International Journal of Computing and Digital Systems
ISSN (2210-142X)
Int. J. Com. Dig. Sys. 5, No.6 (Nov-2016)
http://dx.doi.org/10.12785/ijcds/050605
Evaluation of E-Commerce Web-Based Systems
Sahar A. El_Rahman1,2, Naglaa F. Soliman2,3
1
Electronics, Computers Systems and Communication, Electrical Department, Faculty of Engineering-Shoubra, Benha University,
Cairo, Egypt
2
College of Computer and Information Sciences, Princess Nourah Bint Abdulrahman University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
3
Department of Electronics and Electrical Communications, Faculty of Engineering, Zagazig University, Zagazig, Egypt
Received 8 Apr. 2016, Revised 18 May 2016, Accepted 7 Jul. 2016, Published 1 Nov. 2016
Abstract: Web services and Internet are rapid becoming critically important to industry, business and individuals. Where generating
online society and trademark is the chief goal of web serving. They recognize that web-based systems able to increase their
communications scales where the Internet is able to render big amounts of data within a quick manner to the people. To be
successful, web-based systems require the usability is good. Usability is a measurement of how the interface is easy and simple to
utilize, for instance, as declared that the E-commerce foremost rule is, if customers are incapable to get products, they can't buy them.
Therefore, unused website will direct purchasers to get off them, ensuing in a lack of gross revenue. The involvements in evaluation
of web-based systems have been concerned matters in the latest years. E-commerce sites are selected as subjects for this study.
Where, many businesses in consumer shops have turned into web services and utilized the recently developed paradigms of business,
like as electronic product suppliers, virtual storefront, dealing brokers, auction houses, and online services. Most succeeded websites
assure the importance of website evaluation and human computer interaction, however the applications of e-commerce differs
crucially. A kind of usability assessment techniques has been produced that can be applied to recognize E-commerce site usability
issues. These techniques can be categorized using the identification of usability issues by users, evaluators, or software tools. In this
study, Alexa is applied to evaluate E-commerce sites. Also, The evaluation was conducted using a survey method. Six E-commerce
sites were inspected. From the findings, the site amazon.com is the most popular site and has good usability. Similarly, The feedback
of the analysis show that most organizations apply the functions of marketing distributed reasonably in quality measurements of
services.
Keywords: E-commerce, Website Evaluation, E-commerce Website, Usability, Human Computer Interaction, Alexa.
1.
INTRODUCTION
In general, the fast progress of information and
computer technology and, especially, the internet has
considerably varied the business production. It is vastly
assumed that the Internet can provide an efficient business
tool [1][2][3].
The world wide web (WWW) is an interconnection of
computer system networks that supplies data and services
to web users. Web Servers are services and information to
computer systems provided by other computer systems in
this interconnection of networks. Computer systems that
request information and services called Web Browsers.
The channel of communication between the client (web
browser) and server (web host) is established by ISP
(Internet Service Provider) that grants admission to the
web for both the customer and server. A request/response
paradigm used in the client communication with the
server. The client, via the channel of communication
makes a request to a server and it responds to that request
[4].
With respect to the internet publication is no central
ruling body. It's exceedingly comfortable, inexpensive and
fast to put out along the internet. The quality control
system hasn’t existed due to the underlying kind of
WWW (World Wide Web). It will remain unregulated
and unmonitored too. This, subsequently, drops a great
duty on the user to be critical and careful in the website
evaluation that is you utilize. Since the start of trading
Internet tools in the early 1990s, considerable researchers
have noticed the power of the internet in the commerce,
and supported integrating the world wide web into the
business production [2][3][5].
2.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
By concentrating on speed, accuracy, network design,
automation and reverse logistics, retailers can implement
sales fulfillment strategies that anticipate and exceed
consumer needs. Actually, users want to choose most used
web services with a better trade-off between quality and
E-mail: sahr_ar@yahoo.com, saismail@pnu.edu.sa, sahar.hassan@feng.bu.edu.eg
http://journals.uob.edu.bh
466
Sahar A. El_Rahman & Naglaa F. Soliman: Evaluation of E-Commerce Web-Based Systems
cost. Users can select web services based on Visits Index
ranking where they only spend their money on ecommerce with 8 % of their earning [6][7][8].
A) E-commerce
Till now, the website isn't being played as a source of
information only, but likewise as media of
communications and also, in the media of commercial
activities. Web sites that supply channels of the electronic
services/goods purchase and sale are called E-commerce
websites. It is specified as a single method to supply
services. Recently developed competition issue among the
organizations is created by the website, i.e. by quality
comparison between E-commerce sites of them
[9][10][11][12].
E) E-Commerce and Network Security
The main focus of E-commerce web security are the
secure transmission, web server security and some
concern with client-side security. If the transmission
channel and web server are safe, the client can be greatly
assured that the client's security expectations will be
encountered. For an acceptable premise of secured online
business, the web security is necessary. Where web
security is concerned with preventing attacks on websites
which are classified as attacks on information and
accessibility [4][19][20][21][22][23].
B) How to Evaluate a Website
Since the former 1990s, Various approaches in
assessing websites have been proposed by the researchers
of universities. The widely used techniques involve
benchmarking, capacity analysis, case work, experiment,
survey, and online evaluation [3]. Although many people
evaluate websites (especially trading websites) depending
completely on the websites appearance and behavior.
Then, we must proceed to evaluate for several quality
measures in the scope of accuracy, integrity, security,
support and impartiality. Websites evaluation criteria
have been offered in several settings in later years. In this
scope, researchers strive to decide the principle
evaluation factors for e-commerce and services [13].
C) Usability
Usability is a way to produce development which
integrates user feedback through the cycle of
development so as to decrease costs and generate the
products and applications that meet user demands. It is
the learnability and the use easily of human made themes
(see Figure 1). Also ,it is considered as testing that the
products work completely and well [14][15]. The
customers’ choice is affected by the usability on the web.
For a service or product to be actually forced, it has to
engage with human at various levels as indicated in
Figure 2 [14][16].
D) Alexa
Alexa is a known software tool to calculate the internet
traffic statistics, that gives a flow data range and several
indicators showing the quality and credibility of the
websites, like as external links, bounce rate, ...and so
forth [17][18].
Figure 1. Illustration of Usability Attributes
Figure 2. Illustration of User Engagement Levels
3.
METHODOLOGY
The first matter that each establishment will like to
distinguish the universe of its existence is out of its
electronic website. The best website could support the
gathering of the objectives of the owner and the users, the
most successful, the website will exist [24]. The higher
the usability website has a tendency to catch further links.
It has likewise been indicated that SE (Search Engine)
creates a big balance of the traffic on the web and the
generality of current SE techniques have a tendency to
present heavily related websites foremost. In this work,
the aims were sought to be settled through.
Using Alexa it is possible to gauge the volume of the
web traffic for a specific site. Also, it gave the
situation and circumstances for any website looked
in at: to whom it may concern, how regularly, it was
http://journals.uob.edu.bh
Int. J. Com. Dig. Sys. 5, No.6, 465-472 (Nov-2016)
467
modified, how many other websites indicated to it,
and how many screens it encountered.
have been proceeded to inspect the design and the
usability of the E-commerce websites.
Assessing the prototyping and other E-commerce
website usability through a questionnaire. A sample
of 51 stakeholders (managers, employees, and
customers with different nationalities) makes a
response to the questionnaire was given to them.
Information from the questionnaire was compiled,
formed and studied.
Collecting the information in an efficient way by
using a survey that was prepared based on HCI
(Human Computer Interaction) conception, an
abbreviated version of the feedback is indicated in
Figure 3.
Alexa utilized to assess E-commerce sites usability.
As a preliminary step, Using software tools like Alexa to
issue an easy, cheap, and quick indicator of prospect
usability problems on E-commerce websites and their
screens. By applying the planned procedures could
support to cut back both valuation and time expenses. The
usability of some known E-commerce websites
(Amazon1, Ebay2, Souq3, Jollychic4, Sa.Namshi5, and
Sukar6) were evaluated together using Alexa, the results
and the statistics are indicated in Figure 4, Figure 5,
Figure 6, Figure 7, Figure 8, Figure 9 and Table 1.
Figure 3. A Summary of Results
4.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The web pages usability is evaluated utilizing several
paradigms. Academic researchers debate that a lot of
recommendations and results of usability need
experimental and empirical data. E-commerce websites
are selected as matters to this work. A set of experiments
Figure 4. Results of Q1: How Engaged Are Visitors to the ECommerce Websites?
1
www.amazon.com
www. ebay.com
www.saudi.souq.com
4
www.jollychic.com
5
www.namshi.com
6
www.sukar.com
2
3
http://journals.uob.edu.bh
468
Sahar A. El_Rahman & Naglaa F. Soliman: Evaluation of E-Commerce Web-Based Systems
5. Results ofwebsites?
Q2: How popular is the e-commerce websites?
Figure 5. Results of Q2: How popularFigure
is the e-commerce
http://journals.uob.edu.bh
Int. J. Com. Dig. Sys. 5, No.6, 465-472 (Nov-2016)
www.jollychic.com
www.namshi.com
www.sukar.com
www. ebay.com
SUMMARY OF ALEXA REPORTS
www.saudi.souq.com
TABLE I.
7.2
7.1
7.4
6.9
8.1
6.1
6.3
7.8
7.8
7.4
8.7
7.8
7.0
7.6
8.8
8.5
7.6
6.6
7.7
9.0
5.9
5.5
6.7
6.1
6.8
Code quality
0.4
1.4
2.1
1.7
1.7
Local presence
1.4
1.4
2.5
2.5
5
Overall
(The overall score for this website?)
Accessibility
(How accessible the website is to
mobile and disabled users?)
Experience
(How satisfying the website is likely
to be for users?)
Marketing
(How well marketed and popular the
website is?)
Technology
(How well designed and built the
website is?)
5.
469
CONCLUSION
Aside from being qualified to distinguish among the
fiction and fact, it is significant to be capable of
appraising the security, accuracy, currency, usability and
data content to specific use. Utilizing data resources with
imperfect quality or worse still - quoting misinformation –
will put down the work quality. However E-Commerce
website evaluation has permanently been high
importance, such tone is especially significant when
utilizing details established on the Trading.
E-commerce continues to develop in importance as a
sales channel, and customer expectations have been
higher. Hence, business organizations want to measure
and enhance their E-commerce sites in a manner in order
to increase their successfulness. The website evaluation is
essentially beneficial for leaders of business organizations
that may be concerned with recognizing usability issues
on their websites and making the design better to fit the
stakeholders' demands. The website evaluation, that
specifically determines the efficiency and effectiveness of
these sites. It subsequently supports business
organizations to find the usability procedures that best
meet their needs. It is anticipated that the website
evaluation will support e-commerce organization in
making the suitable decision concerning that usability
procedures to use and how to use it to update the usability
of their websites partially or totally, that might support
growing their profit. Considering the core services
proportion, content rich sites achieve enjoyment fairly
high ranking in Alexa.
Figure 6. Results of Q3: Who Visits the E-Commerce Websites?
http://journals.uob.edu.bh
470
Sahar A. El_Rahman & Naglaa F. Soliman: Evaluation of E-Commerce Web-Based Systems
Figure 7. Results of Q4: Where Are the Sites Visitors Located to the
Figure 7. Results of Q4: Where Are the Sites Visitors Located to the E-Commerce
Websites?
E-Commerce
Websites?
http://journals.uob.edu.bh
Int. J. Com. Dig. Sys. 5, No.6, 465-472 (Nov-2016)
471
Figure 9. Results of Q6: How Fast Dose The E-Commerce Websites
Load?
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The author would like to thank all the participants
involved in this work.
REFERENCES
Figure 8. Results of Q5: Where Do the E-Commerce Website Visitors
Come from?
[1]
Ali H. Al-Badi, Ali O. Al Majeeni, Pam J. Mayhew and Abdullah
S. Al-Rashdi, “Improving Website Ranking through Search
Engine Optimization“, Journal of Internet and e-business Studies,
IBIMA Publishing, Vol. 2011, pp. 1-11, 2011.
[2]
Rob Lawa, Shanshan Qi a, Dimitrios Buhalis, “Progress in
tourism management: A review of website evaluation in tourism
research”, Journal of Tourism Management, © 2009 Elsevier Ltd.
All rights reserved, Vol. 31, pp. 297–313, 2010.
[3]
Wen-Chih Chiou, Chin-Chao Lin and Chyuan Perng, “A strategic
website evaluation of online travel agencies”, Journal of Tourism
Management, © 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved, Vol. 32,
pp 1463-1473, 2011.
[4]
R. J. Boncella, “Web Security for E-Commerce”,
Communications of AIS (Association of Information Systems),
Volume 4, Article 11, 2000.
[5]
Feng-Jyh Lin, Kunhuang Huarng, Yi-Min Chen and Shu-Ming
Lin, “Quality Evaluation of Web Services”, Proceedings of the
IEEE International Conference on E-Commerce Technology for
Dynamic E-Business (CEC-East’04).
[6]
Gang Wang and Kunming Nie, “ A Framework of VI-based
Ranking and Recommendation of Web Services”, 6th
international Conference on Internet Technology and Secured
Transactions, ©2011 IEEE, United Arab Emirates, pp. 478-483.
[7]
Souheil Badran, “What Merchants Need to Know About CrossBorder eCommerce “, © 2008 First Data Corporation. All rights
reserved.
http://journals.uob.edu.bh
472
Sahar A. El_Rahman & Naglaa F. Soliman: Evaluation of E-Commerce Web-Based Systems
[8]
Hsieh, Hui-Ching, Yen-Chiu Chen, and He-Chih Lin. "More
precise: Stores recommendation under O2O commerce."
International Journal of Computing and Digital Systems 3.2
(2014): 91-99.
[9]
Farah Shafira Effendi and Ika Alfina, “Quality Evaluation of
Airline’s E-Commerce Website, A Case Study of AirAsia and
Lion Air Websites”, ICACSIS 2014, © 2014 IEEE, pp. 125-128.
[10] Chen-Yuan Chen, Bih-Yaw Shih1, Zih-Siang Chen and TsungHao Chen, “The exploration of internet marketing strategy by
search engine optimization: A critical review and comparison”,
African Journal of Business Management Vol. 5(12), pp. 46444649, 18 June, 2011. ©2011 Academic Journals Review.
Available online at http://www.academicjournals.org/AJBM
[11] John Lowe and Atif Ali Khan I,”E-commerce Fulfillment
Execution Essentials”, © Cognizant 20-20 Insights, March2013.
[12] Ajantha Herath , Yousif Al-Bastaki and Suvineetha Herath, “Task
based Interdisciplinary E-Commerce Course with UML Sequence
Diagrams, Algorithm Transformations and Spatial Circuits to
Boost Learning Information Security Concepts”, International
Journal of Computing and Digital Systems , Vol. 2, No. 2, pp. 7987, 2013.
[13] Wen-Hsien Tsai, Wen-Chin Chou and Chien-Wen Lai, “An
effective evaluation model and improvement analysis for national
park websites: A case study of Taiwan”, Journal of Tourism
Management, ©2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved, Vol. 31, pp
936–952, 2010.
[14] Layla Hasan, Anne Morris, Steve Probets, (2013) "E‐commerce
websites for developing countries – a usability evaluation
framework", Online Information Review, Vol. 37, No. 2, pp.231 –
251.
[15] Saad Subair, “Assessing the Usability of Institutions Web Pages”,
International Journal of Internet and Distributed Systems, 2014, 2,
pp. 15-21.
[16] Nagpal, Renuka, et al. "FAHP approach to rank educational
websites on usability." Int J Com Dig Syst 4.4 (2015): 251-260.
[17] Xiaoqiang Li, Yun Mi, Yingwei Jin, Heng Qi and Zhiyang Li, “A
Novel System for Evaluating Website Using Link Analysis “,
©2012 IEEE, 11th International Conference on Trust, Security
and Privacy in Computing and Communications
[18] Alexa, http://www.alexa.com/
[19] Drew, G. Using SET for Secure Electronic Commerce, PrenticeHall, Upper Saddle River, NJ, 1999.
[20] Garfinkel, S. and Spafford, G. Web Security & Commerce,
O'Reilly and Associates, Cambridge, MA, 1997.
[21] Rubin, A., Geer, D., and Ranum, M., Web Security Sourcebook,
Wiley, New York, NY, 1997.
[22] Mark S. Ackerman and Donald T. Davis, Jr. , “Privacy and
Security Issues in E-Commerce”, Chapter 39, New Economy
Handbook, Copyright 2003, Elsevier Science (USA).
Sahar Abd El_Rahman was born in
Cairo, Egypt, B.Sc. Electronics &
Communication Branch, Electrical
Engineering Department, Faculty of
EngineeringShoubra,
Benha
University (previously Branch from
Zagazig University) – Cairo, Egypt in
May 1997. She had the first rank over
all graduates in all academic
evaluations. M.Sc. in an AI Technique
Applied
to
Machine
Aided
Translation, Electronic Engineering,
Electrical Engineering Department, Faculty of EngineeringShoubra, Benha University – Cairo, Egypt, May2003. Ph.D. in
Reconstruction of High-Resolution Image from a Set of LowResolution Images, Electronic Engineering, Electrical
Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering- Shoubra,
Benha University – Cairo, Egypt in Jan2008.
She is Assistant Professor from 2008 till now at Electronics
& communication, and Computer Systems Branch, Electrical
Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering-Shoubra,
Benha University, Cairo, Egypt. She was a Lecture in the same
location since 2003 and an Instructor in the same location in
1998.
Dr. Sahar has published many papers in national and
international journals and conferences. Her research interests
include Computer Vision, Image Processing, Signal Processing,
Information Security, Human Computer Interaction, E-Health,
Big Data and Cloud Computing. She immersed herself in
conducting research in the chosen area of specialization, guiding
Ph.D. and M.Sc. students and teaching at undergraduate and
postgraduate level.
Dr. Sahar is a member of IACSIT (International Association
of Computer Science and Information Technology) since 2013.
A member of Internet Society (ISOC) since 2015, a member of
IAENG (International Association of Engineers) since 2011, and
a member of the Egyptian Engineers’ Syndicate since 1997.
Naglaa F. Soliman received the B.Sc.,
M.Sc., and Ph.D. degrees from the
faculty of Engineering, Zagazig
University, Egypt in 1999, 2004, and
2011, respectively. She is currently a
lecturer at the Department of
Electronics and Communications
Engineering, Faculty of Engineering,
Zagazig University. Her areas of
interest are digital communications,
signal processing, image processing,
and coding.
[23] Aly M. Elsemary, Abdullah A. AlAnoor, Ahmad A. Alshammari,
and Abdulaziz E. Aljohani,” Secure Hybrid Payment System in
KSA”, International Journal of Computing and Digital Systems,
Vol. 5, No.1, pp. 59-71, 2016.
[24] Ahmad Bakeri Abu Bakar, “Evaluating the Accessibility and
Visibility of Quran Websites”, ©2010 IEEE, Information
Technology (ITSim), 2010 International Symposium in, Kuala
Lumpur, Vol.1, pp. 1-4.
http://journals.uob.edu.bh