical medicine) & & & (徆闌唾) & & & & & & & YXPG 䞲㦮ἚG ⌊㦮G 㩚䐋㠦㍲☚SG ˄蝉螿SG 蜻蒺˅⧒⓪G ⳾䏶ṖG 㧊⩂䞲G ὖ㩦㦮G ⹲㌳㦚G 㯳 ỆG 䞲┺U YYPG |•šŠœ“‹OX`_\PSG X\_TX`X㴓UG ╏㏷O繉莁PG ⼖䡗㦚G Ệ䂲G 䤚SG 㧊O蝝PG ⹒㫇㠦G 㦮 䞲G ⁞O綎P㦮G Ị㍺㦖G 䞲㫇O豀褈P✺㠦Ợ⓪G 㩫䂮㩗㦒⪲G ㌂䡫㍶ἶ⋮G ┺⯚G 㠜㠞┺UG 㭧㞯G ⹥G 㰖⹿ὖ㰗㠦㍲G ⺆㩲G ╏䞮ỢG ♲G 㰖⹿㦮G ‖㫇✺㦖G 㦮䞯㠦G ⑞㦚G ☢ⰂỢG ♮㠞ἶSG ⁎㢖G 䞾℮SG ㎎㦮O荃蝉P㦮G 㩚䐋㦒⪲ⰢG 㥶㰖♮▮G 㦮䞯Ἒ㠦G 㥶㦮O蛎蝉P 㢧⪣㢤⪋# ⿫㢤⪿ါ2& ⑧⣜⪣㢤⪋# ၇㢤⫃ཋE & (ꊾ战啢膎) & & . & & (椘礚) & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & (medical practice) & &‘ & 24) & & & ’ & & 23) (秀湚), & . & 76 & & & & . & , & & & & & & , & & & & & & & & &‘ & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & (medical & & & & , & (啤萀) & . & , & & , & & & & & .25) & , ‘ . & & & (堳啠嚌) & & & & & & & & , & & & & & & & & & & (端趻) & ’ & . & & , & & & &‘ & & intervention)’ & & & & & & & & & & , & & , & (噰榴)’ & & & & & & & & & (practice) & & & & 26) 㦮G 㩚䐋㧊G ⽎ỿ㩗㦒⪲G 㡗䟻㦚G ⋒䂮ỢG ♮㠞┺UG 䞮㰖ⰢG o ”ŒšOX`_^P⓪G 㥚㢖G ṯ㦖G 㦮䞯㌂Ἒ㦮G 㩫㍺㦚G ⹮⹫䞲┺U YZPG 䢣㤦㔳G ᾦ䞿䘎㺂OX`_XPUG 䢿㩲⌊ἓG ㏢ⶎG 㩲G XY䘎SG ˈ蝝腟脙蜺罸UˈG 㧊G 䘎㠦㍲G ṗG 㰖⹿㦮G ⹿㥚㠦G ➆⯎G ☯⋾㭧㍲⿗O纫網襦苣臦P㦮G 㡺䟟G ⺆㏣O脾荲P㦖G 㧒⹿㩗 㧎G 㡺䟟G ⺆㏣ὒG ┺⯊┺UG 㧊㠦G ╖䟊㍲⓪G oˆ•š–•OYWW]PG 㺎㫆UG Y[PG 㩚ῃ䞲㦮ὒ╖䞯G 㦮㌂䞯ᾦ㔺OYWW]PUG 䢿㩲⌊ἓG 㡗㿪O薠談PG 㩲G ][䘎G ˈ蜭蓪蝊葟 薺蝸UˉG Y\PG 㤦ὧ╖䞯ᾦG 䞲㦮ὒ╖䞯G ⼧Ⰲ䞯ᾦ㔺G ☯ⶎ䣢G OYWWZP㦚G 㞚ⶊⰂG 㺔㞚⽊㞚☚G 㿲 䕦♲G ⏒ⶎ㠦⓪G ₆⪳♮㠊G 㧞㰖⓪G 㞠㦒⋮SG 䞯䣢G ⳾㧚㠦㍲G ⓮G 䞮㔲▮G Ⱖ㝖㧊ⳆSG 䞲㦮䞯㌂O艋P㠦G ╖䞲G 㩗㩞䞲G ′㩫㧊⧒G ㌳ṗ䞮㡂G 㡂₆㠦G 㧎㣿䞲┺U Y]PG ⚦G Ṗ㰖㦮G ㍶䌳㧊G ⹮✲㔲G ㌗䢎G ⺆㩲㩗㧎O”œ›œˆ““ G ŒŸŠ“œšŒPG ộ㦖G 㞚┞┺UG 䞮㰖ⰢG ⏒ⰂG 㩚Ṳ⯒G 㥚䟊G 㡂₆㍲⓪G ⚦G Ṗ㰖⯒G ☯㔲㠦G ㍶䌳䞶G 㑮G 㠜⓪G ἓ㤆 Ꮳ# ⑫# ␇ 77 & & & , & & & , & (decision making) & ‘ & & & & & & & & & . & & & & & , & & & & & & , & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & (text) & & & .31) ,28) & .30) , & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .27) & .29) & , & & & (practice) & & & , & & & & & & & & (situational background) & & & & & & & & (causality) & & & . & & & & & , & & & & & & & (medical practice)’ & , & & & & & & 㠦G 㧞┺ἶG ㌗㩫䟊G ⽊㞮┺U Y^PG ˄{Œ’•ŒOˆ™›P˅G ⪲㍲㦮G 㦮䞯㦮G 䔏㰫㦖G wŒ““ŒŽ™•–OX`_XPG 㠦G 㧮G ₆㑶O絽菶PG ♮㠊G 㧞┺U Y_P 㥶㩚䞯㠦G ₆⹮䞲G 㡆ῂ✺㧊G 㭒⪲G 㧊⩂䞲G 㟒㕂㦚G ✲⩂⌎┺UG yUG kˆž’•š⋮G tˆ››G y‹“Œ 㦮G 㧒⩾㦮G 㩖㧧✺㦖G ┾㰖G 㥶㩚䞯㦮G ㎇ὒ⯒G 㞢Ⰲ⓪G 㹾㤦㦚G ⍮㠊 ㍶┺UG kˆž’•š⯒G 㭧㕂㦒⪲G ⻢㠊㰖⓪G 㫛ᾦ㢖G ὖ⩾䞲G ⏒㨗☚G 㧊⩂䞲G 㟒㕂㦮G 㡆㏣㍶㌗㠦G 㧞┺G 䞮Ỷ┺U Y`PG 㧊㦮G ╖䚲㩗㧊G 㡞ṖG 㡃䞯Ol—‹Œ”–“–Ž P㠦㍲㦮G —™–‰ˆ‰“š›ŠG ŠˆœšŒ㦮G 㫊㨂 㧊ⳆSG Ⱔ㦖G 㩫㔶㰞䢮㦮G ㌳ⰂSG ⼧Ⰲ㠦G ╖䞲G ὒ䞯㩗G 㩧⁒㦮G 㔲☚ṖG ┺⯎G ⿚㟒G 㠦㍲㻮⩒G 䋆G ㎇Ὃ㦚G Ệ⚦㰖G ⴑ䞮ἶG 㧞⓪G 㩦㧊┺UG jˆœšŒṖG ŒŒŠ›⯒G 㰗㩧㩗 㦒⪲G ŠˆœšŒ䞮㰖G 㞠⓪┺⓪G ộG 㧦㼊ṖG 㧊⹎G 㧎ὒ㥾㦮G 㩫㦮G 㧦㼊⯒G ⺆⹮䞮ἶG 㧞┺UG 㧊㠦G ╖䟊㍲⓪G wˆ™ˆšŠˆ•‹–“ˆG Œ›G ˆ“UOYWWXPG 㺎㫆UG ZWPG uˆ›ˆ•G z•㦖G 㑲㤆㦮O菣虚蜻PSG ἽG 㺓ὋO訓簰PG ╖䞲G ₆⪳G ⿚㍳㦚G 䐋䟊SG 䞲㦮 䞯㠦㍲G 䎣㓺䔎㢖G ἓ䠮㦮G ὖἚṖG 㽞₆G 㦮䞯㰖㔳㦮G 䡫㎇₆㠦㍲⿖䎆G ⠒⩺㟒G ⠚G 㑮G 㠜⓪G ὖἚ㡖┺ἶG 㭒㧻䞲┺UG z•G OX``\PUG ZXPG 䞲㦮䞯ὒG ㍲㟧㦮䞯G ㌂㧊㠦⓪G 䐋㟓O讇蓈P㧊G ⿞Ṗ⓻O•Š–””Œ•šœ™ˆ‰“ŒPG 䞮┺⓪G 㭒㧻☚G 㧊⩂䞲G ⏒㦮㦮G 㡆㧻㍶㠦G 㧞┺ἶG ⽒G 㑮G 㧞┺UG 㧊㠦G ╖䞲G ὒ䞯㻶䞯㩗G ⏒㦮㠦G ╖䟊㍲⓪G 㧊㿿㡊OX``\PG 㺎㫆UG 㢧⪣㢤⪋# ⿫㢤⪿ါ2& ⑧⣜⪣㢤⪋# ၇㢤⫃ཋE & &‘ , (喍鰨) & & & & & & & , & & , & & & & & & & & & , & & . & & & & & (绪嘘) & & & & & & & & & . & & , & & & & & & & , & & & & & & , ’ & (啢) & & & (总嬫) & & & & , & & & & & & & , , & & . (骬由) & & & & & & & & & & , & & & & . & & & & &‘ & & & & & & , & & & & & & , , & & & & & , & & & & & & & & & & & & & & (other) & & ’ & & & & 78 & & & & & , & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & (唥午) & & & & & & & . Ꮳ# ⑫# ␇ 79 4. ᇲᇣⴺ# ⷾፏ# Ꮪᾎዂ# ⵞ⚣✓# (Empire of the senses and ordinariness)32) (sense) & & & & & & & & & . ’ & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & . (崑瀞) & (崑瀞) & .35) & & & & & & & & & & . & . & , & & , & & & & & & & & & & & & & , & . , , & & & & & , & & , , , & (thought)33) , ‘ , & . & & . & & & & . & & .34) & & (啨瀞, 鲣忍檌珐痠瑦) (蔃踵) & & & ZYP 㡂₆㠦㍲㦮G Ṧṗ㦖G ₆⽎㩗㦒⪲G ⋮㦮G 㔶㼊㠦G ₆⹮䞮ἶG 㧞ἶSG 㭒ὖ㎇Ošœ‰‘ŒŠ›› P 㦚G ⹪䌫㦒⪲G 䞲┺UG ┺㔲G Ⱖ䟊SG ⋮㦮G ⶒ㰞㩗G ₆⹮㦚G 㧊⬾ἶG 㧞⓪G 㔶㼊㦮G ⊳G Ṗ㧻㧦ⰂO–œ›Œ™G ‰–œ•‹ˆ™ PṖG Ṧṗ㧊G ⊳⋮⓪G Ὁ㧊┺UG 㣎⿖G ㎎Ἒ㢖㦮G ὋⳛO簱 聝P㧊⋮G Ṧ㦧O笚蜴PὒG ṯ㦖G Ṳ⎦㦚G 䙂䞾䞮☚⪳G Ṳ⎦㧊G 䢫㧻♮㠊G 㧞㰖⓪G 㞠┺U ZZPG ⳾✶G ㌳ṗ㧊G ⹮✲㔲G ⳛ㩲䌲☚O—™–—–š›–•ˆ“G ˆ›››œ‹ŒP㧊㰖G 㞠Ỷ㰖ⰢSG 㡂₆㍲ ⓪G 㠎㠊⪲G 㩫Ⰲ♲G 㠊⟺G ㌳ṗ㦚G Ⱖ䞲┺U Z[PG Ṧṗ㠦⓪G ㌂䣢㩗㧎G 㣪㏢☚G 㧞┺UG 㣪䐋G 䢮㧦✺G 㭧㠦⓪G 䔏㩫G 㧻㏢⋮G 㦮㧦ⰢG ⽦ ☚G 䠞ⰂṖG 㞚䝚┺ἶG 䢎㏢䞮⓪G ἓ㤆ṖG Ⱔ┺UG 㧊⓪G ἽG ㌂䣢㩗㧎G 㠊⟶䞲G ㌗䢿G O⌊ṖG ⁎G 㦮㧦㠦G 㞟Ệ⋮SG ⁎G 㧻㏢㠦G Ṗ㟒G 䞮⓪G ㌗䢿PG 㧊G ἆῃ㦖G ⌊G ⴎG 㞞㦮G Ṧṗ㦚G 㧒㦒䋺⓪G ộ㦒⪲SG 㧊⓪G ⌊G ⴎG 㞞㦮G ⶒ㰞㩗G 㣪㏢㠦G 㦮䞲G ộ㈦ⰢG 㞚┞ ⧒SG ⶒⰂ㩗㦒⪲G ⴎG ⹬㠦G 㫊㨂䞮⓪G ㌂䣢㩗㧎G Ṳ㼊⋮G ㌗䢿㠦G 㦮䟊G ⌊G ⴎ㦮G Ṧ ṗ㧊G ⹲㌳䞲┺⓪G 㩦㠦㍲G ⶒ㰞ὒG ㌂䣢SG ⁎ⰂἶG ⁎ộ㦚G ⰺṲ䞮⓪G ⴎSG ⡦䞲G ⁎ 㠦G ₆⹮䞲G Ṧṗ㦮G 㫊㨂⪶㩗G 㡆ὖ㎇₢㰖SG 䞯ⶎ㩗㦒⪲G 䦻⹎⪲㤊G ἶ㺆㦮G 㡞ṖG ♶G 㑮G 㧞┺UG ⶒ⪶SG ␢㔶ἓ䞯㩗㦒⪲G 㩧⁒䞮ⳊG 㧊G ⡦䞲G 㤆ⰂG ⴎSG 䔏䧞G ␢㦮G 㔶 ἓ䞯㩗㧎G 㩫⽊G 㻮Ⰲ㢖G 㑮䟟㦮G ἆὒ⪲G ⽒G 㑮G 㧞┺UG 䞮㰖ⰢG 㧊⓪G ㌂䣢㩗G Ṳ㼊 Oš–Šˆ“G Œ•›› P㦮G 㔺㨂㎇O™Œˆ“› PὒG 㡆ὖ䞲G ┺⯎G 㑮Ⱔ㦖G 㻶䞯㩗 V ㌂䣢䞯㩗G ⏒ 㦮㢖G 㡆ἆG ♮ⳆSG 㧊⓪G ┺㔲G 㤆ⰂG ⴎ㠦G ╖䞲G ⽋㧷䞲G 㫊㨂⪶㩗G ⏒㦮㢖☚G 㠓䧞 ỢG ♲┺UG Z\PG ošœOYWW^P㦖G 㥷₆O蜄絥PG 㭧㠦㍲G 䛣O谓P㠦G ╖䟊G ┺⬾ἶG 㧞┺U 㢧⪣㢤⪋# ⿫㢤⪿ါ2& ⑧⣜⪣㢤⪋# ၇㢤⫃ཋE & & & & & & . & & & & & & & & , & & & & & & , & & (掾分) & & & & & (崬躺) & & (呗 & , & & (蔹) & . . (瀯濍) & & & & & & & & & & , & & (跳朂) & , .38) & & & & & & & & & & & . & & & & & ’ & & & (攚瀞) & & & & , . & , & & (秫) & (戳嬣) & & & (咲忍軑) (怊魌ꎈ牪)37) (掾分) & ‘ (蕉) & (崥驸膎豣轄) & & & & .36) (晆醮) & & . & & (詖疬) , & & & & & & & & & & & 瀯) & (蔃囐) & (刅瀞攚) & (詖) , & & , 7: & . & & . & & & & & & , & & & & & . . . , & & & & , & & & . & & & & & (lived world) & (攚) & & & & (phenomenal world) & & & & & & & Z]PG ošœOYWWWP㦖G 䞲㦮䞯㦮G 䂶㌂ⰻO謥艠耵P㦚G 㭧㕂㦒⪲SG X^SG X_㎎₆㠦G 㭧ῃ㦚G ┺ ⎖ṚG ㍶ᾦ㌂✺㦚G 䐋䟊G 㥶⩓㦒⪲G 㩚䟊㰚G 䞲㦮䞯㦮G ⰻ㰚㦮G ⹿⻫㠦G ╖䞲G 㥶⩓ 㧎✺㦮G 㧊䟊㠦G ╖䞲G 䦻⹎⪲㤊G ₆㑶㦚G 䞮ἶG 㧞┺U Z^PG 芠谻谉膻豻SG 葖谨蛞莤絥㦮G 㯳㎎㠦G ㌂㣿䞲┺UG Ⱎ䢿SG Ἒ㰖SG ⺇㧧㟓SG 㡺⹎㧦SG ㎎ 㔶SG ⹮䞮SG Ṧ㽞SG Ịṫ㦒⪲G 㧊⬾㠊㪎G 㧞┺UG ㌗䞲⪶O芠谻罸P 㤦ⶎ㦮G ⌊㣿㻮⩒G Ⱎ䢿䌫O翺赣譨P㧊⋮G Ἒ㰖䌫O篤覆譨P㠦G 㦮䟊G ⺆㿲♮㰖G ⴑ䞲G ㌂₆O艺絥PṖG 㑮☛ O莤纏P㦒⪲G ⼖䡫G ♮㠊G 㧞⓪G 㯳O襸P㠦G 㻮⹿G ♲┺U Z_PG 繗誵箾衾OYWW[PG 㦮G ⁖㦚G 㧓㠊⽊ⳊG ⍞ⶊ⋮☚G 㻶㩖䞶G 㩫☚⪲G ㍲㟧㦮䞯㩗G ⼧ⳛ ὒ㦮G 㡆ὖ㎇㦚G 䌦ῂ䞮ἶG 㧞┺UG 䞮㰖ⰢG ⁎㦮G 㺛㠦㍲☚G 㻮⹿㦮G ῂ㎇ὒG 㰚┾㦖G ⽋㰚O膠覻P㦚G 䐋䟊G 㦮㌂㦮G ㏦⊳㠦㍲㦮G 㠑㠊㰖⓪G ṦṗὒG 䢮㧦㦮G 㭒ὖ㩗㧎G 㯳 ㎎⯒G 㭧㕂㦒⪲G 㰚䟟♲┺UG 㧊G ἓ㤆⓪G 㕂䞮O葖谨P㠦G 㫊㨂䞮⓪G 㰚㑮㦢O覤莤蜮P㧊G 㰚┾㦮G 㣪㩦㧊G ♲┺U Ꮳ# ⑫# ␇ 7; & & & & & & & , & & & & & & & . & , & & & & & & & & & & ,’ ‘ & & ,’ ‘ & & ’ & (explanatory power) & & & & & , , & & & & & & & & & & & & & , & , & & & & & (辅縩) & & & & & . & & , . & & & & & & & , . & & & ’ & ’ & & , & (鍄圑) & & & & & & & & , & &‘ & (鍄忦) & &‘ & & & & . & & & , & & & & & & & & & & RNA & & . & & & & & & & & , , & & & & & & & , ‘ & & & & & & & & .39) & & & & & & & & & & & & world) & & & & & & & , & & , & &‘ (历) & & & & (崑緌) (phenomenal & , & (ordinariness)’ & & & & & , , & , (觠搢) & & (constitutive elements) & & & & & & (忍疬) , (镳蛡礓鎖ꉴ) & & & & . , & (豣賊), & & (榴嚌) & & (啢崑), & & & & & & Z`PG ὒ䞯㩗㧎G ⹿㔳㦒⪲G ㌊ἶG 㧞㰖G 㞠㦖G 㤆Ⰲ㦮G ㌌G ⳾⚦ṖG 㔺㌗G 㡂₆㠦G 䟊╏G ♲ ┺UG 㤆ⰂṖG ✹⓪G ⧒❪㡺G ⹿㏷SG 䢮㧦⪲⿖䎆㦮G 㰚㑶SG 㩚㻶G 㞞㦮G 㞞⌊ⶎG ❇G Ệ㔲 㩗O筦萣蠿P㧎G Ệ㦮G ⳾✶G ộ✺㦖G 㠎㠊⧒⓪G ⰺṲ㼊⯒G 䐋䟊G 㤆Ⰲ㠦ỢG 㩚╂♮㠊G 㤆Ⰲ㦮G ㌌㠦G 㡗䟻㦚G ⋒䂮ⳆSG ㌂㣿♮⓪G 㠎㠊㦮G ㌗╏G ⿖⿚㦖G ṦṗG ❇G 㰖⁏䧞G 㭒ὖ㩗㧎G 㤆Ⰲ㦮G ἓ䠮㠦G ₆⹮䞮ἶG 㧞┺UG 㢧⪣㢤⪋# ⿫㢤⪿ါ2& ⑧⣜⪣㢤⪋# ၇㢤⫃ཋE & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & , & , & & . & . & , & & & . & & & & & (水抐) & & & . & , , & & & 7< & & & & Ꮳ# ⑫# ␇ 83 , & (2005), , & & & & & & & & , . & (2003) &( & ) . & (1995), “ & & & ,” 19(1), . & & & (2006), & & & (2008), , & & & (2008), ( , . . ) , . & 大 & (1981), & / & & & , & (2004), , . . Andrews, Bridie J. (1996), “The making of modern Chinese medicine 1895-1937,” PhD. Dissertation, Cambridge University. Csordas, T.J. (1993), “Somatic modes of attention,” Cultural Anthropology 8 (2): 135-156 . Good, B. (1990), Medicine, Rationality and Experience, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Hanson, M. (2001), “Robust northerners and delicate southerners: the nineteenth-century invention of a southern medical tradition,” Innovation in Chinese medicine, Elisabeth Hsu ed, Cambridge.: Cambridge University Press, 262-291 . Hanson, M. (2006), “Northern purgatives, southern restoratives: Ming medical regionalism,” ASME 2,2. Hshianglin, L. (2002), “How did chinese medicine become experiential? The political epistemology of Jingyan,” Positions 10:2. Hsu, E. (2000). Towards a science of touch, part I,II: Representations of the tactile experience of the seven Chinese pulses indicating danger of death in early modern Europe. Anthropology and 㢧⪣㢤⪋# ⿫㢤⪿ါ2& ⑧⣜⪣㢤⪋# ၇㢤⫃ཋE 84 Medicine, 7(3). Hsu, E. (2005)a. “Acute pain infliction as a therapy.” Etnofoor XVIII(1), 78-96 . Hsu, E. (2005)b. “Tactility and the body in early chinese medicine.” Science in Context 18(1) 7-34 . Hsu, E. (2007). “The Experience of wind in Early and Medieval chinese medicine.” Wind, life, Health: Anthropological and Historical Approaches, Special Issue. Journal of Royal Anthropological Institute, S. 115-132 . Hymes, R. (1987). “Not quite gentlemen? Doctors in Song and Yuan.” Chinese Science 8, 9-76 . Jones, W. T. (1976), “Worldviews and Asian medical systems,” Asian Medical systems, C. Leslie eds. University of Berkeley. Kim, J. Y. (2006). “Postcolonial Paradox of Transcultural Medicine: A multi-sited ethnography on the Scientific-industrial Networking & of Korean Medicine,” & . Kuriyama, S. (1999), The Expressiveness of the body and the divergence of Chinese and Greek Medicine, Zone Books. Lock, M. (1993). “Cultivating the body: Anthropology and Epistemologies of bodily practice and Knowledge,” Annual Review of Anthropology 22: 133-55 . McCallum, C. (1996). “The body that knows: From Cashinahua Epistemology to a medical anthropology of lowland South America,” Medical Anthropology Quarterly 10(3), 347-372 . Papineau, D. et al. (2000). Introducing Consciousness, Icon Books. Parascandola, M. et al. (2001) “Causation in epidemiology,” Journal of Epidemiology and community Health 55, 905-912 . Pellegrino E. (1981). The philosophical basis of medical practice, Oxford: Oxford University Press. Pockert, M. (1976). “Epistemological premises of Chinese medicine,” Asian Medical Systems, C. Leslie eds. Berkeley: University of Ꮳ# ⑫# ␇ 85 Berkeley Press. Sivin, N. (1995), “Text and experience in Classical chinese medicine,” Knowledge and Scholarly Medical Tradition. Don Bates ed., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Scheid, V. (2005), Chinese medicine in Contemporary China(Plurality and synthesis), Durham: Duke University Press. Unshuld (1985), Medicine in China, University of California Press. Zhang, E. Y. (2007). “Switching between Traditional Chinese Medicine and Viagra: Cosmopolitanism and Medical Pluralism Today,” Medical Anthropology 26, 53-96 . 㢧⪣㢤⪋# ⿫㢤⪿ါ2& ⑧⣜⪣㢤⪋# ၇㢤⫃ཋE 86 <Abstract> Is East Asian Medicine a Philosophy, and Western Medicine a Science? Tg2& Ykut3Ygs& .Qgtmjutm& Ngsyug& Uxoktzgr& Skjoigr& Irotoi/ Abstract: EAM prizes subjectivity in practice while western bio-medicine tries to kill it as thoroughly as possible. So there goes the saying, ‘EAM is a philosophy and western medicine is a science.’ However, this paper argues that it’s a case of pre-reflective simplification in that EAM’s emphasis on subjective engagement in practice actually parallels the process of physicians’ decision making in modern bio-medical settings. Furthermore, medicine cannot be a pure science as many research findings have shown to us. Behind this simplified frame of reference lies the epistemological and political conflict between these two medicines. What’s necessary for us is a perspective that’s not parochial, but is able to resort to our inter-subjectivity. As one such option of possibility, this paper presents the arguments concerning the tactile and sensible ‘body,’ through which the new possibility of synthesizing the experiences gained in EAM traditions and the knowledge from the biomedicine could be explored and critically assessed in an entirely different dimensions of perspectives. Key words: East Asian Medicine, biomedicine, medical anthropology, sense, functional anatomy