Green Manufacturing
Green Manufacturing
Green Manufacturing
OF
DEPARTMENT
OF
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
SEMINAR
ON
GREEN MANUFACTURING
th
CERTIFICATE OF APPROVAL
This is to certify that Tapas Kumar Parida bearing
Registration
Number: 1221225112,
student of
8th
[ASST. PROFESSOR]
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Deposited By:
Tapas Kumar Parida
Abstract
The paper covers a survey of literature and cases on Green Manufacturing : the
methods of manufacturing that minimize waste & pollution and conserve resources. The
review of literature on Green manufacturing gives different Green designs based on
environment management system, energy conservation, development of cleaner products,
waste and pollution reduction. The literature is also available that advocate green
manufacturing as an instrument for sustainable infrastructure. New concepts like green
accounting are emerging that reflect the true welfare by incorporating the cost of
ecological damages and resource depletion.
The cases of Indian and foreign industries covered under the paper, unveil some
new aspects like green supply chain and value chain transition as in corrugated cardboard
industry, role of public policy in commercialization of green technology as observed in
US wind and gas turbine projects. The cases of varied approaches to green manufacturing
with conventional objectives
sectors. The
extension of green manufacturing to buildings and architecture opens new avenues where
green manufacturing can foray.
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Literature Survey
2.1. Green Design Research Area I: Environmental Management
2.2. Green Design Research Area II: Energy & Environment
2.3. Green Design Research Area III: Sustainable Infrastructure
2.4. Green Design Research Area IV: Cleaner Products through Life Cycle Design
(Milk and Juice Packaging)
2.5. Green Design Research Area V : Waste Reduction/Pollution Prevention
2.6. Green Accounting: Setting scales that measure resource conservation
3. Case Studies and Findings
3.1. List of cases analyzed
3.2. Case summaries and findings
4. Conclusion
5. Reference
Introduction
In recent years, with more and more requirement on energy sources saving and
environmental protection, green manufacturing has become an important approach in
production. In green manufacturing, product disassembly process is a key step, by which
the parts can be recycled from the outdated or discarded products for reuse,
remanufacturing or disposing, thus can save the energy sources and protect the
environment efficiently. To find an effective disassembly process, disassembly planning
is usually carried out, which aims at a feasible and optimal disassembly sequence with
minimal cost or time. An effective disassembly planning approach can not only provide a
solution to disassemble the product successfully and economically, it can also help the
designer to consider the product life cycle issues by focusing on the product disassembly
cost or time in the early design stage. In recent years, with the requirement for green
manufacturing technology, investigation on effective disassembly planning approach has
attracted much research attention and a variety of approaches have been proposed. Guo et
al. Proposed a modularization based disassembly sequence planning approach to resolve
the problem resulted from a large number of parts in the product, where the Hierarchy
Network Graph of product is created, and the precedence constraints related to the
hierarchy network graph is used to generate the disassembly sequence. Chung and Peng
proposed an integrated approach to selective-disassembly sequence planning, to get a
partial disassembly sequence where the parts or components are selected for recycling or
reuse. This approach can generate a feasible and practical sequence for selective
disassembly by two matrix- subassembly division precedence matrix and part
disassembly route matrix, to ensure both batch disassembly of components and tool
accessibility to fasteners. Torres et al. proposed a method to represent the hierarchical
relationships among components and/or assemblies of the product. Based on this
representation, an algorithm is established to generate a partial non-destructive
disassembly sequence of a product. Das and Naik proposed a descriptive model with a
structured format for creating, documenting, and evaluating a disassembly process plan.
And the model can transmit the product knowledge from the original product
manufacturer to the consumer and the end-of-life disassembler via the disassembly bill of
materials. Dong et al. proposed an approach to generate the disassembly sequence from a
hierarchical attributed liaison graph representation of an assembly automatically, by
decomposing the assembly into subassemblies recursively. The graph is built according to
the knowledge in engineering, design and demanufacturing, for each layer of the graph,
the preferred subassembly is selected in terms of mobility, stability, and parallelism. With
the graph, the proposed approach can find the feasible and practical sequence.
Veerakamolmal and Gupta proposed a case-based reasoning approach to disassembly
process planning, with a method to initialize a case memory and to operate a CBR
system. The approach can derive a feasible disassembly process quickly by retrieve,
reuse, and revise the product disassembly process plan.
The above works present the different disassembly planning approaches that can
provide the feasible and practical disassembly plans with different focus. However, these
approaches do not adopt the optimization search algorithm, so they can not easily find the
optimal or near optimal solutions.
Besides the above works, the other disassembly planning approaches with some
optimization algorithm are discussed as follows. Andres et al. proposed a two-phase
approach to determine the optimal disassembly sequence with the goal of minimizing
machine acquisition costs. A metaheuristic algorithm named GRASP is used to search for
the disassembly sequence for each product that leads to the minimum number of
intercellular movements. Rai et al. presented a Petri net model to search a partial
reachability graph, with the heuristic function, the proposed approach can generate a
feasible and optimal disassembly sequence based on the firing sequence of transitions of
the Petri net model. In the above two approaches, only one objective such as the machine
acquisition costs was considered, and the other objectives in disassembly process were
ignored. Because disassembly planning is a typical multi-objective optimization problem,
so the above approaches are not suitable to find the optimal or near optimal solutions
considering different objectives in disassembly process.
As an important method, the genetic algorithm (GA) has been widely used in
assembly planning , in the mean time, it is also used in disassembly planning to find the
optimal disassembly sequence. Kongar and Gupta proposed a GA approach to
disassembly sequence planning, with the objective to minimize the number of direction
changes, disassembly method changes, and the group of the identical material
components. Because assembly planning or disassembly planning are highly constrained
problem, using GAbased approach, sometimes the solution can not be converged to a
global optimal or near global optimal solution, or even a feasible solution cannot be found
in an evolution trial due to the precedence constraints when a product is complex and
composed of many parts.
Literature Survey
This account gives an account of what has been published on Green Manufacturing by
accredited scholars and researchers. The readings have been taken from the Internet as
well as from books published on the subject.
all value.The implementation of Green Manufacturing may not only be good for the
environment it is often good business, as well. The same is often true of other efforts
to reduce the energy- and material-intensiveness of manufacturing processes; what is
good for the environment is typically good for the balance sheet as well.
The Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Maryland has
specialists in the following areas where researchers are working on industry problems to
accelerate the process of innovation within the manufacturing sector, for its Green
Manufacturing Initiative (GMI).
Industrial Ecology
Exchangers
Environmental
Impact
Collection
Particulate Matter
10
Full cost accounting assigns the costs of materials, energy, labor, waste disposal, and
other costs to specific products or processes instead of lumping them in an overhead
account, to recognize the true burden of their environmental impacts.
A new focus for their research is benchmarking activities on determining how
environmental management systems influence environmental discharges and impacts
when regulatory requirements are different, to show changes in environmental impacts
over time in a single facility while accounting for product and process technology
changes, on how the organizational structure of a firm is influenced by an environmental
management system and how the information from the environmental management
system is used for better business decision making, etc.
Environmental Implications of Construction and Infrastructure
Life cycle assessment based on economic input output analysis and publicly available
environmental data (EIO-LCA) is used to quantify the environmental implications of
construction alternatives and infrastructure. Life cycle assessment traces out
environmental implications throughout a products life, from supply chain effects through
use and disposal.
Environnemental affects quantified:
Resource inputs: electricity, fuels, ores, fertilizers
Environmental outputs: toxic chemical releases, toxicity-weighted chemical emissions
(CMU-ET), ozone depletion potential, conventional air pollutant emissions, global
warming potential, RCRA Subtitle C hazardous waste generation and management.
Where possible, the social costs of these outputs are also quantified.
Case studies:
Insulation materials
11
12
13
organic compounds. In addition, if new regulations were set to reduce external costs,
significant improvements over current levels would result with savings in the billions of
dollars.
and
tradeoffs for
14
external input to the system as a whole is the (infinite) solar energy. In an industrial
ecosystem, the environmental burden of the system as a whole is reduced. This industrial
system would develop material cycles and employ energy cascades through cooperation
between the companies in the system. When successful, an industrial ecosystem
substitutes raw materials and energy that industry takes from nature with wastes and
hence reduces the virgin input of the system and the waste and emission output from the
system. Economic gains arise in the reduction of raw material and energy costs and waste
management costs. In this study, the basic industrial ecosystem principle is understood as
round put for describing recycling of matter and cascading of energy in an industrial
system. The ecosystem material and energy flow model including the flows of matter,
nutrients, energy and carbon is used for constructing an industrial ecosystem.
Green Accounting, Setting scales that measure resource conservation
Green Auditing /Accounting can be defined as: Identifying and measuring the costs of
environmental materials and activities and using this information for environmental
management decisions. The purpose is to recognize and seek to mitigate the negative
environmental effects of activities and systems.
Certain costs may be hidden and not attributed directly to environmental activity,
such as production shutdowns caused by responding to emergency spills or
retooling for environmental impact reduction.
ABC/ABM
accounting was
applied to
Where Activity Based Costing (ABC) captures cost elements in processes -- need
to add the environmental elements.
Where Activity Based Management (ABM) uses data to make decisions -- need to
add environmental criteria to the decision models.
15
1. From the start, the Green Accounting Team aligned its approach with ABC/ABM
principles.
2. Toward this goal, the Team designed an Activities/Resources matrix, which lists over
two dozen environmental activities.
3. This matrix, along with other information was used by the Team to relate different,
general environmental activities to the three segments of the COQ model as follows:
4. Specific objectives for future applications of Green Accounting include the following:
1. Bring environmental cost considerations into the business case for any future
plant start-ups and divestitures.
2. Inject environmental considerations into standard business case process models
used by AT&T organizations for business planning and management.
16
2.
3.
4.
Operations Strategy
5.
6.
7.
8.
Broadway of Green Bay: Replacing Acetone Solvent with an Aqueous Parts Cleaner
9.
17
18
Three lines of pipe work were commissioned, taking the effluent directly from the tank to
individual holding tanks, avoiding any dumping of effluent within the bund walls (unless
in an emergency).
Findings: The focus of process change was to reduce waste and increase operational
efficiency and environmental benefits were a byproduct.
Case 4: The Use Of Recycled Materials In Manufacturing: Implications For Supply
Chain Management And Operations Strategy
In this study we explore the implications of using recycled versus virgin materials
for the supply chain structure and supplier relationships as well as the broader effects on
operations strategy. We focus our study on the corrugated cardboard industry, where
vertical integration is common, and non-integrated firms are both customers and
competitors of integrated firms.
Findings : Unlike conventional cases on looking at cost or environmental benefits of
green manufacturing , the case extends to Green supply chain with a in depth analysis of
the possible .The Case Are Aimed At Developing A Better Understanding Of The NonEnvironmental Benefits Of Green Manufacturing For Supply Chain Management And
Operations Strategy Will Further Increase The Attractiveness And Use Of
Environmentally Friendly Practices.
Case 5: Northland College Ashland, Wisconsin & Case 7: Oberlin College- Oberlin,
Ohio
Optimize Placement and Configuration for Energy Performance.
Case 6: University of Michigan Ann Arbor, Michigan
Usage of recycled material like rubber, or eco friendly material wood and cork
flooring.
Case 8: Broadway of Green Bay: Replacing Acetone Solvent with an Aqueous Parts
Cleaner
Replacement of Acetone with water & soap for automobile parts cleaning for Cost
efficiency with hazardous waste reduction
19
20
threats and role of environmental policies and directives in systematizing innovations are
the areas of research of the case.
Findings: The case signifies the role of environmental policies in innovations like free
take back by producers, development of systems like Fiat Auto Recycling to meet the set
norms.
21
Conclusion:
Green manufacturing is a relatively new concept about which there is currently significant
confusion and misunderstanding regarding its components, costs, benefits, and
implementation. Its future trends, therefore, are also uncertain. It is likely; however, that
customers will increasingly demand low-cost, quickly produced and designed, highquality products characterized by extensive variety. They will also demand that such
products be produced by processes that are environmental responsible.
Whether green manufacturing is good business or a bad investment is being argued. On
one hand, eliminating waste has potential for reducing cost and increasing value. On the
other hand, investments can result in negative returns, decreasing dividends for
shareholders. Middle managers are often focused on quality and productivity rather than
environmental or marketing issues. This perspective can hinder development and
implementation of green manufacturing.
To ensure success in green manufacturing, corporate cultures need to be developed in
which the organization clearly defines its vision of green manufacturing and defines its
objectives for implementation, establishes a plan for achieving the objectives, and
recognizes the consequences and costs of not achieving these objectives. Along with
support of top management, a team approach with representation from engineering,
production, purchasing and human resources has been found to be necessary, rather than
reliance on plant-level environmental experts or consultants.
Training of the team in the techniques of total quality management would certainly help.
Green manufacturing is likely to be an increasingly important issue because it is a crucial
component in the international trend towards sustainable development. Sustainable
development has been a long term goal to meet the needs of the current generation by
developing systems and processes that do not compromise the needs of future
generations. Achieving this will require interdisciplinary cooperation between politicians,
economists, scientists and engineers.
22
http://www.ce.cmu.edu/GreenDesign/
http://csspub.snre.umich.edu/css_proj/
http://www.enme.umd.edu/greenmfg/links.html
http://www.leidenuniv.nl/interfac/cml/
http://www.indiainfoline.com/bisc/mdigm04.html
www.northland.edu/studentlife/ELLC/index.html
http://www.environmental-center.com/articles/article684/.htm
http://www.epa.gov/opptintr/acctg/pubs/greenac.pdf
http://www.deh.gov.au/industry/corporate/eecp/case-studies/nowra2.html
http://www.apo-kyo.org/gp/manila_conf02/resource_papers/narrative/bohra.pdf
23