A9 James 9 of 12
A9 James 9 of 12
A9 James 9 of 12
SaApostle
Born Unknown
Venerated
Roman Catholic Church
in
Contents
[hide]
• 1 Identity
○ 1.1 Possible identity with James the Less
○ 1.2 Possible identity with James, the brother of Jesus
○ 1.3 Possible brother of Matthew
• 2 Tradition
• 3 References
[edit] Identity
[edit] Possible identity with James the Less
James, son of Alphaeus is often identified with James the Less, who is only mentioned three
times, each time in connection with his mother. Mark 15:40 refers to "Mary the mother of James
the younger and of Joses", while Mark 16:1 and Matthew 27:56 refer to "Mary the mother of
James".
Since there was already a more prominent James (James, son of Zebedee) among the twelve
apostles, equating James son of Alphaeus with James the Less made sense. (James son of
Zebedee was sometimes called "James the Greater"). However, it also made it imperative to
identify Clopas, the husband of Mary, with Alphaeus, the father of the Apostle James.[4] (For the
argument on this, see Alphaeus.) This identification was accepted by early church leaders and,
therefore, tradition knows him more commonly as Saint James the Less.
Modern Biblical scholars are divided on whether this identification is correct. John Paul Meier
finds it unlikely.[5] Amongst evangelicals, the New Bible Dictionary supports the traditional
identification,[6] while Don Carson[7] and Darrell Bock[8] both regard the identification as
possible, but not certain.
[edit] Possible identity with James, the brother of Jesus
James, son of Alphaeus, has also been identified with James, the brother of Jesus. This was
supported by Jerome and therefore widely accepted in the Roman Catholic Church[9], while the
Eastern Orthodox and Protestant tend to distinguish between the two.
[edit] Possible brother of Matthew
Another Alphaeus is also the name of the father of the publican Levi mentioned in Mark 2:14.
The publican appears as Matthew in Matthew 9:9, which has led some to conclude that James
and Matthew might have been brothers. However, there is no Biblical account of the two being
called brothers, even when they appear side by side in the synoptic list of the Twelve Apostles,
next to the fraternal pairs of Peter and Andrew and the sons of Zebedee.
[edit] Tradition
A tradition holds that Saint James, though strongly clinging to Jewish law, was sentenced to
death for having violated the Torah. This however, is highly unlikely as the Jewish authorities did
not practice crucifixion, and unless a possible rebellion was at hand, the Roman authority would
not involve themselves in Jewish religious affairs. He is reported to have been martyred by
crucifixion at Ostrakine in Lower Egypt, where he was preaching the Gospel. A carpenter's saw
is the symbol associated with him in Christian art because it is also noted that his body was later
sawed to pieces [10]
[edit] References
Wikimedia Commons has media related to: Saint James the Less