Aims: The mouse bioassay (MBA) is the biologically relevant gold standard method for assessment of BoNTs. However, the aspiration for replacement, reduction, and refinement – the 3Rs principles – of animal use in potency assays entail...
moreAims: The mouse bioassay (MBA) is the biologically relevant gold standard method for assessment of BoNTs. However, the aspiration for replacement, reduction, and refinement – the 3Rs principles – of animal use in potency assays entail development of alternative methods. Pluripotent embryonic stem cells provide a continuous source of appropriate cells that allow evaluation of receptor binding, internalisation, translocation, and catalytic activity of BoNTs. We aim to develop a cell-based assay that captures all biological functions of BoNTs and is equally sensitive as the MBA.
Methods: Directed differentiation of murine ES cells, strain E14TG2a, into motoneurons was achieved in two steps: 1) embryoid bodies (EBs) were generated and treated with RA (1 μM), SHH (100 ng/ml) and purmorphamine (1 μM); 2) dissociated EBs were differentiated on laminin coated plates in neurobasal medium. Mixed population of mature cholinergic and adrenergic motoneurons were identified by immunolabeling against HB9, MAP-2, tau, synaptophysin, PSD-95, choline-acetyltransferase, and noradrenaline. We demonstrate that they express BoNT/A receptor SV2A and its intracellular target SNAP25. Motoneurons were intoxicated with a range of LD50 values of purified (Metabiologics) and formulated (NIBSC reference) BoNT/A1 samples for 12 to 72 hours. Time and dose dependent changes in the level of cleaved intracellular SNAP25 were evaluated using in-house developed sandwich-ELISA assay: 96 well ELISA plates were coated overnight with affinity purified capture Ab (-amino acids 190-197) specific to epitope exposed upon BoNT/A cleavage of intact SNAP25. Total cell lysates were prepared and added to plates for 90 minutes. Binding of cleaved SNAP25 to coated Ab was detected by addition of a mixture of sheep anti-SNAP25 Abs directed to SNAP25 amino acids 1–57 and 111–157, and reaction was visualised with commercially sourced rabbit anti-sheep HRP conjugated Ab.
Results: Differentiation procedure was optimised to enhance sensitivity of cells to BoNT/A. Optimal sensitivity was achieved when 50,000 cells/well in 96-well plates were cultured for nine days and intoxicated for 48 hours. The preliminary results indicate that intoxication with purified (Metabiologics) BoNT/A1 results in dose dependent proteolysis of SNAP25 respectively within 12 h, 24 h, 48 h and 72 h with EC50s of 10, 3.5, 1, and 0.7 LD50 mL, respectively.
Keywords: botulinum neurotoxins; bioassay; SNA; proteolysis.