No Moon
3.5/5
()
About this ebook
Louisa Gardener is the fourteen-year-old nursemaid to the young daughters of a wealthy, titled family living in London, England, in 1912.
Despite the bullying Nanny Mackintosh, for whom she is an extra pair of hands, she loves her work and her young charges. Then everything changes. The family decides to sail to New York aboard the Titanic. An accident to the children's nanny, only days prior to the sailing, means that Louisa must go in her stead. She cannot refuse, although she dreads even the mention of the ocean. Memories she has suppressed, except in nightmares, come crowding back.
When Louisa was five and her sister seven years old, their two-year-old brother died on an outing to the seaside. Since that time, Louisa has had a fear of the ocean. She blames herself for the accident, though she has been told it wasn't her fault.
If Louisa refuses to go on the voyage, she will be dismissed, and she will never get beyond the working-class life she has escaped from.
How Louisa learns self-reliance, overcomes her fears, and goes beyond what is expected of a girl makes No Moon an unforgettable story.
Irene N.Watts
Irene N. Watts is an award-winning playwright, children's novelist, and educator. A life member of Playwrights Guild, she lives in Vancouver, British Columbia.
Read more from Irene N.Watts
When the Bough Breaks Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Finding Sophie Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Good-bye Marianne: A Story of Growing Up in Nazi Germany Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Flower Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Remember Me: A Search for Refuge in Wartime Britain Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Related to No Moon
YA Historical For You
Red Queen Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Chain of Gold Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Wuthering Heights Complete Text with Extras Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5My Lady Jane Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Witch of Blackbird Pond: A Newbery Award Winner Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Librarian of Auschwitz Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Foul Lady Fortune Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Great Gatsby Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsBrave New World: (Original Classic Editions) Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsChain of Thorns Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Whipping Boy Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Slave Dancer Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Farewell to Manzanar Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Romanov Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Great Gatsby: The Original 1925 Unabridged And Complete Edition (Original Classic Editions) Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Deathless Divide Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Between Shades of Gray Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Black Kids Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Queen Song Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5So Many Beginnings: A Little Women Remix Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Reviews for No Moon
55 ratings20 reviews
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5No Moon is a story about Louisa, a nursemaid who finds herself in charge of two young children while their family sails on the Titanic. Threading factual information about the early twentieth century within a personal narrative format, Watts gives a general overview of what life was like in the early twentieth century within a story that tells of the tragedy of the Titanic. In some ways, I was disappointed by this book, but I can see how that might be useful for introducing children to the subject of the Titanic and the early 1900s.
The Good Things:
This is a great book for children who are reluctant or beginning readers. The story is simple, easy to follow, short, and moves along quickly. It provides a nice contrast between the people of the working-class and upper-class in England during the early twentieth century, and even hints at the burgeoning of the women's rights movement. I could see elementary school teachers reading this aloud in their class to complement a history unit for this time period. It brings up a lot of things to reflect and learn about, such as women's rights, marriage practices, work practices, family dynamics, etc., which makes it a great starter for a unit.
The Bad Things:
As an adult reader, I was a little disappointed in story's lack of complexity. I think that the emotional response of the Titanic's sinking could have been explored further. Instead, the characters said something along the lines of, "Oh, this is so terrible!" And then the story moved on. On a related note, the characters also seemed over-simplified, and I would have liked to see more growth or change within the side characters.
Overall, I think this is a great introduction to the story of the Titanic and it introduces topics that children could research and explore on their own. It'd be a good pleasure read for kids interested in the subject, but I could definitely see elementary school teachers using this in their classroom as an introduction to early twentieth century England and the Titanic.
*I was provided a free copy of this book from the publisher through LibraryThing's Early Reviewer program in exchange for an honest review.* - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Excellent historical fiction with the Titanic central to the story but it's especially notable for vividly depicting the rigid class divisions of the time.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5No Moon is 14-year-old nurserymaid Louisa's story. Louisa feels lucky to land the job and enjoys taking care of the family's two little girls, but has to work hard to please tyrannical Nanny MackIntosh. She's looking forward to a respite when the family plans a cruise to New York with Nanny and the girls, until Nanny breaks her leg. But Louisa has been afraid of the sea since her little brother drowned at the seaside when she was small. Recommended for "Upstairs, Downstairs", "Downton Abbey" and "Titanic" fans.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I thought that I had a lot of knowledge about the Titanic but this book tells the story from a different perspective from anything else I have read. The main character, Louisa, is a young girl of 14 and this is a story about her life with her family before she boards the ship. The reader gets to know her and her family and the struggles they go through to survive life. Louisa was not supposed to go on this ocean trip but circumstances change at the last minute and she has to go as the nanny for the family she is working for.
Even though this is touted as a book about the Titanic, it is a back story to the main story of this young girl in England at the time of the sailing. I really enjoyed this book! - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Fourteen-year-old Louisa Gardener is the second-oldest child in a large working-class family living in London in 1911. She left school a couple of years ago to help her mother with housework and caring for her younger siblings, but now she wants to have a real job, like her older sister Kathleen. Louisa is very lucky, as on her first job interview she is hired to be a nursemaid to two little girls, the daughters of a wealthy titled family in London. Louisa has always loved children, having helped to care for her four younger siblings. And it is a very good position, as the servants in this household are treated very well. Louisa is a bit unhappy that Nanny Macintosh, whom she assists in the nursery, is very strict, but overall she is happy with her job, and very fond of Alexandra and Portia, the little girls she helps care for.
Almost a year goes by, and Louisa is very settled in her routine with helping care for the girls. She is also anticipating her week off to spend with her family, as Lord and Lady Milton are planning to bring the girls on a trip to New York to visit relatives. Because Louisa's little brother drowned during a trip to the seashore when Louisa was just five years old, Louisa is very afraid of water, and she blames herself for not protecting her brother, even though she was just a little girl herself. So she is quite relieved to be staying behind in London while Nanny Macintosh accompanies the girls and their parents on the maiden voyage of the Titanic. But then a few days before the trip, Nanny Macintosh falls down the stairs, and is too injured to travel. Louisa must take her place or lose her job. Will she be able to overcome her fear of the water to save herself and her young charges when disaster strikes?
Although the description on the back cover of this book makes it sound like the voyage on the Titanic is the major focus of the story, it actually doesn't take place until the second half of the novel. The first half is mostly about Louisa's life in London, settling into her new job, and the memories of her brother's death that haunt her years later. Even though it's not written as a diary, the writing style of this book still reminded me a lot of the Dear America series, and I think it would appeal to the same readers. My one complaint was some of the historical facts seemed a bit forced, such as Louisa having a conversation about how there aren't enough lifeboats while talking a walk on the deck the day before the ship sinks.
Disclosure: Review copy provided by publisher. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I worried throughout Irene Watt's No Moon, which luckily for me is quite short, because it's about the Titanic, and so the potential for death is quite high. The cover does feature a life boat, which is reassuring, but not everyone can fit in a life boat...
The view of the Titanic is from the top, but from beneath, because Louisa is the nanny for the preschool daughters of a rich British family. She's really the nursemaid, but has scaled to the heights of temporary nanny because of a last-minute accident. Most of the story follows her from her home to her first job, where she struggles to earn the approval of her direct supervisor, the strict martinet of a nanny who has been with the family for generations.
The historic feel seems right. The characters aren't modern people teleported back for this story; Louisa doesn't argue about social injustice or women's rights or how shockingly little time the children spend with their parents. She worries about bringing money home to her parents, about whether her sister is prospering in her shop work, about whether Nanny's complaints will escalate until she loses her position. B+
(review from my blog, libraryfrog.blogspot.com) - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5This book is about so much more than the sinking of the Titanic. It is about a girl who grows up and matures with every situation she encounters. This book would be great for the young adult who is looking to relate to someone their age and what it is like to take on responsibilities. It also does provide a new view on the sinking of the Titanic, giving one singular perspective as a child involved in the sinking, rather than the Blockbuster type approach from Leonardo Di Caprio's Titanic. Refreshing, new, and eye-opening.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Louisa Gardener is the fourteen-year-old nursemaid to the young daughters of a wealthy, titled family living in London, England, in 1912. Despite the bullying Nanny Mackintosh, for whom she is an extra pair of hands, she loves her work and her young charges. Then everything changes. The family decides to sail to New York aboard the Titanic. An accident to the children's nanny, only days prior to the sailing, means that Louisa must go in her stead. She cannot refuse, although she dreads even the mention of the ocean.
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5I became very conflicted after reading this book. The story is interesting. That the point of view is from a teenage girl gives it a special innocence that I enjoyed. I haven’t read many stories that involve the Titanic, but reading Louisa’s perspective about the voyage and subsequent sinking of the ship gave me goose-bumps. I couldn’t help but conjure up images of James Cameron’s Titanic as I read along (which I freely admit added a great deal to my emotional connection to the story)
But, I’m getting ahead of myself. That part of the book is towards the end, and it’s really the story prior to it that I am conflicted over. First, the book is very short, which will add to my claim that the story could have been fleshed out so much more! There were moments when I felt like events were skipped over a little too hastily. The Gardener family had much more to offer, particularly Louisa’s sister, as could have Nanny Roberts’ story. I thought it would have served better to leave out what was only referenced briefly, or to pursue those storylines fully. The thoughts behind them were too good to waste in my opinion. I felt like I was shown a vein of an idea, and began to follow it down a path, only to find it locked behind a door to nowhere.
I’d give the writer another try….perhaps more luck with one of her other books? Anyone read anything of hers previously? - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5An enjoyable and seemingly realistic look at life in the early 20th century, this was a quick read. Though a little light on details and action, it is a good introduction to the time period, as well as the events that occurred on the Titanic. Recommended for younger readers.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5There are many young adult books that walk that line between young adult and adult books and you often have difficulty knowing which side of the line the book is on. I didn't have that problem with this book. It is definitely a young adult book in my opinion. A very decent young adult book.
The book's main character Louisa Gardener is in her early teens for the book. She is from a working class family in the early 1900's - staying at home and helping her mother raise the younger children, cleaning and cooking, though she longs to join the working world.
She finally gets her chance and becomes a nursemaid within the home of a wealthy family. It is obvious that Louisa loves children and caring for them - though she is often berated and bullied by the Nanny of the house.
Louisa truly grows up during the course of this book. The first half of the book we learn about Louisa and life in general during that time period. The second half of the book is primarily about the family's trip to America aboard the Titanic, a trip that Louisa dreads due to her fear of water.
A good book for late elementary-aged children to learn about life during that time and hearing about the Titanic from a different perspective. - Rating: 2 out of 5 stars2/5There are some children’s books that read just as well to adults as they do to children. This wasn’t one of them. The book was alright, the story had potential, but the writing itself didn’t do the story justice. It felt very juvenile. I’m certain that had I been a fair bit younger, I wouldn’t have been bothered by the writing style at all, but it felt choppy and almost too simplistic.
There were parts in this book where it felt like the author was more concerned with getting facts about the Titanic across to the reader, than she was concerned with telling the story. In those parts, the story got very dry for a few pages, and it didn’t seem like the narrative was coming from the main character anymore or how (for example) seeing the Titanic sink was having an effect on her.
Other than the main character, everyone else felt very flat and cardboard-like. There wasn’t any depth, and you never REALLY got to know any of the secondary characters – especially the other servants in the house that Louisa was working in. It was a little disappointing.
But the book wasn’t all bad – there were good things about it. I have no doubt that young girls would love Louisa and her tale of survival on the Titanic. Louisa is a character that would be easily empathizable. And I did enjoy the glimpse it gave us of an upper-class family at the beginning of 20th century England. It also showed the dynamics and drama between the household staff, which I thought was fun to see. So yes, while there were some good things, the good didn’t unfortunately outweigh the bad in this case.
The Bottom Line: it was alright – I can see how it would be enjoyable to young girls, and it’s certainly educational… but I didn’t particularly enjoy it. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I really enjoyed this book. It was a pretty quick read, and I would recommend it for kids around late elementary school and early middle school age. I loved learning about the Titanic in 4th and 5th grade and this book gave a lot of good information about what happened without seeming like it was just rattling off facts about the Titanic (that was saved for the afterword). All in all the book gives the reader just what they think it will when they read the back cover. No great twists or surprises here.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5First Line: The night before the picnic, Kathleen and I stayed awake long after Johnny had been brought to his room and settled in his crib.
In 1902 when Louisa Gardener was five, her parents took her, her older sister and two-year-old brother on a rare holiday to the seaside. Little brother Johnny was tragically drowned, and since that time, Louisa has wanted nothing to do with the ocean.
A few years pass, and older sister Kathleen is in service, working outside the home to bring in badly needed money. Even though she longs to have a job like Kathleen, her mother needs her to stay at home to help with cooking, cleaning, and caring for her younger brothers and sisters. Finally Louisa gets her chance, becoming a nursemaid to a wealthy London family. Even though she's bullied unmercifully by Nanny Mackintosh, Louisa loves her work, and she loves the children for whom she cares.
Everything is all right until the fourteen-year-old learns that the family has booked passage on the Titanic. Is Louisa going to be able to overcome her nightmares and fear of the sea to go with her employers, or will she stay home, lose her place and any chance of rising above her working class life?
I've been a bit of a Titanic buff for years, so I was very happy to be sent this book through LibraryThing's Early Reviewer program. The narrative moves quickly-- everything seen through the eyes of young Louisa. She chafes at being made to stay home with the endless cleaning and cooking, just like any other young girl would, but she doesn't complain all that much. She's working-class, and she knows that the only way she'll ever rise above is by hard work.
When she moves on to work as nursemaid to a wealthy London family, she lets us see the differences between her own home and a home of a privileged family. Her quiet struggles with Nanny Mackintosh really made me cheer Louisa on because it showed that the girl truly did have the gift of raising children.
Throughout the book, Louisa was full of practicality and common sense without ever seeming like an adult in disguise, but her story really came to life at the end. It was a pleasure to watch Louisa make each choice that would effect her life. It was a pleasure to inhabit her world for a little while. I would be very pleased indeed if Watts shared more chapters of Louisa's adventures. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5While this book was aimed at a children's/YA audience, I think adults would enjoy reading it as well. No Moon is a short, but enjoyable, read. The story progresses nicely from main character's five-year-old memory of her brother drowning to her teenage experiences as a nursemaid in a Victorian home and on the Titanic, with her voice maturing as she grows older. While the novel does not stand out from other novels about the Titanic, it is a good book and I recommend it to anyone who enjoys historical fiction.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A sotry about the sinking of the Titanic from the point of view of a young girl. Geared towards the YA crowd, this is a book detailing the life of a girl who is hired as a nursemaid for a affluent/aristocratic family. She grows to love her little charges but has a tough time dealing with the Nanny who has her own strict views on how the children should be raised. Through a series of events the Nanny is unable to go on the ocean crossing and the young nursemaid is expected to look after the children aboard the Titanic. She is terrified of the ocean after the drowning of her little brother under her supervision and is reluctant to take her two young charges on the boat.
This was a fairly well written account of life during the 1910s and the disaster that was the Titanic's first crossing. It was a really interesting read that had lots of visualization of the opulence that the rich/first class passengers enjoyed. At times the story seemed to jump a bit without explanation, but overall it was a satisfying read that gave a glimpse into that era in English history. Definitely a quick read but a very enjoyable one. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5No Moon by Irene N. Watts is a gentle novel about a girl who must confront deep-set fears. Louisa Gardener is offered the chance to be nursemaid to an aristocratic family. This is an excellent opportunity for someone of her age and status, and she quickly forms a bond with her charges. When she is asked to accompany the family aboard the Titanic, however, she must either overcome her paralyzing fear of water or give up the chance to support her struggling family.
This novel fittingly evokes the style of an early-twentieth-century novel, although the text is narrated in the first person. Louisa is a likeable character, if more innocent than fourteen-year-olds tend to be today, and readers should enjoy getting to know her. Although the setting is historical, it is accessibly presented. Readers will likely identify with some of Louisa's frustrations and excitement, while learning how different the details of other lives can be.
Many tensions are suggested obliquely but are not developed as they might be in a novel for adults. Insightful younger readers might pursue some of these ideas, such as the separation between the family and the servants, the strict gender divisions between men and women, the complicated hierarchies of power, the threat implied by the shadowy character of Roberts, or the unquestioning obedience of those who serve. The possibility for extension of these themes makes this an apt text for use in the classroom. No Moon is a fine book for readers nine and up. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I thought this book had lovable characters and was very pleased with the ending. There were a couple of oddities that I will mention, but whether or not these would be an issue with 9-12 year old children is the real question. I just wanted to mention this sort of disclaimer beforehand. The first oddity I found was the very beginning. I thought it strange that before we got to know any of the characters, one of them was taken away. Since I wasn't invested in the one that left the family so soon, I had a hard time really experiencing how the family felt about the loss and its subsequent influence on future actions. The other oddity I found was that the main character Louisa was desperately wanting to go to work. So much so that she was willing and wanting to work in a factory. I have a hard time believing that she was either ignorant of the factory working conditions or that she knew of them but was still wanting to work for one. The family wasn't so poor that she had no other choice. I was also a bit confused about the purpose for the nasty Roberts character. She didn't add anything to the story and I don't feel that the main character Louisa had grown from the interaction or scandal.
Now to focus on the points I adored. I loved the contrast of child rearing between the nanny and Louisa. One so harsh and respected, the other so caring and loved. The two little girls were absolutely adorable. The Titanic portion of the book I felt was done perfectly. The extravagance of the ship and sheer joy that Louisa expressed painted a lovely picture. I thought the author focused just enough on this to make me happy for the characters but not get bored. The tragic part of the Titanic story was written beautifully. I was sad and worried for the characters I had come to love, but it wasn't too gruesome to where I think children would get scared if they were to read this story. Overall this section introduced the idea of the tragic and beautiful story of the Titanic without being boring or traumatic.
As I mentioned earlier, the ending of the book was great and made me smile. I love happy endings. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I really enjoyed this book. I love anything to do with the Titantic. This book had a loveable main character, Louisa, who comes from a poorer family and leaves them to be a nursemaid to a society family. I could tell that this book was geared to a younger audience. It was a quick and easy read. The plot was well-written, however I guess because it was geared to a much younger audience, I felt that some parts were skipped over too quickly. There was more time spent on the background and how Louisa came to be on the Titantic's maiden voyage than actually being on the ship. I would have like to have seen more details about the Titantic and the life aboard the ship than the life before the voyage. I felt that the author seemed to rush the voyage and went straight for the iceberg incident and the sinking of the ship. That would be my only negative thing about this book. Overall an enjoyable read for a younger audience.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Fourteen-year-old Louisa Gardener is happy in her job as a nursemaid for a wealthy London family, despite being under the supervision of the children's overbearing and critical nanny. But when nanny Mackintosh is injured days before she is to accompany her employers to New York aboard the Titanic, Louisa is dismayed that she must take her place despite an overwhelming fear of the ocean.
I think this book would be enjoyed by its intended 9-12 year old audience, or by anyone who is especially interested in the story of the Titanic. The main character is very likable, and her story held my interest during the short time it took to read. The writing is hampered at times by too much exposition, especially during some of the dialogue, which ends up sounding stiff and unnatural. However, this book is for children who are likely not familiar with the details of the Titanic disaster or with life in early 20th century London. Information that is unnecessary for adults might be very welcome to younger readers.
I was originally going to give the book 3 stars, but I suspected my 11-year-old self would have given it 4, so I split the difference.
Book preview
No Moon - Irene N.Watts
1
Johnny
The night before the picnic, Kathleen and I stayed awake long after Johnny had been brought to his room and settled in his crib. Unlike us, he’d been fast asleep for hours. Our Sunday dresses and aprons were draped over the back of the chair, the collars starched stiffly.
Kathleen and I had run over to the bedroom window half a dozen times to make sure it wasn’t raining.
Is it night yet?
I asked my big sister. Where’s the moon and the stars? When will it be time to go, Kath?
Will you hush, Lou? Mother’s coming upstairs.
The door opened.
One more word from either of you and you won’t be going anywhere! Into bed with you, and stay there, before you wake up your little brother. Father says we’re to leave by five,
Mother said.
I jumped onto the bed, crawled over Kathleen, and burrowed under the thin blanket to my place near the wall. I squeezed my eyes shut so tightly that I could see colored spots beneath my eyelids.
I’m sleeping,
I said.
Close beside me, Kathleen shook with laughter before pushing the blanket away. I’m so hot, Mother, I can’t breathe,
she said.
What did I just say? I’m warning you, one more word and I’m going to tell Father.
We lay still, not daring to move until after we’d heard her go downstairs, into the kitchen, and close the door.
Night, night, sleep tight, don’t let the bedbugs bite,
Kathleen said, and gave me a friendly pinch.
Neither of us had ever been on a train, let alone to the seaside. Mr. Dawson, the greengrocer for whom Father worked, had announced the firm’s annual family outing was to Southend on Sea. This year, Mother said all three of us were old enough to go!
In the morning, I’d been too excited to eat breakfast. The swaying of the train made me feel sick. Getting off, I tripped down the steps. Johnny cried–he’d got soot in his eye. After Mother had taken the smut out with the corner of her handkerchief, Father hoisted Johnny onto his shoulders. We followed him out of the station.
And there was the sea at last, waiting for us. It shone brighter than the scullery window Kathleen and I rubbed clean with newspaper and vinegar, every Saturday.
A hurdy-gurdy man played a barrel organ; his monkey wore a red waistcoat and danced on a chain. The man sang, and the tune made Kathleen and me skip along and Johnny clap his hands. Father said the man was from Italy. I asked if we were going there on the train, and Mother laughed. She forgot to tell us to walk nicely!
Behind us, the hurdy-gurdy man trundled the organ down the lane, wheels rattling over the cobbles. Past the stands selling eels and cockles and mussels, we all went. A few of the men threw coins into the monkey’s little cap.
All along, as far as I could see, was water. I remember thinking it was more water than I’d ever seen before in my whole life! Father bought us a bottle of lemonade to share and promised us a walk on the pier, later in the day.
Kathleen asked, Does the sea stretch all the way to Australia, Father?
He winked at Mother and said, Almost,
and I knew it was a fib. But I didn’t know where Australia was, so I never said anything.
We walked down some rocky steps onto the sand. Father paid the man for two deck chairs.
Mother said, Jack, you don’t need to do that–I brought a blanket to sit on.
Father said, Nothing’s too good for my Flo.
He calls Mother Flo when he’s in a good mood and Florence when he’s had a bad day, but that’s not often.
Don’t be daft,
she said, smiling at him.
It was a happy day, and after we’d eaten our sandwiches, Mother shook the crumbs off the blanket for the gulls. She told us we could go and play. Mind you don’t go out of sight, and mind you watch your brother,
she said, taking out her knitting. She always keeps busy doing something, but Father put his newspaper over his face and went to sleep. We turned round to wave to her, and she waved back.
Kathleen and I each held one of Johnny’s hands. She carried the bucket and I carried the spade, and we ran with him down towards the water. Above us, the gulls screeched and swooped as they flew. I felt dizzy from the sound, from the taste of salt, from the smells of the day, and the warmth of the sun. I never wanted this lovely time to end.
We took off our boots and stockings and helped Johnny off with his. Kathleen lined the boots up in a tidy row beside a small rock. We grabbed Johnny’s hands and jumped him over the rocks and pebbles, closer and closer to the waves that looked like the foam on Father’s pint of beer.
How old are you, Johnny? Say one, two,
Kathleen said.
One, two,
he repeated after her.
We sat him down, and he stuck his fingers into the wet sand over and over and held them up to show us the grains of sand stuck to them. I dug a hole for him before Kathleen and I went looking for shells. I wanted pink ones to decorate the castle I was planning to build. For a while I heard Johnny humming to himself, happy as can be.
The sun shone hot on the back of my neck. The sky got bluer, and a breeze lifted my hair. Waves, aglitter with color, teased my toes, splashing my legs. I pulled my dress higher, hoping Mother couldn’t see me. Filling my apron with shells, I brought them back to shore and began to make a pretty pattern.
Wicked, wicked, girl!
I looked up and there was Mother, shaking Kathleen. I was afraid I’d be in trouble too. Had she seen me with my dress up? I tried to brush the sandy streaks from my apron. Then I grabbed my boots and stockings and put them on as fast as I could. Johnny’s were still there, but I couldn’t see him. Where was he? Had Father taken him on the pier without us?
Then I heard two slaps–one, two–sharp, like wind slapping at sheets on wash day. Turning around, I saw Kathleen standing there, silent, her cheeks red. I ran over and took hold of her hand. I was five and she was seven, and we looked after each other.
What have you done, Kathleen and Louisa Gardener? Look at your dirty frocks. I can’t trust you for a minute! Didn’t I tell you to watch your little brother? Answer me!
I closed my eyes, shutting out the glare of the sun and my mother’s face. Her fingers dug into my shoulder.
Look at me when I’m speaking to you.
The voice didn’t sound like Mother’s.
Mrs. Bernardi came over. She put her arms around Mother and tried to pull her away. Father helped her, all the while talking quietly to Mother.
I heard him say, Let the girls be, Flo, it won’t bring him back.
He picked up Johnny’s boots, and we followed them, hearing the murmurs of the women gathered round us.
Drowned, poor little mite. His father found him, lying face-down in the water.
Who drowned, Kath?
I asked.
We’d left the bucket behind, and when I turned to look, I saw my spade sticking up in the water. The tide had already washed my shell pattern away.
Shall I run back and fetch the bucket and spade? Will we get in trouble for leaving them, Kath?
Hush, Lou, never mind them. Johnny’s drowned.
A small crowd had gathered, and a policeman was holding something wrapped in a blanket. A bare foot dangled against his uniform. A woman picked up Mother’s knitting and put it in the hamper. It was late, too late to go on the pier, like Father had promised us.
Someone brought Mother a mug of tea. She took a sip and put the mug down on the sand.
A long, long time later, when we made our way slowly to the train station, the hurdy-gurdy man was still there, playing his tune. The policeman told him to move along. When I look back on that day, I always think he was playing for my brother.
It was dark by the time we got home.
Where’s the moon, Kath?
I asked.
The moon is asleep,
my sister said.
Is Johnny asleep, Kath?
Yes.
After the funeral, after friends and neighbors had left, Mother came up to our room. Kathleen and I had been sitting on the edge of our bed for a long while. It was too hot to hold hands.
Mother’s face looked hot too, red and blotchy, as if she’d been crying. Come here,
she said. We didn’t move. She knelt down in front of us. Johnny’s never coming back,
she said. It shouldn’t have happened, but it wasn’t your fault. It was an accident, remember that.
She got up and sat down on the bed between us. For a while, no one spoke. Mother reached out and clasped our hands in hers.
We’re sorry, Mother,
Kathleen said.
Sorry, I’ll never do it again,
I whispered, remembering my dirt-streaked Sunday frock and apron that Mother had to wash again before Johnny’s funeral.
We won’t talk about Johnny anymore, just now. We’ll go downstairs in a minute, and Father will give you a cuddle. I’ll make something nice for your tea,
Mother said.
Will Johnny be there?
I asked.
Hush, Lou,
Kathleen said.
I put my head on Mother’s lap, and Kathleen leaned against her arm.
Mother’s voice was quiet–it sounded as if she were speaking from a long way off. Our Johnny can’t come back. He’s gone to heaven to live with the angels. He’s safe there.
Then, holding hands, we went downstairs, and I walked on tiptoes so as not to wake Johnny up.
Later, after we’d put ourselves to bed, after Mother had come in to say good night and we’d fallen asleep, something woke me. I sat up, looking at the moonlight shine through the window onto the bedroom floor, making it glisten like a pool of water. Like the sea where Johnny drowned.
Kathleen sat up beside me, rigid, hearing the sounds coming through the wall. We looked at each other.
Is it a ghost, Kath?
I asked her. Is it Johnny gone back to his room, crying for us?
Ghosts don’t cry, silly. I’ll go and see. Are you coming?
Kathleen slid out of bed.
I was afraid to be left alone, so I followed. Stepping fearfully across the pool of light on the floor that looked like water, I crept out. We listened at the door of Johnny’s room.
It’s not a ghost at all,
Kathleen said. And then, Quick, get back to bed before Father finds us!
We were just in time. We heard Father’s footsteps on the landing, heard him open Johnny’s door.
Now, Flo, don’t carry on so; you’ll make yourself ill,
Father’s deep voice said. Do you want to wake up the girls?
We hardly dared breathe. More steps, our parents’ door closed.
I never forgot the sound of that weeping. And somehow it was all tied together–the sea, the moonlight, Mother’s tears, and the awful knowledge that my little brother was never coming back.
Kathleen and I don’t talk about that night. And I never got over feeling, deep down, that I was to blame for the accident, despite Mother saying I wasn’t. When I have a nightmare and cry in my sleep, my sister has to shake me awake.
Johnny?
I ask, and sit up.
Kathleen puts her arm around me.
You had a bad dream, Lou. Johnny’s with the angels now.
There are times when something reminds me of him again–the way the sun glitters on the River Thames…Mother’s anxious look if one of the young ones comes home late, after play.
It wasn’t long before Father stopped delivering groceries for Mr. Dawson. Uncle Alf spoke about them going into partnership at Covent Garden, selling produce at his stall.
You’re my brother, Jack,
Uncle Alf would say. It stands to reason I want you as a partner. We’re family, aren’t we?
I overheard Mother talking to Mrs. Bernardi from next door about it. It’s the pitying looks he can’t stand. He doesn’t want to be reminded. He’ll do better with Alf. No one knows his fruits and vegetables like my Jack–he’ll go when he’s ready.
Uncle Alf came to see us one evening and brought a big round yellow piece of fruit from the market. He cut it up in wedges and gave Kathleen and me a piece each to taste. Very popular with all the chefs, this is. They buy them to serve up for their lordships’ breakfasts. Grapefruit, they’re called,
he said.
I watched Kathleen pucker up her mouth and run into the scullery. I licked my piece with the tip of my tongue. It’s horrible! I don’t want it.
Mother slapped my bottom, not hard though! Don’t you be so rude to your uncle Alf,
she said. It’s a special treat. Sorry, Alf.
Kathleen came back in, wiping her mouth. It might taste better with a bit of sugar on top, Uncle Alf.
Quite right. You are a clever one and pretty as a picture. So are you, Lou.
He put a penny in the pocket of my pinafore. Mind you share!
Uncle Alf said. "Come on, Jack, I’ll stand you a pint, and we’ll drink to our partnership: Alf and Jack Gardener, Fresh Produce."
That year I started school, two years after Kathleen. Every day, we’d walk home together. One afternoon, instead of Mother waiting for us at the scullery door, Mrs. Bernardi stood by the kitchen table. She was buttering thin slices of bread and cutting them into triangles. She put them on the pretty flowered plate that Mother told us had been a wedding present. We never used it!
You carry the plate, Kathleen, and Louisa can bring up the cup.
Mrs. Bernardi led the way upstairs, holding the tray with our brown teapot, the milk jug, and a bowl of sugar.
Where was Mother? Why weren’t we going to have our tea in the kitchen? We were never allowed