100 Things Maple Leafs Fans Should Know & Do Before They Die

change.

Contents

Introductions

1. The Maple Leafs’ Top Problem

2. Hockey Night in Canada

3. Conn Smythe to Bell and Rogers

4. The 1963–64 and the 1966–67 Marlies

5. Punch Imlach and the June ’67 Expansion Draft

6. The Ultimate Road Trip

7. Brian Burke

8. Worst Leaf Trades

9. Best Leaf Fighters

10. Blue and White Disease

11. Phil Kessel and Brian Burke

12. Best Maple Leaf Trades

13. Dion Phaneuf

14. Five Oddities at Leaf Games

15. Richard Peddie, Tim Leiweke, and Dave Nonis

16. Best Late-Round Draft Picks

17. Nazem Kadri

18. James van Riemsdyk

19. Troy Bodie, Terry Clancy, Brent Imlach, and Mike Walton

20. Forbes Kennedy and Matt Frattin

21. Alex Steen and Ron Wilson

22. Leafs Nation Network and Mapleleafs.com

23. Maple Leaf Square and Real Sports Bar

24. Five Great Sports Bars to Watch a Game

25. Ted Kennedy

26. Bill Barilko

27. Greatest Goals in Maple Leafs History (Playoffs)

28. Ten More Memorable Maple Leaf Goals (Playoffs)

29. Darryl Sittler

30. 2/7/76—The 10-Point Night

31. 2/2/77—Ian Turnbull’s Five-Goal Night

32. Paul Henderson

33. Ten More Memorable Maple Leaf Goals (Playoffs)

34. Walter Turk Broda

35. Syl Apps and Dave Schriner

36. Top 10 Maple Leaf Teams of All Time

37. Top Five Leaf Teams That Didn’t Win the Cup

38. Gerry James

39. Miscalculations by Toronto Maple Leafs Management

40. Five Worst Maple Leaf Teams of All Time

41. Bob Pulford

42. Ten Hockey Innovations Started at Maple Leaf Gardens

43. Peter Stemkowski

44. Bob Baun

45. The Chum Witch

46. Eddie Shack

47. Five Best Maple Leaf Songs

48. Billy Harris

49. Best Maple Leafs Team History Books

50. Andy Bathgate and Dave Andreychuk

51. Autry Erickson and Milan Marcetta

52. Terry Sawchuk

53. Best Maple Leafs Videos

54. A Final Face-Off: Allan Stanley

55. The Mysterious Trophy

56. The 1967–68 Season

57. Jean-Paul Parise

58. Tim Horton

59. Ernie Moser in 1969

60. Ten Worst First-Round Draft Picks

61. Ten Best First-Round Picks Since 1969

62. Four Bench-Clearing Brawls

63. Jacques Plante and Bernie Parent

64. Rick Ley, Brad Selwood, and Guy Trottier

65. Who Should Be Added to Legends Row

66. Blaine Stoughton and Gord McRae

67. Worst Moves by Owner Harold Ballard

68. Borje Salming

69. Is There a Goalie in the House?

70. The Final Broadcast: Foster Hewitt

71. Best TV Commercial Using Maple Leaf Players

72. Best TV Commercials Involving the Maple Leafs

73. Mats Sundin

74. Best Maple Leaf Biography: Dave Tiger Williams

75. Maple Leaf Biographies

76. The Night Wayne Gretzky Got Rocked

77. Leaf Nation— Out of This World

78. A New Year’s Eve to Remember

79. A Game the Leafs Should Have Lost

80. Steve Thomas

81. Best Free Agent Signings by the Maple Leafs Since 1980

82. Best Leaf Farm Team Since the 1960s

83. Doug Gilmour

84. Referee Kerry Fraser and the Maple Leafs

85. The Fab Five: Maple Leaf Defensemen in 1992–93

86. Wendel Clark

87. Nikolai Borschevsky

88. Dave Keon and Wayne Gretzky

89. The Mighty Pat Quinn

90. The New Maple Leaf Gardens and Coca-Cola Coliseum

91. Toronto Maple Leafs Fan Talks

92. Ken Dryden

93. Next Generation Game—Leafs Revive Young Canada Night

94. Worst Free Agent Signings by the Maple Leafs Since 1980

95. Bryan McCabe

96. Joe Nieuwendyk and Brian Leetch

97. Best Opening Ceremony: Felix Potvin and Darcy Tucker

98. The Barilko Puck

99. The Return of David Keon

100. Top 100 Maple Leafs of All Time

Acknowledgments

Bibliography

Introductions

The earliest hockey memory I have is of the magical 1958–59 season when the Leafs made the playoffs on the last night by one point. On Saturday nights, we all watched Hockey Night In Canada starting at 9:00 pm, and the game was joined in progress halfway through the second period. Foster Hewitt would give his postgame summary, with Toronto always in the cellar. But that’s when I fell in love with the underdog Leafs. I treasured my hockey cards from that year (five-cent packs—four cards and a gum). My Bob Nevin card still has the gum imprint on it!

The first Leaf game I went to was on February 22, 1964, and that was the night of the famous trade that brought Andy Bathgate to the Leafs. That was thrilling.

I also saw the Leafs win four Stanley Cups in the ’60s—and, of course, none since.

My co-author in the first edition of this book, Mike Leonetti, sadly passed away in 2016 and there cannot be a more devoted Leaf fan than Mike was. This book is dedicated to his memory.

I hope you enjoy the revised and updated version of our book.

—Paul Patskou

March 2020

The first hockey season I can recall was the 1963–64 National Hockey League campaign, which featured six teams competing for the Stanley Cup. I turned six that year and my favourite team, the Toronto Maple Leafs, were favoured to repeat as Stanley Cup champions for the third year in a row. The ’63–’64 Maple Leafs was a club that featured many stars and future Hall of Fame players like Tim Horton, Johnny Bower, Allan Stanley, Frank Mahovlich, Red Kelly, Bob Pulford, Dave Keon, and captain George Armstrong. I followed their exploits on both television and radio and loved their home sweater with the rich blue colour base and the 35-point white Maple Leaf as the logo. The team played in Maple Leaf Gardens in those days and for most boys growing up in Toronto at that time, it was our field of dreams. The Leafs only managed a third-place finish that year but in the playoffs, they rose to the occasion and won two seven-game series to capture their third straight title. As captain George Armstrong said after it was all over, We never lost the last game. The most memorable games that year came in the postseason. Keon scored three goals right in Montreal to get the Leafs back to the Stanley Cup final and then the Toronto side won both Games 6 (on Bobby Baun’s overtime goal) and 7 against the Detroit Red Wings (a 4–0 win at the Gardens) to hold the crown. Needless to say, it was a great time to be a Maple Leaf fan in the great city of Toronto and the team made everyone proud!

Three years later the Leafs once again won the Stanley Cup when they surprised the hockey world by beating Montreal in the final. Actually, they had shocked the first-place Chicago Black Hawks in the semi-final that year and then behind the superlative goaltending of Terry Sawchuk and Johnny Bower, they edged the mighty Canadiens in six games. The Leafs got many great performances in the ’67 postseason and none was better than Dave Keon (my hero) who was awarded the Conn Smythe Trophy as the best player in the playoffs. The ’67 triumph was the Leafs’ fourth of the decade and the city seemed somewhat blasé about the win since it had become commonplace to see the Leafs hold a parade on Bay Street. If we Leaf fans had only known what was in store for us!

Since those great days of the 1960s the Leafs have experienced little success on the ice. No championships since ’67 and not even an appearance in the Stanley Cup final. Sure, there have been many great players to wear the sweater since the last title—including Darryl Sittler, Lanny McDonald, Borje Salming, Doug Gilmour, Wendel Clark, and Mats Sundin—but none have been able, despite their best efforts, to take the Leafs to a Stanley Cup victory. The best the Leafs have managed is five appearances among the final four teams competing for the Cup and that remains the same now.

The Leafs are a very successful business with an incredibly loyal fan base that brings millions of dollars to the organization year after year. Owners have changed, a new arena was built, coaches and managers have come and gone, the sweater has changed, but the lack of success on the ice continues unabated while the business side of the operation becomes more valuable as each year passes. It has become quite the conundrum and the organization must bear the burden of trying to get the team back to its glorious past while trying to still be the most profitable team in the entire NHL. Leaf fans can only hope that fresh faces and approaches from people like Brendan Shanahan can find the right balance to keep the Leafs successful in every way, but it will not be an easy task.

This book is for Maple Leafs fans who enjoy rooting for the blue and white no matter what situation is at hand. These fans are a resilient lot with a great deal of patience for their local heroes. Covered in these pages are a wide variety of issues, controversies, trivia, and fun facts to give the reader something different on each page. Some points will bring large agreement and some might cause some consternation but Leaf fans can be assured of some thought-provoking fun, facts, and figures.

Toronto’s National Hockey League franchise celebrated its 100th anniversary as a member of the circuit that began play to start the 1917–18 season. This book will focus on more current events and the more recent past than on ancient history (which has been chronicled many times already). We hope this will make for a more dynamic read and include a younger generation of Maple Leafs fans.

The city of Toronto (a cosmopolitan place with a diversity of cultures) and surrounding area deserves a great hockey team and the inhabitants of this part of the world are ready to embrace a new group of champions like never before (see the reaction of Maple Leafs fans when the team made the playoffs in 2013). We cannot be sure when a Stanley Cup championship is going to happen for the Maple Leafs but we can have some fun looking back while we hope the future brings back the glory days we were once accustomed to in Toronto—just like when I was a young fan. Enjoy!

—Mike Leonetti

July 2014

1. The Maple Leafs’ Top Problem

For years now, many in the Toronto media and sports analysts in general across Canada (and even in the United States) blame the Maple Leaf fans who fill the newly named Scotiabank Arena game after game despite years of mediocre play by their favourite team. It used to be written that the Leafs had sold out every game since 1946 and although that was never exactly the case (especially when the team was a wretched organization in the 1980s), it is true that Leaf fans have stayed a devoted and caring group to the team wearing blue and white. The argument goes that empty seats would spur management to do more to make the Maple Leafs a winning club. Seven years ago, the Toronto Sun newspaper listed the top reasons why the Leafs were constantly failing and at the top of the list were Leaf fans who buy tickets and go to the games year in and year out. The reality is that nothing could be further from the truth.

Any sports team wants and needs to sell tickets to survive wherever they are located. Loyal Leaf fans have taken away the main worry of any sports team with consistent sellouts (although not quite every seat) and that should free up management to concentrate on what they need to do to make the team a winner. Money is not a problem for the Maple Leafs as fans and corporations are quite willing to pay top dollar (if not exorbitant rates) to see their local heroes play every winter. As a result, the Leafs are a wealthy team and should use their resources wisely to build the best management group and team possible.

If Scotiabank Arena (and before that the Air Canada Centre and Maple Leaf Gardens) was half empty would it really make a difference? It might cause alarm but would the management of the team now decide they should make good trades and sign top free agents as a result? The answer is that the people who have run the Leafs since 1967 have all tried to make the team better but with mixed or outright bad results. It’s not that they did not try—they were just not competent enough to get the job done properly. Under the ownership of Harold Ballard for instance it would not have made an ounce of difference if the Gardens was completely devoid of fans. Ballard really had no clue how to put a winning team together, but he loved being the boss of the Maple Leafs and all that went with that position.

Maple Leafs fans are always optimistic about their team. (Harold Barkley Archives)

The list of inadequate general managers and coaches who have run the Leafs since ’67 (when Toronto last won a Stanley Cup) is far too long. One poor hire after another only gave Leaf supporters more grief as the beloved team sank lower in the standings most years. Ballard’s passing brought some relief (ever so briefly) to long-suffering Leaf fans but only after a protracted battle for control of the team which was played out in board rooms and court rooms. Sure, many things did improve under new ownership but never enough to make the Leafs a championship team or even a consistent contender.

Fans are helpless to solve these issues but to blame them is ridiculous and an insult. In the modern era of the game, fans, including loyal Leafs supporters, have become less relevant in any event considering that so much money is coming to the team in the form of broadcasting revenues mostly from regular television and cable contracts. The league-wide salary cap instituted by NHL commissioner Gary Bettman and the owners has also taken away an advantage Toronto might have continued to enjoy by outspending others, but this had nothing to do with Leaf fans. Toronto fans deserve to be rewarded with a winning product—not chastised for being loyal to their favourite team. Poor ownership and management are where the finger of blame should be pointed at for the Leafs’ largely inept record since ’67. No Toronto fan should feel that shame. Fans should always be respected because it is their undying passion that not only keeps the great game of hockey alive and well, but also gives life to the premier franchise of the NHL.

2. Hockey Night in Canada

The question of why the Maple Leafs are so popular despite their unenviable record since 1967 is one that is asked over and over again, but there is really only one answer and that is Hockey Night in Canada. Read any Leaf history accounts or Canadian history books and you will find all these volumes with references to the iconic show that first began on radio and then made a seamless transition to television.

Beginning in the 1930s, the Leafs’ Saturday night encounter at home has been a staple of Canadian entertainment. People would gather around their radios to listen to Foster Hewitt’s accounts and descriptions of games played at Maple Leaf Gardens. There was not much in terms of entertainment options in those days and Hewitt seemed to make every game the Leafs played an epic encounter no matter who was playing or what the score happened to be. It was great timing for the Maple Leafs who were a very good team throughout the decade of the 1930s even though they only took the Stanley Cup on one occasion. The 1940s saw the team win the championship five times and helped ease the anguish of Canada being involved in World War II. Hewitt’s HNIC games were often recorded, edited and then transmitted to the BBC in England to be broadcast to Canadian forces fighting overseas to bring the troops some good news about what was going on back home in Canada and provide an immense morale booster.

By 1952 the grand invention called television came into being and Hockey Night in Canada became a country-wide favourite with eventual coast-to-coast coverage. Now people could see what Hewitt was describing and even though the whole game was not shown, fans were thrilled to see even just some of the action. The Leafs were not very good in the 1950s (just one Cup in 1951), but by the time 1960 rolled around the team was back in contention. Once again the Leafs’ timing could not have been better as most Canadians had purchased a TV sometime in the early part of the decade—just in time to see the team win four Stanley Cups. Leaf players became heroes to an entire Nation and their performances on Saturday night were must see TV. It was here that the Leaf Nation was born as the boomer generation saw the Toronto club as winners year after year.

Legendary broadcaster Foster Hewitt. (Harold Barkley Archives)

If the last two seasons (1963–64 and 1966–67) that saw the Leafs win the Stanley Cup is any indication, it is easy to see why the team became so popular. In ’63–’64 they posted a 19–2–4 record (all home games) in the regular season on Saturday night and then go 4–1 (featuring two home contests including the seventh game of the finals) in the playoffs on the same evening of the week. The winning percentage for the 30-game total was 77 percent and they gained at least one-point 90 percent of the time. In 1966–67 the Leafs were 15–4–4 in the regular season and a perfect 3–0 in the postseason for games played on Saturday. Over those two seasons (including playoffs), the Leafs played a total of 56 games on Hockey Night in Canada and won 41 times (for a 73-winning percentage) while gaining at least one-point 85 percent of the time. The funny thing is the team struggled both those seasons but they were great on Saturday nights and good enough to win the Stanley Cup both years.

The tradition of gathering around to watch the Leafs on HNIC was passed on to another generation and then again to other generations as time passed. In the 2013 playoffs the Leafs drew 5.1 million fans (a new record since audiences were measured more accurately) to their TV screen on a Monday night for the seventh game of a playoff series versus Boston. "We’re thrilled at how Canadians