Guendalina Graffigna, Janice M.Morse, A.Claudio Bosio
(Eds.)
ENGAGING PEOPLE IN
HEALTH PROMOTION & WELL BEING
New opportunities and challenges
for qualitative research
Proceedings of the
2 Global Congress for Qualitative Health
Research
nd
www.vitaepensiero.it
All rights reserved. Photocopies for personal use of the reader, not exceeding 15% of
each volume, may be made under the payment of a copying fee to the SIAE, in
accordance with the provisions of the law n. 633 of 22 april 1941 (art. 68, par. 4 and
5). Reproductions which are not intended for personal use may be only made with
the written permission of CLEARedi, Centro Licenze e Autorizzazioni per le
Riproduzioni Editoriali, Corso di Porta Romana 108, 20122 Milano, e-mail:
autorizzazioni@clearedi.org, web site www.clearedi.org
© 2012 Vita e Pensiero - Largo A. Gemelli, 1 - 20123 Milano
ISBN 978-88-343-2251-2
SCIENTIFIC COMMITEE
EDITORIAL COMMITTEE
Prof. JANICE MORSE
University of Utah, USA
Prof. JANICE MORSE
University of Utah, USA
Prof. A.CLAUDIO BOSIO
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore
Prof. A.CLAUDIO BOSIO
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
Prof. KERRY CHAMBERLAIN
Massey University in Auckland
Prof. GUENDALINA GRAFFIGNA
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
Prof. ELVIRA CICOGNANI
University of Bologna, Italy
Prof. EDOARDO LOZZA
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
Prof. CÉSAR A. CISNEROS PUEBLA
Autonomous Metropolitan UniversityIztapalapa, Mexico
Dr. SERENA BARELLO
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
Prof. JULIET M. CORBIN
San Jose State University, USA
Prof. SEUNG EUN CHUNG
Korea National University of
Transportation, Korea
Prof. GIAMPIETRO GOBO
Università degli Studi di Milano, Italy
Prof. GUENDALINA GRAFFIGNA
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
Prof. EDOARDO LOZZA
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
Prof. MARIA MAYAN
University of Alberta, Canada
Prof. KARIN OLSON
University of Alberta, Canada
Prof. WALTER RICCIARDI
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
Prof. JONATHAN A SMITH
Birkbeck University of London, UK
Prof. MASSIMILIANO TAROZZI
University of Trento, Italy
Prof. IRINA TODOROVA
Northeastern University, Boston, USA
Prof. SUSAN TURALE
Yamaguchi University, Japan
Dr. CHIARA LIBRERI
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
M.SS SILVIA BRANCA
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
4
Contents
EDITORIAL .............................................................................................7
INVITED SPEECHES ...........................................................................15
SYMPOSIA.............................................................................................23
ORAL PRESENTATIONS....................................................................45
POSTERS..............................................................................................189
AUTHOR INDEX.................................................................................241
KEY WORDS .......................................................................................255
5
6
Editorial
Qualitative research has for long time considered health as an area of primary
interest where to test its capacity to identify new research topics, to develop
theoretical paradigms and methods of inquiry, and to generate applications
important for individuals and society (Pope, 1995; Jones, 1995; Grypdonck , 2006;
Morse, 2007; Morse, 2010). The richness of the results produced is well known and
documented, and it is – of this I am certain – confirmed by the papers presented at
this Conference.
Nevertheless, this richness has also fostered the growth of a plurality of approaches
in the area of Qualitative Health Research (QHR) and a marked fragmentation of the
discipline into sub-specialties (Creswell, 1997). In order to support the construction
of an effective overview of QHR, it seems that the time has come to “take the bull
by the horns”, as Janice Morse (2011) suggested, in promoting the Second Global
Congress for Qualitative Health Research (GCQHR) project by, for example,
identifying an important topic which traverses the various theoreticalmethodological positions, and from which to start in developing broad dialogue
between researchers and practitioners working in the area of health.
From this point of view, the theme “Engaging People in Health and Well-being
Promotion” (EPH&WBP) seems to have a number promising features which I shall
now briefly discuss, focusing on the key words in the conference theme one by one.
“People”
recognizing the ‘lay’ (psycho-socio-cultural) dimension of health
The reference to “people” confronts us with a first feature that seems essential for a
psycho-socio-cultural approach to health and, more specifically, for a discipline like
QHR.
Historically, the scientific approach to health has consisted in the production of a
system of ‘expert’ knowledge alternative to, and dominant over, the ‘non-expert’
7
(lay, folk, naive) knowledge systems produced by the social field. The bio-medical
paradigm – fundamental to Parsons’ (1951) theory of the doctor-patient relation – is
the pivotal and prototypical expression of this tendency, even if it is not the only one
(analogous attitudes are also to be found in the most recent approaches to the
organizational management of health services: see Bosio, Graffigna & Scaratti, in
press.
This position has given rise to a clear propensity to scientifically underestimate the
importance of interacting with the ‘lay’ health actors (i.e. people) and with their
knowledge systems.
For too long the bio-medical sciences have believed themselves able to manage
health self-referentially, configuring the relationship with social actors in terms of
pure passive adjustment to medical knowledge (Haug & Bebe,1983; Emanuel &
Emanuel, 1992). Only in the past thirty years (Engel, 1980) the proposal of a biopsycho-social paradigm alternative to the traditional ‘doctor/medicine-centred’
model has fostered the advent of a psycho-socio-cultural approach in the health area
also open to the contribution of qualitative research (Morse, Swason & Kuzel,
2001).
This development has come about on the basis of increasing awareness that if
medicine is to be efficacious in its action, it must recognize the patient: that is, it
must learn to converse and to cooperate with him or her (Kazaree et al. 1978;
Friedman & Di Matteo 1979; Zola, 1981).
Openness to the ‘patient’, in fact, has led to scientific analysis of that system of
health knowledge expressed by the ‘lay’ actor (people) hitherto largely excluded
from scientific inquiry. And this, still today, is an open challenge for the human
sciences, and for QHR in particular (Morse, 2011).
2. “Engaging”
management
supporting proactiveness and people’s participation in health
The psycho-socio-cultural analysis of health has generated a wide variety of
research programmes concerning - amongst others - : the experiences of health and
illness and the subjective construction of such experiences (Pelzang, 2010); the
knowledge systems which regulate health (expertise, beliefs, representations...)
produced in social contexts (Kleinman, 1988; Leventhal et al., 2006; Betancourt et
al., 2000); the social construction of health practices and the participation of lay
actors in the construction of those practices (Gruman et al., 2010); information and
empowerment strategies in the area of health (William & Pace, 2009).
It would fall outside the scope of this contribute to conduct a systematic review of
the principal lines of inquiry in which QHR has produced significant results.
However, one tendency is evident: the more knowledge about the lay actors in
health area expands, the more obvious is the need to investigate the conditions that
8
lead to their involvement in health management (Hibbard, 2004, 2007; Cayton,
2006). In short, the reasons for research tend to interweave with applicative reasons,
and the need to understand people tends to merge with the need to sustain their
proactiveness in health management.
The reference to engagement – for some time increasingly present in the literature
(Coulter, 2012; Osborn & Squires, 2012) – seems to take up the challenge to create a
synthesis between theory and practice, between knowledge and action, between
diagnosis and planning, between scientific discovery and participatory action.
Yet still today the challenge appears uncertain in its outcomes. Indeed, the reference
to engagement in health, stresses the need for strong applicative commitment by a
discipline like QHR, but it leaves entirely unspecified the task of
comparison/integration among the various approaches coexisting in this discipline
according to their purpose. What linkage can be established among the various
theoretical and paradigmatic orientations of QHR so as to meet the challenge of
engagement in health satisfactorily?
This is a task that we can all share. On the quality of our responses will ultimately
depend the possibility of giving concreteness to a word (“engagement”) that today
seems already perilously susceptible to purely rhetorical, suggestive or
pragmatically myopic development (Thomson, 2005).
The question now is: how can we best use the multiple theoretical and
methodological resources of qualitative research to facilitate the active involvement
of social actors as co-constructors of their health?
Developing a multi-faceted
3. “Engaging people in health and well-being”
approach.
Finally, the conference theme comprises a third topic of interest. The involvement of
people in health entails recognition of a complex set of actors and situations that can
furnish decisive stimulus for the development of QHR. This complexity can be
divided between two main directions.
a) The first concerns the expansion of the theme from the area of illness to that of
the maintenance of health through the active promotion of well-being. This is a
well-known movement that has origins both cultural (Gergen, 1991) and
political (Reinhardt & Cheng, 2000), and which also has counterparts in science
(Monat, Lazarus & Reevy, 2007).
One aspect of this tendency should be emphasised: the more the approach to
health is configured in the positive terms of promoting well-being, the more
attention to the psycho-socio-cultural (“lay”) dimension of health becomes
necessary. The locus of reference for well-being is more the social sphere than
that of care and the health services.
9
b) A second direction concerns the specificity of the contributions in which social
actors can situate and define themselves. In this regard, it is possible to identify
three, increasingly complex, prototypical patterns.
• The patient dimension. This is the most historically established and familiar
level. Here, the theme of engagement is closely bound up with the practices
of diagnosis and medical treatment and with role of patient assumed by the
social actor.
• The network dimension. The social actor is configured as a diversified
collective entity (couple, family, reference group, community, etc.) engaged
in different tasks in the health area (care, prevention, promotion of wellbeing).
• The extended social dimension. This is the domain in which public opinion
is constructed and consensus on health policies is regulated.
In recent years, QHR seems to have developed specific research agenda at all three
of the levels just described. However, research should pay more attention to those
situations in which the social actor is categorized as a single individual (patient). In
particular, the third level (the more properly social one) still appears to be poor in
contributions, although there seems to be no lack of crucial topics: consider, for
example, social communication on health, or participatory action in the construction
and choice of health policies (see Bosio, Graffigna & Scaratti, in press).
Conclusions
The EPH&WBP perspective tends today to be both an opportunity and a challenge
for QHR.
How should researchers respond to an issue of major ecological importance by
developing scientifically well-founded knowledge? How can they remain faithful to,
and consistent with, their own theoretical and methodological lances and at the
same time develop good collaboration-conversation with other researchers with
different orientations? How can they combine advances in knowledge and practical
applications so as to build scientific and social value for QHR?
It seems to me that these are the important questions for the future of our discipline.
The conference programme inspires confidence that this meeting will make a
significant contribution in this expected direction.
Prof. Bosio, A.C.
Chair of 2nd GCQHR,
Faculty of Psychology, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
10
References
Betancourt, J.R., Green, A.R., Carrillo, J.E., Ananeh-Firempong, O. (2003).
Defining cultural competence: a practical framework for addressing racial/ethnic
disparities in health and health care. Public Health Reports, 118:293-302.
Bosio, A.C., Graffigna,G. & Scaratti, G. (accepted in press). Knowing, learning and
acting in health care organizations and services: challenges and opportunities for
qualitative research. Qualitative Research in Organization and Management.
Cayton, H. (2006). The flat-pack patient? Creating health together. Patient
Education and Counseling, 62:288-290.
Contrada, R.J., Ashmore, R.D. (eds). (1999). Self, social identity, and
physical health, Oxford University Press, New York, 185-208.
Coulter, A. (2012). Patient engagement-what works? Journal of Ambulatory Care
Management, 35:80-89.
Creswell, J. W. (1997). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among
five traditions. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Emanuel, E. J., L.L. Emanuel. (1992). “Four Models of the Physician Patient
Relationship.” Journal of the American Medical Association, 267:2221-2226.
Engel, G.L. (1980). The clinical application of the biopsychosocial model. American
Journal of Psychiatry, 137:535-544.
Friedman, H.S., Di Matteo, M.R. (1979). Health care as an interpersonal
process. Journal of Social Issues, 35.
Gergen, K.J. (1991). The saturated self. New York: Basic Books.
Gruman, J., Rovner, M.H., French, M.E., Jeffress, D., Sofaer, S., Shaller, D., Prager
D.J. (2010). From patient education to patient engagement: Implications for the field
of patient education . Patient Education and Counseling, 78:350-356.
Grypdonck, M.H.F. (2006). Qualitative health research in the era of evidence-based
practice. Qualitative Health Research, 16:1371-1385.
Haug, M.R., Bebe, L. (1983). Consumerism in Medicine: Challenging Physician
Authority. Beverly Hills: Sage.
Hibbard, J.H., Mahoney, E.R., Stock, R., Tusler, M. (2007). Do increases in patient
activation result in improved self-management behaviors? Health Service Research,
42:1443-1463.
11
Hibbard, J.H., Stockard, J., Mahoney, E.R., Tusler, M. (2004). Development of the
Patient Activation Measure (PAM): conceptualizing and measuring activation in
patients and consumers. Health Service Research, 39:1005-1026.
Jones, J. (1995). Qualitative Research: Consensus methods for medical and health
services research. British Medical Journal, 311:376.
Kazaree, A., Eisenthal, S., Frank, A., Stoekle, S. (1978). Studies on a negotiated
approach to patienthood. In Gallager E.B. (ed). The doctor patient relationship in
the changing health scene, Department of Health, Education and Welfare,
Washington.
Kleinman, A., Eisenberg, L., Good, B. (1978). Culture, illness, and care: clinical
lessons from anthropologic and cross-cultural research. Annals of
Internal
Medicine, 88:251-258.
Kleinman, A. (1988). The illness narratives: suffering, healing and the human
condition. New York: Basic Books.
Kleinman, A., Benson, P. (2006). Anthropology in the clinic: the problem of cultural
competency and how to fix it. PLoS Medicine, 3:294.
Leventhal, H., Benyamini, Y., Brownlee, S., Diefenbach, M., Leventhal, E.A.,
Patrick-Miller, L., et al. (1997). Illness representations: theoretical foundations. In:
Petrie, K.J., Weinman, J. (eds). Perceptions of health and illness. 155-88.
Amsterdam: Harwood Academic.
Monat, A., Lazarus, R.S., Reevy, G. (eds). (2007). The pager handbook on stress
and coping (Vol 1). Westport, Connecticut: Praeger.
Morse, J.M., Swanson, J., Kuzel, A. (eds). (2001). The nature of evidence in
qualitative inquiry. Thousand oaks, CA: Sage.
Morse, J.M. (2007) What is the domain of qualitative health research? Qualitative
Health Research. 17, 715-717.
Morse, J.M. (2010). Editorial: Two decades
research. Qualitative Health Research, 20:291-292.
of qualitative
health
Morse, J.M. (2011). Global congress for qualitative health research. Qualitative
Health Research, 3:299-300.
Osborn, R., Squires, D. (2012). International perspectives on patient engagement:
Results from the 2011 commonwealth fund survey. Journal of Ambulatory Care
Management, 35:118-128.
Parsons, T. (1951). The social system. Free Press, Glencoe, IL.
12
Pelzang, R. (2010). Time to learn: understanding patient-centred care. British
Journal of Nursing, 19:912-917.
Pope, C. (1995). Qualitative Research: Reaching the parts other methods cannot
reach: an introduction to qualitative methods in health and health services research.
British Medical Journal, 311:42-45.
Reinhardt, U., Cheng., T. (2000). The world health report 2000 – Health systems:
improving performance. Bullettin World Health Organization, 78:1064.
Thomson, R., Murtagh, M., Khaw, F.M. (2005). Tensions in public health policy:
patient engagement, evidence-based public health and health inequalities.
Quality & Safety in Health Care, 14:398-400.
Zola, I.K. (1981). Structural constraints in the doctor patient relationship: the case of
non-compliance, in Eisemberg, L., Kleinmann, A. (eds). The Relevance of Social
Science in Medicine, 241-252. Reidel London.
Williams, B., Pace, A. (2009). Problem based learning in chronic disease
management: A review of the research. Patient Education and Counselling, 77:1419.
13
14
Invited speeches
Key-note lecture
THE GLOBAL DISSEMINATION OF QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
Morse, J.
University of Utah, USA
Social science research is in the midst of an enormous methodological transition,
adding to—expanding—our abilities and capabilities as researchers. In the past two
decades, qualitative methods emerged from anthropology and sociology into the
applied disciplines—especially into education and health—expanding our repertoire
of research methods. Qualitative methods provided us with the abilities to elicit the
individuals’ experience, to recognize actual patterns of experience. It expanded our
abilities to form on one hand, better, and more pertinent concepts and more accurate
theory, and on the other, enabled a stronger theoretical base to enhance
measurement.
The issue for discussion today concerns us all: How are qualitative methods
disseminated globally? How do those with the barriers of language, distance, lack
of mentors, and courses, access qualitative methods? Today, taking a slightly
historical approach, I will explore the global dissemination of qualitative inquiry.
Within this picture, I will “diagnosis” of the state of the art of qualitative health
research, and discuss its present and future developmental directions.
15
Pre – workshops
SOFTWARE FOR QUALITATIVE DATA ANALYSIS: TECHNOLOGY
AND METHODOLOGY CONVERGENCES ON QUALITATIVE HEALTH
RESEARCH
Cisneros Puebla, C.A.
Department of Sociology, Autonomous Metropolitan University-Iztapalapa, Mexico
This workshop focuses on how some specific software such as ATLAS.ti,
MAXQDA, QDAMiner and NVivo, among other programs, supports qualitative
data analysis in health research. A methodological discussion on how computer
assisted qualitative data analysis software is creatively shaping our ways of
gathering, classifying, analyzing and visualizing human, spatial and social processes
is the main issue to be considered. The sum of diverse sources of data,
synchronization of some of them in several ways and integration of geographic
dimensions into qualitative analysis projects adds news perspectives to shape
contextual and situational angles to a study. The workshop necessarily presents the
role and impact of computer assisted qualitative data analysis software on
methodologies used by qualitative health researchers; these topics will be presented
in a seminar-style by the instructor rather than a hands-on format. Technology and
methodology convergences are the scenery to comparatively evaluate the present
and the future of qualitative health research assisted by such qualitative data analysis
software.
BUILDING THEORIES FROM DATA
Corbin, J.M.
University of Alberta, Canada
This workshop focuses on the use of grounded theory method to develop a
substantive theory. It begins with a discussion of why theory is still an important
research objective. It presents some of the major components of a theory and
differentiates it from descriptive research. It then explains how Corbin constructed
the theory of "Protective Governing" starting at the initial question to an overview
of the final theoretical formulation. Aspects of the grounded theory method will be
16
incorporated into the presentation to show how the researcher arrived at her final
formulation. Then using a set of evaluative criteria participants will be asked to read
and critique published articles that utilized grounded theory methodology.
RETHINKING SAMPLING AND GENERALIZATION IN QUALITATIVE
RESEARCH
Gobo, G.
Università degli Studi di Milano, Italy
This workshop deals with three distinct and important issues in qualitative
methodology: sampling, representativeness and generalizability. Sampling in
qualitative research is contentious. On one hand, it is often neglected by qualitative
researchers who deem it as a positivistic worry; on the other hand, it has been
undervalued by quantitative researchers because it is a non-probabilistic approach
and cannot be used to generalize to a population. Fortunately, in contemporary
qualitative research, the problem of representativeness is a constant and growing
concern of several researchers. Finally, the issue of generalization is something
inevitable: why spend time and resources to conduct a study if you cannot transfer
its results to other contexts? Qualitative researchers need to rethink these old issues
with a new frame. We can have generalizations without probability.
ONLINE QUALITATIVE HEALTH RESEARCH: INTERNET AS A NEW
MEDIUM AND TERRITORY FOR HEALTH RESEARCH
Graffigna, G.
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
The Internet is acquiring growing importance both as a source of information and as
a medium for people with the same illness experiences, feelings and doubts to
establish contact with each other. From this perspective, the Internet is a powerful
tool where patients (and their caregivers) can build relationships, exchange
empathy, empowerment each other, and obtain advice and suggestions to improve
their wellbeing. As a consequence, healthcare professionals are paying growing
attention to the Internet as a new medium and scope for health intervention.
17
In particular, the Internet offers important opportunities and challenges to
qualitative health research as it generates new objects (and subjects) of inquiry as
well as configures itself as a new medium for data construction. In this workshop,
the latest technical and methodological developments of online qualitative methods
and techniques applied to health issues will be discussed.
COMMUNITY-BASED PARTICIPATORY RESEARCH:
PEOPLE AS AGENTS OF THEIR OWN HEALTH
ENGAGING
Mayan, M.
University of Alberta, Canada
Community-based participatory research (CBPR) is gaining broad attention as an
approach for addressing the complex factors that contribute to the health and wellbeing of individuals, families, and communities. CBPR is a collaborative process
that equitably involves all partners in the research process and recognizes the
unique strengths that each brings. CBPR's increasing popularity among researchers
from all fields stems from its potential in maximizing the relevance, rigor, and
results of research. This workshop will introduce the learner to the foundations of
CBPR, terms and definitions, ethics, criticism and current relevance for engaging
people as decision-makers in their health and well-being.
QUALITATIVE DRIVEN MIXED-METHOD AND MULTIPLE-METHODS
DESIGNS
Morse, J.M.
University of Utah, USA
While mixed- and multiple-method designs have given a new interest and
legitimacy to qualitative inquiry, the role of qualitative methods is not appreciated
and often mis-represented. In this workshop, I will discuss the contribution(s) of
qualitative methods to the project as a whole. We will focus on qualitatively-driven
designs, and designs with a qualitative supplemental component. Diagramming the
study components, and listing the outcomes of each component, enables the
researcher to keep the original aims in the foreground, and enables evaluation of
18
results as the study progresses. We will specially focus on diagramming, the
theoretical trust of the project, the point of interface, and writing the results.
DOING INTERPRETATIVE PHENOMENOLOGICAL ANALYSIS: AN
INTRODUCTORY WORKSHOP
Smith, J.A.
University of London, UK.
Interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA) is an approach concerned with the
close examination of participants' lived experience. It has theoretical underpinnings
in phenomenology, hermeneutics and idiography. The last of these marks a
distinctive feature of IPA as it involves the detailed analysis of particular cases. IPA
developed in UK health psychology but has grown to be employed in a wide range
of disciplines and geographical regions. This introductory workshop will
give a brief overview of IPA's theoretical positioning and then go through the stages
involved in conducting a research project using this methodology: research design,
data collection, analysis, writing up. There will be time for some hands on practical
work during the workshop.
GROUNDED THEORY: STRATEGIES FOR DATA CODING.
Tarozzi, M.
University of Trento, Italy
This workshop will focus on an in-depth examination and application of coding in
Grounded Theory Method (GTM), including understanding the logic behind the
method. After an introduction of coding procedures in GTM - initial, focused,
theoretical - participants will be asked to practice some techniques of analysis on
real data provided by the instructor. In particular, the workshop will address,
through critical discussion, some initial and focused coding procedures.
19
Panel discussions
QUALITATIVE HEALTH RESEARCH TRAINING: WHAT MODELS IS
NEEDED FOR THE FUTURE?
Convenor:Tarozzi, M.
Università degli studi di Trento, Italy
Qualitative health research is receiving increasing recognition world-wide and
across disciplines. This is giving rise to a growing demand for training in qualitative
research skills. The proliferation of university programs in qualitative methods,
however, requires close consideration of their formative assumptions and aims in
order to optimize qualitative teaching and learning across the world and to share best
practices. This panel discussion will address the challenges faced in trainings
qualitative health researchers: What are the learning priorities? What are the topics
that must be covered? What are the strategies best suited to train future qualitative
health researchers? The panel discussion will engage experts from different
Continents and disciplines in order to cast light on a variety of experiences and
perspectives.
HEALTH POLICIES AND GOVERNANCE: AGENDA SETTING FOR
QUALITATIVE HEALTH RESEARCH
Convenor: Cicognani, E.
Università di Bologna, Italy
Healthcare organizations and services are facing important reconfigurations in
organizational culture, policies and governance across the world. These changes
have induced an increasing recognition within the scientific community that
qualitative research can contribute significant ‘ecological’ understanding of new
emerging phenomena. The changes have also guaranteed a space for qualitative
research in the process of good science.
This panel will discuss the future agenda that qualitative health research can address
given the emerging trends in policies, governance and organizational practices of
health care systems and health care providers across the world: What are the new
hot issues to be explored? What current topics can qualitative health research
20
challenge? (e.g., patient engagement, ethics, community participation)? Which new
contexts or populations should be studied? The panel discussion will engage experts
from different Continents and disciplines in order to cast light on a variety of
experiences and perspectives.
“GLOCALIZING” QUALITATIVE HEALTH RESEARCH: HOW TO FIND
A BALANCE BETWEEN GLOBAL TRADITIONS AND LOCAL
PRACTICES?
Convenor: Gobo G.
Università degli Studi di Milano, Italy
If we agree to consider scientific knowledge as a cultural product, we note that
social research methods created by a local culture are transformed into general
knowledge products including: journals, handbooks and textbooks Indeed, social
sciences methodology is one of the most globalized knowledge and knowledge
product. However these research methods have been tacitly proposed as universal,
suitable for every culture, even if they were established in “one” culture only. From
1950s, Western or American methodology was widely developed, but the relevancy
of this methodology to the EU and other places never been reflexively explored.
Qualitative Health Research is claimed to reflect and find a balance between
globalized
research
traditions
and
cultural-sensitive
practices.
For
instance,postcolonial methodologies and culturally flexible research methods are
becoming new ways of working. On the basis of these premises, the panel will
discuss a “glocal methodology”: the possibility and ambiguity of thinking
(methodologically) globally and acting (methodologically) locally.
QUALITATIVE
HEALTH
CHALLENGES, PROJECTS
RESEARCH
2020:
OPPORTUNITIES,
Convenors: Bosio, A.C. & Graffigna, G.
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore di Milano, Italy
Qualitative research has produced knowledge and insights important for healthcare
interventions. But today, qualitative research is facing an increasing demand for
efficacy and evidence. Furthermore the diffusion of new technologies in society and
the emergence of new supports to data construction and analysis force qualitative
health research to rethink its practices and to reflect on the emergence of new
research strategies and practices. The 2nd GCQHR is conceived as a critical forum
21
where academics and practitioners, belonging to different disciplines (e.g., nursing,
medicine, psychology, sociology, public health…and many others) can share
experiences matured in the field and new methodological insight. This panel will
thus involve speakers from different countries and disciplines in the aim of
addressing the new challenges, opportunities and tracks opened for the future of
qualitative health research. It will close the Congress and will symbolically act as a
bridge to the forthcoming 3rd Edition of the Congress.
22
Symposia
S1
THE PROMOTION OF THE WELL-BEING OF NURSES FOR THE
HEALTH PROTECTION OF CITIZIENS.
Chairs: Castaldo A. , Muttillo G.
Councilor at the Professional Roll IPASVI of Milan-Lodi-Monza e Brianza, Italy
The Professional Roll Ipasvi, as public corporation, represent registered
professionals - nurses, pediatric nurses and health workers - and protects the right
of citizens to receive nursing care by professionals with updated skills.
The ethical code, framed by the professional community, defines the principles and
values which nurses are based at the practice.
Based on these premises, the Professional Roll Ipasvi of the provinces of Milan,
Lodi, Monza and Brianza, recognizing the high value of research for the
development of knowledge, promoted a series of investigations aimed at citizens, as
users of care, and professional community, which providers of nursing care,
enabling a network of some professional bodies and involve many health care
institutions and scientific societies.
Two studies investigated the phenomenon of restraint, much debated topic in recent
decades, because of the implications that arise, in terms of safeguarding the
freedom of the person (also declared as a constitutional principle) on the one hand,
and protecting the safety of person (such as fall prevention, management of
aggressive behavior) on the other.
The other two studies examined the application of ethical principles in clinical
practice and professional well-being of nurses, given the fact that the assistance
23
provided by a professional in good health (both physical and mental), motivated and
valued, and that is based on shared ethical values and moral principles, is more
appropriate and higher quality.
Keywords: well-being; nurse; ethical conduct; best practices; health promotion
NARRATION AND THE CODE OF ETHICS: THE “INSTRUMENTS” FOR
AN ETHIC REFLECTION ON NURSING PRACTICE
Gobbi, P., Alagna, R., Brunoldi, A., Castaldi, M.G., Gallo, A., Marioni, L., Pari,C.,
Passoni, C., Rosa, D.
Professional Roll Ipasvi of the provinces of Milan, Lodi, Monza and Brianza, Italy
In the period from October 2009 to February 2011, each month a focus group was
carried out at the IPASVI’s venue, for a total number of 12 focus groups. They all
were about the narration of nursing clinical cases with an ethic value. All the
narrated cases were analyzed and discussed by a group of 20 nurses, using the new
Code of Ethics of nurses as the most important point of reference.
The research hypothesis, which guided the entire project, was: “Does the Code of
Ethics represent a useful/valid instrument for a nurse who has to take a decision
concerning an ethic problem in everyday nursing practice”? Each focus group
focused on the written narration of real cases that happened in hospital general units
as, for example, medicine/hospice. But also unusual areas of ethic problems, as for
example the organizational, the educational and the territorial ones, were
investigated.
The participants were asked to describe, through narration, a real, personally
experienced clinical nursing situation which generated an ethic problem in the
multidisciplinary team. The participants were given specific indications to write
their texts, in order to make the different participants’ styles as uniform as possible.
Many of the topics were: nursing the preterm newborn, the respect of the living will
of a person affected by amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, obtaining the (little) informed
consent, the administering of the abortion pill, the role of nurses in clinical trials.
The analysis was conducted using: the Code of Ethics articles related to the
problem; the analysis frame developed by professor Spinsanti of the Institute Giano
in Rome; other documentations referring to the specific topic (guidelines, scientific
societies documents, laws); the personal and professional stories of the participants.
The research hypothesis was confirmed in 9 cases out of 11: we can say that nurses
often must take decisions that not only have technical/professional content, but
which also create ethic-deontological problems with reference to the relation with
24
the other person, with the patient, the family and the colleagues. The Code of Ethics
represents a useful, valid instrument that can be used in nursing practice.
This study was the starting point for a change that is already being carried out: a
group of nurses systematically met, wanted to share through narration their
professional experience, considering emotions too, which can’t be eluded by nursing
profession.
THE NURSES ATTITUDES TOWARDS
RESTRAINT: A FOCUS GROUP STUDY
THE
USE
OF
PHYSICAL
Castaldo, A. 1, Magri, M. 1, Zanetti, E. 2, Noci, C. 2, Gazzola, M. 3, Gobbi, P. 1,
Carniel, G. 1, Crotti, E. 1, Muttillo, G. 1
1
Councilor at the Professional Roll IPASVI of Milan-Lodi-Monza e Brianza, Italy
Councilor at the Professional Roll IPASVI of Brescia, Italy
3
Councilor at the Professional Roll IPASVI of Aosta, Italy
2
This research derives from a first multicentric research that investigated the
prevalence of physical restraint in hospitals and nursing homes. The aim of this
study was to identify nurses’ motivations, attitudes, values and feelings with
reference to the use of physical restraint, and the factors favoring or discouraging it.
This qualitative study was conducted through focus groups. The sample, enrolled on
a voluntary basis, consisted of 60 nurses, 40 ward sisters and 30 nursing directors
working in nursing homes and hospitals in the Italian provinces of Aosta, Brescia,
Milan, Lodi and Monza and Brianza, and who had already been investigated in the
first research. 16 focus groups, each one consisting of four sessions of two hours,
were conducted. The interviews were recorded and transcribed verbatim, with the
consent of the participants. The content analysis of the data was validated by the
moderators together with the observers.
Nurses experience a variety of emotions, often ambivalent and conflicting, when
they apply physical restraint to a patient: anger, compassion, peace, frustration. With
regard to the attitudes and beliefs, the groups discussed the following issues: the
definition of physical restraint in terms of restriction or safety (for patient, family,
other patients and staff), and the frequency and duration of restraint: from
extraordinary intervention (as indicated in the nurses Code of Ethics) to mainly
ordinary intervention.
The study highlighted the conflict experienced by nurses with reference to the
application of restraint, especially when it is used as an ordinary action. Despite the
presence of discouraging factors, the research shown the need and intention
expressed by nurses to implement every evidence based intervention strategy that
can reduce the use of physical restraint.
25
THE USE OF PHYSICAL RESTRAINT IN HOSPITALS AND NURSING
HOMES: A MULTICENTRIC CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY
Zanetti, E. 1, Castaldo, A. 2, Miceli, R. 4, Magri, M. 2, Mariani, L. 4, Gazzola, M. 3,
Gobbi, P. 2, Carniel, G. 5, Capodiferro, N. 6, Muttillo, G. 2
1
Councilor at the Professional Roll IPASVI of Brescia
Councilor at the Professional Roll IPASVI of Milan-Lodi-Monza e Brianza, Italy
3
Councilor at the Professional Roll IPASVI of Aosta, Italy
4
Statistical Unit of Foundation IRCCS Cancer National Institute, Italy
5
Office quality Ambrosiana Hospital, Cesano Boscone, Italy
6
Nursing Service Hospital of Legnano, Italy
2
Nurses in the Italian Nurses Code of Ethic are committed to make "the use of
physical restraint an extraordinary event, supported by documented evaluation or
medical prescription". On the basis of this premise, the Professional Rolls of Nurses
IPASVI of Aosta, Brescia and Milan-Lodi-Monza-Brianza carried out a study to
assess the prevalence of physical restraint in hospitals and nursing homes.
The study is an observational cross-sectional study and it was conducted in June
2010. It involved a convenience sample consisting of 39 hospitals (3,281 beds in
medicine, surgery, geriatrics, orthopaedics, and intensive care units) and 70 nursing
homes (6,829 beds in ordinary and specialized Alzheimer wards).
During the survey period, 15.8% of hospital units patients and 68.7% of nursing
homes residents was restrained. The prevention of falls, alone or in combination
with other reasons, was given as the major reason for the application of physical
restraint in 70% of patients in hospitals and in 74.8% of residents in nursing homes.
Side rails were the most used means of restraint.
The results documented the extent of the use of physical restraint in hospitals and
nursing homes. This is a starting point to introduce solutions for the reduction of the
use of physical restraints and/or of the duration of daily restraint, through the
implementation of evidence based alternatives to achieve the following objectives:
prevention of falls and management of patients agitation. These are the main reasons
which today lead to the use of physical restraint.
A MOTIVATIONAL INTERVENTION TO IMPROVE PERSONAL AND
PROFESSIONAL WELL-BEING OF NURSES: A MIXED-METHODS STUDY
Giordano, A. 1, Castaldo, A. 2, Magri, M. 2, Cavalieri d'Oro, C. 3 Camerino, D. 4,
Conway, P. 5, Melo Ferrari, T. 6, de Angelis, G. 6, Corbo, M. 6, Muttillo, G. 2
1
2
Unit of Neuroepidemiology, Foundation IRCCS Neurological Institute C. Besta, Italy
President of the Professional Roll IPASVI of Milan, Lodi and Monza-Brianza, Italy
26
3
Leader and Director of International virtHuman©, Italy
Researcher University of Milan-Department of Occupational Medicine, Italy
5
Technical graduate University of Milan-Department of Occupational Medicine, Italy
6
Nurse, San Raffaele Hospital, Italy
4
The aim of this work was to evaluate the impact of a motivational program on
personal and professional well-being of nurses, and to explore the experience of the
participants in order to better understand the effectiveness of the intervention.
In period from January to June 2011, 102 nurses participated in a motivational
program (virtHuman©). This program uses a combination of different educational
techniques and consists of a two-day educational course, a four-week interval, and
another two-day course. The participants received the OSME (Organizational Stress
Management Evaluation) questionnaire at the beginning and at the end of the
program.
A qualitative synthesis of the five editions of the course was also made. Data were
collected implementing a summary of work groups held during the program and
grouped, through content analysis, into the following domains: intention to change
the current behaviour.
One-hundred and two nurses successfully participated in the program. Participants
demonstrated significant improvements both for OSME personal well-being (mean
change 3.9, 7.7 (SD); p<0.001) and for OSME professional well-being (mean
change 3.4, 7.4 (SD); p<0.001) subscale scores.
The results of the qualitative study showed that the program was useful, increased
the participants awareness of their capabilities and potentialities, and reinforced
communication and behavioral strategies both in private life and at work
(relationships with patients, colleagues and superiors).
The results emphasize the potential benefits of the motivational program for nurses
and that the program was well-accepted by the participants. The most relevant
qualitative findings regarded the participants new attitudes and behaviors.
27
S2
THE HEALING GARDEN EXPERIENCE. A NATURAL ENVIRONMENT
TO IMPROVE HEALTH AND WELL BEING
Chairs: Ginex V.1, Fumagalli, N.2, Senes, G.2, Rodiek, S.3
1
Department of Neurorehabilitation, Casa di Cura del Policlinico, Milan, Italy
Department of Agricultural Engineering, University of Milan, Italy
3
College of Architecture, Texas A&M University, USA
2
The state of knowledge of evidence-based healthcare design has grown rapidly in
recent years. The evidences indicate that well-designed physical settings play an
important role in making hospitals safer and more effective in healing patients.
In particular, a growing amount of scientific evidence suggests that natural
elements are known to increase quality of life and therefore health quality of
hospitalized patients. Some author suggests that the nature exposure could help to
maintain the level of functioning in patients with disability.
We report four works each one is meant to describe the phases of design,
construction and use of an healing garden for hospitalized patients.
A discussion about the importance of the method used for the design process and
about the observations gathered from different groups of patients that have had
access to the healing garden is proposed.
Keywords: healing gardens; post-acute patients; rehabilitation; quality of life
HEALING GARDENS: PROMOTING HEALTH QUALITY
SPECIALIZED INTENSIVE REHABILITATION HOSPITAL
IN
A
Ginex, V.1, Sozzi M.1, Fumagalli, N.2, Fermani, E.2, Mariani, C. 3, Senes, G.2
1
Department of Neurorehabilitation, Casa di Cura del Policlinico, Milan, Italy
Department of Agricultural Engineering, University of Milan, Italy
3
Institute of Clinical Neurology, Luigi Sacco Hospital, University of Milan, Italy
2
A growing amount of evidences suggests that nature elements can increase health
quality of hospitalized patients (1). The aim of the study is to investigate the
relationship between the characteristics of an intensive rehabilitation hospital
environment and the recovery processes of patients in a post-acute phase.
28
The present study involves two phases. In the first one, now concluded, we
attempted to determine the characteristics of the exterior spaces that best fits with
needs of our patients: a group of landscape architects visited the site, met the
hospital staff, and realized the project of the garden. At the same time, we collected
data from 95 neurologic, orthopedic, and pneumologic patients who were
hospitalized before the construction of the garden. This group will be considered as
a control group for the second phase of the study, in which we will compare patients
who did not use garden and patients who will have access to it. The outcome
measures are: level of disability, quality of life (QOL) and depression symptoms.
Some characteristics of the garden that are thought to be salient for our clinical
population have been identified. We are able to show some master plans of the
project. Moreover, we found a significant difference in QOL and depression
between the three groups of patients.
The benefits from a garden should be considered to reducing the disability in postacute patients in an intensive rehabilitation hospital.
HEALING GARDENS: THE GARDEN ON THE TERRACE OF THE
NATIONAL ONCOLOGY INSTITUTE IN MILAN (ITALY)
Senes, G., Fermani, E.
Department of Agricultural Engineering, University of Milan, Italy
It has been widely described in the literature that gardens and interaction with
natural elements can increase the quality of life in health-care facilities. The former
terrace of the National Oncology Institute in Milan (Italy) was used by patients,
relatives and medical staff as well, as an environment where to find peace and
restoration from pain and stress. The goal of the project was realize a garden
specifically-designed for the users of the Institute.
The method used for the design process was based on the understanding of the user
needs (patients, visitors and staff) through interviews, direct observations and the
application of the findings of environmental psychology on the interaction among
nature and people.
The new healing garden on the terrace of the National Oncology Institute was
designed and realized recovering everything possible and trying to increase as much
as possible the richness in natural elements (bio-diversity) and the possibilities of
interactions among people and nature.
Involving people is the key. Staff is planning ever new activities for involving
patients in using in different ways and time of the year the garden. They are also
29
trying to involve patients and relatives in a very base maintenance (watering,
cleaning, etc.).
ELDERLY HEALTHCARE HOUSE: ENGAGING PATIENTS AND STAFF IN
HEALING GARDEN DESIGN
Fumagalli, N.1, Senes, G.1, Crippa, R.1, Vigato, F.2, Francascani, A. 2, Perkins, N. 3
1
Department of Agricultural Engineering, University of Milan, Italy
RSA Famagosta, Italy
3
School of Environmental Design and Rural Development, University of Guelph,
Canada
2
Patient-specific gardens can provide general benefits related to the restorative
effects of nature and respond to the specific needs of a particular patient population.
These needs are to be considered in the design of outdoor space for healthcare. Our
goal was to design a patient-specific garden for elderly people who live in healthcare
house or use day center services (RSA Famagosta, Milano). A participatory design
process was used through the organization of focus groups. A focus group is a form
of qualitative research in which a group of people are asked about a topic. Focus
groups allowed us to study patients, visitors and professionals in a more natural
setting than a one-to-one interview. With this approach, users work closely together
to create a program that has been implemented by landscape architects to design a
patient-specific garden, that includes elements such as different walking surfaces,
slopes, steps, parallel bars, differing planter edge heights and plant labels, and other
facilities that can be used in rehabilitative activities. The participatory process
involving designers, clinical staff, patients and family members has been
appreciated because the users felt involved in the decision process. After the garden
is built, healthcare professionals, designers and researchers will collaborate to
discern the therapeutic benefits of this garden.
BENEFITS OF HEALING
HEALTHCARE FACILITIES
GARDENS
IN
NEUROPSYCHIATRIC
Senes, G.1, Pasqui, S.2, Borghi, C.2, Bandettini di Poggio, A.3
1
Department of Agricultural Engineering, University of Milan, Italy
Professionals
3
Casa di Cura Neuropsichiatrica Ville di Nozzano (Lucca), Italy
2
30
Recent literature demonstrates that gardens and natural elements can increase the
quality of life of patients and staff in health-care facilities. The study aims to assess
the benefits of nature in the interior and exterior environment for a neuropsychiatric
nursing home patients. The Study has carried out a prospective open-label trial,
among patients with mood disorders, divided into two groups of rooms, according to
a randomization list, characterized by presence/absence of green plants inside. The
variables investigated are both clinical (clinical course with the Hamilton
Depression Rating Scale - HAM-D, the Clinical Global Impression Scale - CGI, and
the Symptom Checklist-90, and the level of functioning with the Global Assessment
of Functioning Scale, GAF) and nature-related (activities and time spent in the
garden, through a daily diary filled by patients with the support of caregivers).
Finally, the improvement of the quality of life was investigated by the European
Quality of Life Questionnaire (EuroQol or EQ-5D).
The presence of green plants in the room seems to be statistically significant in
improving the Qol only for patients with an initial small degree of disorder. The
possibility to use the garden is appreciated by patients that generally indicate they
feel better during and after its use.
The benefits of natural elements in the care of mood disorders should be considered
as a therapeutic effect of the nature.
S3
CO-CONSTRUCTING
PROGRAMME
THEORY:
HOW
CAN
COMMUNITY BASED KNOWLEDGE HELP US TO DEVELOP MORE
EFFECTIVE PROGRAMMES?
Chairs: Harris, J. 1, Cargo, M. 2, Rees., R. 3
1
University of Sheffield, UK
University of South Australia, Australia
3
EPPI-Centre, Social Science Research Unit, Institute of Education, UK
2
Health promotion programmes often pursue the elusive aim of facilitating individual
behaviour change, but are challenged when they do not work in the way intended
across and within different population groups. We need insights from the target
population(s) to help develop workable, acceptable and implementable programme
theory. Such theory can be developed in two ways: via community-based
participatory research and systematic reviews of qualitative research.
31
Participatory methods for conducing systematic reviews have the potential to aid the
development of programme theory, though truly participative approaches demand
more than a cursory consultation with those intended to benefit from the
interventions. Diverse perspectives to inform theory development may also be found
in qualitative research; and methodological development in this area has advanced
greatly in recent years.
This symposium focuses on the challenges of co-constructing programme theory by
integrating diverse perspectives when synthesizing qualitative research. We will
report on questions and challenges arising from systematic reviews of qualitative
research and the application of community-based participatory research to
synthesize what works for whom, under which circumstances and why in addition to
the added value of integrating emic community-based knowledge perspectives into
evidence synthesis.
Keywords: realist review; participation; programme theory; qualitative synthesis
CONCURRENT REALIST EVALUATION AND SYNTHESIS: HOW
STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT ENHANCES UNDERSTANDING OF THE
MECHANISMS UNDERLYING THEORY-BASED HEALTH BEHAVIOUR
CHANGE
Harris, J.1, Booth, A.1, Campbell, F.1, Croot, L.1, Duckmanton, C.2, Goyder, E.1,
Hameed, W.2, Hanson, C.2, Hart, O.3, Muthana, A.3, Passey, R.2, Springett, J.4, van
Cleemput, P.1, Williams, T.3, Wilkins, E.4
1
University of Sheffield, UK
Shipshape, UK
3
NHS Sheffield, UK
4
University of Alberta, Canada
2
The Sheffield Health Trainer Chronic Pain Programme (HT CPP) uses a theorybased behaviour change intervention that is used in the national UK Health Trainer
programme (Michie et al, 2008). The national programme assesses success
quantitatively through questionnaires measuring goal setting and changes in wellbeing and self-efficacy. This presentation will demonstrate how stakeholder
involvement in realist evaluation and synthesis plays a key role in identifying the
underlying mechanisms for promoting self-management of chronic pain.
A realist evaluation is collecting multiple perspectives from Health Trainers,
practitioners and clients via interviews and reflective meetings to explore what
works in terms of helping people to self-manage chronic pain. Participatory,
iterative thematic analysis is identifying the behavioural determinants and
32
mechanisms that enable people with CP to manage activities that are important to
them and set goals for maintaining health and well-being. Mechanisms are being
compared with articles evaluating HT interventions from a realist review of
community-based peer support initiatives. Findings are being synthesized and
compared to the theory-based national intervention.
Findings from the literature are ‘thin’ in terms of explaining why HT programmes
work. Stakeholder involvement has been instrumental in terms of identifying the
underlying mechanisms that promote self-management, clarifying behavioural
determinants, and adding explanatory elements to the existing theory. Concurrent
realist evaluation and synthesis can produce co-constructed programme theories that
can be used to refine theory-based interventions.
ENGAGING STAKEHOLDERS AND INTEGRATING QUALITATIVE
EVIDENCE STRENGTHENS THE RIGOR AND RELEVANCE OF PROGRAM
THEORY IN A REALIST REVIEW OF ABORIGINAL SOCIAL-EMOTIONAL
WELLBEING PROGRAMS
Cargo, M.1, Lekkas, P.1, Evans, D.1, Chong, A.2
1
2
University of South Australia, Australia
Menzies School of Health Research, Australia
In his book "Evidence-based policy: A Realist Perspective", Ray Pawson makes
explicit the notion that programs are theories, whether the theories are implicit or
explicit. This presentation will demonstrate how stakeholder involvement and the
integration of qualitative evidence can strengthen the development and testing of
program theory. A realist review of Aboriginal social-emotional wellbeing programs
targeting children and youth in Australia was undertaken to provide policy-makers
with evidence on what programs work for whom and in what circumstances. The
initial theoretical framework was informed by qualitative interviews with advisory
group members, a review of western and Aboriginal literatures, and advisory input.
The framework was iteratively tested using quantitative, qualitative and mixedmethod studies. A series of mechanisms related to participant recruitment and
engagement emerged as core pathways in the program theory. The pathways to
engagement were influenced by program type, program format, and contextual
conditions implicating the implementing community, sponsoring organisation, interagency collaboration and workforce. Stakeholder insights and qualitative evidence
contributed to the rigor and relevance of context-mechanism-outcome
configurations in the theory.
33
Engaging with stakeholders and integrating qualitative studies strengthened the
development and testing of program theory. Given limitations in primary studies, the
theory emerging from this realist review would have benefitted from the further
integration of “live interviews”.
REVIEWS OF STAKEHOLDER DISTINCTIONS: HOW SYNTHESIZING
STUDIES OF PERSPECTIVES AND EXPERIENCES CAN IDENTIFY
FACTORS IMPORTANT FOR ‘EVIDENCE-BASED’ THEORY
Rees, R.1, Thomas, J.1, Caird, J.1, Dickson, K.1, Woodman, J.2, Oliver, K.3
1
EPPI-Centre, Social Science Research Unit, Institute of Education, UK
MRC Centre of Epidemiology for Child Health, UCL-Institute of Child Health, UK
3
Centre for Occupational and Environmental Health, University of Manchester, UK
2
This presentation will demonstrate how two syntheses of studies of peoples’ views
identified contextual factors with relevance for programme theory.
The opinions and preferences of children and young people have only recently
begun to be sought by those developing and implementing public health
programmes. With a view to including these stakeholders in programme theory
development, two reviews synthesised the findings of UK-based studies of children
and young people’s experiences of, and views about, being overweight. The
reviewers used an inductive approach (thematic synthesis). Study findings were
examined on a line-by-line basis, so as to produce descriptive codes. These codes
were then modified to produce hierarchical themes capturing related, recurrent or
emphasised ideas across studies.
The syntheses identified a range of perceived influences on children and young
people’s well-being related to body size. These influences were largely social in
nature and included experiences of stigma and discrimination that acted as barriers
to weight-loss. The social context is often missing from weight control programme
theory. Theory development can benefit from syntheses of stakeholder perspectives.
34
S4
BEYOND THE QUALITATIVE-QUANTITATIVE DIVIDE: THE USE OF
MIXED METHODS DESIGNS IN HEALTH RESEARCH
Chair: Morse, J.
University of Utah, USA
Both qualitative and quantitative research are critical resources that can provide
mulitple perspecties and insights that can serve to direct healthcare interventions.
Yet, despite all of our support to the contrary, there continue to be gaps in
communication between the qualitative and quantitative paradigms in health
research in general and health equity research in particular. What is the problem?
This is not a new topic. Why haven’t we moved beyond the divide to form stronger
links between the two paradigms? How can we best use the multiple theoretical and
methodological resources of qualitative research to facilitate the active involvement
of individuals as co-constructors of their health and, at the same time, provide a
multi-level approach to the evalution of health promotion programs? Why is it so
hard? The purpose of this symposium is to examine these continuing condundrums
from different perspectives, addressing rationales and successful practices of
interlacing qualitative and quantitative designs in the planning, evaluation and
optimization of health research programs. This symposium, chaired by Prof.
J.M.Morse, will host three contributions. The first presentation (Continuing
conundrums in communication between qualitative and quantitative paradigms in
health promotion and health equity research) will offer insight into mixed methods
designs from a dual perspective: one of a researcher whose research career has
primarily focused on supporting and implementing qualiitative research in health
care (Prof. L. Clark) and those of a researcher whose focus in health promotion and
health equity research has been mostly quantitative in nature, but which has
evolved into a mixed methods approach (Prof. M. Pett). The second contribution
(Interlacing qualitative and quantitative methods in applied health research: a
“generative” taxonomy), presented by Prof. A.C.Bosio, Dr. G. Graffigna e Dr. E.
Lozza will propose a “generative” taxonomy interlacing qualitative and quantitative
methods when designing mixed methods inquiries with different finalities (i.e. from
the diagnosis/description of a phenomenon, to the interpretation of causal
relationships, to the generation of new ideas of services and health programs)
The third presentation will be from Prof.. L.Vecchio , Dr. M.Miglioretti and Dr. M.
Zoppi (Benefits and costs of using mixed methods in quality of health care
assessment) who will argue the merit of a mixed methods approach to studying
perceived quality of a day hospital for infectious diseases.
Keywords : mixed methods; multi methods; quali-quantitative divide
35
CONTINUING CONUNDRUMS IN COMMUNICATION BETWEEN
QUALITATIVE AND QUANTITATIVE PARADIGMS IN HEALTH
PROMOTION AND HEALTH EQUITY RESEARCH
Pett, M., Clark, L.
University of Utah, USA
Qualitative research is a critical resource that provides for direct involvement of
participants in the production of knowledge and insights that would serve to direct
healthcare interventions. Yet, there continues to be gaps in communication between
the qualitative and quantitative paradigms in health research in general and health
equity in particular. What is the problem? This is not a new topic. Why haven’t we
moved beyond the divide to form stronger links between the two paradigms? How
can we best use the multiple theoretical and methodological resources of qualitative
research to facilitate the active involvement of individuals as co-constructors of their
health as well as provide a multi-level approach to the evaluation of health
promotion and health equity programs? Why is it so hard?
The purpose of this oral presentation is to examine these continuing conundrums
from the perspectives of two colleagues: one whose successful research career has
primarily focused on qualitative research to build understanding of disparities in
health (Dr. Clark) and one whose focus in health promotion and health equity
research has been mostly quantitative in nature (Dr. Pett). Finally, we examine indepth several successful research programs that have utilized a mixed methods
approach to the study of health promotion and health equity.
INTERLACING QUALITATIVE AND QUANTITATIVE METHODS IN
APPLIED HEALTH RESEARCH: A “GENERATIVE” TAXONOMY FOR
MULTI AND MIXED METHODS DESIGNS
Bosio, A.C., Graffigna, G., Lozza, E.
Faculty of Psychology, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
The different nature and the complementarities of qualitative and quantitative
methods has been largely discussed in the literature. Evidences also underline the
heuristic value of interlacing these two approaches in the study of health issues.
Mixing qualitative and quantitative methods, thus, opens the possibility for greater
research creativity and allows to reach a maximum flexibility in the inquiry design.
However how to best interlace qualitative and quantitative methods still remain
matter to debate. This paper proposes a “generative taxonomy” which can help
researchers in positioning themselves according to their research object and to the
36
main finalities of the study. The taxonomy articulates four different levels of
“formalization” that the research design can assume (descriptive, associative,
explicative and generative) and describes how each level can be declined according
to qualitative or quantitative methods, by generating specific research objectives and
methodological paths. The taxonomy appears helpful for analysing and defining the
syntax of multi- and mixed- methods design and for managing the process of an
applied health research. The paper concludes by commenting on some case histories,
exemplificative of different “mixed a multi design syntaxes” generated by the
taxonomy.
BENEFITS AND COSTS OF USING MIXED METHODS IN QUALITY OF
HEALTH CARE ASSESSMENT
Vecchio, L., Miglioretti, M., Zoppi M.
Department of Psychology, University of Milano-Bicocca, Italy
The usefulness of mixed methods approach with reference to quality of health care
service evaluation will be discussed, based on results from a study on perceived
quality of a day hospital for infectious diseases. In the first phase of the study, both
the medical staff and the patients were involved in developing the questionnaires for
the assessment of the quality of the health service. In the second phase, the
questionnaires were administered to a sample of patients. Qualitative in-depth
interviews were used in the first phase. This made it possible to develop
questionnaires which considered both aspects of the service relevant for the medical
staff and the patient experience in using the services. That is, we were able to define
instruments for evaluating the quality of health services based on criteria which
reflected the experience and the point of view of service users. Actually, three
(partially) different questionnaires were constructed, one for each of the different
ways patients accessed the service (i.e.to take a blood sample, to do a medical visit
or to be hospitalized for intravenous therapy). Benefits and costs of this approach in
questionnaire development for quality of health services and patient satisfaction
studies will be addressed.
37
S5
THE IMPORTANCE OF MOTIVATION FOR BLOOD AND ORGANS
DONORS
Chair: Saita, E.
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
This symposium provides an overview of qualitative procedures used to measure the
role of motivation in blood or organs donation.
In the modern society, the majority of health donors are unpaid volunteers: they
donate blood for community supply or they donate organs if a family member needs
a transplantation.
Usually, in literature motivation to donate has been examined with standardized
questionnaires that emphasize altruism as the most common reason to donate. In
this direction, motivation seems to be originated from a general moral quality of the
donor, but it was amply demonstrated that the willingness to donate is higher when
the receipt is a known and loved person (as a family member or friends).
For this reason motivation of the donors appears as an important factor to be
studied thoroughly, because it seems to be inscribed into important bonds: with the
community and with the family.
Increasing the existing literature, that has mainly studied the importance of
personality factors of the donors, this symposium focuses also on the relationships
that influence and sustain a donation.
It seems to be extremely important to give donors correct and detailed information
regarding donation and transplantation, moreover it seems to be important to
encourage people to become responsible donors. The comprehension of motivation
to donate is necessary and fundamental, in order to stimulate awareness on the
importance of organs and blood donation.
Keywords: blood donation; organs donation; motivation to donate
38
MOTIVATION IN IMMIGRANT COMMUNITIES
DONATION: THE SITUATION IN NORTHERN ITALY
ABOUT
BLOOD
Castelnuovo, G., Pietrabissa, G., Manzoni, G.M., Pagnini, F., Molinari, E.
Department of Psychology, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
The aim of this study is to establish which motivational factors could be important
for the development of a mid or long-term commitment as a voluntary blood donor
in immigrant communities. Blood donations by populations from non-European
countries are a public health necessity. Previous investigations in France about this
field have show that blood donors from the Maghreb and Sub-Saharan Africa feel a
greater sense of citizenship than non-donors from the same areas. First of all blood
donation by foreign populations could constitute a response to transfusion needs;
moreover blood donation could be used by populations from the Maghreb and SubSaharan Africa as an active mean of expressing their sense of citizenship.
Using a tablet-based and web-based survey, data about a sample of immigrants from
different foreign communities will be collected in Northern Italy. Data on
motivation will be analyzed. Some dimensions of blood-donor motivation will be
investigated: altruism and empathy, social reasons (influence of friends and family),
strengthening of one’s self-esteem, positive experiences associated with donation, a
moral obligation to donate and other more culture-specific dimensions.
This study looked at motivational factors in the decision to donate blood within
immigrant communities in Italy, in view of the lack of Italian published research in
this field. Developing an intervention that encourages migrants to donate blood
seems to be an important modern challenge and needs to be more culturally focused
in Italian Health System. It appears that addressing perceptions based on home
country experiences is essential.
This study was supported by the two associations of voluntary blood donors located
in Lecco (ALDE, Associazione Lariana Donatori di Sangue Emocomponenti e
Midollo Osseo and AVIS Provinciale di Lecco, Associazione Italiana Volontari
Sangue della Provincia di Lecco).
39
BLOOD DONOR MOTIVATIONS: A QUALITATIVE STUDY WITH BOTH
NEODONORS AND RETAINED DONORS
Guiddi, P., Marta, E., Pozzi, M.
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
The aims of this study are different. The first one is to establish which Familial
Values can be relevant to approach blood donation; the second is to highlight which
are the Motivations to start donating blood: are they broader than the ones
considered by the international quantitative literature? The last aim is to understand
if the Motivations that at the beginning of the process substained the blood donation
change as time passes by or if they are constant.
The study is conducted by interviews to blood donors. The approach is the
constructionist revision of grounded-theory approach, from a double point of view:
both, theory and data-driven (Gelo, Braakma and Benetka, 2008). They have been
conducted 48 interviews to blood donors: 24 to neodonors and 24 to regular donors.
The sample has been divided on the basis of the age (young and adult), in 4 Italian
regions: 2 Regions from Northern Italy and the other 2 in the South.
The analyses have been conducted by the Software Altas-Ti (version 5).
The data show various empirical evidences.
From the values quoted by donors, there are “others’ care”, “availability” and
“regard for other’s”. Some donors told that these values derive from their parents
who taught them to care for others. This capability of caring the others allowed them
to understand the social importance of this gesture and of the decision of donating
blood. The parenthood’s role comes even out in the approach to the donation world
through almost all 48 interviews. Many donors have approached the donation due to
family members who already were donors (fathers in particular), or due to the
knowledge of the structure, or for the awareness of the need of blood.
Among the most listed motivations to blood donation there are “personal benefits”,
”altruism”, “social pressure” and the “sense of responsibility for the Others”.
According to Lemmens (2005) and Finkelstein (2009), about 24 retained donors, the
data clarify, otherwise, in which way motivations change during the time. Some
donors say they began donating substained from self oriented motivations (health
control or the desire to meet new people, for example), but they continue giving
blood because of other-oriented motivations (civic engagement or interest to the
"social good"), or because donation is a routine (a central aspect of their Self, using
Piliavin’s words). The important aspect of this study is that motivations are not
crystallized and unilateral, but a modifiable galaxy during the process and the
experience of Donation.
40
LIVING KIDNEY DONATION: THE MOTIVATION TO DONATE AND TO
RECEIVE
Saita, E. 1, Zanini, S. 2, Minetti, E. 2, Mazzola, A. 1
1
2
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
A.O. Niguarda Ca' Granda, Milano, Italy
Aim of the present research is to better understand motivation for choosing to donate
a kidney, as well as motivation for accepting to receive from a familiar or from
emotionally related (but genetically unrelated) people.
Because of the lack in literature, we need to explore recipients and donors’
experiences, examining not only what they think about it, but also how they think
that way. Focus groups are particularly useful in this direction.
We conducted two focus group, one with 6 donors and the other one with their
emotionally or familiar related recipients. The topics investigated in both groups
were: thoughts about donation, story of the illness and of transplantation, decision
making process and emotions connected, evaluation of the experience of
transplantation.
The discussions were recorded, transcribed and analyzed with the software T-lab.
The data suggested that both the motivation to become a donor and the motivation to
receive depended on the familial relationship status between donor and recipient.
The intimacy with the recipient is the most important factor in the decision-making
process and, the more intimate the donor and the recipient are, the higher is the wish
to give.
S6
THE MEASUREMENT AND THE
(WELLBEING INCLUDED) IN PADOVA
PROMOTION
OF
HEALTH
Chairs: Turchi, G.P., Celleghin, E.
Dipartimento di Filosofia, Sociologia, Pedagogia e Psicologia Applicata – FISPPA Università degli Studi di Padova, Italy
Given the civil society demand of effective interventions on Health promotion
(wellbeing included), the Symposia aims at becoming a chance to discuss about the
“scientific rigor” meant as a warranty of the effectiveness of interventions on the
promotion of Health Community.
41
An action-research project will be presented: the “Kairòs” Project, which started
in 2011 from the collaboration between the University of Padova (Philosophy,
Sociology, Pedagogy and Applied Psychology Departments) and 21 Municipalities
of Padova Province. The project objective is the promotion of the social health and
the theoretical assumptions are rooted into the Narrativistic Paradigm (Turchi,
2002; Salvini, 1998) - for which the “health” community is configured by the
discursive productions of all social subjects (citizens and Institutions). According to
these assumptions the research used the methodology M.A.D.I.T. (Methodology of
the Analysis of Computerized Textual Data, Turchi, 2007) for the description of the
discursive configuration “community health”; the interventions were managed
according to the Dialogical Model, working on how citizens, through dialogue,
interact to construct their health. The adoption of a theoretical framework and a
consistent methodological approach allowed to measure how much “health” was
promoted on the interested territory, that is to evaluate the effectiveness of the
intervention.
Keywords: discursive productions; measurement of the effectiveness; theoryapplication consistency; or scientific rigour
THE DIALOGICAL MODEL: FOR A SERVICES ARCHITECTURE THAT
GENERATES HEALTH
Sperotto, M.
Dipartimento di Filosofia, Sociologia, Pedagogia e Psicologia Applicata – FISPPA Università degli Studi di Padova, Italy
To a scientific rigor a relevant step is the definition of the research object. Since
“Health” is a theoretical construct and not a factual-empirical object here it is meant
as a discursive production. According to this the use of the bio-psychological-social
model into the Health Psychology, since it doesn’t refer to a rigorous definition of
the research object (“health”), creates critical aspects, that are linked to the
configuration of health as a factual and empirical object. Antinomically, the
adoption of the dialogical model is consistent with the “health” meant as a reality
configured by discursive productions used by speakers. Furthermore, the adoption of
this model allows to get presuppositions to construct a “architecture” that can
become the skeleton of a services system that can be founded on a construct of
“health” responding to a epistemological consistency criteria. This presentation aims
at defining a operative model (the dialogical model) according to which it is possible
to construct a scientific founded services architecture that generates health.
42
Therefore the definition of the research object, “health”, meant as a theoretical
construct, defines a theoretical and
methodological framework and consistent praxis to provide epistemological founded
and methodological correct interventions.
CONSTRUCTION AND DETECTION OF INDICATORS EVALUATING THE
STATE OF THE COMMUNITY HEALTH
Bortolazzi, E.
Dipartimento di Filosofia, Sociologia, Pedagogia e Psicologia Applicata – FISPPA Università degli Studi di Padova, Italy
According to the theoretical construct of Heath defined in the above presentation,
and it processual dimension, indicators are defined and collected. Those referring to
discursive productions which contribute to maintain/ generate health, that is the
discursive productions used by citizens to interact either keeping a problem
perspective or the chance to face critical aspects.
For defining indicators the ambits told by citizens as the most critical ones were
detected. The 6 fields are: security, immigration, territory sources, intergenerational
critical aspects, health, role of the citizens and institutions.
The indicators represent the discursive productions through which citizens configure
the 6 ambits and they were collected by opened questions questionnaires.
This contribution aims at outlining the methodological steps applied according to the
operative model as the reference key of the project in order to detect the community
need as discursive processes to be promoted in order to support citizenship to get a
active role facing health issues.
THE RESEARCH APPLIED TO THE PROJECTING OF A HEALTH
PROMOTION INTERVENTION
Perno, A.
Dipartimento di Filosofia, Sociologia, Pedagogia e Psicologia Applicata – FISPPA Università degli Studi di Padova, Italy
The essay aims at presenting a proposal of criteria useful for researchers and
practitioners who intend projecting a scientifically rigorous and effective
intervention/research. Through a example of a project applied by the University of
Padova (Applied Psychology Department) in collaboration with the Padova
43
Province Administration, the Padova Province Municipalities, the territorial
Associations, citizens and users, useful methodological steps will be outlined. These
ones will allow to create methodological consistent projects and researches in order
to evaluate their effectiveness.
The project framework elements (epistemological and theoretical framework and the
project development description), the definition of the general objective (according
to the consistent Health epistemological level), the definition of the project
strategies pertinent to the project objective will be outlined and discussed. The
scientific framework is applied by the methodology M.A.D.I.T. and by the
assumptions declared into the above presentation since the projects used the
evaluation of the state of the Health Community.
THE METHODOLOGY OF THE EVALUATION OF THE EFFECTIVENESS
AND THE ANALYSIS OF COSTS AND BENEFITS OF AN INTERVENTION
PROMOTING HEALTH
Francato, S.
Dipartimento di Filosofia, Sociologia, Pedagogia e Psicologia Applicata – FISPPA Università degli Studi di Padova, Italy
As mentioned in the above presentations, the consistency between the definition of
health and the applied praxis allows to evaluate the effectiveness of the intervention,
that is to state to what extent the defined objective was transformed into results.
Since that the indicators which declare the state of health before of the intervention
(time at t0) are discursive indicators, the evaluation of the effectiveness shows to
what extent the discursive productions changed at the conclusion of the project
(time t1). This shift regards how people interact, from a passive role into the
community towards an active participation. The adoption of a methodology of
evaluation of the effectiveness allows to measure the quantum of health generated
by the intervention. The consistency between the definition of health and the applied
praxis allows, furthermore, a analysis of costs and benefits of interventions
promoting health trough the construction of a architecture of services. A analysis of
costs and benefits permits to state how much the intervention can save public
money, that is to show to what extent the interventions help the community to
optimize available sources on the respect of the used ones.
44
Oral presentations
O1
DISTRIBUTED AND MULTIFACETED DECISION-MAKING IN THE
CARE OF CO-MORBID, CHRONIC KIDNEY FAILURE: EXAMPLES AND
IMPLICATIONS
Allen, D., Denyer-Willis, L., Badro, V., Ummel, D., Macdonald, M.E., Cohen, R.,
Pare, A., Hutchinson, T.
McGill University, Canada
Decision-making in health care is often portrayed as a choice between two medical
options, made by a particular individual, at a particular point in time. Health
professionals describe treatment pros and cons and patients provide informed
consent/refusal. In practice, however, this decision-making model, ubiquitous in
health care, is divergent from the complex, non-linear, and non-medical process of
care decision-making, and denies patients and clinicians the opportunity to achieve a
truly, and mutually, informed decision. Drawing on data from a case-based
ethnography of decision-making and communication in the care of patients with comorbid chronic kidney failure, this presentation exposes the multifaceted, fluid, and
distributed nature of seemingly point-in-time medical decisions. We will describe
examples in which treatment decisions were (a) informed by social relations and
economic issues, (b) distributed amongst several people, (c) shaped by hospital
bureaucracy, and (d) repeatedly revisited and questioned by patients and health care
professionals. The data suggest that this alternate understanding of decision-making,
as process rather than point-in-time, might open the possibility for a more sensitive,
collaborative and mutually in informed-approach to care.
Keywords: chronic illness; decision-making; ethnography
45
O2
PRETESTING TOBACCO PACKAGEWARNING LABELS (IMAGES AND
MESSAGES)
Alnajjar, Z.1, Al Fahel, R.2
1
2
DHA Dubai Health Authority, United Arab Emirates
Health Authority AbuDhabi, United Arab Emirates
Recent research in UAE revealed that smoking is widely spread among youth
reaching 14.3% of young males and 2.9% among young females between the age
thirteen and fifteen years old. In addition, 42% of men and less than 1% of women
are smokers. Furthermore, there is large number of both men and women smoke
shisha (water pipe) Smoking is considered as a socially accepted practice among
youth. According to a survey conducted in UAE in 2003, some of the important
tobacco consumption indictors in UAE are the following:
• 80% of children are exposed to tobacco advertising.
• 30% of children have people smoking in front of them at home.
• 70% of children are exposed to negative smoking in public places.
• 30% of the people have possessions showing tobacco companies logos.
• 30 % of children and youth were offered free cigarettes.
World Health Organization calls upon all countries of the Eastern Mediterranean
Region to adopt pictorial health warnings not only for cigarettes but for all tobacco
products including shisha. Main purpose of this qualitative study is to Pre-test 24
pictorial cigarette pack warning labels (design & language) including reactions of
various audience groups (urban/ suburban, male /females, young/old), as well as
their attitude and level of comprehension of to images and messages. List of Images
will be not be sent by email due to size, but will be presented during presentation.the
aim is to find out how clients would react to negative imaging for smoking and its
effects on health. How much they understand the displayed pictures and which ones
they consider most effective.To understand people's comprehension and attitudes
towards new tobacco control messaging. Main data collection technique: organizing
16 Focus Group Discussions using a topic guide.Total participants 128.These groups
included a mix of age groups, sex, education, urban/sub-urban, and smoking
behaviors, namely Target Audiences were:
Citezens and Residents: Urban and Suburban.
• Sex: males & females
• Age: Youth & adults
• Smokers and nonsmokers.
Research activity was completed during the period May-June 2011 including
46
training of moderators and note takers and obeservers.Three teams were involved in
this research. Each team composed of moderator, a note taker and an observer. All
sessions were recorded by a digital recorder,after obtaining audience consent.
Keywords: pre-test; pictorial; health warnings; reactions; attitude
O3
UNITI CONTRO IL PREGIUDIZIO. CONDIVIDERE IL DISAGIO DELLA
VIOLENZA. EXPERIENTIAL WORKSHOPS TO SHARE AND TRANSFER
KNOWLEDGE AND GOOD PRACTICES
Amodeo, A.L., Picariello, S., Scandurra, C.
Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II, Italy
The project Hermes - Linking Network to Fight Sexual and Gender Stigma - aims,
among other things, at constructing a network between different services working on
discriminations and violence related to gender and sexual orientation. To achieve
that, a training of professionals involved is considered fundamental, being carried
out through empowering methodologies able to provide efficient tools and practices,
transferable into respective intervention contexts. Workshops shaped on learningby-doing approach and addressed to first responders have employed Social
Dreaming Matrix, Role Playing, “Roulette of identities” and a final Application
Group. Each of them engaged one or two observers. Participants’ mental
representations on discussed issues came out, together with resources and critic
aspects of their knowledge and activities. Possibilities of sharing experiences,
thoughts and good practices found space, in the perspective of a concrete application
of them into each one’s work context. Detecting resources and criticalities of
existing local working on women and LGBT people’s health, as well as using
methods to share and transfer knowledge and good practices, would make it possible
to train more conscious and skilled workers, furthermore supported in their contact
with users by a complementary and interacting network.
Keywords: good practices; learning-by-doing; empowerment; women and LGBT
health; network
47
O4
SOCIAL AND CONTEXTUAL FACTORS RELATED TO DRINKING
PATTERNS IN ITALIAN YOUNG NIGHTLIFE GOERS
Aresi, G., Forloni, S., Marta, E.
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
Alcohol consumption among young Italian people frequently takes place in nightlife
recreational activities both in formal (clubs, pubs, concerts) and informal (streets,
parks, private party) settings. Despite the well-known alcohol abuse-related risks
(e.g. traffic accidents, violence, injuries), drinking, and even occasional heavy
drinking, is perceived by young people as having social and coping benefits
(Shulenberg & Maggs, 2002). Recognizing how drinking fits into young people
lives may help professionals to design and implement more effective preventive
interventions. The present research aims at getting a better view of drinking motives,
social and contextual factors that may promote alcohol abuse. Grounded Theory has
been the methodological and analytical framework. A pilot focus group oriented the
following sampling. So far a purposive sample of 43 young regular nightlife goers
(18-28 years old) were recruited through snowball sampling and participated in 4
focus-group interviews. More interviews has been planned. Transcripts of the
interviews are being analyzed through NVivo 9.0 software. Alcohol seems to be
intentionally used to reach different outcomes in different settings (e.g. disinhibition
in clubs). Coherently with the literature affiliation and socialization are, in general,
the main drinking motives, while the motive “enjoy the taste of alcohol”, related to
moderate drinking, seems to be specific to our Italian sample.
Keywords: alcohol; nightlife; young adults; drinking patterns
O5
FACING ETHNOGRAPHY: NON-CONVENTIONAL METHODS
Ayala, R.A.1, Koch, T.F.2, Bracke, P.1
1
2
Ghent University, Belgium
Universidad de Playa Ancha, Cile
Despite being in a competing epistemological ground, sociological ethnography has
been gaining more value and acceptance amongst sociologists in the development of
48
theory, especially in the understanding of everyday life at a micro social level.
Following Grounded Theory (Glaser and Strauss, 1967) it can be said that inductive
orientation has a role of great importance in theoretical statements formulation as
hypotheses emerge continuously during data gathering and processing within the
theory-data interplay. Whether or not statements of this kind are cogent shall not be
argued here, but we assume reality has no absolute line between particular cases
logic and universal patterns. Although systematic observation is by far the main and
most common data gathering technique in inductive enquiry, deep understanding
requires a set of research tools beyond observation scope, so that non-conventional
methods can support this within ethnographic research in a further step to
triangulation. Surprisingly, ethnography literature deals disproportionately more
with observation technique, lacking full explanation of complementary methods.
This fact justifies that some other techniques are needed to complement observation
from another angles, in an attempt to better fine-tune meaning. This paper focuses
thus on describing non-conventional methods, such as drawings and sociograms
made by participants, and how they can support researchers to achieve and fine-tune
deeper levels of understanding in ethnography.
Keywords: ethnography; complementary methods; alternative methods; fieldwork
O6
WHAT KIND OF INTEGRATION BETWEEN QUALITATIVE AND
QUANTITATIVE MEASURES IN SPATIAL-DEFICIT RECOVERY?
NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL EVIDENCE FOR THE ASSESSMENT AND
INTERVENTION
Balconi, M. 1, Sozzi, M. 2, Crivelli, D. 1
1
2
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
Casa di Cura del Policlinico di Milano, Italy
Qualitative and quantitative measures to explore the assessment procedures and the
intervention strategies for the successive recovery of spatial attentional deficits
(such as neglect syndrome) were recollected in the past years within
neuropsychological domains. However, whereas the real impact of these two distinct
methodologies on the patients’ recovery was largely considered, no specific analysis
was conducted to directly compare the long-lasting effects of these methodologies
taking into account some subjective and contextual main variables, as well as it was
not considered the impact of the integration between the qualitative and quantitative
49
perspective. Firstly, from one side the effective compliance of patients in clinical
specific treatments was underestimated or unspecifically considered. From the other
side the effective incidence of qualitative (such as psychometric and assessment
measures) or the quantitative (such as experimental and behavioural measures)
methodology within their ecological context (clinical structure/laboratory setting)
was scarcely analyzed. Secondly, a main caveat of the present research domain on
spatial deficit recovery was the absence of a systematic survey on the effective
applicability of the two measure types in integration each other. Coherence,
proficiency and improving of this integrative view, that may include both the
clinical and experimental approach, is suggested and discussed at light of the recent
introduction of new methodologies. Between the others, brain stimulation (induced
mainly by transcranial magnetic stimulation, TMS, or direct current stimulation,
tDCS) may offer a unique opportunity to directly observe the effect of a joined
strategy of assessment and intervention (quali- and quanti-tative) for the health
recovery of patients.
Keywords: recovery; assessment; neglect; spatial; qualitative; quantitative; clinical;
experimental
O7
PSYCHIATRIC ILLNESS AND CARE: LISTENING TO THE MENTAL
PATIENTS’ STORY
Baltrusaityte, G.
Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania
The second half of the twentieth century has witnessed major changes in the way
mental health care is organized and provided for people suffering from mental
illness. Deinstitutionalization and community care became common terms used to
define a policy that aims to shift the locus of psychiatric care from large mental
hospitals and custodial institutions into community. Deinstitutionalization of
psychiatric care requires an empowering approach towards individuals living with
mental disorders. Such an approach inter alia means accepting the mentally ill health
care service users as active participants in the mental health care system, whose
views should be respected and taken into account when developing and providing
user oriented mental health care. By drawing on a qualitative study (in-depth
interviews) with 20 mental health care service users in Kaunas, Lithuania, this paper
explores individual’s subjective experience of psychiatric illness and psychiatric
50
care. During the last two decades, psychiatric care in Lithuania and in other socalled post-communist countries has also undergone significant changes: a gradual
shift from institution based psychiatric care towards the deinstitutionalization and
reintegration of the mentally ill into society has been taking place since then. Yet,
has this changed the psychiatric and public approach towards a mental patient?
By analyzing individual’s subjective experience of psychiatric illness and
psychiatric care, the author of the paper attempts to show how continuing overreliance on the biomedical model in contemporary psychiatric care in Lithuania and
prevailing paternalistic approach towards the mentally ill individuals may continue
to sustain their dependency, vulnerability and powerlessness. It is argued that
qualitative research is very well suited to uncover existing power relations within
medical care that in turn may inhibit development of an adequate and user oriented
mental health care. It may not only serve as a tool in engaging mental health care
users in the construction of more suitable interventions but also contribute to
positive changes in the public approach towards people suffering from serious
mental illness.
Keywords: mental illness; psychiatric care; mental patient’s perspective
O8
EMERGENCY MENTAL HEALTH HOSPITALIZATION AS MORAL
DISCOURSE: ANALYSIS AND IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE
Bartesaghi, M.
University of South Florida, USA
The Baker Act is Florida’s involuntary treatment statute. It provides for emergency
mental health examinations of up to 72 hours in designated facilities in case of harm
to self, others, or self neglect. The phrase “the revolving door” has been coined by
the mental health sector to identify problematic patients; revolving door patients are
poor, cycle in and out of emergency inpatient care, and take up valuable resources.
At the same time, these patients reveal the complexities and systemic limitations of
the Baker Act, as well as its enmeshment with issues of substance abuse, for which
it is not designed. This paper investigates how mental health providers account for
the revolving door problem in their everyday experiences with the Baker Act.
Using a blend discourse analysis and membership categorization analysis (MCA), I
analyze interviews (recorded and transcribed at an intermediate level of detail) with
sixteen staff members responsible for 72 mental health emergency hospitalizations
51
from 5 Florida counties. I show how staff accounts of Baker Act use and abuse
involves moral categorization of patients and community (what they should and
should not do, their responsibilities, issues of blame), as well as reflexive
constructions of staff as moral agents, that have surprisingly little to do with the
Baker Act itself and much to do with upholding traditional accounts of psychiatry
and mental illness. This study adds to the literature on psychiatric discourse as a
form of moral accounting, and sheds light on how the discourse of legislative
change may in fact reveal as much as it conceals. I propose implications for mental
practice and policy of employing this sort of qualitative analysis to health
communication.
Keywords: mental health; emergency hospitalization; moral discourse; accounts;
discourse analysis
O9
SHARED DECISION-MAKING AND DISCOURSE ANALYSIS: THE COCONSTRUCTION OF PATIENT PARTICIPATION IN DECISIONMAKING
Belanger, E.1, Rodriguez, C.1, Groleau, D.1, Macdonald, M.E.1, Légaré, F.2,
Marchand, R. 3
1
McGill University, Canada
Université Laval, Canada
3
Université de Montréal, Canada
2
The aim of this paper is twofold: (1) to review empirical evidence using discourse
analysis as a theoretical/methodological approach to study shared decision-making
(SDM), and (2) to reflect on the ontology of SDM as a discursive event.
A literature search in major databases was carried out to identify studies using
discourse analysis to study SDM. The conceptual models of SDM and their
ontological and epistemological assumptions were also assessed to evaluate their
suitability for discourse analysis. Despite the critical role played by language-in-use
in the interactions that constitute the SDM clinical encounter, there are few
empirical studies using discourse analysis. While there are good empirical measures
of certain aspects of SDM, such as patient preferences for decision roles, we argue
that a constructivist ontology can address the co-construction of patient participation
in decision-making as a discursive event. Conceptual models of SDM adopt an
ontology that is poorly suited for qualitative methodologies. Rather than viewing
52
patient preferences for participation as pre-existing and stable, a discourse analysis
of SDM would conceive of patient participation as a process constructed through
talk in social interactions. A discursive perspective on decision-making is closer to
everyday clinical conversations than empirical measurements scales.
Keywords: shared decision-making; discourse analysis; conceptual models
O 10
PATIENT’S CHOICE
PROSTATE CANCER
OF
OBSERVATIONAL
STRATEGY
FOR
Bellardita, L.1, Donegani, S.1, Granatiero, O.2, Graffigna, G.2, Tresoldi, V.1,
Magnani, T.1, Valdagni, R.1
1
2
Programma Prostata Fondazione IRCCS Istituto Nazionale dei Tumori, Italy
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
Active surveillance is an observational strategy for low risk, potentially indolent
prostate cancer that is obtaining consensus in urologic oncology. AS may represent
for selected patients a viable alternative to radical therapies, thus reducing the risk of
over-treatment and the psychological distress related to side effects that negatively
impact quality of life. We aimed to assess what factors could lead patients to elect
AS among different therapeutic options. Patients entering the AS protocol at our
Institution were administered a semi-structured interview asking to explain the
reasons for choosing AS. Two independent raters conducted a paper-and-pencil text
analysis. The most relevant meta-codes that emerged were as follows: 1) patients’
story (medical history, prostate cancer as the critical event), 2) information
acquisition (based on relationships with physicians and family/friends) 3) pros and
cons of AS (side effects such as incontinence and erectile dysfunction, trust in the
medical team, reversibility of the choice). In conclusion, patients are motivated to
opt for AS, rather than radical therapies, based on the subjective evaluation of a
number of factors that include medical information as well as characteristics of their
psycho-social context. Understanding patients’ motivation for AS will help
clinicians to present this innovative approach.
Keywords: prostate cancer; patient’s choice; observational strategy
53
O 11
THE EMOTIONAL PERFORMANCE IN VIDEO AND AUDIOVISUAL
ANALYSIS: TOOLS FOR THOUGHT, OR THOUGHT FOR TOOLS?
Belli, S.1, Muntanyola, D.2
1
2
Universidad autónoma de Madrid, Spain
Universidad autonoma de Barcelona, Spain
Video is not a new media in health research. Ethnographers in anthropology
initially, and in sociology and psychology later on, have been using for decades the
photographic camera, the video next, and digital software most recently, to capture
and analyze raw emotional performance. Still, a heated debate on the validity and
representativity of video analysis prevails in labs and seminars. In contemporary
terms, video analysis is an embodied activity that involves a medium, the video
camera. If we take the presence of the ethnographer body as an observing function,
we can consider that the camera becomes an extension of her body, just as
computers, phones and cars are active artifacts in our everyday activities. One the
one hand, this paper claims the need to take current methodological debates from the
instrumental level to that of theory. Both reification and intrusion can be avoided or
diminished with the assumption of epistemic reflexivity all along the research
process, and not only as a formal append previous to publication.
Keywords: emotion; performance; ethnography; video and audiovisual analysis; critical
discourse analysis
O 12
UNDERSTANDING MEDICAL HUMANITIES THROUGH A MULTIMETHOD COMPARATIVE RESEARCH DESIGN
Bevilacqua, A.
Università di Verona, Italy
This research aims to identify the Medical Humanities’ constitutive elements and
their operational role in the development of professional skills for healthcare
practitioners. Within a sequential multi-method design it is possible to identify –
through a grounded theory research – an empirical theory of the MH in Italy, which
is then compared with the meaningful English experience. To this aim data are
54
collected and analyzed by adopting a phenomenological approach. The results reveal
that MH in Italy are still in their infancy and require a more systemic approach that
includes all the actors of the healthcare community. MH projects in the United
Kingdom follow two branches of development: on one hand the core of MH is
moving from interdisciplinarity to a democratization process; on the other the
research dimension seems to prevail on the educational one. To improve the quality
of life of patients and healthcare professionals by supporting a scientific
epistemology which includes a socio-cultural perspective, MH professionals need to
follow a more rigorous methodology and evaluation, to reflect on their hidden
personal intention going beyond the moralistic idea of a necessary humanization of
healthcare services, and work on practices to reach a knowledge alive to the present.
Keywords: medical humanities; medical education; medical research; caring practices;
interdisciplinarity
O 13
LOOKING FOR DATA IN DIABETES HEALTHCARE: SELFMONITORING AS DISTRIBUTED AND FRAGMENTED PRACTICE
Bruni, A.1, Rizzi, C.2
1
2
Università di Trento, Italy
Trento RISE, Italy
In the contemporary logic and rhetoric of patient empowerment, self-monitoring and
the delegation of a series of tasks and measurements traditionally associated with
healthcare work constitute one of the most evident forms of the endeavour ‘to enlist’
ordinary citizens in the management and organization of healthcare services. From
this point of view, diabetes is an interesting example of a healthcare sector where
patient empowerment has become prominent, and self-management is seen as a key
determinant of health outcomes. Drawing on the results of a broader research project
on diabetes services in Italy, the paper illustrates (by mean of ethnographic excerpts)
the importance for practitioners of not only collecting the data provided by patients
but also of understanding how these data have been produced. Interpreting the selfmonitoring practice within a framework between Science and Technology Studies
and sociology of medicine, our contribution addresses the contradictory aspects of
Patient 2.0, showing the invisible work performed by various other (human and nonhuman) actors.
Keywords: self monitoring; distributed and fragmented practice; doctor-patient
interaction
55
O 14
PROMOTING HEALTH AND SAFETY IN HEALTH CARE: A BOTTOMUP TOOL DEVELOPMENT
Bruno, A.1, Bracco, F.1, Sossai, D.2
1
2
Università di Genova, Italy
IRCCS IST Azienda Ospedaliera Universitaria San Martino, Italy
The objective of this project was to develop a tool for safety and health monitoring
in operating theatres that tried to overcome the limitations of existing methods. Sixty
health care operators (nurses and physicians) of six ligurian hospitals joined the
project in 2010-11. Following the action-research methodology, we facilitated them
in developing a tool - tailored on their cultural and operational environments - for
the detection and solution of issues related to health and safety at their early stage.
The tool is composed of three parts: (1) anomaly detection (problem description,
potential consequences and proposal solutions); (2) problem setting and problem
solving (definition of timeline and roles for problem management); (3) solution
process monitoring (effectiveness assessment and new actions to do). The tool has
several strengths both at the organizational and individual level: it enhances
interaction and information sharing, improving organizational health, it empowers
operators self efficacy and locus of control in influencing organizational processes,
it can become a database of already solved issues concerning safety and well-being,
allowing operators to learn from these experiences, it can also afford a clear
monitoring of processes that are generally long and tortuous due to the
organizational complexity of health care units.
Keywords: organizational health; action research; operating theatres
O 15
WOMENS MANAGING GENETIC RISK OF CANCER IN EVERYDAY
LIFE. A CONCEPTUALIZATION
Caiata-Zufferey, M.
University of Geneva, Switzerland
Since fifteen years, genetic tests are available to identify the predisposition for
56
breast and ovarian cancer due to specific gene mutations. Sometimes healthy women
get tested. In case of adverse results they receive a probabilistic information: they
know that they carry the mutation associated with the illness, but they don’t know if
the illness is going to develop. Once the at-risk health status has been determined,
then, these womens are required to manage it. Yet, the way they are supposed to do
it is unclear. The at-risk label places them in an ambiguous position, somewhere
between health and illness. Moreover, a closer analysis of the at-risk role shows that
its ambiguity is due to an excess of contradictory norms simultaneously promoted
by different social institutions. This paper provides a conceptualization of the
process of self-management of genetic risk in everyday life, based on a critical
review of the literature. Specifically, it explores the paradoxical situation of being
genetically at-risk and it presents the concept of “legitimization” as a heuristic tool
for understanding it. These considerations, drawn from a qualitative study on selfmanagement of genetic cancer risk currently ongoing in Switzerland, suggests
suitable interventions to support genetically at-risk individuals.
Keywords: predictive medicine; genetic risk; uncertainty; self-management; lifestyle;
legitimization
O 16
FROM THERAPY TO HEALING: A PHENOMENOLOGICAL STUDY ON
MEDICAL DOCTORS ENCOUNTERING TRADITIONAL HEALING
TECHNIQUES
Calabrese, G., Lattuada, P.
Integral Transpersonal Institute, Italy
This qualitative phenomenological study was undertaken to describe the experience
of traditional healing techniques for medical doctors.
Medical doctors use the scientific paradigm to deal with disease and therapy (Wulff
H.R. et al., 1995) and apply the neuroscientific paradigm to explain shamanic
phenomena (Krippner, S.C., 2002). Primitive culture people use a different
paradigm when they apply their knowledge for healing purposes (Wulff H.R. et al.,
1995). I was interested in the change of paradigm needed when these two cultures
meet each other. Using the phenomenological approach developed by Moustakas
(Moustakas, C., 1994) I analyzed the data collected by interviewing six doctors. The
experience would trigger a paradigm change only in association with a process of
epoche (Moustakas, C., 1994). This process was facilitated by either a critical
57
position toward the academic and institutional environment where doctors were
already practicing or by a personal crisis due to life event. There was a sense of
dichotomy between medicine as a science based on technological development and
medicine as a humanistic science. The experience raised doctors’ awareness about
the therapeutic relation with the patient. Technological development and
management organization has changed medical practice leaving behind human
aspects. The experience of healing paradigm may challenge a paradigm shift which
would be helpful to re-consider on human terms the therapeutic relation.
Keywords: health care system; therapeutic relationship; patient care & cure experience;
healing techniques; phenomenological study
O 17
THE STUDY OF MORAL CAREERS OF ILL PERSON AND OF PATIENT
FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF PARTICIPATED CARE PATHS
Calvi, C., Fucci, S.
Università degli Studi del Piemonte Orientale, Italy
This paper presents the advantages of using the perspective of the life course and, in
particular, the reconstruction of the moral career (Goffman 1961) from the
subjective point of view in researches that involve health and illness. This
theoretical perspective shows how the concepts of health and illness are socially
constructed. The process of defining these concepts involves the cultural baggage of
social actors, or better the set of shared norms, values and practices that they are also
behind the construction of the perception of the state of health and illness and of
well-being and malaise. The reconstruction of the moral careers of ill person and of
patient, through the use of qualitative research techniques, such as biographical
interviews, makes it possible to investigate the construction of identity, with
particular attention to aspects concerning the identity’s negotiation, the coconstruction of the path of care, and the self-perception. This kind of researches,
adopting a perspective that might be called “bottom-up”, may be a useful tool for
institutional structures that are responsible for the care in order to identify coconstruction paths of healing and of sharing health decisions in a more general
perspective of improving the relationship between healthcare providers and patients
Keywords: moral career; co-construction; biographical interview
58
O 18
“CAM” PROGRAM: THE IMPORTANCE OF CREATING BALANCE
BETWEEN BODY, MIND AND SOUL
Camilli, B., Marchesin, D.
Associazione Psicologia Utile ,Italy
Following the way of active listening, you develop an emotional and sensory
listening: this, in addition to the consciousness of your own beliefs, strengthens
oneself knowledge. The aim of this study is to give self cognition including: the
emotional lived, self beliefs and knowledge of the body. Who is it turned to: to
anyone who lives situations of change, crisis, has problems in managing his own
emotions or is looking to find his way. The system: Sessions focused on questions
and exercises developed in order to train people to listen to themselves on the three
levels: body, mind and soul. Application example: After a course titled “ BODY –
SOUL – MIND, effective approach to the profession” a participant writes: “Just at
the age of 25 years old I found out that till now I’ve only been an onlooker instead
of the absolute protagonist of my life, acting in the name of other people’s
motivations and beliefs that reflected the “perfectly respectable girl model” that I
have made mine. Consequently in me a sense of total estrangement and alienation
has continuously grown. I can’t manage to feel myself as a union of these three
aspects: I constantly feel them as detached. The question is: how to come out of this
situation and try to connect these three dimensions?”. At the end of the course the
girl was acquiring an increasing self consciousness, together with a renewed
enthusiasm. Currently the girl is finding out how to operate in her job coming out of
the mental numbness that inhibited her.
Keywords: active listening, self-cognition, emotional managing
O 19
EXPERIENCES OF THE CARING FAMILY IN THE TRANSITION TO
DEPENDENCE OF AN ELDERLY RELATIVE
Canga, A., Vivar, C., Naval, C.
University of Navarra, Spain
To develop a theory which explains the phenomenon of the transition to dependence
59
in the elderly person and in the family who cares for them.
Grounded theory study. The sample consisted of both dependent elderly who were
assessed according to Navarre’s Law on the Promotion of Care for Dependent
Persons, and their relatives. The core category of this study, called “dependent’s
dependence”, emerges as a substantive theory that accounts for the experiences of
these caring families. Data show that the families are not able to find a balance
between the dependent’s needs and the needs of the rest of the family system. The
dependent person and the situation of dependence become the centre and core theme
of their family life. The main problem these families are struggling with is to be able
to “carry on with their own lives”. These findings support the need for promoting
sustainable caring families, which are able to “carry on with their lives” and, at the
same time, who are able to provide the best care possible, and that this caregiving
becomes a positive family reinforcement. Family nursing interventions may have
positive outcomes for these caring families.
Keywords: family; dependence; elderly; grounded theory
O 20
FACILITATORS AND BARRIERS TO PARTICIPATION IN HEALTHY
LIFESTYLE BEHAVIORS THROUGH THE EYES OF ADULTS WITH
INTELLECTUAL DISABILITIES: A PHOTOVOICE STUDY
Cardell, B.
University of Utah, USA
People with intellectual disabilities (ID) have been identified as being more
sedentary and having more health concerns than people without intellectual
disabilities. Although the health conditions recorded in this population are largely
preventable, evidence-based health promotion interventions have been slow to meet
these needs. The aim of this study was to identify facilitators and barriers to
participation in healthy lifestyle behaviors through the direct solicitation of the
participants, 26 adults with intellectual disabilities. Photovoice, a community-based
participatory research method, was utilized to include participants in the research
process and solicit their insights and lived experiences, thereby co-creating
knowledge. The results combine data from photo-elicited individual interviews,
group discussions, and contextual observations. The results reflect facilitators and
barriers to healthy behaviors in the areas of content-driven health knowledge,
participation, and environment. The International Classification of Functioning,
60
Disability and Health is used to highlight clinical application of the results. The
insights and experiences of people with ID are necessary in order to develop
effective health promotion programs. This study begins that process by offering a
voice to a community that often goes unheard.
Keywords: intellectual disability; photovoice; health promotion; ICF
O 21
“PROMOTING
PSYCHOLOGICAL
WELL-BEING
PROJECT: PRELIMINARY FINDINGS FROM ITALY
GLOBALLY”
Cavallo, A.
Università di Padova, Italy
This contribution represents the Italian part of Promoting Psychological Well-Being
Globally, a large international project being conducted in several countries around
the world, under the guidance of Dr. Bonnie Nastasi (Tulane University, USA).
The purpose of this international project is to develop definitions of psychological
well-being and psychologically healthy schools/communities, based on perspectives
of key stakeholders (teacher, student, school, community) within participating
countries. Each research partner, collected data in their local community through
qualitative data collection techniques including focus group and individual
interviews, and structured activity related to stress and coping. The presentation will
concentrate on describing some findings derived from focus group interviews and
Ecomap activities with students from primary and secondary grade levels (ages 6-8,
9-11, 12-14, 15-17). Focus group interviews with parents and teachers, followed by
individual interviews with administrators and mental health support staff. Data
collection activities involved: sixty-four students (8 groups of 6-8 each); thirty-two
parents of primary and secondary grade level students (4 groups of 6-8 each); thirtytwo teachers of primary and secondary grade levels (4 groups of 6-8 each); five
school administrators and five psychologists (TOTAL SAMPLE = 64 students; 74
adults). Data collection activities were audio-taped, transcribed and translated into
English. A shared predetermined coding scheme was applied to the data. It was used
as a tool to face the ambiguities of the psychological well-being definition, and to
investigate the opportunities to contextualize more effectively environmental factors
involved in children and adolescents psychological well-being. These preliminary
findings represent an attempt at understanding students psychological well-being
and psychologically healthy environment.
Keywords: well-being; ecological model; qualitative method
61
O 22
KNOWING YOUR COLLEAGUES AND THEIR PRACTICE THROUGH
INTERPROFESSIONAL LEARNING
Chan, E.
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong
Explore how interprofessional education (IPE) and collaborative practice (IPCP)
improve relationship for health professionals through an understanding of roles,
values, communication and collaboration.
Thirty-three nursing and thirty-two social work students were recruited voluntarily.
The study is descriptive with two phases. In phase one, students attended two
interprofessional reflective seminars where they shared their views on decisionmaking and caring practice. In phase two, they participated in a two-week
collaborative community practice. The seminars and post-practice focus group
interviews were videotaped and transcribed verbatim for thematic analysis.
Four themes were identified. 1. Role clarification and enhancement; 2. Conflict
management through which various patterns of resolution emerged as explaining,
appreciating, incorporating and wishing to learn more from each other; 3.
Understanding the issue of assumption, the values of observation and blurred role
boundaries for communication in teamwork; 4. Recognition of interdependence in
providing better care through practice. Students’ openness and reflection played a
crucial role in the development of interprofessional competence. Their participation
in IPCP provided them with further insight into teamwork and collaboration.
Students’ continuous interprofessional learning about, from and with each other for
team communication and interdependence will enhance their relationship in
practice.
Keywords: interprofessional; collaboration; practice
62
O 23
EXPLORING FAMILIES’ EXPERIENCE IN PRACTICING POSITIVE
COMMUNICATION TO PROMOTE HEALTH, HAPPINESS AND
HARMONY: A COMMUNITY-BASED PARTICIPATORY PROJECT
Chan, S.S.C. 1, Zhou, Q. 2, Mui, M. 3, Lam, T.H. 2
1
School of Nursing, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
School of Public Health, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
3
The Hong Kong Council of Social Services, Hong Kong
2
A community-based participatory research (CBPR) project, ‘Happy Family Kitchen’
(HFK) was initiated to promote family communication and health, happiness, and
harmony (3Hs) using a positive psychology approach among families in a district of
Hong Kong. This qualitative study aims to explore participants’ experiences in
practising positive family communication through eating and/or preparing meals
together with family members.Twenty-one semi-structured focus group interviews
involving 207 programme participants were conducted after their participation in the
HFK project. Purposive sampling was adopted and families who have (1) mothers,
(2) parents, (3) elderly, (4) new immigrants, (5) children who required special care,
and (6) physically/mentally challenged members. were selected to participate in the
interview.. The focus groups were conducted by one moderator and two note takers..
All interviews were audio-taped and transcribed verbatim. Content analysis was
performed and themes identified. A total of 207 participants of the HFK joined 21
focus group interviews from April to August, 2011. The majority of focus group
participants were female (87%), aged between 35-54 years old (67.1%), married
(80.1%), and majority (81.2%) had been living in Hong Kong for seven years or
more. A total of five themes were identified: the families had become more aware of
the importance of family communication after the intervention, and its quantity and
quality of were improved. Moreover, empathy among family members as well as
some changes in parenting styles and practices was observed. Challenges to
achieving family communication and 3Hs were highlighted including busy life
rhythm and difficulties to mobilize passive family members. Cooking and dinning
seems to be a useful platform to enhance communication among family members,
and improve family 3Hs. The CBPR programmes seemed to have raised the
awareness and changed behaviours in improving communication practices among
most participated families. The overall context of a fast- paced and busy work life in
Hong Kong and the presence of passive family members have posed some
challenges in attaining quality communication and further innovative and targeted
interventions are needed.
Keywords: family communication; community-based intervention; focus group
63
O 24
WORKING WITH YOUNG ADOLESCENTS ON PREVENTION OF AND
DEALING WITH TEENAGE PREGNANCY: AN ACTION RESEARCH IN
NORTHEASTERN THAILAND
Chirawatkul, S., Kumdee, B., Chareonwong, S., Yigusang, R.
WHO Collaborating Centre for Research and Training on Gender and Women’s Health,
Khon Kaen University, Thailand
This study explores the situation of teenage pregnancy in Thailand and demonstrates
the participation of teenagers and multi-disciplinary approach on the prevention of
and dealing with teenage pregnancy in Khon Kaen city, Thailand.
An action research using a mixed method of qualitative and quantitative approach
was employed during April 2011-February 2012. In the situational analysis stage,
3,114 girls aged 9-19 participated in the quantitative part and 451 boys and girls in
the qualitative part. In the implementation and evaluation stage, 80 participants
including 25 girls, 15 boys and 40 parents joined the activities and were interviewed.
Descriptive statistics and content analysis were used for data analysis.
It was found that sexual activities of teenager were accepted by young adolescents.
Forty percent of pregnant girls did not use contraceptives or condoms, while boys
did not like using condoms.
Pregnant girls were condemned and had to drop out from school. Working with
teenage boys and girls lead to organize a “Warm family camp”. The camp’s
activities, provided by a multi-disciplinary team encouraged both young adolescents
and their parents to communicate about sexuality issues and be aware of gender
sensitivity.
The key findings suggest that a qualitative approach allow researchers and young
adolescents to gain deep understanding and create successful strategies in dealing
with teenage pregnancy issues.
Keywords: teenage pregnancy; gender; action research; Thailand
64
O 25
COLLEGE STUDENTS’ PERCEPTIONS ABOUT SUICIDE AWARENESS
VIDEO
Choi, H.1, Suarez, M.2, Wilkie, D.2, Park, H.2
1
2
Seoul National University, College of Nursing, South Korea
University of Illinois at Chicago, College of Nursing, USA
This Internet-based study was conducted to describe Asian American (AA) and nonHispanic White (NHW) college students’ suggestions regarding the changes they
believe are needed to increase the clarity, credibility, and cultural relevance of the
video, the Truth about Suicide: Real Stories of Depression in College (Truth about
Suicide), delivered via the Internet. After students were recruited from one
University in the U.S., by logging in to the study website they completed a baseline
survey, watched the 27-minute video, and completed debriefing/video evaluation
questions. All the answers were read, coded, and then sorted into categories. A total
of 301 NHW and 349 AA students answered the 8 debriefing/video evaluation
questions. Participants were impacted most by personal stories and statistics about
depression and suicide presented in the video. They were able to relate to the video
because of the similarities in experiences and situations between presenters and
themselves and the genuineness of content. The participants reported that the video
should include more diversity and address the cultural influence on suicidal
tendencies and suicide prevention. his study highlights the strengths of the Truth
about Suicide video and the need for and importance of addressing cultural
influences on suicide.
Keywords: suicide; college students; video; culture
O 26
SOCIAL SUPPORT IN AN INTERNET FORUM FOR PATIENTS WITH
SYSTEMIC LUPUS ERYTHEMATOSUS (SLE)
Cicognani, E., Mazzoni, D.
Università di Bologna, Italy
Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE) is an autoimmune disease which leads
patients to live with a variety of unpredictable symptoms. The consideration of
65
psychosocial factors, such as social support, is critical in order to understand their
disease experience. Internet support represents a potential but largely understudied
resource for persons with SLE. his presentation reports the findings of a qualitative
study aimed to describe the type of support that patients seek through internet
forums. 119 posts were collected from an on-line forum which represents a source
of support and information for the Italian community of people living with SLE. The
posts covered a time span of 12 years (2000-2011) and were authored mainly by
women, from 15 Italian regions. Messages were analyzed combining qualitative
content analysis with the use of statistical tools for textual analysis. Results showed
the presence of different purposes for posts, which included seeking information,
emotional support, psychological relief, starting new relationships and offer a
contribution. The content of the posts is discussed describing the relationship
between the kind of requested support, illness representations and coping strategies.
Implications include suggestions for the development of supportive on-line and offline communities of patients with SLE.
Keywords: lupus; social support; internet; chronic illness and disease
O 27
FACILITATING CONVERSATIONS ABOUT HEALTH PROMOTION
WITH PEOPLE WITH INTELLECTUAL DISABILITIES
Clark, L., Pett, M., Cardell, B.
University of Utah, USA
Health Promotion is an abstract topic for many people. Our objective was to engage
30 overweight/obese young adults with intellectual disabilities in a health promotive
lifestyle. A grounded theory methodology accompanied the twice-weekly physical
activity and nutrition intervention. Field notes and informal interviews recorded
individual experiences and group interactions and dialogue about health promotion.
Results describe a process of dialogue among participants and researchers about the
nature of health and health promotion. Researchers aimed to make health promotion
tangible for people with intellectual disabilities. Weekly weights and blood pressure
measures were ritualized and individual choice-making emphasized. Research
participants chose photographic poses as one means of representing their health
promotion identity. Other expressions of health promotion concepts were evidenced
in group and family interactions and stories about healthy activities. Participants
variously depicted health promotion as having, doing, and getting. Their photos
66
showed having beauty and self-esteem, doing activities for fun, and getting along,
getting noticed, or getting past bad experiences. Future efforts to develop health
promotion interventions for people with disabilities can incorporate more disparate
processual definitions of health promotion to fully engage this community in
realizing their goals.
Keywords: grounded theory; intellectual disability; photography; interviews
O 28
PATIENTS
AND
THERAPIST’S
PERSPECTIVE/VIEW
ON
PSYCHOTHERAPEUTIC CHANGE AND OUTCOMES: A FOLLOW-UP
STUDY
Colangelo, L.1, Fellin, L.2
1
Unità di Psicologia Clinica - ASL Azienda Ospedaliera Ospedali Riuniti di Bergamo,
Bergamo, Italy
2
Università degli Studi di Bergamo, Italy
This follow-up study presents a helpful factor design to compare patients and
therapist’s experience of change and outcome in 8 systemic-oriented individual,
marital and family psychotherapies completed with the same therapist in an Italian
public mental health service. 16 follow-up semi-structured interviews (8 with
patients and 8 with their therapist) were conducted by 2 trained clinicians 2 years
after the end of each treatment. All interviews were transcribed and analyzed using
Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (Smith, 1996) to compare the outcomes
and the helpful factors identified by patients and therapist. The master themes
identified in the two main areas (outcomes and helpful factors) are shared by both
patients and therapist. Client-identified important outcomes in psychotherapy are the
same 8 pointed out by their therapist. Another significant finding concerns the
therapist-patient matching: each dyad highlight some factors rather than others. Our
findings support the hypothesis that the follow-up is experienced according to a
pattern which connects it to the previous negotiation process of terminating therapy
and not as a separate and independent evaluation context. Cautions about ways of
conceiving and implementing follow-up and clinical implications for systemic
theory of co-constructing therapeutic change and end of treatment will be addressed
too.
Keywords: follow-up study; helpful factor design; Interpretative Phenomenological
Analysis; systemic psychotherapy
67
O 29
ELONGATION OF THE LABIA AIMED TO SUCCEED GREATER
SEXUAL SATISFACTION AND CONSEQUENTLY, INCREASED SELFESTEEM AND QUALITY OF LIFE: VISION MOZAMBIQUE
Costa-Reis, A.
Portugal
In Mozambique is basically carried out in parts of central and North of country. It is
a process of self-manipulation, based on massages that stimulate the small labia.
This work aimed to understand the purpose of carrying out this modification. To this
end, thirteen individuals’ interviews were collected from Mozambicans, of both
sexes. The subjects were living in Portugal, in the regions of Lisbon, Porto and
Braga. The data indicate that emerged a procedure aims to achieve more sexual
pleasure for both. Usually, the procedure requires the inclusion in a group of girls
who are experiencing the same process. Strengthen cohesion of the group and, in
simultaneously the psychological, social and community support. The results show
that this process aims to effectively achieve greater pleasure. At the same time, due
to fact that this procedure is accompanied by teaching, there is an increased selfesteem, which provides better quality of life in individual and community terms. It is
concluded that obtaining greater pleasure is obtained either by the greater coverage
of the area of physical pleasure, information and empowerment acquired during
instruction, as all the education that is provided the girl / woman.
Keywords: modification of the sexual organ; sexual minority; stretching; Mozambique;
cultural diversity
O 30
PERPETUATION OF FEMALE CIRCUMCISION IN THE EYES OF MEN
OF THE REPUBLIC OF GAMBIA
Costa-Reis, A.
Portugal
The innovation of this work relates both to the lens that was used in the
interpretation of Female Genital Mutilation and the focus on the male opinion on
68
this procedure. This report proposes the exploration of the theme according to the
Gambian androcentric vision. The information was obtained by using qualitative
methodology. For that, were interviewed eleven men in Banjul. In collecting the
data I used an intermediary. The results point to the development of a mindset based
on cultural and religious beliefs. This mindset is considered beneficial and essential
for the psychological balance of a woman; family stability; for the control of
sexually transmitted diseases; prevention of early pregnancy; and therefore for the
welfare and community members. Given this, there is a value for the circumcision
implications of achievement, even by those who have knowledge that the practice
can cause serious physical implications. A conclusion is reached that the painful
experience of the cut is offset by the positive emotions that go with it. In Gambia,
the eradication of the practice is an unrealistic and an unattainable goal in the near
future. As a result, it is advisable to review how to approach the subject.
Keywords: female genital mutilation; circumcision; sexual minorities; Republic of
Gambia; sexuality
O 31
STRUCTURAL VIOLENCE, BODY POLITIC AND WOMEN’S HEALTH IN
NEPAL
Dahal, K.
Tribhuvan University, Nepal
This paper aims to analyze gender based violence enacted against women in Terai
region of Nepal. It is based on data acquired from an in-depth ethnographic study
carried out to examine how gender based violence affects the health of women who
have to undergo through, stay in or bear this situation. This paper aims it examine it
from a social constructivist framework. Instead of focusing on merely any incidence
as a form of violence, this paper deals with structural violence, enacted and
manifested in different forms, against the women. In this way, it examines how
powerful social bodies exercise body politic over the less powerful bodies of these
women. Various socio-cultural processes have been found as mechanisms through
which gender-based violence is enacted. This study highlights that gender based
violence is embodied in the everyday life of women, such as, in the sphere of
socialization, space usage in the house and marital practices and making them
vulnerable to and embody a locally construed illness -Man Kharab Hune- a
psychosocial uneasiness which may accompany with some bodily disease. Different
69
empirical evidence provided me sound basis to conclude that health is a socially
constructed entity. In exposing the mechanisms, processes and consequences of
Nepalese women’s oppression, marginalization and exclusion this paper/issue has
significance not only in academia but also in practical and policy arena.
Keywords: embodiment; gender based; violence; women’s health; Nepal; Man Kharab
Hune
O 32
PERSONALITY PROFILES AMONG BULLYIED WORKERS CLAIMING
FOR A COMPENSATION: A GROUNDED THEORY STUDY
De Ambrogi, F.
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
The present study is a grounded theory research among bullied workers claiming for
a compensation. This study focuses on personality profiles and developmental
patterns and lead to new hypothesis on the role of personality and resilience in early
intervention, consulting and psychoterapic intervention. The results are compared
with existing literature on the same topic showing remarkable differences between
different methodological approaches.
Keywords: bullying; grounded theory; personality; resilience
O 33
DISTANCING ONESELF FROM A CARE GIVING IDENTITY: THE
EXPERIENCE OF FAMILY CAREGIVERS AND MIGRANT PAID
CAREGIVERS RELIEF OF BURDEN
De La Cuesta-Benjumea, C.1, Roe, B.2,3
1
University of Alicante, Spain
Evidence-based Practice Research Centre, Edge Hill Univesity, UK
3
Personal Social Services Research Unit, University of Manchester, UK
2
Caregivers comprise about 12% of the Spanish labour population and increasingly
migrant women from developing countries care for our older adults. The present
70
study aimed at knowing, from family caregivers and migrant caregivers’ points of
view, the experience of relieving the burden of care. Categories that emerged from a
larger study into the relief of burden were contrasted using comparative analysis.
The larger study was guided by constructivist grounded theory. Data came from 51
semi-structured interviews, 12 written testimonies collected and one group
discussion to validate results. To leave the life of care giving is the strategy that
family caregivers use to rest from care giving while turning to one’s own world
describes the way migrant caregivers seek to relieve the burden of care. The
comparative analysis shows that migrant and family care givers need to distance
themselves from a care giving identity and that, both employ strategies that are false
exits to their care giving identity. Health care professionals must promote
caregivers’ leisure activities and their involvement is different social roles, as well
as raise general awareness of paid caregivers needs for rest. Attention must be given
to those strategies that, disguised as rest, add burden to caregivers.
Keywords: grounded theory; family caregiving; immigrant caregiving; burden of care;
respite care
O 34
WHICH TOOLS FOR MENTAL HEALTH PRACTICE AND RESEARCH?
Di Blasi, M., Di Falco, G.
Università degli Studi di Palermo, Italy
The study regards the evaluation of supervision group; this kind of research fit in
with the field of the effectiveness’ evaluation that concerns the treatments’ efficacy
inside public or private Health Services.
The research aims to detect the process of two different supervision groups inside a
therapeutic community and a Public Department for mental health services. The
groups were led by an expert group analyst and they met ten times in one year.
The objectives of the group were: to make better the quality of health workers’
relationships, to improve self esteem, to increase the reflection about the emotions
and affects connected with their job and - indirectly – to improve the quality’s care
for patients. The meetings of the groups were recorded and analyzed through the
software for statistic text analysis “Taltac2” (Bolasco, 2007). The process analysis
shows interesting data regarding the different role and importance give to
institutional framework and patients’ background by health workers. Another
important aspect concern the ability to reflect on their emotions connected with
patients’ relationship: this skill represents a fundamental tool in the field of mental
71
health, but at the same time it’s one of the main difficulty for workers inside mental
health services.
Keywords: supervision; mental health service; groups
O 35
UNDERGRADUATE NURSING STUDENTS LEARNING EXPERIENCES
OF CLINICAL PLACEMENT: A QUALITATIVE EXPLORATION
Dinmohammadi, M. 1, Peyrovi, H. 2, Mehrdad, N. 2
1
2
Zanjan University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Nursing is a practice-based discipline and clinical practice is considered to be a very
important part of the nursing education. Through clinical placements, students are
exposed to different clinical fields thorough which the professional socialization is
facilitated. The aim of the study was to explore undergraduate students’ experiences
in the context of the clinical placement. The data was collected from 12
undergraduate nursing students in two large nursing and midwifery schools located
in Tehran, Iran. In-depth semi-structured individual interviews were conducted with
a purposive sample of undergraduate nursing students during their clinical
placements. Three main clinical themes emerged from thematic analysis: "clinical
poverty", "clinical distress" and "clinical pride", all of which are interrelated with
relatively chronological order in nature. Students begin learning in non-educational,
non-conducive and non-supporting clinical environment. They suffer from types of
distress in their clinical teaching period. During the last year of their courses,
Internship program, students gradually achieve a sense of control and satisfaction
for their own learning status. The importance of providing a supportive clinical
learning environment to enhance clinical teaching and learning is crucial. Faculties,
students, and preceptors involved in the selection and preparation of clinical
placements for nursing students should collaborate to ensure that the environment is
conducive to learning and promotes the personal and professional development of
students.
Keywords: nursing student; learning experience; clinical placement; thematic analysis
72
O 36
EXPERIENCE, NARRATIVE AND KNOWLEDGE: THE PERSPECTIVE
OF USERS DIAGNOSED WITH SCHIZOPHRENIA
Domont de Serpa, O.1, Leal, E.1, Malajovich Muñoz, N.2, Magalhães Dahl, C.1,
Monteiro Peixoto, M.1
1
2
Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Fluminense Federal University, Brazil
The general objective of this research was to know if the experiential knowledge of
people diagnosed with schizophrenia can instruct psychiatrists’ medical knowledge
and to know if psychiatrists’ medical knowledge on schizophrenia can modify the
experience people diagnosed with schizophrenia. The specific objectives were to
know users’ experience of crisis, treatment and the changes after the onset of illness
and to know psychiatrists’ knowledge, by their narratives, about the experience of
the crisis, treatment and the changes after the beginning of the mental suffering. In
this presentation we will focus on users’ narratives (first specific objective).
This is a qualitative study, based on users and psychiatrists’ narratives, analyzed
from the theoretical framework of Interpretative Phenomenological Approach. Three
series of focus groups were done: T1 - focus groups with users and psychiatrists,
separately, investigating in a temporal perspective, the illness experience of the first,
and the experience of diagnosing and thinking about prognosis of the second; T2 the narratives of one group was presented to another group; T3 - one focus groups
was done with users and psychiatrists together. The narratives obtained were
analyzed focusing on the content, following an analysis tree. Concerning users’
experience of illness some of our findings were the overlap between life experience
and illness experience; differences in the perspectives of 1st and 3rd person about
the “experience of the illness”; impact of the experience/”stigma”; coping strategies
(1st person perspective) x therapeutic resources (perspective of the caretakers).
Keywords: schizophrenia; experience; narrative
73
O 37
UNDERSTANDING RECRUITMENT TO RANDOMISED CONTROLLED
TRIALS: CLINICIANS’ PERSPECTIVES
Donovan, J.
University of Bristol, UK
Recruitment to randomized controlled trials (RCTs) is acknowledged to be difficult.
A program of qualitative research has been undertaken using interviews and focus
groups with trial organizers (TOs) and recruiters to understand reasons for levels of
patient recruitment. Data from six RCTs has been synthesized to produce a detailed
and nuanced understanding of the recruitment process from the perspectives of those
designing and recruiting to RCTs and to identify the key factors inhibiting or
promoting RCT recruitment. Interviews and focus groups were analysed using
constant comparison techniques (content and thematic approaches), and synthesized
using meta-ethnography. Data were available from 74 interviews (57 individuals).
TOs and recruiters identified practical/organisational difficulties that acted as
barriers to recruitment. They reported that patients often seemed to have strong
preferences for one trial arm or another. TOs were very committed to the RCT, but
many recruiters expressed uncertainty about treatments in the RCT. Clinicians had
mixed feelings about being involved in RCT recruitment, and many described issues
with their roles as doctor/nurse, scientist/researcher, or patient advocate or
manager/carer. Qualitative research methods can be used to understand the process
of recruitment to RCTs and indicate areas for improvement.
Keywords: interviews; focus groups; recruitment; clinicians’ perspectives; randomised
controlled trials
O 38
USING QUALITATIVE RESEARCH METHODS TO IMPROVE
RECRUITMENT TO RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS OF
HEALTHCARE INTERVENTIONS
Donovan, J.
University of Bristol, UK
Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are the design of choice for evaluating the
effectiveness of healthcare interventions, but many RCTs fail to recruit sufficient
74
patients. We embedded the feasibility phase of an RCT of treatments for localized
prostate cancer comparing surgery, radiotherapy and conservative management
(ProtecT trial) within qualitative research to investigate recruitment issues.
In-depth interviews explored clinicians’ views about the design of the RCT and
recruitment difficulties; and patients’ experiences of recruitment. Appointments
where patients were asked by clinicians to take part in the ProtecT RCT were audiorecorded. Content, thematic and conversation analysis techniques were used to
explore RCT information delivery and interpretation. Findings from the qualitative
research included that surgery was presented more enthusiastically than
radiotherapy; the conservative arm was unattractive to patients; and terms such as
‘random’ were misunderstood by patients. Changes were made to the recruitment
process: the order of presenting treatments was reversed to ensure equivalence;
misinterpreted terms were avoided or carefully defined; and the conservative arm
was redefined as “active monitoring.” Levels of consent to randomization increased
from 30% to 70% within eight months. Embedding RCTs within qualitative research
can improve recruitment and may enable the most difficult evaluative questions to
be tackled.
Keywords: qualitative research methods; health research; recruitment; randomized
controlled trials
O 39
A RETROSPECTIVE ON A NARRATIVE STUDY OF CLINICAL
TEACHING
Dwyer Kent, R.
Education and Practice Narratives in the Health Professions, Canada
“What brought you to graduate school?” asked the professor in my first teacher
education curriculum class. “I want to know why my teaching works well with some
students and not with others?” I replied. My participation (1990-1993) as researcher
in a SSHRC sponsored narrative inquiry into teacher knowledge and curriculum
development (Connelly and Clandinin, principal Investigators), and our in class
process of thinking narratively about our practice as educators and practitioners
were critical to the direction of my thesis work. The research in nursing by Benner
(1984), Bevis and Watson(1989) and Tetz Neal (1989) informed my decision to
enter graduate studies. Later, narrative research with colleagues and students in
clinical teaching led me to think about theory practice tensions in nursing and the
75
connecting teacher and student narratives across time and place in curriculum
situations. In this paper, through a retrospective on narrative as methodology and my
doctoral thesis work, (2004) I come to terms with the question posed in that first
class. I will share stories of practice and narrative inquiry into experience as
schooling (Dewey, 1938), the “learning stories” in my teacher narrative and an
understanding of teaching as a complex experience, shaped in and across life stories
of caring in relationship with self and others in professional health care situations.
Keywords: narrative; nursing; caring in relationship
O 40
FACILITATING THE ACTIVE INVOLVEMENT OF SOCIALLY
DISADVANTAGED WOMEN AS CO-CONSTRUCTORS OF THEIR
MATERNITY CARE
Ebert, L.1, Ferguson, A.1, Browne, J.2, Bellchambers, H.1
1
2
University of Newcastle, Australia
University of Canberra, Australia
Socially disadvantaged women have less choice and control over their maternity
care than more advantaged women. Although midwifery literature suggests that
woman-centred care can improve the birthing experiences and birth outcomes of
women, challenges have been identified in supporting socially disadvantaged
women to engage in choice and attain a sense of control within their maternity care
encounters. Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis, a qualitative research
approach was used to gain an understanding of the elements of woman-centred care
as experienced by socially disadvantaged women, midwives and student midwives.
This presentation reports specifically on findings that relate to the elements of
woman-centred care – choice and control and the socially disadvantaged woman’s
ability to be involved in her maternity care encounters.
Socially disadvantaged women do not feel safe to engage in choice or seek control
within their maternity care encounters. Inadequate information, perceived risks in
not conforming to routine procedures and the actions and reactions of midwives,
when choice or control is sought by women, results in silent compliance. This action
is a consequence of women accepting the responsibility for their baby’s wellbeing.
Midwives however, do not recognize that the women have made a considered
decision to shift the responsibility for their maternity care choices. Women and
midwives have different understandings of what constitutes involvement and active
76
decision-making within maternity care encounters. While socially disadvantaged
women want to engage in, and be informed of their maternity care choices,
inadequate information and facilitation of choice by midwives compels women to
delegate responsibility for maternity care choices that are outside their scope of
practice as a mother to the maternity care expert – the midwife. Midwives need to
understand that while decision-making can be hidden, women are never passive in
their choices.
Keywords: involvement; control; socially disadvantaged women; maternity care
O 41
THERAPEUTIC
COMPLIANCE
IN
CHRONIC
EXPERIMENTAL QUALI/ QUANTITATIVE RESEARCH
DISEASES.
Faini, F.
CE&Co srl, Italy
Pharmacological research aims at offering therapies that can ensure the
best compliance on the part of patients through reduction of the side effects, ease of
administration, lower number of administrations, preconstituted combinations in
order to guarantee maximum therapeutic continuity. The degree of compliance
which a treatment can ensure has thus become one of the indicators in assessing its
efficacy. Despite these improvements, today a part of patients still do not properly
comply with the treatments prescribed. This problem is what led to our interest in
studying non compliance, understanding how it manifests itself and identifying
possible solutions. A method-related problem regards whether online research on
access panels created for market research can effectively support exploration into
the health and therapies sphere.
Two research stages were conducted: a quantitative stage and a qualitative,
methodological stage. Quantitative stage: 331 individuals affected by at least one
chronic pathology, selected from a master sample of the CE&Co. Web panel. May
2011; 791 diseases observed, classified into 51 types. Treatments prescribed and
behavioural analysis. Qualitative stage: online forum on 20 individuals chosen from
the respondents of the previous stage. Analysis of the causes underlying failure to
comply with the therapy. Control of the motivations for participating in the research.
The results are encouraging from the methodological viewpoint: the feasibility of
this type of research on online panels is confirmed. High response rate: 50%, and
good reception by the panelists, appreciation: 80%. Good sample quality:
77
satisfactory distribution by stratification cells, possibility of filtering by pathology
and specific behaviors, consistency of the results with the epidemiological data.
Significant limitations for age threshold, however (up to 65 years old). High
response quality also confirmed by the qualitative exploration. The results of the
quantitative stage will be provided upon request.
Keywords: compliance; quali/quantitative approach
O 42
WHAT DO YOU DO TO BE WELL? PRINCIPLES AND METHODOLOGY
ON CHILDREN’S HEALTH PRACTICES
Favretto, A.R., Zaltron, F.
Università degli Studi del Piemonte Orientale, Italy
Definitions of health/illness and of being well/unwell are conceived today as the
result of an elaboration not only by adults, but also by children who are seen as
competent social agents in their health care. The children’s social competence
stimulates questions about which methods should be adopted to facilitate the
development of their view health and health care.
These themes were the objects of three qualitative, pilot studies. In the first study,
parents’ and pediatricians’ points of views on knowledge and practices related to
children’s health care were compared. Results showed that adults did not
acknowledge the status of children as competent subjects. The other two studies
focused on the youngsters’ competences on health, and on the most appropriate
methods to point out their views. Youngsters’ competences and representations will
also be discussed, based upon results of interviews aimed at their interpretation of
the etiology of certain health problems, treatment practices that they consider as
effective, and the sharing of social work by gender (among parents and peers) that
they consider as adequate in case of disease.
Keywords: children’s well-being; health’s representation; children’s social competence
78
O 43
THE WEAKEST LINK: PATIENTS’ INVOLVEMENT IN QUALITY
PROCESSES IN ACUTE HOSPITAL TREATMENT
Feder-Bubis, P.1, Azuri, P.2, Reicher, S.2
1
Health Systems Management Dept., Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Israel
2
Nursing Division, Ministry of Health, Israel
To examine perceptions of clinical teams in general hospitals regarding patient’s
involvement in the context of quality treatment. Senior Physicians and Head Nurses
from General Surgery and Orthopedics departments (N= 30) were interviewed using
open ended, semi-structured questionnaires including questions about teams overall
attitude towards quality treatment and processes, their measurement, and quality
benchmarking. The interviews were recorded and transcribed verbatim. Data was
analyzed in the spirit of grounded theory, using Narralizer software for qualitative
data analysis. Patients’ involvement was not acknowledged as a parameter when
defining quality treatment. However, it was perceived as an enabling factor in
reaching patients’ clinical goals. In most nurses’ and few physicians’ interviews
patient involvement was reported, and described as initiated by the medical teams,
not patients. Perceptions of patients’ involvement in quality processes differed
between physicians and nurses. Hospital teams perceive that in clinically acute care,
patients are not considered an essential active partner for the provision of quality
treatment and for the development and measurement of quality processes. This
stifles patient involvement in hospital care. Future qualitative research can elucidate
those factors that enable patients’ involvement in other contexts that may be
“translated” into acute situations.
Keywords: patients’ involvement; hospital acute quality care; quality perception
O 44
THE EMOTIONAL-INTERACTIVE LOOPS IN NARRATIVES OF WOMEN
WITH POSTNATAL DEPRESSION
Fellin, L., Emide, E.
Università degli Studi di Bergamo, Italy
The aim of this presentation is to investigate the emotive-relational context of
Postnatal Depression (PND). Despite the wide number of studies on PND, there is a
79
lack of qualitative empirical material that explores the contextual and
phenomenological experience of women diagnosed with PND. We adopted a
systemic-constructionist hermeneutics to analyze through Interpretative
Phenomenological Analysis (Smith, 1996) the self-narratives posted by 13 mothers
on an Italian PND-dedicated web forum. We will discuss six of the ten master
themes identified, selected for their relevancy to the emotional-relational context in
which the PND developed and is maintained. The most significant findings concern
three main areas: The emotional loops related to the interactive dynamics; the
relationship with the newborn; the marital relationship. Confronting our findings
with the literature on depression, some common points emerge: Concerning the
emotional-interactive loops, some similarities have been found with Ugazio’s (2010)
theory on depressive organizations; and, about the marital relationship, with Linares
and Campo’s (2003) patterns of depression and dysthymia. Limitations and future
perspectives will be addressed too.
Keywords: Postnatal Depression (PND); Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis
(IPA); web forum; emotive-relational context
O 45
PRACTICAL AND EMOTIONAL EXPERIENCES IN THE CARE PATH OF
TUMORAL
ILLNESS:
QUALITATIVE
ANALYSIS
OF
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL NARRATIVES
Fioretti, C., Smorti, A.
Università di Firenze, Italy
The present study aims to investigate the lived experiences of a family with a
children affected from cancer, in order to understand and deepen, through a textual
analysis of a qualitative nature, the emotional dynamics and practices related to
confront and fight experience of illness. The research involved four members of a
Florentine family in which the younger son of nine years has been affected by a rare
form of cancer at the age of 4 years. Each member of the family, father, mother, the
young patient and the older brother of 17 years, have taken part individually in an
autobiographical interview in which have reconstructed their own story and that of
the family from the time of diagnosis to the current one. The interviews have been
subsequently submitted to text analysis with the aid of word processing software
LIWC and TLAB, to identify the categories of words common to the interviewees or
specific of each of them. The textual analyzes conducted show how, despite
80
differences in gender, age and role within the family unit, the narratives of some
stages of the disease are characterized by similar terminology, while other phases,
such as the communication of the diagnosis, showing a significant difference in the
rates of terms related to the presence of therapeutic practice. In general, the higher
the levels of first-person singular pronouns, designed to recognize the disease as a
personal experience, at the expense of first-person plural. By sharing fully the
assumption that cancer emerges as a disease "family", this study aims to provide
scientific input to the analysis of the experiences of illness of several members of a
family.
Keywords: cancer; autobiographical narrative; family involvement; text analysis
O 46
ADVANTAGES OF AN ADHD DIAGNOSIS IN ADULTHOOD: A
GROUNDED THEORY STUDY OF ONLINE NARRATIVES
Fleischmann, A.
Achva College of Education, Israel
This study explores the impact of a diagnosis of attention deficit hyperactivity
disorder ADHD in adulthood on coping among the diagnosed adults.
I used grounded theory to examine seventy-one biographical narratives, selfpublished on the Internet by adults with AD(H)D. The findings illuminated a threesegment continuum. In the first segment the narrators had suffered from lack of selfconfidence accompanied by functional difficulties, stress, and guilt feelings. The
second segment began after the diagnosis. They began to believe in their ability to
lead meaningful lives, they found life more manageable. The third segment reflected
an additional effect of the diagnosis: realizing or thinking that AD(H)D may have a
positive impact. Some narrators subscribed to the belief that their traits as persons
with AD(H)D help them to cope better than others. An ADHD diagnosis seems able
to defeat unnecessary negative emotions distancing the diagnose adults from the
destructive cycle of amassing unfulfilled tasks and indulging in self-blame.
Keywords: adult; diagnosis; ADHD; Salutogenic theory
81
O 47
DO THAI PARENTS REALLY KNOW ABOUT SEXUAL RISK-TAKING
OF THEIR CHILDREN: A QUALITATIVE STUDY IN BANGKOK
Fongkaew, W.1, Cupp, P.2, Miller, B.3
1
Chiang Mai University, Thailand
Pacific Institute of Research and Evaluation, USA
3
Prevention Research Center, Pacific Institute of Research and Evaluation, USA
2
This qualitative study explores the perceptions of parents and adolescents toward
sexual risk taking behaviors. In-depth interviews were conducted with 30 parents
and 30 adolescents aged 13-14 in Bangkok, and were analyzed by using coding and
thematic analysis. Results showed that even though parents believed in general Thai
teens begin having sex at an early age and engage in sexual risk behaviors, they
trusted that their teens would follow parental guidance and rules and not engage in
sexual activity at this age. Meanwhile, most Thai youth reported that their parents
were not really aware of their teen’s sexual behaviors because of their tendency to
keep their sexual stories secret, for fear of being scolded, blamed and punished.
Teens also reported that they want their parents to listen, give them warmth and
more freedom, and be more in touch with their activities. Parents expressed their
need for knowledge and skills that could help them in guiding their adolescent
children so as to avoid sexual risk behaviors. A family intervention specifically to
empower Thai urban parents is needed.
Keywords: family; Thailand; sexual risk behaviors; qualitative study; Thai urban
parents
O 48
PROCESS OF COPING AND ACCEPTANCE OF MASTECTOMY BY
BREAST CANCER PATIENTS
Fouladi, N., Alimohammadi, H., Purfarzi, F., Masumi, A.
Ardebil University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Breast cancer with %22.6 is the most prevalent cancer among Iranian women and
mastectomy comprises %81 of surgeries done for treatment of breast cancer.
Mastectomy may create feelings such as deformation or impairment in patients,
82
cause body-image disorder, and reduce sexuality and sexual activity, subsequently
may prone to other disorders.
A grounded theory method was used to guide this study. Twenty participants were
recruited. Open, semi- structured questionnaire were conducted. Data analysis was
carried out with the constant comparative method using Strauss-Corbin method.
Seven main categories was administered from the collected data; reactions to
mastectomy, apposition of lose and death, re-evaluation of evaluation system,
consent for undergoing mastectomy, reactions and troubles after lose, confrontation
of lose and health, compatibility withy changes and reorganization all of which
affected the coping process in patients with breast cancer. The results of the study
indicated that patients were informed on their breast cancer and the necessity of
mastectomy as the treatment, they passed the seven categories to adaptation with
mastectomy.
Keywords: breast cancer; mastectomy; coping; acceptance
O 49
MEDITATION FOR HEALTH PROMOTION
EDUCATION. A QUALITATIVE APPROACH
AND
WELLBEING
Francesconi, D., Tarozzi, M.
Università di Trento, Italy
The scientific interest in meditation is rapidly growing in recent years and its role in
health promotion and wellbeing education is now actively in discussion (KabatZinn, 2005; Siegel, 2007; 2010). The Embodied Theory (Varela et al., 1991) has
here a crucial role because it merges meditation, phenomenology and western
scientific approach into the study of the “body-mind problem”. Meditation can be
considered a “body-mind practice” and a specific kind of experiential learning
aimed to develop, among other characteristics, wellbeing, awareness, metacognition
and bodily consciousness (Francesconi, 2009). This paper presents and discusses
two topics emerging from two qualitative phenomenological studies on the effects of
meditative practice on wellbeing perception in adults: 1) the promising alliance
between meditation and health promotion, 2) the fundamental role of qualitative
research in studying the meditative experience within healthcare and medical fields.
In particular, the main categories relating to wellbeing which emerged from the data
will be shown, namely awareness, metacognition, proprioception (intero- and
exteroception), nonreactivity, emotion recognition, empathy, bodily consciousness,
83
body scan, body mereology, self learning. Finally, scientific and applicative
relevance of meditative practices for health promotion and wellbeing education
programs will be discussed.
Keywords: health education; meditation; embodiment; qualitative methods
O 50
DECONSTRUCTING
ADHD:
A
CRITICAL
ANALYSIS
OF
PROFESSIONAL, SCHOLARLY AND PARENTAL NARRATIVES ON
CHILDREN HYPERACTIVITY AND INATTENTION
Frigerio, A., Montali, L.
Università degli Studi di Milano Bicocca, Italy
Attention Deficit and Hyperactivity Disorder and its treatment have primed a
profound controversy involving a confrontation of competing discourses. The
research analyses the social construction of ADHD in the Italian context within a
Discourse Analysis frame. In order to compare different stakeholders’ discourses
and to explore the interplay of professional, scholarly and parental narratives, the
research design involves diverse social actors (professionals, teachers, and parents)
and employs different forms of data collection (in-depth interviews, focus groups
and observations). Regarding the analysis method, we use a variety of resources
derived from Critical Discourse Analysis, integrated with Positioning Theory and
Bakhtinian dialogical approach. The analysis shows that each group is characterized
by a peculiar interplay of the socially available discourses regarding ADHD. These
discourses contribute to construct ADHD in relation to the position taken by the
speaker and the position she/he attributes to the child and to other relevant social
actors.
Keywords: ADHD; critical discourse analysis; positioning theory
84
O 51
EXPERT PATIENT ENGAGEMENT IN THE
REORGANIZATION OF CLINICAL PATHWAYS
ASSESSMENT
AND
Gilardi, S., Guglielmetti, C.
Università degli Studi di Milano, Italy
The presentation describes how the use of a participative method of analysis of
practices can lead to changing the clinical pathways of two chronic diseases and to
promoting a different relationship between patients and organization. The focus is
on the critical step between the data gathering phase and the phase of shared sense
making, as a basis for the transformation of practices.
In collaboration with the relevant stakeholders (healthcare personnel, expert patients
and hospital bioethical researchers) two instruments were chosen to analyze
practices: a revised version of Proactive Analysis and the Analysis of Decision
Nodes of the clinical pathway. The integrated use of both instruments highlighted a)
certain ambivalences in the representation of the chronic patients as adults, and their
consequences in the choice of treatment; b) the sense of belonging to the community
of care as an important construct for the patient’s quality of life. Regarding the
research process, we analyzed the group dynamics with reference to acquiescence
and acting out behaviors on maintaining the collaborative framework of the
research.
The results are relevant to the design and maintenance of collaborative management
of adult chronic patients who are high users of healthcare services.
Keywords: chronic illness and disease; patient engagement, clinical pathways;
participative research
O 52
A QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS OF ELFOSS COMMUNITY OF PRACTICE
Ghislandi, P.1, Cumer, F.1, Paolino, D.1, Eberle, C.1, Bellotti, F.2
1
2
Università degli Studi di Trento, Italy
Provincia Autonoma di Trento, Italy
In 2007, the Autonomous Province of Trento (Italy) decided to expand its training
offer for health workers through a distance learning network. For this purpose, they
85
sought the University of Trento’s help to coordinate and organize a project known
by the acronym eLFOSS - eLearning Training for Operators of Health Services. The
eLFOSS goal was to create a community where the “practice” would be that of
designing socio-constructivist eLearning modules using new teaching/learning
strategies (i.e. scripted collaboration, role playing, etc.) and the access to innovative
training tools (i.e. wiki, concept maps). This paper presents the factors that made the
community of practice birth possible and the analysis of this process evolution
through the qualitative data collected by means of a focus groups and the messages
posted in the community’s forums.
Keywords: case study; community of practice; eLearning; health; lifelong learning;
qualitative research
O 53
JOURNALS AS A KEY TOOL IN WAKEFUL INQUIRY.
TRANSDISCIPLINARY APPROACH TO SMOKING EXPERIENCE
A
Giorgino, V.M.B.
Università degli Studi di Torino, Italy
Journals are a key tool of the AURIGA action research program for smoking
cessation and reduction implemented in 2009-10 and involving 25 health workers of
the main Health District of Torino (IT). The program is characterized by the
interplay between clinical methods, contemplative practices and sociological tools in
order to help participants to quit or reduce smoking. The specific definition of
experience characterizing contemplative practices challenges the current concepts of
self and action in social sciences and the methodologies orienting their empirical
understanding as it opens the door for a broader conceptualization and practice of
well being. In this presentation I deal with the use of journals as first-person
methods enabling the emergence of participants’ experience, hence representing a
powerful tool for the co-construction of health promotion. The strategy adopted to
develop a second-person understanding of their lives is grounded on the dynamic
integration of the sensorial, emotional and cognitive dimensions and includes the
aim of alleviating human suffering through a social transformation from within
(wakeful inquiry).
Keywords: contemplative practices; first-person methods; grounded theory; journals;
smoking cessation; transdisciplinary approach; wakeful inquiry
86
O 54
ENHANCING CONSUMER AND CARER PARTICIPATION IN MENTAL
HEALTH SERVICES
Goodwin, V.
Australian Catholic University, Australia
This paper reports on the findings of a study which examined the role of psychiatric
nurses in enhancing participation of consumers of mental health services and their
carers in treatment. The study explored the experience of consumers and carers of
participation, via focus groups and interviews. The experiences of nurses were
considered, as were those of significant key informants. The study findings indicate
the importance of mutual respect, support and encouragement in the therapeutic
relationship, and the existence of attitudinal and systemic barriers to participation.
While nurses considered there was potential for consumers and carers to hold
conflicting agendas, this was not viewed as a barrier by consumers and carers in the
study. Recommendations include a call for greater involvement of consumers and
carers in the preparation of nurses.
Keywords: mental health; consumers; carers; mental health nurses
O 55
MANAGING SUSTAINABLE INNOVATION IN HEALTHCARE: THE
START-UP MANAGEMENT OF AN INNOVATIVE HEALTHCARE
SERVICE IN ITALY
Gorli, M., Galuppo, L., Scaratti, G.
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
The paper presents a case study on innovation management in healthcare. More
specifically, it aims to explore the management processes involved in the start-up of
an innovative healthcare model, by focusing on the challenge of safeguarding the
social sustainability of such a new organizational design. The case is a network of
healthcare services based in Italy, whose mission is to provide high quality services
with economic viability, by positioning itself “in between” the private and the public
offer. Through a qualitative and interpretive research framework, the study explores
87
the management practices involved in the start-up of the new organization, by
focusing on their perceived social sustainability according to the managers’ and the
stakeholders’ perspectives. The methodology presents a variety of tools taken from
the ethnographic tradition, as ethnographic interviews with the Board and the local
management, observation sessions of daily activities in two pilot centers, the
shadowing of a manager involved in the start-up of the centers, and document
analysis. The results highlight the central role of managerial practices related to
participative knowledge circulation and sharing. The study provides indication
around how to prompt sustainable and innovative healthcare systems through
effective cooperative processes of knowledge management.
Keywords: innovation management; sustainability; ethnography
O 56
ACCOUNTS OF MALE DEPRESSION: A CRITICAL SYSTEMATIC
REVIEW OF QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
Gough, B., Marks, K.
Nottingham Trent University, UK
It is increasingly suggested that the low number of men receiving formal help for
depression-related disorders is a result of widespread under-diagnosis, rather than
sex-differences in actual prevalence. This is variously attributed to the concealment
or atypical presentation of symptoms by men, resulting from social identity
performance or biological sex-related aetiology. In this paper we present a
systematic review 25 contemporary qualitative research papers focusing on men and
depression. Instead of highlighting key themes, however, we point to common
theoretical and methodological problems which limit the utility of this research. In
particular, our critique reveals the reification of researcher categorizations, such as
‘male’ and ‘depressed’, which subsequently necessitates the treatment of ‘deviant
cases’ as troublesome. We suggest that the reciprocal relationship between
membership of multiple dynamically constructed categories and the concept of
‘normality’ is considerably more complex than that assumed by such a narrow predetermined categorical focus. To overcome these difficulties, we propose that future
research should examine how such categories are constructed by participants
themselves within ‘naturally occurring’ interactions, so that they might be leveraged
within future interventions.
Keywords: men; masculinity; depression; help-seeking; discourse; online support
88
O 57
THE CONTRIBUTION OF THE PROFESSIONAL LIFE SPACE DRAWING
(PLS) TO THE STUDY OF PROFESSIONAL WELL BEING. A STUDY
ABOUT PROFESSIONALS OF THE ITALIAN JUSTICE SYSTEM
Gozzoli, C., Tamanza, G., D’Angelo, C.
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy.
This work has been carried out within the framework of the Italian justice system,
characterized by a very critical situation. It deals with two specific professional
groups: freelance lawyers and prison police officers.
These professionals have to face important challenges related to the social context
every day, for this reason their professional identities are at risk. The research
herewith described aims at presenting the contribution of the Professional LifeSpace drawing (PLS) to the study of professional wellbeing. The PLS, an adaptation
of the individual version of the Family Life Space (Gozzoli, Tamanza, 2008), is a
graphic-symbolic tool which aims to catch the representation made by a single
professional on his professional world and the relevant relational network.. In
particular the research aims to monitor the professional wellbeing / malaise of two
professional groups. Twenty police officers of a “casa circondariale” in Lombardy
Region (Italy) and twenty freelance lawyers have been involved. Both groups filled
the Organizational Check-up System (OCS) by Leiter and Maslach (2005), in order
to measure the workers burn-out level and their relation with their own job.
Afterwards they compiled the PLS. The OCSs were analysed with the support of
SPSS software, while the drawings were analysed at a phenomenologicalinterpretative level. The first analysis shows that most of the professionals are in a
situation of considerable burn-out. Their graphic representations are extremely
lacking in elements and bonds. Many individuals drawn themselves at the margins
of the sheet, surrounded by their family members. They also put their colleagues far
from themselves in the sheet, underlying their distance from a very hard working
framework. With these two pilot studies we want to show that the data collected
using the PLS may complete the ones about the professional burn-out, introducing
the aspect of the representation of their professional relational network. We think
that it is an important aspect to be monitored and supported, as a protecting factor in
promoting wellbeing in professional setting.
Keywords: professional well-being; burnout; professional life-space
89
O 58
ITALIAN CHILDREN’S PERCEPTIONS AND INTENTIONS ABOUT
HEALTH AND HEALTHY EATING: A FOCUS GROUP STUDY
Grassi, E.1, Evans, A.E.2, Messina, L.3
1
Scuola di dottorato in Scienze Pedagogiche, dell'Educazione e della Formazione –
Università di Padova, Italy
2
Michael & Susan Dell Center for Healthy Living- University of Texas School of Public
Health - Austin Regional Campus, USA
3
FISSPA - Dipartimento di Filosofia, Sociologia, Pedagogia e Psicologia applicata –
Università di Padova, Italy
The purpose of this study was to investigate the effectiveness of a school-based
media education curriculum on the promotion of fruit and vegetables consumption
to prevent childhood obesity. The target population for the study was 10 years old
Italian children (n=60) and their parents. The study utilized a mixed-method
approach, with a quasi experimental design (with one intervention group and one
control group). During pre-test and post-test and delayed post-test(after three
months), psychosocial determinants (i.e. self efficacy, motivation, parental support)
and fruit and vegetable intake were measured. Upon completion of the intervention,
focus groups were conducted with children in the intervention group. During the
focus group, children were asked to express their health and media beliefs and
knowledge, and nutritional behavior intentions, as well as their opinions/satisfaction
with the intervention. The purpose of this presentation is to present the results from
the focus groups. 21 children (7 female and 14 male) participated in 3 focus groups.
The focus groups were recorded and transcribed. The transcripts are currently being
coded and analyzed following standard qualitative analyses protocol. Data
interpretation will be completed by the end of May 2012.
Keywords: healthy nutrition; media education; children
O 59
BEYOND THE SILENCE: LISTENING TO THE STORIES OF ABUSE AND
VIOLENCE SURVIVORS
Greco, M.M., Portis, L., Sabatino, L., Stievano, A., Rocco, G.
IPASVI Roma - Centro di Eccellenza per la Ricerca e la Cultura Infermieristica, Italy
In 2010-2011, a research team of the Centre of Excellence for Culture and Research
90
of the Nurses Board IPASVI of Rome (Italy) realized the narrative-based action
research project "Listening to the silence: women victims of violence stories of
contacting health facilities". The main objective was to collect women stories of
their experience with health facilities in order to assess women’s needs and
healthcare workers' skills needs. The research team asked a group of women of four
shelter centers to write a letter directly to the health personnel they met. 37 letters
were collected and then analyzed with an hermeneutic-phenomenological approach.
Nurses appeared as background figures: unable to speak up for a respectful
treatment, uncertain about a comprehensive care and, overall, unable “to listen”,
beyond the silence of the women. Caring for vulnerable subjects requires leadership,
ethical sensitivity, deep listening, suspension of the judgment and overcoming
stereotypes with critical thinking. Narrative Based Research can help to gather
interesting material that can be also exploited in Education, to learn how "to
acknowledge, absorb, interpret, and act on the stories and plights of others", that is,
as Rita Charon defined it, to develop a narrative competence.
Keywords: violence against women; abuse survivors; narrative based research;
healthcare assistance; nursing;
O 60
NEW BOUNDARIES IN BREASTFEEDING SUPPORT IN ITALY: A PILOT
STUDY
Greco, F.1, Armeni, M.E.2, Cordella, B.1
1
2
Università La Sapienza di Roma, Italy
AICAPM, Italy
Health promotion policies today face new challenges and qualitative research can be
a helpful tool to explore the patterns of a phenomenon by helping developing
hypothesis useful to improve services. In this perspective, this action research was
generated by the interest of an association of health care providers (International
Board Certified Lactation Consultants –IBCLCs-) to identify strategies to develop
new services useful to fulfill individuals’ needs and to improve cooperation with
other health care providers already working in the field. According to this request a
preliminary research has been realized aiming to understand the characteristics of
the phenomenon and to assess the opportunity of a wider research on the topic with
the client. Audio-taped in-depth face-to-face interviews to explore physicians’
representation of breastfeeding were completed with 30 physicians: 15
91
gynecologists (9 women), 15 pediatricians (8 women); practice (30% hospital, 34%
NHS community services, 36% private). Transcriptions underwent a text analysis
with a computer software package (T-Lab), to identify factors (t-value; p<0.05) and
clusters (Chi2, p<0.01) characterizing breastfeeding representation and relating them
with the willingness in collaborating with an IBCLC (Favourable, Against,
Hesitant). The results show four different clusters characterizing physicians’
narrations, which represent breastfeeding as a complex phenomenon, leading to a
variety of perspective, each one perceiving a different target, professional function
and process. Moreover professionals’ breastfeeding representation influences
physicians’ willingness to collaborate with IBCLCs. When the perspective gets
more complex, accounting on medical and relational factors, physicians feel the
need to better understand and to build a relationship with the IBCLCs in order to
accept and collaborate with him/her. This need could be taken into account by the
IBCLCs in the construction of specific strategies to improve professionals’
cooperation and to offer customers integrated services.
Keywords: breastfeeding; health care providers; healthcare services improvement; text
analysis
O 61
STUDYING ADDICTION: THE CHALLENGES, ETHICS,
OPPORTUNITIES OF QUALITATIVE HEALTH RESEARCH
AND
Gueta, K.
Bar-Ilan University, Israel
Previous research has indicated the failings of the existing studies of addiction and
recovery, such as the absence of the patient’s view, neglect of relationships in favor
of techniques, and overlooking modern developments in the philosophy of science.
The literature suggests that qualitative health research can address these
shortcomings. Drawing from earlier research, the presentation will focus on how
qualitative research can generate change in the field of addiction. First, in addition to
representing the patient’s view, such research also enables drug-dependent research
participants to be experts regarding their experiences, enhancing the ability of
qualitative studies to serve as a basis for more adequate therapeutic tools. Second, in
light of the stigma attached to addiction, it should be classified as a socially sensitive
research topic, requiring special focus on ethical issues, a characteristic unique to
the qualitative research of addiction. Finally, qualitative health research may have
92
advantages for the evaluation of therapy issues from the perspective of drugdependent individuals and for producing applied theories of addiction and recovery.
Keywords: addiction; recovery; qualitative approach
O 62
BEYOND THE NUMBERS: INTEGRATING QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
INTO THE AUSTRALIAN MATERNITY OUTCOMES SURVEILLANCE
SYSTEM (AMOSS)
Halliday, L.1, Sullivan, E.2
1
2
University of NSW, Australia
Perinatal & Reproductive Epidemiology Research Unit (PRERU), Australia
Severe acute obstetric complications or maternal near misses are described as ‘very
ill pregnant or recently delivered woman who would have died had it not been but
luck and good quality care was on her side. These events are unexpected and
extremely distressing for women and the obstetricians involved, particularly if the
woman or her child dies. AMOSS is a proven system for epidemiological
surveillance of severe maternal conditions and interventions during pregnancy and
childbirth in Australia and New Zealand. However, due to the nature of quantitative
surveillance data, divergence among populations, process details, actual experiences
and situated meanings of these events are currently largely unknown. Interviews
with patients and obstetricians, recruited from the AMOSS network of almost 300
hospitals in ANZ. Scientific and applicative relevance. Conceptually, by
incorporating a complimentary qualitative component alongside the existing
epidemiological data collected the breadth, depth, and scope of knowledge about
severe maternal conditions in Australia and New Zealand will be enhanced, with
increased potential to address complex questions and to determine the nonmedical
effects of maternal complications on the long term, enduring psychosocial and
emotional health of women and clinicians. Beyond the numbers, exploring and
determining the experiences of women and the perspectives of the health
professionals who provide care, are critical to understanding some of the nonmedical aspects that contribute to the long term burden of these events.
Keywords: patient experiences; maternal health, qualitative reserach; surveillance
93
O 63
THE LIVED EXPERIENCE OF OSTEOPOROSIS
Hansen, C.1, Konradsen, H.2, Abrahamsen, B.3, Pedersen, B.D.4
1
Dept of Medicine C, Gentofte Hospital, Denmark
Research Unit of Gentofte Hospital, Denmark
3
Dept of Medicine F, Gentofte Hospital, Denmark
4
Research Unit of Nursing, Institute of Clinical Research, Faculty of Health Sciences,
University of Southern Denmark, Denmark
2
Non-adherence to medical treatment of chronic diseases remains unclear. People
with osteoporosis are mostly unaware of the disease, until bone fractures may occur.
The medical treatment might be the manifest of the disease before fracture.
However, it is unknown how this is experienced and affects the individual’s life
situation. The aim is to illuminate the human experiences and perspective in relation
to living with osteoporosis without fractures, but with prophylactic treatment. It is a
descriptive, longitudinal study that used a phenomenological-hermeneutic approach.
Sixteen women with osteoporosis and in prophylactic treatment were included. Data
was obtained using individual interviews three times during one year. Data were
analyzed at three levels: naive reading, structural analysis and critical interpretation
and discussion. The preliminary findings indicate that there are three categories of
lived experiences of osteoporosis: 1) accepting the diagnosis and embracing the
medical treatment, 2) seeking knowledge about the disease and the medication
during embracing, 3) alarmed by the diagnosis and of any adverse effect of the
medication. The project provides new basic research to be used in the efforts to
enhance patient participation and to provide health professionals improved
opportunities to support, guide and inform the individual patient.
Keywords: lived experience; osteoporosis; phenomenological; longitudinal study
O 64
CRISIS… WHAT CRISIS? WOMEN’S EXPERIENCE OF
WITHDRAWAL OF VIOXX AND DISCREDITING OF THE COX-2S
THE
Harris, M.
University of Newcastle, UK
To examine the impact of the withdrawal of Vioxx (rofecoxib) and issuing of safety
94
warnings on other COX-2s, on the medication behaviours and attitudes of female
consumers. Qualitative in-depth telephone interviews and intensive analysis of
interview transcripts to derive thematic codes. Participants were part of the
Australian Longitudinal Study on Womens’ Health (ALSWH) who had been taking
COX-2s. Emergent themes related to women’s reactions to the withdrawal of Vioxx
and issuing of safety warnings regarding other COX-2s. Interviews were conducted
with ten (10) women from the Mid-aged (born 1946-51) and 15 from the Older-aged
(born 1921-26) cohorts of the ALSWH who had been prescribed a COX-2, and
consented to linkage to Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme data. Reactions to the
Vioxx event were largely calm. Women sought information from their GP and made
treatment decisions with the GP based on that information. The media was the key
source of information of the withdrawal event. Women were skeptical of the long
term use of prescribed medication while they were happy to be using
complementary alternative medicine (CAM) and to manage CAM treatment on their
own. Results for women in the Mid cohort were highly similar to those for women
in the Older cohort. The older cohort voiced equal use of CAM but more reliance on
the GP for decision making. Overall these results suggested that women taking
medication for arthritis will react calmly in the event of a medicine recall, and will
consulting their GP to discuss the event. The media is the key source of information
regarding such an event. A tendency to focus on complementary alternative
medicine (CAM) independently as a way of managing symptoms was evident and,
more so in younger women. These findings will offer guidance in the future for the
management of such large scale withdrawal events.
Keywords: women; longitudinal
inflammatory
study;
discredited medicine; arthritis;
anti-
O 65
THE BENEFITS AND CHALLENGES OF USING LIFE HISTORY TO
EXPLORE THE EXPERIENCE OF WOMEN LIVING WITH A RARE
CHRONIC ILLNESS (LYMPHANGIOLEIOMYOMATOSIS, LAM)
Haylen, D., Fisher, M.J.
Sydney Nursing School, the University of Sydney, Australia
LAM is a rare, incurable, chronic condition characterized by progressive cystic lung
disease affecting 3-5 per million women, usually during their childbearing years.
This study aims to explore the experience of women living with LAM over the life
95
course to understand the impact of LAM as a rare disease on their lives, identify
their needs, and recommend ways to improve support. Life history methodology
examines the illness experience within a whole life. Nineteen women aged 36 to 64
years were recruited through an Australian hospital and LAM organization. Data
was obtained from two semi-structured interviews and the medical record of each
participant, and analyzed using Rosenthal's (1993) method of narrative analysis. The
benefit of life history was its ability to explore and represent the process of
reflection, decision making and action as women constructed their lives and health
in response to the challenge of being diagnosed with a rare incurable condition. It
linked physical reality, critical events, social context and personal meaning across
time to reveal women's complex experiences and support needs. Challenges for this
study related to recruitment, ethical considerations, distance, time and cost.
Keywords: life history; lymphangioleiomyomatosis; LAM; rare; chronic; incurable
O 66
CO-CONSTRUCTING THERAPY: REFLECTIONS OF LATINAS ON
ENGAGING IN A DEPRESSION INTERVENTION
Heilemann, M.1, Dornig, K.2, Pieters, H.1
1
2
UCLA School of Nursing, USA
UCLA Department of Social Welfare, USA
To describe the perceptions of 8 low-income, second generation Latinas 3 months
after completing an 8-week individual intervention for depression about what they
found desirable, useful, and effective to decrease depression symptoms. As part of a
mixed-methods study, constructivist grounded theory (CGT) guided collection and
analysis of data. Interviews were conducted by a researcher previously unknown to
the participants who was a psychotherapist trained in CGT. The open ended CGT
interviews allowed the women to freely share why they engaged in treatment and
why they chose to complete the program rather than dropping out. Through the
constructivist process, women described gaining a “tool belt” of useful techniques
for reducing confused thoughts, clarifying the cause of angry/sad feelings, analyzing
what they could do in response, and gaining confidence in healthy responses. By
engaging in the co-construction of their experiences, this CGT interview was also
therapeutic; women felt empowered to give advice on why and how specific
activities should be included in future treatment programs with other depressed
women. By participating in this study, women had the highly gratifying experience
96
of sharing personal advice for developing future interventions to increase Latina’s
engagement in and completion of depression treatment.
Keywords: depression; treatment; Latinas; resilience; constructivism; grounded theory
O 67
DISCOURSES ABOUT SUFFERING: MYTHS AND REALITIES OF CARE
FOR PEOPLE WITH MENTAL HEALTH PROBLEMS IN ANDALUSIA
(SPAIN)
Hernández-Padilla, M.
University of Jaén, Spain
To understand the discourses of suffering in people diagnosed of “Severe Mental
Disorder” in Andalusia and in its reference sociosanitary context.
From a constructionism, hermeneutic and phenomenological framework, we used
Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) from the sociolinguistic approach of Teun A.
Van Dijk on the discourses of patients, families, professionals and managers into
sociosanitary mental health system of Andalusia.
These communication presents the different topics, themes, discursive strategies and
other argumentative resources surrounding the emerging discursive category called
“disease versus suffering”. We analyze the main differences of this category in the
discourses of their key protagonists (patients, relatives, professionals and managers)
contextualizing these differences in their sociocultural, political, economic and,
fundamentally, ideological context.
Suffering and disease are two concepts with clear ideological implications that affect
different forms of caring and assigning the social-health resources. It is necessary to
analyze these implications from the Social Determinants of Health sponsored by
World Health Organization, focused on equity, knowledge and universal health care.
Keywords: suffering discourses; mental health patients; autonomy of patients; social
exclusion
97
O 68
ENGAGING ALL RESEARCH STAKEHOLDERS. CLOUD- BASED TOOLS
FOR COLLABORATIVE QUALITATIVE PROJECT MANAGEMENT,
DATA COLLECTION AND SHARING
Holewa, H.
CQUniversity, Australia
The benefits of collaboration in health related research are well known and include:
greater access to specialized knowledge and expertise; greater cross discipline
awareness and discoveries; and increased translation outcomes. It is also
acknowledged that active engagement of all stakeholders in the research process
including researchers, health professionals and patients can maximize research
outputs and translation if appropriately managed. Despite the recognition of such
benefits, little innovation has occurred in the development of qualitative specific
software to streamline collaboration, data collection and sharing. This is particularly
important for collaborative qualitative research projects which often involve the
management of sensitive data across multiple stakeholders and data collection sites.
This presentation will detail findings from research conducted to develop ‘Quadrant’
an online software tool designed to enable qualitative researchers to collaborate,
collect and store sensitive data in a secure and ethically sound environment. It will
be demonstrated how the software assists in efficiently conducting qualitative
research projects and in fostering research stakeholder engagement (including
individual participants).
Keywords: electronic collaboration; data management; participant engagement
O 69
THINKING OUTSIDE THE (BMI) BOX: AN INTERPRETATIVE
PHENOMENOLOGICAL ANALYSIS OF HEALTHY WOMEN WHO LIVE
OUTSIDE THE BIOMEDICALLY DEFINED IDEAL WEIGHT RANGE
Holland, F.1, Peterson, K.2
1
2
University of Derby, UK
University of North Carolina, USA
This paper presents findings and applications of a study using interpretative
98
phenomenological analysis (IPA) to explore the lived experiences of women
classified as overweight or obese on the BMI charts. In semi-structured interviews,
women from the US and UK aged 40-55 discussed received messages around food,
body, health and weight, and their paths to health, well-being and non-dieting.
Influenced by feminism and positive female role models, respondents found ways to
insulate themselves from the battle with bodies that their culture imposes on them,
reinterpreting family and peer pressure to be thinner as they reached adulthood.
They articulated the benefits of movement and healthful eating and practiced these
behaviours without weight loss as a goal. The interviews reveal women who have
increased self-esteem, take good care of their bodies and are resilient to media
messages that often lead to body dissatisfaction. The paper addresses ways that
health providers can positively work with “overweight” populations and
demonstrates the role qualitative research can play in balancing the biomedical
paradigm of health that leans heavily on measurements such as the BMI.
Keywords: interpretative phenomenological analysis; body esteem; women
O 70
DIFFICULTIES IN CARING FOR PEOPLE WITH DEMENTIA AT A
GROUP HOME: UNDERSTANDING THROUGH REFLECTING ON DATA
THROUGH INTERVIEWS AND PARTICIPANT OBSERVATIONS
Hori, K.
Yokohama National University, Japan
Providing care for the demented elderly is a serious problem in Japan, where the
population is aging rapidly. This study was designed to develop a psychological
understanding about caring for elderly people with dementia at a group home where
they are utilizing surviving abilities, from the perspective of the interactions
between care workers and users. Exploratory analysis was conducted with data on
care workers talking about their work that was obtained through participant
observations. Then, a structural model was constructed and analyzed using
qualitative research methodology, because the context of dementia care was
considered to be important. Therefore, “reflection in action”, the practical
epistemology developed by D. A. Schön was adopted as the framework for
analyzing the complex practical problems involved in care work.. Care workers
placed importance on offering quiet hours. They felt that elderly people with
dementia spend the daytime calmly. Care workers however, had difficulties in
understanding the elderly people with dementia that manifested Behavioral and
99
Psychological Symptoms of Dementia (BPSD). They felt to manage care work
during the daytime with colleagues, but inadequate and need support at night
because they have to take care of elderly people with dementia all alone. Nighttime
BPSD aggravated problems and lead to stress, fear and breakdowns in care workers.
As a result, they felt that the most significant source of difficulties in caring for
people with dementia were elderly people with midnight BPSD. Results were
examined from the perspective of “reflection in action”. A gap was created between
their intentions and practice of care, and care workers were unable to pay attention
to the structure of the gap, as a result, they couldn’t control their care strategies,
setting goals, conducting and modifying strategies, and examining the results.
Furthermore, how to deal with BPSD varied depending on their individual
experiences, therefore it was difficult to sufficiently generalize the strategies, to
share effective methods. It is suggested that supporting care workers psychologically
can play a role, so that they are able to control care strategies under changing
conditions.
Keywords: demented elderly caring; group home; psychology; reflection in action;
interaction
O 71
ROLE OF CURRICULAR ELEMENTS IN IRANIAN
STUDENTS’ PROFESSIONAL IDENTITY DEVELOPMENT
NURSING
Hosseini Shahidi, L. 1, Mahram, B. 2
1
2
Gonabad University of Medical sciences, Iran
Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran
As nursing students’ professional identity has been declined, it could be profoundly
understood and identify its effective educational components using qualitative
evaluation. In this study, Criticism and Connoisseurship of Eisner has been used for
qualitative evaluation of nursing education system. This model includes four steps
of descriptive, interpretative, evaluative and thematic. Data sources were in-depth
interview with students and faculty members and observation of educational
environments (theoretical and clinical). At first, components of professional identity
and its present situation were selected by semi-structured interviews with 10 nursing
students and faculty members using accessible sampling and educational
environment observation. Then, data were analyzed by content analysis and coded
by mining themes. Four fundamental components include shortcoming in student
100
admission with lateral themes of gender-oriented admission, failure of educational
system for presenting nursing discipline with lateral themes of inconsistency
between theory and clinical practice and awareness of background of profession,
reality shock with lateral themes of uncertain task, role overlap and inequality, selfsteam with lateral themes of body of knowledge and role modeling, were effective
educationally on nursing students’ professional identity. It seems, changing
admission process as well as presentation nursing discipline to students as much as
possible, more realistic education and making exclusive body of knowledge and
successful role models are helpful in students’ professional identity development.
Keywords: education; nursing graduate; professional curriculum identity
O 72
IRANIAN WOMEN AND LIVED EXPERIENCES
VIOLENCE: A HERMENEUTIC STUDY
OF
DOMESTIC
Hosseini Shahidi, L.1, Sadegh Moghdam, L.1, Shamaian Razavi, N.2, Heidary, A.2
1
2
Gonabad University of Medical sciences, Iran
Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran
Domestic violence towards women is a damaging experience which deserves to be
studied and a way to control and hopefully destroying it as to be found. This
hermeneutic study has been done to understand the Iranian women’ lived
experiences dealing with domestic violence. Participants in this study are Iranian
women from a small town. This research was conducted by in–depth unstructured
interview, with eight women who have experienced a domestic violence from 20082009. Data Analysis was performed based on interpretation technique of Van
Manen’ content analysis. The women described experiences in five themes of
tolerating it, deprivation, being confused, feeling of ignored and self – blaming are
the ways these women described their experiences. Women had been exposed to
domestic violence through social pressures, culture and gender based values. They
believed that, domestic violence is very common and normal in society, and it was
accepted as a male behavior. However, all participants experienced physical
violence they believed that psychological and emotional was the worst alternative.
The life experience these women have gone through concludes their experience as a
damaging effect on Iranian women lived experiences.
Keywords: lived experiences; domestic violence; women
101
O 73
PHILOSOPHICAL HERMENEUTIC RECKLESSNESS: UNDERSTANDING
THE UN-METHOD FOR SOCIAL AND HEALTH SCIENCE RESEARCH
Hovey, R.
McGill University, Canada
The purpose for preparing this presentation is to contribute to the conversation about
qualitative research methods and approaches with specific consideration of
philosophical hermeneutics as a research approach within the social and health
sciences context. Philosophical hermeneutics may somewhat misunderstood and
misinterpreted as a research approach, because of its apparent lack of repeatable and
structured method with exact steps and processes. Through this presentation, the
author will provide an overview of philosophical hermeneutics and why it should
remain the un-method among other qualitative research methods. As well as to
explore why philosophical hermeneutics is not a method per se but rather an
approach that the researcher evolves with time and commitment to the philosophy
underpinning hermeneutics. In this research, context philosophical hermeneutics
becomes a means to gain an understanding of complex social-relational, cultural,
and historical human experiences of health within an interdisciplinary framework
for research in practice. The presentation will incorporate research findings as
examples from several philosophical hermeneutics research projects that span topics
such as, patient safety, osteoporosis, diabetes within an Aboriginal context and
patient / medical education.
Keywords: philosophical hermeneutics; Hans George Gadamer; research approach;
interdisciplinary collaboration; chronic illness; patient centered care; education
O 74
TRANSITION FROM SELF-SUPPORTED TO LIVING: OLDER PEOPLE'S
EXPERIENCES
Hvalvik, S., Reierson, I.A.
Telemark University College, Norway
To become dependent on professional support to accomplish the daily activities of
102
life can be considered a turning point, involving a range of challenging changes in
life. The purpose of the study was to describe the experiences of older homedwelling individuals in transition from self-supported to supported living from a
lifeworld perspective. Five women and five men were interviewed, and a descriptive
phenomenological design was used. The findings showed that an attitude of
acceptance was an essential characteristic for this group. An attitude of acceptance
comprised: flexibility and tolerance, recognition and hopes, and valuation of self and
situation. Finding themselves in a situation they had to submit to, they took an
attitude of acceptance. An attitude of acceptance implied acknowledgement of the
situation as well as positivity and desires to manage. This attitude may represent a
significant potential for improvement. Awareness of this is crucial to support older
individuals in a healthy way through the transition process. An attitude of
acceptance, however, also implied an acceptance of discontinuity in their lives,
renunciations, and denigration of own needs. But this aspect of the acceptance was
trivialized by the participants and not equally obvious. Insight into this complexity is
vital to avoid ignorance of older individuals’ vulnerability in the transition process.
Keywords: lifeworld; elder; phenomenological approach; support; transition
O 75
WHAT PEOPLE LEARN FROM ANIME AND MANGA AS VISUAL LIFE
STORIES: VISUAL NARRATIVES FOR QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
Ieshima, A.1, Yamada, Y.2, Urata, Y.2
1
2
Shimane University, Japan
Kyoto University, Japan
The purpose of this study was to explore the impact of anime (Japanese animation)
and manga (Japanese comics) on young people. In the first study, 992 online
narratives mentioning the influence of manga were extracted and analyzed on the
basis of the KJ-method (a common methodology for analyzing qualitative data in
Japan, categorizing text data without losing their original nuances). The following
five main topics were observed: (1) the meaning of love, (2) the importance of true
friendship, (3) the value of effort, (4) the meaning of life, and (5) useful/practical
information. In the second study, 28 Japanese and 16 American young people
participated in a semi-structured interview that explored what and how they learned
from anime and manga. The results revealed that anime and manga improved young
people’s mental health because they derived not only information but also
103
motivation and relaxation from anime and manga as the hero/heroine’s visual life
stories and some of them intentionally used anime and manga to control their
negative feelings such as anxiety and stress.
Keywords: visual life story; narrative; model of life; anime; manga
O 76
NURSES’ LIVED EXPERIENCE OF THE DEATH OF THEIR PATIENTS
Karimi Moonaghi, H. 1, Zoubin, F. 1, Binaghi, T. 2
1
2
Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Parvin High School, Iran
Understanding of Nurses’ experiences about death and dying can lead to knowing
this phenomenon appropriately. Then, this can help nurses to find suitable
approaches to cope with the aspects of death. In addition, nurses’ conception of
death can help them emotionally and psychologically. Finally, delivering an
acceptable care for patients depends on nurses’ knowledge about this phenomenon.
Nurses cannot make good decision about this complex phenomenon, if they have not
enough knowledge about their experiences regarding death. In addition, knowledge
deficit about death affect other roles of nurses. To describe and interpret Nurses’
Lived Experience of The Death of Their Patients to gain in depth insight to this
phenomenon. Phenomenological approach was used to conduct this study.
Individual interview was convened with 12 nurses for data gathering.
Contemporaneous notes were taken and the interviews were tape-recorded and later
transcribed verbatim. Transcriptions were analyzed by using the Van Manen
procedures. Data from the interviews developed into 4 themes: losing oneself life,
deficit communication process, caring with stress, and feeling grief. Findings
showed that increasing of work experience and frequent encountering with patient
death, promotes coping approaches of nurses. Although, losing of the sensitivity to
death of patients has useful effects for nurses, but the patients’ family reactions to
nurses must be considered. Results show that nurses need organizational and family
supports to cope with the death of their patients. Neglecting of nurses’ needs may
have unwanted effects on patients and nurses.
Keywords: nurse; lived experience; death; phenomenology
104
O 77
EXPLORATION
HEALTHCARE
OF
THE
TRIADIC
COMMUNICATION
IN
Karnieli-Miller, O.1, Werner, P.1, Neufeld-Kroszynski, G.1, Eidelman, S.2
1
2
University of Haifa, Israel
Rambam Medical Center, Israel
To explore and understand the dynamics of triadic communication between a
specialist, a patient and a companion. An innovative combination of grounded
theory text analysis and the use of graphics developed for this study focused on
illustrating triadic communication and the dynamics within them. Twenty-five realtime observations of actual triadic encounters in memory clinics by six different
physicians were analyzed. T
he graphic analysis illustrated that the triadic communication was actually a series of
alternating dyadic exchanges where the third person tries, with inconsistent degrees
of investment and success, to become actively involved. The core dyad shifts from
physician-patient (during the introductions and assessment) to physician-companion
(during the diagnosis disclosure and treatment discussion). The focus of
communication shifts within these encounters: from talking with the patient to
talking about him or ignoring him.
These shifts may be experienced as offensive and paternalistic. Effective and
empathic management of a triadic communication that avoids unnecessary
interruptions and frustrations requires the professional to acquire specific
communication skills (e.g., explaining the rules and order of the conversation).
The use of graphics seems helpful for qualitative researchers in untangling the
complex phenomena of triadic communication.
Keywords: triadic communication; graphic analysis;
news/diagnosis; Alzheimer's and dementia; observations
communicating
bad
105
O 78
USING DIGITAL
CONVERSATIONS
STORYTELLING
TO
PROMOTE
RECOVERY
Kenny, A. 1, Hardy, P. 2, Kidd, S. 1, McKinstry, C. 1
1
2
La Trobe University, Australia
Pilgrim Projects, UK
Community involvement in healthcare is enshrined in international policy, with
policy indicating that individuals must be involved as co-constructors of their health.
The challenge is to develop ways for consumers to directly influence healthcare
design and delivery. Australian mental health policy focuses on recovery and
wellness oriented services; however, the lack of shared understanding of recovery
impacts on service delivery. To identify health professionals and consumers shared
understanding of mental health recovery, using digital storytelling to promote
recovery conversations. As part of an action research study, health providers and
mental health consumers shared their recovery experiences in a digital storytelling
workshop. Data included ten digital stories and discussions that emerged through the
process. Consideration of the data resulted in a shared view that recovery is a
threshold concept. A threshold concept has the potential to transform understanding.
The group contended that without the development of a shared understanding of
recovery, services will remain acute focused, rather than wellness oriented,
supporting people to live meaningful lives. Digital storytelling is an empowering
tool that can be used to facilitate the active involvement of consumers and
healthcare providers in co-constructing wellness focused health care.
Keywords: recovery; digital storytelling; consumers; health providers
O 79
“STRENGTHENING MY FAMILY FOUNDATION”: A THEORETICAL
SCHEME OF COUPLES’ FIRST CHILDBEARING EXPERIENCE IN
URBAN SOCIETIES
Khadivzadeh, T., Latifnejad Roudsari, R.
Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Having a child is a major experience in human life. The process of forming first
106
childbirth experiences has a little attention in empirical researches on fertility,
especially in socio-cultural context of Iran considering the great variations in
fertility indicators in recent decades. Therefore, this qualitative study was conducted
to develop a theoretical scheme on the process of couples’ experience of having
their first child in urban society of Iran. In this Grounded theory study in-depth
interviews were performed with 24 fertile women living in urban society of
Masshad. Data analysis were carried out adapting Strauss and Corbin mode of
analysis through constant comparative analysis applying methods of open, axial and
selective coding using MAXqda software and continued until development of
theoretical scheme. Study rigor was verified via prolonged engagement, member
validation of cods and deep description of the study. The core category that
describes couples’ experience of having a child was “Strengthening my family
formation”. The categories were presented into a paradigm consisted of 1)
Cognitive-affective stimulus for having a child, 2) Evaluation of circumstantial
conditions and making a decision, 3) Managing the course of having a child and 4)
Parenthood role attainment. In condition of “being ready”, couples might enjoy the
sense of achieving to aims of everlasting, strengthening the foundation of their new
built family and satisfying parental instinct. Un-readiness mostly led to poor
adjustment with playing the parenthood role and sometimes to seek for abortion.
Couples’ fertility decisions and behaviors are influenced by their cognitions and
emotions and also a variety of circumstantial conditions. It is important to
comprehend this process and apply it in reproductive health care delivery system.
Keywords: child bearing; fertility; parenthood; theoretical scheme
O 80
QUALITATIVE RESEARCH: PSYCHOSOCIAL PROBLEMS OF SPINAL
CORD INJURY PATIENTS
Khazaeipour, Z.1, Noroozi Javidan, A.2, Pesteh, K.2, Mirmajidi-Hashjin, S.Z.2
1
Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Brain and Spinal Injury Repair Research Center, Tehran University of Medical
Sciences, Iran
2
Medical management of spinal cord injury (SCI) patients has now shifted from
physical measures outcome to attempt to better understand factors that affect their
quality of life. The aim of this study is to describe the psychosocial outcomes of SCI
patients to help rehabilitation group to recognize and solve the patients’ problems
107
and their demands, in order to have a healthy and happy life. We evaluated SCI
patients and the specialists and nurses who are related to them. They were requested
to report and write about the cause of injury and psychosocial problems which these
patients were coping with. The problems were financial problems as a result of
losing their jobs, the lack of diagnostic and therapeutic facilities in their towns,
transportation in or out of their houses, marriage state, education state, insufficient
entertainment and psychological problems, depression, plan or attempt to suicide
and contact with others. Careful planning by the spinal unit staff, and the staff who
are responsible for community services, in conjunction with the patients and their
family or community, is essential. Coping with a chronic physical condition like SCI
requires daily, ongoing self-care, exemplified by conscious, instrumental efforts.
Keywords: psychosocial problem; spinal cord injury; education; suicide
O 81
CONSENSUAL QUALITATIVE RESEARCH (CQR): A NEW METHOD IN
QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
Kim, D.M.
Jeonju University, South Korea
Consensual Qualitative Research(CQR) is a comparably new inductive research
method first introduced to the research field in 1997 by C. E. Hill, B. J. Thompson,
and E. N. Williams(1997), intending to integrate the best features of the existing
qualitative methods and also to be rigorous and easy to learn. CQR lies between
constructivism and post-positivism in terms of philosophical stance (Hill, Knox,
Thompson, Williams, Hess, & Ladany, 2005) and incorporates elements from
phenomenological, grounded theory, and comprehensive process analysis,
ultimately aiming for generating theories (Hill, Thompson, & William, 1997). The
essential components of CQR are (a) the use of open-ended questions in semistructured data collection techniques to collect consistent data across participants
and to examine their experiences more in-depth; (b) the consent of at least three
judges including the researcher and one auditor in order to establish the
trustworthiness and accuracy of the results throughout the data; and (c) the use of
domains, core ideas, and cross-analyses in the data analysis. Throughout the
consensual process CQR requires mutual respect, equal involvement, and shared
power among the team members. CQR is ideal for comprehensive studies of the
inner experiences of individuals in various filed, because it involves consensual data
108
analysis that reduces the biases inherent with one researcher analyzing the data, and
also because it acknowledge the relationship between the participant and the
researcher (Hill et al., 2005).
Keywords: consensus; domain; core ideas; cross-analysis; constructivism; postpositivism
O 82
FROM PATIENT TO MENTOR: THE EXPLORATION OF NEW ROLES
AND UNDERSTANDING - EXPERIENCES FROM PARTICIPATING IN
DESIGNING A NEW EDUCATION PROGRAMME FOR PEOPLE
DIAGNOSED WITH RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
Kristiansen, T.M.1, Antoft, R.2, Primdahl, J.1, Hørslev-Petersen, K.3
1
University of Southern Denmark, King Christian X´s Hospital for Rheumatic Diseases,
Denmark
2
Aalborg University, Dept. of Sociology and Social Work, Denmark
3
MD DMSci, Denmark
This fieldwork followed a project which aimed to develop education for people with
rheumatoid arthritis (RA). Health professionals from two hospitals, two community
health care centers and five persons with RA took part in the project.
The objective was to explore how participation was experienced from the point of
view of those people living with RA. The fieldwork was carried out from November
2010 till January 2012 and consisted of both participant observation and individual
interviews. The study took inspiration from a social-phenomenological framework,
situated within everyday life sociology, aiming to explore the subjective experiences
of the participants. Internal and external factors affecting the possibilities and
challenges to participation will be investigated, both exploring the individual
narratives of the five persons with RA and analyzing across the individual cases.
The possibilities to participate changed over time. As a general tendency the role of
the people with RA changed from “patients having a right to be heard” to
“professionals possessing expert knowledge” equal to the knowledge of the health
professionals. The insights from this fieldwork can contribute to enhance the
empirical and theoretical knowledge in the field of patient participation.
Keywords: chronic illness; participation; education; fieldwork
109
O 83
END OF LIFE IN THE PEDIATRIC INTENSIVE CARE UNIT: THE
PARENTS’ EXPERIENCE
Lamiani, G.1, Fossati, I.2, Giannini, A.3, Prandi, E.3, Vegni, E. 1
1
Università degli Studi di Milano, Italy
San Paolo University Hospital, Italy
3
Fondazione IRCCS Ca’ Granda Ospedale Maggiore Policlinico, Italy
2
There is a considerable variability among European countries on the management of
end-of-life care in intensive care. In Italy, the physicians’ attitudes have been
explored but no study has investigated the parents’ perspective to improve end-oflife care. The objective of this study was to explore the experience of parents who
lost a child in the pediatric intensive care unit (PICU). Parents whose children had
died between 2007-2009 in the PICU at Policlinico Hospital, Milan, were recruited.
Upon approval of the Ethical Committee, parents were mailed a presentation letter
and were later called to verify their willingness to be interviewed. Parents who
participated in the study were asked to tell the story of the hospitalization of their
child in the PICU including the final moment. The interviews were analyzed
according to the hermeneutic-interpretive approach which aims to highlight the
founding elements of the parents’ experience. We conducted 8 interviews. Parents’
experience was characterized by: 1) An expropriation of parental role and practices.
The expropriation of parenting aspects and of physical intimacy was bearable only
when there was the hope of a cure; 2) An alternation between delegating an
assuming responsibility. An initial delegation of the child care to clinicians, was
followed by an assumption of responsibility by parents at the home transfer or in the
final moment; 3) An appropriation of the child only at the moment of death. The
dying process was lived by parents as a moment that belonged to them but that in
some cases was ‘stolen’ by clinicians. Our findings suggest the need to integrate
medical and parental priorities in a process of shared care that allows parents to
preserve their role. The most critical aspects for parents were not related to the
involvement (or not) in end-of-life decisions but rather on the management of the
dying process.
Keywords: end-of-life care; parents’ experience; hermeneutic-interpretative approach
110
O 84
USING WRITTEN REFLECTION ASSIGNMENTS TO ENCOURAGE
GAINS IN BODY IMAGE AND SELF-EFFICACY IN COLLEGE WOMEN
Lanou, A., Peterson, K., Artman, A., Shuurmans, B., Lax, J.
University of North Carolina Asheville, USA
In an effort better understand the impact of written reflection assignments in the
context of a women’s health course on female college students’ attitudes about body
image and their strategies for promoting a healthy body and positive body image, we
conducted qualitative analysis of response papers asking students to share
“something they like about themselves,” reflect on ways to encourage positive body
image, and evaluate themselves on efforts to make a personally important health
behavior change. We compare these findings with analysis of pre- and post-test
scores of two body image scales, and pre- and post- analysis of a measure of selfefficacy, and behavioral outcomes. Content analysis of student response papers
focusing on self-efficacy and external vs. internal solutions for modifying body
concept highlighted barriers to fostering a healthy body image as well as strategies
to address these perceived obstacles. Sixty percent of the students considered
themselves successful at changing one or more health behavior some by using the
technique of reframing the project. On average students made gains in body image
and a subset made significant gains in health self-efficacy. Written reflections in the
context of a college class may improve women’s self-efficacy, body image and
health behaviors.
Keywords: body image; self-efficacy; college students
O 85
SOCIAL NETWORK INFLUENCE ON COUPLES’ INTENTIONS FOR
HAVING THE FIRST CHILD, A QUALITATIVE CONTENT ANALYSIS
STUDY OF MASHHAD URBAN SOCIETY
Latifnejad Roudsari, R., Khadivzadeh, T.
Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Iran
There is a lack of information with regard to quality of social network’s interaction
111
with couples’ intention with regard to their fertility in Iran, so this qualitative study
was conducted to explore the influence of social network on couples’ decisions to
having their first child in urban society of Mashhad. In this exploratory study indepth interviews were performed with 25 fertile women, 5 midwives and 5 other
informed persons living in Mashhad. Sampling began purposively and continued
until data saturation. Data analysis was carried out adapting content analysis
approach through constant comparative analysis giving analytical codes.
Determination of categories was performed using MAXqda software. Study rigor
verified via prolonged engagement, validation of cods through participants’
confirmation and peer debriefing. Findings from data analysis demonstrated four
major categories about social network’s influence on couples’ intention to have their
first child. 1) Construct and meaning of fertility relevant social network, 2)
Mechanism of social influence “including social learning, social support, social
services and social pressures”, 3) Subjective analysis and judgment about its benefit
and fitness to life, 4) Couples’ interaction (OR complying) with social network
(including complying or not and network re-adjustment. Managing the fertility
behaviors need to include the consideration of personal social network surrounding
the couples. The study findings should be applied in providing family planning
services and dissemination of fertility behaviors through community based
reproductive health care delivery system.
Keywords: fertility; childbearing; social network; couples; qualitative; content analysis;
explanatory
O 86
CHRONIC PAIN AS A NARRATOLOGICAL DISTRESS
Lavie-Ajayi, M., Krumer-Nevo, L., Almog, N.
Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Israel
This paper reports findings from a phenomenological study that aimed to explore the
experience of women living with chronic pain. Following Arthur Frank’s argument
about the illness experience as a postmodern experience, the paper presents chronic
pain as a quintessential postmodern illness. The paper presents an interpretative
phenomenological analysis of two interviews with women living with chronic pain.
The interviews were taken from study about life with chronic pain. Each interview
had two parts: an open request to tell their own story of chronic pain and a semistructured interview about specific details of their experience. Chronic pain is a
112
double faced experience, constituted by the tension between the vivid and evident
personally felt pain, and the interpersonal and public ignoring, denying and
delegitimizing of the pain. The encounter between these two faces creates a
narratological distress, which is the result of not having a supportive echo or
reflection in public discourse to the individual personal experience. A website
resource is planned that will be based on this research and will bring the analysis of
patients’ experiences together with audio and video clips from the interviews, to
provide a source of information and support for people who live with chronic pain,
for their circles of support and for professionals.
Keywords: chronic pain; patients’ experiences; narrative; on-line resource
O 87
MEETING A CANCER
DIFFICULTIES
PATIENT
IN
PAIN:
HISTORIES
OF
Leone, D.1, Anania, S.2, Fossati, I.2, Cassardo, C.2, Vegni, E.1
1
2
Università degli Studi di Milano, Italy
San Paolo University Hospital, Italy
The aim of the study was to explore the oncologists’ internal representation of a
difficult encounter with a patient in pain. Using a written open narrative format, 46
oncologists were asked to tell “About an history in which you feel in difficulty
during a meeting with a patient who was in pain”. The narrations were analysed in
accordance to Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA), through an inductive
process aimed at gaining an holistic understanding of narratives. The data storage
was supported by the software N-Vivo8. Three main issues were identified each
with sub-issues: 1. The “unwritten” histories: similar to medical records. 1.1. the
oncologist as a professional that doesn’t get him/her self in the game; 1.2. the
oncologist as a vain artist that lets the reader to understand the untold. 2. The
“written” histories: 2.1. Histories of doctors: the doctor as the “human-divine” who
saves the patient from the destroying oncologic pain; 2.2. Histories of pain: the pain
as a “devil” that cancels the patient’s humanity and makes the “divine” doctor
powerless, humanizing her/him; 2.3. Histories of difficult, if not impossible,
encounters: the meeting between a “human divine” and an inhuman subject, the
pain, makes the relation paralyzed. 3. The relative: is the third person that could
permit the relation: 3.1. The relative as a patient’s amplifier; 3.2. The relative as a
witness and a judge of the relation.
113
The study showed the difficulty for the oncologist’s profession to be patient centred,
in a context in which the pain is central, forbidding a relation between human
beings. An alternative to the all-powerfullness of the doctor, should be that of
tolerating the limits of medicine. The third party could be an interesting medium to
consent a possible, and difficult, human relation.
Keywords: interpretative phenomenological analysis; oncologists’ representation; pain;
qualitative research
O 88
UNDERSTANDING CHILDHOOD
PARENTS’ EXPERIENCE
ASTHMA
IN
FOCUS
GROUPS:
Liao, Y. 1, Tzeng, Y. 2, Gau, B. 3
1
National Yang-Ming University, Taiwan
Cardinal Tien College of Healthcare & Management, Taiwan
3
College of Medicine, National Taiwan University, Taiwan
2
Asthma is among the most prevalent chronic illnesses in school-aged children and
adolescents worldwide. The incidence of asthma has risen steadily over the past 20
years and approximately 20% of school-age children have asthma. Its affects not
only the children but also parents’ quality of life. This research reports parental
experiences with their children with asthma, specifically their beliefs, knowledge,
and attitudes about asthma management, including medication use. To allow parents
of children with asthma to understanding their concerns, needs and perceptions.
A qualitative research of four-times focus group will be conducted, to invited 24
mothers and 1 father to explore the experience of living with asthma child. A semistructured interview guide was used to allow for consistency of format and
sequencing of questions for each group. No modifications to the discussion guide
were made during the study period. All facilitators had previous experience leading
group discussions. Each 90-minute session was audiotaped and transcribed verbatim
then sorted by qualitative software of Nvivo 8.0. All parents were aware of some of
the risks their children faced at home. Common parental fears included uncertainty,
long-term effects of medication, and concern that the condition would not go away
or improve. Five main themes within the domain of asthma management and
medication use were identified: need more information; trial and error; parents are
scared and fearful; living with asthma is difficult, and this stress affects the parents’
behavior; and parents know what is best for their child.
114
This study illustrates how strongly parental perceptions of illness and medication
influence adherence to health care providers’ advice and that such perceptions can
be modified within a strong doctor-patient partnership, improving adherence.
Keywords: children with asthma; parent experience; focus group
O 89
GENERATING WISDOM IN PALLIATIVE CARE
Liu, Y-C. 1,2, Chiang, H-H. 1
1
2
National Yang-Ming University, school of nursing, Taiwan
National Defense Medical Center, Taiwan
Dying is the process to experience the death. For a patient, it could be a suffering
process. During the past two decades, medical care has been started to focus on the
spiritual needs of patients receiving palliative care. However, not much attention has
been drawn to explore the spiritual needs of nurses performing palliative care. Death
is a critical issue about existential for both patients and nurses. Therefore, if we can
understand the experiences of palliative nurses, it could help the palliative care with
spiritual entity which can improve the quality. The purpose of this study is using
both perspectives including practical wisdom and face the other to understand the
experiences of palliative nurses when they care the dying patients. The
methodological approach in this qualitative study is interpretive hermeneutic. A
purposive sample was taking from each five palliative nurses who worked in
hospice settings including palliative care unit, and home-base hospice. Data were
collected through in-depth interviews between the participants and researcher. Data
were analyzed using thematic analysis. Findings can be categorized into three
themes: (1)Being aware of the harm in caring-for; (2) understanding the selflimitation; (3) tuning in to the patients. Each moment in dying could be a chance to
transform and grow spiritually for both dying patients and nurses. Palliative care can
inspire nurses to be aware of the ethical responsibility for patients, generate the
wisdom for care-giving with compassion attitudes. These findings suggest using the
concept of practical wisdom and face the other for clinical education and basic
nursing education, It will enrich the nursing quality and deepen the meaning of
palliative care.
Keywords: palliative nurse; practical wisdom; face the other
115
O 90
THE LIVED EXPERIENCE OF CERVICAL LEVEL SPINAL CORD
INJURY PATIENTS WITH ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY
Logue, L.1, Chadwick, R.2, Colbourn, C.1
1
Teesside University, UK
2
South Tees Hospitals NHS Trust, UK
With an annual incidence of spinal cord injury (SCI) throughout the world at 15−40
cases per million, promoting well-being in these cases can be a particular challenge.
Assistive Technology (AT), i.e., products and services designed to enable
independence for disabled and older people, such as infrared devices to operate
televisions, telephones, etc., are an important rehabilitation approach for SCI cases.
Previous research results suggested success requires matching the characteristics of
users and the AT. However, these studies failed to acknowledge that for some
individuals, independence may not be a priority and there may be a preference for
social support and interpersonal interaction.
To investigate such psychological factors, nine individuals with a range of cervical
level spinal cord injuries who were users or non-users of AT were recruited through
a local spinal cord injury centre. Transcriptions of semi-structured interviews
addressing these individuals’ experiences of AT, were subjected to Interpretative
Phenomenological Analysis.
This revealed seven themes; the process of decision making, learning experience,
coping, the double edged personal meaning of AT, relationships, safety and security,
and community context and understanding. Clinical implications, drawn from these
findings, related to increasing the person centred approach and psychological
awareness of multi-disciplinary teams within SCI services.
Keywords: spinal cord injury; assistive technology; clinical psychology; health
psychology
116
O 91
SHARING THE FULL STORIES ABOUT CHRONIC DISEASE:
IMPROVING COMMUNICATION WITH AUSTRALIAN ABORIGINAL
CONSUMERS
Lowell, A.1, Maypilama, E.1, Gundjarranbuy, R.2
1
2
Charles Darwin University, Australia
Yalu Marnggithinyaraw Indigenous Corporation, Australia
In the Northern Territory of Australia more than 30% of the residents are Aboriginal
and more than 70% of Aboriginal people do not speak English as a first language.
However, few health service providers share the cultural and/or language
background of their clients and research has shown that ineffective communication
is pervasive. The prevalence of preventable chronic disease is extremely high in this
population and improving communication in both clinical and educational contexts
is crucial to improving health outcomes.
We conducted a collaborative project to explore the strengths and limitations of
communication and education related to chronic disease and to identify strategies for
improvement from the perspectives of Aboriginal consumers. This paper reports on
the initial research and a subsequent chronic disease education project that was
developed in response to the research findings. A key feature of this work is the high
level of community participation and control in developing an approach to health
promotion that is responsive to the specific cultural and linguistic needs of this
population. This approach integrates Aboriginal and Western knowledge and
practice, sharing the ‘full and true stories’, that is, detailed explanations about
causes, prevention and management of chronic conditions in local languages.
Keywords: communication; intercultural; Aboriginal; chronic disease
O 92
THE ILLNESS NARRATIVES
OSTEOARTHRITIS
OF
TAIWANESE
WOMEN
WITH
Lu, Z.1, Hsu, C.H.2
1
2
National Yang-Ming University, Taiwan
Banciao District Health Center, Taipei County, Taiwan
Osteoarthritis (OA), with estimated prevalence between 10 to 20% in Taiwan and
117
women outnumbered men by 2:1, has been recognized as a significant problem by
WHO by designating the years of 2000-2010 as the Bone and Joint Decade.
Illness narratives from the lay view have been recognized to assist biomedical
professionals providing the holistic care to enhance the quality o life of OA
sufferers, while both lay and professionals have been frustrated with ineffective
treatments.
The purpose of this study was to ascertain the meanings of OA and the strategic
management among Taiwanese OA women through their life course narratives. The
life history approach was used to conduct in-depth interviews with women of 55
years of age diagnosed with OA without joint replacement and without lifethreatening illnesses. Narrative analysis was applied to discern various “genres” and
the meanings of the account in the context by identifying stories organized around a
specific time and consequential events in a life world of an OA sufferer and also
compare the entities of accounts within each individual.
The results showed that the illness narratives of OA sufferers in the Taiwanese
society can be categorized into three types as Bury (2001) suggested namely,
contingent, moral, and core. While contingent narratives describe life events, illness
causes and unfolding effects in relation to the performances in everyday life, moral
narratives introduce an evaluative dimension into the links between the personal and
social.
Core narratives represent various genres that were constructed by women’s cultural
linguistic resources to present their everyday experience and themselves. For
instance, physical discomforts and increased limitations as biographical disruption
gradually led to women’s re-examination of personal, family or work conditions and
viewed as the integral part of aging.
Expression of worries being others burden reflected in telling stories of engaging in
healthy lifestyle in order to be carer rather than cared for. Biographical reflection
revealed that the narration of wearing and tearing of OA simultaneously brings out
the threatened or already injured women’s self and in turn opens up the chances for
self reconstitution with new surrounding and resources.
Keywords: illness narratives; osteoarthritis; biographical disruption; story-telling
118
O 93
DIPEX
PROJECT:
DATABASE
OF
EXPERIENCES.
AN
INTERNATIONAL
UNDERSTAND HEALTH EXPERIENCES
INDIVIDUAL
PATIENT
COLLABORATION
TO
Mahtani-Chugani, V. 1, Ziebland, S. 2, Sakuma-Sato, R. 3, Lavie-Ajayi, M. 4, Dipex
International Members 5
1
DIPEx Spain Association, Spain
Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, UK
3
DIPEx, Japan
4
DIPEx, Israel
5
DIPEx International
2
DIPEx UK was established in 2001 by General Practitioner Dr. McPherson and Dr.
Herxheimer (HYPERLINK:http://www.healthtalkonline.org
www.healthtalkonline.org). Since then other countries have joined this group to
develop DIPEx in Australia, Canada, Germany, Israel, Japan, Korea, Netherlands,
Palestine and Spain. The main goal of DIPEx is to promote the spread of accessible,
well researched illness and health related personal experiences and information
throughout the world for the support of patients and the benefit professionals,
students, health services, health care providers and carers. A maximum variation
sample of approximately 30-50 respondents is recruited for each health condition, to
identify the widest practical range of patient/carer experiences within the project.
Recruitment continues until ‘data saturation’ is achieved. Qualitative semistructured audio or video recorded interviews using a narrative approach are
collected and transcribed verbatim. Through the constant comparative method the
interviews are analysed and summaries representing the full range of the data in the
interviews, not just the most frequent experiences, are included. Illustrative clips are
chosen to represent the main points included in the summary and to ensure that the
best sections from each interview are used. Lincoln and Guba’s credibility criteria
and techniques to enhance rigour are used. In this presentation we will show the
palliative care module developed in DIPEx Spain as an example of a module within
this project (HYPERLINK "http://www.dipex.es" www.dipex.es). Patients´ and
carers´ experiences with health care services and beliefs about health care
information and difficulties in decision making processes are presented. By
providing highly reliable data on patients´ experiences, we believe that these
perspectives help people to make better informed decisions backed by personal
experiences of other people suffering from the same condition and to cope with the
impact of their illness.
Keywords: internet; health personal experiences; qualitative methods
119
O 94
STRENGTHS AND CHALLENGES OF SYNTHESIS OF QUALITATIVE
STUDIES. A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW
Mahtani Chugani, V.1, Axpe-Caballero, A.2, González-Castro, I.3
1
Research Unit University Hospital Nuestra Sra de Candelaria.Canary Islands Health
Care Services, Spain
2
University of La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain
3
University Hospital Nuestra Sra de Candelaria. Canary Islands Health Care Services,
Spain
The objective of this presentation is to analyze and reflect about how to solve the
questions of why, when and how to incorporate qualitative studies in evidence-based
practice
The method used was a systematic review about synthesis of qualitative research in
systematic reviews, complemented by international expert feedback. Search strategy
was developed and applied through Ovid platform to Medline, Embase, PsycInfo,
EBM and Cinhal, including studies published in Spanish or English from 1988 to
May 2005. Ninety-one studies were included. The challenges identified are related
to access and retrieval of qualitative studies, quality evaluation and synthesis
process. The results of our work provide information about how researchers have
overcome these difficulties.
We classified and describe in detail the methods identified:
• Specific techniques (meta-synthesis, meta-ethnography, meta-study, metainterpretation and aggregation review)
• Generic techniques (Reviews, Bayesian synthesis, Cooper´s framework)
• Methods in primary qualitative research applied to synthesis of qualitative studies
(Grounded theory, Ritchie & Spencer Framework and feminist model).
Different options in accessing qualitative studies are described. Some researchers
have used exhaustive searches and others a convenience sample.
There are no clear guidelines about quality evaluation of qualitative research. Some
researchers suggest avoiding excluding papers based on the quality evaluation, and
on the other extreme there are researchers who suggest the use of checklist similar to
traditional systematic reviews. Although there are many challenges exposed, it
seems that we can keep the hope of achieving the capacity of solving some of these
problems, especially by learning from each other and having multidisciplinary
teams. We must reflect on the values of synthesis of qualitative studies, for instance
qualitative studies have increased and some subjects are widely explored and need
to be summarized in order to identify future research and avoid unnecessary or
120
unethical repetition. In addition, there is a growing interest in including qualitative
results to answer or to contribute in evidence-based practice.
Keywords: synthesis methods; quality evaluation; search strategy; evidence-based
practice
O 95
HUMANIZING THE HEALTH CARE SYSTEM FOR CREATING A
SUITABLE ENVIRONMENT FOR CARING COMMUNICATION:
INSIGHTS FROM A GROUNDED THEORY STUDY IN INDIA
Martis, L.
Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada
Despite various preventive programs, pharmacological inventions, and state-of-theart medical technologies, there is and probably will always be bad news in the field
of patient care. A patient’s capacity to accept bad news depends not only on his or
her personal make up, but presupposes professionals well-trained to break the bad
news. Unfortunately, the extant models produced for guiding the health care
professionals in the most challenging contexts of clinical communication, restrict the
concept of bad news to unfavorable medical information and communicative
competence to a set of skills related to delivering the distressful ‘truth’ and dealing
with emotional responses. Such myopic view privileges the interpersonal aspect and
precludes the socio-structural dimension of truth telling. Hence, a grounded theory
study was conducted in India, for examining both the psychosocial and sociostructural processes impacting on truth telling. The analysis of the narrative data
collected from 27 physicians working in three types of hospitals has generated a
theory that draws our attention to the socio-political meanings of bad news and the
adverse effects of a fragmented system of health care on truth telling. In consonant
with the principles of Health Promoting Hospitals, the emergent theory suggests that
the ability to humanize the culture of health care systems is integral part of
communicative competence. In a quantitatively dominated research world,
invariably, this study highlights the usefulness of grounded theory methods for
unraveling the less recognized processes of clinical communication.
Keywords: clinical communication; breaking bad news; truth telling; communicative
competence; health promoting hospital; grounded theory
121
O 96
PERSON-CENTERED HEALTH CARE AND RESEARCH USING EVENT
HISTORY CALENDARS
Martyn, K.
School of Nursing, University of Michigan, USA
The event history calendar (EHC) method designed to elicit holistic histories
necessary for person-centered health care and research will be described.
EHCs actively engage people in co-constructing their health with clinicians using
open-ended questions about individual/family events, behaviors, and goals in a time
and context-linked history graph that shows interrelationships, patterns, and triggers.
The underlying theory and evidence will be presented, including Conway’s
autobiographical memory concepts, Cox’s Interaction Model of Client Health
Behavior, the author’s grounded theory and descriptive studies. EHCs and
interviews with adolescent patients and clinicians will be presented to illustrate the
EHC method. Constant comparative analysis revealed that EHCs are easy to use and
helpful for history-taking, discussion, and identifying events that are temporally
linked to risk behaviors. Adolescents reported the EHCs they completed made them
more aware of their risk behavior and were a reflection of their “whole life on
paper.” Clinicians noted the EHCs help adolescents to see their actual risk
behaviors, “think maybe [they] should change and make better choices.”
Implications for use of EHC methods to enhance person-centered health care and
research with people of a variety of ages, cultures, and health needs will be
discussed.
Keywords: person-centered; history; calendars
O 97
THE BALANCING ACT REQUIRED OF QUALITATIVE RESEARCHERS
WHO ARE SEEKING ETHICAL REVIEW
McCormack, D., Keeping-Burke, L., McCloskey, R., Carr, T., Doucet, S.,
Furlong, K.
University of New Brunswick, Canada
The “Tri-Council Policy Statement: Ethical Conduct for Research Involving
122
Humans” is the gold standard for research and ethical conduct involving humans in
Canada. Yet, for qualitative researchers these guidelines present challenging
situations. The requirement to identify risks and benefits in qualitative research
designs that are emergent in nature is contrary to the meaning of an emergent
design; leaving researchers to predict risks and benefits that might be experienced
by participants based solely on the researchers’ values and beliefs. Sometimes
privacy and confidentiality can be compromised by small sample designs, rare
populations, and rich descriptions of environmental contexts. These ethical
quandaries are compounded when members with expertise in quantitative research
designs are overrepresented on Research Ethics Boards; creating the potential for
biased assessments of qualitative research applications. As a result, the experience
of qualitative researchers when seeking ethical review can be liken to “a balancing
act” or “walking a tight rope”.
Keywords: qualitative research; ethical review; emergent design; research ethics boards;
small samples; rare populations; rich descriptions
O 98
THE EXPERIENCE OF PROVIDING INFORMAL SUPPORT
CHEMOTHERAPY OUTPATIENTS: AN EXPLORATORY STUDY
TO
McKenzie, H.1, White, K.1, Hayes, L.1, Cox, K.2, Fitzpatrick, S.1, River, J.1,
Fethney, J.1
1
2
Sydney Nursing School, University of Sydney, Australia
Sydney Cancer Centre, Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, Sydney, Australia
This paper presents findings from a qualitative project exploring the experiences,
particularly during the days immediately following chemotherapy administration, of
primary support persons of chemotherapy outpatients.
Experiences of these informal carers of cancer patients are well researched, but less
is known about their experience of actively providing ongoing support to loved ones
during chemotherapy trajectories. In-depth interviews were therefore conducted with
seventeen information-rich participants to increase understanding of their
experiences of providing this support, and also their views about how they might be
best supported in this role. Three emergent themes conceptualize significant
experiences common to most participants. From the moment of diagnosis it was
clear to participants that they must, with the utmost urgency, shift their positioning
in the world from ‘frightened novice to reassuring expert’. ‘Watching and waiting’
123
encapsulates ongoing experiences, from intense vigilance (fearful of serious side
effects) following chemotherapy administration to continuous, often secretive,
monitoring of physical and emotional wellbeing. ‘Discordance’ expresses the
overriding emotional experience for participants in this study.
This paper explores these themes, highlighting the importance of this new
knowledge for health professionals concerned with facilitating active involvement of
informal carers in ongoing care provision and as co-constructors of their own health
Keywords: informal carer; chemotherapy outpatient; discordance; novice to expert;
watchfulness
O 99
POTENTIALITIES AND FRAGILITIES OF CARE NETWORK OF PEOPLE
WITH HIV/AIDS
Meirelles, B.H.S., Tonnera, L.C.J., Da Silva, D.M.G.V.
Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Brazil
It is a qualitative research whose goal is to know the potentialities and fragilities of
care network for people with HIV/AIDS. The scenario of the research was an
infectious disease reference service, in the State of Santa Catarina - Brazil.
Participants were eight people with HIV/AIDS and its network of care, totaling 18
participants. Data were analyzed through content analysis, supported by the
theoretical framework of the Symbolic Interactionism. The research resulted in the
following categories: The network offering care to people with HIV/AIDS and
Addressing barriers to care in HIV/AIDS. These reflects their potentialities and
fragilities, where respectively, the first depicts the provision of emotional care,
humane and quality and the second is limited, basically with part of health
professionals and one or other family member. The role of members of the
professional and institutional care network are important in front of a large demand
for care in a small physical structure and a limited number of professionals.
Keywords: health care; nursing; HIV; symbolic interactionism
124
O 100
NURSES’ MEANING OF CARING WITH PATIENTS IN ITALIAN
HOSPITAL SETTINGS: A PHENOMENOLOGICAL STUDY
Mortari, L., Cavada, L., Canzan, F., Ambrosi, E.
University of Verona, Italy
To improve a good quality in the health environments it is important to understand
what are the practicalities of the nurses which produce a good caring.
To identify the essential qualities of a good nursing caring. This paper presents a
qualitative research framed in a naturalistic epistemology. 203 Italian hospital nurses
were asked to write narratives on the practice of good care. The narratives were
verbatim transcribed and then analyzed according to a phenomenological approach.
All the data has been codified, individually, by two inside-researchers and then the
results has been confronted and through a dialogical analysis the researchers
elaborated a new kind of coding system; then an outside-researcher analyzed the
accounts and restructured the coding system to have an instrument of analysis which
is faithful to the data. The research lasted 36 months. The research produced a
formal result, which consists in a inductively constructed coding system and a
content result, emerged from the application of the coding system on the narratives,
which identifies the essential structure of a good caring. To improve a good quality
of life in a healthcare environment it is necessary to implement a good caring
approach to the patients. The results of the research help to reflect on a new
approach to nursing daily practice.
Keywords: caring; nursing practice; phenomenological approach
O 101
A COGNITIVE ETHNOGRAPHY OF MEDICAL EXPERTISE: HOW
DOCTORS AND NURSES MAKE DECISIONS AT WORK
Muntanyola-Saura, D.1, Belli, S.2
1
2
Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Spain
Universidad Autonoma de Madrid, Spain
This paper discusses how cognitive ethnography can be an adequate method for
understanding the social dimension of medical teamwork. Our working hypothesis is
125
that medical expertise can be better explained through video-aided analysis of
narratives; gestures and other distributed cognitive phenomena. We recorded the
communication patterns of doctors and nurses, setting up cameras in an angioplasty
unit of a Spanish public hospital for 3 months, taking daily fieldnotes and
interviewing the participants regularly. Analysis of activity episodes (Barab, Hay &
Yamagata-Lynch, 2001) with Transana & Atlas.Ti allowed us to put together a new
methodology for expertise in real work settings. Our results include the detection of
the information path for errors and other unexpected events, and the understanding
of the complexity of decision-making, including multitasking and synchronization.
Our findings make visible the embodied and distributed nature of medical decisions,
specifically in gestures, multimodal interactive systems and negotiated narratives
among doctors and nurses. The observation of physical and interactive context of
medical decision-making shows how the system’s performance shape the outcome
of the process. In all, we believe cognitive ethnography is a tool that allows us to
access the distributed cognition of expertise.
Keywords: cognitive ethnography; expertise; distributed cognition
O 102
HEALTH PROVIDERS‘ VIEWPOINTS ABOUT NEONATE‘S NEEDS
DURING TRANSITION FROM NICU TO HOME: A CONTENT ANALYSIS
Namnabati, M. 1, 2, Valizadeh, L. 2, Zamanzadeh, V. 2, Badiei, Z. 1
1
2
Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Health professionals try to provide the neonate a safe transition from neonatal
intensive care unit to home. Identifying neonate‘s needs through staff‘s viewpoints
facilitates the transition. A qualitative study helps obtaining comprehensive and rich
description about neonate‘s needs. The aim of this study was to explore health
providers‘ viewpoints about neonate‘s needs while being transited from NICU to
home. A content analysis approach was carried out for identifying neonate‘s needs.
Data collection was done by interviews with sixteen nurses and physicians in the
neonatal intensive care units of university hospitals in Iran. MAXQDA 10 software,
a qualitative data analysis package, was used for coding and categorizing. The
cognition and the barriers to meeting neonate’s needs were the two major themes
resulted by the data analysis. There were also six categories named as: knowing,
noting, perceiving, reasoning, training, and managing that influenced neonate
126
transition. The result of the study helped further understanding the elements of
cognition of neonate‘s needs that facilitate or hinder transition of neonate from
neonatal intensive care unit to home. The positive aspects of the cognition must be
improved and some policies should be made to decrease the barriers.
Keywords: barriers; content analysis; need; neonate; NICU
O 103
ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE: CAREGIVER AND PHYSICIAN TESTIMONY
FROM THE WEB
Nani, C.
CE&Co srl, Italy
The epidemiological data indicates that there are 800 thousand people in Italy who
suffer from Alzheimer’s; more precisely, it should be said that 800 thousand
families suffer from this disease, bearing, with little or no institutional or social
support, the terrible burden of the practical problems involved in caring for the
patient, and the pain of seeing him transformed “into a shell that looks like my
father, but he’s not in there anymore”.
The research analyzes, in a qualitative key, the testimony the caregivers left on the
web, and especially in the forums in which they compare experiences, and in the
medical advice columns:
• the attitudes are compared of the caregivers and specialists on the assessment
criteria in determining disease severity level, on the pharmacological and
cognitive-behavioural therapies, on prevention, on experimental drugs
• the day-to-day experiences of the caregivers are reported, their feelings, the fear
of falling ill themselves in the future, the conflict that occurs relative to the
possibility of hospitalization.
This methodology is a new qualitative Web listening practice, the fruit of original
experimentation; it represents an evolution of netnography: kindred to it insofar as it
demonstrates how Web listening can go well beyond the study of reputation and
sentiment, but significantly different in its psychological approach, focused on the
individual, rather than ethnological and social approach. The testimony is gathered
through a technique of progressive generation of the research keys; then processed
and interpreted by applying tools deriving from those of motivational research to the
online ‘conversations’. Especially on health-related topics, people pour a tale of
exceptional interest into the Web: research has shown that qualitative Web listening
127
can constitute a passkey particularly suited to understanding this tale; few other
research tools allow ‘sitting and listening’ while the caregivers speak freely amongst
themselves, and gathering fragments of their discussion with the physician. In the
case of Alzheimer’s, the aspect that emerges most dramatically is the overall picture
of the families’ needs for assistance, beyond the purely pharmacological sphere, and
the almost complete absence of answers from the health institutions. As the daughter
of one patient writes: “Maybe the most terrible thing is not even that there aren’t
medicines, but that if you have someone with Alzheimer’s you are completely alone,
facing a thing that is far too much bigger than you.”
Keywords: web listening; Alzheimer’s disease
O 104
CAUGHT BETWEEN ILLNESS, DISEASE, AND SICKNESS.
QUALITATIVE STUDY OF THYROID DISEASE AND WORK LIFE
A
Nexo, M.A. 1, Watt, T. 2, Feldt-Rasmussen, U. 2, Rasmussen, A.K. 2, Bonnema, S.J.
3
, Hedegus, L. 3, Groenvold, M. 4, Bjørner, J.B. 1
1
The National Research Center for the Working Environment, Denmark
Department of Medical Endocrinology. Copenhagen University Hospital,
Rigshospitalet, Denmark
3
Department of Medical Endocrinology, Odense University Hospital, Denmark,
Denmark
4
Institute of public health. Copenhagen University, Denmark
2
The aim of this study is to examine how the experience of thyroid disease influences
work life. Seventeen medically treated patients with thyroid diseases (autoimmune
hypo- and hyperthyroidism) were strategically selected for semi-structured
interviews from two main hospitals in Denmark. Interviews were concerned with
how the patients experienced their health, work and daily life. Interviews were
analyzed applying Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis.
Three main themes of importance to the patients’ work life:
1. Thyroid diseases were not experienced as a disease, rather as a diffuse mental
state primarily with psychological limitations to work life (e.g. fatigue, foggy mental
state).
2. Patients doubted that their diffuse state of mind was a valid manifestation of
thyroid disease, which created a demand for an objective validation of symptoms via
biomedical tests.
128
3. A discrepancy between the manifestations of thyroid disease and the results from
the biomedical tests rendered the experienced work disability and sickness behavior
invalid.
This study illustrates how conflicting perceptions of illness complicates
identification of work disability and limits the rehabilitation for some people with
thyroid disease. This complication can be handled applying the quality of life
methodology, thus securing better identification of rehabilitation needs.
Keywords: thyroid disease; qualitative approach; work life
O 105
ENGAGING YOUNG WOMEN WITH SKIN CANCER PREVENTION;
UNEXPECTED LEARNING FROM A GROUNDED THEORY STUDY
Norton, E.
Bournemouth University, UK
In this paper I discuss how a qualitative research process involving female
adolescents unexpectedly provided insight into what may ‘work’ when health
professionals seek to engage young women in health promotion. An unintended and
surprising outcome of using semi-structured interviewing during a qualitative
grounded theory study was evidence to support health promotion concepts including
empowerment, media literacy and partnership working. Exploration of the reasons
behind the sun-related behaviours of the young women in the study apparently
raised their consciousness of the factors affecting them. For example they realized
the influence of media, peers and celebrities and it seems that I was inadvertently
involving the participants as co-constructors of their health through the research
process. On reflection it seems that simply talking with, and listening to, the
participants in the exploratory, non-judgemental and respectful way afforded by
qualitative methodology and method, facilitated their engagement with the health
issue of sun exposure. It seems that participants began to comprehend the broader
contextual issues that could impact on them and this has implications if they are to
resist cultural norms that impinge on their health.
Keywords: health promotion; qualitative method; female adolescents
129
O 106
HAWAIIAN WELLNESS: BELIEFS AND BEHAVIOR
Odell, A. 1, Carey, M.A. 2, Ching, K.K. 3, Bean, R. 3
1
Azusa Pacific University, USA
Kells Consulting, USA
3
Na Wai Iwi Ola Foundation, USA
2
The aim of this study is to address health disparities in the Native Hawaiian
population, through honoring Native perspectives; to develop authentic information
to inform practice and adapt research-based evidence to fit with cultural belief
systems. It has become somewhat common to acknowledge the importance of
clinicians and researchers listening to individual client’s needs. Less commonly
recognized is the importance for researchers and clinicians to understand the belief
system and the values of the local society, and how practice may be adapted to fit
with the health beliefs of the clients. Learning the societal origins of the health
beliefs will help the researcher and clinician to best collaborate with the client. This
study used a grounded theory approach to analyze data collected using focus groups
with elderly Native Hawaiians, key interviews, and document reviews. The meaning
of wellness, the importance of returning to Native life style as much as practical, and
the concept of balance in life were key findings. The embeddedness of the
individual in Native society, as a strength and as a responsibility, was very clear.
Collaboration of client and clinician, enhanced through knowledge developed with
this approach, will lead to improved health outcomes.
Keywords: client-clinician collaboration; transformative paradigm; grounded theory
O 107
THE DEVELOPMENT OF A CLINICAL INTERVENTION MODEL FOR
COMMUNICATION AND INFORMATION – A PARTICIPATORY
ACTION RESEARCH PROJECT IN THE FIELD OF PALLIATIVE
CANCER CARE
Öhlén, J. 1, Friberg, F. 2
1
2
Ersta Sköndal University College, Sweden
Sahlgrenska Academy at the University of Gothenburg, Sweden
The specific aim was to develop a model for person centered information and
130
communication to enhance patients’ knowledge seeking in order to handle daily life
related to treatment and illness. A participatory action research project was designed
by means of qualitative outcome analysis. Initially, bimonthly focus groups with one
palliative care team at a palliative oncology outpatient unit were performed.
Previous major results, from qualitative studies into patients’ knowledge seeking
and experiences of communication and information in palliative cancer care, were
used as facilitators for discussion. Collaboratively, the researchers and the team
worked on developing an intervention model for communication and information. A
preliminary model was developed and refined by means of focus groups with
additional palliative care teams and patients. A model of person centered
communication and information in palliative cancer care aimed for clinical
intervention was developed, including concepts, strategies and outcomes. The model
involves four interrelated core concepts: the patient, the provider, the family and the
communicative arena put in the context of progressing advanced cancer. Different
layers of the components are discriminated in order to explain how person
centeredness is to be created. The next step is to further evaluate the model
clinically.
Keywords: participatory action research; qualitative outcome analysis; palliative; cancer
care; information; communication
O 108
AN INTERDISCIPLINARY EXPLORATION OF ETHICAL GUIDELINES
AND POLICIES RELATED TO ONLINE HEALTH QUALITATIVE
RESEARCH AND WEB 2.0
Oprescu, F.
University of the Sunshine Coast, Australia
The Internet has become a ubiquitous source of health information and a space for
social support for millions of people who are affected by illness or want to improve
their health. The Internet also represents a rich source of data for qualitative health
research, due to its richness in user generated content. Qualitative analysis of user
generated content can provide information to increase compliance, can foster
relationships between health care consumers and health care professionals and can
provide insights into the sociological construction of disease and health. However,
the ethical issues around health qualitative research using the Internet needs to be
revisited due to advances in web technologies (Web 2.0) and due to increased focus
131
on interdisciplinary research. This work contributes to previous knowledge on the
ethics of internet-based qualitative health research (Eysenbach & Till, 2001) by
comparing and contrasting guidelines from health, social science, psychology, and
business. Furthermore, this work analyses the most recent privacy policies of three
major players in the Internet space: Facebook TM, Google TM (including YouTube
TM), and Twitter TM and their potential impact on previously developed ethical
guidelines for online qualitative research. The results suggest the following: (1)
some of the previously developed ethical guidelines are still valid for use with Web
2.0 and user generated content; (2) some of the existing ethical guidelines are
transferrable across disciplines; and (3) the privacy policies of major Internet players
are a valuable source of information for enhancing the existing ethical guidelines for
online qualitative research.
Keywords: online qualitative research; ethics; ethical guidelines; health research;
interdisciplinary research; web 2.0
O 109
THE USE OF UNCERTAINTY MANAGEMENT THEORY IN ONLINE
QUALITATIVE HEALTH RESEARCH – METHODOLOGICAL AND
PRACTICAL CONSIDERATIONS
Oprescu, F.
University of the Sunshine Coast, Australia
With the advent of the Internet a lot of health information exchanges moved in
virtual spaces, often outside the boundaries or control of health institutions
(Weitzman, Cole, Kaci & Mandl, 2011). The systematic research of such
information can contribute greatly to our understanding of the reality and needs of
patients and their caregivers, thus improving compliance and the quality of
relationships between healthcare providers and patients. However, systematic
research functions best if it is theoretically based, while contributing to theory. As a
result, qualitative research methods and the Uncertainty Management Theory
(Brashers, 2001), focusing on the role of communication in the management of
health and illness, were employed to explore and describe the information requested
and provided in a large online social support community by caregivers of children
affected by clubfoot. Clubfoot (Talipes Equinovarus) is a common congenital
deformity affecting one in 1000 live births across the globe. Due to its visual nature,
clubfoot diagnosis is often accompanied by high levels of uncertainty and stress for
132
parents. Uncertainty management theory provided a relevant framework for the
study of information behaviour in this population and its use in online environments
was relatively new. In addition to highlighting the need for future investigation of
user managed virtual support communities this study shifted in a profoundly
theoretical activity. From a methodological perspective, the presentation will discuss
the role of theory in expressing and explaining subjective realities. From a practical
perspective the presentation will describe the formation of the research question,
sampling methodology for online qualitative health research, approaches to coding
data and results of the study. Theoretical and practical implications will be discussed
as potential gains in knowledge and methodology; including the fact that theory
based qualitative research offers logical and structured lenses through which we can
explore subjective realities. The aim is to add to the knowledge base regarding the
mutually beneficial relationship between theoretical underpinnings and contributions
of qualitative research studies to theory development in response to new challenges
in health promotion, education and communication.
Keywords: online qualitative health research; online social support; management of
health and illness; health promotion; theoretical contributions; qualitative research
methodology
O 110
USING QUALITATIVE RESEARCH TO EXPLORE AN ONLINE
COMMUNITY DESIGNED TO REDUCE ALCOHOL MISUSE AND
IMPROVE HEALTH AND WELLBEING
Oprescu, F., McAllister, M., Jones, C., Katsikitis, M.
University of the Sunshine Coast, Australia
Sixty percent of young men and 44% of young women in Australia engage in risky
levels of alcohol consumption every month (Australian Institute of Health and
Welfare, 2010) the resulting cost (direct and indirect) due to alcohol were estimated
to be over 15 billion dollars (Collins, 2008). Harms associated with alcohol misuse
by young people include passing out, memory loss, accidents, injuries, crime,
unwanted/unprotected sex, financial difficulties, social conflicts, low self-esteem
and poor performance in school and outside school (Rickwood, Goerge, Parker &
Mikhailovich, 2011; Kypri, Paschall, Langley, Baxter, Cashell-Smith & Bourdeau,
2009). Hello Sunday Morning (HSM) is an Australian web-based alcohol reduction
online community that has been lauded by the National Cooperative Research
133
Centre for Young People, Technology and Wellbeing (Burns, 2011) as an exemplary
and innovative health promotion initiative that is resulting in positive health related
outcomes for many individuals, who would otherwise be at high risk for alcohol
misuse, addictions and other risk behaviors associated with binge drinking. To learn
more about the community and what makes it a success a qualitative research
methodology based on social constructivist theory has been employed to explore the
content of 200 randomly selected first blog posts. Results indicate that HSM has
been successful in engaging its members in generating a social interpretation of
alcohol (mis)use that can encourage healthy behaviors. A combination of real life
user generated content, peer to peer social support and public goal setting
contributes to the attractiveness and sustainability of the initiative. It is suggested
that qualitative health research can generate valuable evaluation data, a better
understanding of the social construction of alcohol consumption and positive health
promotion messages while posing no burden on online community members.
Keywords: qualitative health research; internet based health promotion; health
communication; behavior change; health behavior
O 111
GLOBAL AGEING EXPERIENCE-DRIVEN SUSTAINABLE INNOVATION
IN PRODUCTS, SERVICES, CARE OPTIONS, LIVING ENVIRONMENTS
Origlia, C., Cattaneo, A., Ravanelli, L.
Market Dynamics Cultures & Strategies, Italy
“Global ageing” is a reality that we must be prepared to face in a responsible way.
It is also a great opportunity for change, cultural and social integration, and
innovation. We decided to look at ageing from a fresher, future-oriented and projectoriented perspective, and contribute with different fresh and workable ideas and
solutions to address the needs and demands of “current agers” as well as those of
“future ageing” generations.
We orchestrated a multi-phase, hybrid approach study; combining different research
methods, from the classic to the most unconventional, mixing off-line and on-line
• Interviews: one on one, paired, triads.
• Groups: focus groups, creative/interactive, some pre-tasked, some re-convened,
and fluid groups
• Panel interviews and forums
We interviewed individuals (from Young adults to Old-oldies 80+); families (with
134
an elderly in their care); caregivers (private, professional, institutional).
Sensibly designed engaging research methods help develop engaging relationship in
the research process, which can spark deeply felt creative ideas. And solutions to
deeply felt problems. Which can hopefully, stimulate the engagement of private,
social and institutional players, and of all stakeholders in the AGE, HEALTH,
WELLNESS sector, and related industries.
Keywords: ageing, online research; stakeholder engagement
O 112
MANAGING UNEXPECTED EVENTS IN
PRACTICES - AN ETHNOGRAPHIC STUDY
ICU’S VIA
INFORMAL
Ostermann, S.M., Schreyögg, G.
Freie Universitaet Berlin, Germany
Apart from applying standards, ICUS’s are driven by frequent unexpected events.
Therefore, medical practitioners develop practices to handle the unexpected studied
in a field marked by extensive uncertainty: The ICU. Our exploratory study based
on semi-structured interviews identified a complex interplay between formal and
informal spheres to be central in managing the unexpected. Its results tell us that
practitioners facing the unexpected do not strictly adhere to formal hierarchical lines
but instead utilize personal networks including experts from other units or hospitals,
private or even patients’ contacts (eg., relatives, legal spokespersons). The complex
combinative processes of formal and informal elements will be subject to an indepth case study. Implications for qualitative research and practices are drawn and
are currently picked up on. Following an ethnographic approach, we momentarily
conduct a participant observation, studying the combination of formal and informal
communication and decision processes that occur during unexpected situations,
complemented by a social network analysis and further in-depth interviews. We
hope to learn more about successful cooperation and communication practices when
facing the unexpected complementing the application of standards and consequently
improving quality of care.
Keywords: informality; unexpected; semi-structured interviews; ethnography; in-depth
case study
135
O 113
HOSPITAL SURVEY ON PATIENT SAFETY CULTURE (HSOPSC): A
CROSS-CULTURAL
TARGET-LANGUAGE
INSTRUMENT
TRANSLATION STUDY
Palmieri, P. 1, Ford, E. 2
1
2
Universidad San Ignacio de Lodola, Peru
University of North Carolina at Greensboro, USA
The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) developed the English
language psychometrically validated instrument called the Hospital Survey on
Patient Safety Culture (HSOPSC). The instrument is used in multiple countries;
however, studies do not report translation validation and provide limited
psychometric analysis. This study intended to produce a target-language Spanish
instrument that asks the same questions as the English instrument.
A mixed method, target-language translation study with 9 participants (3 per round
for 3 rounds). The study developed and tested a two-step mixed analytic
methodology for survey and cognitive interviews. The research protocol for this
study was approved by the A.T. Still University Institutional Review Board.
Data were collected and compiled for each participant. We examined each
participant data for each item during each round. Progressive changes to each item
were reviewed and the rationale for changes coded and categorized.
The mixed method approach, using survey and cognitive interviews, found Round 1
had 33 problems (translational 43%, cultural 33%, and general design 24%) but the
number decreased to 1 problem in Round 3. The majority of the issues were
attributed to negatively worded questions.
This study produced the first target-language HSOPSC translation study reported in
the literature and validated the effectiveness of the mixed-method approach. Also,
we determined cognitive interviews are critical to correct issues with negatively
worded questions.
Keywords: qualitative methods; mixed methods; cognitive interview; target-language
translation; hospital survey on patient safety culture; safety culture; patient safety;
Spanish
136
O 114
APPLYING THE BROKERED DIALOGUE METHOD TO EVALUATE
CITIZEN ENGAGEMENT IN HEALTH POLICY-MAKING IN ONTARIO
Parsons, J., Rowland, W., Mamdani, M., Laupacis, A., Sridharan, S., Lavery, J.
St. Michael’s Hospital, Canada
Objectives: 1) To evaluate a complex Canadian health policy intervention aimed at
incorporating citizens’ values into public health-funding decisions. 2) To explore the
feasibility of applying our new Brokered Dialogue (BD) method to evaluating this
process. Informed by narrative theory, BD can reveal unique insights and pathways
for improvement. Participants engage in filmed interviews offering their
perspectives, then share their views with, and pose questions of, one another through
film. Participatory editing creates a ‘safe’ space for respectful interaction. Through
narrative analysis, layers of accounts are assembled to approximate dialogue.
Interim analysis reveals four themes: 1) implications of the political context for the
council; 2) role of dialogue in shaping recommendations; 3) roles/responsibilities of
private industry; 4) council processes. BD revealed a tension between council
members’ expectations regarding their role in health-system reform and their
perceptions of government’s intentions for using their input. The empowering
experience of council participation was seen as at odds with identified inefficiencies
in the process (e.g. member selection, meeting frequency), which they interpreted as
lack of clarity from the government regarding its goals for the intervention.
BD identified opportunities for practical improvements, exposed axes of
differences/disagreement, and reinforced agreement, by providing a ‘safe space’ in
which to forge common understandings.
Keywords: dialogue; narrative analysis; visual methods; health policy; citizen
engagement
O 115
CHILDREN AND YOUNG PEOPLE WITH CHRONIC ILLNESS AS COCONSTRUCTORS OF THEIR HEALTH - REFLECTIONS TOWARDS A
PARADIGM OF RIGHTS IN HOSPITAL CONTEXT
Pais, S. 1, Guedes, M. 2, Menezes, I. 1
1
2
Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences - University of Porto
Institute of Biomedical Sciences Abel Salazar - University of Porto
137
Recognizing the emergency of social, cultural, economic, etc. implications resulting
from daily life with chronic illness, it is essential to review priorities and paradigms
(Paterson, 2003; Stanton et al., 2007). In fact, the literature reveals that children and
young people with chronic conditions face a diversity of situations, namely
integration, indifference and, unavoidably, discrimination in various contexts in
which they operate (Sutherland, 1981). Thus, their families acquire new roles and
tend to become, on the one hand, experts in the health challenges management and,
on the other hand, interveners of their children’s rights (Lister, 2003). In this respect,
and admitting the contribution of community groups in promoting more equitable
and fair living conditions, the chronic disease support associations are often ways to
meeting emotional and instrumental support, claiming rights and questioning
instituted paradigms (Menezes, 2007).
In this line of thought, in view of the hospital setting and attending to the health
professionals’ action in monitoring children and youth with chronic illness and their
families, there are some aspects to register. See, for example, the practical and the
discursive dimensions of these professionals. Both literature and practices show that
health professions are, not always, adequate given the fact that these people are in
vulnerable conditions. Such results have disempowering effects for families,
inhibiting them from participating actively in both processes and decisions related to
their children health (Lear, 2006).
In fact, that remains to a symbolic heritage that emphasizes an asymmetric
relationship between professionals and families based on paternalistic assumptions
(Costa, 2009). It is clearly of framing this issue in a rights paradigm that, more
emphasizing needs, assumes that promoting health and fair living conditions is a the
responsibility for of all. The idea of placing this issue about chronic disease in a
public dimension refers implicitly to a question of citizenship. In this sense, this
study highlights the importance of recognizing children and adolescents with
chronic diseases as citizens who should be treated differently so that their needs are
met (Stainton, 2005; Barnes, 2007).
The aim of this study is to know the main difficulties and strategies in living with
chronic disease, particularly in hospital context. In this sense, it is intended to realize
the role of children and adolescents with chronic disease, families, health
professionals and community members in promoting the well-being of children and
adolescents with chronic illness. Although this study is based on a mixed
methodology, data presented in this paper result from qualitative approaches
recognizing them as essential strategies for understanding and producing valid
knowledge, particularly in studies such as this one. Including interviews, narratives
and focus group discussion our research considers the perspectives of multiple
agents whose role is essential in the promotion of quality of life of people with
chronic diseases.
138
The data collected reveals many aspects concerned with the obstacles and strategies
in children and adolescents with chronic disease daily life, particular in their
relationship with hospital context. The results will enable a better understanding
about the daily experiences of children and adolescents with chronic disease and
their families, unveiling the power relationships in hospital context. Similarly, the
results also focus on dimensions of communication and practices of these
professionals. Finally, the results emphasize the role played by families in the
management of discrimination situations, pointing out the possibilities inherent to
the participation on support associations.
Keywords: chronic disease; children and adolescents; well-being; empowerment
O 116
"NOT IN OUR REMIT”: COMMUNICATION CHALLENGES AND
OPPORTUNITIES IN DEMENTIA CARE
Peel, E. 1, Harding, R. 2
1
2
Aston University, UK
Keele University, UK
To explore caregivers’ perceptions about communication in dementia care.
Dementia is a challenging, progressive set of conditions which present a large care
burden to informal, familial carers. A complex array of health and social care
services are needed to support people living with dementia (PWD).
Qualitative comments from a mixed-method questionnaire (n=185), focus groups
(n=15) and interviews with informal carers of people with dementia (n=12). Of the
twenty-seven qualitative participants: 63% were women and participants cared for a
spouse (55%) or parent (42%) with various dementias including: Alzheimer’s (35%)
and vascular dementia (35%). Data were analyzed using thematic discourse analysis.
Navigating “the system” and accessing appropriate care and support for PWD was
described as a considerable challenge by most carers. We focus our analysis on three
interlinking themes: 1) services as a ‘maze’; 2) services as overly limited –‘not in
our remit’; and; 3) battle and fighting discourse deployed by these carers.
Our analysis highlights that systemic issues in dementia care present communicative
challenges and opportunities. Qualitative health researchers can critically engage
with the complexities of dementia discourse. We offer some recommendations for
improving caregivers’ experiences of navigating health and social care services.
Keywords: dementia; care; caregivers; communication; health services
139
O 117
FROM PARENTS TO PATIENTS: HIDDEN STORIES OF ASSISTED
KINSHIP BETWEEN BODIES AND POLITICS
Perrotta, M. 1, Parolin, L.L. 2
1
2
Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Norway
Università Milano Bicocca, Italy
Assisted reproductive technologies (ARTs) developed quickly and broadly in the
last decades, producing a number of new options that changed the definition of
kinship and parenthood, as well bodies and gender relations, and even culture and
life itself. ARTs, in fact, often question the traditional (and taken-for-granted)
meaning of kinship, shifting the attention towards the hegemonic medicaltechnological device and its monitoring, management and supervision. According to
the Italian law, however, these techniques are available only for infertile stable
heterosexual couples. All other aspiring parents (singles, homosexual couples,
people with genetic diseases, sterile heterosexual couples) do not have access to
health care in national health facilities. In this paper we will present stories of
“assisted kinship” from aspiring parents belonging to those categories, who have
used these techniques in foreign centers to carry out their parental project. Using
episodes of in-depth interviews this paper will explore the personal reproductive
choices of many aspiring parents, which are hidden from the public representation.
Our aim is to discuss this phenomenon in terms of biological and reproductive
citizenship, since it produces new kinds of individual governance of the self rather
than direct management of life through public health.
Keywords: assisted reproduction; biopolitics; reproductive citizenship
O 118
USING QUALITATIVE METHODOLOGICAL STRATEGIES TO
ENHANCE STUDENT LEARNING IN A UNIVERSITY-LEVEL WOMEN’S
HEALTH CLASS
Peterson, K., Lanou, A.
UNC Asheville, USA
Our study reports on findings of a study we conducted with students in a women’s
140
health class that employed qualitative methods as a pedagogical tool to enhance
student learning. The class itself was transformed from a more classical pedagogy
that emphasizes the delivery of information into one that used a more holistic
pedagogy that invites students to engage in a series of reflection-action exercises.
Using retrospective health inventories and reflection, student writing about their
body image, creative projects about their self care, and focus groups with students
during the semester, we infused the course with practices of qualitative research. We
report on the content of student reflections and learnings during the course and how
these relate to student perception of self-efficacy and body image. We make
recommendations for using qualitative methodologies as pedagogical strategies
integrated within learning and discuss the challenges and benefits of this approach.
Keywords: college learning; women’s health; holistic pedagogies
O 119
CLIENT SATISFACTION AND PHYSICIANS’ QUALITY PERCEPTION IN
AMBULATORY CARE. EVIDENCE OF THE IMPACT OF DIFFERENT
ORGANIZATIONAL MODELS
Pino, O. 1, Dazzi, D. 2, Chiari, A. 2, Agnetti, B. 2
1
2
Department of Psychology, University of Parma, Italy
Centro Studi SMI Emilia Romagna, Italy
Client satisfaction is relevant for quality health-care delivery besides objective
outcomes. The Italian primary care sector has undergone several changes aimed to
improve efficiency in service provision. Particular emphasis has been placed on
promoting various forms of collaboration, and financial incentives have been
provided to physicians to join these new organizational arrangements. The network
implies sharing the electronic patient records, network connection of the
ambulatories, working in the same facility and sharing administrative and clinical
staff. However, few research studies have analyzed the impact of collaborative
organizational arrangements on quality perception. The aim of this study was to
examine client and physicians’ quality perception in ambulatory care within the
different models. The survey consists of 20-minute interviews with a random sample
of adults age 19 and older. Clients and physicians answered 22 questions (6 point
Likert scale) subdivided into four factors (i.e. client-physicians relation,
organization, physical environment, competence). We analyzed the psychometric
properties of our questionnaire compared with the EUROPEP-ITA administered
141
only to the clients. We found moderately high level of satisfaction with care. Results
show significant association for age classes with several dimensions. The clientcentred approach is seen as an effective way to provide effective patient care.
Keywords: perceived quality; client-centred approach; ambulatory care
O 120
FOLLOWING PREFERENCES FOR DYING AT HOME AND THE
INTERPLAY BETWEEN PATIENTS, FAMILIES AND PROFESSIONALS
IN THE PROCESS OF RECOGNIZING DYING
Pleschberger, S.
IFF, Palliative Care and Organizational Ethics, University of Klagenfurt, Austria
Good end-of-life care has a huge potential to contribute to the public health and
wellbeing of people. This is most evident in the field of palliative home care, where
preferences of patients and their families are valued most. This study aimed at
putting light on the process of negotiating issues of death and dying throughout the
process of care at home. It focused specifically on the interplay between patients,
families and professionals in recognizing dying.
An ethnographic study was done in the field of specialist palliative home care. Data
collection included observations of palliative care specialists’ visits at home from
patient’s admission to the service until death of patient (n=15). Interviews with
service professionals and bereaved carers and an analysis of records complemented
data collection. Sampling and data analysis followed Grounded Theory and an
approach of case-reconstruction.
While family carers as well as professionals tended to identify a certain “turning
point” of recognizing dying when asked in retrospect, observation data and
documentation did not support such clarity. Ambiguities of caring for a dying
relative at home between maintaining hope and letting die turned out as key factor.
A sensitive approach and high communication skills are necessary to provide care
which contributes to the wellbeing of dying patients and their families. The potential
of a rich data set informed by several collection strategies is underlined.
Keywords: end-of-life care; interface between professionals and family carers; home
death; palliative care; recognizing dying
142
O 121
AGGRESSION IN THE SOUTH
CONTEXTUAL SNAPSHOTS
AFRICAN
SOCIETY:
TWO
Poggenpoel, M. 1, Myburgh, C. 2
1
2
Department of nursing sciences, University of Johannesburg, South Africa
Department of educational psychology, University of Johannesburg, South Africa
Research worldwide indicates that educators and learners experience aggression in
the secondary school setting.
The objectives of this research project were to explore and describe the experience
of learners and educators of aggression in secondary schools in South Africa and to
describe strategies to manage aggression in secondary schools.
The research design was qualitative, explorative and descriptive and contextual. A
purposive sample was taken from secondary school learners and educators in four
provinces of South Africa. The final sample consisted of 554 learners and 63
educators. Data was collected using in depth phenomenological interviews, diaries,
naïve sketches, observations and field notes.
The identified themes from the learners’ experiences were: personal experiences
such as negative feelings and negative perceptions and ideas; and interpersonal
experiences such as physical actions, verbal actions, indirect actions, disrespect and
distrust. Identified themes from educators’ experiences are personal experiences of
irritation and frustration and interpersonal experiences such as actions by learners,
learners not used to being treated with respect; educators loose their temper and beat
the learners, passive aggressive from colleagues.
Personal and interpersonal strategies were described to manage aggression.
Keywords: aggression; learners experience; phenomenological interviews
O 122
ROMANIAN NURSES PROFESSIONAL STRATEGIES AND THEIR
IMPACT ON THE QUALITY OF HEALTHCARE DELIVERY
Popovici, S.
University “Alexandru Ioan Cuza”, Romania
The aim of this study is to identify and describe the professional strategies adopted
by the Romanian nurses in the effort to adapt to the changing healthcare system and
143
to comply with the European professional standards and regulations. Individual
interviews were performed with nurses from various nursing specialties and
healthcare units and examined with qualitative content analysis. A qualitative
software-based data analysis was also used. The main findings show: labour
migration for a similar or lower skilled position, transfer from a public to a private
healthcare provider, early retirement or becoming a free-lancer, as being the nurses’
main strategies to overcome the difficulties from the health system. The need for
professional autonomy and recognition, the motivation for choosing and practicing
the profession, as well as the self-perception of the profession proved to be
important for the choice of the nurses’ professional strategies and practice. Burnout,
powerless feelings and lack of group cohesion decrease work effectiveness and
satisfaction and have deteriorating impact on patients’ care and on the healthcare
delivery. The potential of the present analysis lies in providing data for further
research and for nursing and healthcare decisions and policies.
Keywords: nurses; professional strategies; labour migration; autonomy; recognition
O 123
WHAT EVERY WOMAN KNOWS – TRADITIONAL ARAB WOMEN
HEALERS IN ISRAEL
Popper-Giveon, A.
David Yelling Academic College, Israel
Over the past few decades, complementary medicine of various types has been
increasingly integrated into health care provided by established biomedical
organizations. By contrast, treatment methods commonly known as “folk” or
“traditional" medicine remained at the fringes of established care or outside it
altogether.
The above mentioned claim was analyzed in this study by examining the activity of
traditional Arab women healers in Israel, who treat physical and mental problems, to
which conventional medicine offers no adequate solution. They also address various
hardships of life, such as poverty, barrenness and spinsterhood, along with problems
of “supernatural” origin, such as the evil eye and spells.
The study included ten Muslim Arab women who are recognized by their
communities as traditional healers. Contact with the relevant informants was made
using the "chain sample" method, and included observations and in-depth
interviews, which were analyzed thematically.
144
To treat their patients, traditional Arab women healers in Israel prepare amulets,
spells and counterspells, love charms and herbal potions. They massage patients,
pray for them, console them and advise them about the hardships of life. Healers
attempt to reintegrate patients within their families. They direct patients to adopt
their traditional gender roles as wives and mothers. Finally, the healers help patients
bond with their culture by imparting a collectivist conception, rooting out
manifestations of individualism that may have caused rifts between patients and
their families, and consolidating patriarchal values.
The healers thus constitute an alternative to the biomedical establishment. Instead of
turning outside the community to the Western, Jewish, modern and secular world –
as the public medical system in Israel is sometimes perceived by the Arab minority
– they provide an inward-oriented, traditional, local and Muslim alternative. The
solutions proposed are indeed outside the purview of the professional biomedical
establishment and may not be readily discernible to researchers. Nevertheless, they
provide a significant alternative to biomedical treatment, whose attraction may exact
a heavy personal price from Arab women in Israel.
Keywords: traditional healing; women; minority; Arabs; Israel
O 124
THE EXPERIENCE OF INFERTILITY AMONG RELIGIOUS JEWISH
MOTHERS
Possick, C.
School of Social Work, Ariel University Center, Israel
The negative economic, physical, social and psychological effects on women who
are coping with infertility has been well documented (e.g. Cousineau & Domar,
2007). However, the medicalization of infertility often inadvertently leads to a
disregard for women’s emotional responses. In addition, once the infertility is
successfully treated, health service professionals may assume that the psychological
and social sequelae dissipate. Finally, there has been little attention given to possible
positive growth experiences that infertility engenders.
The objective of this qualitative study was to understand how religious Jewish
women construct the meaning of primary infertility after they have given birth to
one or more children. In-depth, semi-structured interviews were conducted with ten
religious, Jewish-Israeli married women of child-bearing age who had experienced
primary infertility and had subsequently given birth. The interview texts were
145
analyzed using Interpretative Analytic Phenomenology (Smith & Osborn, 2004).
The analysis yielded rich results around the meaning-construction of the women’s
infertility experience through their interactions with various eco-systemic levels—a
woman’s inner experience of infertility and internalized identity of “barrenness”
even after the birth of child(ren), the existential limits of “togetherness” in the
marital relationship, the extended family and community as the
social/cultural/contextual voice that is both jarringly dissonant with the woman’s
experience as well as an echo that resonates with her own values and aspirations.
This study expands and deepens our understanding of women’s contextual
experience of infertility and indicates directions for effective psychosocial
interventions during and subsequent to biological infertility.
Keywords: infertility; meaning construction; religious Jewish women; cultural context
O 125
PSYCHOLOGICAL PROBLEM SOLVING IN MULTICULTURAL
HEALTH ORGANIZATIONS – THE CASE OF LACOR HOSPITAL IN
GULU (UGANDA)
Prati, M. 1, Castiglioni, M. 1, Nencini, A. 2
1
2
Università Milano Bicocca, Italy
Università di Verona, Italy
Moving from a socio-constructionist theoretical background (Gergen, 1999; Gergen
& Thatchenkery, 2004), we propose a model for interventions in multicultural health
organizations. Cultural and ideological systems of knowledge, interpersonal
processes and pragmatic practices constitute forms of knowledge that construe the
representation of the organization, or in other words, its pragmatic meaning. The
way in which these forms of knowledge interact generates the “field” of effective or
ineffective actions, decisions or individual positioning. The main dimensions of this
model represent three intertwined fields of analysis that need to be taken into
consideration when planning interventions in multicultural contexts. We will
particularly focus on a specific case-study: the intervention that CFI-Multicultural
and Organizational Psychology carried at the St. Mary's Hospital in Lacor - Gulu
(Uganda). After many years of civil war in the “Acholiland” (a region in the northeast of Uganda), a former “family-run” missionary hospital founded by two doctors
from Italy and Canada, turned into a big multicultural organization. This rapid and
profound change involved (and is still involving) more than 400 Ugandan
146
employees, many international donors and organizations, some Italian
representatives of the Italian/Canadian foundation that sustains the hospital, as well
as a larger community of people who daily refer to Lacor hospital for health cares.
Since 2009, CFI has been involved to help handling some managerial and
organizational issues, with specific attention to the empowerment of a new Ugandan
middle-management. Preliminary interviews and focus groups helped us to show
that different roles within the hospital convey conflicting and contradictory
representations of the emerging middle-manager. Training, consultancy and
appreciative inquiry sessions were then carried on at different levels of the
organization in order to promote a more functional (in terms of responsibility and
autonomy) role of middle-manager. Main changes promoted in the context as well
as implications for the organization and for future developments of multicultural
health organizations projects will be discussed.
Keywords: multiculture; psychology; social-constructionism
O 126
PATIENTS OF ALTERNATIVE MEDICINE
Pretto, A.
University of Trento, Italy
My exposition aims to illustrate the results of a research carried out in the field of
alternative medicines in order to understand which kind of people approach them
and their motivations to do so. This research has been conducted (particularly but
not only) gathering the life stories of these patients. I choice this technique because
it provides a specific interaction between researcher and interviewee that allows
his/her to be a testimonial of life experiences (own, but also of other people) and not
as simply interviewee. Data analysis show that these patients fall into very different
types: some of them haven’t a specific disease; some of them are desperate ill who
haven’t get answers from traditional medicine; some of them approach these
therapies to found a personal path of well-being (more psychological than physical).
Everybody is joined by an extreme trust towards alternative therapist: the patients
often follow his or her recommendations and guidelines for treatment even going
against the advice of their doctor. It follows that there should be greater controls on
alternative therapists so as not to allow "quack" to harm patients.
Keywords: patients; alternative medicines; alternative therapists
147
O 127
EMPOWERMENT IN ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS GROUPS
Pretto, A. 1, Pavesi, N. 2
1
2
University of Trento, Italy
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
Our exposition aims to illustrate the results of a research carried out among
members of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) in order to understand if they achieve a
path of empowerment.
Our study, carried out in Italy, aims at emphasizing how, within AA groups, the
empowerment process represents a true development process by which individuals
who are in trouble gain a better control over their lives and their environment,
improving significantly their quality of life with positive effects on the group they
belong to and the surrounding community.
The study was conducted empirically through focus groups and life stories of
members of AA belonging to 5 different groups located in the north-east of Italy.
We have also analyzed the documents published by the AA General Services and
the documents created specifically by the association (statute, guide for the
associations and the groups, minutes of national conferences of the Italian General
Services.
The social activity attached to AA, which is based on the empowerment of
individual abilities, has a strong political value because it has significant effects at
community level. Unfortunately, public institutions and health care organizations
sometimes do not encourage these activities because, in Italy, AA is still not very
well-known.
Keywords: empowerment; alcohol; quality of life; health promotion
O 128
THE USE OF PHOTO-NOVELLAS IN HEALTH RESEARCH
Raffaeta, R.
University of Trento, Italy
This paper aims to illustrate two case studies in which conventional ethnographic
techniques of participant observation and interviews have been complemented by
the use of photo-novellas. Using this method, the researcher asks to research
148
participants to take pictures with regard to a specific theme. Subsequently, the
pictures provide a means of facilitating discussion and exploring alternative ‘ways
of seeing’. Photo-novella is a creative and innovative method for understanding and
describing health experiences, especially when working with young people,
immigrants, heavy disabled people or people with mental illnesses. Moreover,
methods of visual practice are attentive to the embodied, material and affectual
register of experience and can counter the traditional power dynamics of interview.
The first case study refers to recovery from mental illness in Mebourne (Australia),
while the second explores how Ecuadorian immigrants in Trentino (Italy) enhance
and maintain their wellbeing. These two case studies are similar in establishing a
connection between place (understood as an assemblage of resources) and
wellbeing. Photo novella allows to identify how people find informal resources (non
state-led) for health and wellbeing and to explore the tension between formal (stateled) and informal resources.
Keywords: photo-novella; space and wellbeing; informal and formal resources
O 129
A REFLEXIVE METHODOLOGY FOR ACTION-RESEARCH WITH
DISADVANTAGES STUDENTS IN HIGHER EDUCATION
Rainone, N., Martino, M.L., Cannata, A., Freda, M.F.
Università degli studi di Napoli “Federico II”, Italy
The growing phenomena of disadvantaged and non-traditional students increases the
risk of educational underachievement and drop-out in university context of the
European countries.
Within European funded project INSTALL (Innovative Solutions to Acquire
Learning to Learn), to be developed over the next two years in Italy (lead partner),
Romania, Denmark, Ireland, and Spain, this paper discusses the effectiveness of the
use of qualitative tools to promote a reflexive competence on the formative
experience and so a functional adjustment to the university context. The Narrative
Mediation Path (NMP) is an innovative and qualitative methodology that develops a
group training process targeted to disadvantaged students. NMP, based on the
psychological concept of mentalization, also known as reflexive competence
(Fonagy & Target, 1997; Allen & Fonagy, 2008), combines into one methodology
four discursive modules: Metaphoric, Iconographic, Writing and Bodily. The use of
“multidimensional” narrative (Hermans, 2001), promote a progressive cognitive and
149
emotional involvement of the student; a gradual transition from exploration of the
entire university experience to a specific and individual experience and a gradual
evolution from a reconstructive function of the formative experience to a planning
function that allows students to act in an effective way in the university context. The
results suggest that the use of different discursive modules supports the students in
the recognition of different abilities.
Keywords: narrative; reflexive competence; higher education
O 130
FACTORS RELATED TO SEEKING CERVICAL CANCER SCREENING:
AN ACTION RESEARCH APPROACH
Ray, D.V. 1, Stiffler, D. 2, Carey, M.A. 3
1
Indiana University, USA
School of Nursing, Indiana University, USA
3
Kells Consulting, USA
2
Cervical cancer is a condition that can be successfully treated if identified early. In
Clay County, Indiana (US), there was a very low rate of screening for cervical
cancer. Two related question arose in relation to the issue. First, what are the
barriers to preventive health care in the county, and second, how do women in the
county generally access health care. As a part of the project, a mobile unit to provide
health education and health screening was to be taken to the community. Initial
conversations were held with local health related community leaders and their input
used in designing the project. The methods used were key informant interviews and
focus groups. The information obtained was organized using an ecological model.
The results of the research suggested that the barriers to preventive care were not
different from those found in other geographic areas. Financial issues related to
health care and the organization of health care services were two of the major
contributors to not seeking preventive care. The scarcity of health care resources for
women in the county will require new solutions if women’ needs are to be met.
Keywords: community engagement; preventive health care; women’s health
150
O 131
PUTTING THEORY INTO PRACTICE: NURSES NEGOTIATING
INFORMED CONSENT WITH VULNERABLE AND COMPROMISED
PATIENTS
Richardson-Tench, M.
Victoria University, Australia
The concept of consent provides nursing with both theoretical and practical
challenges. Nursing ethics theory addresses issues raised by patients who are unable
to provide implied, informed, voluntary, or competent consent. What is less clear is
how nurses in carrying out their professional responsibilities negotiate the question
of consent with patients who have limited scope to negotiate their own nursing care.
This explorative, qualitative project used interviews within a critical incident
framework to examine how nurses undertake negotiating and obtaining consent
from compromised patients. The project collected data from nurses working within
psycho-geriatric wards and perioperative areas in an acute public hospital in
Melbourne, Australia. The project used ‘consent episodes’ as units of data, and
explored these with 16 nurses. Participants were asked to focus on daily tasks of
nursing associated with these areas of practice, including for example the use of
restraints, the use of monitoring equipment, use of analgesics, loosening or removal
of gowns, and lifting and moving of patients. Findings indicate that verbal
communication plays a minor role in consent negotiation with these patient cohorts.
The project has sought to articulate a wide range of nursing skills that are employed
in the negotiation of consent with vulnerable and compromised patients beyond
verbal communication. These are examined in relation to current nursing ethics
theory, as well as feminist discussion regarding the value of feminine
communication practices. The paper will include discussion of the challenges of a
more extensive and transparent inclusion of non-verbal communicative practices in
nursing theory, teaching and practice.
Keywords: nursing; communication; consent; compromised
151
O 132
HEREDITARY THROMBOPHILIA – LIVING A CONTEXTUALISED LIFE
Roddis, J.
Bournemouth University, UK
A constructivist grounded theory interview study was carried out to explore the
problematic journey of individuals diagnosed with hereditary thrombophilia. This
inherited condition leads to an increased risk of inappropriate blood clotting and
potentially to deep vein thrombosis (DVT) and pulmonary embolism. Diagnosis
may result from a clot, diagnosis of another family member or experience of certain
symptoms. The findings demonstrated that individuals made informed choices
regarding medications, non-medical treatments and activities they were or were not
prepared to undertake, in order to reduce their risk of having a clot (for example,
taking blood-thinning medication, wearing compression stockings, adopting advice
about immobility or healthy eating). Some of the behaviour contradicted medical
advice and led to an increased risk; in particular, eating unhealthily and taking long
haul flights were mentioned as ‘risky’ activities. This study has found that
individuals’ choices focus strongly on personal wellbeing, though this may be in
conflict with advice and the principles of health promotion. Individuals have
personal reference points regarding what activities and treatments are personally
acceptable. Health professionals need to be aware of this contradiction between
health promotion and wellbeing as it may explain patients’ adoption of ‘risky’
behaviours.
Keywords: thrombophilia; grounded theory; health choices; deep vein thrombosis; DVT
O 133
BODY WORK AND AGING:
NUTRITION PRACTICES
THE
BIOMEDICALIZATION
OF
Rodeschini, G.
University of Trento, Italy
In recent years, a lot of changes have taken place in health care facilities for elderly
people. Residents’ age and their physical and mental problems have increased, and
recipients are more and more dependent. The setting and many working practices
152
have adapted to this new situation, creating new strategies of care and cure, often
based on new kind of tools and technologies. In this context, the process of nutrition
assumes a relevant role. The common practice of artificial nutrition, in particular,
moves the process of nutrition from the field of assistance to the medical one,
creating a distance between bodies and modifying the social meaning of a meal.
Drawing on a participant observation of 4 months in two Italian facilities for older
people (a public nursing home and a private care home), this article intends to
explore the organizational changes in the setting of care for older people, by
studying the geriatric care and medical practices enacted by health care
professionals. Discussion focuses on the physical and relational transformations of
recipients’ bodies caused by the nutrition work and on the perception of bodies as
“bodies at risk” and as “risky bodies”. Conclusion will focus on the different
meanings of the processes of medicalization inside facilities for the elderly, on the
“false” rational solutions offered by new forms of nutrition, and on the
“securitarian” character of risk management by professionals.
Keywords: aging; medicalization; artificial nutrition; body work
O 134
YOUNG MEN’S AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL ACCOUNTS OF RECOVERY
AND SELF-CHANGE FROM ADDICTION
Rodríguez-Morales, L.
Birkbeck University of London, UK
Recovery from addiction encompasses dramatic changes in a young person’s life.
The availability of favorable psychosocial conditions for change influences the
individual’s ability to sustain resolution from addictive behaviour and create
meaningful identity. In this presentation I discuss young men’s self-change and
identity transformation in light of their emotional development during recovery. The
discussion is built upon findings from a qualitative study that investigated how
young men worked through the process of recovery from addiction (from alcohol
and drugs) whilst participating in 12-step fellowships. Autobiographies from ten
participants were analysed with interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA).
Examining the participants’ experience of recovery exposes the vital significance of
the interpersonal and affective patterns of relating within their masculine life-world;
such understanding is essential for the creation of intervention programs that
incorporate the developmental challenges faced by young adults. I suggest that
qualitative approaches such as IPA can make a valuable contribution towards further
153
understanding the experience of recovery and how successful self-change unfolds in
this season of the life course.
Keywords: young adulthood; addiction recovery; IPA
O 135
QUALITATIVE METHODS 2.0: INNOVATIVE APPROACHES TO
SAMPLING, FIELD MANAGEMENT AND ENGAGING COMMUNITIES
IN SOCIAL AND HEALTH RESEARCH
Romero, D.
School of Public Health, City University of New York, USA
This research considers two questions involving qualitative methods and
demonstrates how community engagement and innovative web-based technologies
were used to conduct large-scale data collection.
The first topic addresses closure of a 160-year-old hospital in NYC and its impact
on the community. We participated in a Steering Committee that developed the plan
for assessing the effect of the hospital closure. Mixed-methods data collection
included key informant interviews; focus groups; and, a web-based survey. Data
included demographics/health status; experiences accessing health care pre/post
closure; access to medical records, prescriptions; hospital utilization patterns;
relationship with primary-care physician, appointments, travel to health care visits;
unmet health care needs; most significant effect of the closure; and,
recommendations for improving health care in the community. A community-based
participatory research (CBPR) paradigm was utilized to define the research
questions, design the data collection instruments, identify study participants, and
interpret the results.
The second topic addresses changing family demographics in the US. Specifically,
declining marriage, and increases in divorce, cohabitation, and non-marital
childbearing have troubled social observers who worry about ‘loss of the family,’ as
well as public health professionals who consider better availability of reproductive
health services as a logical solution to unintended pregnancy. The Social Position
and Family Formation (SPAFF) study collected information on the factors that adult
men and women consider when making decisions regarding family formation (ie,
nature of intimate relationships; childbearing) to better understand changing family
demographics. This large-scale qualitative research study involved 200 in-depth
interviews in New York and New Jersey, and employed several web-based
technologies to assist with a community-based sampling frame, recruitment, data
154
collection, and field management (eg, Google Earth/Maps, Skype, Google Docs,
DropBox, SurveyMonkey).
These two studies demonstrate the value of both traditional and innovative
qualitative research methodologies and show how the inherently reflexive nature of
qualitative research is suited to collaborative work with health services providers,
community stakeholders, and policymakers.
Keywords: in-depth interviews; focus groups; survey; web-based tools; family
demography; community-based sampling; Community-Based Participatory Research
(CBPR)
O 136
QUALITATIVE RESEARCH ON PREGNANCY AND POSTNATAL CARE
IN HIV-ENDEMIC RURAL SOUTHERN ZAMBIA
Sacks, E.
The Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, USA
In Southern Province, Zambia, the HIV rate among adults aged 15-49 exceeds 15%.
Antiretroviral (ARV) medication for adults has become widely available. However,
uptake of Nevirapine for prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV
(PMTCT) during delivery has been slow.
This study uses qualitative research methods to examine women’s choices and
interactions with the formal and informal health care system based on their
serostatus during pregnancy. It compares the experiences of a group of 12 women
who were HIV+ and a group of 12 who were HIV- during pregnancy to understand
the frequency and type of care received, throughout the pregnancy and postnatal
period. Additional in-depth interviews with 52 women and care providers in the
community were also conducted, focusing on the general perception of HIV during
pregnancy and birth. Women identified and ranked challenges and barriers and
highlighted community and familial practices that were beneficial for care and care
seeking. HIV generally did not rank high on these lists; the first listed concerns were
almost always about prolonged or difficult labors. Traditional caregivers did not
rank HIV high on their lists of concerns and often did not refer patients to the
hospital solely based on a positive HIV status.
This study found that stigma still remains high, largely as a local understanding
about contagion, in which is it is thought that healthy babies may become sick with
chibele (a fatal, febrile illness) if they are exposed to another infant who is taking
155
“strong medicine,” which includes ARVs. Thus, HIV- women are vocal in their
objection to sharing clinics with women and infants who are medicated or perceived
to be medicated. Due to these tensions, HIV+ women are less likely to visit a clinic
for newborn care if the clinic or clinic waiting area is a common space dominated by
HIV- women. In rural Zambia, HIV is not necessarily perceived as the greatest
threat to a newborn; other illnesses are identified as more threatening to the mother
and baby. Birth has long been understood as both a medical event and a cultural
tradition, imbued with meaning for women and their families. In focusing
exclusively on PMTCT as a medical event, the context of other choices and
negotiations made during pregnancy and birth are missed. The use of in-depth
qualitative interviews is essential for understanding the ways in which community
members practice and negotiate health and health care, especially in cases where
stigma around HIV remains strong.
Keywords: newborn health; HIV endemicity; in-depth interviews; Zambia; sub-Saharan
Africa
O 137
CTI-REPERTOIRE: A TOOL FOR FLOURISHING COMMUNITIES
Santi, M., Ghedin, E.
FISPPA, University of Padova, Italy
The inclusion process is considered as a fundamental aspect of health, a dimension
of well-being, and a valuable condition for individual happiness. The question
would be: Does seem plausible to argue that an inclusive education system promotes
children’s developing capabilities and so considered as co-constructors of their wellbeing? (Biggeri e Bellanca, 2010). The main purpose was to move from a
descriptive to a prescriptive level in order to offer a pro-active tool (within the
Capability Approach (CA) (Sen, 1999a, 1999b) and the International Classification
of Functioning (ICF) (WHO, 2007) rather than just a monitoring procedure. The
Commitment toward Inclusion Repertoire (CTI-Repertoire) is presented as a new
tool to implement individual and social commitment toward inclusion and to stress
good practices. A first part of the study is already concluded: the modification of the
Index for inclusion (Booth, Ainscow, 2002, 2006) into the “CTI-Repertoire” that
presents itself as a platform accessible on the web by communities. It offers
different versions of 29 commitments/functionings according to the users (academic
staff, technical and administrative, auxiliary, executives, students and families).
Each user, using the grids of the Directory, is called to choose the commitments
156
which recognizes by detailing the relevant activities in terms of
responses/opportunities
to
the
next
sets
of
questions/demands/opportunities/capabilities (10) for each commitment that
represent the feedback for the institutions’ work toward inclusion. To close, even
temporarily, the path of self-monitoring and evaluation of efforts toward inclusion,
the system needs to “load" in the CTI-Repository, materials (documented through
video, images, texts...) by witnessing the communities inclusive agency of belonging
towards that commitment. The CTI-Repertoire offers a multidimensional approach
to the evaluation of commitments toward inclusion, in which quantitative feedbacks
regarding the level of persistency, intensity, and investment are complemented with
qualitative feedbacks elaborated by registered peer-communities review of the
actions upload in the Repository. The evaluation procedure is regulated by shared
criteria and dimensions of analysis available in the system. The criteria are coherent
with the assumed Capability Approach and has to do with internal/external
capabilities, conversion factors, and choice opportunities which are offered by the
community agency. The dimensions of analysis are declined into six facets,
following the structure of understanding proposed by Wiggins and McTighe (1998):
explanation (accurate, coherent, justified, systematic, predictive) interpretation
(meaningful, insightful, significant, illustrative, illuminating), application (effective,
efficient, fluent, adaptive, graceful), perspective (credible, revealing, insightful,
plausible, unusual), empathy (sensitive, open, receptive, perceptive, tactful), selfknowledge (self-aware, metacognitive, self-adjusting). The discussion highlights
these main potential of the CTI-Repertoire and focuses on analyzing its implications
in educational contexts. Finally, the role of education as fundamental vector for
converting children’s capabilities into “flourishing” functionings within
developmental communities is also pointed out.
Keywords: repertoire; well-being; diversity
O 138
THE IMPACT OF HEALTH CONDITIONS ON PERCEIVED HAPPINESS,
MEANING AND GOAL PURSUIT. A COMPARATIVE STUDY
Sartori, R., Negri, L., Delle Fave, A.
Università degli Studi di Milano, Italy
Theoretical advancements and empirical evidence support the role of perceived
happiness, goal setting and meaning making processes in promoting well-being even
under suboptimal health conditions.
157
This study aimed at comparing the perception of happiness, goals and meaning
between healthy participants and people with chronic diseases through a qualitative
approach. 30 healthy participants and 30 persons with a neuromuscular disease
provided their own definition of happiness and listed the most important goals and
meaningful things in their life through the Eudaimonic and Hedonic Happiness
Investigation (EHHI). Answers’ content and frequency were compared between
groups. Participants reported situational and psychological definitions of happiness.
People with disease more frequently described it as a transient emotion, healthy
participants as a psychological condition of balance and growth. In listing their
goals, both groups referred to work and family, but healthy participants’ goals were
more realistic and attainable. No group difference emerged instead for meaningful
things, with participants mostly reporting family and relationships.
The pursuit of meaning and attainable goals, together with constructive family and
social relations can represent useful tools to support individuals in the process of
adaptation to disease.
Keywords: neuromuscular disease; happiness; meaning making; goals
O 139
PATIENT-SCARING ANTIGEN? EMOTIONAL RESPONSES OF
JAPANESE PROSTATE CANCER PATIENTS TO POST-TREATMENT
PSA MONITORING
Sakuma-Sato, S. 1, Sawada, A. 2, Beppu, H. 1, Iba, N. 1
1
2
DIPEx, Japan
Iwaki Meisei University, Japan
The use of prostate-specific antigen (PSA) for monitoring recurrence and metastasis
in patients with prostate cancer is a standard practice in Japan today. Patients under
monitoring often become preoccupied by the ups and downs of their PSA level. The
goal of this paper is to analyze the anxiety and distress caused by PSA testing, find
patterns and causes of such emotional response, in order to improve patient-doctor
communication with respect to post-treatment PSA monitoring.
The study is based on narrative interviews with 49 Japanese men with prostate
cancer, varying in age, cancer stages, and choices of initial treatment. A qualitative,
interpretive approach was taken, combining thematic analysis with constant
comparison. Those who had “definitive therapy” for clinically localized prostate
cancer were keen of the post-treatment PSA level, because they saw it as the
158
primary indicator of the success of the treatment. Some of the participants were
confused by the information on expected PSA levels after surgery and radiation
therapy which differ widely. Men who chose hormonal therapy because of their
advanced cancer stage tended to have a more relaxed attitude toward the results of
PSA testing, because their initial PSA levels were extremely high. Most of our
participants eventually overcame the anxiety by developing their own standard for
defining the “danger zone”; however, some were still haunted by the image of
“invisible enemy” creeping up, as their PSA levels rose in spite of the absence of
confirmed metastasis. The results suggest that at the beginning of monitoring period,
patients should be given information on how to interpret the PSA levels according to
the treatment they had. Doctors should also discuss with their patients the clinical
significance of “biochemical recurrence” (which does not necessarily develop into
actual metastatic disease).
Keywords: PSA; prostate cancer; patient reaction; information communication; distress;
anxiety
O 140
EXPLORING THE HUMANNESS OF CARE IN THERAPEUTIC
RELATIONSHIPS THROUGH THE NARRATIVE REFLECTIVE PROCESS
Schwind, J.
Ryerson University, Canada
There is a growing recognition that illness narratives are a rich source of information
for caregivers who wish to enhance the quality of caregiver-carereceiver
relationships. Stories are mechanisms through which we articulate ourselves,
thereby giving meaning to our illness-disordered lives. Illness narratives, the
reconstructed stories of experience, are multidimensional, consisting of internal
conditions of feelings and hopes, situated within an external environment over time.
By reconstructing our past in the present moment personal illness stories are given
voice through creative self-expression, such as Narrative Reflective Process
(Schwind, 2008), which encompasses storytelling, metaphors, drawing and writing.
As a nurse-teacher and a researcher, who was also a patient, I explore, using
Narrative Inquiry (Clandinin & Connelly, 2000), the notion of what it means to be in
a caring therapeutic relationship. Reflecting narratively on my own illness
experience I have come to understand that we feel cared for when we connect with
one another on a human level; more specifically, when we are seen and valued as
159
human beings. This recognition prompted further reflection and realization that this
humanness of care, in addition to theoretical knowledge, in order to be embodied,
may be elicited through the thoughtful creativity of the Narrative Reflective Process.
Keywords: therapeutic relationship; humanness of care; narrative reflective process;
illness narratives; narrative inquiry
O 141
POST-TRAUMATIC GROWTH: REALITY OR ILLUSION?
CRUCIAL ROLE OF NARRATIVE AND LINGUISTIC APPROACH
THE
Scrignaro, M., Marini, E., Magrin, M.E.
University of Study of Milano-Bicocca, Italy
There are a recent interest in the post-traumatic growth (PTG) reported after medical
illness (Park et al., 2010). The identification of PTG in the accounts of those that
have survived medical illness is beyond question, but there is a controversy
concerning the nature of PTG: real (i.e identity change) or illusory (i.e. a coping
strategies)? (Sumalla et al., 2009). The aim of this study was to examine this issue
moving both from the theoretical as well as methodological assumptions of
Pennebaker’s differential emotion model (1997) and that of McAdams’s identity
narrative model (2001). Autobiographical sequences (means of words = 1095) of 40
mixed cancer patients were codified.
100% used redemption sequences. 26% used both positive and negative emotion
words, 37% used more positive emotion words and the other 37% used more
negative emotion words. Surprisingly only the redemption sequences with more
negative emotion words correlated with linguistic indicators of cognitive change (r
=.82) (i.e. real PTG) while the redemption with more positive emotions did not
correlate with linguistic indicators of cognitive and emotion processes (i.e. illusory
PTG). These results highlighted the crucial role of narrative and linguistic approach
to disambiguate the real vs illusory side of PTG.
Keywords: post-traumatic growth; identity; narrative model; emotions words;
adjustment
160
O 142
EXPLORING SUPPORT SERVICES FOR EATING DISORDERS IN IRISH
FEMALES: AN EXPLORATORY STUDY
Sheridan, G. 1, Mc Ardle, S. 1, Gaffney, P. 2, Miles, N. 2
1
2
Dublin City University, Ireland
Health Service Executive, Ireland
The paucity of qualitative research investigating eating disorder (ED) patients’
experiences of health care remains a critical area of enquiry. The purpose of this
study was to investigate qualitatively ED patients’ perspectives on their treatment
experiences and expectations, within the Irish context. Semi-structured interviews
were conducted with a purposive female sample of 17 current and discharged ED
service users, ranging in age from 14 to 51 years. An interpretive thematic analytic
approach was employed to identify key themes in the data. Participants described
the importance of treatment approaches that addressed the emotional aspects of an
eating disorder and reflected on perceptions of autonomy and support for motivation
and collaboration. All participants identified instances where they had encountered
lack of ED specific expertise and reflected on the implications of these experiences
for the recovery process. The role of treatment expectations in therapeutic
engagement and the importance of continuity of care were other key findings. The
results of this study highlight the often complex and dynamic nature of the treatment
process for eating disorders. An in-depth understanding of sources of both resistance
and change in ED patients can inform health policy and future service development,
enhancing the quality of care provided.
Keywords: eating disorders; patient experiences; health care journey; Interpretive
Thematic Analysis
161
O 143
HEALTH-CARING NEEDS OF THE FIRST DIAGNOSED YOUNG
SCHIZOPHRENIC PATIENTS AND THEIR MOTHERS IN TAIWAN: A
PROSPECTIVE STUDY
Shih-Pi, L. 1, Ping-Chuan, H. 2, Hai-Gwo, H. 3
1
Department and Institute of Nursing, National Yang-Ming University, Taiwan
Department of Social Work, National Taiwan University, Taiwan
3
National Taiwan University, Taiwan
2
Early intervention had done for many years. However, the patients with
Schizophrenia and their mothers in Taiwan while first diagnosed, they still felt
uncertainty to face their symptoms of illness and intervention at hospital. Therefore,
the aim of this research attempts to explore what health-caring needs of first visit
with schizophrenia and their main family in Taiwan looking for among 6 months.
The data collection sessions were conducted individually and were tape recorded for
later coding and analysis. I took the cases after their agreement in one medical
center of Taipei in Taiwan. The cases are 7 patients with schizophrenia and their
mothers, and I collected the data by in-depth interview. I took the experience of
health care needs with the cases at entry, 1 month, 3 months, and 6 months.
In this study, via the illness experience of the patients with Schizophrenia and their
mothers in Taiwan while first diagnosed, the results showed that the change of
attitude from primary symptom confirmation to primary diagnosis confirmation, and
therefore understand the health-caring needs from them. Moreover, these results
may be explained by considering the young patients with growth, role, and major
caregivers, we understand the different need and illness experience from them. Such
findings underscore the importance of recognizing timely accurate and useful
information, reorganized daily life, sufficient support system, and chance of holding
the hope.
These results show the difficult position and need between the patients with
schizophrenia in this study. Besides, we could offer our results on clinic, teaching,
research, in order to reach the good communication with the patient.
Keywords: schizophrenia;
intervention; first diagnosed
162
help-seeking
behavior;
health-caring
needs;
early
O 144
WHAT PROFESSIONAL COMPETENCES ARE RELEVANT FOR
TOMORROW´S HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS IN CONVERSATIONS
ABOUT LIFE AND DEATH?
Soerensen, M.
Aalborg University, Denmark
In Denmark the Health Board in 2012 has made a program for rehabilitation and
palliation as a specific part of the general cancer treatment plan. In this program a
holistic perspective is presented, including increased focus on the collaboration
between health care providers, patient and relatives. The plan focuses on a physical,
a psychological, a social and an existential/spiritual perspective.
Research and published narratives indicates that a cancer diagnosis often incites
questions of an existential nature. This paper is based on an ongoing qualitative
study of 28 nurses´ perspective on skills required in dialogues about life and death
anxiety, and on experience with teaching a master class in humanistic palliation.
Staff meets psychological and spiritual needs in hospice but how will this
communication take place within the interdisciplinary hospital team?
The presentation leads to a discussion of what is needed to make nurses capable of
balancing between different values and norms. How can they be trained to reflect on
existential/spiritual issues? And how can existential conversation be part of
interventions that facilitate the active involvement of individuals and groups as coconstructors of their health?
Keywords: existential/spiritual; palliation; rehabilitation; cancer; health care providers
O 145
THE FAMILY PHYSICIAN AND THE PSYCHOLOGIST TOGETHER IN
PRIMARY CARE: A FRUITFUL SYNERGY
Solano, L.
Department of Dynamic and Clinical Psychology, Sapienza University of Rome, Italy
It is well known that motives for consulting the family physician, though expressed
as physical symptoms, often derive from problems needing a psychosocial,
163
approach. Progressive differentiation between medicine and psychology makes
cooperation through referral to the psychologist by the physician quite problematic.
Acceptance of psychological referral may anyhow be difficult, due to the social
stigma that still surrounds mental distress.
As a possible solution 13 psychologists attending the postgraduate School in Health
Psychology of the Sapienza University of Rome have been present during
consultations, one day a week for 3 years, in the office of a family physician. This
allowed a) direct access to a psychologist in the absence of any filter and without the
need for a formal request on the patient’s part and b) a biopsychosocial approach to
any form of distress reported. Patients have welcomed the presence of the
psychologist and, as expected, took a broader approach in reporting their distress.
Each psychologist in three years met about 700 patients, implemented meaningful
intervention in about 120, had separate consultations in about 12. Only about 6 were
referred to mental health specialists. In two cases where data were available, drug
prescription on part of the physician showed a 17% decrease (75.000 euros in one
year) in one case and 14% (55.000 euros) in the other. An illustrative clinical case
will be presented.
Keywords: family medicine; first-level psychologist; somatic symptoms
O 146
CHALLENGING SOME OF THE DISCOURSE ON LOW-INCOME LONE
MOTHERS: STEPS TO EMPOWERMENT
Solberg, S.
Memorial University of Newfoundland, Canada
Attitudes towards low-income lone mothers have improved in many circles with
generally a more positive view of members of this group and the group as a whole.
However, in health and social care there is room for improvement if we are to work
more effectively with lone mothers. The objective of this presentation is to identify
some of the negative stereotypes that still prevail when we talk about low income
single mothers and what they would see as a more positive way to view their
situation. Discourse if it presents a negative view can be quite disempowering. Four
focus groups were held with 20 low-income mothers and five individual interviews
were held with selected women from the focus groups. The women felt that much of
the discourse around reasons why they were single parents, their attitudes and
decisions towards work and education, time use, balancing scarce resources, and
164
how they were compared to men in parallel situations were barriers they needed to
overcome. The findings from this research have relevance for policy makers and
providers of health and social care to this group of women so that services may be
improved.
Keywords: lone mothers; stereotyping; focus groups; empowerment
O 147
DEVELOPMENT THROUGH
INVESTIGATION
DISABILITY:
A
CROSS-CULTURAL
Soosai Nathan, L., Fianco, A., Bassi, M., Delle Fave, A.
Università degli studi di Milano, Italy
According to the bio-psycho-social model any health evaluation should consider,
besides biological aspects, cultural beliefs concerning health, disease and the impact
of impairments, as well as individual’s values, goal hierarchy and quality of daily
experience.
This study aimed at identifying individual and contextual dimensions of well-being
in daily experience and in the long-term developmental perspective among people
with motor disabilities in Italy and Nepal.
Data were collected among 100 participants (40 in Nepal and 60 in Italy) through: a)
Flow Questionnaire, to assess the occurrence of optimal experience - a positive and
complex condition of engagement and well-being - and the associated activities; b)
Life Theme Questionnaire, to explore past life influences, present challenges, and
future goals. Answers to open ended questions were categorized within life domains
and their content and frequency were compared between groups.
Regardless of socio-cultural conditions and disease severity, participants reported
optimal experience in their life, associating it to challenging and complex tasks.
Substantial congruence was detected between perceived present opportunities for
engagement and future goals.
Models of optimal functioning based on perceived well-being and development can
be useful in designing person centered interventions in the disability domain.
Keywords: disability; development; culture
165
O 148
FROM LAB TO CLINIC: THE ROLE OF THE NEUROPSYCHOLOGIST IN
A REHABILITATION TEAM
Sozzi, M., Pisani, L.
Department of Neuro-Rehabilitative Sciences - Casa di Cura Privata del Policlinico,
Italy
Taking care of a patient in a rehabilitation unit after a neurological disease entails
great multi-professional intervention. Actually patients may show complex disability
involving at the same time motor, communication and cognitive abilities. For this
reason rehabilitation practices involve a wide range of specialists: physiotherapists,
speech therapists, occupational therapists, physicians and neuropsychologists as
well. In last years neuropsychology saw a wide develop in clinical practice, a
number of scientific publications describe neuropsychological syndromes such as
visual-spatial neglect, aphasia, disexecutive disorders etc. and their rehabilitation
procedures. Nevertheless one of the main problems in rehabilitation units consists in
finding a functional role of neuropsychologist amongst the team. It is assumed that
neuropsychological assessment concerns an analysis of cognitive impairment in
neurologic patients but no contribution illustrates how this information about patient
disability can be used in rehabilitation by other healthcare providers. Aim of this
work is to show an integration of neuropsychological intervention in a rehabilitation
team by means of multiprofessional equipe discussion. In particular we will describe
a single case discussion throughout a clinical audit procedure in order to illustrate a
method to manage rehabilitation cares. Moreover practical effects on motor training,
speech therapy and nurse care will be discussed as well.
Keywords: neuropsychology; healthcare; providers; team work; rehabilitation
O 149
USING POETRY AND INTERPRETATIVE PHENOMENOLOGICAL
ANALYSIS TO EXPLORE THE LIFEWORLD OF A DIALYSIS PATIENT
Spiers, J., Smith, J.
Birkbeck University, UK
The experience of living with end-stage renal disease is complex and multi-faceted.
166
Patients may have to deal with the restrictive regime of dialysis as well as living
with the uncertainty of life on the waiting list for a kidney. This paper uses the
autobiographical poetry of a renal patient to explore these experiences. There is a
growing tradition for the use of poetry within qualitative social science research.
Some authors have turned data into poetry (Willig 2007), while others have used
poetry as data (Furman et al. 2007). The poems in this paper, by Jon Seaman,
explore life on dialysis and on the waiting list for a kidney, and look at wider themes
including mortality and self. These poems were analysed from a psychological
perspective, using Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (Smith, Flowers and
Larkin 2009). The presentation will set the context for the use of poetry as data
within health psychology, explore how this poetry illuminates themes as such as loss
of self and examine one man’s experiences of living with kidney disease and
dialysis. It will also present some of the communication with the poet himself about
the researcher’s interpretation.
Keywords: IPA; renal disease; poetry
O 150
NORMALCY FROM THE PERSPECTIVES OF CHRONICALLY ILL
CHIDREN
Sripichyakan, K., Chotibang, J.
Faculty of Nursing, Chiang Mai University, Thailand
Normalcy is a concept describing illness in a holistic aspect. However, there is no
clear body of knowledge in this concept. This qualitative study aimed to understand
normalcy of chronic ill children from the family's perspectives. Research
participants included 24 parents of children with cancer or blood diseases. Data were
collected through interviews, and analysed using content analysis techniques. It was
found that normalcy of the children was perceived as being happy despite of illness;
and living as usual, as needed, or like others. Abnormalcy of the children included 5
dimensions: 1) psycho-emotion, such as irritable, fussy, stressful, bored, etc.; 2)
physical health, such as weak, slim, easily infected, etc.; 3) decreased intelligence,
thinking, and memory; 4) activities, such as no schooling, no playing, etc.; and 5)
daily living, such as inconvenience, non-tasty food, etc. It is suggested that nursing
personnel take care of chronically ill children by balancing between therapy and
living a normal life as usual or like other children, as much as possible.
Keywords: normalcy; abnormalcy; chronic ill chidren
167
O 151
HEALTH IN VALUE SYSTEM AMONG PATIENTS WITH DIABETIC
FOOT SYNDROME
Stankiewicz, G.
Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Medical Science, School of Nursing, Midwifery and
Health Science, Monash University Melbourne, Australia
Nowadays health plays a basic role both for people free from any kind of disease,
and for those suffering from chronic and incurable ones.
Diabetes is an illness, which requires the change of life priorities, expectations,
values, ambitions and aims.
Diabetic Foot Syndrome (DFS) is a complication of diabetes, of angiopathic and
neuropathic background with coexisting infection. Very often it leads to severe foot
ulcerations, what results in amputation and invalidity/disability at the end.
The aim of this research was to estimate the character and quality of changes in
value system among patients with DFS. The outcome was related to patient’s sex,
education, resilience, knowledge about illness, attitude towards alcohol, smoking,
pharmacological and dietetic treatment.
The research was carried out in 2009-2010 in Public Hospital in Melbourne. There
were 48 patients: 20 women and 28 men in the age between 25 and 84 years with
average of 63 years. All of them were hospitalised in the hospital at that time
because of DFS.
In order to collect all necessary data, several methods were used, such as:
participating observation, questionnaire and document analysis.
Conclusions:
Despite of incurable illness, which diabetes undoubtedly is, and its chronic results
leading to lower limb amputation (DFS), health in patient’s value system occupies
the first place.
Low level of education among patients has the influence on the awareness of
possible complications (DFS) which have direct influence on health.
The level of knowledge was subjectively insufficient, and as the consequence of
this, disobedience to recommended lifestyle was observed.
Very characteristic is 2-grade classification: because of the diabetes and DFS.
Keywords: health; diabetes; diabetic foot syndrome
168
O 152
THE SPATIAL DIMENSIONS OF THE RIGHTS IN HOSPITAL. A
QUALITATIVE RESEARCH IN THREE CASE STUDIES IN TUSCANY
Surrenti, S. 1, Chiesi, L. 1, Costa, P. 1, Bruscaglioni, L. 2
1
2
University of Florence, Italy
Dep. of Political Science and Sociology, University of Florence, Italy
This paper presents the first findings of the project “Spaces. The space of rights", an
interdisciplinary research for the evaluation of spaces in hospitals, carried out in
three case studies in Tuscany.
The project aims to explore the relationship between space configuration and quality
of environments on one side and use of space and patients’ accessibility, equality
and empowerment on the other. The first research phase is adopting a qualitative
approach, using techniques such as observation and in depth interview.
The observation of practices along typical patients’ itineraries (such as emergency,
outpatient and hospitalization) allows to investigate the spatially located actions that
are related to accessibility to healthcare and other aspects of rights to health in
hospitals.
Through observation and the involvement of patients and hospital staff, the first
qualitative phase of the research allows findings from the field about the relevant
dimensions of patients’ experiences that are related to their rights and to the new
ones that are emerging in a changing society. In particular the analysis focuses on
spaces that are particularly significant for the protection of social rights but that
gained less attention from researches in this field, such as reception spaces, waiting
rooms, spaces of transitions and thresholds along them, where social relationships
are developed.
The paper will also propose a methodological analysis of the strengths and
weaknesses of qualitative approach research in this research area.
Keywords: space configuration of hospital; accessibility to healthcare; quality of
environments; patients' itineraries; social rights; reception spaces waiting rooms;
observation and in depth interview
169
O 153
PROMOTION OF NURSING CARE AMONG CANCER PATIENTS
THROUGH APPLICATION OF ELECTRONIC RECORDING SYSTEM
BASED ON NURSING PROCESS: AN ACTION RESEARCH STUDY
Taleghani, F., Torabinejad, S., Naji, H., Rezaee, B., Shahsavari, H., Emami, M.,
Tabakhan, M.
Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Iran
One of the methods that can organize nursing activities systematically with a
common language is nursing process. Since electronic recording system of nursing
care based on nursing process is utilized in some countries, with regard to existing
facilities, application this system was done in Iran. In the first cycle of action
research, research idea discussed by nurses in selected hospital. Then, nursing
process was designed in a software program and the facilities needed were provided.
In the second cycle, the participants’ experiences were measured through focus
group discussion during the project for evaluation the clinical effect of the program
in promotion of nursing care. Data were analyzed by content analysis. Main
emerged themes included: saving time, ease in patients’ information access, holistic
care provision, changing duty oriented nurses to nurses with creative thinking,
change in patients’ attitude toward nurses, conflict between electronic and
traditional care programs, human obstacles in program administration and
operational obstacles in administration of interventions. This program is an efficient
and functional tool, and a guarantee for holistic care provision. It acts as a way to
promote nurses’ knowledge and experiences to develop their judging skills in
description of patients’ problems and caring strategies.
Keywords: cancer patients; nursing process; action research
O 154
CONTINUITY AND CHANGE: LIVING WITH CANCER IN OLD AGE
Teucher, U.
University of Saskatchewan, Canada
“I am the same and yet forever changed” writes Elisabeth Simpson at the end of her
cancer memoir (“Perfection of Hope,” 1999), articulating one of the many paradoxes
170
of life with cancer. It I obviously an experience that is enormously difficult to put
into language: how should the lived experience of suffering, uncertainty, and the
fear of dying be stated? How can we (re)construct a semblance of continuity despite
radical change, despite a self-shattered into pieces? More specifically, how do we do
so when growing old and the continuity of life itself becomes tenuous?
Studies of self in life crises (Charmaz 1993, Chandler et al, 2003) have suggested
life span differences as we negotiate sameness and change in order to make our lives
our own and yet adapt to pervasive change. Building on these studies, our life
history interviews with 20 aging cancer patients, using Interpretive Description
(Thorne 2008), suggest that aging patients anchor their selves in the review of
relations and contexts, creating continuity in the very act of the telling of the
changing time slices of their lives. At the same time, metaphors of transcendence
help to plan for a future that may well be uncertain. Knowledge of these aspects of
self in illness narratives can help health professionals and care-givers improve
personal care for cancer patients.
Keywords: cancer; aging; self; narrative; metaphor
O 155
ENHANCING PSYCHOLOGICAL INTERVENTION IN HOSPITAL
SETTINGS:
A GLIMPSE OF
THE
ITALIAN
PHYSICIANS’
REPRESENTATIONS AND DEMANDS
Tomai, M. 1, Esposito, F. 2, Brancadoro, B. 1
1
2
Department of Dynamic and Clinical Psychology, Sapienza University, Rome, Italy
School of Specialization in Health Psychology, Sapienza University, Rome, Italy
This contribution presents a research aimed at exploring Italian hospital physicians’
knowledge, representation and demand of psychological intervention in hospital
settings. This topic is particularly relevant for the lack of literature both at national
and international level. In a first phase a semi-structured pilot interview was
submitted to a group of twenty hospital physicians differing in gender, age,
professional specialization, hospital and region. From the qualitative data a
questionnaire was developed and administered to a wider sample of hospital
physicians. The content analysis revealed that the prevalent representation is that of
a psychological intervention focused only on the single patient in order to support
them and to contain the emotional distress related to the disease event. Although the
organizational and relational dimensions were perceived as the most critical ones,
171
there was an inability to consider the psychological competence as useful in
fostering organizational functioning of hospital services and in addressing
relationship problems in them.
This contribution intends to launch a reflection on how qualitative research can
improve the comprehension of the demands of psychology in hospital contexts and
on how psychologists can use these insights to co-construct their interventions in a
more contextualized way, enhancing the quality of healthcare services.
Keywords: hospital-services; qualitative health research; physicians representations;
psychological intervention demand
O 156
FOSTERING ORGANIZATIONAL FUNCTIONING OF THERAPEUTIC
COMMUNITIES THOROUGH EVALUATIVE RESEARCH BASED ON
QUALITATIVE RESEARCH METHODS
Torrigiani, C.
DISFOR, Università di Genova, Italy
This research was aimed at evaluating the effectiveness of addiction treatment in the
therapeutic community. This required a pre-agreed definition of what changes
should produce an effective treatment. The plurality of approaches, methods and
tools undertakes to wonder why the treatment is effective or not by identifying the
elements of the process to be related with its degree of effectiveness. The growing
abundance of people with psychiatric or other clinical and health problems,
requiring different approaches, has led to identifying the specific contribution of
socio-educational intervention that characterizes the Community with respect to the
set of inputs that the user can benefit. The work of the Community is located within
a wider path: other actors define objectives, provide inputs, carry out evaluations.
The community treatment is only one part of the pathway and this has led to
evaluate the integration of the Community and the network services. These
cognitive objectives have suggested the adoption of qualitative research methods,
which have proved useful in facilitating organizational learning processes with
positive effects on the functioning of the organization, communication, process
management and evaluation of treatment efficacy in prospect of integration into the
network of services.
Keywords: addiction; treatment efficacy evaluation; organizational functioning
172
O 157
HEALTH PARTNERSHIP BETWEEN HOME AND SCHOOL USING AN
APPROACH OF PARTICIPATORY ACTION RESEARCH
Tossavainen, K., Sormunen, M., Turunen, H., Saaranen, T.
University of Eastern Finland, Finland
This study utilized participatory action research approach with the use of focus
groups and individual interviews (pre-, during, and post-intervention) as data
gathering method from primary school parents, classroom teachers, school health
nurses, and principals. The two-year (2008-2010) intervention study aimed to
increase the knowledge and skills of participants to enable the development of
collaboration between home and school towards health partnership, which is an
ideal format for supporting pupils’ health learning. The paper describes the starting
situation, the intervention process, and the assessment of the process after
intervention. The results present how the successes and challenges were encountered
during the development process and how they were addressed. Furthermore, the
boundary-crossing integration of sectors of health and education in school aged
children’s health learning process is discussed.
Keywords: participatory action research; home-school health partnership; intervention
study
O 158
THE DELIVERY OF A NEW HEALTH SERVICE AND THE PATIENT
MANAGEMENT APPROACH
Tzannis, A., Cantù, C.
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
Growing demand for health care has increased interest in improving the attention on
quality for health services. The quality of health services is founded on patient
satisfaction that requires his/her active role in the care process delivery.
In this context the main aim of this work is to investigate how the introduction of an
innovative service (Acute Pain Service) implies a review of the internal processes
and a new approach to manage the relationship with the patient.
The research is founded on a systematic combination of the continuous interaction
173
between theory and the empirical world.
The research adopted a case study approach as a suitable method for studying the
process of service innovation that characterize Humanitas Mater Domini Hospital
(Castellanza - Italy). The research is founded on an explorative research that implied
several steps 1) participant observation of the service encounters 2) semi-structured
interviews to patients 3) semi structured interviews to nurses, doctors and managers
involved in new service delivery in order to map the different processes (blueprint).
The main results concern the alignment of different health operators’ perspective.
The combining of different maps allowed the emerging of a new patient’s
management approach.
The offering of Acute Pain Service increased the quality of all health services
delivered by the hospital raising the satisfaction of patient’s needs.
Keywords: acute pain service; quality; health care processes; patient satisfaction
O 159
IT’S HOW, NOT WHO OR WHAT: PARENTS’ EXPERIENCES OF
RECEIVING
INFORMATION
FROM
NEWBORN
SCREENING
PROGRAMMES
Ulph, F. 1, Cullinan, T. 2, Qureshi, N. 3, Kai, J. 3
1
University of Manchester, UK
East Staffordshire Clinical Commissioning Group, UK
3
University of Nottingham, UK
2
To examine parents’ experiences of receiving carrier results for their child via
newborn screening.
Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 67 family members across all
health regions in England. Data generation and analysis were informed by grounded
theory methodology, utilizing cyclical data generation and analysis, theoretical
sampling and constant comparison analysis. Member checking was conducted with
one third of the sample.
Parents viewed their child’s carrier result as valuable information and were capable
of understanding the implications for their child. Of note, anxiety or distress were
caused by communication processes, rather than the results per se, particularly if
parents were left in an information vacuum. Parents were clear about how an
efficient service could meet their needs, with access to well informed health
professionals who could answer their queries in a timely manner sought. They had
174
no preference for type of health professional communicating results to them.
The first completely qualitative study to be funded and published by the NIHR-HTA
program, this work highlights some issues of how services are developed and
academic debates focused. The findings have helped to provide timely guidance on
how best to support parents in receipt of carrier information.
Keywords: user
communication
experience;
knowledge
transfer
and
construction;
health
GIVING OR RECEIVING A LIVE KIDNEY DONATION:
EXPERIENCE OF FIVE DONOR-RECIPIENT DYADS
THE
O 160
Ummel, D., Achille, M.
Université de Montréal, Canada
Living kidney donation (LKD) is currently being promoted and practiced in all
western countries despite the fact that some studies have found it to be related to
major psychological challenges. The goal of the current study is to describe the
experience of giving or receiving a kidney by examining the donor and the recipient
as an interactive dyad. Five dyads (five donors and five recipients) were interviewed
individually. The dyads included were diversified in terms of the type of relationship
between the donor and the recipient, and the time elapsed since donation. Data was
analyzed following the principles of Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis
(Smith, 2009).
Results obtained from the analysis of five donor-recipient dyads will be presented in
two ways: 1) intra-case analysis will visually detail the specific interactive trajectory
of each dyad, and 2) transversal analysis will present the main common themes
found across dyads. Anticipated results will provide in-depth information that can be
shared with future donor and recipient candidates about the possible effects of LKD.
In turn, our results can serve to promote individuals’ psychological health and wellbeing in the context of chronic kidney disease.
Keywords: living kidney
phenomenological analysis
donation;
psychological
adaptation;
interpretative
175
O 161
VISUALIZING
MEANING-OF-LIFE
NARRATIVES:
NARRATIVES FOR QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
VISUAL
Urata, Y. 1, Yamada, Y. 1, Ieshima, A. 2
1
2
Kyoto University, Japan
Shimane University, Japan
The aim of this study was to develop a new methodology to transform narratives
about the meaning of life into a visual model. Thus, three models were constructed:
Framework (Model I), Element (Model II), and Composition (Model III). Model I
was a theoretical framework model based on philosophical, anthropological, and
psychological theories. Model II was constructed using categorized data on the
meaning of life drawn from various previous studies. Model III was constructed by
integrating Models I and II. These models proposed four fundamental principles
underlying meaning of life concepts: personal, relational, social/universal, and
religious/spiritual. These principles formed a “nested” structure that unfolded from
personal to relational to social/universal to religious/spiritual. Using Model III,
narratives of eminent people and participants’ beliefs about the meaning of life were
transformed into Model III network illustrations. Based on the illustrations, the
sources, breadth, and depth of meaning of those narratives were assessed by
combining a qualitative and quantitative approach. This visual narrative approach
seemed to be helpful for research and clinical assessment of a parson’s view of life.
Keywords: meaning of life; narrative; visual model
O 162
"IT'S HARD WORK!" FAMILY MEMBERS' AND CRITICAL ILLNESS
Vandall-Walker, V. 1, Clark, A. 2
1
2
Athabasca University, Canada
University of Alberta, Canada
Critical illness can be hard work for an ill relative's family members. The objective
of this study was to investigate what constitutes this work.
The phenomenon of family work revealed during a grounded theory study with ICU
family members (blinded) was explored in more depth during a subsequent, related
176
study. Data consisted of 42 interviews with 35 family members. Following analysis
the grounded theory of Working To Get Through was revealed (blinded).
The first phase included the Work of Gaining Access, pivotal to meeting family
members' overarching NEED to be at the bedside. With access, they engage in
concurrent Patient-related, Nurse/Physician-related, and Self-care-related Work, to
access information, reassurance, respect, respite, and opportunities for partnering in
care provision. Their needs and the work to meet them are influenced most by the
intensity of their relationship to the ill relative, by their personal resources, and by
the level of professional support received.
This grounded theory of Working To Get Through challenges traditional
paternalistic perceptions of family members' experiences that focus on crisis, stress,
and burden. Appreciating the nature and intent of this work can help health
professionals effectively support family members meet their own needs.
Keywords: family work; critical illness; burden; ICU; CCU
O 163
NURSING SUPPORT WITH FAMILY MEMBERS OF CRITICALLY ILL
CARDIAC PATIENTS
Vandall-Walker, V. 1, Clark, A. 2
1
2
Athabasca University, Canada
University of Alberta, Canada
Previously, the theory of LIGHTENING OUR LOAD was proposed to explain the
activities and behaviours engaged in by nurses to support family members of
critically ill relatives (blinded). The purpose of this second study was to extend the
findings related to ICU family members so as to encompass the perspective of
family members of critically ill cardiac patients as well.
Grounded theory informed recruitment, data collection, and analysis. Seventeen
family members representing 15 families recruited from three hospitals in one
Western Canadian city were interviewed.
Previous findings regarding ICU family members' work, interpreted as being
analogous to "carrying a heavy load", and regarding nursing support being about
LIGHTENING OUR LOAD, are supported and extended. The three interconnected,
recursive phases of Engaging With Us, Sustaining Us, and Disengaging From Us,
each including subcategories, were reconfirmed and further refined. Differences
between the experiences of the two samples were related to the degree of support
177
perceived.
The explanatory power of the grounded theory of LIGHTENING OUR LOAD is
now extended to include family members of adult critically ill cardiac patients. This
comprehensive health promotion theory provides guidance to critical care
practitioners in their interventions with family members.
Keywords: nursing support; ICU; CCU; family; critical care
O 164
THE PATIENT SATISFACTION OF GENERAL PRACTITIONERS: A
THEORETICAL MODEL BASED ON THE EXPERIENCE OF
SATISFACTION AND DISSATISFACTION
Velasco, V., Miglioretti, M., Strada, M., Vecchio, L.
Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca, Italy
The study focuses on patient satisfaction of general practitioners (GPs) and, in
particular, on the process and criteria used by patient to pass judgment about their
health experience. The objective was to identify the determinants of patient
satisfaction in this field and to develop a theoretical model. Both GPs (n=24) and
their patients (n=48, 2 for each physician) were interviewed. The GP’s interview
focused on organizational characteristics of their office and work and on the factors
that can influence the patient satisfaction or dissatisfaction. The patient’s interview
focused on their experience and expectations regarding the GP. The transcriptions of
the interview were analyzed according to the grounded theory approach, using the
software N-vivo. We developed a theoretical model that relates 6 factors that can
influence patients’ satisfaction – office organization, external factors, practitionerpatient relationship, dialogue and listening, physician expertise and physician
personal characteristics – and 6 about their dissatisfaction – waiting times, human
factors, meeting and its organizational aspects, physician behaviour, external factors,
practitioner-patient relationship. The theoretical model can be useful to develop a
methodology and an instrument to assess patient satisfaction of GP in order to
monitor the services, to compare different organizational solutions and to redesign
the primary health service.
Keywords: patient satisfaction; patient experience; primary health service
178
O 165
SELF-PERCEPTIONS OF WELL-BEING IN PROFESSIONAL HELPERS
AND VOLUNTEERS OPERATING IN WAR CONTEXTS
Veronese, G., Castiglioni, M.
Department of Human Sciences, University of Milano-Bicocca, Italy
We carried out qualitative research with 61 health professionals and volunteer
workers to explore their perceptions of both their own and their clients’ well-being
in a context of political and military violence, namely the West Bank in the
Occupied Palestinian Territories. We conducted eight focus group discussions and
eleven individual interviews, asking participants to define and discuss in a
naturalistic manner the concept of well-being and its main components. We then
applied content analysis to identify the core themes emerging from these sessions.
Participants were answered to define and describe the concept of well-being in terms
of three key areas, namely security, participation and development; each of these
areas broke down into further sub-themes at individual, micro- and macro-social
levels. Palestinian health providers see promotion of economic development and
professional growth, involvement in political and social life, and resistance to the
occupation as the main factors required to enhance wellbeing and quality of life for
both themselves and their clients.
Keywords: wellbeing; quality of life; helpers; military violence; war
O 166
FEMALE INDIGENOUS AGRICULTURAL WORKERS’ EXPERIENCE
WITH HEALTHCARE SERVICES IN NORTHWESTERN MEXICO
von Glascoe, C. 1, Camarena-Ojinaga, L. 2, Arellano-García, E. 2, Martínez-Valdés,
C. 2
1
2
El Colegio de la Frontera Norte, Mexico
Universidad Autonoma de Baja California, Mexico
The aim of this work is to document the experiences of indigenous female migrant
workers with the healthcare system in an agricultural region of northwestern
Mexico. Information was collected over a two-year period using various qualitative
techniques such as non-participant observation, participative workshops and in-
179
depth interviews. Approximately 100 migrant indigenous women took part in the
study, all of whom were agricultural field workers. The participants indicate an
alarming deterioration of sanitary conditions in their communities and an
insufficient number of doctors and health centers; the health centers that exist have
inadequate equipment, insufficient stocks of medicines and lack medical specialists;
these women also mention a need for translators in the clinics. They report an
absence of timely and quality medical attention and detect discrimination in their
interactions with clinic staff. Female indigenous migrant agricultural workers are an
understudied group that suffers great social disparities, having historically been
discriminated against as indigenous females, affected by poverty that translates to
fewer opportunities for access to education, healthcare and general levels of
wellness. Although these communities have basic healthcare facilities, the services
continue to be inadequate and do not satisfy the needs of this growing population.
Keywords: female indigenous agricultural workers; Mexican healthcare system; quality
of healthcare
O 167
THE IMPLEMENTATION OF BEDSIDE HANDOVER IN AN ITALIAN
CARDIAC INTENSIVE CARE UNIT FOR PATIENT EMPOWERMENT
AND IMPROVEMENT OF NURSING QUALITY
Wildner, J.
Azienda Ospedaliera ASMN, Istituto di Ricovero e Cura a Carattere Scientifico, Italy
The purpose of the handover is to transfer responsibility from one nursing shift to
the other, providing precise details of the patients’ state of health and current
physical condition. The bedside handover system will improve safety, efficiency and
team-work.
Action Research. Lewin’s theory of change is widely used in studies concerned with
the implementation of bedside handovers.
Population: 40 nurses, about 600 patients during 1 year of implementation.
We already started with meetings of a focus group and created a project team. A
questionnaire will be distributed to all of the nurses before and during the testing.
An anonymous questionnaire on satisfaction will be administered to patients.
Bedside reporting provides nurses with an opportunity to improve nursing quality
and patient safety. The bedside handover reassures patients that the nursing staff are
working as a team and they are able to witness a safe, professional transfer of
180
responsibilities. Including patients in the handover is another strategy to promote
patient-centred care. The results will conform many other studies in the general
appreciation of the method by patients, an appreciation which is identifiable in all
research irrespective of the country, language or health care structure, organisation
or context concerned.
Keywords: bedside handover; patient-centred care; empowerment
O 168
USE OF FOCUS GROUPS IN IDENTIFYING BARRIERS
UTILIZATION OF HEALTH CARE SYSTEM IN THE U.S.
TO
Willougby, L. 1, Matsuo, H. 1, Brown, C. 2, Gao, M. 1, Tomazic, T. 1
1
2
Saint Louis University, USA
Agness Scott College, USA
Researchers have studied health disparity among different racial groups in order to
address and redress the inequalities that pose challenges to health care providers and
policy makers. The increasing number of immigrants, who represent diverse cultural
backgrounds and expectations, creates further challenges in improving the system.
The number of older immigrants in the U.S. is at an all time high and the lack of
evidence based research poses serious challenges in improving access to health care
system among immigrants. This community-based gerontological study explored
barriers to health care delivery system using a sample of older immigrants (65 and
older) from Bosnia and China. These two groups represent distinct differences in
their entry to the U.S., racial and religious backgrounds, and length in the U.S. Data
were also collected from U.S.-born older adults in order to compare differences
between immigrants and the latter group. While focus group data revealed some
common themes among three groups, there were many distinct differences between
immigrant and U.S-born older adults. The study provides some suggestions to health
care providers and community leaders who assist older immigrants with their health
care needs.
Keywords: utilization of health care system; older immigrants; community-based
gerontological study; focus groups
181
O 169
PATIENT PERSPECTIVES OF CO-LEARNING WITH PRIMARY CARE
TEAMS
Worswick, L. 1, Little, C. 1, Ryan, K. 2, Carr, E. 3
1
Bournemouth University, UK
La Trobe University, Australia
3
University of Calgary, Canada
2
Learning experiences which involve health service users may benefit health care
professionals but little is known about the experience from their perspective.
This study explored the experiences of health service users (HSU) who participated
in an interprofessional educational co-learning initiative (Learning to Improve the
Management of Back Pain in the Community (LIMBIC) HYPERLINK
"http://www.limbic.org.uk" www.limbic.org.uk) with primary care teams
implementing quality improvements in practice. Using a case study/qualitative
approach, two types of data were collected.
1. Eleven semi-structured interviews with HSU about their experience of being
involved in the LIMBIC project. Transcripts were analysed thematically.
2. Document and thematic analyses of secondary data from the LIMBIC project
which included film, focus group transcripts, patient stories, emails, meeting notes.
Three broad themes were identified; belonging to a community, communication and
influencing change. Belong to a community captured a sense of participating in an
equal partnership, patients felt valued and embraced leadership roles whilst health
care professionals benefitted by learning from their patients in an open and honest
environment.
Patients and healthcare professionals can learn together to generate better
understanding and create changes which impact on professional and patient
behaviour.
Keywords: co-learner; health service user; interprofessional education
182
O 170
GENERATING A WOMEN-CENTRED HEALTH INTERVENTION FOR
ABUSE SURVIVORS FROM A GROUNDED THEORY OF FAMILY
HEALTH PROMOTION AFTER LEAVING AN ABUSIVE PARTNER:
LESSONS LEARNED
Wuest, J. 1, Merritt-Gray, M. 1, Ford-Gilboe, M. 2, Varcoe, C. 3
1
Faculty of Nursing, University of New Brunswick, Canada
Arthur Labatt School of Nursing, University of Western Ontario, Canada
3
School of Nursing, University of British Columbia, Canada
2
The aim of this work is to outline the translation of a grounded theory (GT) into a
clinical intervention using theoretical sensitivity, theoretical sampling, constant
comparison, modification, and emergent fit. GTs explain human behavior in specific
contexts, and can help people rethink situated phenomena. Moving beyond
conceptual utilization to action requires purposeful translation. The GT
strengthening capacity to limit intrusion captures the naturally occurring actions
taken by women to promote family health after leaving abusive partners. While the
theory directs clinicians to draw upon and augment women’s expert knowledge in
helping them to promote their health, it does not explain the “how to” needed for
clinical application. Informed by our theoretical sensitivity, we used theoretical
sampling, constant comparative analysis and emergent fit between the theory and
extant knowledge and/or expert practice to develop and examine the feasibility of
the Intervention for Health Enhancement after Leaving. We will discuss the
challenges and outcomes of using GT techniques to modify the theory for
application and detail the theory-based components and practice principles, and how
analysis of data from feasibility studies leads to refining both the intervention and
the theory. Despite the current emphasis on knowledge translation, and the belief
that GTs are starting points for change, little is written about how to effect such
translation or the outcomes of such practice application.
Keywords: grounded theory; knowledge translation; intervention; intimate partner
violence
183
O 171
IRANIAN NURSING STUDENTS’ AND TEACHERS’ PERCEPTION OF
STUDENT-TEACHER RELATIONSHIP IN CLINICAL NURSING
EDUCATION
Yaghoubinia, F., Heydari, A., Latifnejad Roudsari, R.
School of Nursing & Midwifery, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Nowadays, student- teacher relationship in clinical settings is different from the past
due to changing in nursing education paradigm and its emphasis on the centrality of
the student- teacher relationship. So understanding this relationship in humanistic
paradigms from the perspective of teachers and students is a vital requirement. This
study was conducted to explore the perception of Iranian nursing students’ and
teachers’ in relation to student–teacher relationship in clinical nursing education.
This study is a part of findings of a grounded theory study in which eight BSc
nursing students and ten clinical nursing teachers, who were teaching in Mashhad
Nursing and Midwifery School, (Iran), were selected by purposeful sampling. Data
were collected through in-depth semi-structured interviews. Data analysis was
carried out by Strauss and Corbin method. Data analysis identified three major
themes about perception of relationship in clinical nursing education including 1)
Multidimensional nature of relationship (dimensions related to teacher and student,
dimensions related to relationship itself), 2) Ideal relationship (relationship resultant,
relationship characteristics, relationship skills and 3) Effectiveness of nonverbal
relationship (behaviors and appearance). The perception of Iranian nursing students
and teachers regarding relationship in clinical nursing education seems different in
some cases from other countries in terms of relationship nature and its attributes and
because of such differences, relationship concept should be viewed from their points
of view based on Iranian culture.
Keywords: student teacher relationship; clinical nursing education; perception;
grounded theory
184
O 172
IMAGE
DRAWING
METHOD
ABOUT
MOTHER-CHILD
RELATIONSHIPS: VISUAL NARRATIVES FOR QUALITATIVE
RESEARCH
Yamada, Y. 1, Ieshima, A. 2, Urata, Y. 1
1
2
Kyoto University, Japan
Shimane University, Japan
We propose a “visual turn” in narrative theory, which offers a new method for
qualitative study. The image drawing method (IDM) was designed to transform
invisible worlds into visible worlds across different cultural contexts. We introduce
a study that used IDM, entitled “Visual Images of Mother-Child relationships”. This
study had two purposes. First, it examined how young adults represent themselves
and their relationships with their mothers. Second, it compared the patterns
characterizing these relationships with those in drawings of Japanese, British, and
American university students. Visual narratives about the three types of drawings
(past, present, and future relationships) were collected from 491 Japanese, 117
British, and 295 American university students. The following nine fundamental
relationship patterns were observed: (1) wrapping, (2) supporting, (3) looking after,
(4) siding, (5) facing, (6) separating, (7) leading, (8) giving, and (9) punishing.
Despite the diversity of cultural contexts, fundamental patterns were common
among these young adults. These patterns were qualitatively represented not as
classification categories for counting quantitatively but as “knots” of a visual
network model.
Keywords: methodology; visual narrative; life story
O 173
TENSIONS BETWEEN ANCIENT AND PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE IN
THE FORMS AND SENSES OF ELDERS CARE
Yuni, J., Urbano, C.A.
Facultad de Humanidades-Argentina, Universidad Nacional de Catamarca, Argentina
Providing care for the elderly is a challenge for health policy worldwide. In
emerging countries, the public policy responses to population aging and the frailty
185
of the elderly, is the training of formal caregivers. This situation demands
addressing the relationship between social and community practices, which have
historically given meaning to the task of caring, and also new professional practices.
Thus, long-standing and culturally situated social and community practices confront
with technical and scientific knowledge. In this interaction there come into play
socio-cultural and identity aspects, which redefine the meanings assigned to the task
of caring, which unbalance the institutions, families and health care subjects.
In order to explore this process an action- research was conducted in the northwest
region in Argentina (Catamarca). 59 interviews were done to reputed members of
the communities, and were also implemented 15 community participatory scenarios.
Through this participatory approach a training model was built for: a) optimize
social support systems for families and groups of frail older adults, and b) recover
the values of solidarity groups of older people facing biopsychosocial forms of
helplessness.
Keywords: caring; frail elderly; caregivers training
O 174
THE HEALTH RELATIONSHIP IN THE CONTEXT OF GENETIC
COUNSELING: THE COMMUNICATION OF RISK AND DECISIONMAKING PROCESSES
Zaccaro, A. 1, Freda, M.F. 2, Politano, L. 1
1
Cardiomyology and Medical Genetics, Second University of Naples, Italy
Department of Theory and Method of Human and Social Sciences, University of Naples
“Federico II”, Italy
2
The prenatal or preconception genetic counseling may represent a key step for those
who cope with reproductive choices in genetic risk situations (Kessler, 1997;
Uhlmann, Schuette and Yashar, 2009; Freda, Zaccaro, Gleijeses and Politano,
2010). Over the last four decades, advances in genetic knowledge and the
opportunities for geneticist to learn about their genetic risk have led to renegotiate
notions, such as health and illness and, specifically, the conception of life and
procreation which have several implications in ethical issues and in clinical practice.
The current investigation focuses on ultimate experience of genetic counselling in
prenatal or preconception setting. The aim is to explore the processes of significance
about the consequences of communication of risk within one month to the end of
genetic counseling intervention in order to hypothesize research-intervention
projects which involve medical and psychological profession in a joint setting.
186
Participants are all attending Cardiomyology and Medical Genetics counseling in
Naples (Italy) for the first time. Transcripts of 18 semi-structured interviews were
conducted and then analysed by Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (Smith,
2004; Smith, Flowers and Larkin, 2009).
Through this approach, three super-ordinate themes were identified: the familiar
outcomes of genetic counselling; the representation of risk and the vicissitudes of
decision-making. In prenatal and reproductive scenarios, we hypothesize the sole
choice to request genetic counseling can have several consequences on family and
inter-/intra-generational ties. In such context, the counselor’s task is to introduce the
information as a new source of sense-making and to accompany the use of this
information so that the proband’s personal sense of control became more powerful,
in managing the decision-making processes. In our opinion, the psychological
function can play a central role in an integrated perspective with the medical
function. As discussed in other articles (Zaccaro and Freda, 2011; 2012), we wish
that the psychologist could take part in the whole temporal context of the process of
genetic counseling (pre-test, test, post-test, follow-up) (Laurent, Croupier and Pujol,
2006; Léger, Dauchy and Chompret, 2006) and that, from the pre-counseling step to
the follow-up, could contribute to the achievement of protecting and promoting
health (Bertini, 2004).
Keywords: genetic counseling; health relationship; couple at risk; decision-making; IPA
O 175
PATHWAYS TO TREATMENT FOR HEART DISEASE AND DIABETES:
LESSONS
FROM
AN
EXPLORATORY
STUDY
IN
FOUR
MEDITERRANEAN COUNTRIES
Zaman, S., Phillimore, P.
Newcastle University, UK
This paper is based on a large EU-funded (FP7) mixed method research project
aiming to shape policy initiatives to reduce the burden of cardiovascular diseases
and diabetes in four Mediterranean countries: Syria, Tunisia, Turkey and Palestine.
As part of the project, teams in each place conducted brief exploratory fieldwork
into the health-seeking pathways of patients with these NCDs. Researchers used
various qualitative tools including in-depth interviews and observation in selected
clinics. Together, we investigated topics including the cultural understanding of
these chronic conditions, the experience of patients in the clinic encounter, and
187
conversely the experience of clinic staff with these patients, enabling us to highlight
the scope for mutual misunderstandings between patients and clinic staff. While
recognising the limited scope of this fieldwork, these findings are highly suggestive
in countries where little such research has been attempted before. We show how
policy regarding NCDs is translated into practice in diverse settings and how
treatment is experienced by patients, within a larger framework shaped by history,
culture and politics. And we are not the first to suggest that incorporating
recognition of patients’ experience into policy-making for health interventions
would greatly assist the likelihood of these interventions being tailored to the
circumstances of those they are intended to serve.
Keywords: patient’s treatment pathways; mediterranean countries; health policies; heart
disease and diabetes
188
Posters
P1
HEALTH IN THE EXPERIENCES OF IRANIAN WOMEN WITH
DIABETES
Aghamohammadi, M.
Ardabil University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Health is a key concept of nursing which has not been fully described in nursing
literature. Thus this study is devoted to exploring the meaning of health among
Iranian women with diabetes. Hermeneutic phenomenology based on van Manen′s
approach was used. Nineteen diabetic women referred to the diabetes center of
Imam Khomeini hospital in Ardabil-Iran, were recruited using purposive sampling
method. Unstructured interviews were used for data gathering. Each interview was
recorded with participants’ permission and transcribed verbatim after the meeting
and analyzed simultaneously. Data analysis led into emerging five main themes
which are as follows: God-centered life, health as precious possession, health as
well-being, independence and acceptance. Health is an issue that is important for the
patients and they try to cope with the illness by using spiritual and religious
incentives as well as changing lifestyle. These elements lead to a feeling of more
health in these patients. As a result, taking these factors into account in planning for
health care is recommended for these patients. Moreover, findings of this study can
be used by health care teams to revise their opinions about diabetic patients
according to the culture of their patients.
Keywords: diabetes; health; Iran; phenomenology; women
189
P2
HOW THE STUDENTS TRANSFER FROM THEORETICAL PHASE TO
PRACTICAL IN CLINICAL SKILLS CENTERS: A QUALITATIVE STUDY
Alimohammadi, H., Tazakori, Z., Fouladi, N., Azarkolah, A.
Ardebli University of medical sciences, Iran
One of medical studying characteristics is necessity of learning practical skills
besides knowledge and theoretical fields. This medical knowledge characteristic has
resulted in that students with their professors learn and practice the medical skills
practically in hospitals. In recent decade by being sceptical the learning processes,
importance of values concerned with medical ethics traditional have been doubted
procedures and now, the practical programmers in worldwide have been prepared on
models; and clinical skills centres (CSC) have been established for this reason.
Considering the practical programmers as newly established in the university, and
whereas a CSC needs a flexibility in designing and adjusting learning periods. We
decided to study how to a affect in CSC on transferring the students from theoretical
process to practical process.
This study is a qualitative study which uses content analysis. Data were collected
through aim – oriented sampling. Information was accumulated by semi- structural
interview. In principal the interview was done with 23 (4 teachers, 10 intense, 9
trainees) data was analyzed by coding that was done in two steps: open coding and
axial coding.
Finally, 4 main categories were obtained: effective individual on learning, factors of
decreasing instruction, progression of instruction and results of instruction in CSC
which have effects on transferring process of the students from instructions to
practice.
Results show that effective clinical instruction is a multi– dimension process and
like other programmers it needs an accurate programming and suitable environment
with attending to all dimensions. There is a direct relationship in learning and
obtaining clinical skills with factors such as motivating the students, professor
supervising on learning and obtaining the skills, student's from learning process to
practice is prepared.
Keywords: instruction; CSC workshop; transferring process; clinical capability
190
P3
ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY OF MUTUAL HELP GROUP TO PEOPLE
WITH PARKINSON'S DISEASE AND THEIR FAMILIES
Alvarez, A.1, Goncalves, L.2, Sena, E.3
1
UFSC - Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Brazil
UFPA - Universidade Federal do Pará, Brazil
3
UESB - Universidade Estadual do Sudoeste da Bahia, Brazil
2
Study of multicentric and convergent-assistance type that aimed to adapt and test an
assistive technology of mutual help group for people with Parkinson's disease and
their families, in two distinct geographic and cultural contexts of Brazil. One city in
the Northeast and another one in the South of the country. Such technology
exclusively expresses the live work and actions of mutual help that occur in the
group meetings, with a focus on social inclusion/reinclusion and expansion of the
relations network as a potential social support to the parkinsonian patients.
According to the adopted research type, its implementation took place in two stages:
first, it was initially settled the Mutual Help Group (MHG) in both contexts, in order
to invite people with Parkinson's disease and their families to participate assiduously
at the meetings. It took one semester of preparation to the installation of research
locus. Among the participants, 14 from each context comprised the study sample
after accepting and signing a free and clear agreement, according to the ethical care
precepts. Technology adaptations were based on the peculiar characteristics related
to each cultural context. They were successively tested, rectified and evaluated over
the two semesters. In a general way, MHG fortnightly meetings used to begin with
integration and relaxation activities, music and body movements, in order to
motivate the participants for the next moment, in which they used to socialize daily
experiences about coping with the disease, encouraging the exchange from personal
and family experiences that would be shaping up with help and support. The
meeting used to finish by encouraging contacts between them, strengthening ties of
affection and mutual help. The technology tested for mutual help of parkinsonians
contributed to maintain or expand relations network, potential social support to
favor the patients inclusion. That was assessed by comparing the application, pre
and post testing, from Sluski’s Relations Minimum Map. The adopted approach of
research-action type, lasting relation among researchers, parkinsonian patients and
their families, in the process of adaptation and testing of such assistive technology,
has contributed to this study success, and certainly, it is an appropriate method for
researches looking for beneficial interventions to the people with prolonged
chronicity.
191
Keywords: Parkinson disease; self-help group; assistive technology; coping; chronical
disease
P4
THE MATERNAL PERSPECTIVE
QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
OF
KANGAROO
CARE:
A
Arzani, A.
Health Ministry, Iran
Objective: having a premature infants hospitalized in the neonatal intensive care unit
is an unexpected and traumatic event. A major nursing challenge in this situation is
supporting mothers in the intensive, technology-driven environment by emerging
physiological care of the infant with meaningful mother-infant interaction involving
touch, communication and intervention such as kangaroo mother care.
The purpose of this study is to describe the maternal perspective of kangaroo care.
Design: qualitative, naturalistic inquiry design using open-ended, transcribed audio
taped face-to-face interviews. Coding used content analysis with construction of
themes by 3 researchers.
Setting: tertiary level neonatal intensive care unit in Babol, Iran, in 2010.
Participants: in-depth interviews were conducted with eight mothers by using
purposive sampling who done kangaroo care for their premature infants.
Results: the four themes that emerged are described as: calmness, feeling of
becoming a mother, decrease mother stress, self – satisfied, gaining confidence.
Also mothers reported that this method improve maternal confidence in caring for
premature infants.
Conclusions: results identified, engaged mothering indicated an active, involved,
and mutual process of preparation for motherhood through kangaroo care for
themselves and their infants. Understanding these views helps the health care team
offer targeted intervention & support for mothers.
Keywords: kangaroo mother care; premature infant; neonatal intensive care unit
192
P5
BRINGING THE PATIENTS BACK IN! INTEGRATED CARE NETWORKS
AND THE PATIENT PARTICIPATION
Bach, M., Reuter, A
Freie Universität Berlin, Germany
With our poster we want to provide a theoretical framework as a basis for qualitative
approaches in research on patient involvement – focusing on integrated care
networks. To do so, we combine network theory with a Public Health perspective.
Research on the nexus between health networks and patient participation has so far
not received due attention. This is significant because professionals and patients
have to deal with a set of network-specific issues. We want to focus on networkrelated challenges within the German health system. Here network building is seen
as a key innovation for overcoming the sectorally divided health care system. An
improved quality of care delivery through network building is hindered when only
structures are integrated but professional practice remains in old patterns. As one
result the traditional paternalistic relationships between professionals and patients
prevail and patient participation hardly happens. From this perspective, our key
concern is to discuss some of the essential features networks should possess in order
to enable patient participation. Starting with the German case, we also take into
account good practices from Canada, the UK and the Switzerland.
Keywords: network building; patient participation; professional practice; integrated care
P6
CONCEPTUALIZING PATIENT ENGAGEMENT IN HEALTHCARE: A
THEMATIC SOFTWARE-BASED ANALYSIS
Barello, S. 1, Vegni, E.2, Graffigna, G.1
1
2
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
Università degli Studi di Milano, Italy
Engaging patients in their own healthcare is now widely acknowledged as a critical
ingredient for high-performance health system as it may improve quality of care,
health outcomes and patient satisfaction. Within the health research field, patient
engagement is receiving increasing attention as it reflects the collective aspiration to
193
build a health care system able to make patients and families active participant and
co-producer of their health. Despite the growing popularity of the term “patient
engagement” (PE), few authors have attempted to define this concept. As a
consequence, the term PE remains conceptually and empirically undeveloped. The
aim of this study is twofold: (1) to explore the main dimensions associated with
“patient engagement” in the health academic literature by conducting a qualitative
explorative and systematic content analysis; (2) to highlight the thematic elements
most associated with the word “patient engagement” across different health
disciplines (medicine, nursing, psychology, social science…). The key-word
“patient engagement” was searched on May 11st, 2012 using the databases more
likely to cover the core research publication in health issues (SCOPUS, PUBMED,
PsychINFO), within the peer-reviewed literature in the years 2000-2012. A study
was eligible for inclusion in the analysis if it describes (a) PE generally, (b)
intervention to promote PE, (c) determinants of PE or (d) outcomes of PE and (e)
measures of PE. T-lab software-based content analysis (Thematic Analysis of
Elementary Context, Word Association Analysis and Correspondence Analysis)
were performed on titles, abstract and key-words of the selected studies. Out of 216
studies, 155 were consistent with the eligibility criteria. The result of the analysis
has highlighted that the concept of patient engagement is indeed extremely complex,
multifaceted and dynamic in its nature thus suggesting the need to assemble a
comprehensive theoretical framework and to develop reliable and valid measures for
assessing the full range of dimensions that may be implicated in such engagement.
Moreover, the study highlighted distinct attitudes towards the concept of patient
engagement within different health disciplines thus showing an urgent call for a
deeper understanding of patient engagement in order to contribute to hard
knowledge development useful both for clinical practice and health policies
orientation.
Keywords: patient engagement, review; thematic analysis, T-Lab software
P7
PHYSICAL COMORBIDITY IN PSYCHIATRIC PATIENTS: THE
OPINION OF PATIENTS AND MENTAL HEALTH PROFESSIONALS OF
THE COMMUNITY PSYCHIATRIC SERVICE (CPS) OF VERONA-SUD
Bonfioli, E., Berti, L., Fiorini, I., Burti, L.
University of Verona, Italy
In the context of HELPS (European Network for Promoting the Health of Residents
194
in Psychiatric and Social Care Facilities; Contract No.: 2006334, 2008–2010) we
carried out focus groups to gather information on how staff members and psychiatric
institutions users perceive physical health risk factors, illnesses and symptoms, and
prevention possibilities.
We carried out 4 focus groups with patients and mental health professionals of the
Verona-Sud CPS using the following research questions:
1. What kind of physical illnesses/somatic symptoms have you experienced/have
your patients experienced?
2. In your view, what causes or conditions lead to such physical illnesses/somatic
symptoms?
3. What can be done to improve your/your patients physical health?
Transcripts of the findings were analyzed with MaxQDA software. Health problems
most often experienced by patients are neurological, musculoskeletal,
cardiovascular, metabolic, and overweight problems. Psychopathology, personal
beliefs, lack of medical care and prevention, diet and medication side effects are
among the most common causes. Prevention measures suggested are further medical
advice and lifestyle interventions. Focus groups identified behavioural,
environmental and iatrogenic risks. Efforts must be directed towards health
promotion interventions based on the heterogeneity of mental disorders and physical
problems and on beliefs and life conditions of psychiatric facilities users.
Keywords: psychiatric patients; comorbidity; physical health; focus groups
P8
SOCIAL THEATRE, MENTAL DISEASE AND INCLUSION. ANALYSIS OF
AN EXPERIENCE IN TUSCANY
Bosco, N.1, Petrini, F.1, Giaccherini, S.2, Meringolo, P.1
1
2
Department of Psychology, University of Florence, Italy
Public Mental Health Service Tuscany, Italy
People with mental illness often face with stigma in local communities. Spreading
knowledge about this disease may positively influence social attitudes and reduce
prejudice and discrimination. Perceived stigma stand in the way of opportunities and
relationships for people with mental illnesses and may interfere with perceived
social support. Empowering activities may work, on the contrary, to promote social
inclusion. Theatre may be an useful instrument to encourage expression and
195
communication of emotions, and so improve a better inclusion of patients with
mental disorders. Theatre Project may promote socialization, building network
between Public Mental Health Service (PMHS) and local community. Aim: this
study explores motivations of mental patients to participate in playing theatre and
opinions of professionals and citizens in order to analyze changes in wellbeing
leaded by these interventions. Participants: actors, relatives, professionals, audience
(24 interviews and 1 focus group). Method: semi structured interviews, audio-taped
and transcribed, about motivation in participating, difficulties, perceived changes.
Data analysis was based on qualitative method (software Atlas.ti). Results have
highlighted perceptions about: well-being and capabilities (particularly in actors
who are patients of PMHS, and in audience); importance of experience for
enhancing empowerment, promoting health, building social networks and improving
inclusion.
Keywords: social theatre; mental health; mental disease; inclusion; public health
service; qualitative research
P9
STRESS, HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE AND SOMATOFORM
DISORDERS: AN EXPLORATIVE STUDY IN A UNIVERSITY STUDENTS
GROUP
Carpinelli, L., Savarese, G., Marsico, G., Boccia, G., Cavallo, P.
Department of Human, Philosophic and Education Sciences–DISUFF, University of
Salerno, Italy
The mental health of university students is an area of increasing concern worldwide.
The objective of this study is to examine the prevalence of bruxism (uncontrolled
teeth grinding), stress vulnerability and Health-Related Quality of Life (HRQoL) in
a group of students of the University of Salerno, Italy.
A questionnaire was used to obtain background characteristics of the participants
and the prevalence of bruxism. The questionnaire was completed anonymously by
274 students (57.3% F; mean age F=24.9, M=24.3) and included personal data,
measures of perceived stress and vulnerability, with PSS-14 and Stress Vulnerability
Scale (SVS), and HRQoL measure, performed by EuroQoL EQ-5D.
Bruxism was found in 10.6% of all subjects, and was either correlated with
perceived stress and with vulnerability (p=.0198 and.0334). There was significantly
higher score for the “tension” factor of the SVS scale (p=.0029), and worse HRQoL
196
in students with bruxism (p=.0208). The relevant findings of high prevalence of
stress and low HRQoL among university students are alarming. These indicate the
need for primary and secondary prevention measures, with the development of
adequate and appropriate monitoring activities and individual support activities,
such as a Psychological Counseling Service for students.
Keywords: university student; stress; Health-Related Quality of Life; Stress
Vulnerability Scale (SVS); Perceived Stress Score (PSS-14); bruxism; EuroQoL EQ-5D
P 10
DEPRESSIVE FEELINGS CAPTURED IN TWITTER
Cha, C.1, Cha, M.2
1
2
Ewha Womans University, Korea
KAIST, Korea
The purpose of this study was to explore the depressive feelings expressed in
Twitter.
The Twitter Application Programming Interface (API) was used to obtain the tweets
which included the word “depression” over a five-month period between March and
July, 2009. Twenty five hundred tweets (500 per month) were randomly selected for
data analysis. Two researchers read the tweets and coded them independently with
the guidance of previously established categories developed for this project.
Through regular meetings, codes were finalized. Depressive feelings posted on
Twitter were classified into three categories: (a) my depressive feelings, which
described one’s personal depression, (b) other’s depressive feelings, which were
mentions of others’ depression, and (c) thoughts related to depression, which
contained tweets about one’s perception and attitudes towards depression. Twitter
users were not shy about disclosing their and others’ depressive feelings and posting
their perceived meaning of depression. This indicates that Twitter might be used as a
channel to communicate with the hard to reach population who withdraw from
society to deliver health information. The limitation of this study was that possible
indicators of Twitter user’s influence, such as the number of followers or retweets of
the data, were not considered.
Keywords: depression; depressive feelings; social network service
197
P 11
IDENTIFICATION OF FAMILY CAREGIVER NEEDS OF PATIENTS
WITH BIPOLAR DISORDER
Cheraghi, F., Shamsaei, F.
Medical Science of Hamadan, Iran
Nowadays, families of individuals with bipolar disorders are actively participating in
the care of their relative. Successful management of bipolar disorder in the
community relies significantly on family caregivers. The need and experiences of
such caregivers have been little studies with respect to bipolar disorder.
The aim of the study was to identify family caregivers needs of patients with bipolar
disorder. In a qualitative research of phenomenological methodology, the family
member's caregivers of bipolar disorder in farshian psychiatric hospital in Hamedanl
were selected by purposive sampling in the year 2010. By reaching data saturation
the number of participant was 12. Data were gathered through in-depth interviews
and analyzed by "van Manen" method. Five main themes were identified in this
study analysis: educational needs, consult needs, economical needs, care and nursing
needs and supports needs. This study highlighted the importance of identifying the
need of family member caregiver with bipolar disorder users of mental health
services to be helped and to identify the specific caring interventions that are
effective in helping to sustain family caregiving.
Keywords: family caregiver; bipolar disorder; phenomenology
P 12
THE EXPERIENCE OF ELDERLY WITH HEARING AIDS
Chung, S.E.1, Choi, C.H.2
1
2
Korea National University of Transportation, Korea
Sunmoon University, Korea
About half of all people over age 65 have hearing loss. Hearing loss is common in
the elderly and the natural process of the body aging. Aging causes the inside nerves
and the ear cell to die off over a long period of time. In elderly, it is difficult to hear
high-frequency sounds. Hearing aids is useful to amplify sound. However, many
elderly avoid wearing it. Although the elderly decided to wear hearing aids, some of
198
them resisted the use of it within one month. It is important for the elderly to
understand their experience of the use of hearing aids. We interviewed 9 elderly
who wear hearing aids without specific ear diseases. We then analyzed data by
qualitative thematic analysis. Data collection and analysis were performed
simultaneously. We found 6 themes: shame in wearing it, discomfort during the
wearing it, difficulty of its operation, distress for unwanted sound, worry about
falling it out while they are out, and participating actively in conversations. It is
significant for health professionals to have negative feelings of hearing aids in
elderly. These findings highlight the need for identifying appropriate hearing aids
and teaching coping strategies may have a positive impact on their life.
Keywords: aging; elderly; hearing aids; hearing loss
P 13
AN ANALYSIS ON QUALITATIVE
QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
NURSING
RESEARCH
IN
Chung, S.E. 1, Kim, M. 2
1
2
Korea National University of Transportation, Korea
Ewha Womans University, Korea
The Qualitative Research (QR), The Korea Center for Qualitative Methodology and
The Academy of Qualitative Research’s official journal, includes articles that deal
with analysis and description of human endeavors related to health, disease and
welfare, socio-cultural organization systems for health and welfare, health care and
management, welfare policies, and so on. The journal is the one and only qualitative
methodology publication based on multidisciplinary approaches in Korea. First
issued in 2000, the QR has been released twice yearly. It is important, for the future
of nursing, to reflect the trend of qualitative nursing research in the QR. We sort
nursing studies published in the QR for the last twenty years. We then examine these
studies by publication year, types of methods, the number and classification of key
words (according to human, health/disease, nursing, and environment), participants,
data collection and analysis by methodology and/or author, confirmation of
reliability and validity, and research fund. We present the importance and the
shortcomings of nursing research utilizing qualitative research methodologies. We
then suggests various and new concepts and approaches is needed to promote a
further contributions in future nursing research.
Keywords: nursing research; qualitative research; analysis
199
P 14
NURSE MANAGER’S ROLES IN WORK-FAMILY BALANCE
NURSES: FLEXIBILITY AND PRINCIPLE
OF
Chung, S.E. 1, Kim, M. 2
1
2
Korea National University of Transportation, Korea
Ewha Womans University, Korea
Nurse managers are playing pivotal role in fostering the environment for nurses to
maintain work-family balance. This study was to explore how nurse managers are
showing flexibility without undermining principles to help nurses keep work-family
balance. Data were collected from December 2011 to February 2012 through faceto-face interviews with 14 nurse managers, recruited via purposive sampling.
Participants were asked to state their position and opinion about nurse job
scheduling, maternity leave, and working conditions necessary for married nurses to
maintain work-family balance. Data were analyzed by Colaizzi’s method; data
collection and analysis were performed simultaneously. This study found that
‘consideration’, ‘persuasiveness’ and ‘change in perception’ are the elements of
‘flexibility’ needed for nurse managers to ensure work-family balance; and that
‘justice’, ‘deliberate job distribution’ and ‘self-directedness’ are the elements of
‘principle.’ On the other hand, nurse managers who have longer work experience
showed more flexible thinking based on principles like ‘role-modeling’,
‘negotiation’ and ‘harmonization.’ Nurse managers played an important role in
helping nurses maintain work-family balance through flexible yet principle-based
thinking. This study suggested implications to the way nurse managers handle the
nurses’ work-family balance issue in terms of nursing management and practice.
Keywords: family; flexibility; nurse manager; qualitative research; work
P 15
EXPERIENCE OF MOTHER WHO CARE FOR CHILDREN WITH
CANCER
Chung, Y.S.1, Park, S.Y.2, Chung, B.R.2
1
2
Department of Medical Information Technology, Hanny University, Korea
College of Nursing, Kyungpook National University, Korea
The purpose of this qualitative study was to understand the experience of mothers
200
who care for children with cancer.
The participants of the study were 7 mothers of children diagnosed with cancer in
the past 3 to 36 months. Data were gathered through in-depth interview from March
to September 2011, and each session lasted about one and a half hours. Data were
analyzed by Colaizzi’s (1978) phenomenological methodology. As a result, 62
significant statements and 6 themes were identified. The 6 themes included ‘feel my
heart melted’, ‘hard and difficult journey’, ‘feel my dearest kid's pain’, ‘irresistible
sense of dismay’, ‘crossing sense between gratitude and disappointment’, and
‘desire for better future with family’. Mothers who have had children with cancer
have experienced strong emotional fluctuation such as anxiety, uncertainty,
confusion, fear of death as well as hope based on the health status of children during
they are caring. However, they also try to embrace their family to cope with and to
get the future expectation. The results of this study would be support for health
professionals to understand mothers who have a child with cancer and to make
program development for them.
Keywords: mother; experience; children; cancer; qualitative research
P 16
THE IDENTIFICATION OF WORK-RELATED STRESS FACTORS IN AN
ITALIAN HOSPITAL: A QUALITATIVE APPROACH
Cortese, C.G.
Department of Psychology, University of Turin, Italy
The study aims to identify the presence of risk factors of work-related stress in a
large Italian Hospital comprising 53 primary care departments, in which a total of
2,356 employees work.
The research was organized in four main stages.
1) Analysis of the literature, followed by 53 interviews of department managers. A
check-list comprising 42 work-related stress indicators was drawn up, and it was
used in the subsequent stages.
2) Observation carried out using the shadowing technique.
3) Worker focus groups.
4) Questionnaire to a representative sample of workers from each department.
The data analysis, performed with pencil-and-paper methods and with descriptive
statistics, made it possible to assign to each indicator for each department a score
from 0 to 3 (0=risk absent; 1=low; 2=risk; 3=high). In terms of departments, there
201
were 2 whites, 43 greens, 8 yellows and no pinks. In terms of indicators, no whites,
36 greens, 6 yellows and no reds. The qualitative approach made it possible to foster
strong involvement on the part of hospital trust employees, which guarantees the
quality of the data obtained through the research, and facilitates real effectiveness of
intervention measures to be put forward.
Keywords: participatory approach; work-related stress; hospital
P 17
LEADERSHIP AND FOLLOWERSHIP: WHAT PERSPECTIVES FOR
WELL-BEING?
Cortese, C.G., Ghislieri, C., Tartari, M.
Department of Psychology, University of Turin, Italy
The role of followers in the "leadership process" has long been recognized (e.g.,
Hollander, 1992; Shamir, 2007). The interest is extending to the way leaders and
followers may build together a “high quality relationship” that can contribute to
people’s well-being at work (Sparr & Sonnentag, 2008).
This study aims to make an exploratory investigation into the nature of these
phenomena in Italian nursing. The focus is on the distinctive elements of
followership in relation to leadership and possible well-being outcomes.
A qualitative study using individual, in deep, interviews (n = 10) was conducted.
Participants were nurses in an “intermediate” position as “group-coordinators”. All
interviews were digitally recorded and transcribed verbatim. Using Turner’s
Grounded Theory (1983) reformulation, a preliminary content analysis was
performed. People in intermediate position, having to use upward and downward
influence according to the role they have to play at the moment, linked an increase
in their sense of personal well-being to the chances of balancing these roles
dynamically. As a first conclusion, it can be hypothesized that the synergistic
integration of the concepts of “followership” and “leadership” in training programs
may contribute to people’s well-being at work, aiding in organizational functioning
of healthcare services.
Keywords: leadership; followership; well-being; nurses
202
P 18
A PSYCHOLOGICAL PRE-OPERATIVE PROGRAM IN A DEPARTMENT
OF PAEDIATRIC SURGERY: EFFECTS ON PATIENT COOPERATIVE
BEHAVIOUR DURING INDUCTION OF ANAESTHESIA
Cuzzocrea, F., Gugliandolo, M.C., Larcan, R.
University of Messina, Italy
This study wants to evaluate the efficacy of a specific Psychological Pre-operatory
Program in reducing pre-operatory anxiety of pediatric participants and their parents
and in facilitating children’s compliance with surgical procedures.
104 children undergoing surgery and their mothers were assigned to 4 conditions of
treatment, in order to investigate the effectiveness of individual components of the
Psychological Pre-operatory Program, which included “Surgical Puppet Theatre”,
“Playing doctor” and “Accompaniment” by Psychologist. Observed child anxiety
was assessed using the modified Yale Preoperative Anxiety Scale; compliant
behaviors were measured with Induction Compliance Checklist; mothers’ anxiety
was evaluated using the Amsterdam Preoperative Anxiety and Information Scale.
Children in the first condition (Complete program- all the components together)
were significantly less anxious and more cooperative in the preoperative period and
during induction of anesthesia than children in the other three conditions, who
participated only to partial program. Complete psychological program was more
efficient also in reducing mothers’ anxiety. The Psychological program was
effective in reducing children and parents’ anxiety and promoting cooperative
behaviors in pediatric patients and would be a useful tool in pediatric surgical
settings.
Keywords: anxiety; compliance; pediatric surgery; Psychological Preparation Program
203
P 19
A PARTICIPATORY APPROACH TO DEVELOPING PROGRAM
THEORY TO ENABLE ABORIGINAL HEALTH WORKERS TO QUIT
SMOKING
Daniel, M.1, Cargo, M.1, Dawson, A.1, Chong, A.2, Stewart, H.3
1
University of South Australia, Social Epidemiology & Evaluation Research Group,
Australia
2
Charles Darwin University, Menzies School of Health Research, Australia
3
Aboriginal Health Council of South Australia, Australia
Aboriginal Health Workers (AHWs) deliver smoking cessation support to
Aboriginal people in Australia. However, over 50% of AHWs smoke which
undermines their delivery of smoking cessation programs. Conventional “top-down”
tobacco control strategies have been ineffective. Objective: to develop a state-wide
culturally-sensitive program theory for AHWs across South Australia, based on the
experiences of AHWs, health service administrators, and Aboriginal stakeholders in
tobacco control. Research project: social-ecological mixed-method needs
assessment, guided by participatory research principles. Methodology: locally and
culturally-relevant strategies to enable AHWs to quit smoking were derived from the
fundamental qualitative descriptive analysis of 34 qualitative interviews and 3 focus
groups. Strategies were rated on their perceived importance and changeability, using
concept mapping methodology. Stakeholder engagement included translation of the
concept map into a program theory linking multi-level cessation strategies to shortand long-term smoking impacts. Results: the program theory features four smoking
triggers – work-related stressors, social norms, contextual cues, and addiction
biology – and two organizational change processes embedded within community,
family and policy-level strategies to mitigate smoking triggers. The theory
implicates local and state-wide Aboriginal ownership of prevention efforts.
Conclusions: qualitative interviews to contextualize smoking and build program
theory highlights multi-level social and environmental stressors acting through
direct and indirect pathways. These processes require attention beyond the use of
conventional tobacco control strategies.
Keywords: aboriginal health workers; tobacco control; program theory; participatory
research; needs assessment
204
P 20
AGING AND OCCUPATIONAL WELLBEING OF OLDER WORKERS: A
QUALITATIVE STUDY IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR
Depergola, V.1, Manuti, A.2, Tanucci, G.2
1
2
University of Verona, Italy
University of Bari, Italy
An aging population is a phenomenon characterizing the world society (Yeung,
Fung,2009). The future workforce will consist of a greater proportion of workers
over the age of 40 (Shultz & Adams, 2007). In this regard, it would be interesting to
reflect on the nature of work, career paths associated with aging by point of view of
occupational wellbeing (Sparks, Faragher, Cooper, 2001).
Objectives:
- to explore the views of older workers about their representation of the concept of
work and career;
- to investigate if, for older workers, more extensive career paths over time can
affect the level of occupational wellbeing and how organizations can promote
occupational wellbeing of older workers.
Participants were workers aged 45 years or more, with a medium-high educational
level, employed in the University of Bari. For this research, has used qualitative
methodology of focus group discussion (Annese, Mininni, 2002). Four focus groups
were conducted with a total of 16 participants that 4 participants for each focus,
from all major administrative work areas. Subsequently, the information collected
were subjected to a content analysis (Berelson, 1992) which was facilitated by the
use of T Lab (Lancia, 2002). The “Work” for older workers is a very important part
of their lives in which the relationship with colleagues and students is significant.
Also the enhancement of their professional background by management can be a
process that promotes their occupational wellbeing.
The study shows how important is to think of human resource management practices
aimed at enhancing the occupational wellbeing of older workers within
organizations.
Keywords: occupational wellbeing; aging; work
205
P 21
EXPERIENCES OF LIVING WITH INTERMITTENT CLAUDICATION
Egberg, L., Andreassen, S., Mattiasson, A.C.
Karolinska Institutet, Sophiahemmet University College, Sweden
Intermittent claudication is a symptom caused by peripheral arterial disease and is
associated with pain, impaired mobility and loss of control. Walking ability is
reduced due to the pain and both physical and social functions are often negatively
affected, which can lead to the feeling of being a burden to others. An interview
study using a qualitative descriptive design, aimed to describe experiences of living
with intermittent claudication caused by peripheral arterial disease, was carried out
during Winter and Spring 2009/2010. Fifteen people suffering from intermittent
claudication were interviewed and the interviews were analyzed using qualitative
thematic analysis. Six themes were identified: “Experiencing discomfort in the
legs”, “Moving around in a new way”, “Feeling inconvenient when forced to stop”,
“Missing previous life”, “Incorporating intermittent claudication in daily life” and
“To lead a strenuous life”. The findings show that intermittent claudication has a
major impact on daily life. Apart from the severity of symptoms, how the illness is
experienced differs dependent on how active the ill person is or wants to be. These
findings suggest that increased knowledge about living with intermittent
claudication is important in order to understand the effects on the ill person’s life, as
a complement to physical examinations when planning individual treatment.
Keywords: experiences; intermittent claudication; peripheral vascular diseases
P 22
I FEEL GOOD: A QUALITATIVE RESEARCH ON ADOLESCENTS’
WELLBEING AT SCHOOL
Giancaspro, M.L., Manuti, A.
University of Bari, Italy
During the early adolescent years, secondary schools play an important role in
facilitating or inhibiting successful adolescent development. Schools potentially can
provide early adolescents with opportunities to develop their intellectual capacities,
to experience a sense of competence and belonging, and to interact with supportive,
206
non parental adults (Vedder, Boekaerts, Seegers, 2005). Although school adjustment
and achievement are important for adolescents' continued engagement with school,
general well-being, and future opportunities (e.g., Eccles, Lord, & Roeser, 1996),
few studies have addressed how different aspects of the secondary school
environment relate to wellbeing during these years.
The aim of this study is to investigate the meaning of well-being for a sample of
secondary school students. In particular, we are interested in understanding the
factors that could promote health education at school, with reference to different age
cohorts. Five focus group discussions have been conducted with different groups of
students attending all school grades. The topics of discussion have been the concept
of well-being at school, the role played by the school in promoting well being of
student and the effects of the subjective wellbeing. Discursive data have been
transcribed and analyzed using the software T-Lab.
The contribution will discuss the main results and the future perspectives.
Keywords: health education; adolescent development; school wellbeing
P 23
PERSONAL AND INTERPERSONAL CHANGES IN CAREGIVERS OF
PATIENTS IN VEGETATIVE STATE OR MINIMALLY CONSCIOUS
STATE: A QUALITATIVE STUDY
Giovannetti, A.M., Covelli, V., erniauskait , M., Meucci, P., Leonardi,. M.
Neurology, Public Health and Disability Unit - Scientific Directorate - Neurological
Institute Carlo Besta IRCCS Foundation, Italy
There are few studies on caregivers of patients in Vegetative State (VS) or
Minimally Conscious State (MCS) which findings show high level of burden and
worse general health of caregivers of these patients. To bring a better understanding
about how caregivers themselves view and perceive their role and changes in family
relationships after acute event a qualitative study was conducted. Fifteen caregivers
of adult patients in VS or MCS were interviewed and main contents related to
caregivers’ burden emerged. Caregivers reported some psychological difficulties
and problems in integrating past and present inner representation of the patient:
confusing past with present tense describing the patient and switching from “adultadult” to “adult-child” attitude to the patient. They also reported actively avoiding
thoughts about the future. Needs expressed by caregivers were mainly related to the
patient: care-giving was the main role of their life. However, they reported to find
207
new personal resources to deal with this situation. This study brings a better
understanding about changes in family relationships and caregivers role in life.
Targeted interventions aiming to empower their capabilities and personal new
abilities, and to support a better integration between past and present, may be useful
to promote their health.
Keywords: caregivers role; vegetative state; minimally conscious state; qualitative study
P 24
A QUALITATIVE STUDY ON HEALTHCARE PATHWAYS OF 0-5 YEARS
CHILDREN WITH SEVERE DISABILITY IN MILAN: IS THERE THE
NEED TO ENHANCE COLLABORATION BETWEEN FAMILIES AND
HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS?
Giovannetti, M. 1, Covelli, S. 1, Govi, C., Gangi, O. 2, Riva, M. 3
1
Neurological Institute Carlo Besta IRCCS Foundation, Italy
NICU, Clinica Mangiagalli, Fondazione IRCSS Cà Granda Ospedale Maggiore
Policlinico Milano, Università degli Studi di Milano, Italy
3
Associazione L’Abilità Onlus, Italy
2
Few studies have focused on children with disabilities from 0 to 5 years and on the
main difficulties that families of these children have to face. The present study aims
to outline the care-pathway activated for children 0-5 with disability in order to
identify needs, deficiencies or difficulties encountered by parents. Semi-structured
interviews were conducted with 20 families of children 0-5 years with severe
disability (with diagnosis from autistic spectrum disorders or genetic syndromes, to
congenital or acquired perinatal lesions) living in Milan. Families were recruited at a
Neonatology Intensive Care Unit (follow up service), or in an association devoted to
social and educational interventions on children with disability. All parents
expressed need for a better integration and coordination between services. They
usually reported that they had to find essential information on curing and caring
their kids by themselves. Perceived lack of services made informal support of
relatives necessary in daily care-giving activities. Furthermore, a psychological
support during the communication of the diagnosis and all over the care-path is
required. Collaboration between parents and health care services by enhancing
coordination between services, improving information availability and offering
targeted psychological/social support, may improve children well-being.
Keywords: disabilities; children; healthcare providers; families
208
P 25
HOW CAN NURSES FACILITATE ICU PATIENTS TRANSITIONS? A
GROUNDED THEORY
Häggström, M., Kristiansen, L., Asplund, K.
MidSweden University, Sweden
Intensive care patients often experience feelings of powerlessness and vulnerability
when being transferred from an intensive care unit to a general ward. The aim of this
study was to develop a grounded theory of nurse’s care for patients in the ICU
transitional care process. Group interviews, individual interviews and participant
observations were conducted with nurses in two hospitals in Sweden and were
analyzed using grounded theory. The substantive theory shows the process of
nursing care activities—from the contexts of the ICU and the general ward. The
main concern was to achieve a coordinated, strengthening, person-centered standard
of care to facilitate patient transitions. The core category “being perceptive and
adjustable” was a strategy to individualize, that was related to the other categories:
“preparing for a change” and “promoting the recovery”. However, the nurses were
forced to “balance between patient needs and the caregivers’ resources” and
consequently were compromising their care. To facilitate an ICU- patient’s
transition, individual care planning is needed. It is also essential that the patients are
adequately prepared for the change to facilitate the transitional care. Knowledge
about transitional needs, empowerment and patient-education seems to be important
issues for facilitating transitions.
Keywords: critical care; discharge; healthcare transitions; person-centered care; nursing;
grounded theory
P 26
PEOPLE AND PLACES: THE GEONARRATIVE MODALITY OF HEALTH
PROMOTION AMONG CHRONICALLY ILL OLDER ADULTS
Harvey, I.S.
University of Connecticut, USA
Understanding the relationship between social support and health promotion depend
on ascertaining the role of the physical environment. The objective of this study is to
209
examine the location of the participants’ support network members compared to the
location of various formal (e.g., pharmacies) and informal (e.g., health food stores)
health promoting institutions. This study integrated Geographic Information System
(GIS) and narrative analysis through NVivo to visualize and understand the
complexity of health promotion among older adults residing in senior homes and the
strategies they adopt maintain their health and wellbeing. Based on 15 interviews
(i.e., 13 women and 3 men), the study mapped the route of the older adults and
found that African Americans health promotion practices were much more spatially
restricted compared to non-Hispanic whites. By studying the social support systems,
the study found that both men and women residing in the senior homes considered
friendships as an important social predictor in their daily health promotion practices.
The study shed light on the complex relationships between the social and physical
environment and health promotion among residents of a senior housing complex.
The results have implications in designing specific support programs within senior
housing.
Keywords: health promotion; older adults; GIS mapping and narrative analysis
P 27
“HEARING IT FROM BOTH SIDES”: IDENTIFYING AND COMPARING
THE PERSPECTIVES OF HEARING AID USERS AND AUDIOLOGISTS
ON OPTIMAL HEARING AID USE
Jensen, L.D.1, Laplante-Lévesque, A.1, Dawes, P.2, Nielsen, C.1
1
2
Eriksholm Research Centre, Denmark.
Audiology and Deafness Research Group, University of Manchester, UK
This poster describes a focus group study of hearing aid users’ and audiologists’
perspectives on optimal hearing aid use. Hearing aid use is an important treatment
outcome of hearing aid rehabilitation. Hearing aid use is typically measured as a
number of hours per day, with extended hearing aid use time representing a better
treatment outcome. However, no consensus exists as to what optimal hearing aid use
is. With the aim of establishing common ground for hearing aid users and
audiologists with regard to the definition of optimal hearing aid use, this study
explored the hearing aid users’ and audiologists’ perspectives on optimal hearing aid
use and the factors which influence hearing aid use. The research team conducted 4
focus groups: 2 with hearing aid users and 2 with audiologists. The focus group
participants were asked about their views and experiences regarding hearing aid use.
210
The research took place in Denmark and in the United Kingdom. The focus group
data were transcribed and analyzed with qualitative content analysis (Graneheim UH
& Lundman B, 2003). Data from the hearing aid users and audiologists were
analyzed separately by different researchers. A person uninvolved in the coding
reviewed the data analysis. The category analysis of the users’ and audiologists’ data
sets resulted in 3 similar main categories with dissimilar content. Although hearing
aid users’ and audiologists’ focus group discussions revolved around the same
topics, the research team found points of agreement and disagreement between the
two groups. Qualitative inquiry is a relatively new and developing field in
audiologic rehabilitation research and studies which compare the perspectives of
hearing aid users and audiologists are rare. More research with this comparison in
focus will help to establish common ground between hearing aid users and
audiologists for assessing hearing aid use. This study is part of a larger mixed
methods research program on hearing aid use conducted at Eriksholm Research
Centre, Denmark.
Keywords: focus groups; content analysis; users; healthcare professionals; hearing
rehabilitation
P 28
CONTROL OF
ATMOSPHERE:
EXPERIENCES
AND ADAPTATION IN
NURSING
TEACHERS’
THE EDUCATIONAL
PERCEPTIONS
AND
Karimi Moonaghi, H. 1, Dabbaghi, F. 2, Oskouei, S.F.H. 2, Binaghi, T. 3, Hosseini,
S.M. 1
1
Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Iran
3
Khorasan Razavi Education Organization, Iran
2
Control and adaptation of teachers with educational atmosphere as a whole is less
regarded in nursing education. This study was conducted to explore, describe, and
illustrate teachers' perceptions and experiences about their control of and adaptation
in the educational atmosphere. In this qualitative study, 15 teachers in different
academic disciplines were selected through purposeful sampling and interviewed
using deep and semi-structured interviews. All interviews were tape-recorded,
transcribed and then analyzed using constant comparison based on Strauss and
Corbin's method. Control of and adaptation in the educational atmosphere as the
211
main process (theme) comprised 4 sub-process:
• Teacher’s perception of self
• Teacher’s perception of the student
• Teacher’s perception of the environment
• Teacher’s perception of nursing knowledge.
Knowing and appraisal of self, students, environment and nursing knowledge can
develop right pattern for controlling of and adapting in educational atmosphere.
Having right knowledge and attitudes about mentioned factors are necessary to be
an effective teacher. Nursing teachers, students, and curriculum planners could use
the introduced processes in this study in order to modify and promote the quality of
nursing education.
Keywords: educational atmosphere; nursing teacher and experience; control of and
adaptation
P 29
AN INVESTIGATION OF NURSING STUDENTS' EXPERIENCES IN AN
IRANIAN PSYCHIATRIC UNIT
Karimollahi, M.
Ardabil University of Medical Sciences, Iran
This qualitative study aimed to investigate and explain clinical experiences of
nursing students in a psychiatric unit in an Iranian hospital. The researcher
performed a Heideggerian hermeneutic phenomenological study by conducting indepth interviews of 13 participants. An analysis based on Diekelmann's method
helped to interpret the data and uncover common themes. The following four
correlated themes were obtained: anxiety, maturation, dissatisfaction and
enthusiasm. These results present distinctive insights on contextualizing, developing
and implementing clinical education in Iran, especially in psychiatric units. The
exploration and description of students' experiences will help nurse educators to plan
the clinical learning opportunities such that they are less stressful, thus ensuring that
nursing students are equipped to act as therapeutic professionals.
Keywords: clinical education; experience; hermeneutics; Iran; nursing student;
phenomenology
212
P 30
KOREAN AMERICAN CAREGIVERS’ PERCEPTIONS OF DEMENTIA
Kong, E.
Gachon University School of Nursing, Korea
Family caregivers’ perceptions of dementia are very important because it has great
impact on the caregivers’ help-seeking, utilization of formal support, and caring.
The purpose of this study was to describe the perceptions of Korean American
family caregivers of old adults with dementia. This study used a qualitative
descriptive method and a purposive sampling method. A total 17 in-depth interviews
were conducted. Symbolic interactionism and cultural models were used as
theoretical frameworks. Qualitative content analysis was used to analyze the data.
Four themes were identified: is a brain disease, caused by lack of interaction,
precipitated by lack of interaction, and delayed by family contact. While they
described dementia as death of brain cells, and changes in brain structure and
function, they believed that their care recipient’s dementia was caused by a lack of
interactions. In addition, they thought that the progress of dementia would be
delayed by frequent family visits and communication, and would be precipitated by
lack of interactions. Regarding beliefs about dementia, Korean American family
caregivers combined the biomedical model with their cultural model. Future
research should continue to examine the perceptions about dementia among
minority caregivers.
Keywords: Korean; caregiver; perception; dementia
P 31
EXTERNAL VALIDITY AND MEMBER CHECKING
Konradsen, H.1, Olson, K.2
1
2
Gentofte University Hospital, Denmark
Faculty of Nursing, University of Alberta, Canada
External validity is one of the cornerstones of research quality. Different positions
discuss how to or if to apply criteria for judging validity of a qualitative study. As
this often ends when a study is finished, a new idea is suggested; that external
validity can be judged after the completion of a qualitative study. This is possible if
member checking is thought of in a new way. In every situation there are features
213
that are unique but also features that are typical, and thereby recognizable.
Recognisability, either in relation to own experiences or the experiences of others, is
central to the meaning of external validity in qualitative research. To test our idea,
we therefore gathered data about recognisability in relation to a specific study on
facial disfigurement. The results from the original research were presented to peers,
and health care professionals and then they were asked: do you recognize this?
Furthermore former patients where interviewed and asked: are this how it was for
you? Four categories occurred: full recognition, partial recognition, recognition in
others and no recognition. Instead of judging these categories in relation to the
correctness of the findings, possibilities for knowledge transfer and receiving new
data to modify findings from the original research is discussed. This is also
suggested as a way of actively involving individuals in health care research.
Keywords: external validity; member checking; knowledge transfer
P 32
THE DIFFICULTY WITH DABBLING: CONSIDERING RIGOR IN ARTSBASED RESEARCH
Lavoie, M., Miciak, M., Daum, C., Mayan, M.
University of Alberta, Canada
Arts-based research (ABR) is being used in health care research to deepen
knowledge generation and integration through different types (e.g. visual) and
qualities (e.g. emotional) of experience. Although promising, ABR is ill-defined and
has a broad scope. For example, an art practice such as painting can be used as the
main strategy during data generation or to represent findings during knowledge
dissemination. Yet, possible tensions can arise when researchers arbitrarily use art
practices with the sense that 'anyone can do it'. This is understandable given the
familiarity created through avenues such as pop culture and the web. We claim that
familiarity is not fluency. Art is a method with diverse strategies, each with its own
history, scope, technique, skill and rigor. If researchers are expected to have a solid
understanding of their chosen method (e.g. phenomenology) including its
philosophical underpinnings, should this not be expected of researchers using ABR?
We will outline the importance of having a foundation in a given art practice for its
effective use in a research project. To conclude, a rigorous qualitative research
project demonstrates methodological congruence. We suggest that ABR must be
held to the same standards as any methodological option.
Keywords: arts-based research; rigor; method
214
P 33
CONFLICT
LIVED
EXPERIENCES
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPIST
OF
CLINICAL
KOREAN
Lee, O-J.1, Lee, J-S.2, Jeon, B.J.2, Han, S-W.3, Ham, B-H.3, Hong, D-G.3, Choi, SY.3
1
Kottdongnae university, South Korea
Konyang University, South Korea
3
The graduate school of Konyang University, South Korea
2
This study was done to discover the structure of the lived experiences of conflict of
clinical Korean occupational therapists.
The research question: ‘what is the lived experience of conflict?’ was examined
based on Parse’s Human becoming research method. Conflict experience is caused
by social environment (poor working condition, salary issues, lack of awareness of
occupational therapy, etc.). They donned the process of trying through confusion of
identity for occupational therapy and worry about self ability. It is self-development
and growth experience for them and made a positive look at the future. Conceptual
integration found to be in process of powering and transferring the connectingseparating, enabling-limiting values.
Systematic management plans should be established, in order to enable more
effective occupational therapy to patients.
Keywords: occupational therapist; conflict; lived experiences; Parse; human becoming
research method
P 34
WOMEN’S EXPERIENCE
MIDWIVES
ON
SPONTANEOUS
DELIVERY
WITH
Lee, S.
Department of nursing, Hallym University, Korea
Objectives: to understand meaning of women’s experience on spontaneous delivery
with midwives at midwifery clinic or home in Korea.
Methodology: used van Kaam’s Psychophenomenological method that is composed
of four-stage, 12-step format.
215
Results achieved: through the data analysis, 403 significant statements, 172
elements, 48 subcategories, and 19 categories were extracted, and from the 19
categories, 8 themes were drawn. The eight themes were: “Conflict on whether a
hospital or a midwifery clinic”, “Choosing natural delivery on the assurance of
ability in spontaneous delivery of herself and on the trust in the midwives” “Being
encouraged by a midwife and family members with one accord”, “Experience of the
spontaneous delivery process on body”, “Comfortable delivery in spite of painful
process”, “Deeply impressed by the overwhelming joy of birth”, “Satisfaction of
spontaneous delivery”, and "Deeper love among the family members". Scientific
and applicative relevance: be expected to provides information and data for women
on choosing the delivery place other than just hospitals by the experience of delivery
with the midwives and for the midwives to improve their facilities concerning
women and level of expertise in Korea.
Keywords: spontaneous delivery; women’s experience; midwives; midwifery; van
Kaam’s Psychophenomenological method
P 35
CATCHING ONLINE PATIENTS EXCHANGES: A TOOL PROPOSAL
Libreri, C., Graffigna, G.
Faculty of Psychology, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Italy
It’s well established that online exchanges are becoming more and more central for
processes of peer knowledge sharing and construction.
This is really true for the health management and care, in particular for the chronic
conditions; indeed, chronic patients are the experts of their illness, yet scientific
knowledge does not translate well into meaningful lay knowledge from which
patients can make decisions about daily care management of their illness. So they
turn to the Internet and especially to the online peer exchanges (e.g.: social networks)
to find more information about their condition, to seek support from other patients
and more and more to share and construct together useful knowledge for their health
management: in practice patient share experiences, information and practical
solutions that help them to learn a better care management.
However, the study of online knowledge sharing and construction between chronic
patients is difficult as it brings together a variety of concepts, methods and tools not
uniformly shared or understood across disciplines. Moreover, these exchanges are
usually used as a source of information and contents, but less attention is given to
216
the way in which people exchange and construct these contents: this means not only
to consider group and conversation dynamics, but also to be able to understand how
the growing richness of the online contexts is modifying the exchange possibilities
(online exchanges and knowledge construction processes are not just written texts!).
Since there are not shared tools to comprehensively study these processes, the aim
of this work is to present a grid for the analysis of the online patients peer exchanges
that comprehends:
•
contents: written texts, but also the use of pictures and videos and the role
of links;
•
group dynamics;
•
conversational and discourse processes (considering online conversation as
an hybrid between written and oral conversations);
•
knowledge and support sharing and construction processes;
•
social presence and subjectivity construction processes.
As its explorative and naturalistic nature, this is a qualitative tool in part developed
by theory and in part, inductively developed from the initial analysis of online
chronic patients exchanges. The analysis was organized using ATLAS.Ti software.
Keywords: online patient exchanges; grid development; chronic patients; ATLAS-Ti
P 36
BEST PRACTICE NURSE MANAGER AT RISK MANAGEMENT: A
PERSPECTIVE FOR HOSPITAL ACCREDITATION
Meirelles, B.H.S., Costa, V.T., Erdmann, A.L.
Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Brazil
This is one case study, exploratory, whose goal was to identify the actions of the
nurse managers in a risk management program, considered as best practices for
hospital accreditation in a general hospital. The setting was a private hospital in the
south of the Brazilian country and participated in the study nurse managers, who
make up the risk management committee, nurses who work indirectly in the
program of risk management and risk manager. Data were collected from April to
September 2011, through document analysis, interviews and non-participant
observation. From the triangulation, data were analyzed by an operative proposal.
The results showed as best practices the actions in education, critical analysis of
reality and the multiple dimensions of management. These practices have pointed to
hospital accreditation, since it is similar to the present institutional compliance to
217
obtain quality certification. By using records of adverse events, it was noted the
concern of the nurse managers to ensure safety in nurse care practice. This implies a
tool for implementing quality management programs.
Keywords: best practices; benchmarking; accreditation; risk management
P 37
PERSPECTIVES OF HEALTH PROMOTION THROUGH DAILY LIVING
DESIGN FOR PEOPLE WITH SCHIZOPHRENIA
Minato, M.
Aichi Medical College, South Korea
People with schizophrenia demand health promotion through engaging in daily
living. However, health care intervention has rarely focused on orchestration of
daily living for health promotion and avoided support for their work in Japan.
Knowledge on healthy living design for persons with schizophrenia is expected to
powerfully influence development of intervention. This study aimed at exploring
process of the healthy living design using grounded theory approach. I interviewed
nine persons with schizophrenia. The results showed that designing a daily living
enacting each person’s concept of a healthy self led informants to actively engage in
a variety of doing in daily living. Stress in those daily living was managed through
overcoming difficulties of believing ‘I can’t’ and ‘I feel fatigued’ to develop a sense
of ‘I can do it’ and managing energy for and through engaging in doing. The daily
life of informants was an attempt to move toward their concept of a healthy self
through daily living design. I managed to provide the knowledge gained from this
study with health care staff members who had worked for clients with
schizophrenia. The staff members became to start supporting clients to design daily
living involving work for health promotion.
Keywords: health promotion; daily living design; schizophrenia; stress management
218
P 38
COMPLIANCE IN CHRONIC PATIENTS: A CONCEPT ANALYSIS
Modanloo, M.M.1, Abdollahy, H.2, Forough, R.1
1
2
Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Golestan University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Non-compliance to prescribed medical regimens is an ever present and complex
problem, especially for patients with a chronic illness. The medical regimens will be
invaluable, if patients don’t obey them. Compliance as a complex and unclear
concept would seem to be a central element of treatment in chronic disease, but
there is no consensus about its meaning. The purpose of this study was to clarify and
explore the concept of compliance within the context of chronic patients. The 8steps method of concept analysis (select concept, determine purpose, identify
definitions, define attributes, identify model case, describe related and contrary
cases, identify antecedents and consequences and define empirical referents)
proposed by Walker and Avant was used to clarify the concept of compliance.
A literature search was conducted using MEDLINE, CINHAL, Ovid, Elsevier, Pro
Quest and Blackwell databases until 2010 with the search terms of ‘Compliance,
Noncompliance, Adherence, Concordance in the title, abstract, keywords, or text.
Studies were eligible if they included adult patients with chronic disease, reported
characteristics of compliance and published in English. Twenty-seven relevant
research papers were chosen purposefully. Data from literature review analyzed
through qualitative content analysis. Data analysis showed that, the term compliance
is still used widely in medical research, but often with the same underlying
definition as adherence and concordance which were used interchangeably. Because
of, overlapping these concepts, we presented the most common attributes of all of
related concepts. Compliance defining attributes include; obedience, passive and
powerless care recipients, which flexibility, adaptability, subordinates behaviors of
patients. Adherence defining attributes include; active, responsible and voluntary
roles in close collaboration with the health care personnel. Concordance defining
attributes include; alignment of patient behavior and health recommendations,
mastery of a new behavior and health knowledge, ongoing collaborative
relationships between the patient and healthcare provider, and their perceived ability
to meet the outcome targets. Findings reveal compliance's antecedents can fall into
five categories; patient-related factors, disease -related factors, therapy-related
factors, healthcare professional-related factors, healthcare system-related factors.
According to, characteristics and theoretical definition resulting from concept
analysis, it is possible to determine criteria for measuring of compliance and predict
219
patients' compliant behaviors.
Keywords: compliance; patient; chronic illness; concept analysis; Walker and Avant's
method; Wilson’s method
P 39
EMOTIONAL EXPERIENCES OF THE ELDERLY PERSONS WITH MILD
COGNITIVE IMPAIRMENT AND THEIR FAMILY LIVING IN THE
COMMUNITY
Nakano, M. 1, Shimanouchi, A. 2, Sato, S. 3, Nakahara, J. 3, Nakagawa, T. 3
1
Kyoto Municipal Junior College of Nursing, Japan
Faculty of Social Welfare, Gunma University of Health and Welfare, Japan
3
Graduate School of Human Sciences, Osaka University, Japan
2
The purpose of this study was to clarify the emotional experiences of elderly persons
with Mild Cognitive Impairment and their family living in the Community.
Participants ware elderly man and woman with Mild Cognitive Impairment and their
family. Data were collected using semi-structured interview and analyzed by using
qualitatively inductive method. The husband of 74 years and the wife received the
interview, and the mother-in-law of 80 years and the daughter-in-law received the
interview. As a result there were 216 codes extracted from the interviewing recodes
and then the codes were sorted into 37 sub-categories. Final 8 categories were
“Negative feelings to family member” “Social participation evasion” “Receipt
feelings of disease” “Action desire for health” “Respect between families” “Nontreatment decision feelings” “Life defence feelings” “Self-dignity feelings”.
Keywords: MCI; family; the elderly person; emotional experience
220
P 40
FACILITATION OF EARLIER DISCHARGE OF LONG-TERM,
PSYCHIATRIC IN-PATIENTS AND THE ATTITUDE OF PSYCHIATRIC,
HOME-VISITING NURSES NECESSARY TO ALLOW THE PATIENTS TO
CONTINUE THEIR COMMUNITY LIFE
Narumi, F.1, Yuri, F.2, Yuko, W.3
1
Kyushu University, Japan
Wakahisa Hospital, Japan
3
International University of Health and Welfare, Japan
2
The purpose of the present study was to clarify the attitude of nurses required to
facilitate earlier discharge of long-term in-patients in the Department of Psychiatry
and for allowing their community life to continue. We conducted interviews with the
subjects, by using a semi-structural questionnaire, and made a qualitative and
inductive data analysis, using as subjects home visiting nurses from a psychiatric
department who had experience in nursing care at hospital psychiatry wards. The
following are the attitudes were revealed to be taken by hospital ward nurses
necessary for facilitation of earlier discharge of the long-term, psychiatric inpatients. The “correction of a fixed idea toward long-term, psychiatric in-patients”,
the “attitude to recognize discharge as a realizable goal for a patient”, the
“correction of a fixed idea toward a long-term, psychiatric in-patient who will live in
his or her community”, the “respect of self-determination”, and the “role recognition
of a nurse as a relationship coordinator with the surroundings of a patient”.
As an attitude of a psychiatric hospital ward nurse required to facilitate earlier
discharge of a long-term, psychiatric in-patient, which should be depicted by the
subjects in the present study, it was suggested that it is necessary to adopt an
“attitude that recognizes discharge as a realizable goal” through the “correction of a
fixed idea toward a, long-term, psychiatric in-patient”. In other words, it was clearly
shown that correcting the point of view and the way of understanding of a hospital
ward nurse, towards a long-term, psychiatric in-patient, is the most important thing
for facilitating an earlier discharge. The attitudes to be taken by a psychiatric nurse
that could be necessary to support long-term, mentally-ill in-patients after discharge
were the “respect of self-determination” and the “role recognition as a relationship
coordinator in surroundings of a user”. A home-visiting nurse is expected to support
the patient’s family, to alleviate the burden or difficulty of the family, and at the
same time to provide the support to draw out the user’s own ability, while actively
extending direct support to the user.
Keywords: home-visiting nurses; earlier discharge; long-term psychiatric in-patients
221
P 41
CREATING COMMUNITY OF PRACTICE WITHIN GSH GENDERSPECIFIC/GENDER-SENSITIVE HEALTH PROMOTION
Nishihara, A., Sayama, M., Suzuki, T.
School of Health Sciences, Niigata University, Japan
This is a longitudinal, reflective and continuing study into the developmental
experiences at “the Center for GSH research and practice”, recently established by
the School of Health Sciences, Niigata University, Japan.
GSH Gender Specific/Gender Sensitive Health is a new discipline for health
research, practices and promotion, specifically concerned with, and sensitive to,
differences in sex and/or gender. GSH approach is more holistic and inclusive than
traditional health promotion. This presentation will focus on the process of creating
a system for GSH promotion involving lay people and professionals. We review
participant’s developmental experiences at our GSH open lectures.
We created a cycle of practice and reflection to enable us to consider the context of
our own practice or its developmental processes. This was performed from the
standpoint of epistemology, organizational values and structures. We utilized
narrative and descriptive research methods.
Our presentation examines the developmental experiences of participants at our
GSH open lectures, by analyzing data from questionnaires and from focus group
interviews.
Preliminary results suggest that Community of Practice (COP) may facilitate
exchanges of knowledge, experiences and cross fertilization of ideas. COP may act
as a catalyst for wider participation in the process of knowledge creation,
information sharing and paradigm building.
Keywords: gender-specific/gender-sensitive; health (GSH); community of practice
(COP); reflective research; knowledge management
222
P 42
PERCEPTION OF CERVICAL CANCER SCREENING AMONG FEMALE
UNIVERSITY STUDENTS IN JAPAN
Oshima, S.1, Maezawa, M.2
1
2
Hokusei Gakuen Universit, Japan
Hokkaido University, Japan
This study aims to determine factors influencing attitudes towards cervical cancer
screening among Japanese female university students who had never taken a pap
smear test. Four focus-group discussions were conducted with 15 female university
students in November–December 2009 and the transcripts were analyzed to extract
the relevant themes describing attitudes of young women towards cervical cancer
screening. Participants were divided into two groups: those who were not interested
in cervical cancer screening and those who were interested but had not taken a pap
smear test. Themes describing the attitudes towards cervical cancer screening were
1) the lack of knowledge, and 2) the reluctance to visit obstetrics and gynecological
clinics. Those who were interested in the screening listed the following as the reason
they got interested in the first place: conversation with family members, having
someone within the family with cancer, and information from the media. The results
indicate the importance of getting young women more interested in the cervical
cancer screening. It is also necessary to mitigate general tendency to avoid visiting
obstetrics and gynecological clinics by creating an environment where it is less
embarrassing for young women to visit the clinics.
Keywords: cervical cancer; pap smear test; university students; perception
P 43
THE ILLNESS EXPERIENCE IN PATIENTS WITH PSORIASIS:
PATIENT’S PERSPECTIVE AS A RESOURCE TO IMPROVE QUALITY
OF CARE
Passalacqua, A.1, Dolcetti, F.R.2, Battisti, N.2, Tabolli, S.1
1
2
IDI IRCCS, Italy
Studio RisorseObiettiviStrument, Italy
Psoriasis is a chronic, disabling disease. We explored patients emotional experience
of living with psoriasis. Patients (n.101) were asked to describe their deepest
223
thoughts and feelings living with psoriasis, according to Pennebacker writing
technique. The text analysis was performed with T-Lab and the outputs were
interpreted using the Emotional Analysis of Text (AET). This method bases on
clinical-psychological models that focuses on the representations of the dynamic
relationship between patients and the context. We identified two relevant domains:
a) the influence of the medical context (cluster 2 “The relationship with healthcare
providers and with the healthcare services: from illusion to disenchantment”; cluster
3 “adaptation to psoriasis: the fluctuation between sorting out the problem and
negative pervasive emotions”); b) the relational aspects concerning patients
investments into social life (cluster 1 “the hard work of integrating psoriasis in
social life”; cluster 4 “the ‘familistic’ retreat as a reaction to shame and stigma”).
This study offers an insight in how patients manage this chronic disease and reveal
several critical emotional strategies that may represent a resource to orientate the
development of health care strategies. Moreover the findings suggest relational
abilities for health care providers in connection with the illness experience of
patients.
Keywords: psoriasis; quality of care; health care services; adherence; communication;
chronic diseases; emotional experience; coping strategies; illness experience
P 44
KEEPING THE MIND IN MIND: A WAY TO IMPROVE THE
PSYCHIATRIC CARE OF BORDERLINE PERSONALITY DISORDER
THROUGH MENTALIZATION BASED TREATMENT AND TO HELP
THEIR FAMILIES COPING WITH THE DISEASE
Pepe, N.L.1, Oasi, O.1, Caverzasi, E.2
1
2
Dipartimento di Psicologia, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore Milano, Italy
Dipartimento di Psichiatria, Università degli Studi di Pavia, Italy
BPD are often treated with non-specialistic standard psychiatric care. Anyway these
treatments have demonstrated partial efficacy, with very high prevalence of dropouts (50-60%). In the Unit for Personality Disorders in Pavia a study aimed at
identify a valid treatment in terms of efficacy, patients' compliance and involvement
was set up. Psychoeducation within the Mentalization Based Treatment (MBT),
addressed to both patients and caregivers, foster improvement in the patient and
reduce the subjective and objective burden linked to the patient's management
(Hoffman, 2005; Blum, 2008; Gunderson, 2010).
224
To create a suitable intervention for BPD that enhances patients' care and cure
experience and overcomes compliance problems; to complement patients' treatment
with caregivers' involvement, decreasing thus their burden. Patients are treated using
MBT. Psychoeducational groups have been introduced and provided before the
beginning of the treatment aimed to introduce the approach and receive patients
feedback. Caregivers are followed with psychoeducational groups too.
Data are being collected. We do expect a decrease of the family burden and of the
drops out. MBT showed its effectiveness with BPD (Bateman, Fonagy, 1999, 2001).
Psychoeducation plays a great role since it is meant to increase therapeutic alliance
and therapeutic compliance.
Keywords: psychoeducation; mentalization-based treatment; care experience; borderline
personality disorder
P 45
THE PROMOTION OF WELL-BEING IN HOSPITAL: THE POINT OF
VIEW OF PARTURIENT WOMEN IN AN INTERVENTION RESEARCH
ON THE “TIME OF THE BIRTH”, CONDUCTED WITH A QUALITATIVE
APPROACH
Petrillo, G., Capone, V., Caso, D., Donizzetti, A.R.
Department of Theories and Methods of Human and Social Sciences, University of
Naples, Federico II, Italy
Studies conducted in a bio-psycho-social perspective have highlighted the central
role of humanization and quality of life for parturient women. In an intervention
research perspective, our work aims to investigate the point of view of women in
childbed on their well-being and quality of life in hospital. 21 new mothers, in a
hospital of Naples, answered some questions for a narrative interview. Through a
categorical analysis we detected some themes particularly relevant to women: the
need for informational support, the difficulty in relating to the health workers and in
reconciling the hospital stay with the separation from other children. A textual
analysis, using TLAB software, showed the existence of cross-category dimensions
linked to the use of language, and highlighted the differences between primiparae
and women which have already had children. Some methodological aspects are
relevant for the intervention research in hospital settings, conducted with a
qualitative approach: the influence of the environment; the relational difficulties
with participants with medium-low sociocultural level; the co-validation of the
225
results of the analyses through a discussion with the training participants. These
results have encouraged the implementation of a training addressed at the hospital
staff, aimed at increasing the level of well-being of parturient women through a
critical review of professional practices.
Keywords: well-being; parturient women; quality of life in hospital; intervention
research; categorical and textual analyses; hospital
P 46
LIVING, NARRATING AND NAMING THE MENTAL HEALTH: THE
ENCOUNTER BETWEEN THE EXPERIENCE OF MIGRATION AND
HEALTH SERVICES
Piasentini, A.
Università di Padova, Italy
The analysis of the relationship between immigrant patients and italian health
services in psychiatry is a story of the encounter between two different provinces of
meaning, concerning the representations of health, illness and care. This analysis
can give a prolific perspective to the research, at various levels. In particular, it may
be able to highlight different dynamics, such as the ability of health care services to
be crossed from alterity, the questioning of the biomedical model applied, in this
case, to psychiatry and, finally, the possibility of the patients to name their suffering
without borrowing from the diagnostic manuals. The questions concerning the
characteristics and modalities of this meeting, and in particular the "first contact",
the narratives put in place, the sense and meaning of illness and disease embedded in
a broader biographical narrative, and the role of health service as a potential "repair"
of this disease. The methods most appropriate to the topic and the questions belong,
in large part, to the universe of qualitative approach: it is given wide space at the
ethnographic observation of the psychiatric examination and interviews were
collected, both biographical interviews of migrants, and seeds-structured interviews
of health workers, in a mental health center of the province of Padua.
Keywords: migration; mental health; disease; care; biomedical model; narratives
226
P 47
MANAGING NURSING CARE TO THE ELDERLY USER AT THE
FAMILY HEALTH PROGRAM IN A PERIPHERAL DISTRICT OF
BELÉM, PA, BRAZIL
Polaro, S.1, Gonçalves, L.2, Alvarez, A.3
1
Universidade Federal do Pará – UFPA, Brasil
Universidade Federal do Parà, Brasil
3
Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina – UFSC, Brasil
2
The research that resulted in a doctoral thesis aimed to explore nurses’ perception
from the Family Health Program (FHP) in the peripheral area of Belém, Capital of
Pará State and located in the north of Brazil, on work conditions, context and their
know-how that enable or not, in order to meet the elderly health needs at their
family scope. The theoretical framework supporting the thesis was the current
paradigm on health promotion, provisions from the Health Unique System,
foundation of gerontological nursing and work process on nursing and health.
Methodology: Study of qualitative approach. Data were obtained through open and
guided interview technique, by a set of questions that triggered and incited the
answers for the research issue. The study included fourteen nurses who carry out
their activities at the FHP. Result: The adopted method was content analysis
technique, by Bardin, and resulting in the construction of a conceptual framework
whose main topic was nominated: Managing nursing care to the elderly at the FHP.
Three surrounding issues contributed to the main topic emergence: Building
gerontological practice, managing administrative problems at the health unit and
challenging territorial and intra-family violence. The nurses at the FHP, in the midst
of adversity on their daily work process and even with insufficient training in
gerontological nursing, worked facing barriers and administrative problems at the
service, despite the guidelines from the SUS (Health Unique System), challenging
the community violence when caring for users at their homes, taking advantage of a
sui generis nursing practice, in different situations and doing their best. Practice and
scientific relevance: Knowing health services context through workers perspective,
in this case nurses, has made its assessment closer to the reality and with prospects
for a better contribution to the review and correction of health services programs.
Keywords: elderly; family; family health program; nurse; work process; health service
management
227
P 48
CARER’S EXPERIENCE OF A BRIEF SYSTEMIC GROUP
INTERVENTION FOR PARENTS OF ADOLESCENTS WITH EATING
DISORDERS: A QUALITATIVE STUDY
Salerno, L.1, Lo Coco, G.1, Gullo, S.1, Amato, L.1, Buffa, G.M. 2, Signa, C.2, Cicero,
L.2, Alauria, F.2
1
2
Department of Psychology, University of Palermo, Italy
ASP Palermo, Center of Eating Disorders (Ce.Di.Al.), Italy
Several studies support the importance of involving parents of adolescents with
eating disorders (ED) to facilitate successful treatment. This study explores the
experiences of parents of adolescents with ED after having participated in a brief
systemic group intervention.
Data were obtained from a group of 12 parents (mean age = 51.82 ys; sd = 6.40), of
adolescent outpatients (mean age = 18 ys; ds = 2.83) with ED, carried out in an
Italian public center specializing in ED treatment. All participants filled in a
questionnaire constructed specifically for this study measuring group helpful events
for the individual and for the family. The content analysis was performed by two
independently raters after the ending of the group.
This study has confirmed that parent’s groups can be beneficial in increasing
parents’ self-efficacy and reducing psychological distress, anxiety and burden. The
results showed that parents reported changes about themselves and their family
relationship. The parents’ perceptions about the possible impact of this intervention
on the relationships with their daughters will be discussed.
Improve parent’s mental health and reduce caregiver stress is important to increase
the effectiveness of treatment.
Keywords: parent groups; eating disorders; family intervention
228
P 49
LIVED EXPERIENCES OF FAMILY CAREGIVER OF
DISORDER RELATIVES: A PHENOMENOLOGICAL STUDY
BIPOLAR
Shamsaei, F.1, Mohamad Khon Kermanshahi, S.2, Vanaki, Z.2
1
Research institute of behavioral disorders & substances abuse, Hamadan University of
Medical Sciences, Iran
2
Department of Nursing, Tarbiat Modares University, Iran
Attention to caregiving consequences has been mainly restricted to bipolar disorder,
although studies suggest that relatives of bipolar patients also experience
considerable distress. The purpose of this study was to explore the lived experiences
from family member caregiver with bipolar disorder patient. In a qualitative
research of phenomenological methodology, the family member’s caregivers of
bipolar disorder in fsrshchian psychiatric hospital in Hamedan (Iran) were selected
by purposive sampling in the year 2010. By reaching data saturation the number of
participant was 12. Data were gathered through in-depth interviews and analyzed by
“Van Manen” method. Analysis of the interviews revealed six major themes: fears
and anxiety for the future, psychosomatic impact, feeling Isolated and loneliness,
Financial Impact, change in life style and family functioning and lack of support and
knowledge. Highlight the need for family-oriented mental health services to be
developed and for further research to identify the specific nursing interventions that
are effective in helping to sustain family caregiving.
Keywords: family caregiver; bipolar disorder; lived experience
P 50
WHAT THE SCHOOL-LEVEL BARRIERS TO PHYSICAL ACTIVITY
EXPERIENCED BY OVERWEIGHT ADOLESCENTS CAN TELL US
ABOUT STRATEGIES FOR ENGAGEMENT
Stankov, I., Cargo, M.
Social Epidemiology and Evaluation Research Group, University of South Australia,
Australia
Physical activity is a key behavioural risk factor for the development of obesity.
Epidemiological studies show that many adolescents do not meet recommended
229
physical activity guidelines. Little, however, is known about the barriers to schoolbased physical activity experienced by overweight/ obese adolescents.
A qualitative descriptive study, guided by Bronfenbrenner’s ecological model of
human development, was undertaken to: a) understand barriers experienced by
overweight/obese adolescents to engaging in school-based physical activity; and b)
identify strategies for engagement. Semi-structured interviews with 12 young adults
reflecting back on their experiences as overweight/ obese adolescents were analyzed
using thematic network analysis. Young people’s perceptions of their bodies and
social inferiority in addition to inhibitory social norms, lack of privacy in change
rooms and school rules emerged as potent individual, interpersonal and
environmental barriers to physical activity. Adolescents internalized negative
experiences which led to feelings of demoralization and fear. Adaptive (e.g.
concealing body) and avoidance (e.g. faking sickness) coping behaviours were used
to deal with uncomfortable situations.
Adolescents will continue to grapple with their weight and weight loss; however,
creating supportive, inclusive school environments that offer choice, encouragement
and empathy have the potential to facilitate weight loss through engagement with
positive physical activity experiences.
Keywords: barriers to school-based physical activity; youth; obesity; engagement
P 51
IS THERE A SOLUTION FOR ORGAN SHORTAGE ?
Takagi, M.
Nihon University, Japan
In Japan the average waiting time to receive a kidney from brain-dead patients or
those in cardiac arrest is about 14 years. Therefore patients receive a kidney from a
living family member, or undergo dialysis. Approximately 30,000 new patients are
introduced into dialysis and about 20,000 of them die every year. At present, about
300,000 patients are on dialysis. In a comparison of dialysis and transplant, patient
survival rate is much better in transplant than dialysis (10 years patient survival rate:
dialysis 40%, transplant 80%). The continuing organ shortage requires evaluation of
all potential donors, including those with malignant disease. As research method, I
interviewed doctors involved in the renal transplant, and also I survey the literatures.
Tokushukai Medical Group (TMG) in Japan considered it better to use the restored
kidneys for the benefit of patients who desperately wanted transplant, than to discard
230
them. Namely cancerous kidneys were removed from patients, then after having the
diseased part removed, restored kidneys were transplanted. TMG has already started
Clinical Trail in 2009 to evaluate the curative efficacy (renal function, QOL) and
safety. More than 80% of small renal tumours (4 cm or less) are nephrectomised in
Japan, estimating 2000 kidneys as such discarded every year. This would be
breakthrough for the shortage of donors, and as a new supplier, we consider restored
kidney humanely and ethically.
Keywords: kidney transplantation; shortage; waiting time; restored kidney
P 52
A CASE STUDY ON THE USE OF AMERICAN SOCIAL SKILLS BY
JAPANESE STUDENTS STUDYING IN THE U.S.: BASED ON A
QUESTIONNAIRE SURVEY CONDUCTED BY JAPANESE STUDENTS
WHO STUDIED IN THE U.S.
Takahama, A.1, Tanaka, T.2
1
2
Hitotsubashi University, Japan
Okayama University, Japan
The authors of this paper provide pre-departure sessions on American social skills to
Japanese university students who plan to study in the U.S. to facilitate their health.
Students learn several skills during the sessions. These skills foster the ability to
form relationships in cross-cultural settings, which has a positive influence on the
students’ well-being and mental development. In this study, in order to identify
more useful and appropriate skills, the authors employed a qualitative research
method; the results of a questionnaire survey completed by seven Japanese students
who returned from the U.S. are reported. In the questionnaire, students were asked
about whether they had used twelve specific social skills during their study in the
U.S. They were also asked about the reasons why they used or did not use the skills
and whether they thought it was important to acquire the skills prior to studying in
the U.S. The results show that the students used the skills of making friends, actively
participating in class, asking the professors questions, and negotiating most
frequently and regarded them as the most important: on the basis of these results, it
was inferred that those four skills need to be included in the sessions.
Keywords: social skills; Japanese students; studying in the U.S.; intercultural education;
psycho-education
231
P 53
MEDICAL SAFETY EDUCATION FOR TEACHERS AT NURSING
SCHOOLS USING AN INSTRUCTION ILLUSTRATION GAME
Tanaka, T., Hyodo, Y.
Okayama University, Japan
A new method of medical safety education using a simulation game was developed.
An instruction illustration game was applied, response of participants measured and
educational effects investigated. Thirty-eight teachers joined the game. They were
assumed to be new nurses and received ambiguous instructions to bring a few
bottles of distilled water. They were requested to 1) illustrate the location of the
bottles, 2) to describe their action to the instruction, 3) show their illustrations to
each other and discuss them, and 4) describe what they felt and learned. As per an
analysis by Hayashi’s quantification method III (Hayashi, 1974), cognition of
learning has two axes - “individual-interpersonal” and “coping-cause”; “individual
effort” and “cooperation” were found; 2) preventive measures has “procedurecommunication” and “receiving instruction-sending instructions” axis; ”steadiness”
and “environment” were found. Content analysis showed that participants felt
anxiety, doubt, and difficulty during the game. It reminded them of mistakes in
transmissions in medical situations. Participants became aware of the different
interpretations and noticed dangers. They become more aware of how to prevent
errors. This learning will provide cognitive, behavioral, and emotional learning.
Keywords: medical safety education; simulation game; nurses
P 54
WHAT QUESTIONS DO RADIOGRAPHY STUDENTS HAVE ABOUT XRAY PHOTOGRAPHY?
Terashita, T.1, Kisa, K.2, Oshima, S.3
1
Faculty of Health Sciences, Hokkaido University, Japan
Healthcare Systems Research, Graduate School of Medicine, Hokkaido University,
Japan
3
Department of Psychology and Communication, School of Humanities, Hokusei
Gakuen University, Japan
2
232
We aimed to determine what questions radiography students have about X-ray
photography for introducing to lectures and trainings on X-ray photography.
We collected descriptions for questions on X-ray photography from radiography
students' reports after a X-ray photography training program. The descriptions were
assigned codes, and categorized by similar codes. From 111 students' reports, 348
descriptions were collected, from which the following 4 categories were created:
required knowledge, radiography services, radiographers' challenges, and patient
types. "Required knowledge" included anatomy, disease, and methodology required
for taking X-ray photographs. "Radiography services" included work profile of a
radiographer in a hospital. "Radiographers' challenges" included the unusual
situations that a radiographer encounters at work. "Patient types" included patients'
disease states, disorders, age, and gender. "Radiographers' challenges" and "patient
types" category included overlapping entities, for example, the question of "How
should a radiographer handle a patient with visual impairments?" or "May
radiographer induces pain in severely diseased patients on X-ray photography?"
Radiography students had concerns regarding whether they would be able to handle
patients efficiently in a real-time environment considering their limited experience
and knowledge. Radiography teachers should impart sufficient knowledge and
practical experience to students during lectures and while training.
Keywords: health provider's education; radiography students; X-ray photography's
question
P 55
PATIENTS PERCEPTION OF DIGNITY IN IRAN: A QUALITATIVE
CONTENT ANALYSIS
Torabizadeh, C.1, Ebrahimi, H.2, Mohammadi, E.3, Valizadeh, S.2
1
Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Iran
3
Tarbiat Modares University, Iran
2
The necessity of bringing patient’s dignity into wide use is being noticed in recent
years. There is no doubt that patient’s dignity in health care settings is often
devalued and its maintenance is crucial. The aim of this study was to explore the
Iranian patients’ perspective concerning their dignity.
By utilizing purposeful sampling, 20 patients, over an 11-months period were
233
interviewed in three educational hospitals in Iran. Qualitative content analysis was
used to identify recurring themes in the data.
Following data analyses, nine categories and four themes identified. Respondents
expressed their expectations and attitudes concerning dignity by the following
themes: Seeking for a haven; disrespecting privacy; communicating in vacuum; and
disregarding second-hand caregivers. They described how they feel dignified by
respect to their privacy, effective communication; access to facilities; and the
requirements for their companions. This study reveals that based on patient’s views;
there are still gaps in the conception, interpretation and consequent preservation of
dignity in the health care system of Iran. Healthcare professionals should be aware
of the factors that violate or preserve the dignity based on patient’s perspective.
Keywords: human rights; patient dignity; qualitative approach; content analysis
P 56
MATERNITY CARE EXPERIENCES OF CHILDBEARING SOUTH ASIAN
IMMIGRANT MOTHERS GIVING BIRTH IN FINLAND
Vehviläinen-Julkunen, K., Kumari Banjara, T., Kankkunen, P.
University of Eastern Finland, Finland
To investigate the experiences of maternity care of South Asian immigrant (SAI)
mothers who gave birth in Finland. 15 (SAI) mothers were interviewed for recording
in 2011. (SAI) mothers who got at least one child in Finland and could speak
English were interviewed at their residence. Data were analyzed by using qualitative
content analysis methods. Three major themes emerged: focusing on the positive,
identifying the negative and, making recommendations for improvement of
healthcare for immigrant childbearing women. Overall (SAI) mothers had positive
experiences with maternity care in Finland. This is particularly, to that when they
compared care quality in Finland with their home country. Despite of positive
experiences, mothers indicated the concern of their dissatisfactions associated with
language barrier, open communication between doctors and patients, and not
facilitated family centered care at hospital. So these findings have somewhat similar
with the findings of previous studies on immigrant’s perception of health care.
Attention given to eliminate the language barriers and provision of supportive
prenatal education could promote positive acceptance of health care among
immigrants child bearing mothers.
234
Keywords: maternity
communication
care
experiences;
South
Asian
immigrant
mothers;
P 57
ENGAGING THE VOICES OF MEN INVOLVED WITH IPV
Woolm, J.
San Diego State University, USA
Notions about why men engage in IPV are often influenced by the approaches
mental health providers take to treat them. Current IPV paradigms construct
knowledge about the identities of men involved with IPV with little to no
consideration of how men themselves conceptualize and experience how violence
shows up in their lives. This paper explores and expands on ideas about IPV by
incorporating the stories of men who are most influenced by it.
Keywords: IPV; social construction; identity; dominant and local knowledge; power
P 58
SUPPORTIVE RELATIONSHIP: EXPERIENCES OF IRANIAN STUDENTS
AND TEACHERS CONCERNING STUDENT-TEACHER RELATIONSHIP
IN CLINICAL NURSING EDUCATION
Yaghoubinia, F., Heydari, A., Latifnejad Roudsari, R.
School of Nursing & Midwifery, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Iran.
Student-teacher relationship is a salient issue in nursing education and has longlasting implication in professional development of nursing students. This
relationship is valuable in clinical nursing education and can be facilitated through
various ways. Nowadays, this relationship in clinical settings is different from the
past due to changing in nursing education paradigm and its emphasis on the
centrality of the student- teacher relationship. This study was conducted to explore
the students and teachers’ experiences about student-teacher relationship in the
context of clinical nursing education in Iran.
This qualitative research is a part of findings of a grounded theory study in which 6
235
bachelor nursing students with apprenticeship experience and 6 clinical educators
with at least one year of clinical education experience who worked at Mashhad
University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran were selected through purposive
sampling. Semi- structured interview and participant observation were used for data
generation. Interviews transcribed verbatim and analyzed by Strauss and Corbin
method.
Findings from data analysis showed four major categories about supportive
relationship in clinical nursing education including Educational, Emotional and
Social support, along with an awareness of being supported.
The results showed that in Iranian socio-cultural context, supportive relationship has
been propounded as one of the major features of effective relationship in clinical
education from nursing students and teachers’ point of view.
Keywords: clinical nursing education; supportive relationship; experiences; grounded
theory
P 59
BONE SET THERAPY EXPERIENCED BY LOW BACK PAIN PATIENTS
Yim, B-K.1, Park, I-S.2, Lee, J-H.3, Choi, S-M.1
1
University of Science and Technology, Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Korea
College of Nursing Chungnam National University,Korea, Korea
3
Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Korea
2
Bone set therapy is one of the traditional manual therapies which have been used to
treat musculoskeletal disorders resulted from trauma and come to a crisis of
extinction. But, it is found that there are still patients who visit bonesetter’s offices
to treat their low back pain. The purpose of this study is to identify the essence of
bone set therapy experienced by those patients.
The current study was approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB No. I1110/005-001) and planned by phenomenological methods among qualitative
studies. In-depth interviews with six patients who visit and treat their low back pain
in a bonesetter’s office at Busan were completed and was analyzed based on a
Collaizzi’s phenomenological method.
The interviews were classified into three categories as follows: “low back pain
coming with great amounts of pain”, “Korean and Western medicinal treatment with
no clear effects”, “treatment by hand is the best for a misaligned low back pain”.
236
Patients often caused misunderstanding because they couldn’t actively participate in
social activities due to their low back pain or frustrated by their incompetence to
finish their work in time. They also visited a hospital to treat their pains but had no
reactions even after getting an injection or rather felt worse due to formal treatment.
Most of them visited bonesetter’s offices by the introduction of their acquaintances.
At first, they felt nervous and great pains in the process of treatment, but after a
certain period of treatment, they felt much easier in their back and refreshment.
The therapeutic effects by a unique treatment called bone set experienced by low
back pain patients who have no effects from the institutional treatment were
reported in the current qualitative research. Through this finding, it is considered
that further study on more objective and detailed therapeutic effects should be
conducted.
Keywords: bone set therapy; low back pain; phenomenological approach; qualitative
research
P 60
FACTORS INFLUENCING THE MEANING OF LIFE IN THE OLD IN
LONG-TERM INPATIENTS FOR SCHIZOPHRENIA
Yuko, W.1, Narumi, F.2
1
2
International University of Health and Welfare, School of Nursing at Fukuoka, Japan
Kyushu University, Japan
Elderly long-term inpatients with schizophrenia of psychiatric hospitals are
generally in a state liable to lose the will of positive living and also the hope for the
future because of their symptoms of schizophrenia such as weakened motivation and
flattering of emotion along with so-called hospitalism (Yoneyama 1992 and Inaoka
1997). It is thought that whether a person can achieve ego integration in the old
(Erikson 2002) is depending on the way of life until then and recognition for it.
Even if a person has mental disorder, ego integration would be achieved by finding
out the meaning of life by remembering what seems good in one’s own past life. In
this study, factors influencing the meaning of life in the old were investigated with
elderly long-term schizophrenia inpatients to obtain helpful suggestions for nursing
practice. The meaning of life for the elderly in the final stage of development was
defined as to find out the worth living and the significance to live in the old as well
as in the present/past circumstances through looking back upon one’s own particular
237
life, and also find out one’s goal of life though they are in physically, mentally and
socially disturbed conditions and objectively not in hopeful circumstances.
Subjects: Among patients with schizophrenia during admission in two private
psychiatric hospitals, nine patients at age 65 or more whose hospitalization was 5
years or more were used as the subjects. Informed consent was obtained from them
after the aims of this study were explained orally and in writing.
A qualitative inductive survey was made through semi-constitutive interview in the
period July ~ November 2009.
The data were analyzed by Grounded Theory Approach (GTA) method according to
Strauss & Corbin (1988)and Saiki Kraybill (2008).
This study was conducted with approvals from the ethical review board of the
university to which the author had belonged and the ethical review board of the
facility of joint research.
The mean age of 9 subjects (5 males and 4 females) was 71.7 years and the mean
age of onset was 30.8 years. The mean duration of disease was 40.8 years and the
mean hospitalization was 22.1 years. In this study, one category and 11
subcategories were extracted as the central concept. The category was “confidence
and pride valuable to support a life in the old”, which was chosen as an important
factor by all members concerned in this study. And 11 factors extracted as
subcategory were “feasibility of hope”, “will expression of hope”, “friendship with
surrounding people”, “medical care and nursing given”, “wisdom for living in the
old with the disease”, “grope and efforts to realize one’s hope”, “anxiety for own
future life”, “worry about the onset of disease”, “satisfaction in inpatient life”,
“abandonment of one’s hope” and “realization of alternative hope”.
It was demonstrated that the subjects were able to keep “the confidence and pride to
support their living in the old” and continuously made efforts and groped to realize
their hope making full use of their wisdom for living in the old as a patient even if
the feasibility of hope was low. The wisdom is to find out a knack to positively live
one’s life with the disease as settling various problems in their circumstances
through overcoming the worry about the onset of disease. And it was suggested that
full use of the wisdom would stimulate the will toward one’s hope, resulting in its
realization. Therefore, we thought that nursing practice paying more attention to
patient’s desire and respecting their confidence and pride valuable for living in the
old would lead to a support for patient’s independent life (self-standing and selfdirecting). For advancement of patient’s life and improvement of QOL, it is the first
step of nursing practice to take a great interest in patient’s particular life and make a
design for support program together with the patient aiming at the greatest selfactualization by himself/herself.
Keywords: the meaning of life; elderly long-term in patients; schizophrenia
238
P 61
NURSES’ LIVED EXPERIENCE OF NIGHT SHIFT: NARRATIVES,
MEANINGFUL EPISODES AND METAPHORS. IMPLICATIONS FOR
NURSING EDUCATION
Zannini, L.1, Ghitti, G.2, Martin, S.3, Saiani, L.4
1
Faculty of Medicine, Università di Milano, Italy
Lecturer, School of Nursing, Università di Brescia, Italy
3
Servizio Formazione, Azienda ULSS Vicenza, Italy
4
Faculty of Medicine, Università di Verona, Italy
2
The negative impact of night shift on nurses’ health and social life has been
extensively analyzed. Nevertheless, a few studies have explored nurses’ lived
experience of night shift.
Thirty-five nurses, coming from 3 hospitals of Northern Italy, were purposively
sampled and interviewed in 2009. Interviews were analyzed following an
Interpretative Phenomenological Approach. Meaningful episodes and metaphors
were elicited from interviews and mapped.
During night shifts, nurses consider themselves more responsible for patients’ care
and surveillance; a negative emotional climate prevail, but expert nurses and
collaborative physicians can help; senses are used differently and hearing prevails
over the others; the relationship with patients and colleagues changes and new
learning opportunities arise, although this shift is considered as highly demanding
both from a physical and a psychological point of view. Meaningful episodes mainly
concern stories of patients who died. Prevalent metaphors of the night shift evocate
a sense of solitude and unpredictability.
Night shift is perceived as an enriching experience, but it mostly takes place in an
emotional context characterized by anxiety, fear of patient’s death and loneliness.
To cope with it, a great deal of emotional work is carried on by nurses. Students
should be adequately trained to this challenging activity.
Keywords: interpretative phenomenological analysis; lived experience; night shift;
nursing education
239
P 62
THE JOINT OUTPATIENT CLINIC (JOC): A TOOL FOR IMPROVING
RELATIONSHIPS AMONG DIABETOLOGISTS AND DIABETICS IN
TRANSITION FROM PEDIATRICS TO ADULT HEALTH CARE SERVICE
Zito, E.1, Adamo. S.M.G.2, Siani, G.1, Racioppi, F.1
1
2
Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II, Italy
Università degli Studi di Milano Bicocca, Italy
The JOC is a place where young patients in transition meet, for the first time, adult
diabetologists, in the presence of their pediatricians. The aims of the study were to
determine the emotional climate of the institution during the JOC and the
unconscious emotional aspects of the doctor-patient relationship which may
influence the transition process.
Five non-participant observations, according to the psychodynamic approach, have
been conducted during five sessions of seven JOCs performed in pediatrics, for a
total of 35 patients (20M, mean age 21.8±1.7). The protocols of the observations
were supervised and discussed in group in order to trace the main emotional
dynamics related to the relationships between institution, doctors and patients.
All the actors of the JOC felt intense concerns related to the transition process and
derived from the knowledge that the young patient must leave a familiar place to
rely on a new unknown medical staff, experienced in phantasy as unreliable.
The return of the observations allows medical teams to reflect on their unconscious
defensive dynamics which, in addition to the other intrapsychic and relational
problems of the young patient to pass, can make the transition process even more
inaccessible.
Keywords: diabetes; transition; joint outpatient clinic; non-participant observation
240
Author index
Abdollahy, H............................... 219
Antoft, R..................................... 109
Achille, M................................... 175
Arellano-García, E. ..................... 179
Adamo. S.M.G. ........................... 240
Aresi, G. ....................................... 48
Aghamohammadi, M................... 189
Armeni, M.E. ................................ 91
Agnetti, B.................................... 141
Artman, A. .................................. 111
Al Fahel, R.................................... 46
Arzani, A. ................................... 192
Alagna, R. ..................................... 24
Asplund, K.................................. 209
Alauria, F. ................................... 228
Axpe-Caballero, A. ..................... 120
Alimohammadi, H................. 82; 190
Ayala, R.A. ................................... 48
Allen, D. ....................................... 45
Azarkolah, A............................... 190
Almog, N. ................................... 112
Azuri, P......................................... 79
Alnajjar, Z..................................... 46
Bach, M. ..................................... 193
Alvarez, A........................... 191; 227
Badiei, Z. .................................... 126
Amato, L..................................... 228
Badro, V. ...................................... 45
Ambrosi, E.................................. 125
Balconi, M. ................................... 49
Amodeo, A.L. ............................... 47
Baltrusaityte, G. ............................ 50
Anania, S. ................................... 113
Bandettini di Poggio, A. ................ 30
Andreassen, S.............................. 206
Barello, S. ................................... 193
241
Bartesaghi, M................................ 51
Bruni, A. ....................................... 55
Bassi, M...................................... 165
Bruno, A. ...................................... 56
Battisti, N.................................... 223
Brunoldi, A. .................................. 24
Bean, R. ...................................... 130
Bruscaglioni, L............................ 169
Belanger, E. .................................. 52
Buffa, G.M.................................. 228
Bellardita, L. ................................. 53
Burti, L. ...................................... 194
Bellchambers, H............................ 76
Caiata-Zufferey, M........................ 56
Belli, S. ................................. 54; 125
Caird, J. ........................................ 34
Bellotti, F. ..................................... 85
Calabrese, G.................................. 57
Beppu, H..................................... 158
Calvi, C......................................... 58
Berti, L........................................ 194
Camarena-Ojinaga, L. ................. 179
Bevilacqua, A................................ 54
Camerino, D.................................. 26
Binaghi, T. .......................... 104; 211
Camilli, B. .................................... 59
Bjørner, J.B. ................................ 128
Campbell, F. ................................. 32
Boccia, G. ................................... 196
Canga, A....................................... 59
Bonfioli, E. ................................. 194
Cannata, A. ................................. 149
Bonnema, S.J. ............................. 128
Cantù, C...................................... 173
Booth, A. ...................................... 32
Canzan, F.................................... 125
Borghi, C. ..................................... 30
Capodiferro, N. ............................. 26
Bortolazzi, E. ................................ 43
Capone, V. .................................. 225
Bosco, N. .................................... 195
Cardell, B................................ 60; 66
Bosio, A.C. ....................... 10; 21; 36
Carey, M.A. ........................ 130; 150
Bracco, F....................................... 56
Cargo, M............................. 204; 229
Bracke, P....................................... 48
Carniel, G. .............................. 25; 26
Brancadoro, B. ............................ 171
Carpinelli, L................................ 196
Brown, C..................................... 181
Carr, E. ....................................... 182
Browne, J. ..................................... 76
Carr, T. ....................................... 122
242
Caso, D. ...................................... 225
Choi, C.H.................................... 198
Cassardo, C. ................................ 113
Choi, H. ........................................ 65
Castaldi, M.G. ............................... 24
Choi, S-M. .................................. 236
Castaldo A. ................................... 23
Choi, S-Y.................................... 215
Castaldo, A. ............................ 25; 26
Chong, A. ................................... 204
Castelnuovo, G.............................. 39
Chotibang, J. ............................... 167
Castiglioni, M. .................... 146; 179
Chung, B.R. ................................ 200
Cattaneo, A. ................................ 134
Chung, S.E...................198; 199; 200
Cavada, L.................................... 125
Chung, Y.S. ................................ 200
Cavalieri d'Oro, C.......................... 26
Cicero, L. .................................... 228
Cavallo, A..................................... 61
Cicognani, E. .......................... 20; 65
Cavallo, P.................................... 196
Cisneros Puebla, C.A..................... 16
Caverzasi, E. ............................... 224
Clark, A. ............................. 176; 177
Celleghin, E. ................................. 41
Clark, L......................................... 66
erniauskait , M. ........................ 207
Cohen, R....................................... 45
Cha, C......................................... 197
Colangelo, L. ................................ 67
Cha, M. ....................................... 197
Colbourn, C. ............................... 116
Chadwick, R. .............................. 116
Conway, P..................................... 26
Chan, E. ........................................ 62
Corbin, J.M. .................................. 16
Chan, S.S.C................................... 63
Corbo, M. ..................................... 26
Chareonwong, S. ........................... 64
Cordella, B.................................... 91
Cheraghi, F. ................................ 198
Cortese, C.G........................ 201; 202
Chiang, H-H................................ 115
Costa, P....................................... 169
Chiari, A. .................................... 141
Costa, V.T................................... 217
Chiesi, L. .................................... 169
Costa-Reis, A. ............................... 68
Ching, K.K.................................. 130
Covelli, S. ................................... 208
Chirawatkul, S............................... 64
Covelli, V. .................................. 207
243
Cox, K. ....................................... 123
Dinmohammadi, M. ...................... 72
Crippa, R....................................... 30
Dipex International Members ...... 119
Crivelli, D. .................................... 49
Dolcetti, F.R................................ 223
Croot, L. ....................................... 32
Domont de Serpa, O. ..................... 73
Crotti, E. 1 .................................... 25
Donegani, S. ................................. 53
Cullinan, T. ................................. 174
Donizzetti, A.R. .......................... 225
Cumer, F. ...................................... 85
Donovan, J. ................................... 74
Cupp, P. ........................................ 82
Dornig, K...................................... 96
Cuzzocrea, F. .............................. 203
Doucet, S. ................................... 122
D’Angelo, C.................................. 89
Duckmanton, C. ............................ 32
Da Silva, D.M.G.V...................... 124
Dwyer Kent, R. ............................. 75
Dabbaghi, F................................. 211
Eberle, C. ...................................... 85
Dahal, K........................................ 69
Ebert, L......................................... 76
Daniel, M. ................................... 204
Ebrahimi, H. ............................... 233
Daum, C...................................... 214
Egberg, L. ................................... 206
Dawes, P. .................................... 210
Eidelman, S................................. 105
Dawson, A. ................................. 204
Emami, M. .................................. 170
Dazzi, D...................................... 141
Emide, E. ...................................... 79
De Ambrogi, F. ............................. 70
Erdmann, A.L. ............................ 217
de Angelis, G. ............................... 26
Esposito, F. ................................. 171
de La Cuesta-Benjumea, C. ........... 70
Evans, A.E. ................................... 90
Delle Fave, A. ..................... 157; 165
Evans, D. ...................................... 33
Denyer-Willis, L ........................... 45
Faini, F. ........................................ 77
Depergola, V............................... 205
Favretto, A.R. ............................... 78
Di Blasi, M. .................................. 71
Feder-Bubis, P. ............................. 79
Di Falco, G. .................................. 71
Feldt-Rasmussen, U. ................... 128
Dickson, K. ................................... 34
Fellin, L. ................................. 67; 79
244
Ferguson, A................................... 76
Gallo, A. ....................................... 24
Fermani, E. ............................. 28; 29
Galuppo, L. ................................... 87
Fethney, J.................................... 123
Gangi, O. .................................... 208
Fianco, A. ................................... 165
Gao, M........................................ 181
Fioretti, C...................................... 80
Gau, B. ....................................... 114
Fiorini, I...................................... 194
Gazzola, M.............................. 25; 26
Fisher, M.J. ................................... 95
Ghedin, E.................................... 156
Fitzpatrick, S............................... 123
Ghislandi, P. ................................. 85
Fleischmann, A. ............................ 81
Ghislieri, C.................................. 202
Fongkaew, W. ............................... 82
Ghitti, G...................................... 239
Ford, E. ....................................... 136
Giaccherini, S.............................. 195
Ford-Gilboe, M. .......................... 183
Giancaspro, M.L. ........................ 206
Forloni, S. ..................................... 48
Giannini, A. ................................ 110
Forough, R. ................................. 219
Gilardi, S. ..................................... 85
Fossati, I. ............................ 110; 113
Ginex V. ....................................... 28
Fouladi, N. ............................ 82; 190
Giordano, A. ................................. 26
Francascani, A............................... 30
Giorgino, V.M.B. .......................... 86
Francato, S. ................................... 44
Giovannetti, A.M. ....................... 207
Francesconi, D. ............................. 83
Giovannetti, M. ........................... 208
Freda, M.F. ......................... 149; 186
Gobbi, P............................ 24; 25; 26
Friberg, F. ................................... 130
Gobo G. ........................................ 21
Frigerio, A. ................................... 84
Gobo, G. ....................................... 17
Fucci, S......................................... 58
Goncalves, L. .............................. 191
Fumagalli N. ................................. 28
Gonçalves, L. .............................. 227
Fumagalli, N. .......................... 28; 30
González-Castro, I....................... 120
Furlong, K................................... 122
Goodwin, V. ................................. 87
Gaffney, P................................... 161
Gorli, M. ....................................... 87
245
Gough, B....................................... 88
Harris, J. ................................. 31; 32
Govi, C. ...................................... 208
Harris, M. ..................................... 94
Goyder, E...................................... 32
Hart, O.......................................... 32
Gozzoli, C..................................... 89
Harvey, I.S.................................. 209
Graffigna, G. 17; 21; 36; 53; 193; 216
Hayes, L...................................... 123
Granatiero, O. ............................... 53
Haylen, D...................................... 95
Grassi, E. ...................................... 90
Hedegus, L.................................. 128
Greco, F. ....................................... 91
Heidary, A. ................................. 101
Greco, M.M. ................................. 90
Heilemann, M. .............................. 96
Groenvold, M.............................. 128
Hernández-Padilla, M.................... 97
Groleau, D. ................................... 52
Heydari, A. ......................... 184; 235
Guedes, M................................... 137
Holewa, H..................................... 98
Gueta, K........................................ 92
Holland, F. .................................... 98
Gugliandolo, M.C........................ 203
Hong, D-G. ................................. 215
Guglielmetti, C.............................. 85
Hori, K.......................................... 99
Guiddi, P....................................... 40
Hørslev-Petersen, K. ................... 109
Gullo, S....................................... 228
Hosseini Shahidi, L. ............ 100; 101
Gundjarranbuy, R........................ 117
Hosseini, S.M.............................. 211
Häggström, M. ............................ 209
Hovey, R..................................... 102
Hai-Gwo, H................................. 162
Hsu, C.H. .................................... 117
Halliday, L. ................................... 93
Hutchinson, T. .............................. 45
Ham, B-H.................................... 215
Hvalvik, S. .................................. 102
Hameed, W. .................................. 32
Hyodo, Y. ................................... 232
Han, S-W. ................................... 215
Iba, N.......................................... 158
Hanson, C. .................................... 32
Ieshima, A....................103; 176; 185
Harding, R. ................................. 139
Jensen, L.D. ................................ 210
Hardy, P...................................... 106
Jeon, B.J. .................................... 215
246
Jones, C. ..................................... 133
Larcan, R. ................................... 203
Kai, J. ......................................... 174
Latifnejad Roudsari, R.106; 111; 184;
Kankkunen, P.............................. 234
235
Karimi Moonaghi, H. .......... 104; 211
Lattuada, P. ................................... 57
Karimollahi, M............................ 212
Laupacis, A................................. 137
Karnieli-Miller, O. ...................... 105
Lavery, J. .................................... 137
Katsikitis, M. .............................. 133
Lavie-Ajayi, M.................... 112; 119
Keeping-Burke, L........................ 122
Lavoie, M. .................................. 214
Kenny, A..................................... 106
Lax, J. ......................................... 111
Khadivzadeh, T. .................. 106; 111
Leal, E. ......................................... 73
Khazaeipour, Z............................ 107
Lee, J-H. ..................................... 236
Kidd, S........................................ 106
Lee, J-S....................................... 215
Kim, D.M.................................... 108
Lee, O-J. ..................................... 215
Kim, M. .............................. 199; 200
Lee, S.......................................... 215
Kisa, K........................................ 232
Légaré, F....................................... 52
Koch, T.F...................................... 48
Lekkas, P. ..................................... 33
Kong, E....................................... 213
Leonardi,. M. .............................. 207
Konradsen, H. ............................. 213
Leone, D. .................................... 113
Kristiansen, L.............................. 209
Liao, Y........................................ 114
Kristiansen, T.M. ........................ 109
Libreri, C. ................................... 216
Krumer-Nevo, L.......................... 112
Little, C....................................... 182
Kumari Banjara, T....................... 234
Liu, Y-C...................................... 115
Kumdee, B. ................................... 64
Lo Coco, G. ................................ 228
Lam, T.H. ..................................... 63
Logue, L. .................................... 116
Lamiani, G. ................................. 110
Lowell, A.................................... 117
Lanou, A. ............................ 111; 140
Lozza, E........................................ 36
Laplante-Lévesque, A.................. 210
Lu, Z........................................... 117
247
Macdonald, M.E...................... 45; 52
Masumi, A. ................................... 82
Maezawa, M. .............................. 223
Matsuo, H. .................................. 181
Magalhães Dahl, C. ....................... 73
Mattiasson, A.C. ......................... 206
Magnani, T.................................... 53
Mayan, M. ............................ 18; 214
Magri, M................................. 25; 26
Maypilama, E.............................. 117
Magrin, M.E................................ 160
Mazzola, A.................................... 41
Mahram, B. ................................. 100
Mazzoni, D. .................................. 65
Mahtani Chugani, V. ................... 120
Mc Ardle, S................................. 161
Mahtani-Chugani, V. ................... 119
McAllister, M. ............................ 133
Malajovich Muñoz, N.................... 73
McCloskey, R. ............................ 122
Mamdani, M. .............................. 137
McCormack, D............................ 122
Manuti, A............................ 205; 206
McKenzie, H............................... 123
Manzoni, G.M............................... 39
McKinstry, C. ............................. 106
Marchand, R. ................................ 52
Mehrdad, N................................... 72
Marchesin, D................................. 59
Meirelles, B.H.S.................. 124; 217
Mariani, C..................................... 28
Melo Ferrari, T.............................. 26
Mariani, L. .................................... 26
Menezes, I................................... 137
Marini, E..................................... 160
Meringolo, P. .............................. 195
Marioni, L..................................... 24
Merritt-Gray, M. ......................... 183
Marks, K. ...................................... 88
Messina, L. ................................... 90
Marsico, G. ................................. 196
Meucci, P.................................... 207
Marta, E. ................................. 40; 48
Miceli, R....................................... 26
Martin, S. .................................... 239
Miciak, M. .................................. 214
Martínez-Valdés, C. .................... 179
Miglioretti, M. ...................... 37; 178
Martino, M.L............................... 149
Miles, N. ..................................... 161
Martis, L. .................................... 121
Miller, B. ...................................... 82
Martyn, K.................................... 122
Minato, M. .................................. 218
248
Minetti, E. ..................................... 41
Nencini, A................................... 146
Mirmajidi-Hashjin, S.Z................ 107
Neufeld-Kroszynski, G................ 105
Modanloo, M.M. ......................... 219
Nexo, M.A. ................................. 128
Mohamad Khon Kermanshahi, S. 229
Nielsen, C. .................................. 210
Mohammadi, E............................ 233
Nishihara, A................................ 222
Molinari, E.................................... 39
Noci, C. ........................................ 25
Montali, L. .................................... 84
Noroozi Javidan, A...................... 107
Monteiro Peixoto, M. .................... 73
Norton, E. ................................... 129
Morse, J. ................................. 15; 35
Oasi, O........................................ 224
Morse, J.M. ................................... 18
Odell, A. ..................................... 130
Mortari, L.................................... 125
Öhlén, J....................................... 130
Mui, M.......................................... 63
Oliver, K....................................... 34
Muntanyola, D. ............................. 54
Olson, K...................................... 213
Muntanyola-Saura, D. ................. 125
Oprescu, F....................131; 132; 133
Muthana, A. .................................. 32
Origlia, C. ................................... 134
Muttillo G. .................................... 23
Oshima, S. .......................... 223; 232
Muttillo, G. ............................. 25; 26
Oskouei, S.F.H............................ 211
Myburgh, C................................. 143
Ostermann, S.M. ......................... 135
Naji, H. ....................................... 170
Pagnini, F...................................... 39
Nakagawa, T. .............................. 220
Pais, S. ........................................ 137
Nakahara, J. ................................ 220
Palmieri, P. ................................. 136
Nakano, M. ................................. 220
Paolino, D. .................................... 85
Namnabati, M. ............................ 126
Pare, A.......................................... 45
Nani, C........................................ 127
Pari,C............................................ 24
Narumi, F............................ 221; 237
Park, H.......................................... 65
Naval, C........................................ 59
Park, I-S...................................... 236
Negri, L. ..................................... 157
Park, S.Y..................................... 200
249
Parolin, L.L. ................................ 140
Poggenpoel, M. ........................... 143
Parsons, J. ................................... 137
Polaro, S. .................................... 227
Pasqui, S. ...................................... 30
Politano, L. ................................. 186
Passalacqua, A. ........................... 223
Popovici, S.................................. 143
Passey, R....................................... 32
Popper-Giveon, A. ...................... 144
Passoni, C. .................................... 24
Portis, L. ....................................... 90
Pavesi, N..................................... 148
Possick, C. .................................. 145
Peel, E......................................... 139
Pozzi, M........................................ 40
Pepe, N.L. ................................... 224
Prandi, E. .................................... 110
Perkins, N. .................................... 30
Prati, M....................................... 146
Perno, A........................................ 43
Pretto, A.............................. 147; 148
Perrotta, M. ................................. 140
Primdahl, J. ................................. 109
Pesteh, K..................................... 107
Purfarzi, F. .................................... 82
Peterson, K.....................98; 111; 140
Qureshi, N................................... 174
Petrillo, G.................................... 225
Racioppi, F.................................. 240
Petrini, F. .................................... 195
Raffaeta, R. ................................. 148
Pett, M. ......................................... 66
Rainone, N. ................................. 149
Peyrovi, H..................................... 72
Rasmussen, A.K.......................... 128
Phillimore, P. .............................. 187
Ravanelli, L. ............................... 134
Piasentini, A................................ 226
Ray, D.V..................................... 150
Picariello, S................................... 47
Rees, R. ........................................ 34
Pieters, H. ..................................... 96
Rees., R. ....................................... 31
Pietrabissa, G. ............................... 39
Reicher, S. .................................... 79
Ping-Chuan, H............................. 162
Reierson, I.A............................... 102
Pino, O........................................ 141
Reuter, A .................................... 193
Pisani, L...................................... 166
Rezaee, B.................................... 170
Pleschberger, S............................ 142
Richardson-Tench, M.................. 151
250
Riva, M....................................... 208
Sawada, A................................... 158
River, J........................................ 123
Sayama, M. ................................. 222
Rizzi, C......................................... 55
Scandurra, C. ................................ 47
Rocco, G. ...................................... 90
Scaratti, G. .................................... 87
Roddis, J. .................................... 152
Schreyögg, G. ............................. 135
Rodeschini, G.............................. 152
Schwind, J................................... 159
Rodiek, S. ..................................... 28
Scrignaro, M. .............................. 160
Rodriguez, C. ................................ 52
Sena, E........................................ 191
Rodríguez-Morales, L.................. 153
Senes, G............................ 28; 29; 30
Roe, B........................................... 70
Shahsavari, H. ............................. 170
Romero, D. ................................. 154
Shamsaei F.................................. 229
Rosa, D. ........................................ 24
Shamsaei, F................................. 198
Rowland, W. ............................... 137
Sheridan, G. ................................ 161
Ryan, K....................................... 182
Shih-Pi, L.................................... 162
Saaranen, T. ................................ 173
Shimanouchi, A........................... 220
Sabatino, L.................................... 90
Shuurmans, B.............................. 111
Sacks, E. ..................................... 155
Siani, G....................................... 240
Sadegh Moghdam, L. .................. 101
Signa, C. ..................................... 228
Saiani, L...................................... 239
Smith, J....................................... 166
Saita, E.................................... 38; 41
Smith, J.A. .................................... 19
Sakuma-Sato, R........................... 119
Smorti, A. ..................................... 80
Sakuma-Sato, S. .......................... 158
Soerensen, M. ............................. 163
Salerno, L.................................... 228
Solano, L. ................................... 163
Santi, M. ..................................... 156
Solberg, S. .................................. 164
Sartori, R..................................... 157
Soosai Nathan, L. ........................ 165
Sato, S......................................... 220
Sormunen, M. ............................. 173
Savarese, G. ................................ 196
Sossai, D....................................... 56
251
Sozzi M......................................... 28
Tazakori, Z.................................. 190
Sozzi, M................................ 49; 166
Terashita, T................................. 232
Sperotto, M. .................................. 42
Teucher, U. ................................. 170
Spiers, J. ..................................... 166
Thomas, J...................................... 34
Springett, J. ................................... 32
Tomai, M. ................................... 171
Sridharan, S................................. 137
Tomazic, T.................................. 181
Sripichyakan, K........................... 167
Tonnera, L.C.J. ........................... 124
Stankiewicz, G. ........................... 168
Torabinejad, S. ............................ 170
Stankov, I.................................... 229
Torabizadeh, C............................ 233
Stewart, H. .................................. 204
Torrigiani, C. .............................. 172
Stievano, A. .................................. 90
Tossavainen, K............................ 173
Stiffler, D. ................................... 150
Tresoldi, V. ................................... 53
Strada, M. ................................... 178
Turchi, G.P. .................................. 41
Suarez, M...................................... 65
Turunen, H.................................. 173
Sullivan, E. ................................... 93
Tzannis, A................................... 173
Surrenti, S. .................................. 169
Tzeng, Y. .................................... 114
Suzuki, T..................................... 222
Ulph, F........................................ 174
Tabakhan, M. .............................. 170
Ummel, D. ............................ 45; 175
Tabolli, S. ................................... 223
Urata, Y. ......................103; 176; 185
Takagi, M.................................... 230
Urbano, C.A................................ 185
Takahama, A............................... 231
Valdagni, R................................... 53
Taleghani, F. ............................... 170
Valizadeh, L................................ 126
Tamanza, G................................... 89
Valizadeh, S................................ 233
Tanaka, T. ........................... 231; 232
van Cleemput, P. ........................... 32
Tanucci, G. ................................. 205
Vanaki, Z. ................................... 229
Tarozzi, M. ....................... 19; 20; 83
Vandall-Walker, V. ............. 176; 177
Tartari, M.................................... 202
Varcoe, C.................................... 183
252
Vecchio, L. ........................... 37; 178
Yaghoubinia, F.................... 184; 235
Vegni, E.......................110; 113; 193
Yamada, Y. ..................103; 176; 185
Vehviläinen-Julkunen, K. ............ 234
Yigusang, R. ................................. 64
Velasco, V. ................................. 178
Yim, B-K. ................................... 236
Veronese, G. ............................... 179
Yuko, W. ............................ 221; 237
Vigato, F. ...................................... 30
Yuni, J. ....................................... 185
Vivar, C. ....................................... 59
Yuri, F. ....................................... 221
von Glascoe, C. ........................... 179
Zaccaro, A. ................................. 186
Watt, T........................................ 128
Zaltron, F. ..................................... 78
Werner, P. ................................... 105
Zaman, S..................................... 187
White, K. .................................... 123
Zamanzadeh, V. .......................... 126
Wildner, J.................................... 180
Zanetti, E. ............................... 25; 26
Wilkie, D. ..................................... 65
Zanini, S. ...................................... 41
Wilkins, E. .................................... 32
Zannini, L. .................................. 239
Williams, T. .................................. 32
Zhou, Q......................................... 63
Willougby, L............................... 181
Ziebland, S.................................. 119
Woodman, J. ................................. 34
Zito, E......................................... 240
Woolm, J..................................... 235
Zoppi M........................................ 37
Worswick, L. .............................. 182
Zoubin, F. ................................... 104
Wuest, J. ..................................... 183
253
254
Key words
Aboriginal people; 102
Australia; 117; 204
Action Research; 56; 64; 92; 150;
170; 181; 186
addiction; 93; 154; 172
ADHD; 81; 84
adherence/compliance; 78; 220; 224
adolescents; 82; 207; 230
aggression; 143
alcohol/alcoholism; 148
art-based research; 56; 167; 196; 214
body image; 111
breastfeeding; 92
Brokered Dialogue (BD); 137
bullying; 70
cancer; 81; 124; 131; 163; 170; 171;
201
breast; 83
cervical; 150; 223
genetic; 57
pain; 114
prostate; 53; 159
skin; 129
caregivers/caregiving; 60; 71; 81;
110; 115; 124; 139; 177; 178; 192;
198; 208; 213; 220; 225; 227; 228;
229
case study; 78; 86; 147; 174; 182;
231
children; 78; 90; 115; 139; 157; 167;
203; 208
chronic illness and disease; 85; 102;
117; 167; 188; 210; 217
arthritis; 95; 109
asthma; 115
diabetes; 55; 168; 189; 240
hearing loss; 199; 211
kidney; 45; 167; 231
LAM; 96
lupus; 66
neurology; 108; 116; 158; 166; 192
osteoarthritis; 118
osteoporosis; 94
peripheral vascular diseases; 206
255
psoriasis; 224
thrombophilia; 152
thyroid disease; 129
chronic pain; 113; 237
Colaizzi; 200; 201
communication, medical; 105; 121;
159; 175
Community-Based Participatory
Research (CBPR); 32; 63; 155
community-based program; 32; 222
Community-Based Research (CBR);
181
constructivism; 109
coping and adaptation; 160
cross-cultural; 136; 165; 188
death and dying; 104
decision-making; 53; 187
dignity; 234
disabilities; 61; 67; 165; 208
Discourse Analysis; 52; 53; 84; 97;
139
donation
blood; 38
kidney; 38; 175
eating disorders; 161; 228
education
patients; 109
professionals; 55; 62; 72; 101; 182;
184; 190; 212; 232; 233; 236;
239
elderly; 60; 100; 103; 135; 153; 171;
181; 186; 199; 205; 210; 213; 220;
227; 238
emotions; 54; 59; 220
256
empowerment; 47; 106; 148; 165;
181
end-of-life; 110
ethics; 24; 123; 132; 151
Ethnography; 45; 49; 54; 69; 88; 135;
142
cognitive; 126
Event History Calendar (EHC); 122
fertility/infertility; 112; 140; 146
GIS mapping; 210
Grounded Theory; 48; 60; 67; 70; 81;
83; 97; 107; 121; 130; 152; 175;
177; 178; 183; 184; 209; 212; 236;
238
healing; 28; 145
health and illness
social construction; 58
health care
professionals; 100; 195; 211
services; 88; 172; 178; 193; 196;
208
teamwork; 52; 72; 126; 166
work environment; 169
health policy; 137; 188
health promotion; 42; 61; 63; 129;
173; 218
Hermeneutics; 102
HIV/AIDS; 124; 156
immigrants/migrants; 71; 181; 226;
235
Intensive Care Unit (ICU); 135; 209
cardiology; 177; 178; 181
neonatal; 127; 192
pediatric; 110
Interpretative Phenomenological
Analysis (IPA); 67; 73; 77; 80; 99;
113; 114; 116; 129; 146; 154; 167;
175; 187; 239
involvement, patient; 79
learning/teaching strategies; 182
life history; 96; 104; 118; 185
medicalization; 153
medicine,complementary and
alternative; 59; 95; 147
men's health; 70; 88; 154; 159; 235
mental health and illness; 51; 52; 72;
87; 97; 106; 195; 196; 221; 226
bipolar disorder; 198; 229
borderline personality disorder;
225
dementia; 100; 105; 128; 213
depression; 80; 88; 97; 197
schizophrenia; 73; 162; 218; 238
mixed methods; 35; 50; 90; 136; 204
mothers/mothering; 77; 93; 146; 165;
192; 201; 235
multi methods; 35
multi-cultural; 147; 231
narrative inquiry; 76; 81; 119; 160
neglect syndrome; 50
nursing; 24; 72; 76; 87; 101; 104;
115; 124; 125; 144; 151; 163; 170;
178; 184; 199; 200; 202; 209; 212;
218; 221; 227; 232; 236; 239
obesity; 99; 230
occupational therapy; 215
online
intervention; 55; 86; 134
research; 66; 78; 80; 81; 98; 128;
132; 133; 155; 197; 217
palliative care; 115; 131; 142; 163
parenting; 107; 112; 140; 175
Participatory Action Research (PAR);
131; 173
Participatory Research; 85
patient engagement; 194
Phenomenology; 55; 58; 84; 89; 94;
101; 103; 104; 110; 115; 125; 189;
198; 212; 216; 229; 237
post-traumatic growth (PTG); 160
pregnancy; 64; 156; 226
psychology; 164; 172; 203
neuropsychology; 166
psychotherapy; 67
quality of care; 79; 142; 144; 174;
178; 180; 218; 224; 226
quality of life; 28; 197
recruitment; 74; 75
relationships
patient-provider; 58; 160; 240
review; 88; 121; 194; 199; 220
risk behaviour
alcohol; 48; 134
eating; 90
sexual; 82
smoking; 47; 86; 204
sexuality/sexual health; 68; 69
suffering; 97
suicide; 65; 108
teaching/learning strategies; 62; 76;
86; 111; 141; 190
validity; 214
violence; 70; 91; 101; 183; 235
257
visual methods; 54; 104; 176; 185
photo; 61; 149
video; 65
war; 179
well-being; 24; 42
individual; 59; 61; 78; 84; 130;
149; 157; 158; 179; 205; 207;
226
258
organizational; 56; 202
women's health; 47; 57; 70; 77; 91;
95; 96; 99; 101; 111; 129; 141;
150; 161; 180; 183; 189; 216; 223
young adults; 48; 104; 134; 150; 154;
162; 223; 231
259
Finito di stampare
nel mese di giugno 2012
da Litografia Solari
Peschiera Borromeo (Mi)
260