Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                

Caste: Oxford India short introductions

2015, Asian Ethnicity

114 Book reviews Caste: Oxford India short introductions, by Surinder S. Jodhka, New Delhi, Oxford University Press, 2012, 224 pp., Rs. 195 (paperback), ISBN 9780198089360 For a long time now, the social reality of caste in India remains an anathema for social theorists. As caste system is a highly complex, dynamic and enduring aspect of Indian social life, the book under review can be taken as an indispensable starting point towards understanding caste in India. It combines the most up-to-date research on the prevailing situation of caste in India with a rigorous exposition of its various dimensions as an institution, as a traditional practice and as power and humiliation. The author, who himself is a noted sociologist, leaves no gaps in understanding the contemporary manifestations as well as the changing perspectives on caste in social science writings and popular discourses. The moot questions that he tries to answer are the most relevant in the contemporary Indian society, such as does caste really matter today beyond electoral politics? What has changed and what remains of it? Do caste-based quotas and reservations strengthen divisions in society or do they help bridge them? How does the reality of caste play out in modern-day labour markets, social life and popular culture? For a proper understanding, the book has been divided into five chapters. The very first chapter ‘Caste as tradition’ focuses on the classical view of cast and describes the term ‘caste’ as a system of social relations that is considered to be uniquely Indian and presumably distinguishes the traditional Indian society from the West but it is ironically not of Indian origin. In fact, the term ‘caste’ comes from the Spanish word ‘casta’, means race. They describe a variety of prevailing social divisions and hierarchies of status and class that include the idea and practices of ‘pollution’ or ‘untouchability’. The ground reality of the Indian society, however, did not easily concur with the Varna model of caste. The author describes Varna system as a panIndian system, while the jatis (caste) had a regional character. Every region had a large number of jatis and its subunits, ranging between 200 and 300 or even more. Quoting Nicholas Dirks, the author argues that caste was widely recognized by the colonial regime as a local form of ‘civil society’, which was responsible for India’s ‘political weakness’ and symptom of the overdevelopment of its religious preoccupations’ (Dirks 2001, 40). Interestingly, the author contests the French scholar Louis Dumont’s Bougle’s theory on caste. Although Dumont looked at caste as a peculiarly Hindu practice and contrasted the Indian culture with the Western society, the author of the book under review says that his theory has been one of the most criticized academic writing on caste and that too for good reasons. In the second chapter ‘Caste as power’, the author begins with a descriptive account of caste as presented by the social anthropologists in studies of the ‘traditional’ Indian village. In sharp contrast to the first chapter, this chapter analyses the viewpoints of caste on the basis of social scientific research. But the popular social movements that revolve around caste have frequently questioned the validity of such an understanding of caste. The author agrees with several sociologists, social anthropologists and other social scientists who have extensively explored the ‘power’ dimension of caste. Caste power and politics are also subjects of contemporary relevance, which have been discussed in a theoretical prospective as well. While discussing in detail about the cast and politics in contemporary India, the author argues that the leaders of India’s freedom movement did not have a uniform attitude towards caste. Gandhi found nothing fundamentally wrong with the system of castebased division in the Indian society, and so did B.R. Ambedkar, who was more emphatic on this. Asian Ethnicity 115 The third chapter titled ‘Caste as humiliation’ deals with the sociology of untouchability with a few examples of the humiliated Dalit students. The author claims that the sociological and social anthropological studies focusing on untouchability and the communities located below the line of pollution also present diverse pictures on the ideological order of caste. The fourth chapter titled ‘Contesting caste’ discusses in length the protective measures that are taken by the state and modern-day reformist movements. What brings to the attention of the reader is that the employment in the government sector at the senior level not only gives the individual employee better salaries and a sense of dignity, but it also creates a resource for the historically deprived communities, social capital or a new network of contacts in the state departments that provide a channel of mobility to other members of the communities as well. ‘Caste today’ is the theme of the fifth chapter that debates the institution of caste as dynamic in the system of social life. However, the nature and pattern of change varies with time. The author strongly feels that a large majority of those located below the ‘line of pollution’, the ex-untouchables or SCs, and those located immediately above this line, the so-called lower-OBCs, the legacy of caste continues to be a major source of deprivation. Indeed, the legacy of caste is hard to erase for those coming from the lower end of the ‘traditional hierarchy’. The author finds that the caste, for many of them, continues to matter beyond kinship and family values, and therefore, it is a source of deprivation, denial and discrimination. Combining with authoritative analysis, new ideas and diverse perspectives, the book discusses subjects that are topical yet enduring, as also emerging areas of study and debate. One would find that the book covers many themes and issues around the lived reality of caste in India, caste as tradition, as a constitutive element in power politics, its manifestation in everyday violence and humiliation, and its contestation by movements ‘from below’ and policies ‘from above’. Accessible and thoughtprovoking, this is a must-read for scholars, students, activists, policymakers and general readers interested in all-pervasive aspect of Indian social life. Notes on contributor Subhash Kumar Baitha is pursuing his PhD at the Centre for Inner Asian Studies, School of International Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi. Earlier, he did his graduation in History from Banaras Hindu University (BHU), Varanasi and MA in Politics (specialization in international relations) from Jawaharlal Nehru University. He also holds his MPhil in Inner Asian Studies from School of International Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University. He has published articles on his area of study in several journals. Author’s postal address: Subhash Kumar Baitha, Room No-210E, Brahmaputra Hostel, JNU, New Delhi-110067, India. Bibliography Dirks, Nicholas B. Caste of Mind: Colonialism and the Making of Modern India. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2001. Subhash Kumar Baitha School of International Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi, India subhjnu@gmail.com © 2015, Subhash Kumar Baitha http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/14631369.2014.1001155 Copyright of Asian Ethnicity is the property of Routledge and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.