Ibuprofen-MediatedInfarct Size Reduction: Effects on
Regional Myocardial Function in Canine
Myocardial Infarction
PHILIP C. KIRLIN, MD,* JOSEPH L. ROMSON, PhD,+ BERTRAM PITT, MD,
GERALD D. ABRAMS,
MD, M. ANTHONY SCHORK, PhD, and
BENEDICT R. LUCCHESI, PhD, MD
Normal, marginal, and central ischemic regional
myocardial function were evaluated in a canine
model of myocardial infarction during 90 minute left
circumflex coronary artery occlusion in 25 anesthetized dogs randomly assigned to intravenous
ibuprofen infusion (n = 13,5.36 mg/kg/h beginning
1 hour before occlusion) or vehicle solution as
control (n = 12) and in 15 conscious, unsedated
dogs 48 and 72 hours after 90 minute circumflex
artery occlusion followed by reperfusion (ibuprofen,
5.36 mg/kg/h by intravenous infusion over 7 hours
beginning 1 hour before occlusion, n = 7; or vehicle
solution infusion as control, n = 8).
Miniature subendocardial sonomicrometer crystal
pairs were used to calculate left ventricular regional
end-diastolic segment length, end-systolic segment
length, and regional percent systolic shortening.
Infarct size was estimated in 72 hour animals by a
postmortem dual perfusion technique using triphenyltetrazolium histochemical dye and Evan’s
blue dye for determination of infarct area, risk area,
and area not at risk. Ibuprofen treatment significantly
reduced infarct size expressed as percent of risk
area (mean f standard deviation of 44.6 f 18
versus 64.4 f 16% for control dogs, p <0.05) but it
did not improve normal, marginal, or ischemic region
end-diastolic length, end-systolic length or percent
systolic shortening during coronary occlusion in
anesthetized dogs or after reperfusion in conscious
animals at 48 and 72 hours, and it did not enhance
inotropic reserve at 72 hours in conscious animals.
During 90 minute circumflex occlusion in anesthetized dogs, ibuprofen was associated with increases
in systemic arterial pressure and worsened ischemic
regional percent systolic shortening.
Thus, ibuprofen does not improve normal, marginal, or ischemic zone regional myocardial function
during acute ischemia or 48 or 72 hours after myocardial reperfusion despite a significant reduction
of infarct size.
Reducing
the extent of ischemic injury has been proposed as a rational goal in the management
of acute
myocardial
infarction.’
Initial attempts to achieve this
goal centered primarily on hemodynamic
interventions
which lessened
myocardial
oxygen consumption
or
improved
blood flow or oxygen delivery to ischemic
myocardium;
more recent investigations
have evaluated
a variety of agents whose primary effect is not hemodynamic but rather anti-inflammatory.
The hypothesis
supporting
the use of these agents is that a significant
determinant
of ultimate ischemic injury is the inflammatory process itself. Among the many agents currently
under evaluation
is ibuprofen,
a nonsteroidal
antiinflammatory
agent clinically
employed
for rheumatic
disease.* Experimental
studies have demonstrated
a
From the Departments of Pharmacology, Internal Medicine (Cardiology
myocardial
protective
effect of ibuprofen
in a variety
Division), and Pathology, University of Michigan Medical School and
of animal models,3-7 presumably
attributable
to its
the Department of Biostatistics, University of Michigan School of Public
antiinflammatorv
actions which affect arachidonic
acid
Health, Ann Arbor, Michiaan. This studv was suooorted in oart bv National Institutes of Health Research Grant HL19782-03 from zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
ihe National
metabolism
and-consequent
physiologic
events.8
Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, Bethesda, Maryland, and by a grantHowever, few studies on myocardial
infarct size rein-aid from the Upjohn Company, Kalamazoo, Michigan. Manuscript
duction
involving
either
hemodynamic
or antiinflamreceived November 30, 1981; revised manuscrrpt received April 27,
matory interventions
have addressed
the issue of the
1982, accepted May 6, 1982.
functional
integrity of the salvaged
mvocardium
or the
Dr Kirlin was the recipient of a Michigan Heart Association Re_
search Fellowship Award, Lathrop Village, Michigan.
effect of these agents on the function
of myocardium
+ Dr Romson was the recipient of a Pharmaceutical Manufacturer’s
removed from the area of ischemic injury. In order to
Association Fellowship, Washington, D.C.
assess the myocardial
protective
effect of ibuprofen
on
Address for reprints: Benedict R. Lucchesr, MD, Department of
regional myocardial
function,
the following investigaPharmacology, M6322 Medical Science Buildina I, Universitv of Michigan Medicaikhool.
Ann Arbor, Michigan 48159.
tion was undertaken
using implantable
subendocardial
l
October 1982
The American Journal of CARDIOLOGY
Volume 50
849
IBUPROFEN AND REGIONAL MYOCARDIAL
FUNCTION-KIRLIN
ET AL.
sonomicrometer
crystals to measure segment length
changes in normal, marginal and ischemic regions9 in
a canine model of left circumflex
coronary artery occlusion and reperfusion.
In this study, regional myocardial function was evaluated in open-chest,
anesthetized dogs during coronary
artery occlusion
and in
conscious,
unsedated
dogs 48 and 72 hours after circumflex occlusion and subsequent
myocardial
reperfusion.
tricular wall to straddle
the border between cyanotic and
noncyanotic
zones. The marginal area was defined in the
present study as a region of intermediate
function between
normal and ischemic zones.9 Normal zone sonomicrometer
crystals were implanted
on the anterior left ventricular
wall
in the region supplied by the left anterior descending coronary
artery well removed from the ischemic area as determined
by
the zone of cyanosis. The crystals were implanted
in a plane
perpendicular
to the base-apex cardiac axis and secured by
an epicardial
suture around the connecting
wires as they
emerged from the myocardium.
Repeated calibrations at 1 ~LS
intervals were obtained to eliminate variation due to signal
Methods
drift.
Regional Myocardial Function During Coronary
In addition, a small left neck incision was made for insertion
Artery Occlusion zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
of a polyethylene
carotid artery catheter for blood pressure
measurement
and an external jugular catheter for infusion of
Coronary occlusion: In order to assess the acute effects
ibuprofen or control solution. The carotid artery catheter was
of ibupiofen on regional function during evolving myocardial
connected
to a Statham P23DC pressure transducer.
Mean
injuiry due to coronary artery occlusion, 25 dogs were studied
arterial pressure was calculated as diastolic pressure plus one
in the open-chest
anesthetized
state. Healthy male mongrel
third of the pulse pressure.
dogs weighing 10.2 to 18.9 kg (mean f standard deviation 13.9
Ibuprofen infusion: Crystalline
ibuprofen
(sodium salt)
f 1.9) were anesthetized
with 30 mg/kg intravenous
sodium
was dissolved in 0.2 zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPO
M sodium carbonate and adjusted to a pH
pentobarbital
and mechanically
ventilated
on room air by a
of 8 by 1.0 N HCl. Solutions were mixed fresh before each
Harvard
animal
respirator
(Harvard
Apparatus,
Millis,
experiment and diluted to 50 ml in physiologic saline solution.
Massachusetts)
using an endotracheal
tube. A left 5th interThe ibuprofen dose employed was 5.36 mg/kg/h (7.14 ml/h of
costal space thorocotomy
was performed and the pericardium
ibuprofen
solution) by continuous
intravenous
infusion beincised and sutured to form a pericardial cradle. The left cirginning 1 hour before occlusion and continuing
throughout
cumflex coronary artery was isolated distal to the left atria1
occlusion (90 minutes). This dose is similar to that used in a
appendage proximal to major branches. A zone of cyanosis was
previous investigation6
with the exception of initiation of the
determined
to be at least 9 cm2 during transient
(10 to 15
infusion before occlusion in the present study. Vehicle solution
second) coronary
occlusion.
Three pairs of commercially
prepared in an identical manner without ibuprofen served as
manufactured
miniature
(3 mm) piezoelectric
crystals (800
a control.
A Harvard infusion pump was used to provide a
kHz frequency in radial mode with a resolution capability of
constant infusion rate. Animals were randomly assigned to
0.1 to 0.5 mm) connected to an oscilloscope sonomicrometer
their treatment
groups (13 ibuprofen,
12 control). A lead II
(Norland Instruments
sonomicrometer
crystals and NI-202
electrocardiogram
was
monitored
throughout
the experisonomicrometer)
were implanted
1 to 2 cm apart in the left
ment. zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJ
ventricular subendocardium
(Fig. 1). One crystal pair (central
After instrumentation,
visible epicardial arterial anastoischemic zone) was implanted
in the posterolateral
left venmoses between the left anterior descending
and circumflex
tricular surface in the center of the cyanotic zone as detercoronary arteries were ligated to eliminate potentially
large
mined by the transient
circumflex occlusion, and a 2nd pair
collateral routes of blood flow.‘O A subtotal left circumflex
(marginal area) was implanted
in the anterolateral
left vencoronary artery stenosis was produced just distal to the left
atria1 appendage
by tying 1-O silk suture around both the artery and an 18 gauge needle followed by immediate
needle
removal; subsequent
total circumflex
artery occlusion was
performed after 10 minutes with a total duration of occlusion
of 90 minutes. Three mg/kg of intravenous
lidocaine and 3
mg/kg of intramuscular
lidocaine were administered
at the
time of coronary artery occlusion as antiarrhythmic
therapy.”
Approximately
one fourth of the animals developed ventricular fibrillation during coronary occlusion, which was readily
converted
to sinus rhythm within 30 to 60 seconds by low
energy (10 to 20 J) direct. current cardioversion
using epicardial paddles. No myocardial
dysfunction
has been reported
at these energy levels.12
Regional myocardial segment length: Measurement
of
regional myocardial
segment length was obtained
by converting sonomicrometer
crystal transit time in microseconds
to distance in millimeters using a known value for the velocity
of ultrasound
in myocardium
at the frequency
employed:
Distance (mm) = transit time (I.CS)X ultrasound
velocity in
myocardium
(1.58 mm/ps).l3 Before occlusion, end-diastolic
length was defined in each segment as the maximal crystal
separation in millimeters before the onset of the carotid artery
systolic pressure rise, and end-systolic
length was defined as
FIGURE 1. Diagram of subendocardial sonomicrometer crystal
the minimal crystal separation
in millimeters
before the diplacement in normal, marginal, and central ischemic left ventricular
erotic notch of the carotid artery pressure tracing. Nonsimregions. LCX = left circumflex coronary artery. See text for discusultaneous end-diastolic
or end-systolic
timing in marginal or
sion.
a50
October 1982
The American Journal of CARDIOLOGY
Volume 50
IBUPROFEN AND REGIONAL MYOCARDIAL
FUNCTION--KIRLIN
ET AL.
lengths were obtained in the conscious, unsedated
state with
ischemic segments in relation to normal segments was noted
the animal standing upright in a nylon sling. In order to assess
before occlusion and used as a reference to determine
endresidual ventricular contractile function, inotropic reserve was
diastole and end-systole
in the presence of dyskinesia during
also tested at 72 hours after coronary occlusion-reperfusion,
coronary artery occlusion.
Measurement
of absolute end5 minutes after administration
of the beta-adrenergic
stimdiastolic and end-systolic length in millimeters were obtained
ulant prenalterol(30
pg/kg intravenous
bolus).‘*
and regional percent systolic shortening
defined as end-diaDetermination
of infarct
size and risk area: Animals
stolic minus end-systolic
length divided by end-diastolic
were then reanesthetized
with sodium pentobarbital,
the chest
length X100%. Subendocardial
crystal placement
was conwas reopened, and the hearts were electrically fibrillated and
firmed by postmortem
examination. zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
rapidly excised for immediate
postmortem
in vitro determiA Grass model 7 polygraph was used to record measurenations of infarct size and risk area by a dual perfusion techments at a paper speed of 100 mm/s. Determination
of carotid
nique using 4% triphenyltetrazolium
chloride mixed with
artery pressure, heart rate, and regional segment lengths and
phosphate buffer for histochemical
staining of dehydrogenase
percent systolic shortening
were obtained before and at the
enzyme and 0.5% Evan’s blue flow-dependent
staining as
end of 90 minutes of coronary occlusion. All measurements
described in detail elsewhere. 7~s Briefly, this method involves
were obtained at end-expiration
and when the animal was free
simultaneous
selective left circumflex
perfusion
with triof arrhythmias.
phenyltetrazolium
and nonselective
retrograde
aortic perfuRegional Myocardial Function 48 and 72 Hours After
sion with Evans blue dye at physiologic pressure (100 mg Hg),
Coronary Artery Occlusion-Reperfusion
with the resultant Evan’s blue staining tissue identifying the
area not at risk of ischemic injury and the remaining tissue
The effect of ibuprofen on regional myocardial function and
representing
the area at risk with red triphenyltetrazolium
infarct size was evaluated in conscious, unsedated
dogs after
staining tissue identifying the viable, noninfarcted
region, and
left circumflex
coronary artery occlusion with subsequent
the remaining tissue (unstained)
representing
the area of inmyocardial
reperfusion
in the anesthetized
state. Fifteen
healthy male mongrel dogs weighing 13.6 + 1.5 kg (range 10.2
farction. After staining, the heart was sliced from apex to base
in 5 mm thick transverse
sections and the atria and right
to 15.8) were used. Instrumentation,
baseline regional function
ventricle were excised. Left ventricular
weight was recorded
measurements,
and 90 minute circumflex occlusion followed
and left ventricular
slices were traced on transparent
plastic
by reperfusion
were performed
using aseptic technique
in
sheets for hand planimeter
determination
of left ventricular
pentobarbital
anesthetized,
open-chest
dogs as in the acute
area, area at risk, and area of infarction.
Infarct size was
occlusion study. Animals were randomly assigned to either
ibuprofen (n = 7) or vehicle as control (n = 8). Solutions were
measured as percent of area at risk and percent of total left
prepared as before and administered
intravenously
by Harventricular
area. The anatomic perfusion bed of an occluded
vard infusion pump over 7 hours beginning 1 hour before occoronary has been shown to correlate well with the area at risk
clusion with an ibuprofen dose of 5.36 mg/kg/h (7.14 ml/h of
of infarction
in experimental
canine coronary artery occluibuprofen solution) or with an identical volume of vehicle as
sion.lO Subendocardial
crystal placement was also confirmed
at postmortem
evaluation.
a control. Ischemic zone sonomicrometer
crystals were associated with greater postoperative
mortality
in preliminary
Light microscopic evaluation of hematoxylin and eosin
studies and therefore
implanted
in only 4 animals in each
stained left ventricular slices was performed
in a blinded
group. As in the acute occlusion study, a critical circumflex
manner on 72 hour specimens from all animals in each group
stenosis was placed 10 minutes before total occlusion using
to assess the morphologic integrity of myocardial cells and the
an 18 gauge needle and 1-O silk suture. A Carolina Medical
inflammatory
response.
Electronics electromagnetic
flow probe was placed around the
Statistical
methods:
All results are expressed as mean f
circumflex artery proximal to the subtotal occlusion to doc1 standard
deviation. Statistical
analysis was performed
by
ument a critical stenosis (defined as a stenosis causing at least
a computerized
statistical
program
of the University
of
a 50% reduction
in peak reactive hyperemic
flow after 10
Michigan Statistical
Research Laboratory
(Michigan Interseconds of coronary occlusion without altering basal flow or
active Data Analysis System). Two factor analysis of variance
sonomicrometer
crystal segment length). This subtotal critical
for repeated measures (profile analysis)i6 was employed for
stenosis was left in place throughout
the remainder
of the
the same variable measured more than twice, and paired or
experiment
(until the animals were killed at 72‘hours). zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
unpaired t test was performed
as appropriate
on data meaCoronary
occlusion
and reperf!sion:
Total left cirsured only twice. A probability
value (p) less than 0.05 was
cumflex occlusion was performed
using soft plastic tape for
considered
significant.
90 minutes and the occlusion was slowly released over 5 to 10
minutes. Intravenous
lidocaine, 3 mg/kg, was administered
Results zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXW
on reperfusion.
Reperfusion
occurred in all animals as docuRegional myocardial function during coronary
mented by 3 or more of the following criteria: (1) the onset of
artery occlusion: In anesthetized,
open-chest
dogs 90
ventricular
arrhythmias
within 15 to 30 minutes of occlusion
release; (2) a decrease in marginal and ischemic region endminute circumflex
coronary artery occlusion resulted
diastolic and end-systolic
segment length on release of the
in a marked alteration
of contractile
function
maniocclusion; (3) at least 5 ml/min of circumflex artery flow on
fested by greatly diminished
marginal
and ischemic
occlusion release documented
by electromagnetic
flow probe;
segment systolic shortening
and increased end-diastolic
and (4) the absence of visible coronary artery thrombosis
at
and end-systolic
segment lengths in all 3 regions, in72 hours when the animal was killed.
dicative
of ischemia-associated
ventricular
dilations
After reperfusion, the chest was closed and the animals
(Fig.
2,
Table
I).
Ibuprofen
administration
did
not dewere allowed to recouer. Intramuscular
ampicillin, 6 mg/kg,
crease these segment length increases or improve syswas administered
twice on the day of surgery and daily
tolic shortening
in any region during coronary artery
thereafter.
No recordings were obtained until 48 hours after
occlusion.
In the central
ischemic
zone, ibuprofensurgery because of frequent ventricular
arrhythmias.
At 48
and 72 hours, recordings of sonomicrometer
crystal segment
treated animals developed more severe impairment
of
October 1992
The American Journal of CARDIOLOGY
Volume 50
951
IBUPROFEN AND REGIONAL MYOCARDIAL FUNCTION-KIRLIN ET AL
I
Control,n=8-I2
QZJ Ibuprofen (37.5 mg/kg,IV), n=ll-I3 zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCB
T
T
FIGURE 2. Effect of ibuprofen on regional myocardial
function after 90 minute left circumflex coronary artery
occlusion. Marginal and ischemic zone percent systolic
shortening was reduced in both groups compared with
preocclusion (paired t test), and ibuprofen animals had
significantly worse systolic shortening than controls in
the ischemic zone at the end of the 90 minute occlusion
(unpaired t test)
”
Pre-Ocdusion SO minute
Occlusion
Pre-Occlusion SO minute
Occlusion
NORMAL ZONE
MARGINAL AREA
lp ( .Oi fOcctusm vs. Pre-&&S&I,
**PC 123 (tbuprofm g
poked t-test)
Controt, unpolred t-test)
systolic shortening
with paradoxic systolic expansion
(Table II, Fig. 4 to 6). In the conscious, unsedated
state
48 and 72 hours after occlusion with myocardial
reper(dyskinesia).
Heart rate was not altered by ibuprofen
fusion,
both marginal
and ischemic
zone systolic
during coronary occlusion; however, mean carotid artery
shortening were impaired despite partial recovery, while
pressure rose significantly
with a rise in pressure-rate
normal zone systolic function remained
relatively unproduct
(the product
of mean arterial
pressure
and
altered. Ibuprofen
treatment
did not improve systolic
heart rate divided by 100) (Table I). zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
function
or decrease ventricular
end-diastolic
or endRegional myocardial
function 48 and 72 hours
systolic segment lengths in normal, marginal, or ischeafter coronary artery occlusion-reperfusion:
Serial
mic regions at 48 hours or 72 hours before or after inochanges in regional myocardial
function
in a control
animal before, during, and up to 72 hours after coronary
tropic stimulation. zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPON
A significant reduction in the extent of ischemic
artery occlusion-reperfusion
are shown in Figure 3.
injury as measured
by percent of the area at risk inSimilar
baseline
regional
myocardial
function
was
farcted was noted in ibuprofen-treated
animals (44.6 f
present in ibuprofen-treated
and control animals in the
18%) compared
with control animals
(64.4 f 169’0, p
anesthetized,
open-chest state before coronary occlusion
TABLE
I
Effects
of Ibuprofen
During Coronary
Occlusion
Normal Zone
Heart Rate
(beats/min)
Baseline
90 minute
coronary
occlusion
Mean Arterial
Pressure (mm Hg)
Pressure-Rate
Product
Control
Ibuprofen
Control
Ibuprofen
Control
167
f25
171
*20
159
f17
174
fia
111
f14
106
f14
120
f20
137
f15’
la7
f46
178
*30
Ibuprofen
194
650
239
f44’
End-Diastolic
Length (mm)
Control
Ibuprofen
Control
12.6
f3.1
14.6
f4.0
14.7
f2.4
17.1
f3.0
9.7
f3.2
11.4
f3.9
Control
Baseline
90 minute
coronary
occlusion
15.0
f2.9
la.1
f2.a
Ibuprofen
13.9
f5 2
17.2
f6.0
End-Systolic
Length (mm)
% Systolic
Shortening
End-Diastolic
Length (mm)
October 1982
11.5
62.3
13.3
*3 1
Control
Ibuprofen
24.3
f9.7
23.0
f9.9
21.4
f9.2
22.5
410.0
End-Systolic
Length (mm)
% Systolic
Shortening
Control
Ibuprofen
Control
Ibuprofen
Control
Ibuprofen
Control
Ibuprofen
Control
Ibuprofen
12.5
43.0
17.8
f3.1
12.1
f5.3
16.8
f5.9
17.2
f6.3
1.7
f4.4
14.3
f9.7
2.1
f5.9
15.6
f4.6
la.4
15.4
17.1
f4.6
19.7
f5.2
13 6
442
la.1
f49
15.3
f4.6
20.0
f5.1
13.3
*4.2
1.3
f2.7
11.6
f5.5
-1.5
f2 37
* p <0.003; t p <0.03 (both unpaired t test).
Pressure rate product = mean arterial pressure X heart rate divided by 100. Values are mean f
852
Ibuprofen
% Systolic
Shortening
lschemic Zone
Marginal Zone
End-Diastolic
Length (mm)
End-Systolic
Length (mm)
The American Journal of CARDIOLOGY
Volume 50
1 standard deviation
IBUPROFEN AND REGIONAL MYOCARDIAL FUNCTION-KIRLIN
ET AL.
FKZURE 3. Serial changes in normal, marginal, and central ischemic segment length in a control animal before and at the end of 90 minute circumflex
occlusion and 48 and 72 hours after reperfusion, and with inotropic stimulation (intravenous prenalterol, 30 pg/kg) at 72 hours. Acute effects of
circumflex occlusion on regional myocardial function and evolutionary electrocardiographic
changes of infarction are demonstrated. BP = blood
pressure; EKG = lead It electrocardiogram; LCX = left circumflex coronary artery.
Es50
I
m
I
0
:!
contml, n=a
eiza lbu~ofea (37.5 mg/kg, IV), n =7
m
m
CentId, n=7
Ibuprofen(37.5 mg/kp, IV), n ~7
il*SD
tw40
8
8
T
T
zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
0
Rr-occkxim
Pro-Ocdudon
40 bra
72 hrr
72 bra with
klotmpii AQmt
FIGURE 5. Effect of ibuprofen on marginal area regional function (as
in Figure 4). No significant differences between groups were present
4ahrs zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
RhrS
72 hrs wifh
(analysis of variance for repeated measures).
lmtropic &ant
FIGURE 4. Effect of ibuprofen on normal zone regional myocardial
function before circumflex occlusion and in conscious, unsedated animals at 48 and 72 hours and with inotropic stimulation at 72 hours. No
significant differences were present between groups (analysis of
variance for repeated measures). IV = intravenous; SD = standard
deviation.
a
pg
control, n=4
Ibuprofen(37.5 mp/kg, IV), n= 4
‘O
vr
0
Pm-occ&
46 hrr
72 hn
72 hrs with
lnolmpicAgent
FIGURE 6. Effect of ibuprofen on central ischemic zone regional
function (as in Figure 4). No significant differences between groups were
present (analysis of variance for repeated measures).
FIGURE 7. Effect of ibuprofen on infarct size. No differences were
present between ibuprofen and control animals in left (L.) ventricular
weight or area at risk; ibuprofen significantly reduced infarct size expressed as percentage of area at risk (unpaired t test).
October 1982
The American
Journal of CARDIOLOGY
Volume 50
853
IBUPROFEN AND REGIONAL MYOCARDIAL
FUNCTION-KIRLIN
ET AL
cO.05, unpaired t test) despite a similar area at risk and
left ventricular
weight (Fig. 7). The percent of total left
ventricle
infarcted
was substantially
reduced by ibuprofen (19.7 f 9.1% versus 26.0 f 5.5% for controls), but
this did not reach significance
(p = 0.12, unpaired
t
test). By visual inspection
of stained ventricular
slices,
the predominant
area of tissue salvage in ibuprofentreated animals was at the epicardial
and lateral margins of the infarct. zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPO
Light microscopic analysis of hematoxylin and eosin
stained left ventricular slices revealed no evident differences in the extent of inflammatory
infiltrate
or
hemorrhage or in the appearance of necrotic myocardial
cells. The appearance
of contraction
band lesions and
of fibroblastic
proliferation
was comparable
in both
groups,
Visual inspection of the left circumflex coronary
artery after death demonstrated
no detectable
thrombus
in ibuprofen-treated
animals
and visible
thrombus
in 1 of 8 control animals. zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYX
Discussion
Rationale for this model: Coronary artery occlusion
with myocardial
reperfusion
through a critical stenosis
as employed in this model may more closely simulate
the evolution
of human
myocardial
infarction
than
permanent
coronary artery occlusion. DeWood et al.17
demonstrated
a progressive
decline in the prevalence
of total coronary occlusion over 24 hours in patients with
acute myocardial
infarction,
a finding consistent
with
coronary
artery spasm superimposed
on fixed obstructive disease’* or with partial resolution
of a coronary artery thrombosis,17
or both. In addition, experimental animal data indicate that reperfusion
may enhance survivallg
and improve the likelihood
of myocardial functional
recovery.20 Thus, a rationale
exists
for the coronary artery occlusion-reperfusion
model of
myocardial
infarction.
Possible mechanisms
of ibuprofen’s
myocardial
protective
effect: The present study demonstrates
a
myocardial
protective
effect of ibuprofen
during experimental
myocardial infarction without improvement
of normal, marginal,
or ischemic regional myocardial
function
during coronary artery occlusion or 48 or 72
hours after reperfusion
or of inotropic
reserve at 72
hours. The reduction
in infarct size noted with ibuprofen in this study is consistent
with previous investigations”-’ employing a variety of dosage schedules and
routes of administration.
While the mechanisms
of infarct size reduction
mediated
by ibuprofen
have not
been established,
several possibilities
have been evaluated.
First, it is unlikely that ibuprofen exerts a hemodynamic effect through diminished myocardial oxygen
consumption
or increased myocardial blood flow.
Jugdutt et al.fi and Romson et al? noted no significant
effect of ibuprofen
on blood pressure
or heart rate
during myocardial
ischemia, and the drug has only a
minimal effect on ventricular
contractile
force.4 In our
present study, continuous
ibuprofen infusion beginning
1 hour before ischemia resulted in significant elevations
of systemic arterial pressure (Table I) without an effect
854
October 1982
The American Journal of CARDIOLOGY
Volume 50
BUPROFEN
AND REGIONAL MYOCARDIAL
FUNCTION-KIRLIN
ET AL
tiDn,33,34
which may in part account for its anti-inon heart rate after 90 minutes of coronary occlusion.
flammatory effect.
This result, not found in previous investigations
The use of lidocaine in our study could also reduce the
employing different models of ischemia and different
severity of myocardial ischemic injury.35 Our data,
drug administration
schedules, would increase rather
however, indicate extensive infarction despite lidocaine
than decrease myocardial oxygen consumption and thus
administration
and an additional beneficial effect of
tend to worsen ischemic injury.21 In addition, directly
ibuprofen if lidocaine myocardial preservation
ocmeasured myocardial oxygen consumption is not altered
curred. zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHG
by ibuprofen administration
during 60 minutes of
Discordance
between infarct size reduction and
normothermic global ischemia in the isolated, bloodfunctional
recovery: The discrepancy between myoperfused feline heart.i5 zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
cardial infarct size and functional recovery in this inIncreased blood flow to ischemic tissue by direct
vestigation may be due to several factors. Improvement
coronary artery vasodilation or enhanced collateral
in regional myocardial function may occur at a time not
blood flow is also an unlikely mechanism of ibuprofen’s
evaluated in this study. A functionally beneficial effect
beneficial effect. Tracer microsphere studies in exof ibuprofen between the onset of reperfusion and 48
perimental myocardial infarction have failed to demhours cannot be excluded; in the present study a funconstrate increased blood flow to ischemic tissue up to
tional assessment was not performed during that time
6 hours6 or 24 hours15 after coronary occlusion in ibubecause of marked beat-to-beat segment length changes
profen-treated
experimental animals.
associated with frequent reperfusion arrhythmias. AlAn antithrombotic effect of ibuprofen is a 2nd posternatively, improvement in myocardial function with
sible mechanism by which ibuprofen may reduce inibuprofen could occur at a time later than 72 hours. This
farct size.7 In the present study, however, coronary
possibility is supported by sonomicrometer crystal data
artery reperfusion occurred in all animals and only 1 of
in conscious dogs studied up to 4 weeks after 2 hour
8 control animals developed visible thrombus at 72 hour
postmortem
examination. Also, the antithrombotic
coronary artery occlusion.20 Substantial recovery of
agent sulfinpyrazone does not appear to reduce infarct
marginal and ischemic segment systolic shortening occurred 1 to 4 weeks after coronary artery occlusionsize.22 Thus, it is improbable that an antithrombotic
effect of ibuprofen played a role in the present study.
reperfusion. Further studies will be necessary to deThe potentially related phenomenon of platelet depotermine whether ibuprofen treatment alters regional
sition at the site of ischemic injury also occurs in myomyocardial function more than 3 days after myocardial
cardial infarction and is diminished by aspirin.23 Ibuinfarction.
profen, however, does not alter indium-111-labeled
Improvement
in indexes of myocardial function
other than subendocardial segment length changes is
platelet accumulation in the ischemic myocardium.2”
A 3rd possible mechanism by which ibuprofen may
another possible explanation of the discordance beexert a myocardial protective effect is its antiinflamtween infarct size reduction and functional recovery in
matory action, related to inhibition of the arachidonic
this investigation. Roan et a1.36noted spontaneous imacid pathway.” Cyclooxygenase enzyme inhibition could
provement in ischemic zone ventricular wall paradoxic
have a beneficial effect in ischemic tissue through a
systolic thinning between 24 hours and 1 week after
reduction in the synthesis of thromboxane, a potent
coronary artery occlusion. Other measures of regional
vasoconstrictor. However, other nonsteroidal cyclooxfunction which were not evaluated in this study include
ygenase inhibitors do not reduce the extent of experimid-myocardial
and subepicardial
segment length
mental ischemic injury.zsJsJe
An alternative
hychanges, which may have been altered more than subpothesis also related to the arachidonic acid cascade
endocardial functional measurements in view of prewhich may in part explain ibuprofen’s beneficial effect
dominant subepicardial tissue salvage by gross inin myocardial ischemia is inhibition of the lipoxygenase
spection.
pathway. This branch of‘the arachidonic acid cascade
A persistent inability of ibuprofen to significantly
is capable of producing powerful chemotactic subimprove marginal or ischemic region myocardial
stances (hydroxyeicosatetraenoic
acid [HETE] derivfunction despite infarct size reduction as determined
atives)
and leukotrienes, which are additional mediby histochemical staining is also possible. Glucocortiators of the inflammatory response.27 Ibuprofen has
coids have been implicated in “mummification”
of
been shown to inhibit the synthesis of 12-HETE, cataischemic myocardium (loss of nuclei with intact myolyzed by a putative peroxidase enzyme.zs Lipoxygenase
fibril striations and sarcolemma).37 Such tissue may
pathway inhibition may in part account for ibuprofen’s
retain the ability to stain dehydrogenase with triphenability to inhibit the migration of polymorphonuclear
yltetrazolium despite the loss of functional integrity.
leukocytes,2g an effect noted with ibuprofen in experiThe absence of such a “mummification” effect on light
mental myocardial ischemia.24
microscopic evaluation in this investigation provides
A 4th mechanism of potential significance in exevidence against that possibility.
plaining ibuprofen’s myocardial protective action is
A recent publication by Kloner et a1.38demonstrated
inflammatory cell lysosomal membrane stabilization,
that a 15 minute period of coronary occlusion followed
an effect suggested by data from noncardiac in vitro
by reperfusion, which is not associated with the develpreparationsa0-:s2 and by indirect evidence in canine
opment of necrosis, nonetheless results in prolonged
cardiac ischemia.4 In addition, ibuprofen affects kinin
biochemical, functional, and ultrastructural
abnorand histamine release2 and superoxide radical formamalities. Wall motion, as determined by ultrasonic
October 1992
The American Journal of CARDIOLOGY
Volume 50
955
IBUPROFEN AND REGIONAL MYOCARDIAL
FUNCTION-KIRLIN
ET AL
crystal measurements,
was still reduced at 3 days of
reperfusion,
whereas creatine phosphate
levels and regional myocardial blood flow recovered rapidly and had
returned
to normal after 90 minutes
of coronary
reperfusion.
Brief periods
(15 minutes)
of regional
ischemia followed by full reperfusion,
therefore, can be
associated
with abnormalities
in cardiac contractile
function which persist for a relatively long period. Bush
et al.sg showed that the biochemical
abnormalities
associated with regional ischemia after reperfusion
also
extend to the normally perfused myocardium.
Thus, a
regional ischemic event may produce an influence on a
remote region of myocardium
which may persist for
several days after the restoration
of coronary
blood
flow.383
In the present investigation,
coronary artery occlusion
was maintained
for 90 minutes
and was followed by
reperfusion
in the presence of a critical stenosis. It is
conceivable
that the failure of the salvaged myocardial
segment to regain contractile
function could be related
to the relatively
persistent
derangement
in segment
length shortening
which is seen even in the absence of
cellular necrosis. Future attempts to assess the potential
benefits of pharmacologic
interventions
in protecting
ischemic myocardium
should consider the functional
recovery of the “salvaged”
myocardium
days to weeks
after the ischemic episode.
Implications: Intravenous
ibuprofen
infusion
reduces myocardial infarct size without improving normal,
marginal, or ischemic region myocardial function during
coronary artery occlusion or 48 or 72 hours after myocardial reperfusion,
or inotropic
reserve at 72 hours.
Further studies are necessary to assess ibuprofen’s effect
on regional myocardial
function
at intervals
greater
than 72 hours after myocardial infarction and to further
elucidate the mechanisms
by which ibuprofen
exerts a
protective
effect on ischemic myocardial
tissue.
Ac kno wle dg m e nt
We acknowledge the assistance of James Kipnis in performing surgical procedures and Dixie Thomas for the preparation of this manuscript. Upjohn Laboratories, Kalamazoo,
Michigan, kindly provided ibuprofen.
Re fe re nc e s
1. Gillespie TA, Sobel BE. A rationalefor therapy of acute myocardial infarction: limitation of infarct size. Adv Intern Med 1977;22:319-353.
Kantor, TG. Ibuprofen Ann Intern Med 1979;91:877-882.
:: Maclean D, Fishbeln MC, Blum RI, Braunwakf E, Maroko PR. Long-term
preservation of ischemic myocardium by ibuprofen after experimental
coronary artery occlusion (abstr). Am J Cardiol 1978;41:394.
4. Lefer Am, Polar&y EW. Beneficial effects of ibuprofen in acute myocardial
ischemia. Cardiology 1979;64:265-279
5. Rlbelro LGT, Yasuda T, Lowensteln E, Braunwafd E, Yaroko PR. Comparative effects of anatomic infarct size of verampamil, Ibuprofen, and
morphine-promethazine-chlorpromazine
combination (abstr). Am J Cardiol
1979;43:396.
6. Jugdutt BI, Hutchins GM, Bulkley BH, Becker LC. Salvage of ischemic
myocardium by ibuprofen during infarction in the conscious dog. Am J
Cardiol 1980;46:74-82.
7. Romson JL. Bush LR. Haack DW, Lucchesi BR. The beneficial effects of
oral ibuprofen on coronary artery.thrombosis and myocardial ischemia in
the conscious dog. J Pharmacol Exp Ther 1980;215:271-278.
a. Vane JR. Prostaglandins as mediators of acute rnflammation and pain. In
856
October 1982
The American
Journal
of CARDIOLOGY
Rainsford KD, Fort-Hutchrnson AW, eds Prostaglandins and Inflammation.
Easel: Birkhauser Verlag, 1979:113-l 18.
9. lherwx P, Franklln D, Ross J Jr, Kernper WS. Regional myocardial function
during acute coronary artery occlusron and Its modification by pharmacologrc agents rn the dog Circ Res 1974;35:896-908
10. Geary GG, Smith GT, McNamara JJ. Defining the anatomic perfusion bed
on an occluded coronarv arterv and the reoion
., at risk to Infarctron Am J
Cardiol 1981;47.1240-i247
’
11. Borer J’S, Harrison LA, Kent KM, Levy R, Goldstein RE, Epstein SE. Benefrcral effect of lidocaine on ventricular electrical stability and spontaneous
ventricular fibrillation durrno exoerimental mvocardial infarction Am J
Cardiol 1976;37:860-863.
12. Kerber RE, Martins JB, Gascho JA, Marcus ML, Grayzel J. Effect of direct-current countershocks on regional myocardial contractility and perfusion Circulation 1981,63:323-332
13. Franklin D, Kernper WS, Patrick T, McKown. D. Technique for continuous
measurement of regional myocardial segment dimensions in chronic animal
preparations (abstr) Fed Proc 1973;32:343
14. Kirlin PC, Pitt B, Lucchesi BR. Comparative effects of prenalterol and
dobutamine In a canine model of acute.ischemrc heart failure. J Cardiovasc
Pharmacol 1981.3:896-905
15. Romson JL, Bush LR,, Jolly SR, Lucchesi BR. The cardioprotectrve effects
of ibuprofen rn experrmental, regional and global myocardial ischemia J
Cardrovasc Pharmacol 1982;4:187-196.
16. Morrison DF. Multtvanate Statistical Methods. New York: McGraw-Hill,
1976:153-160.
205-216
17. DeWood MA, Spores J, Notske R, et al. Prevalence of total coronary occlusion during the early hours of transmural myocardial Infarction. N Engl
J Med 1980,303,897-902
18. Oliva PB, Breckenridge JC. Arteriographrc evrdence of coronary arterial
spasm in acute myocardral Infarction. Circulation 1977;56:366-374
19. Baughman KL, Maroko PR, Vatner SF. Effects of coronary artery reperfusion on myocardial Infarct size and survrval rn conscious dogs. Circulation
1981;63.317-323
20. Theroux P, Ross J Jr, Franklin D, KemPer WS, Sasyama S. Coronary arterial reperfusion Ill Early and late effects in regional myocardial function
and dimensrons in conscious doos. Am J Cardiol 1976:38:599-606
21. Maroko PR. Braunwald E. Effecis of metabolic and pharmacoloaic interventions on myocardial infarct size following coronary occlusion. Ctculation
197653 Suool 1:1-162-l-168
22. Bolli R, Gokfstein RE,Davenport N, Epstein SE. Influence of sulfinpyrazone
and naproxen on Infarct size in the dog. Am J Cardiol 1981,47:841-847.
23. Ruf W, Leinburger H, McNamara J. Influence of aspirin on platelet trapping
m myocardial infarctron rn baboons (abstr). Am J Cardiol 1978:41:407.
24. Romson J. Hook B. Riaot V, Swanson D. Lucchesi B. Effect of ibuprofen
on the accumulation of 111’” leukocytes and platelets In Infarcted dog
mvocardium (abstrl Fed Proc 1982:41:1766.
25. B&row RO, Lipson LC, Sheehan FH, et al. Lack of effect of asprrrn on
myocardial infarct size in the dog. Am J Cardiol 1981;47:258-264
26. Jugdutt BI, Hutchins GM, Bulkley BH, Pitt B, Becker LC. Effect of indomethacrn on collateral blood flow and infarct size in the conscious doa
Crrculation 1979;59:734-743
27. Kuehl FA, Egan RW. Prostaglandins. arachidonrc acrd and inflammation
Science 1980:210:978-984.
28. Siegel MI, McConnell RT, Porter NA, Selph JL, Truax JF, Vinegar R, Cuatrecasas P. Aspirin-like drugs inhibit arachidonic acid metabolism via Iipoxygenase and cyclooxygenase rn rat neutrophils from carrageenan pleural
exudates. Biochem Brophys Res Commun 1980;92:688-695
29. Brown KA, Collins AJ. Action of nonsteroidal, antiinflammatory drugs on
human and rat peripheral leukocyte migration in vitro. Ann Rheum Dis
1977;36:239-243
30. Araki H, Lefer AM. Lysosomal stabilizing effects of two non-steroidal
antiinflammatory agents in the hypoxic liver. Naunyn Schmiedebergs Arch
Pharmacol 1980.311 79-84
31. Nakanidri M, GotoK. Inhibitory effects of antrtnflammatory drugs on enzyme
release from rabbit polymorphonuclear
leukocyte lysosomes. Biochem
Pharmacol 1975,24:421-424.
32. Smlfh RJ, Sabin C, Gilchresf H, Willlams S. Effect of antsnflammatory drugs
on lysosomes and lysosomal enzymes from rat liver. Biochem Pharmacol
1976.25:2171-2177
33. Simchowitz L, Mehta J, Spilberg I. Chemotactic factor-Induced generation
of superoxide radrcals by human neutrophils. Effect of metabolic inhibitors
and antrinflammatorv druos. Arthritis Rheum 1979:22:755-783.
anion production in non-stimulated
34. Ovanaaui Y. lnhibrtibn o/suoeroxide
guIneapig perttoneal exudate cells by anti-inflammatory drugs. Biochem
Pharmacol 1978.27:777-782.
35. Nasser FN, Waiis JT, Edwards WD, Harrison CE. Lidocaine-induced reduction in size of expenmental myocardial infarction Am J Cardiol 1980;
46 967-975
36. Roan P. Scales F. Saffer S. Buia LM. Willerson J. Functional characterlzation of left ventricular segmental responses during the initial 24 hr and
1 wk after expenmental canine myocardial infarction. J Clan Invest 1979;
641074-1088
37. Kloner RA, Fishbein MC, Lew H, Maroko P, Braunwald E. Mummificatron
of the infarcted myocardrum by high dose corticosteroids.
Circulation
1978;57 56-63
38. Kloner RA, DeBoer LWV, Darsee JR, lngwall JS, Hall S, Tumas J,
Braunwald E. Prolonged abnormal$es of myocardium salvaged by reperfusion. Am J Physrol 1981;241:H591-599.
39. Bush LR. Shlafer M. Haack DW. Lucchesi BR. Timedeoendent chanaes
rn canine cardrac mbochondrial function and ultrastructure resulting from
coronary occlusron and reperfusion
Basic Res Cardiol 1980:75:555571
zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGF
zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJ
Volume 50