Basics of Reactor Design & Selection: Mechanically Agitated Contactors
Basics of Reactor Design & Selection: Mechanically Agitated Contactors
Basics of Reactor Design & Selection: Mechanically Agitated Contactors
Prof. A. B. Pandit
Institute of Chemical Technology
University of Mumbai
Design Variables
Independent Variables
1. Reactor Geometry : Diameter, Height
2. Impeller type
3. Impeller diameter
4. Impeller Position
5. Impeller rotational speed
Minor Variables
1) Power
Important design variable; decides the operating cost
P = Power (watts) = NP N3 D5
2) Torque
Useful for drive consideration / selection
Power N P
Torque = τ = = ρN 3D5
2πN 2π
1
ND 2ρ
Re =
10 100 1000 104 105
Dimensionless Numbers
N 2 D Acceleration due to impeller
3) Froude No. :
g Acceleration due to gravity
N 2 D3 inertial forces
4) Weber Number :
surface tension forces
– surface / interfacial tension, N/m
D
Experimental observations : N Q
T
T
0.5
Q D
NQ Q – pumping rate, m3/s
ND3
Concept of turnover
4) Richardson Number :
Δρ ρ L g H
Ri =
ρL N 2D2
Certain Critical Impeller Speeds
0.45
N JS = S υ0.1 d P 0.2 gΔρ X 0.11 D-0.85
ρ
S – function of impeller type
T
3) C/T ratio : 0.1 ≤C/T ≤0.3
Solid suspension, low C/T etc.
Solid Suspension
1. Scale-up rules can vary
2. P/V decreases with increase in tank diameter
3. T/V can be constant
Surface Effects
1. Vortex formulation
2. Dry solids drawdown
3. Foam breading / non-wetting nature
High Viscosity Special Cases
Special Impellers : Close wall clearance
Anchors, Helical ribbons, screws / draft tubes
Range of applications :
Anchor : 10,000 cp – 1,50,000 cp
Ribbon : 30,000 cp – 1,50,000 cp
2.0 m
Utility of the relations in design
Max. temp. 260oC and hence hot fluid temp. 200oC very high steam pressure,
increase in reactor wall thickness expensive
Various designs are available : by varying pitch axial or radial component can
be altered, by making it profiled, it could alter shear and flow levels etc.
Due to slightly higher viscosities D/T ratio used 0.5 and two
impellers on the same shaft can be used
The final geometric design
Parameter selection
285-170 - 285-260 =
Average temp. gradient = 115
ΔT =59oC
ln
25
Q 1,00000
Hence the required HTC = =
A . ΔT 15.0×59
kcal
U =113
hrm2oC
The final design
Impeller speed required is calculated as follows
1 1 x 1 1 1 1 0.006
= + + = + +
U hR km ho 113 h R 800 km
kcal
hR 226
hr m2 oC
23 13 0.24
hR T ND ρ
2
CP μw
=0.485 k T =2.0 m;k o =0.163
kcal
ko μ μ hrm2oC
kcal
D=1.0 m;hR =226
hrm2oC
N = 1.52 r/s 91 rpm (90 rpm) kg kg
=3 poise=0.3 1080
ms mm
Now check whether this impeller speed CP =0.5
kcal
; 900kg m3
satisfies the other operational o
kg C
requirements
The final design
Heating to 150oC in 1 hr.
Heat duty = m Cp T
= 3235 x 0.5 x (150-30) = 194000 kcal
Heat flux obtainable = U A T
= 113 x 15 x [(285-30)-(285-150)]/ln(255/135)
= 319816 kcal / hr.
Expected time of heating = 194000/319816 = 0.6 hrs 37 min.
Final mixing depends upon the exchange between the two loops which is 35 %.
21
θmix 60 sec 1min
0.35
GOAL ACHIEVED
1.5× 1 ×900
2
2
ND ρ
Reynolds Number = = = 4500
μ 0.3
Thus, you can
• Expect NP to increase to about 1.1
• Actual power curve is necessary
3
D ×RPM
HP= C = 50, for only torsional
C
A
A – Reactor
B – Condenser for reflux
C – Separator for xylene return
& water removal
Vapors might be cooled due to atmospheric heat losses by the time they
come to the condenser
2.58 3m 2
Due to pthalic evaporation, considerable fouling is observed,
Thus, Let A 10m2
Mounted Vertical : Washing of vapors and preheating of returned
liquid
Fouling : Tube dia ≥ ¾”, periodic clearing
Cooling water requirement
Total heat removed = 1,00, 000 kcal/hr
Q = m CP T
1, 00, 00 = m x 1 x 7
Diameter of separator 20 cm
Height or length = 50 cm
Separator Arrangements
A
B
xylene
vapors
vap
liquid
water
vapors
C
Xylene to
reactor
water
Other Utilities
2) Cooling water
Important Criteria
1) Size of the droplets
2) Heat of reaction to be removed
3) Controlling the molecular wt. distribution
Ci ki Vi ti C1
e-k1t1
Ci -ki Vi Co
t t
m CPi Ti dt - QL CP Z ΔT ×t +R HR dt
0 0
t
=CPR TR mi +m dt (2)
0
Now, all these impeller speeds are function of the following additional
parameters
1. Physical properties of system
2. Type and size of impeller
3. Required production rate (also dependent on temp. & catalyst conc.)
Thus number of combinations need to be tried for an optimum design
Again : parameter might be different for different recipes
Thus finding a compromise, suitable for all recipies
Type of Services
• Continuous – Slow speed
• Otherwise – high speed
• Future changes / Experiments (built in flexibility)
• variable speed
Power for agitator
Absorbed for agitator
Add for baffles and fittings
Dip pipes (10%) and thermo wells (40%)
Transmission Losses
Worm wheel < 85%
Helical gears > 90%
Planetary gears > 96%
V belts 90 to 95 %
Gland Losses
Higher of ½ HP or 10%
Motor Aspects
Oversize for start up
oversize for settling solids
next higher standard size
Mechanical Aspects
Concerns
• Jamming
• Fatigue Failure
• Pitting / corrosion
• Deflection
Mechanical Aspects
Shaft diameter
3300×12×HP
Tm = 2.5 Tc ton.in Tc =
2 n×2240
S
Tm
Force, Fm = ton
0.75r
dt
L Moment Mm = Fm x L ton.in
0.75 r
32 Mm
Stress, fy =
dt
3
2r
Shaft deflection
448 Fm L3
x x= =
0.75 r 9 D4 E
Mechanical Aspect
Critical Speed
If ‘x’ is the critical speed we must not work at (0.7 x) RPM to (1.3 x) RPM
EI
x=k Rev / min.
Ws l4
E : Young’s Modulus
I : Moment of Intertia k
Ws : Weight of shaft
K : from graph
= L/S
= length / distance from
bearing
Mixing
Types
• Liquid – Liquid (most common) a) density difference b) viscosity difference
• Solid – Liquid a) slurry b) suspension c) dissolution
• Gas – Liquid a) dispersion
• Liquid – Liquid (immiscible) a) emulsion / dispersion
Requirement
Energy to be supplied for moving the different phases
a) Supplied internally : e.g. Mechanically Agitated Contactors
b) Supplied externally : e.g. use of pumps, compressors, blowers
Devices Used
a) Stirred vessels
b) jet mixing
c) static mixing / mixers
Z1L 2 T
Mixing time = θ =
νido
16 46
Re g1 6
Jet Mixing
Energy associated with the moving fluid is used for mixing, i.e. if fluid is
made to go everywhere in the reactor / vessel uniformity (mixing) will be
achieved.
Common Examples
Inserted in pipes
Flow bifurcation takes place and
the direction is changed
Energy for mixing
Stirred Vessel
Jet mixing
Static mixing
Typical = 1 to 10 %
Requirement
C
1) Length of loop, longest
D
2) Average velocity
3) No. of circulations
B E
A
1) Length of the longest loop ‘ABCDE’
2) Average velocity Vrw = 0.53 (D/w) ND (D/T)7/6
3) No. of circulations 5 for 95% mixing
And
KL a = 0.025 (P/V)0.59 (VG)0.5
N
PG = NPG L N3 D5
NPG/NP
VG 30 to 40 mm/s
P/V = g VG
Problem Statement
3) To suspend catalyst particles
0.45
gΔρ
Njs =S 0.1 dp0.2 x0.11 D-0.85
ρ
b
QG
NjsG =NjsG x 3
ND
x – type of sparger / location and regime
b – extent of reduction in NPG
Thus knowing dp, , x & S. Select either Njs for a fixed D or select D for a
fixed Njs.
1 1 x 1
Now, = + +
U hR k m ho
Jacket -0.14
hR T 0.33 μwall
=1.35 Re Pr
0.59
N
k μ
bulk