. 2017. № 1 (36) , *, А.А. . . *, А. . * *, . . . ** ( ) , 199034, E-mail: ucha.89@mail.ru; kazarnitski@mail.ru; a.v.gromov@mail.ru ., 3, ** ., 2, А , 190000, E-mail: lazaretov@yandex.ru Ы А : , Ч , 1 . - . , - . . . , , . К ч а. а: ха а а, а , М а а, а а а DOI: 10.20874/2071-0437-2017-36-1-078-087 - - . . . . . , [1931]. , - , , [ , , 1948]. , . 126]. [ . . [1961, . 251]. , . . [ , [1973, 1975] ], . . . , - . , , . . [1977]. - , . . . . , . , . . . . , — , 1 № 16-31-01050. 78 . . . . . , - … , . , , - . , - , , , , [ , 1977, . 44]. , . - , . . [1977, . 67]. , - , . , . « », , [ , , 2007], - , . . , « . . [2011], ». « » - ( ), . . . [ , , 2006], . . . . . [ , 2004, 2009; , , 2009]. , . [ ., 2012, , , 2013]. , , , . , . , , . . : 1) ; 4) ; 9) ( I; 5) ; 10) ). - I; 6) ; 11) I; 7) ; 12) - I; 2) IX [ [ I, IV; 3) , 1977]; 8) , 1961], 13) - : 14) , , II ( ). : 15) I, VI, VII; 16) 17) I; 18) II; 19) III [ , 1977]; 20) ; 21) 1961]; 22) ; 23) ; 24) 72 ; 25) I, III ( ). : 26) I; 27) III ( 28) III [ , , 2009]. : 29) VI; 30) ; 31) [ ., 2012]. [ , 1977], - - , [ III; , ); II - : 32) : 34) : 35) 2[ , 33) 1, 2; 36) , 2013]. 79 : [ , 1973]. ( ) [Čikiševa, 2010]. 1, 2; 37) 1–3; 38) - , А.А. . . , А. . : 39) . ; 44) . 46) . , -1, , . ; 43) , 2012]; 45) [ , 2003]. : 47) : -3 , [ -1, 2; 55) ; 59) -1, -2, 61) , 2000]. ). 2[ 2014]; 70) - - [ , ( , 2004]; , ( ); 50) , - -1, ( 1, 3; 52) : 51) ; 53) -2, ; 41) , 2012]. : 48) ); 49) -1 ); : 54) . . ; 40) ; 42) [ , , -3 -1, 3; 56) -1, 2; 57) -1, 2; 60) , , -4 ; -2, 3, 4; 58) -1; ; 62) - -1 [ ( ): 63) ( , 2012]; 68) — - 2; 64) ): 66) 1, 2 [ [ , 2012]; 65) [ , ., 2015]; 69) ., 1987]. [ , 2001]. : 72) : 71) , 74) - [ ( ( , 2011]; 67) 1[ , , 73) ); 75) , 77) ( ); 76) , , 1972]; 78) — ; 79) — [Han Kanxin, 1995]; 80) ( )[ ., 2015]; 81) ; 82) ( ); 83) ; 84) [ , , 1972]. : 85) , VII–IV . . .[ , 2000]; 86) [ , , 1972]. : 87) ; 88) ; 89) ; 90) ; 91) [ , 2000]. : 92) ; 93) ; 94) ; 95) [ , 2000]. : 96) III–I . . .; 97) I . . . — II . . . [ , 2011]. : 98) VI–IV . . .; 99) IV–III . . .; 100) III–I . . .[ , 2014]. : 101) [ , 2015]. ( ) 15 ( , , , , , , ( ) , , , ). . — Statistica 12.0. . . 14 , , , . [ . ( 80 - … — ), . . . , . 1 , 19,5 % , II (13 % . . , ) - . 1 ( ) , — , ( )2. , . , - , - . ( .). : . 1. : — — ; ( ); — ; — ( — ; ). , , [ , 2016]. , 2 . 81 , А.А. . . ( n 114 114 102 119 99 110 114 114 110 114 114 103 112 112 93 mf. X 184,9 140,5 135,6 98,8 137,0 71,0 51,5 24,7 43,6 32,7 139,5 127,9 8,4 4,7 30,8 , А. . . ), , . . .2 41,6 % n 22 19 13 22 12 20 21 21 21 21 19 18 19 19 16 X 185,7 137,1 138,0 97,2 135,8 69,3 51,0 25,9 43,7 32,3 141,5 128,3 9,3 5,2 30,9 n 174 151 131 176 127 156 160 161 149 161 154 140 148 148 128 X 186,8 139,3 133,9 97,9 136,5 71,4 51,2 25,1 43,2 32,6 139,7 129,3 8,6 4,5 30,1 n 46 38 42 60 31 55 59 50 52 56 42 45 52 52 34 . X 183,4 146,0 133,0 98,9 138,1 74,5 52,6 25,3 43,5 33,1 141,9 129,1 7,9 4,3 28,0 n 45 43 32 51 37 45 47 47 46 48 49 44 48 48 38 X 187,1 140,3 132,4 98,4 135,4 72,5 52,2 24,9 43,0 33,0 139,0 127,6 8,9 4,4 28,3 . 2. ( . . 1). 1 , 2— . — 1 — , , , - , . , . - . 2, — . I, I . 82 … , , , - . , , . « — - », . 3. . 3. , : ; ; — — — — — ; ( ; ; — : — — ); — ; ; - ; ; ; - — — — - ( — — ; — ; , ); ; ; , — — . (31 % - ), . — - , ; I. - , . . [1974, . 37], . (15 % , ) , , II . , 83 - , А.А. . . , А. . , . . , : ( , , ); - - ( ); - , . - ; , , , . , - , , - , . , , , . - . , , . , I, - . — , - - , . , , , ,— , - , . , , . . , ( , . « ») , . , : ). I . . ., 1973. . 220–232. . . ., 1975. . 109–119. . ., . ., . . . . , 2000. 354 . . . . .: , 2000. 133 . . . IX . / : , 2011. 160 . . ., . ., . ., . . : . . . . ., . . . ., 1961. . 238–327. ( // . . . . 84 ; . 20). // // : - , 1987. . 208–241. : . : . . — IV . . .: ( . . , 2015. 188 . . .: , 1972. 271 . - … . ., // . . // . .: . . 2009. № 3 (7). . 143–147. . ., . .: . : ; . XLIX). , 2004. . 204–207. ( . ., // - . // : . ., : ( III: , 2009. № 1. . 136–145. . . , . . . . , 2012. . 1. . 117–122. - . . ) // , 2013. . 32–38. . . .: , 2015. . 379–388. .: 2012 . .: . ., . ., I II ( ) // 2014 . .: . . // . . 1931. . 5–6. . 195–209. . . // . . . .; ., 1948. . IV. 391 . . . // . , 1973. . 7. . 190–225. . ., . . // . 2015. № 14 (369). . . 64. . 16–28. . ., . . . : . . . . . , 2014. 352 . . . . .: , 1977. 144 . . . // .: 2015 . .: , 2016. . 381–390. . ., . . : // .: 2010 . .: , 2011. . 217–222. . . : . ., 2011. 456 . . . // . ., 2007. . 14. . 93–105. . . // . .: , 2006. . 66–75. . . ( . : , 2013. 284 . . . (VIII–VI . . .) // . . , 2001. № 7. . 67–82. . . // . . , . . , . . . . . II: . II. : , 2003. . 137–169. . ., . . // . : . , 2004. № 12. . 32–49. . . // . IV (XX) . . . : , 2014. . IV. . 413–416 Ч . . — . , 2012. 468 . Ćikiševa T.A. Die paläoantropologischen Materialien // K. Čugunov, H. Parzinger, A. Nagler. Der skythenzeitliche Furstenkurgan Arzan 2 in Tuva. Mainz: Verlag Philipp von Zabern, 2010. (Archaologie in Eurasien; Bd. 26). Han Kanxin. Studying the Paleoanthropological Materials From Barrows in Zhaos. Studying Racial Anthropology of the Ancient Population of the Silk Way. Urumqi, Xingjiang zhemin, 1995. . 261–304. (in Chinese). 85 . . , А.А. , А. . , . . Eu.N. Uchaneva*, A.A. Kazarnitsky*, A.V. Gromov*, N.I. Lazaretova** *Peter the Great’s Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography, Russian Academy of Sciences University Emb., 3, St. Petersburg, 199034, Russian Federation E-mail: ucha.89@mail.ru; kazarnitski@mail.ru; a.v.gromov@mail.ru **The State Hermitage Museum Dvortsovaya Emb., 34, St. Petersburg, 190000, Russian Federation E-mail: lazaretov@yandex.ru THE EARLY IRON AGE POPULATIONS OF THE MINUSINSK HOLLOW: REVISITING INTER- AND INTRAGROUP VARIATIONS By means of multivariate statistics, we analyzed male craniological series of the Early Iron Age from Western and Southern Siberia, Central Asia and Eastern Europe. The intra-group analysis of the series from the Minusinsk Hollow reveals specificity of individuals from the tombs of the Tesinsk culture, in comparison with other groups. At the same time, the population which left Tesinsk burials is obviously related to the Tagar culture. The analysis of the Tagar series reveals a strong differentiation of individuals from the burials between the Podgornovo and the Saragash periods. The results of the intra-group analyses are confirmed by a broad-scale inter-group analysis of the Eurasian Iron Age series. The Tagar series show clear craniometrical specificity which includes rather small cranial and face breadth, not very broad orbits, small naso-malar and zigomaxillary angles, long cranium and protruding nasal bones. Key words: Early Iron Age, craniological data, the Minusinsk Hollow, the Tagar culture. DOI: 10.20874/2071-0437-2017-36-1-078-087 REFERENCES Alekseev V.P., 1961. Paleoantropologiia Khakasii epokhi zheleza [The Iron Age paleoanthropology of Khakassia]. Sbornik MAE, vol. 20, pp. 238–327. Alekseev V.P., 1973. K proiskhozhdeniiu tashtykskogo naseleniia Iuzhnoi Sibiri [The origins of the Tashtyk population in Southern Siberia]. Problemy arkheologii Urala i Sibiri, Moscow, pp. 220–232. Alekseev V.P., 1975. Antropologicheskie dannye o lokal'nykh razlichiiakh naseleniia tagarskoi kul'tury [Anthropological data on local differences of the population of the Tagar culture]. Pervobytnaia arkheologiia Sibiri, Leningrad, pp. 109–119. Alekseev V.P., Gokhman I.I., Tumen D., 1987. Kratkii ocherk paleoantropologii Tsentral'noi Azii [A brief essay of paleoanthropology of Central Asia]. Arkheologiia, etnografiia i antropologiia Mongolii, Novosibirsk: Nauka, pp. 208–241. Bagashev A.N., 2000. Paleoantropologiia Zapadnoi Sibiri: Lesostep' v epokhu rannego zheleza [Paleoanthropology of West Siberia: The forest-steppe zone in the Early Iron Age], Novosibirsk: Nauka, 354 p. Balabanova M.A., 2000. Antropologiia drevnego naseleniia Iuzhnogo Priural'ia i Nizhnego Povolzh'ia: Rannii zheleznyi vek [Anthropology of ancient population of the Southern Urals and the Lower Volga Region: The Early Iron Age], Moscow: Nauka, 133 p. Batieva E.F., 2011. Naselenie Nizhnego Dona v IX v. do n.e. — IV v. n.e.: ( aleoantropologicheskoe issledovanie) [Population of the Lower Don in the IX-IV century B.C.: ( paleoanthropological research)], Rostov-naDonu: Izd-vo IuNTs RAN, 160 p. Beisenov A.Z., Ismagulova A.O., Kitov E.P., Kitova A.O., 2015. Naselenie Tsentral'nogo Kazakhstana v I tysiacheletii do n.e. [Population of Central Kazakhstan in the I millennium BC], Almaty: IA im. A.Kh. Margulana, 188 p. Chikisheva T.A., 2010. Die paläoantropologischen Materialien. K. Cugunov, H. Parzinger, A. Nagler. Der skythenzeitliche Furstenkurgan Arzan 2 in Tuva, Mainz: Verlag Philipp von Zabern. (Archaologie in Eurasien; Bd. 26). Chikisheva T.A., 2012. Dinamika antropologicheskoi differentsiatsii naseleniia iuga Zapadnoi Sibiri v epokhi neolita — rannego zheleza [Dynamics of anthropological differentiation of the population of Southern Western Siberia in the Neolithic — the Early Iron Age], Novosibirsk, 468 p. Debets G.F., 1931. Eshche raz o belokuroi rase v Tsentral'noi Azii [Once again about the blond race in Central Asia]. Sov. Aziia, 5–6, pp. 195–209. Debets G.F., 1948. Paleoantropologiya SSSR [Paleoanthropology of the USSR]. Trudy I AN SSSR, vol. 4, 392 p. Dremov V.A., 1973. Antropologicheskie materialy iz tagarskikh kurganov Kemerovskoi oblasti [Anthropological materials from the Tagar burials grounds in Kemerovo Region]. Iz istorii Sibiri, 7, Tomsk, pp. 190–225. Ginzburg V.V., Trofimova E.A., 1972. Paleoantropologiia Srednei Azii [Paleoanthropology of Central Asia], Moscow: Nauka, 271 p. Gokhman I.I., Gromov A.V., 2009. Tesinskii gruntovyi mogil'nik Kamenka III: Dannye kraniometrii i kranioskopii [The Tesinsk Burial Ground of Kamenka III: craniometric and cranioscopic data]. Arkheologiia, antropologiia i etnografiia Evrazii, no. 1, Novosibirsk, pp. 136–145. Gromov A.V., 2004. Paleoantropologiia tesinskogo naseleniia iuga Khakasii po materialam iz gruntovykh mogil'nikov [Paleoanthropology of the population of the Tesinsk culture in the South of Khakassia, basing on the 86 … materials from burial grounds]. Muzeinye kollektsii i nauchnye issledovaniia: aterialy godichnoi nauchnoi sessii MAE RAN, St. Petersburg: Izd-vo MAE RAN, pp. 204-207. (Sbornik MAE; vol. XLIX). Gromov A.V., 2009. K antropologii tesinskogo naseleniia Minusinskoi kotloviny [The anthropology of the population of the Tesinsk culture in the Minusinsk Hollow]. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, Istoriia, no. 3 (7), Tomsk, pp. 143–147. Gromov A.V., Lazaretova N.I., Uchaneva E.N., 2012. Naselenie Minusinskoi kotloviny na rubezhe nashei ery po materialam iz sklepov [Population of the Minusinsk Hollow at the turn of the Common Era, basing on the materials from tombs]. Kul'tury stepnoi Evrazii i ikh vzaimodeistvie s drevnimi tsivilizatsiiami, Kn. 1, St. Petersburg: IIMK RAN: Periferiia, pp. 117–122. Gromov A.V., Uchaneva E.N., 2013. Rannetesinskoe naselenie Minusinskoi kotloviny po dannym kraniologii: ( pyt sopostavleniia dvukh sistem priznakov) [The population of the Early Tesinks culture of the Minusinsk Hollow, basing on craniological data: omparison of two methods]. Radlovskii sbornik: Nauchnye issledovaniia i muzeinye proekty MAE RAN v 2012 godu, St. Petersburg: MAE RAN, pp. 32–38. Gromov A.V., Selezneva V.I., Uchaneva E.N., 2015. Antropologicheskie materialy iz mogil'nikov Suglug-Khem I i Suglug-Khem II (Tsentral'naia Tuva) [Anthropological data from the burial grounds of Suglug-Khem I and II (Central Tuva)]. Radlovskii sbornik: Nauchnye issledovaniia i muzeinye proekty MAE RAN v 2014 godu, St. Petersburg: Izd-vo MAE RAN, pp. 379–388. Han Kanxin, 1995. Studying the Paleoanthropological Materials From Barrows in Zhaos. Studying Racial Anthropology of the Ancient Population of the Silk Way, Urumqi, Xingjiang zhemin, pp. 261–304. (in Chinese). Kitov E.P., Beisenov A.Z., 2015. Pervye kraniologicheskie dannye pamiatnikov korgantasskogo tipa Tseentral'nogo Kazakhstana [The first craniological data from the Korgantas-type burials in Central Kazakhstan]. Vestnik Cheliabinskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, no. 14 (369), Istoriia, 64, pp. 16–28. Kitov E.P., Mamedov A.M., 2014. Kochevoe naselenie Zapadnogo Kazakhstana v rannem zheleznom veke [The nomadic population of Western Kazakhstan in the Early Iron Age], Astana: Izdatel'skaia gruppa FIA im. A.Kh. Margulana v g. Astana, 352 p. Kozintsev A.G., 1977. Antropologicheskii sostav i proiskhozhdenie naseleniia tagarskoi kul'tury [Anthropological affinities and origin of the Tagar population], Leningrad: Nauka, 144 p. Kozintsev A.G., 2016. O nekotorykh aspektakh statisticheskogo analiza v kraniometrii [Some aspects of the statistical analysis in craniometry]. Radlovskii sbornik: Nauchnye issledovaniia i muzeinye proekty MAE RAN v 2015 g., St. Petersburg: MAE RAN, pp. 381–390. Kozintsev A.G., Selezneva V.I., 2011. Kraniometricheskie osobennosti naseleniia Tuvy epokhi zheleza: Cherepa iz mogil'nika Sagly [Craniometrical specific features of the Tuva population in the Iron Age: Skulls from the burial ground of Sagly]. Radlovskii sbornik: Nauchnye issledovaniia i muzeinye proekty MAE RAN v 2010 g., St. Petersburg: MAE RAN, pp. 217–222. Kuz'min N.Iu., 2011. Pogrebal'nye pamiatniki khunno-sian'biiskogo vremeni v stepiakh Srednego Eniseia: Tesinskaia kul'tura [Hun-Syanbi burial monuments in the steppes of the Middle Yenisei river: he Tesinsk culture], St. Petersburg, 456 p. Lazaretov I.P., 2007. Pamiatniki bainovskogo tipa i tagarskaia kul'tura [The Bainovsky-type monuments and the Tagar culture]. Arkheologicheskie vesti, 14, Moscow: Nauka, pp. 93–105. Lazaretova N.I., 2006. Kraniologicheskie materialy iz bidzhinskikh kurganov v kontekste mezhgruppovoi izmenchivosti naseleniia tagarskoi kul'tury [Craniological materisl from the Bidzha burial grounds in terms of morphological variation of the Tagar population]. Nekotorye aktual'nye problemy sovremennoi antropologii, St. Petersburg: MAE RAN, pp. 66–75. Rykun M.P., 2013. Paleoantropologiia Verkhnego Priob'ia epokhi rannego zheleza (po materialam kamenskoi kul'tury) [Paleoanthropological data on the Early Iron Age population of the Upper Ob Basin (the Kamenskaya culture)], Barnaul: Izd-vo AltGU, 284 p. Tur S.S., 2001. Kraniologicheskie materialy iz Bobrovskogo mogil'nika bol'sherechenskoi kul'tury perekhodnogo vremeni ot epokhi bronzy k epokhe zheleza (VIII–VI veka do n.e.) v svete etnogeneticheskikh problem drevnego naseleniia Verkhnego Priob'ia [Human Crania from the burial ground of Bobrovsky of the Bolsherechenskaya culture in the light of the ethnogenetic aspects of the ancient population in the Upper Ob region, the transition time from the Bronze Age to the Iron Age (VIII–VI century B.C.)]. Drevnosti Altaia. Izvestiia laboratorii arkheologii, no. 7, Gorno-Altaisk, pp. 67–82. Tur S.S., 2003. Antropologicheskii sostav naseleniia Srednei Katuni skifskogo vremeni [Anthropological structure of the Scythian population in the middle reaches of the Katun river]. Iu.F. Kiriushin, N.F. Stepanova, A.A. Tishkin. Skifskaia epokha Gornogo Altaia. Chast' II: Pogrebal'no-pominal'nye kompleksy pazyrykskoi kul'tury. Prilozhenie II, Barnaul: Izd-vo AltGU, pp. 137–169. Tur S.S., Rykun M.P., 2004. Kraniologicheskie materialy pazyrykskoi kul'tury iz mogil'nikov v urochishche Kyzyl-Dzhar [Human Crania from the Pazyryk burials in the Kyzyl-Dzhar natural landmark]. Drevnosti Altaia, no. 12, Gorno-Altaisk: Izd-vo GAGU, pp. 32–49. Uchaneva E.N., 2014. Novye kraniologicheskie materialy skifskogo vremeni iz Tsentral'noi Tuvy [Recent craniological data of the Scythian time in Central Tuva]. Trudy IV (XX) Vserossiiskogo arkheologicheskogo s"ezda v Kazani, vol. IV, Kazan': Otechestvo, pp. 413–416. 87