International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology (2007) 71, 1129—1137
www.elsevier.com/locate/ijporl
Healing time, long-term result and effects of
stem cell treatment in acute tympanic
membrane perforation
Anisur Rahman a,*, Magnus von Unge a, Petri Olivius a, Joris Dirckx b,
Malou Hultcrantz a
a
Center for Hearing and Communication Research and Department of Otorhinolaryngology,
Karolinska University Hospital and Institute, 17176 Stockholm, Sweden
b
Biomedical Physics Group, University of Antwerp, Belgium
Received 8 February 2007; received in revised form 4 April 2007; accepted 5 April 2007
KEYWORDS
Laser;
Moiré interferometry;
Morphology;
Myringotomy;
Rat;
Stem cell
Summary
Objective: The incidence of otitis media in children between the age of 2 and 6 years
is well documented. Repeated attacks may cause acute and chronic perforations. The
surgical treatment for repairing chronic perforation is quite uncomfortable for the
patients of this age group because of the invasiveness of this treatment. The aim of
this study was to determine the long-term influence of embryonic stem cells on acute
perforations and the effect of gelatin as a vehicle for applied stem cells. The
possibility of teratogenic effects of the stem cells was also observed.
Methods: Bilateral laser myringotomy was performed in 17 adult Sprague—Dawley
rats, divided into two groups. Gelatin, a substance suitable as vehicle for bioactive
material was used bilaterally around the perforation in group A, to serve as a scaffold
for repairing tissue. The stem cells were used in the right tympanic membrane
perforation leaving the left tympanic membrane as a control. The animals in group
B received the same treatment except for the use of gelatin and in addition received
an immuno-suppressive agent. After half a year of observation the mechanical
stiffness of the tympanic membrane was measured by moiré interferometry for group
B and the morphological study was performed by light microscopy for both groups A
and B and electron microscopy for group A.
Results: Stem cell treated ears did not show any enhanced healing of the perforation
although a marked thickening of the lamina propria was observed compared with
control group. After half a year the strength and the stiffness of the tympanic
membrane was almost the same for both treated and untreated ears. No evidence
of teratoma was found after half a year.
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +46 8 5177 9344; fax: +46 8 5177 6267.
E-mail address: anisur.rahman@ki.se (A. Rahman).
0165-5876/$ — see front matter # 2007 Published by Elsevier Ireland Ltd.
doi:10.1016/j.ijporl.2007.04.005
1130
A. Rahman et al.
Conclusion: This study suggests that the stem cells stimulate the proliferation of
connective tissue and fibers in the lamina propria, possibly mediated by secreted
substances, although the stiffness properties do not seem to be altered. The use of
gelatin does not seem to enhance the healing process of the tympanic membrane
perforation.
# 2007 Published by Elsevier Ireland Ltd.
1. Introduction
2. Material and methods
Perforation of the tympanic membrane (TM) is an
important clinical problem worldwide, especially in
children. It can cause a conductive hearing loss and
repeated infections. It is often the result of
repeated otitis media or trauma or as sequel after
treatment with ventilating tubes [1]. Traumatic
acute perforations heal spontaneously in a relatively
large number of cases whereas chronic perforation
generally requires surgical repair with a tissue graft.
Surgical treatment (myringoplasty) is successful in
88—95% of the cases but can cause operative risks,
causes discomfort for the patient and costs for
society [2]. Millions of people from developing
and under-developed countries have not got access
to such treatment and are left with having the
problem life-long. Repairing a perforation by office
techniques has been successful for a few cases for
small traumatic perforations [3]. These attempts
have however been disappointing in case of nontraumatic or large perforations. The healing process
of TM perforations has been subjected to several
investigations with the purpose of finding better
treatment of chronic TM perforations [4].
Because of a broad clinical potential, it is important to test the healing enhancing capability of
various substances that can be applied to the perforation, so that conventional surgery might become
unnecessary. Studies have been reported on enhancing the healing with the use of hyaluronic acid [5—
7], blood [8] and growth factors [9]. So far, no final
solution for a simple out-patient procedure of closing chronic TM perforations has been established.
Since the first successful derivation of embryonic
stem (ES) cells from the blastocyst-stage, these cells
are in the center of tremendous interest over the
potential application in the newly emerging field of
regenerative medicine. ES cells are pluripotent and
they can proliferate infinitely in an undifferentiated
state in vitro. In a previous study the application of
mouse ES cells in a gerbil acute TM perforation
model appeared to enhance the healing [10].
The purpose of the present study is to test and
compare the capability of applied mouse ES cells to
enhance the closure of acute perforations with and
without the use of gelatin.
Twenty adult female Sprague—Dawley rats, weighing between 250 and 300 g, were used. Three rats
died during anesthesia and the 17 remaining rats
were divided in two different settings, 10 rats in
group A and seven rats in group B. The animals were
bred at Biomedicinskt Centrum, Uppsala, and were
kept in the animal department during the experiments. The animals were kept in a single-species,
temperature-controlled, 12 h light/dark cycle facility. Food and water were provided ad libitum. The
research protocol was approved by Stockholms
Norra Djurförsöksetiska Nämnd (N344/02).
The Tau-GFP-labeled mouse ES cells were collected from the laboratory of Prof. John O. Mason,
department of biomedical sciences and center for
developmental biology, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
The cells were dispended in physiological saline
giving a solution of approximately 1 104 cells/mL
in each application.
Myringotomy was performed bilaterally on all 17
rats, under general anesthesia of 100 mg ketamine
hydrochloride (Ketalar, Pfizer AB, Täby, Sweden) and
10 mg xylazine hydrochloride (Rompun, Bayer
Health Care AG, Germany) intraperitoneally. The
myringotomy was done under an operating microscope using a KTP laser beam, directed through a
0.2 mm fiber in group A and a 0.4 mm in group B that
were entered via the external auditory canal. 0.5 s
single pulses of 1 W were given repeatedly. The
myringotomy was made in the postero-superior
quadrant of the pars tensa. It was verified under
a scaled ocular microscope that the fiber diameter
coincided with the created perforation size (Fig. 1).
In group A, a droplet of gelatin was applied
bilaterally on the TM around the perforation. The
purpose of putting gelatin over the perforation was
to produce a platform for the ES cells to migrate or
proliferate upon. Ten minutes after the application,
the gelatin has formed a layer which spans the
perforation. Thereafter the solution of ES cells
was applied to the perforation site on the right
TMs and the same solution without ES cells was used
in the left, control side.
The seven animals in group B were treated in the
same way as described above, except for the gelatin
Tympanic membrane perforation and stem cells
Fig. 1 0.4 mm perforation observed by otomicroscopy
immediately after laser myringotomy. Margin of perforation (arrow) and handle of malleus (M) are indicated.
application, and a larger diameter of laser fiber of
0.4 mm was used. In order to minimize the immunological rejection, the transplanted host animals
received injections of cyclosporine (Novartis, Sweden, 0.56 mg/100 gm body weight) at every alternate day from the day of transplantation up to 2
weeks.
Postoperatively, all TMs in groups A and B were
monitored with otomicroscopic examination daily
for three consecutive days followed by every second
day until the perforations were closed, and at the
study end after 6 months. Observation was made
regarding the presence of a perforation, blood clot,
infection, myringosclerosis and thickened TM.
The animals in group A were euthanized under
CO2 anesthesia after 6 months. Two ES cell treated
TMs were dissected out along with the annulus,
placed on a glass slide and photographed using
fluorescence light under a Zeiss Axioplan. The
remaining ES cell treated right ears, as well as
the non-treated, left ears were fixed in 2.5% glutaraldehyde for 24 h. The tympanic bulla was opened,
the external ear canal and the cochlea were
1131
removed and the temporal bone was trimmed.
Post-fixation was done in osmium tetroxide for
1 h. The specimens were then embedded according
to the standard methods in agar-resin for light- and
transmission electron microscopy. Thickness measurements were made at 10 different places in TM
sections based on electron micrograph pictures.
In group B the animals were sacrificed at 6 months
after myringotomy and the fresh TMs were prepared
according to the protocol for moiré interferometry
[11,12] to assess the mechanical strength and stiffness. The displacement of the TM was measured
during sequences of static pressures applied to the
middle ear in the range between 350 to +350 daPa.
At first a positive pressure cycle was run, starting
from 0 to +350 daPa and then in reverse sequence
from +350 back to 0 daPa. A negative pressure cycle
from 0 to 350 daPa and back to 0 was performed in
analogy with the positive one. After measurements
the TMs were prepared for light microscopy as
described above.
3. Results
3.1. Otomicroscopy
Two rats from group A died during the experiment
from the effects of anesthesia. Closure time of the TM
perforations was recorded in all other ears (see
Table 1). In both groups the control side closed earlier
than the ES cell treated side, indifferent of whether
the immunosuppressive agent was administered or
not. These differences, however, were minute and
insignificant. It was obvious that the TMs of group B,
larger perforation (0.4 mm) without gelatin, tended
to close earlier than those of group A.
The 16 TMs of group A and the 14 of group B
showed neither signs of blood clot, nor infection or
thickening of the TM. At 1 month after myringotomy
most of the TMs of both groups showed a visible scar,
as an opalescent ring in the postero-superior quadrant of the pars tensa. Visible scars were no longer
found at the end of the study where all TMs
appeared normal.
Table 1 Accumulated number of closed TMs at various days after myringotomy
Group A (gelatin)
Group B (no gelatin, immuno-suppressive agent)
Day
Control
Treated
Control
Treated
6
8
10
12
14
0
1
4
6
8
0
0
1
6
8
1
7
7
7
7
0
6
6
6
7
1132
3.2. Fluorescence microscopy
Two treated TMs of group A were investigated for
fluorescent labeled cells and a faint staining of
unspecific origin could be found. It was not possible
to correlate the staining to any specific cell or
structure in the TM.
3.3. Light and electron microscopy
For both groups A and B, light microscopy have
showed a similar thickening of the TM at and around
the site where the myringotomy was done. This
thickened area covered almost the entire posterosuperior quadrant (Fig. 2a and b). The anterior
quadrants appeared completely unaffected. Electron microscopy performed in group A revealed that
the thickening mostly consists of changes in the
collagen layers of the TM lamina propria. The thickening was more pronounced in the ES cell-treated
TMs than in the controls. The mean TM thickness as
measured at different places in a few treated and a
few control ears were approximately 36 and 28 mm,
respectively. The normal thickness is approximately
5 mm [11]. The thickening was in both groups characterized by edema with dispersed and disconnected fiber bundles running in diverse directions
(Fig. 3a and b). There was also an abundance of
cells, mainly fibroblast and vessels in the fibrous
layer (Fig. 3c). In some TMs the keratin layer was
A. Rahman et al.
found unevenly thickened. Myringosclerosis was not
found in any of the TMs.
3.4. Moiré interferometry
3.4.1. Displacement of control ears
Moiré interferometry allows to measure TM deformation over the entire surface, and was described in
our previous paper [11]. Successful moiré interferometry measurements were obtained from six out of
the seven TMs in group B. One specimen leaked
before starting the pressure cycle. One TM ruptured
at 160 daPa while the others went through the
complete positive and negative pressure sequences
of 350 daPa. The appearance of the moiré fringes
was normal (Fig. 4a) [13].
In Fig. 5a the peak displacement values calculated from the interferograms of a control ear are
plotted versus the applied pressures, and the curve
shows an ‘‘S’’ shape which is typical for visco-ealstic
material. The displacement is more extensive in the
negative pressure zone as compared to the corresponding positive pressure zone.
In a mean peak displacement curve plot for the
entire group of control ears the ‘‘S’’ shape becomes
even smoother (Fig. 5b). The mean peak displacement for the control group at +350 daPa pressure
was 2.65 10 4 m with a S.D. of 0.68 10 4 m and
at 350 daPa was 3.45 10 4 m with a S.D. of
0.10 10 4 m.
3.4.2. Displacement of treated ears
All seven treated TMs were successfully measured
during the pressure sequences between 0 and
350 daPa. Moiré fringes showed similar patterns
as compared with the control ears (Fig. 4b). The
displacement versus pressure curve plot of the TM’s
again resembles an ‘‘S’’ shape (Fig. 5a). The ‘‘S’’
shape of the mean curve plot of this group becomes
smoother in a similar way as for the control group
(Fig. 5b). The largest hysteresis effect was found
around 50—100 daPa in the positive pressure cycle.
The mean curve plot of control and the treated
groups almost overlapped each other, meaning that
there was no difference in the stiffness of the TMs
between the treated and the untreated controls.
4. Discussion
Fig. 2 Light microscopy photograph of healed (a) a
control and (b) a stem cell treated tympanic membrane
at 6 months after myringotomy. The myringotomy site
(arrow), handle of malleus (h), middle ear cavity (ME),
external auditory canal (EAC) are indicated. Note that the
thickness increase is largest in the treated tympanic
membrane.
The exact prevalence on chronic tympanic membrane perforation for the entire human population is
not available. In developing countries a level well
over one percent is probable. Kamal et al. [14]
presented a prevalence >7% in slum dwellers in
Dhaka City, Biswas et al. [15] reported >12% in
Tympanic membrane perforation and stem cells
1133
Fig. 4 Displacement interferogram at an ear canal pressure load of +350 daPa of (a) a myringotomized left tympanic membrane and (b) a myringotomized ES cell treated
right tympanic membrane recorded at 6 months after the
intervention. Presence of two fringes in both the anterior
and posterior part of the pars tensa confers the similar
changes in both groups. Orientation: superior rim to the
right, posterior rim upward in (a) and downward in (b).
Fig. 3 (a) Transmission electron microscopy of a myringotomized control TM after 6 months. Note increased
thickness of lamina propria. Proliferating fibroblast
(arrowhead), collagen fibres (arrow), and external auditory canal (EAC) are common for figures a—c. Accumulation of keratin (K) is evident. The lamina propria shows the
collagen fibre bundles in straight rows. Three clear layers
of the TM: the mucosal layer (M), the lamina propria (LP)
and the epidermal cell layer (E). (b) Transmission electron
microscopy of a myringotomized stem cell treated tympanic membrane after 6 months. Note larger thickness of
lamina propria (LP) as compared with control sample in
Bangladesh rural areas and Morris et al. 17% in
Australian Aboriginal children [16]. Treating chronic
perforation by simple procedures other than conventional surgery is still an unresolved problem in
the field of otology. Such a treatment would be
greatly beneficial especially for the pediatric
patients. Multiple approaches and graft materials
have been used to reconstruct the lost or damaged
TMs to avoid recurrent otitis media and hearing loss.
Recent advances in developmental biology and
tissue engineering give the opportunity to repair
(a). Note proliferating fibroblast. (c) Transmission electron microscopy of a myringotomized stem cell treated
tympanic membrane after 6 months in higher magnification. Note oedema (*), fiber bundle (fb) and dispersed
fibers in disorganisation with increased amount of ground
substance and lots of cells and vessels in lamina propria.
1134
A. Rahman et al.
Fig. 5 (a) Peak displacement vs. pressure plot of a control and a treated tympanic membrane of one animal recorded at
6 months after myringotomy. Note that the plotted curves almost coincide in a smooth S-shape. Different readings during
increasing and decreasing sequences at identical pressures are due to hysteresis. (b) Moiré interferometry testing the
pressure resistance (daPa) in the myringotomized control and treated group. The two curves are almost identical in the ES
cell treated group (grey diamond) and control group (black squares). Results were obtained during increasing pressurization from 0 to +350 and 0 to 350 daPa.
damaged or lost tissues with cells supplied from
exogenous sources or mobilizing the cells from
endogenous origin. Despite the promising experimental results yielded from using adult stem cells,
the increasing evidence of their limited plasticity
made them less suitable for transplantation. ES cells
are particularly important because they can be
precommitted towards a specific cell lineage and
they can complete their maturation under in vivo
situation. Several studies reported the positive catalytic effect of ES cells on tissue repair and regeneration [17—19]. The potential therapeutic
application of ES cells still depends on addressing
some key prerequisites like cell purity, amplification
and immunogenicity.
Chronic perforation causes distortion of the
epithelial cells as well as of the stromal framework
of the TM. The epithelial cells cannot repair the
damage solely without the mechanical support of
proliferating connective tissue. The healing process
of the TM is not similar to that of other cutaneous
structures. The epithelial cell proliferation and
invasion of granulation tissue does not take place
concomitantly. The epidermis is the first layer to
Tympanic membrane perforation and stem cells
come forward when the TM starts to heal and a
proliferation of stratified squamous epithelium
migrates toward the edges and tries to span the
gap [20]. These epithelial cells might originate from
the more vascularized portions of the remnants of
the TM such as at the umbo and around the handle of
malleus. This central area of the TM is supposed to
host progenic cells that generate the epithelial
migration known to move in centrifugal direction
[21]. This area is at risk during the surgical closing
procedure, so avoiding a surgical procedure in the
TMs would be beneficial in this respect. Secondarily
in the healing process, the inner mucosal layer
comes forward and finally the lamina propria, which
will often be incomplete and invade in-between
these two epithelial layers [20]. This is not the case
in usual wound healing where the fibrous tissue
starts to fill the defect [21]. Another recent, important finding reported that plasminogen plays an
important role in wound healing especially in the
TM perforation [22].
In order to promote healing there should be some
sort of mechanical support for the progressing
epithelial proliferation. In wound healing, blood
clots may act as a scaffold to epithelial migration,
and the extra-cellular matrix proteins provide a
substratum for cells to adhere, migrate and proliferate. In the present perforation study we used
gelatin on group A. Gelatin is a heterogeneous
mixture of water-soluble protein of high molecular
weight which is usually found in collagen. Gelatin
was used to provide the support to the applied stem
cells. Another purpose was to prevent the migration
of transplanted cells towards the middle ear cavity.
In order to test whether a platform of gelatin could
support a faster regeneration, it was applied in
group A. Such application, however, did not help
to reduce the closing time. On the contrary, group B
not having gelatin showed faster closure despite
that the perforations were larger. This difference
was found for both the treated and the non-treated
subgroups. Park et al. [23] reported the effects of
different substances on TM repair and found the
same closer rate of gelatin treated TMs to controls
similar to the findings of our group A study. Although
immunosuppressive drug impairs the wound healing
[24], but introduction of cyclosporine in group B
rather showed faster healing. So, it cannot be concluded that changes of parameters (exclusion of
gelatin, introduction of cyclosporine) from group
A, caused faster healing in group B and the reason
is not known and is not clarified by the present
results.
The design of the group B study was aimed to
promote the possibilities to detect an effect of stem
cell treatment with a small number of animals. The
1135
closing time was not shown to reduce with the ES
cell treatment as compared with control ears. In a
previous study [10], also using mouse ES cells for
treatment an obvious enhancement of the closing
time was found. In that study cells of different origin
was used and they were applied on another species
other than the Sprague—Dawley rat, namely the
Mongolian gerbil. One may speculate on how different related species accept xeno-transplantation in
different ways.
Comparing the healing in groups A and B, significant difference in the total healing time could not
be found whether the perforation was 0.2 or 0.4 mm
or using gelatin or not. When comparing the time for
the closing procedure, a recent study [25] reported
9 days in the same animal species, while in the
present study both the control side and the ES cell
treated side closed within 14 days. Earlier studies
with laser myringotomy have shown closing times of
9—14 days [11].
Morphologically investigated TMs presently show
a dispersed pattern of the lamina propria in the
myringotomized area, especially on the ES cell
treated side where the thickness of the TM was
increased by approximately 33%. In the untreated
control TMs the increase is approximately 28%.
The ES cells were originated from mouse and
xeno-transplanted into the rat ear. Xeno-transplantation has earlier been shown to be successful with
the same type of cells although the host species was
different, i.e. the gerbil [10]. Shortage of donor
organs for clinical transplantation and increasing
need for available organs has focused attention
on the possibility of xeno-transplantation. Transplantation of xenogenic cells or tissues instead of
complex organ provided better therapeutic result.
Pig fetal neuronal cells survived and formed dopaminergic neuron when transplanted into patients
with Parkinson’s disease [26]. Groth et al. [27]
reported that the porcine fetal pancreatic cell produce insulin for a limited time after transplantation
to diabetic patients. Immune rejection is the greatest challenge for this treatment. The risks of
immune rejection in the present study may be less,
since the TM pars tensa has low metabolism and
restricted vascularization. The ES cells used in the
present study were not indicative of the origin or
location at 6 months after treatment. Nevertheless,
it cannot be excluded that the implanted ES cells
might have had indirect effect on healing of the TM,
which might have been mediated via secretion of
growth factors or other unknown substances from
the ES cells.
It has been described earlier that the part of pars
tensa that closed after myringotomy was thicker
than normal up to 1 month later [11]. Presently
1136
after 6 months the site of the myringotomy was
thicker in the treated TMs than in the controls
(36 mm versus 28 mm), which might be due to an
introduction of more proliferating cells. Whether
this difference is a result of actions of the ES cells
can be argued. Secretion of growth factors from the
ES cells might be responsible for the larger biological response in the lamina propria in the treated
ears. The elasticity was almost identical with or
without the treatment, as the displacement by
pressure was nearly the same in both groups. The
strength of the TMs puts a limit to the pressure
which can be applied, and resulted in rupture during
pressurizations in the untreated group, whereas
none of the treated ears had TM rupture in this
situation.
In the present study investigating the long-term
closing effects of the TM after acute laser perforation, there seems to be no difference between the
ES cell treated ears and the controls concerning
stiffness and pressure tolerance. The large amount
of tissue in the lamina propria is however still there
at 6 months after myringotomy. This has been interpreted, that the loss of orientation of the collagen
fibers is compensated by a large amount of ground
substances and dispersed and disorientated collagen
fiber bundles. This way the stiffness and the pressure resistance will show the same values as in nonperforated TMs [13].
A possible disadvantage of ES cell treatment is
the risk of teratoma formation in a recipient organ
[28]. In the present long-term follow-up study there
was however no such evidence obtained: no tumourlike pathology was encountered in the middle ears.
5. Conclusion
Myringotomy performed with a laser beam showed
after 6 months, a healed TM with the same pressure
withstanding and stiffness, whether the perforation
size varied or ES cells or gelatin was used or not. The
morphology, however, was different. The ES cell
treated TMs were thicker than the controls at the
site of the perforation due to disarrangement of the
lamina propria that contained a lot of cells, vessels
and ground substances.
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank Dr. Gregory Margolin,
Karolinska University hospital, for his kind assistance,
Prof John O. Mason, Department of Biomedical
Sciences and Center for Developmental Biology,
The University of Edinburgh for generously supplying
A. Rahman et al.
ES cells for the study. They also wish to thank Paula
Mannström and Mikael Eriksson, Karolinska Institute
and Jan Van Hecke, University of Antwerp for their
excellent technical support. The study was supported
by Centrum för Klinisk Forskning, Landstinget Västmanland and Helga Hjerpstedts Fond, Sweden and
funding from Karolinska Institute, Sweden, and University of Antwerp, Belgium.
References
[1] A. Golz, A. Netzer, H.Z. Joachims, S.T. Westerman, L.M.
Gilbert, Ventilation tubes and persisting tympanic membrane perforations, Otolaryngol. Head Neck Surg. 120
(1999) 524—527.
[2] E. Vartiainen, J. Nuutinen, Success and pitfalls in myringoplasty: follow-up study of 404 cases, Am. J. Otol. 14 (1993)
301—305.
[3] J.M. Kartush, Tympanic membrane patcher: a new device to
close tympanic membrane perforations in an office setting,
Am. J. Otol. 21 (5) (2000) 615—620.
[4] A. Johnson, M. Hawke, The function of migratory epidermis
in the healing of tympanic membrane perforations in guinea
pig: a photographic study, Acta. Otolaryngol. 103 (1987)
82—86.
[5] K. Ozturk, H. Yaman, M.A. Cihat, H. Arbaq, B. Keles, Y. Uyar,
Effectiveness of MeroGel hyaluronic acid on tympanic
membrane perforations, Acta Otolaryngol. 126 (11) (2006)
1158—1163.
[6] C. Laurent, O. Söderberg, M. Anniko, S. Hartwig, Repair of
chronic tympanic membrane perforations using application
of hyaluronan or rice paper prosthesis, ORL J. Otorhinolaryngo. Relat. Spec. 53 (1991) 37—40.
[7] L.E. Stenfors, L. Berghem, G.D. Bloom, S. Hellström, O.
Söderberg, Exogeneous hyaluronic acid (Healon) accelerates
the healing experimental myringotomies, Auris. nasus. Larynx. 12 (1985) S214—S215.
[8] K.H. Siedentop, M.D. Harris, K. Ham, B. Sanchez, Extended
experimental and preliminary surgical findings with autologous fibrine tissue adhesive made from patients own
blood, Laryngoscope 96 (1986) 1062—1064.
[9] Y. Ma, H. Zhao, X. Zhou, Topical treatment with growth
factors for tympanic membrane perforations: progress
towards clinical application, Acta Otolaryngol. (Stockh)
122 (2002) 586—599.
[10] M. von Unge, J.J. Dirckx, N.P. Olivius, Embryonic stem cells
enhance the healing of tympanic membrane perforations,
Int. J. Pediatr. Otorhinolaryngol. 67 (2003) 215—219.
[11] A. Rahman, M. Hultcrantz, J.J. Dirckx, G. Margolin, M.v.
Unge, Fresh tympanic membrane perforations heal without
significant loss of strength, Otol. Neurotol. 26 (2005) 1100—
1106.
[12] J.J. Dirckx, W. Decraemer, Optoelectronic moiré projector
for real-time shape and deformation studies of the tympanic
membrane, J. Biomed. Opt. 2 (1997) 176—185.
[13] A. Rahman, M. Hultcrantz, J.J. Dirckx, M. von Unge, Structural and functional properties of the healed tympanic
membrane: a long-term follow-up after laser myringotomy.
Otol. Neurotol. (2007) April 11; [Epub ahead of print].
[14] N. Kamal, A.H. Joarder, A.A. Chowdhury, A.W. Khan, Prevalence of chronic suppurative otitis media among the
children living in two selected slums of Dhaka city, Bangladesh Med. Res. Counc. Bull. 30 (3) (2004) 95—104.
Tympanic membrane perforation and stem cells
[15] A.C. Biswas, A.H. Joarder, B.H. Siddique, Prevalence of
CSOM among rural school going children, Mymensingh
Med. J. 14 (2) (2005) 152—155.
[16] P.S. Morris, A.J. Leach, P. Silberberg, G. Mellon, C. Wilson, E.
Hamilton, et al., Otitis media in young aboriginal children
from remote communities in Northern and Central Australia,
BMC Pediatr. 20 (5) (2005) 27.
[17] D. Fraidenraich, E. Stillwell, E. Romero, D. Wilkes, K. Manova, C.T. Basson, et al., Rescue of cardiac defects in Id
knockout embryos by injection of embryonic stem cells,
Science 306 (2004) 247—252.
[18] R.K. Chien, A. Moretti, K.L. Laugwitz, ES cells to the rescue,
Science 306 (2004) 239—240.
[19] P. Menasche, Embryonic stem cells pace the heart, Nat.
Biotechnol. 22 (10) (2004) 1237—1238.
[20] A.P. Johnson, L.A. Smallman, S.E. Kent, The mechanism of
healing of tympanic membrane perforations: a two-dimensional histologic study in guinea pigs, Acta Otolaryngol. 109
(1990) 406—415.
[21] C.J. Reijnen, W. Kuipers, The healing pattern of the drum
membrane, Acta Otolaryngol. Suppl. (Stockh) 287 (1971)
1—74.
[22] J. Li, P.O. Eriksson, A. Hansson, S. Hellström, T. Ny, Plasmin/
Plasminosen is essential for the healing of tympanic
1137
[23]
[24]
[25]
[26]
[27]
[28]
membrane perforations, Thromb. Haemost. 96 (4) (2006)
512—519.
A.H. Park, C.W. Hughes, A. Jackson, L. Hunter, L. Mcgill, S.E.
Simonsen, et al., Crosslinked hydrogel for tympanic membrane repair, Otolaryngol. Head Neck Surg. 135 (6) (2006)
877—883.
M. Schaffer, R. Schier, M. Napirei, S. Michalski, T. Traska, R.
Viebahn, Sirolimus impair wound healing, Langenbecks
Arch. Surg. (2007), Epub ahead of print.
W. Wang, Z.M. Wang, F.L. Chi, Spontaneous healing of
various tympanic membrane perforations in the rat, Acta
Otolaryngol. 124 (2004) 1141—1144.
T. Deacon, J. Schumacher, J. Dinsmore, C. Thomas, P.
Palmer, P.S. Kott, Histological evidence of fetal pig neural
cell survival after transplantation into a patient with Parkinson’s disease, Nat. Med. 3 (3) (1997) 350—353.
C.G. Groth, O. Korsgren, A. Tibell, J. Tollemar, E. Moller, J.
Bolinder, et al., Transplantation of porcine fetal pancreas to
diabetic patients, Lancet 344 (1994) 1402—1404.
R. Chinzei, Y. Tanaka, K. Shimizu-Saito, Y. Hara, S. Kakinuma, M. Watanabe, et al., Embryoid-body cells derived
from a mouse embryonic stem cell line show differentiation into functional hepatocytes, Hepatology 36 (2002)
22—29.