Finally, suggested areas for future research are widely discussed throughout the book. Notably, the chapter on Internet
technologies introduces the role of emerging implementation research, particularly in facilitating the adoption of new
technologies or behavioral vaccines. Some of the implementation and dissemination of mental health prevention interventions may require a sequel to this already comprehensive
monograph, especially as ongoing prevention research studies come to fruition. Yet in keeping with the public health
framework, this emerging field of research may end up taking
a page from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
(CDC) experience with the research to practice framework to
ultimately get effective research off the academic shelf and
into communities (2). Developed in the 1990s, the CDC research to practice framework was developed to identify and
rapidly disseminate HIV prevention interventions in community-based settings in response to the growing epidemic and
was recently adapted to translate mental health treatments
to community practices (3). Ultimately Prevention in Mental
Health provides guidance for the next generation of mental
health research and, by focusing on prevention efforts, leads
the call for this emerging paradigm shift toward a public
health model that holds promise in reducing the burden of
mental disorders in our communities.
References
1. Martin D: Lester Breslow, Who Linked Healthy Habits and Long
Life, Dies at 97. http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/15/health/
lester-breslow-who-tied-good-habits-to-longevity-dies-at-97.
html (accessed April 14, 2012)
2. Sogolow E, Peersman G, Semaan S, Strouse D, Lyles CM; HIV/
AIDS Prevention Research Synthesis Project Team: The HIV/
AIDS Prevention Research Synthesis Project: scope, methods,
and study classification results. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr
2002; 30(suppl 1):S15–S29
3. Kilbourne AM, Neumann MS, Pincus HA, Bauer MS, Stall R:
Implementing evidence-based interventions in health care:
application of the replicating effective programs framework.
Implement Sci 2007; 2:42
AMY KILBOURNE, PH.D., M.P.H.
Ann Arbor, Mich.
Dr. Kilbourne is affiliated with the VA Ann Arbor Center for
Clinical Management Research and Department of Psychiatry,
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Mich. The views expressed
in this book review are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of the VA. The author reports no financial relationships with commercial interests.
Book review accepted for publication May 2012 (doi:10.1176/
appi.ajp.2012.12050582).
The Psychotherapy of Hope: The Legacy of Persuasion and Healing, edited by Renato D. Alarcón, M.D. and
Julia B. Frank, M.D. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press,
2011, 368 pp., $55.00.
Jerome Frank was a towering figure in American psychiatry.
Sadly, I doubt if his work is well-known by many in our profession. This carefully edited volume should fill that knowledge
gap. The book is not a Festschrift, but a primer on common
elements in psychotherapy, with a focus on the concept of
demoralization. Its two editors have done a masterful job of
carefully integrating the chapters in a sequential manner so
Am J Psychiatry 169:8, August 2012
that the book is a joy to read but also so that each chapter can
stand alone.
Frank’s genius was his ability to ask important questions
about the theory-bound psychodynamic psychotherapy of
mid-twentieth century America, which was dominated by
psychoanalytic schools of thought. He concluded that the role
of the socially sanctioned healer, whether a psychoanalyst or
culturally based practitioner, was to instill hope in the demoralized patient. It was this phenomenon, rather than the specific theory, that fostered the treatment alliance and fueled
the trajectory toward a positive therapeutic model. It must be
noted at the outset that his research was focused on nonpsychotic ambulatory patients but also contained elements that
were helpful to other clinical populations and their families.
The book is divided into two parts. The first section reviews the basic principles common to all psychotherapies,
and the second focuses on clinical issues regarding a variety
of therapies and clinical populations. The book opens with a
discussion of the genius of Frank and provides a review of his
systematic research of the therapeutic elements of psychotherapy. By developing such testable hypotheses via empirically based outcomes, Frank documented that a demoralized
individual is able to restore a sense of hope and mastery via
various psychotherapies. This denotes the development of
self-efficacy, which is defined as an individual’s belief that
he or she can accomplish a given task. Role induction was
an essential technique for successful outcomes. Role induction is educating the patient about what to expect from the
therapy and how it might work. This process may enhance
placebo responses in many therapies and has currently reemerged as a controversial topic (1). Chapters on the biological substrates of therapy and evolutionary biology offer current neuroscience data on psychotherapy. Demoralization is
the central element in Frank’s work. de Figueiredo’s essay on
deconstructing demoralization defines and expands the role
of this psychological state that may include hopelessness,
helplessness, and a sense of subjective incompetence. Drs.
Slavney and McHugh (2) placed Frank’s work within the life
story perspective of psychiatry and described how demoralization fits into the personal narrative that patients offer the
therapist.
The role of hope in various forms of practices in psychotherapy is reviewed in the second part of the book. Dr. Clarke
presents a chapter on depression, demoralization, and psychotherapy in the medically ill. He conceptualizes demoralization as a construct that is an independent dimension in
depressed individuals. Demoralization is similar to but has
unique qualities distinct from a major mood episode and is
also different from grief. It may be best categorized as a subtype of depression, which is rarely a stand-alone phenomenon. The chapter on psychotherapeutic communication in
the medical setting is discussed by Dr. Freeman and should
be essential reading for all consultation-liaison psychiatrists.
Both of these chapters should be essential reading for psychosomatic specialists.
Next, Drs. Griffith and D’Souza review the development of
self-efficacy in clinical work as a product of “agency thinking,”
wherein an individual’s perceptions evolve into the belief that
he or she can act effectively, and the development of “pathway thinking,” which is a road map of how to reach such coping mechanisms and relief from current stressors.
ajp.psychiatryonline.org
871
One of the gems of this book is the chapter on psychodynamic psychotherapy, by Drs. Wells and Frank. The subtitle,
“From Psychoanalytic Arrogance to Evidence-Based Modesty,” summarizes the evolution of theory-bound psychoanalysis as a contemporary form of psychotherapy. Other chapters
expand on behavioral therapies, group therapy, and cultural
psychotherapies. The book concludes with a discussion by Dr.
Griffith on religion and spirituality. He elegantly reminds us
that many individuals have increasingly turned to religion but
can easily become demoralized when adversity strikes, and
he reviews management strategies for such demoralized individuals bereft of a previously held spiritual orientation. The
discussion of cultural elements by Dr. Alarcón is also important in the multiethnic fabric of contemporary America.
This volume should be required reading not only for all
psychiatric residents, but also seasoned psychotherapists, as
it should lead to a more tempered advocacy of specific forms
of therapy and allow better understanding of the common
therapeutic elements in this essential psychiatric intervention.
References
1. Kirsch I: The use of placebos in clinical trials and clinical practice. Can J Psychiatry 2011; 56:191–192
2. McHugh PR, Slavney PR: The Perspectives of Psychiatry, 2nd
ed. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press, 1998
THOMAS N. WISE, M.D.
Falls Church, Va.
Dr. Wise is affiliated with Fairfax Hospital, Falls Church, Va.
The author reports no financial relationships with commercial
interests.
Book review accepted for publication April 2012 (doi:10.1176/
appi.ajp.2012.12040486).
Casebook of Interpersonal Psychotherapy, edited by
John C. Markowitz and Myrna M. Weissman. New York, Oxford
University Press, 2012, 504 pp., $55.00 (paper).
Interpersonal psychotherapy (IPT) was officially described
and “codified” in the 1970s and 1980s with the publication of
what are now classic studies and a foundational book (1–3).
Through decades of research, IPT has since been elevated to
the anointed ranks of evidence-supported or evidence-based
treatments. Therapists practicing IPT attend primarily to hereand-now issues, such as recent losses, interpersonal conflicts,
role transitions (e.g., empty nesting, divorce, retirement), and
interpersonal deficits (personality and communication difficulties). IPT fully respects biological, psychodynamic, and
cognitive and behavioral influences and strategies. Featured
techniques include education, exploration, interpretation,
emotional ventilation, goal setting, and problem solving. Focusing on the psychological spaces in which most patients
actually experience their problems, honoring and emphasizing the importance of the common and universal factors accounting for much of the favorable outcomes of psychotherapy, and fitting into an overall brief therapy time frame that
many patients can actually accommodate, from my perspective, make IPT one of the most practical, holistic, and effective
real-world psychotherapies.
The founding father of IPT, Gerald Klerman, was an outstanding, broad-based academic psychiatrist who, among
872
ajp.psychiatryonline.org
other roles, variously served as research director at Massachusetts General Hospital, professor at Harvard, Yale, and
Cornell universities, and head of the federal government’s Alcohol, Drug and Mental Health Administration. He was also a
prominent psychopharmacology researcher. Notably, IPT was
originally crafted to serve as an active treatment control for
studies designed to test and demonstrate the effectiveness of
tricyclic antidepressants in the treatment of nonpsychotic unipolar depression in middle-aged adults. Intended to serve as
a credible manualized psychotherapy treatment alternative,
the initial formulation of IPT was heavily influenced by the
work of Harry Stack Sullivan and John Bowlby, who focused
on interpersonal issues and attachment in depression. Somewhat to the amazement of these investigators, the IPT control
proved to be a reasonably robust intervention, leading to it
being fleshed out and further developed as an independent
treatment for depression.
Subsequent investigation has expanded these original
studies far beyond their initial applications. In research conducted at Cornell and Columbia universities, the University
of Pittsburgh, Washington University in St. Louis, and other
centers in the United States and internationally, IPT has demonstrated effectiveness in a wide array of patient types, diagnoses, and problems. Some of these findings were previously
drawn together in the Comprehensive Guide to Interpersonal
Therapy (3).
Casebook of Interpersonal Psychotherapy was edited by two
of the authors of the Comprehensive Guide to Interpersonal
Therapy: John Markowitz, a professor at Columbia and Cornell universities, who, as a former student of Klerman’s, became a principal researcher and standard bearer for IPT, and
Myrna Weissman, a professor of epidemiology and psychiatry
at Columbia University, one of the collaborating investigators
in the original IPT research studies. The editors have made an
exceptionally valuable contribution to the advancement of
IPT, and, in my view, to the field of psychotherapy as a whole.
Since psychotherapy is what psychotherapists do, it is critical for those learning to perform psychotherapy to get as close
as possible to observe the workings of master practitioners,
looking, as it were, over their shoulders. Short of providing
complete sets of videotapes or treatment transcripts for detailed study, the next best possibility is for seasoned practitioners to offer comprehensive descriptions of their treatments—boots on the ground. That is just what we are given
in this book.
Although the 20 well-written, amply referenced case-based
chapters in this book primarily deal with various types of depressive disorders, they also include bipolar disorder, eating
disorders, posttraumatic stress disorder, social anxiety disorder, and borderline personality disorders. The chapters cover
a wide variety of populations, from adolescents to the elderly,
and include peripartum patients, low-income populations,
and patients in developing countries. In addition to individual face-to-face psychotherapies, the authors elaborate
on their applications of IPT in group formats and telephonebased therapies. The 39 contributing authors include psychiatrists and psychologists from numerous academic centers
and private practice settings throughout the United States as
well as international settings. The chapters are rich in detailed
clinical vignettes, descriptions, reflections on moment-tomoment interactions, and clinical pearls.
Am J Psychiatry 169:8, August 2012