Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                

18thGA ICOMOS2014 nelsonbrito PPT

2014

“Upgrade opportunities for buildings in city centers” (ongoing Ph.D. thesis) Learning from Traditional Knowledge towards engaged inhabiting Assumptions • Well designed and built ancient buildings were able to guarantee comfort; • Culture instilled good practices; • Most of ancient buildings related discomfort comes from improper use; Modern day limitations • Few can stay home to learn and use well their homes; • Energy is becoming a major issue; A "hard science" approach proves that: •New tools help for new findings, and new strategies; •Ancient buildings can be very efficient, •They are worth being more investigated and worked on. Nelson BRITOa,b,c, Manuel GAMEIRO DA SILVAa, Gonçalo BRITESa, Rute CASTELAc, Paula FONSECAb but... (a) ADAI, LAETA, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, University of Coimbra (b) ISR, Instituto de Sistemas e Robótica, Coimbra, (c) modular, arq:i+d, lda Travessa de Montarroio, 2, 3000-288 Coimbra, Portugal. Tel. (+351) 917600000, info@modular.pt • users and stakeholders are not convinced; • technicians prefer to build new, without “limitations”; • legislation is to heavy, and interpretations troublesome; • there is no money to do it right, they say. Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 Presentation structure: Energy Efficiency: an opportunity? Energy Efficiency (EE): an opportunity? Energy Security & Climate Change Towards Energy Efficacy – New buildings: Reactivating Traditional Knowledge – Ancient buildings: 2 • Main focus, most of money; • Dictate rules / solutions; • Biggest: – built area & – energy consumption; Living legacy: involving others • RED EPBD certificates Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 3 4 IEA EBC Annex 56 Energy Efficiency: an opportunity? High cost Energy Security and Climate Change require actions Low cost Cost Effective Energy and Carbon Emissions Optimization Negative in Building Renovation cost Operating Agent: Manuela AlmeidaUniversidade do Minho (Initial idea from Andreas Eckmanns) • Buildings represent 40% of the energy consumption in Europe • Ancient buildings are the large majority Ocupants & stakeholders Minimize needs City center ancient buildings have triple savings potential: • In knowledge: built before fossil fuels; • In centrality: less transportation consumption; • Well placed demonstrators of good practices. Energy conservation Reduce Energy/Carbon Energy efficiency & Renewables nZEB: nearly Zero Energy Buildings Produce beyond needs “+” Energy Buildings Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 5 Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 6 Opportunity Opportunity for maintenance? “The impact of small actions on the majority of the existing buildings would far outweigh their potential efficiency and viability for a fraction of the cost” 1845 20% EXISTING buildings: potential savings with 20% reduction (easy and low cost) 2014 40% 60% 80% New “nZEB” buildings potential savings 100% 1 Variação estimada do consumo dos edifícios por épocas de construção, com indicação da área construída acumulada (in IEA ECBCS Annex 56) Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 7 Scale & rehabilitation strategies 8 Funding for (more) new 3.000.000€ Service buildings: “Buildings don’t use energy, people do” Janda (huge consumptions, investment and decision capacity, easy ROI: Return of investment) • Detailed depiction, integrated interventions One SERVICE with: • Multidisciplinary teams pushing together • Responsibility from engaged parties: viability, scheduled maintenance and optimization, … 20.000€ Residencial buildings: (small consumptions, no investment / decision capacity, context costs make ROI difficult) • Generic depictions, many teams of “specialists” pulling their own direction Too many PRODUCTS • “Average” user approach, which is none of us • Incapacity to guarantee real savings: “one size fits all” • Energy Performance Certificates (EPCs) ≠ efficacy and economic viability Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 9 10 In short: Towards Energy Efficacy Rehabilitation legislation and rules: • Most legislation, efforts/money for new buildings • old buildings will never comply with these inadequate rules Thanks to you, many historic buildings are exempted “Montarroio” case study: – Assess, depict, upgrade and optimize • Tagged as: • energy hogs, “cast-away”, a burden for society Is it really good to be left out? • How can you be proud of your old home nowadays? Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 11 Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 12 Tape measurement Towards Energy Efficacy: “Montarroio” case study – In the city center of Coimbra, Portugal, in the protection areas of “Jardim da Manga”, nacional monumento and UNESCO; • Built and changed throughout centuries; Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 13 Laser scan &photogrammetry Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 14 Video(photo)grammetry? – Images from a flying drone (AR-drone with iPhone 4S) Special thanks to Luis Mateus and project ReabOp, FCT (PTDC/ATP-AQI/5355/2012) Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 15 BIM: 3D, 4D & 5D representation Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 Termography (infra-red imaging) ±08:30h Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 16 17 ±14:30h ±18:30h Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 18 “Online” measurements (2011-05-13) “Online” measurements (2013-07-09) – WSBP Janus System CO2 reading: I went there at 07.00h 30ºC Exterior temperature 15ºC Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 19 Summer human failure (2013-07-09) Open shutters, closed windows = “greenhouse effect” Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 20 Dynamic simulation 30ºC Exterior temperature 15ºC Passive, bioclimatic, green, …, architecture? Yes: If adequate to the users lifestyle; No: If no one is home to activate gadgets; if it is not “fail-safe” Otherwise? ICT (Information and Communication Technologies) assistance Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 21 Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 22 Reactivating Traditional Knowledge Problems Existing buildings rehabilitation Neighborhood scale detailed depictions? • measurable cost-effective energy-saving retrofit and upgrade interventions require information that is still too hard to retrieve and compile; Better starting points? Energy consumption reduction in buildings Mass-customization? • Efficient equipments ≠ efficient energy use; • Efficacy—“the power to produce an effect”1— will only be attained when information is available with an acceptable cost, quality and consistency Intensive local workforce instead of imports? Efficacy (Merriam-Webster, 2014) “Izidoro” Chart, 1845. Montarroio is Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 23 depicted in the center Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917of 600the 000 circle 24 Solutions Studied options for Montarroio Neighborhood scale detailed depictions? • Professional grade service, lower costs • Reduced context costs, improved intervention • Multidisciplinary teams • Research centers can optimize resources • In line with: • funding mechanisms like “Jessica” • community driven conservation, … One detailed model for 600€? • Stimulate “mass-customization” • Create the need for more knowledge Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 25 Studied options: thermal analysis 26 No expert needed: Something bad will happen in Option B due to internal insulation Option A Option B Option C Option D Option A: no insulation Option E Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 International Energy Agency IEA EBC Annex56 Option B: internal insulation Option C THERM, depiction of thermal behavior of the five options (special thanks to Eng. Marlene Melo) Figure 9: THERM, depiction of thermal behavior of the five options (special thanks to Eng. Marlene Melo) 27 Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 International Energy Agency IEA EBC Annex56 28 International Energy Agency IEA EBC Annex56 Reactivating Traditional Knowledge Integrate the knowledge of yesterday and today • present and future needs and expectations • ICT towards mass customized solutions Promote sustainability • Local sources/ materials/ energy • Quality of Life (IEQ; IAQ, …) • New/old “arts and crafts”: local labor Inform and Empower users and stakeholders • Develop and make simple: • Life Cycle Costs (LCC) , Life Cycle Assessment (LCA), … • Value patrimony and collective pride Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 Needed twist: from degraded area… Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 32 …to a place for architecture, again? 33 Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 34 Living legacy Multiply case studies: A 3D print: model or symbol? – Collective strength; – Good practice guides; – Demonstrate EFFICACY A box, left outside, inviting to: • look in a different perspective: – “normal” people don´t understand “plans” and “cuts” language Funding • use ICT for more information: QR code, NFC – H2020 Energy Efficiency; – UrbAct – Other local sources Touch, feel, ask. Peer review: you ALL • questions, opinions, contacts, invitations, … Special thanks to Tiago Fróis and Oficinas do Convento, UNESCO Center, Montemor-o-Novo, PT Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 35 Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 36 Milestones In what are we better than others? Multiply the number of case studies We value: – buildings and people as teams; – multidisciplinary approaches; – immaterial (tasty) things like Mediterranean Diet • Promote a wide network of partners • Research Centers, Universities, private, … Support neighborhood/zone-based approaches • (Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity) • In line wide funding, in line with people Energy effective mass- customization How does this connect with buildings? • A good excuse for maintenance and improvements • Make it easy and appealing through ICT: mobile phones! – Example: • An oven cooking inputs about 3kWh of heat A movement towards engaged inhabiting – (2 or 3 electric resistance heaters), cosy in winter but bad idea in summer • Re-learn how to use your house; • what you cook affects your comfort (Winter food: roast = heat) Cooking habits used to be related with seasons • Work is needed to demonstrate impacts Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 37 With whom? Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 38 With what? Investigation Centers Horizon 2020 funds for energy efficiency – Energy use, Efficacy and Optimization – Virtual models depiction; – Interface with all stakeholders » ancient buildings have the most potential for lower cost. Governmental Institutions – Support to the energy efficiency and to the economy – Promoting scale (neighbourhood, city, etc) approaches Business and suppliers – Optimize efficiency to reach efficacy – Reduce context costs EeB-05-2015: Innovative design tools for refurbishing of buildings at district level EeB-06-2015: Integrated solutions of thermal energy storage for building applications EeB-07-2015: New tools and methodologies to reduce the gap between predicted and actual energy performances at the level of buildings and blocks of buildings EeB-08-2015: Integrated approach to retrofitting of residential buildings Technicians – Informed knowledge with low cost price Users and owners – Effective savings / improvement = trust Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 39 Actions, instead of complaints: Help needed: Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 40 Acknowledgments (please feel free to contact!) • This thesis is developed within the University of Coimbra/MIT Portugal Energy for Sustainability Initiative funded by the Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia Ph.D. grant SFRH/BD/51017/2010 and possible with the engaged commitment of stakeholders from • To peer-review prototype beyond (my/others) personal taste; • For help on similar projects all over the world; • To develop a network of “demonstration projects”. – WSBP, lda (www.wsbp.eu), – ADAI – modular, arq:i+d, lda, – IGESPAR, – Câmara Municipal de Coimbra, to name a few. Steal, copy or contribute with ideas for H2020 funding! •Approved applications and visible results help us all! •Open calls for Energy Efficiency: Horizon 2020: Feb 2015 •New regulations need new scientific support •Efficacy (and Quality of Life) are essential for Europe 2020 goals We must scientifically demonstrate the obvious. •Proposal: an ICOMOS task-force for nZEB ancient buildings? Universidade de Coimbra, ADAI/LAETA & modular, arq:i+d, lda nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , tlm. +351 917 600 000 41 University of Coimbra, ADAI-LAETA / modular, arq:i+d, lda Presented by nelson silva brito, info@modular.pt , +351 917 600 000 42 Learning from Traditional Knowledge towards engaged inhabiting Nelson BRITOa,b,c, Manuel GAMEIRO DA SILVAa, Gonçalo BRITESa, Rute CASTELAc, Paula FONSECAb (a) ADAI, LAETA, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, University of Coimbra (b) ISR, Instituto de Sistemas e Robótica, Coimbra, (c) modular, arq:i+d, lda Travessa de Montarroio, 2, 3000-288 Coimbra, Portugal. Tel. (+351) 917600000, info@modular.pt