Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
(Purchasing Computers)
Consumer Behavior
Translated by
Dr. Mohamed Atif Mogahed Mohamed
Al-Jeraisy, Khaled ibn Abdurrahman Consumer behavior./ Khaled ibn Abdurrahman Al-Jeraisy - 3. Riyadh, 2008 338P; 17x24 cm ISBN: 978-603-00-0680-9 1- Consumer behavior - Saudi Arabia 2- Marketing Saudi Arabia II- Title 658, 834 dc 1429/3338
Dedication
Dedication
To my dear parents, I humbly dedicate this work. They are my heart's delight. They have supported me throughout my life. They have instilled in me high aspirations and determination. Their pleasure I do seek, and their prayers I do need.
Khaled
Consumer Behavior
Contents
Table of Contents
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
1.1 The Marketing Concept . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 1.2 Historical Development of the Marketing Role . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18 1.3 Components of the Marketing Activity. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 1.4 Product Classification from a Marketing Perspective. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30
Chapter 2: Consumer Behavior: Definition & Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37
2.1 Consumption, the Consumer and Consumer Behavior . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43 2.2 Models of Consumer Behavior. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 50 2.3 The Saudi Family's Decision Model of Purchasing a PC. . . . . . . . . . . . . 64
Chapter 3: Consumer Purchase Decision . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 83
3.1 The Process of Purchase Decision-Making . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 87 3.2 Determinants and Types of Purchase Decisions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102 3.3 The Consumer's Decision to Adopt New Products . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 109
Chapter 4: Social Factors Affecting the Purchase Decision. . . . . . . . . . 121
4.1 Culture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 125 4.2 Social Class. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 130 4.3 Reference Group. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 137 4.4 Age . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 145 4.5 Educational Level. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 150 4.6 Gender. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 153
Consumer Behavior
Contents
Consumer Behavior
Introduction
Introduction
At present, project management is facing a lot of contextual changes, such as rapid changes in the modern consumer's desires, inflation in world economies, growing consumer awareness and consumer protection movements. The changes require proper solutions, which care for consumer needs and the public interest while achieving the business aim of profit-making. Seeking easy solutions for marketing problems aggravates matters due to the complexity of consumer behavior and the intricacy of related factors. In addition, management often suffers from lack of relevant information necessary for proper decision-making. Therefore, it is imperative to understand the intricacies of behavior motives, calculate the costs of alternative marketing strategies and gather the information needed for competent decision-making. These requirements are considered essential for modern management. The present book deals with various aspects of consumer behavior, in addition to the study of consumer purchase decision and its major determinants. It is methodologically based on a practical application approach. A unique feature of this book is its adoption of a methodological framework integrating all marketing dimensions with consumer behavior, theoretically and practically. The book contains nine chapters, discussing the basic principles of marketing, the marketing environment and consumer behavior. As the cornerstone of marketing activities, consumer behavior is discussed in terms of the following: behavior patterns and major determinants; purchase decision process and stages; purchase decision patterns; various roles in purchase decision-making; the psychological, social, economic and marketing factors related to the purchase decision; and the purchase decision interaction within the
6
Consumer Behavior
Introduction
family, with special reference to the Saudi family. A major reason for writing this book is the author's desire to provide students with up-to-date vital material related to untraditional, varied and intensive research areas in the field of marketing. Another major reason is his desire, as a practitioner of marketing, to contribute to the advancement of the management and practice of the marketing process in our developing environment in order competence. In conclusion, the author prays that Allah, the Almighty, may make his effort, though humble, contribute to the fulfillment of felt needs and achieve its desired benefits. It is only Allah that grants success. to attain the required effectiveness and
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 1
Marketing Activity Management
Chapter Topics
1.1 The Marketing Concept 1.2 Historical Development of the Marketing Role 1.3 Components of the Marketing Activity 1.4 Product Classication from a Marketing Perspective
Consumer Behavior
11
Chapter 1
Consumer Behavior
of marketing for being narrow. Seeking a broader definition, he puts forward this one: ``Marketing is a total system of interacting business activities designed to plan, price, promote, and distribute want-satisfying products and services to present and potential customers.''(3) Erickson and Richard define marketing as ``a set of integrated activities performed by an organization in order to facilitate exchange processes.'' For that purpose, the marketing department has to perform two essential functions: (a) encouraging demand for its products; and (b) servicing demand. The former function is to be achieved through the following: determination of market opportunity, research, product planning, advertising, personal selling and sales promotion, pricing, and branding. The latter function is to be achieved through actual exchange implementation. It involves storage and transportation, filling orders and exchange, technical service, warranty, distribution outlets, selecting market segments, and financing the marketing activity.(4) Kotler, the pioneer of the new school of marketing, considers marketing as ``a social and managerial process whereby individuals and groups satisfy their needs and wants through making and exchanging products and values... with others.''(5) This definition considers marketing as a mix of these particular elements: a human activity element; a satisfaction element; and an exchange element. The human activity element is concerned with individuals and their behavior. The marketer is to identify their needs and wants in order to satisfy them. The satisfaction element is to be accomplished through the products supplied by the firm to the market. Satisfaction is to be accomplished through exchange. The exchange element is to be implemented within a spacio-temporal dimension representing the market.(6). In spite of the comprehensiveness of Kotler's definition, there are other practical considerations that require researchers to deal with
Consumer Behavior
13
Chapter 1
the marketing concept from other perspectives in order to reach a thorough understanding of the value and importance of marketing; a lot of organizations consider marketing the backbone of their activities, survival and growth. Ferrel and Pride agree that these definitions and others may be acceptable to some academicians and practitioners, but they have some defects for one or more of the following reasons: 1. One definition limits marketing to business enterprises even though it is practiced by non-profit and service organizations. 2. The definitions marketing scope. 3. Marketing does not only deal with goods and services but also with ideas. 4. The definitions do not recognize that marketing decisions are activities that take place in a dynamic environment. In light of these criticisms, Pride and Ferrell give the following definition: ``Marketing consists of various activities of individuals and organizations that facilitate
(7)
seem
to be too
general
to determine the
exchange
in
dynamic
environment by producing, distributing, promoting, and pricing goods, services, and ideas.''
Obviously, the definitions mentioned so far do not give an accurate or comprehensive Thus, picture of marketing, to define probably because each marketing, as a science, is still undergoing fast and continuous development. attempting marketing, researcher has dealt with a particular aspect of marketing. The following definition attempts to give a more comprehensive picture: ``Marketing is all the activities that are designed to make and facilitate any exchange process aiming at satisfying human needs and wants.''
(8)
According
to
this
definition, aim
both
the at
consumer and the society are considered the starting point in planning an organization's activities, which basically
14
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
15
Chapter 1
Utilitarian Exchange
This type of exchange is often associated with economic utility where the motive is to benefit from the expected use of the product or its tangible attributes. In general, the theory of utilitarian exchange is founded on the concept of the ``economic man'', which is, in turn, based on the following assumptions: D Individuals are rational in their behavior. D Individuals try to maximize their satisfaction through exchange. D Individuals have complete information on the available alternatives.
Symbolic Exchange
This is the exchange of psychological and social values and other intangibles between two or more parties. According to Levy, who first introduced this behavioral aspect to the exchange process in marketing, a consumer often purchases goods and services not because of what they directly offer, but because of their social and psychological symbolism. So, when a lady purchases a fur, it does not only mean the great warmth the fur provides, but also the high social status it symbolizes for the lady as well as her feeling of pride and elegance.
Mixed Exchange
An exchange process in marketing may be both utilitarian and symbolic. Underlying this mixed exchange is the new concept of the ``marketing man,'' who simultaneously seeks material and symbolic utilities from the exchange process. The ``marketing man'' concept is based on the following assumptions: a. Some aspects of a person's behavior are rational, while others are emotional.
16
Consumer Behavior
b. A person is motivated by material and non-material stimuli, and by internal and external forces. c. A person participates in utilitarian and symbolic exchanges, which have psychological and social dimensions. d. Although one is exposed to incomplete information, one benefits from it in the best way possible, and simply calculates the costs and social and economic advantages associated with exchange. Exchange does not take place in isolation, but it is subjugated to a large number of economic, social, legal, and ethical limitations, etc.(9) In light of the mixed exchange concept and the previous discussion on marketing definitions, the researcher adopts a definition that is best suited to the present study: ``Marketing is a set of integrated activities that take place within a specific managerial activity framework and guide the flow of goods, services, and ideas in order to achieve satisfaction through an exchange process and achieve the objectives of producers, distributors, or importers within the constraints of the surrounding environment.''(10)
Consumer Behavior
17
Chapter 1
Four distinct stages can be identified in the evolution of marketing role since 1910 as follows:
[A] The Production-Oriented Stage (Production Concept)
The production-oriented stage lasted from the middle of the eighteenth century to the beginning of the twentieth century. The focus was essentially on the production process, not on marketing. It was assumed that the consumer was the party seeking the
18
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
19
Chapter 1
denies his being ``the master of the market''. The world economic crisis of the late 1920s made consumers afraid of further crises. So, they had to reduce their consumption of various products. This led to less demand on the one hand, and accumulation of surplus supplies on the other. Producers had to store excess supplies, creating the problem of how to get rid of their surplus stocks.(15)
[B] The Sales-Oriented Stage (Sales Concept)
The sales-oriented stage lasted nearly from the beginning to the middle of the twentieth century. Facing the problems of excess inventories, product damage risks and obsolescence, made producers and distributors think of ways to get rid of the excess supply, so they resorted to marketing. (16) The emphasis was on selling and promotional efforts since the sales concept requires a great deal of salesmen's efforts in order to influence the consumer, motivate him to purchase, and repeat purchasing. ``Thus, marketing focused on selling in order to maximize sales and, in turn, maximize profit.''(17) This concept considers selling and advertising among the most important marketing activities, and, like the production-oriented concept, it gives priority to the firm's interest over the consumer's. Among the most important assumptions upon which the sales concept is based are the following: (18) 1. Customers normally tend to hold comparisons when buying things they do not urgently need. 2. Through persuasion the consumer can buy more. 3. The organization must have a strong sales department in order to attract and keep customers. According to the sales concept, the sales manager has to sell the firm's products through his sales workforce. Also, advertising is done by the advertising department, whose manager is independent
20
Consumer Behavior
of the sales department. The production department plans and designs products according to purely technical principles. As a result, no due attention is given to the marketing process as a coordinated effort.(19) A number of companies still adopt the sales concept. Their aim is to maximize their sales by all means possible. Although this aim seems to express a legitimate statement, its content is subject to criticism; maximizing sales is a major objective for all organizations, but only through a proper philosophy of marketing. Such philosophy should give priority to satisfying the consumer's needs and desires by means of a varied and integrated marketing mix. Only then, will sales and profits increase and grow in the long run. This is the essence of proper marketing.
[C] The Marketing-Oriented Stage (Marketing Concept)
The marketing-oriented stage (the marketing concept) continued from the early 1950's to the present time. Unlike the sales concept, which focuses on meeting the seller's needs, the marketing concept focuses on meeting the needs of both the seller and the buyer. Also, whereas the sales concept seeks to turn the product into a monetary value, the marketing concept seeks to achieve the organization's aims through satisfying the consumer's needs and wants. Thus, the marketing concept considers the consumer as the axis as well as the mover of the marketing process. Underlying the marketing concept are the following principles: 1. The consumer's needs and wants represent the starting point. 2. The marketing activity is linked to the managerial process. 3. The marketing function is continuous, and it does not focus on short-term objectives alone, but targets long-term ones, too. The modern concept of marketing has developed the following set of principles:
Consumer Behavior
21
Chapter 1
1. The company's assets have no value without customers. 2. The organization's main task is to attract consumers to its goods and services. 3. The major means to attract consumers is the promise to achieve the required satisfaction of their needs and wants. 4. The main duty of marketing is to define, explain and offer such promises, and to ensure the satisfaction of the consumer's needs. 5. The real satisfaction of consumers' needs and wants is affected in the first place by the performance of all administrations and departments of the organization. 6. Satisfying human needs through marketing cannot be achieved without having all administrations and departments base their activities on marketing principles.(20) 7. There have to be long-term plans for the organization's marketing efforts. The consumer concept has given rise to the term ``consumer research'', which refers to the study of the consumer's motives, characteristics, habits and expectations in order to influence his behavior, hence increase sales opportunities. It has also given rise to the activity of surveying consumers' opinions. This activity is concerned with studying the market and the factors affecting it, and studying consumers and their motives in order to know their opinions about the products on sale in the marketplace. In other words, marketing research has become increasingly important and has developed into an independent science. To sum up, the marketing concept focuses on the consumer's needs and wants, which are to be met through an integrated marketing activity.(21)
[D] The Societal Marketing Concept
Consumer Behavior
Proponents of this thriving concept consider marketing an effective and influential business activity that should play a role in raising individuals' living standards. They maintain that the marketing activity - through providing goods and services - contributes to the well-being of consumers. However, this affects a limited number of individuals who can afford to buy the goods and services. Apparently, many departed from the essence of the marketing concept when they devoted most of their efforts to satisfying a limited segment of consumers. Unfortunately, satisfying consumers is sometimes done at the expense of public interest. In order to overcome this deficiency, Kotler suggests adopting the societal marketing concept.
Consumer Behavior
23
Chapter 1
planned), and food stores that are run by professional associations/ societies for the benefit of their members. These stores sell subsidized products or buy direct from the producer and sell to the public at competitive prices. They sometimes recycle glass, aluminum and plastic containers. The association of the marketing concept with the society and its interests is quite obvious in competitions prevailing nowadays, which make producers and distributors adopt the marketing and societal concepts. Today's consumer is no longer unaware of the products available in the marketplace. In addition, consumers' tastes and puchasing motives, more than ever, require serious study on the part of producers and distributors. How could they market a product without consulting the consumer about it?! However, there are those who hold firmly to the view that despite individual cases of monopoly that necessitate the application of the societal marketing concept, the marketing concept - especially through marketing research - remains dominant. They also believe that businesses cannot work actively except in the areas where the consumer wants them to. In other words, it is the consumer that determines the policies, programs, and directions of businesses. With the dominance of the marketing concept, the marketing philosophy has emphasized and reinforced the notion of consumer sovereignty, as based on Adam Smith's economic views. Smith considers the final consumer to be the focus of the process of production and distribution of goods and services. In other words, business activity basically centers around the consumer.(24) Thus, the marketing role is no longer limited to persuading the consumer to buy products; rather, it seeks to identify his needs and to satisfy them. The information provided by traditional marketing research - such as market size and consumers' demographics - is no longer sufficient in helping management in making good production and marketing decisions. More comprehensive research is now needed to provide management with consumer information
24
Consumer Behavior
from various angles: social, psychological, economic and personal. This helps understand consumer behavior - how and why he acts in a certain way - in order to be able to predict his purchasing decisions.
(25)
It is a fact that the consumer is ``the master of the market''. It is also a fact that the study of his needs, wants and behavior is the safest way for business survival and growth. Ignoring these facts often leads to the collapse of business. Intelligent management should realize that the consumer represents the starting and closing points in the present world of business. It should also realize that understanding the nature of the consumer and studying his purchasing behavior have become an essential component of the marketing activity. Therefore, the producer is not to provide the market with what he thinks the consumer needs. Instead, he has to identify the consumer's real needs and wants, then make them available to him.
(26)
Without
doing
so,
production
would
be
pointless, and no increase of sales should be expected. Indeed, understanding the consumer is the key to successful marketing.
Consumer Behavior
25
Chapter 1
Marketing is no longer considered the last stage in business activities. Instead, marketing principles and procedures have to be applied prior to, during and after production. In the post production stage, the marketing activity follows the product till it reaches the consumer and till he uses it in order to get feedback on his reaction, suggestions or complaints. The vital role of an organization's marketing activity is manifested in the interaction between the organization and its environment. It is also reflected in the coordination with all the other activities of the organization, e.g. finance, production, human resources and customer service. The interaction and coordination should lead to (27) the achievement of the organization's higher interests. Thus, an effective marketing activity requires full integration and coordination among the marketing functions and tasks themselves. This should lead (28) to the successful implementation of the organization's plan, which is meant to influence the behavior of (29) the final consumer in the market. When formulating the marketing plan, those responsible have to choose the products, pricing policies, promotion methods and distribution methods that suit the organization's conditions on the one hand, and the surrounding environment on the other hand.(30) In other words, marketing management has to answer the basic question of what marketing mix is suitable for meeting the needs (31) and wants of the organization's target market.
-
Consumer Behavior
studying and analyzing the marketing environment and available opportunities for the organization. It also requires identifying the factors affecting consumer behavior. Such studies are considered the main source for developing plans necessary for the following: 1. The policy of goods / services and the mix of goods / services suitable for markets and market segments; 2. Pricing policies for goods / services, and how to make these policies effective in gaining a larger share of the market; 3. A promotion and marketing communication policy explaining all about the organization and its goods and services through a proper promotional mix including personal selling, advertising and sales promotion, in addition to preparing plans for
advertising campaigns whenever required by market conditions; 4. Distribution methods and how to make them successful in relation to the nature of the market and the organization's potentials.
(32)
Thus, an effective marketing activity must include the four elements of the marketing mix, for they constitute the framework of an integrated marketing plan. Also, it may need a set of secondary policies that ensures successful application in varied circumstances. Let us define each of the four elements.
1.3.1.1 Product
The term ``product'' refers to what business organizations offer to their prospective customers in terms of goods, services or ideas. Modern marketing studies have expanded the definition to include personnel and tourist places and cities. A successful marketer is to identify the products that are best suited to his customers. This requires the application of a number of essential marketing
Consumer Behavior
27
Chapter 1
functions, products; such as: marketing the research for developing current new studying product lifecycle; and launching
products that meet customers' needs and wants. In addition, the successful marketer is to perform a set of activities that facilitate obtaining and using the products, e.g. distinctive branding, package design, and providing warranty, and servicing, maintenance and spare parts that keep the products in good condition for a reasonable period of time.
indirect,
intermediaries);
intermediaries
(agents,
wholesalers, retailers); and evaluating intermediaries and the ways of dealing with them as channels of distribution.
1.3.1.3 Pricing
Pricing is the process of balancing the benefits that a final consumer or industrial buyer obtains with the money he can pay for a product, a service or an idea. It is a complex process related to several economic and behavioral considerations; the price mix is based on the careful study of several factors, such as supply, demand, competition and consumer's ability to pay. Inaccurate price determination definitely has disastrous consequences; the organization loses either its customers or its profits, and both scenarios are bad. So, it must set proper pricing strategies that secure a strong competitive position for it in the market.
(33)
28
Consumer Behavior
1.3.1.4 Promotion
Promotion represents the element of communication with the consumer. Through it suitable information is conveyed to the consumer in order to motivate him to buy the organization's products. Promotion aims to achieve the following: 1. Familiarizing consumers with the organization's goods and services on sale, particularly new ones, in terms of name, brand, characteristics, benefits, and sales-outlets; 2. Reminding consumers of available goods or services in order to reinforce loyalty to the product, and possibly to prevent switching to rival products; 3. Changing any negative attitudes consumers may have towards the product into positive ones; and 4. Persuading consumers that the goods or services are beneficial to them and that they satisfy their needs and wants.(34) 5. Encouraging consumers to buy. The promotional mix consists of several elements: advertising, personal selling, sales promotion and publicity.(35) Accordingly, promotion is described as ``the official spokesperson'' of marketing activities. It is carried out through a personal or impersonal means (newspapers, radio, television, etc.). It also involves continuous communication with customers so as to ensure the organization's presence in the present and future market. Finally, it is worth emphasizing that all marketing activities must be integrated, otherwise serious consequences will accrue. For example, the good product whose price exceeds the consumer's ability to pay will be difficult to sell. Also, the distinct product that is not distributed at the suitable place and time will not see the light. If knowledge about the product is not given at the appropriate time, it may lose the consumer forever.(36)
Consumer Behavior
29
Chapter 1
the means of bringing such benefits to the consumer. Therefore, marketing management is concerned with defining the quality of the required product, promotion methods and providing
(38)
the
Thus, from a marketing point of view, a product is considered ``a set of tangible and intangible properties, including package, shape, color, price, reputation - of the producer and the seller - and postsale services, all of which are presented to the prospective buyer as an offer to be used for satisfying his needs.''
(39)
From a producer's point of view the product is seen as a tangible object containing raw materials, parts, and chemical specifications, and has certain physical properties. From a consumer's point of view, it has a different meaning. When he buys it, he buys its expected benefits and the material or non-material satisfaction resulting from using it.
(40)
expects not just to satisfy the need for transport, but also to get distinction and enjoyment when driving it. It is necessary that the producer see the product from the consumer's angle as well.
30
Consumer Behavior
a. Consumer products
These are the goods and services that a consumer buys by himself or through others in order to use (consume) them to satisfy his own needs and wants as well as his family's, but not to re-sell them.
b. Industrial products
These are the goods and services that an industrial buyer purchases for the purpose of using them in his production processes or producing other goods or services.
1. Convenience products
These products are available to the consumer everywhere and at all times. The consumer does not exert a special effort in searching for them, and he can buy them from the nearest store at any time. They include such items as bread, groceries, drinks, and newspapers. Usually he buys them frequently and does not spend time planning for them or comparing among varieties or selecting among stores. Convenience products are usually sold to a very large number of consumers in small quantities and in small sizes. For each type and brand there are many alternatives, and the consumer often sees them to be similar in characteristics, advantages and quality.
Consumer Behavior
31
Chapter 1
Convenience products are divided into three types: a. Staple products: These are products the consumer buys on a regular basis, such as groceries, toothpaste and laundry services. b. Impulse products: They are unplanned purchases or products that require very little planning, such as soft drinks. They are available everywhere the consumer goes, so he rarely exerts any effort searching for them. c. Emergency products: These are products not purchased under normal circumstances, but purchased to meet urgent needs, such as an umbrella to protect one from sudden rain, and over-the-counter medications. Marketers place these products on nearby shelves so that the consumer can get them easily whenever he needs them.
2. Shopping Products
These are the goods a consumer buys after comparing the available items in terms of price, properties, quality, warranty and service in order to select the best among them. Examples of these goods are household electric appliances, clothes and furnishings. The consumer spends more time searching for these selective goods than for convenience goods. They are purchased less frequently than convenience goods, and their prices are higher.
3. Specialty Products
These goods have unique properties and satisfy special consumer needs. Their buyers are willing to spend more money and effort to obtain them. With this type of products, the consumer plans carefully for buying them and does not compare available alternatives when shopping; he looks for a specific brand. If he does not find it, he is willing to wait for some time until it becomes available. Examples of these products include jewelry, gold lighters,
32
Consumer Behavior
certain brands of perfume, luxurious cars, advanced medical equipment, luxury hotels and special services for first class flights. Most of these goods satisfy social and psychological desires, e.g. the desire for distinction and recognition. It is worth noting that this product classification is associated with the consumer's environment and time. So, what is considered a specialty product at one time can be a shopping product at another time, and vice versa. Product classification is also related to age, income level, social class and other consumer characteristics that influence consumer behavior. Therefore, some writers classify consumer products in terms of the type of need they satisfy.
Consumer Behavior
33
Chapter 1
technical expertise, and need post-sale service. Examples of these products include personal computers, television sets, refrigerators, cars, washing machines and furniture. b. Non-durable (consumable) goods: These goods are used or consumed fast, once or several times during a short period of time, and are sold for relatively low prices. They include all the products consumed by the final consumer, such as food products and other goods he regularly needs and uses in his daily life.
(43)
34
Consumer Behavior
Endnotes of Chapter 1
(1) Al-Hajj,
Tareq,
Ali
Rabayia,
Mohamed ,
Al-Basha, (Arabic),
and
Munzir Dar
Amman,
Publishing and Distribution, 1990, pp. 11-12. (2) Harb, Bayan Hani, (Arabic), Amman, Al-Warraq Publishing
(Arabic),
Maktabat Ashshagri, Riyadh, 9th. edition, 1999, p. 19. (5) Kotler, P.., Armstrong, G.,
(8)
Obaidat, Mohamed,
for Publishing and Distribution, 1997, p. 35. (12) (13) (14) (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) (21) (22) (23) (24) Abdul-Hameed, Ibid., p. 33. Idrees and Al-Ghais,
Eective Marketing,,
Marketing Management,
Al-Musa'ed, op.cit., p. 35. Ibid., p. 35. Ibid., pp. 35-36. Abdul-Hameed, Ibid., p. 34. Ibid., p. 73-63.
Eective Marketing,
op. cit., p. 35
Al Eqtesadia,
-
Consumer Behavior
35
Chapter 1
(25)
Assulami, Ali,
Printing and Publishing, 1983, p. 43. (27) (28) Harb, Bayan Hani,
the Purchase Behavior of Saudi and non Saudi Women in Jeddah, Principles of Marketing,
op.cit., p. 17. Idrees and Al-Ghais, Harb,
Analysis of
Research Center of the Chamber of Commerce and Industry in Jeddah, op. cit., p. 17. Hanna, Neseem,
Dar Al-Marrikh for Publishing, 1985, p. 153. op. cit., pp. 457-458.
Research Center of the Chamber of Commerce and Industry in Jeddah, op. cit., pp. 17-19.
(35)
(Arabic),
Amman, Dar Al-Zahran for Publishing and Distributing, 1999, pp. 240-244. (36) (37) (38) (39) (40) (41) (42) (43) Research Center of the Chamber of Commerce and Industry in Jeddah, op. cit., p. 19. Al-Abdaly and Al-Allaq, Harb, Bayan Hani,
Marketing: Essentials and Principles, Principles of Marketing, Marketing Management Eective Marketing,
op. cit., p. 121. op. cit., p. 311.
36
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 2
Consumer Behavior: Denition & Models
Chapter Topics
2.1 Consumption, the Consumer and Consumer B ehavior 2.2 Models of Consumer Behavior 2.3 The Saudi Family's Decision Model of Purchasing a PC
Consumer Behavior
39
The marketing activity sets the consumer at the top of the organization's hierarchy of aims. Its main aim is to satisfy the consumer's organization activities. needs plans, and wants. Towards directs that aim, the its organizes, and controls
D D D
Not only does marketing seek to identify the consumer's current needs and wants, but also to discover dormant ones. The marketing activity seeks to translate needs and wants into goods or services. The marketing activity seeks to select the appropriate
marketing mix from the 4 Ps. (product, price, place and promotion).
The proper marketing mix is determined in light of the findings reached through the study of targeted consumers. The marketing strategy is based on market segmentation according to [consumers'] demographic, behavioral, and economic characteristics.
Consumer Behavior
41
Chapter 2
Marketing activities go beyond the selling transaction. They involve post sale services and (3) following up with the consumer to ensure his satisfaction.
-
42
Consumer Behavior
Consumption can be defined as the process of purchasing and using a product, then disposing of the remainder. Final consumption involves using or enjoying the products (goods/ services) to satisfy such purposes that nothing suitable is left out of them to satisfy further needs. (4) Accordingly, the basic components of the definition of consumption are: 1. Purchasing; 2. Usage; 3. Disposal of the remainder; and 4. Inability of the remainder to satisfy other needs.
2.1.2 Consumer
The term ``consumer'' refers to two types of consuming units, final consumer and organizational consumer. The final consumer (an individual, a family or a household) differs from the organizational consumer (a business organization, a government agency and a non-profit-making organization) in terms of behavior and the factors affecting it.
1. Final consumer
As the first type of the consuming units, the final consumer is any individual that purchases goods or services either for his own personal use (e. g. clothes and dental treatment) or (5) for his family use (food items and carpets or curtains for the house) .
Consumer Behavior
43
Chapter 2
In other words, the purchase goal is to satisfy a need or wants of his own or of his family members. In that regard, a distinction is to be drawn between the consumer and the customer. Whereas the consumer looks for a certain product or service to buy, evaluates it, owns and uses it, or disposes of it / the rest of it, the customer buys his needs regularly from a particular store. Accordingly, a consumer may or may not be a regular customer of a store. Also, the term ``customer'' is more associated with a certain store, while the term ``consumer'' is not associated with any company or store.
2. Organizational consumer
The second type of consuming units, the organizational consumer, includes commercial, industrial, and agricultural firms, governmental agencies, and non-profit institutions (e.g. charity societies, orphanages, relief organizations, and research centers). These organizations and institutions need the goods and services (e.g. machines, parts, stationery, furniture and merchandise) that enable them to perform their functions and to achieve their organizational objectives. For instance, industrial companies need raw materials, parts, and semi-finished goods necessary for production. Also, to help deliver their services to final consumers, service companies need equipment, e.g. for airline companies: airplanes, maintenance equipment; for government agencies, schools and universities: computers, furniture, laboratories, and stationery; and for hotels: furniture, sheets, and food stuff. The organizational consumer does not purchase these products for the purpose of individual or family consumption, but for the purpose of organizational consumption. The purchased goods and services are used in the organization during official hours to achieve the organization's goals. The distinction between the individual consumer and the
Consumer Behavior
Since the behavior of the final consumer differs from that of the organizational consumer in many aspects, each type requires a particular marketing strategy that suits its respective market.(6) 2.1.3 Consumer Behavior As demonstrated above, defining ``the consumer'' is not easy, since the consumer is deemed the target and the starting point of the production and marketing processes. Thus, the key to consumption is the purchase decision, the consumer is the decision maker, and the consumption process is the result of making the purchase decision. As for consumer behavior, it is defined as the activities the consumer engages in when looking for a good or a service to satisfy his need or want and when evaluating, obtaining, using and disposing of it, in addition to related decision-making processes.(7) This definition implies a number of underlying assumptions that can be summarized as follows:(8) 1. The process of decision-making may take place individually or collectively. The former is carried out by only one person. For example, a person takes a decision on his own to buy a book or personal clothes, without interference from anybody else. The latter is carried out by more than one person, as in the case of family members deciding to spend the summer vacation abroad. 2. Consumer behavior involves physical and mental activities. Examples of physical activities are: shopping, talking to salespeople and collecting necessary information. Examples of mental activities are: information analysis and comparison and making purchase decisions. 3. Consumer behavior is often goal-oriented, not haphazard or accidental, i.e. has a goal or a set of goals seeking to satisfy
Consumer Behavior
45
Chapter 2
presently unfulfilled needs. From the above, it is obvious that consumer behavior is the pattern of behavior a consumer follows in searching for, purchasing, using, or evaluating goods, services, and ideas that he expects to satisfy his needs and wants. Consumer behavior studies are valuable in terms of their impact on consumption units, ranging from the individual to the family, as well as industrial and commercial organizations. For example, they provide the individual with useful information to take proper purchasing decisions best-suited to his specific needs, wants, purchasing ability and taste. They can also help him determine and prioritize his needs and wants in light of his financial resources and surrounding circumstances. Regarding their value for the family, consumer behavior studies can help families in the evaluation and selection of alternatives in relation to desired satisfaction, in addition to determining the purchase source and most opportune times for shopping from the psychological and financial point of view.(9) Regarding the value for marketers, the study of consumer behavior helps the marketing manager understand the family's purchase attitudes and behavior. As a basic consumption unit, the family is regarded as the main buyer. Awareness of such things enables the marketing manager to develop appropriate plans for the family and each of its members too.(10)
2.1.4 Keys to Understanding Consumer Behavior
In order to understand consumer behavior, we must first consider the concepts related to this behavior, which are referred to as ``keys'' to understanding consumer behavior. These are:(11)
1. Consumer behavior is based on motives and incentives
Consumer behavior results from motives and incentives. Motives are internal factors that urge the consumer to behave, whereas
46
Consumer Behavior
affection by purchasing, for example, a gift. c. Complex motive: A complex buying motive aiming at
achieving more than one goal as a result of the purchase act. d. Defined motive: A buying motive that is clear and known to the consumer and others. This is the easiest purchasing
motive.
b. Examining the advertisements on this good or service that are seen in the media or advertisement boards, for example, in the streets, on buses or on roof tops; c. Discussing the issue with friends or family members and sometimes consulting them about it; d. Making the purchase decision; e. Visiting the stores displaying and offering the good or service for sale; f. g. Evaluating and comparing product properties; and Finalizing purchase.
Consumer Behavior
47
Chapter 2
Consumer behavior is a decision that consists of three stages: D Pre-purchase decision. D Purchase decision, and D Post-purchase decision. Examining these three stages, we find that the first stage involves thinking about available offers, comparing their properties, and making evaluations and consultations. In the second stage, purchase actually takes place, as one visits sales-outlets in order to carry out the purchase. In the third or post-purchase stage - after possessing and using or benefiting from the product - evaluation is made to judge whether the purchase decision was right.
4. Consumer behavior varies according to time and structure
Time refers to when a purchase takes place and the length of purchase time. Both time dimensions are affected by a number of factors, which, in turn, vary across time. As for structure, it refers to the number of purchasing steps or stages and the set of activities undertaken in each stage. So, time and structure are closely related.
5. Consumer behavior includes different roles
Consumer behavior differs from place to place, and this depends mainly on the roles the consumer plays, which eventually associate with his behavior very closely. As we will see later, consumer behavior can be represented by several roles starting with finding a purchase idea, passing through the purchase decision, and ending with using the product.
6. Consumer behavior is influenced by external factors
As the consumer exists in an environment, he naturally interacts with it. We are concerned here with the external factors that affect
48
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
49
Chapter 2
Consumer Behavior
explaining consumer behavior can be traced to Adam Smith's The Wealth of Nations and Germy Benthamen's The Consumer-
Producer-Product. In his book, Adam Smith introduced a principle by which he explains individual and collective behavior on the basis of self-utility. In other words, whether the individual is a producer or a consumer, he always seeks to maximize his self-utility and minimize his sacrifice, i.e. buying for the least price and selling for the best price. This is referred to as ``marginal utility'', which is considered as the difference between the utility obtained from the latest produced or consumed unit and that obtained from the unit before it. However, Adam Smith did not address marginal utility directly but concentrated on ``total utility.'' Toward the end of the nineteenth century, Alfred Marshal and William Hyrvonss introduced the concept of marginal utility
separately but almost simultaneously, and the economic model or the Marshal model came into existence. Other scholars such as Karl Mynjer from Austria and Lyon Walrs from Switzerland wrote about the economic model, which focused on maximizing utility and
minimizing sacrifice. In other words, according to this model the consumer is a wise, rational individual, calculates his steps
Consumer Behavior
51
Chapter 2
based on the belief that the product he chooses is the best. However, from a practical point of view, a few consumers follow this model. It is also difficult to apply the model even to the industrial consumer. Although this model provides an acceptable, logical interpretation, it does not offer a good scientific explanation.(13) In fact, economists themselves differ about this model. Some economists argue that the so-called rational man does not always make rational decisions, and that the economic man is a consumer who is influenced by several factors. For instance, low income may not allow the consumer to make rational decisions when he chooses from alternatives, and he has to take the prevailing price level into account. In this respect, the economist Bach remarks that most consumers are not that calculating economic man who compares the utility he will attain from what he wants to buy with the price he will pay. Yet, they are aware of the utility-price consideration.(14)
2. The Pavlov Model
Due to the inadequate explanations put forward by economists for many of the behavioral phenomena of consumers according to the economic model, marketers sought psychological explanations. This was based on the premise that the purchase decision is related to what goes on in the consumer's mind, and therefore psychology is the closest discipline to deal with such behavior.(15) The psychological model of consumer behavior goes back to classical conditioning or conditioned reflex experiments conducted on dogs by the Russian physiologist Ivan Pavlov. He attempted to generalize the association concept between man's behavior and his nervous system. Others tried also to develop this learning model so as to apply it to human behavior. This model consists of four main elements: a. Need or motive, which has two types: primary motives, and
52
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
53
Chapter 2
inferences based on the decisions consumers had already made. Psychologists concluded that some psychological factors inf luence consumer behavior, and they must be studied to know their
inf luence on decision-making. Among these factors are motives, perception, and learning.
(18)
from
several
sources:
general
culture,
determinants, and the communication groups in his daily life. The consumer's wants and behaviors increase because of belonging to more groups, at present or in future. Though man is an individual, his behavior cannot be explained independently, for he is a social being. Man is inf luenced by his surroundings, and this will result in differences in individuals' behavior on the basis of their aspirations. To explain his perspective, Fiblin gave an example of the behavior of a certain social class and tried to generalize it to the behavior of the other social classes. He based his explanation on the aff luent social class, whose behavior was motivated by internal factors such as pride, fame, love for appearances, and egoism. He explained that self-pride factors direct people's behavior in this class when they search for and buy some products that can reflect this feeling, such as luxurious houses, expensive, distinguished cars, and famous
brand clothes. Despite the importance of this model, it is relatively overstated for the following reasons: The affluent class is not the reference class for all people, nor is it the class reflecting the behavior of all social classes, because not all people wish to be in this class; even if they became part of it, they would not behave like its members, whose behavior differs from one society to the other. Even if we accept that ambition inf luences consumer behavior, that
54
Consumer Behavior
ambition will often be reaching one class upward; a person does not jump from zero level to the top level of the social ladder. So, if he is a lower-class person, he tries to join the middle class, and gradually tries to reach the upper class. It is also observed that many individuals belonging to the affluent class tend to reduce consumption, not to indulge in it. Perhaps the reason behind this is self-sufficiency or the desire to develop and invest. There are many individuals who seek to get along with their class, and few of them try to get away from it. In other words, a person belonging to a certain class tries to conform to it rather than leave it and become independent, otherwise he will be completely isolated from all classes. Thus, the upper class behavior is not supposed to be taken as a model to explain the behavior of the (19) members of other classes. In general, sociologists consider the marketing activity to be focusing on a group of individuals influenced by a set of social factors. Marketing specialists have classified social factors and their influence on consumers from several perspectives that serve the explanation of consumer behavior according to the sociological model, in relation to the influence of reference groups, social (20) class, and cultural factors.
Consumer Behavior
55
Chapter 2
components. It is used as a didactic model to depict consumer behavior in selecting the desired brand from available alternatives. It consists of three main parts:
(21)
a. Motivating inputs:
They are embodied in the brand significance and symbolism. They are largely influenced by social and environmental factors, particularly the things learned from family, friends and reference group.
b. External factors:
They comprise some social variables, not under the consumer's control, at least in the short run, but can be controlled in the long run. They include purchase significance, personal factors, social status, knowledge, timing and financial position. These factors might be either persuasive positive motives that encourage a consumer to buy, or frustrating negative motives that restrain the purchase process, depending on the situation facing the consumer during the purchase process.
c. Consequential factors:
They result from the internal and external variables. The model's hypothetical structure that assists in forming the inputs is concerned with two major elements: perception and learning.
Perception
Perception is the processes concerned with receiving information coming in through a person's five senses (sight, hearing, smell, taste, and touch) and interpreting it to give it a meaning or recognizable, convincing form that the person can understand. It is also a mental representation resulting from the information received over days and years.
56
Consumer Behavior
The above three aspects together affect the quality and means of acquiring information. They also process information in terms of its relation to the would-be purchased product. On the basis of these significant aspects, the model has been developed, taking into consideration the accumulated information, impressions and recognized values. It also takes into account consistency between the information and what the person perceives, as well as the importance and influence of the information on the consumer.
Learning
Learning can be defined as a process of semi-permanent change in a person's behavior. It can also be defined as the process of acquiring experiences, qualifications, skills and information that help improve the individual performance. As a whole, they aim to positively modify behavior.
Consumer Behavior
57
Chapter 2
consumer takes into consideration when purchasing a product in a particular category. In addition, there are other brand groups, like the rejected group and the equity group. The rejected group includes the brands that a consumer never takes into account or thinks of acquiring, and it is known as the neglected or rejected brands. The equity group includes the brands whose availability or non-availability makes no difference to the consumer.
(3) Situation
The situation refers to the prior arrangements regarding the purchase or use of brands.
(4) Intermediate factors
Satisfaction represents the positive response to the purchase or use of the product.
Advantages of the Howard-Sheth Model
The following are some important advantages of the Howard-Sheth Model: (1) It can be satisfactorily used in the multi brand products as a good learning tool regarding the various aspects of studying consumer behavior. (2) It can be viewed as a dynamic model which can be changed or modified by researchers. (3) It has been put to the test in some applied studies and yielded good results.
58
Consumer Behavior
These are some important disadvantages of the Howard-Sheth Model: (1) All purchase decisions are not systematic or sequential for all products. Some decisions are taken with no prior planning, and they do not follow the model's sequence. (2) Unless there are various brands and products, the model will be difficult to apply, for it emphasizes the existence of varied conditions.(22)
It is a learning model, and it is an example of the models used to solve the problems concerned with consumer behavior. The information processed under this model is exciting, motivating and stimulating, and can be compared to the inputs of the HowardSheth model. When being processed, the information impacts the consumer's purchase decision to determine the extent of the required response. The pivot of this model is the internal auditing unit that directs information searching, processing and storage. The decisionmaking phase of this model is comparable to the input phase of the Howard-Sheth model. It comprises the following: (a) Problem identification and definition; (b) Evaluation of available alternative solutions; (c) Selection of a potential alternative; and (d) Evaluation of results. Sometimes, there is no need to go through the activity of evaluation of solutions, as in the case of decisions based on routine. The decision-making process moves directly from problem definition to
Consumer Behavior
59
Chapter 2
selection. Environmental factors can affect any of the decision phases and can be internally or externally related. Internal factors are concerned with the consumer's basic needs (e.g. hunger) or acquired needs (e.g. self-esteem). External factors are market related or the result of some marketing activities, such as advertising. According to this model, behavior outcomes take one of the following modes:
(a) Satisfaction
The satisfied consumer stores his future purchase decision data in his memory so that he can remember to buy the same product in future.
(b) Frustration
It results from the consumer's skepticism of the decision he has taken. It is due either to his unawareness of the availability of alternatives, or to his belief that the selected alternative was not the best. Such a feeling (of dissatisfaction or frustration) can behaviorally lead to: attempting to reinforce the decision validity, and seeking support for the decision made from other sympathetic individuals; or not attempting again. From a marketing perspective, seeking support for the decision can best be achieved by developing promotional programs aiming to:
D D
Reinforce the consumer's attitude towards the organization's products and brands. Raise doubts, through the media, over the consumer's
decisions favoring rival products. Thus, the environmental effects of the Engel-Kollat-Blackwell Model are obviously comparable to the external variables/factors of
60
Consumer Behavior
The
Nicosia
Model
is
considered It is based
simplified on the
form
of of
the the
comprehensive
model.
inputs
organization's message to the consumer, which correspond to his characteristics. The Nicosia Model provides for interaction between the organization's behavior and that of the individual. Still, it is limited, as shown below: (a) It assumes that the organization's message is concerned with products unknown or unfamiliar to the consumer, and consequently, he compares their characteristics to his own. Then, he adopts an attitude towards the products and what he wants from them. Basically, the model is limited to the products about which the consumer has no knowledge or experience. (b) It has not been practically tested. In other words, no applied studies have been conducted to verify its hypothesis or practical potential.
(23)
Having reviewed the most important models for studying consumer behavior, we can generally say that marketers have two ways for understanding the nature of consumer behavior. The first way includes the use of direct observation and questioning of the consumer, as part of the marketing program application. In the past, marketing managers achieved this goal through daily contact with consumers. Today, most the size of markets managers and from organizations such direct obviously prevents marketing
contact with consumers. This has given rise to direct means. The second way relies basically on the use of direct means in marketing research. The marketing manager employs specialist researchers to study and describe consumer behavior by use of various qualitative and quantitative methods. The answers to the following questions represent the main goals of such research
Consumer Behavior
61
Chapter 2
efforts:
Who will buy? How will he buy? When will he buy? Where will he buy? Why will he buy? Who will buy refers to the actual purchaser and his roles during the
purchase process.
Why will he buy indicates the potential motives and reasons behind the When will he buy refers to purchase time: weekdays or weekends; morning,
afternoon or evening; or season (summer, winter, spring or fall).
Finally,
the commercial centers a consumer prefers as well as the geographical area, (24) (e.g. the Eastern / Western Province of Saudi Arabia).
Where will he buy indicates the sales outlet he will buy from and
The answers to the above-mentioned questions are crucial and vital to the evaluation of the efficiency of the marketing strategy and the marketing program elements. The organization that properly recognizes how consumers respond to its marketing mix (product, price, distribution, and promotion) will most likely achieve significant competitive advantages in the market. The primary question will then be: How will consumers respond to the various marketing stimuli used or may be used by the organization? The organization that is well aware of how consumers will respond to the various properties and prices of its products will have clear superiority over other rivals, thus strengthening its competitive position. A starting point for understanding consumer response can be depicted as a stimulus-response relationship through a (25) refers consumer Black Box Model. The term ``Black Box Model'' to the consumer's mind, for its content is not known. The marketing and non-marketing stimuli enter the Black Box, then particular consumer responses emerge.
62
Consumer Behavior
Marketing staff should endeavor to understand the Black Box of potential buyers / consumers. They have also to understand how stimuli yield positive responses inside the box. The black box has two main parts: The first is concerned with the consumer's characteristics that influence his response to the stimuli, in addition to the environment factors influencing him. The second represents the purchase process itself, which influences the final outcome or response.
Consumer Behavior
63
Chapter 2
64
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
65
Chapter 2
For the purpose of this study, the Saudi family is considered a consumption unit consisting of two or more individuals, related by marriage or blood, and live in the same house. Therefore, the family - as a decision-making unit in this model - is often expected to consist of a father, a mother, children, and sometimes other relatives. The absence of any of these elements does not necessarily negate the characteristic of being a consumption unit.(26)
2. External information sources
(27)
These are the non-family sources that provide the family with information on products, sales outlets, offers, prices, and services. These sources can be divided into: 1. Personal sources: such as friends, neighbors, acquaintances, and workmates. 2. Commercial sources: such as advertisements, salespeople, distributors, displays, and packages. 3. Public sources: such as the media, government publications, and other organizations concerned with serving consumers. 3. Marketing environment This includes all the firms, products, and marketing methods available in the PC market. Here, the manufacturing firms, different types of marketing firms, their sales outlets, display styles, and sales, pricing, and advertising personnel; in other words, all the forces that comprise the supply side of the market. PC technologies - including both hardware and software - might be considered a component in this environment due to their direct impact on marketing activities.
4. Macro-environment (28)
Consumer Behavior
cultural trends and demographics surrounding the PC market in the Kingdom. It is known that the decisions of the family as a buyer of a durable product having a technological dimension, such as the PC, will be subject to - among other factors - the influence of the general climate of the market, including the Saudi market. For example, the economic climate might be in a state of expansion, recession, or in-between. The social climate might be for or against buying. As to the cultural dimension of the environment, it has a major influence on the buying behavior of the Saudi family, and this influence ranges between motivating, encouraging, approving, rejecting, and setting a taboo on behavior. The domestic, regional, and international political situations, with their stability or instability, have their influence too. Finally, the geographic dimension of the market (how large it is), as represented by the spread of the population on a large geographical area, has its influence as well.
Inputs
These are the actions and interactions of the model's elements in the form of information exchange or expression of behavior or opinion in light of the received information. This takes place before making the purchase decision.
Operations
The operations relate to the family's actions when a need is felt, information is collected, alternatives are considered, a purchase decision is made and purchase is completed. They cover post-
Consumer Behavior
67
Chapter 2
purchase behavior, including attitude change. They also include information storage when the chosen alternative is not to buy. Outputs Outputs are the outcome of the process in the model's motion, whether it is buying (behavior), forming an opinion (expressing an attitude), or postponing the purchase decision for a later time (behavior). The buying action (behavior) may result in secondary outputs such as satisfaction or dissatisfaction with the purchase experience, or post-purchase dissonance. The interaction among these components can be described as follows: 1. The Saudi family starts to feel a need for a PC due to a stimulus on the part of one or more family members, either for an objective reason related to the need to improve one's performance at work or at school, or for a personal reason such as a desire to learn, to imitate others, or to possess new products.(29) The stimulus might be external in the form of an advice from a colleague, a friend, or a relative, an advertisement about a product or about an attractive offer, work pressures, or school problems for which a PC provides a solution. In this case, all of these stimuli may be pressing on one family member, and different individuals may be influenced by different stimuli.(30) Feeling a certain need will create a gap in one's satisfaction domain, which moves the family toward behavior in order to fill this gap. 2. After a need appears, one or more family members start to collect information on the gap in the satisfaction domain. He (or they) will refer first to his (or their) mental inventory of knowledge, past experience, and values that are related to this need in order to form a knowledge base. Then, he supplements this base with information obtained from external sources. Among these sources are: personal sources such as friends,
68
Consumer Behavior
neighbors, acquaintances, and workmates; commercial sources such as advertisements, sales people, distributors, and displays; and public sources such as the media or governmental and academic publications. It can be said that in its effort to collect enough information for making a decision concerning its need for a PC, the family, as a consumer, will exert above-average effort in terms of the type and quantity of information and the checking of several sources for the following reasons: a. The consumer behavior literature(31) indicates that a consumer usually tries to obtain more information when he buys durable goods - as in the case of the PC - than when he buys convenience goods or even shopping goods of a lower value. Buying durable goods is always associated with two types of risk that a consumer perceives. The first type is related to the large amount of money he will pay for the product, and the second type relates to the relatively long period of time in which he will be using the product. Therefore, before making a purchase decision, a consumer usually tries to reduce these risks by obtaining more information about the product. b. In the case of new and complex products, such as the PC, the consumer does not know the mechanisms of their production and operation and how to benefit from them in the ideal way. This adds an element of ambiguity, which increases the consumer's perception of further risks when making the purchase decision. c. Immature or technically incomplete products are always subject to continuous technological development (as in the case of PCs and mobile telephones), which creates another type of consumer perceived risk related to planned obsolescence. Planned obsolescence makes the product that was purchased one year ago, for instance, an old product, not
Consumer Behavior
69
Chapter 2
because of use but because of the introduction of new models that are more efficient and sometimes less costly. This situation results in consumer's hesitation. He will then search for more information that helps him in approaching the right decision. Here, the reference group might play a role as a trusted source of information. d. The PC purchase decision is multi-dimensional technically and economically. There are also dimensions related to the purchase sources and appropriate transactions. Accordingly, we can say that the nature of the PC as a durable, complex product that is subject to planned obsolescence, will make the family - as a buying unit - seek more information in order to clarify the situation of the purchase decision, as illustrated in Figure 2.
70
Consumer Behavior
Given that risk perception differs among people according to their personality types (adventurous, hesitant, or moderate), collecting and analyzing information in order to reduce perceived risk also takes place at different levels according to the differences among personalities. 3. Processing the information collected by the family - as a consumer - will enable its members to determine the size of the unsatisfied gap, then determine various buying alternatives. Information processing will identify the needs of family members, whether they are entertaining, educational, or related to task implementation at work or at home. Some families might realize that the PC can perform some functions that they did not know about before they obtained the information, such as: using the PC as a fax machine; using it in preparing a list of acquaintances, their telephone numbers, and class schedules; or using the Internet in several ways. After determining the gap, the family identifies the buying alternatives, including not buying because there is no justification, or at least postponing the purchase to a later time for financial reasons, etc. If the decision is to buy a PC, the alternatives will be considered through the analysis of obtained information. Some information sources will dominate others due to their credibility (e.g. a friend who is an expert negotiator with salesmen), clarity, and reliability. Among the alternatives available to the family when buying are the following:
PC capacity
Two factors account for consumers' attention. They are speed and processor capacity, which are subject to continuous development over time. At the present time, the available speeds are 1.5, 1.7, 1.8, and 2.0 gigabytes, while the available processors are 3 or 4 gigabytes. The more sophisticated consumer may ask about RAM,
Consumer Behavior
71
Chapter 2
ROM, cache memory, HD, VGA, fax modem, the number of slots which range now between 14, 15, 17, 18, and 20, CD writer, etc.
Purchase sources
These sources provide information about various PC specifications and trademark choices in addition to economic incentives such as lower prices or free attachments (e.g. software, cables, gifts), credit sales and technical incentives (such as training, free home delivery, warranty extension, or free maintenance). The consumer obtains information on purchase sources from shopping around, examining PCs, and sometimes experimenting with them. In this regard, the experienced salesman can play a positive role in persuasion. The consumer may obtain the information from a newspaper advertisement or a mail brochure. Other sources include previous experience with a purchase source, and a recommendation by a friend, relative, or workmate. Comparing among the sources remains an analytical process determined by an evaluation of the advantages and(32) shortcomings of each source in terms of its purchase terms. As in the case of many other durable goods, the PC trademark has a significant influence on the purchase decision. The trademark represents an indicator of product quality and reliability. Although the PC has become one of the products that requires less post-sale service, the consumer carries more positive attitudes towards the trademarks of significance in the history of PCs, such as IBM, Apple, Dell, Compaq and HP. These are trademarks of US companies known for their high quality products and great ability for development. However, since the mid-1980s, the PC market has been dominated by Asian alternatives that perform basic computer functions without high quality, but are characterized by lower prices which entice consumers towards them, sacrificing quality. The American
72
Trademark
Consumer Behavior
industry
seems
to
be
benefiting
from
this
situation
and
to
be
regaining its share of the international market by offering PCs whose prices are close to their Asian counterparts, but with obvious merits in terms of real quality as well as perceived quality, as
represented by a well-known trademark of great history (e.g. IBM). 4. At the stage of information processing, when the family
identifies the alternatives, evaluates them, and selects one of them (i.e. makes the purchase decision), the social, economic, and demographic variables surrounding the family inf luence its action. When
(33)
determining
the
appropriate
PC
for
the
family,
certain
considerations are relevant. For example, considering its size, a family may select a high-capacity PC or buy two PCs or more because of varied needs. Also, age distribution of family members also influences the type and number of purchased PCs. For instance, the presence of
children at different ages, hence varied educational or entertaining needs, may inf luence the purchase decision. Considering the father's profession, it has social significance that inf luences purchase decisions since it signals the social status of the family as a whole. Also, the mother's work, especially in a
distinguished professional or technical field, inf luences the type and number of purchased PCs and the chosen brand since her profession may have a relationship to PC use at home. As for the educational levels of the father and the mother, it may have a direct relationship not only to the selection of the
appropriate PC, but also to determining how urgent the need for it is. A high level of parents' education is related to having a PC at home, and to the type and number of PCs bought, and the
preference of a specific brand. In addition, the type of diploma received by a spouse (e.g. a diploma in a computing field) has direct impact in this respect.
Consumer Behavior
73
Chapter 2
Then comes the family income. It plays a role the influence of which varies in most purchase decisions. This role is a major one in the case of durable goods including PCs where the ability to buy has direct relationship to the PC purchase as soon as needed and without postponement until money becomes available. The higherincome families are expected to own higher-priced PCs, and perhaps more than one. Considering the geographical area with its special social atmosphere, a distinction can be drawn between countryside and nomadic families and urban families. PCs are expected to penetrate the latter more than the former due to the urbanites' lifestyle and their exposure to the social conditions that facilitate their knowledge of technologically-oriented products. In addition, marketers of this type of product are very active in urban areas, and the nature of jobs available in these areas makes the need for PCs more urgent. Thus, it is expected that countryside residents are less inclined to own PCs and less willing to follow-up related technological changes or own new PC generations than city residents are. 5. In the stages of information analysis, alternative evaluation, and decision-making, the role of each family member differs according to the following: a. The degree of need urgency for the PC may influence the speed of decision-making. b. The size of personal knowledge and past experience affect the PC type, purchase sources, and related information sources. In this respect, some psychological reflections may surface from the ``black box'' (or the mind, as described by behavioral scientists, as none know what is going on in it). The most important of these reflections is the inventory of personal knowledge, experiences, and values, which form one's attitudes toward the products and the firms selling them. These attitudes cause biased perception (taking a
74
Consumer Behavior
position toward a product or a firm without providing good objective reasons). It is rather based on the accumulated psychological inventory. c. The nature of one's need for the PC determines its specifications and the type of software loaded on it. d. Who finances the PC - the father, the mother, or both - has a role in determining how much is to be allocated to the purchase. e. One or more family members might do the purchasing, because of negotiating skills, past experiences or mobility outside the house. 6. After buying and using the product, many sentiments arise. They range from dissonance regarding the rightness of the purchase decision to the feeling of satisfaction or dissatisfaction with it. Dissonance usually takes place after making the decision, especially in the case of durable goods where the consumer would have been exhausted in searching for information, comparing alternatives, and selecting the best alternative. This is described as a high-involvement situation. So, at this stage, the consumer becomes sensitive to the decision's utility and needs information that supports his decision. Satisfaction takes place when the benefits sought by the consumer from the purchase are attained. If attained beyond his expectations, the benefits make him happy, whereas lack of some expected benefits results in a state of dissatisfaction. Therefore, it is recommended not to raise consumers' expectations regarding product benefits to unrealistic levels. 7. Post-purchase sentiments may have many possible outcomes: a. The buyer may repeat the purchase of the same brand or from the same source in the future. For example, past research
Consumer Behavior
75
Chapter 2
points to this behavior in the case of buying cars. b. The buyer may feel satisfied with the brand, and so he spreads positive opinions about it. c The dissatisfied customer may return the product or even make a complaint or go to court. d. The dissatisfied customer may look for information in favour of the product in order to help him overcome the feeling of dissatisfaction. e. The dissatisfied customer may stop buying the same brand in the future. f. The dissatisfied customer may advise acquaintances and relatives not to buy the product. g. Advertising and communication efforts by producers and marketers will definitely reduce negative post-purchase sentiments and help convince the buyer that his purchase decision was right.(34)
2.3.3 Model Implications
The above analysis of the PC purchase decision model of the Saudi family has the following academic and professional implications: 1. PC producers and marketers have to study the social, economic, and demographic background of the Saudi family (i.e. consumer characteristics) before developing their marketing plans. Also, the motives and needs of this family for a PC must be studied (i.e. consumer's objectives when buying). Then comes the analysis of the purchasing process itself in terms of: the multiplicity of roles inside the family (how the family interacts as an organization when buying); how the decision-making process is completed and implemented (what the processes are); and finally the time and place suitable for
76
Consumer Behavior
implementing the purchase (when and where the purchasing process takes place). 2. PC Marketers' awareness of the mechanism of the Saudi
will help them offer a suitable marketing mix, which them to serve the consumer more effectively.
Knowledge of the socio-economic background helps identify the family's lifestyle, which, in turn, helps define the demanded goods and services. 3. Knowing the relative roles of family members in making the PC purchase decision, knowing the psychological involvement of decision makers when searching for and analyzing information, and knowing the number of available alternatives may reveal possible negative post-purchase sentiments among consumers. This knowledge enables marketers to plan for dealing with such sentiments through a campaign of information and
psychological reinforcement. 4. The consumer has different needs for information at each of the purchase certain decision-making stages. Also, at each stage and he is subject some to
inf luences
perceives
risks
associated with the decision. Realizing this, marketers must provide decision makers with information, advice, or action that leads them to the proper decision at the proper time. 5. Knowing post-purchase behavior, whether that of the happy consumer, the satisfied consumer, or the dissatisfied consumer, enables marketers to deal with each of them more effectively. The happy and satisfied consumers are a living advertisement for the producer, the marketer, and the product, whereas the dissatisfied consumer is not. Prevention might be better than cure. Thus, marketers must be always prepared to secure their customers' satisfaction and beyond, to the happiness level. This will only be
Consumer Behavior
77
Chapter 2
achieved by offering a product that satisfies the customer's need, as well as by marketing efforts that facilitate decision-making and maximize the benefits the customer gets from the product. As to the dissatisfied consumer, marketers must look for him, find out the reason behind his dissatisfaction, compensate him, and change his negative attitudes and dissatisfaction to satisfaction and happiness, even if this requires returning the product, refunding its price and apologizing to the consumer. No marketing benefit will be achieved if a transaction is made but a customer is lost. This customer will convert in the long run to a counter-force against the firm's success. In addition, dissatisfaction is sometimes caused by mis-marketing and mis-selling, which lead the consumer to expect a performance level which the product cannot reach. The result is consumer's disappointment because of the gap between the expected ideal performance promised by the firm and the actual performance. Hence, it is not a good marketing practice to claim benefits for the product that it does not originally possess, or to use an approach that makes the customer expect these alleged benefits; these promises will backfire. Figure (3) shows the ideal zone that producers and marketers should try to get their customers to reach, either through a distinct product or a high-quality service. In fact, the consumer seeks an integrated transaction of a product, cost, and service. As a rational being, he tries hard to maximize his benefits.
78
Consumer Behavior
6. The inventory of post-purchase experience, whether related to happiness, satisfaction, or dissatisfaction, will be stored in the "black box" as a chemical composite (mental inventory), and will interact with events every time there is a chance to do so either positively or negatively. The reaction of the consumer, who has this inventory, will take place every time a friend or a relative seeks his help in a similar buying situation, or even in the form of a voluntary advice for or against the product or the firm in a social gathering or in an invitation to dinner. 7. We expect that the Saudi family's cultural heritage of religion, language, and history, and even the official and public political situation will have direct and strong impact on purchase decisions. Positive or negative bias towards certain products or firms may occur, resulting in buying or refusing to buy. This is due to the stored attitudes formed on religious, linguistic, or historical values, or due to official or public political positions vis-a-vis certain countries, firms, or products (e.g. boycotting some products). 8. Family extension and cohesion in the Kingdom, bringing
Consumer Behavior
79
Chapter 2
together parents, children, and grandparents, will always increase the importance of family members' impact on the purchase decision, particularly on the choice of products or firms. The family will continue to be the primary reference group when making decisions, since the pressures of children sometimes influence decisions.
80
Consumer Behavior
Endnotes of Chapter 2
(1) Mohamed, Mahmoud Fouad and Abdul-Fattah Moustafa Al-Shirbeeny,
Consumer
Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice with a Focus on the Saudi Market (Arabic), Riyadh, Institute of Public Administration, 2000, p. 21.
Consumer Behavior, N.Y., John Wiley and Sons, 1990, p. 12. Soliman, A., Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice, op. cit., p. 22. Obaidat, Mohamed, Consumer Behavior: A Behavioral Approach, (Arabic), Amman,
Future for Publishing and Distribution, 1995, pp. 7-8. (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) (21) Soliman, A.,
Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice, op. cit., p. 28. Consumer Behavior, op. cit., pp. 4-9. Harb, Bayan Hani, Principles of Marketing, op. cit., p. 47. Al-Ghadeer and Al-Saed, Consumer Behavior, op. cit., pp. 275-277. Al-Abdaly and Al-Allaq, Marketing: Essentials and Principles, op. cit., pp. 72-74. Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 281.
Marketing: Essentials and Principles, op. cit., pp. 74-80. Consumer Behavior, op. cit., pp. 278-280. Al-Abdaly and Al-Allaq, Marketing: Essentials and Principles, op. cit., p. 82. Hassan, S. A., Marketing: Principles and Strategies (Arabic), Riyadh, King
Al-Abdaly and Al-Allaq, Al-Ghadeer and Al-Saed, University, 1995, pp. 59-61. Al-Ghadeer and Al-Saed, Ibid., pp. 287-291.
Saud
Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice, op. cit., p. 23. Harb, Bayan Hani, Principles of Marketing, op. cit., p. 49.
Soliman, A., Schaninger, C. M., and William D. Danko, ``A Conceptual and Empirical Camparison of Alternative Household Cycle Models,''
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 2
(27) (28) (29) (30) (31) Vol. 19, March 1993, pp. 580 - 594. Kotler, P., Marketing Management, Upper Saddle River, N.J. Prentice-Hall, Inc., 2000, p. 179. Aaker, D. A. Strategic Market Management, 4th ed., N.Y., John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1995, pp. 110124. The reader may refer to the literature on consumer motives for explanation of consumer needs and motives, e.g., Maslow, A., Motivation and Personality, N. Y., Harper & Row, 1954, pp. 77-104. Assael, H., Consumer Behavior and Marketing Action, 2nd edition, Boston, Kent., 1987, Ch. 4. Malhotra, N.K., ``Approach to Measurement of Consumer Preferences Using Limited Information,'' Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 23, February 1986, pp. 3340. See also: Al-Sulami, Ali, Marketing Research: A Behavioral Approach (Arabic), 2nd Edition. Cairo: Dar Al-Ma'aaref, 1969, p. 353. Cooper, L.G., and Akihiro Inoue, "Building Market Structure from Consumer Preferences," Journal of Marketing Research, 33, No. 3, August 1996, 293-306. This is what the author proposed in his doctoral research when formulating the Saudi family model for purchasing a PC. See: Al-Jeraisy, Khaled A., "Analysis of Consumer Decision in the Purchase Process", Ph. D. dissertation, Kensington University, U.S.A, 2003. Donnelly, J..H., and John M. Ivanovich, "Post-Purchase Reinforcement and Back-Out Behavior," Journal of Marketing Research, August,1970, pp.399-400.
(32) (33)
(34)
82
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 3
Consumer Purchase Decision
Chapter Topics
3.1 The Process of Decision Making 3.2 Determinants and Types of Purchase Decisions 3.3 The Consumer's Decision to Adopt New Products
One of the basic duties of marketing management is to accurately define the potential buyers of its product. Since marketers are mainly interested in the purchase decision-making process, marketing management needs to identify the individuals who participate in it, and to define the significance of the roles each one plays throughout the phases of the purchase process.
Consumer Behavior
85
Chapter 3
decision phase alone. Also, it maintains that the purchase decision passes through five stages: (1) Problem identification (need) (2) Search for information (3) Evaluating alternatives (4) Purchase decision (5) Post-purchase behavior Considering that by taking purchase decisions, consumers seek to solve their consumption problems, the purchase decision process comprises three stages:
First: Pre-purchase stage (1) Encountering a consumption problem and feeling the need to solve it.
(2) Searching for and collecting relevant data. (3) Evaluating solution alternatives. (4) Selecting the best alternative.
Second: Purchase stage (5) Finalizing the purchase. Third: Post-purchase stage (6) Consumption and evaluation of the purchased brand during and after consumption.
(7) Product disposal.(2) Though there are a lot of purchase decision process models, no ideal, comprehensive model of consumer behavior has been reached,(3) for the consumer is still a ``closed box'', and it is difficult to predict his internal thoughts and decisions.(4) The author, therefore, suggests a
88
Consumer Behavior
practical model for the purchase process stages as applied to the Saudi family's PC purchase decision. The proposed model can be applied to decision-making in the purchase of other products.(5) The purchase process stages can be summed up as follows: (1) feeling a need and recognition of the product advantages; (2) data collection and evaluation of data sources; (3) identifying alternatives; (4) evaluation of available alternatives; (5) decision-making; (6) actual purchase; and (7) post-purchase feelings (satisfaction, dissatisfaction / frustration). In what follows, we will consider the above-mentioned phases in detail:
1. Feeling the need and recognizing the product advantages
The starting point of any behavior is feeling a specific need, where the consumer is driven by a stimulus. The stimulus is important since it can help create the need or make the latent one clear, and hence the consumer can identify the good or service that will solve his problem or satisfy his need. The stimulus is of various forms and sources. It could be social, coming from one's surroundings, like friends, neighbors or family members. It could be commercial, as represented by a message from marketing bodies, such as the producer, wholesaler and retailer in order to draw his attention to a product or to awaken a latent need. This way, one feels an internal drive to satisfy the need. The most outstanding forms of this stimulus include advertisements, personal sale techniques, and various promotion methods. There are noncommercial stimuli as well, as provided by non-profit organizations,
Consumer Behavior
89
Chapter 3
including data offered by government departments and consumer reports. These stimuli are reliable as consumers feel that they are for public, not personal interest. Finally, the stimulus can be a basic need a person feels, as in the cases of hunger, pain or fatigue. This feeling drives him to behave in a particular way, and so it is called ``motive''. In many cases, it is difficult to determine why the consumer thinks that a particular good or service will satisfy his needs; consumers buy the same items for different reasons (actual need, prestige, boasting, etc.). A
consumer may not recognize the actual motive behind his response to a stimulus in a particular way. He may be aware of his motive, but due to social or economic considerations, he decides to conceal it, by pretending to respond to another motive. Thus, needs can be said to result from internal or external stimuli. What, then, is the role of marketing management at this stage? Its role lies in identifying the conditions that stimulate the consumer's needs. It has to conduct studies to identify the needs he feels, how to stimulate
(6)
to
direct
them towards
the target
product.
When the consumer realizes that his need or want is pressing and must be satisfied, he proceeds to the second phase of the purchase decision-making process, otherwise the process will end there, or will be delayed until a stronger stimulus emerges.
alternatives. Therefore, he does not need to embark on a process of comparing alternatives. Instead, as soon as he feels the need, he makes an instant purchase decision. For these reasons, marketing
90
Consumer Behavior
efforts at this stage should increase the amount of information available to customers about the products. This is meant to (7) reinforce need urgency. The consumer can obtain necessary information about the alternatives that can satisfy his needs from a variety of resources. They are:
A. Internal resources
Internal resources refer to the consumer's past experiences, uses, (8) investigations and study of the product. In other words, he relies on his own past experiences in dealing with a specific need. He tries to remember the alternatives that best satisfied that need in the past.
B. Group resources
This is sometimes called ``personal resources'' or ``social (10) Information is normally obtained through contact resources''. with others, including family members, friends, neighbors, etc. These are often regarded as the most effective in the purchase decision-making process, particularly if the information comes from a reliable person, with expertise on the alternatives that can achieve the purchase process aim.
(9)
C. Marketing resources
These are commercial resources that contain information prepared through communication efforts made by an organization for the market. They include advertisements, product display methods, personal sales, sale boosters, and package labels. These are considered one of the important information sources on a particular product.
Consumer Behavior
91
Chapter 3
organizations. Maintenance and repair technicians can also be considered among these resources, since they provide unbiased advice on the basis of their professional experience. These resources are highly reliable, as they are mainly concerned with product quality, and they are not on the side of the producer or the marketer.
E. Experimental resources:
This includes the possibility of examining and trying the product during purchase. This requires an actual shopping tour as a final resource for information. For instance, the individual can test a TV set before purchase to check picture and sound quality. The same thing can be done with a PC. Some car showrooms invite customers to test-drive their cars as a means of providing substantial information about the new models and enticing prospective buyers.
Consumer Behavior
proceeds to collect information about the product that can satisfy that need.(11) He may determine the alternatives in a simple way using his memory and past experience. He may also conduct a research to define the required alternatives. This depends on the amount of information available to him, the depth and variety of his past experiences, and the extent of his trust in the validity of the information and his attitude towards its resources. (12) When this stage is complete, the consumer has to decide whether or not his immediate need can be satisfied through any of the available alternatives. If it turns out that most of the available alternatives are satisfactory, the consumer moves to the following stage, otherwise the decision-making process comes to a halt. This means the consumer's need cannot be satisfied through any of the available alternatives. If there is only one alternative, the decision is spontaneously taken, and the consumer directly moves to actual purchase. This seldom occurs in competitive markets, but often happens in monopoly markets and in the absence of alternatives.
4. Evaluating available alternatives
At this stage, the consumer has plenty of information to enable him to select from a list of available alternatives. The choice can be easy if an alternative is markedly advantageous, as in the case of comparing a product of high quality and low price to a product of medium quality and high price. Naturally, the consumer will spontaneously opt for the first alternative, but this is not always that simple. The consumer often has to evaluate the alternatives before deciding to buy. This comes in the middle of the purchase decision-making process. Some of the factors that affect the period between feeling the need and making the purchase decision include: a- the extent of the consumer's need urgency for the product and the quality of benefit expected from it; b- the personality of the purchaser, his experience and the
Consumer Behavior
93
Chapter 3
information available to him; and c- the product price, as the monetary sacrifice the purchaser makes to benefit from the product advantages; the higher the price, the longer the time taken by the consumer to make a decision,
(13)
particularly
in
evaluating
the
available
alternatives. If there is more than one suitable alternative, the consumer will have to define the evaluation criteria for the alternatives and their relative importance. So, he lists alternatives in their order of
importance. Then, he selects one, i.e., a decision is taken. ``The consumer criteria. evaluates alternatives is the
(14)
according of
to
set
of
specific criteria
What
matters
definition
the
suitable
finds in a
particular good or service. They include price, quality, warranty, and availability of spare parts, etc. The consumer can be assumed to see the commodity as a number of properties. A camera, for
instance, comprises such properties as picture quality, ease of use, size, and price. As for a hotel, desirable characteristics include location, service, cleanliness,
(15)
reasonable
charge,
and
the
surrounding atmosphere.
to each of these properties, and he evaluates each alternative in terms of meeting these criteria. The importance of each advantage is determined according price to as consumers' the most desires. While others some prefer
consumers quality.
consider
important,
Herein comes the significance of arranging alternatives in terms of preferences. alternatives This are can be difficult cut, or if the differences the between are
not
clear
when
alternatives
completely new to the consumer, hence lack of experience. We can accurately predict the customer's choice of brands if we characterize the relative weights of the criteria he employs in selecting from a multiplicity of alternatives.
94
Consumer Behavior
Generally speaking, a logical approach to characterizing the evaluation processes rests on the following: 1. The consumer is well-informed about a number of trade marks of the product. 2. The consumer is aware that some of these brands can satisfy his need. 3. Each of the brands has certain advantages and characteristics in varied degrees. The consumer is aware that a number of these features are suitable for him. 4. The consumer will select the brand that has the greatest number of desirable features. 5. The consumer will make a decision to buy the desired brand.
5. Making a purchase decision
Following the process of evaluation, comes the consumer's decision to purchase the selected alternative. The purchase decision is similar to any other decision that involves choosing from among alternatives and weighing costs and benefits. It is the result of a number of interrelated sub-decisions regarding the purchase of a specific good, of a specific nature, from a specific outlet, at a specific (16) time, for a specific price, and with a specific payment method. The purchase decision involves a number of sub-decisions that require a great deal of time and effort. A sales outlet, for instance, might be a department store or any other place. In spite of the fact that the majority of products and services are available at department stores, many products are sold at workplaces (medical insurance), or even at home (by mail, telephone or through roaming vendors). Like the product, a sales outlet is evaluated. Potential sales outlets are listed out, then an evaluation of their characteristic features and advantages are conducted with the aim of selecting the most suitable alternative. Some of the factors
Consumer Behavior
95
Chapter 3
involved in the evaluation of a sales outlet include: location, rank, prices, and salesmen's conduct, etc. As for the sales-outlets that are not available, they are evaluated according to prices, working hours, availability of products and salesmen's conduct. Purchase conditions include price, i.e. the amount of money paid for a product or a or service. giving a The purchase to process in is basically for a
spending
money,
promise
pay,
return
particular product or service. Specifying the method of payment (cash, short term installments or long term installments, etc.) is a purchase condition. The purchase decision involves risks that vary in degree according to the product and purchase conditions. The consumer seeks to reduce the possibility of risk in the decisions he takes (to the best of his knowledge). He does his best to minimize possible negative outcomes, ranging from economic loss to feeling embarrassed if the product is not effective. The risk may even involve sustaining
physical injuries. Thus, if the consumer is satisfied with the sales outlet and terms, and he evaluates the sales risk factors as affordable, he proceeds with the purchase process. If not, he postpones or cancels the purchase, even for reasons having nothing to do with the product itself. Thus, the consumer's decision to modify, postpone or cancel the purchase decision is strongly
(1 7)
influenced
by
perceived
risks.
Consequently, consumers cannot be entirely certain of the outcome of the purchasing process.
Undoubtedly, marketing efforts provide the consumer with enough information to make his purchase decision look good, and to make him satisfied with having taken it. It is worth noting that decisionmaking varies within the same family. This is related to such factors as social class, place of family residence, and family size.
(18)
96
Consumer Behavior
6. Actual purchase
This phase involves finalizing the purchase. Consumers rely on well defined decision-making strategies they have frequently used before and have stored in their memories. Such strategies include selecting the brand that carries a price discount at purchase time. In other cases, consumers apply their choice strategies only at the time of purchase, relying on their previous experience, and their knowledge of the rival brands. The nature of finalizing the purchase process is affected by many situational factors, such as: time limit; amount of available information about alternatives; the effect of the entire family's presence when shopping; and the social effects resulting from the presence of other customers inside the store. In addition, the way information is presented to consumers at sales outlets can have a great impact on consumers choices.(19) Accordingly, decision-making and actual purchase are so integrated that the two phases can sometimes be fused into one, particularly when the purchase decision is taken on the spot at the purchase place. Finalizing the purchase process entails other behaviors, such as subsequent purchase processes related to and complementary with the first purchase. The purchase of a PC, for instance, might be followed by the purchase of a scanner, and the purchase of a VCR may entail buying or renting video tapes. In other words, some purchase processes pave the way for others. Thus, the purchase decision-making process continues until the last item on the shopping cart.
7. Post-purchase thoughts
After making the purchase decision, and actually buying the product, the consumer conducts an evaluation of the deal. He compares the actual performance of the product (or service) with
Consumer Behavior
97
Chapter 3
his pre-purchase expectations. This results in a feeling of contentment and satisfaction or a feeling of discontentment and dissatisfaction.(20) The consumer's contentment / satisfaction can be defined as the end result of the evaluation which the consumer does for the selected alternative (for the sake of which the purchase decision has been taken) after consuming or using. This concludes that the performance of the purchased item meets or outweighs prepurchase expectations. Dissatisfaction, on the other hand, is the outcome of an evaluation process in which the consumer concludes that the performance of the purchased product is below his expectation.(21) In other words, if the actual performance of a PC, for instance, is equal to or more than the consumer's expectations, he will feel satisfied with the entire purchase process, and he will bring this satisfaction to bear in the event of any similar purchase in the future, thus increasing the possibility of repeated future purchase. Moreover, the consumer will recommend the product to others, reinforcing his confidence in the purchase decision he has made. At this stage, the consumer may be affected by the opinions of his family members or the users of the same product. (22) If, on the other hand, the performance of the purchased product is below the consumer's expectations, he experiences a state of dissonance, and a feeling of regret and disappointment; he has made a wrong decision, and the expected aim has not been achieved, although that decision was based on the study and comparison of available alternatives. Unfortunately, this is a very common case that should be given proper attention and close follow-up by marketers to convince the consumer that he had made the right decision. (23) Lack of follow-up entails losing this customer forever together with all the customers that may seek his advice. If this happens, it will be a big loss for the marketing organization.
The state of dissonance and doubting of the purchase decision is aggravated in the following cases:
98
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
99
Chapter 3
consumer in order to create a positive attitude that can be utilized in encouraging future purchase. This can foster consumer confidence in the product, a primary goal of the marketer. Also, realistic, unexaggerated, promotion material can alleviate postpurchase dissonance. This makes the consumer set realistic expectations regarding the product, thus bridging the gap between expectations and reality. Post-purchase attention to the consumer, reinforcing his decision through various marketing techniques, and presenting realistic promotion of the product can alleviate post-purchase dissonance. As one marketer once said, ``A satisfied customer is our best advertisement''. A successful marketing administration should promote the consumer's post-purchase satisfaction, while trying to eliminate dissatisfaction as much as possible. A good measure of post-purchase satisfaction is a lower rate of returned goods, of (24) cancelled orders, and of complaints about the product. In summary, feelings of conflict and post-purchase evaluation are basic factors that affect consumer behavior after making a purchase decision. Personal and psychological factors play a very effective role in his behavior, particularly in the purchase of expensive goods. Feelings of conflict and dissatisfaction are affected by such factors as the following: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. The amount of money allotted to the purchase of the product. The number of available alternatives. Degree of affordable risk prospective consumers are willing to take. The social and psychological value of the product. The cost of the product compared to the consumer's income.
Some of the techniques marketers resort to in order to alleviate consumer's feelings of conflict and dissatisfaction following actual purchase include the following:
100
Consumer Behavior
1. Conducting promotion campaigns that target consumers who have already purchased the product with the aim of fostering positive feelings toward the purchase process. 2. Adopting effective and realistic promotion techniques that respect the mentality of the consumer. 3. Avoiding exaggerated promotion of the product so as not to raise consumers' expectations beyond realistic levels that aggravate conflict. (25) Thus, some of the main features of the purchase decision-making process include:(26) 1. The purchase decision process is not as inevitable as it seems to be because the consumer can abort this process at any stage preceding actual purchase. This can happen if his urge to purchase diminishes, or if he is not happy with any of the available alternatives. In such cases the purchase process is unexpectedly aborted. 2. Purchase processes often proceed in a traditional way, but if the consumer feels satisfied at any point, some of the stages can be skipped. For instance, he can proceed without distinguishing or evaluating alternatives. Also, purchase phases do not necessarily take the same amount of time, depending on the product value and urgency to buy it. For example, the need may arise for a product that is not really valuable, yet the evaluation of alternatives can take long. 3. Some stages of the purchase decision-making process may take place deliberately in certain cases, while subconsciously in others.
Consumer Behavior
101
Chapter 3
The factors influencing the purchase decision can be summed up into four determinants: the nature of the consumer; the nature of the product; the characteristics of producers and salespeople; and (27) the nature of the purchase situation.
1. Nature of the consumer
The consumer's purchase decision, the nature of the purchase stages through which he goes, and the time spent on each stage vary according to his socio-economic characteristics, social class, beliefs, occupation, income, learning abilities and past shopping experiences, etc.
102
Consumer Behavior
The nature of the product has a direct impact on the consumer's decision. He considers such factors as need for the product, its quality, price, post-purchase services, and psychological and socioeconomic benefits. Therefore, producers seek to continually add to their products new utilities and advantages, maximizing benefits, hence encouraging consumers to buy.
3. The nature and characteristics of producers and salespeople
The consumer is often influenced by the producer and salespeople, particularly at the purchase stage of product evaluation. He considers such factors as trustworthiness and reputation. For this reason, producers tend to select suitable sales outlets and provide the necessary training to salespeople in order to gain the confidence of the consumer. This secures the consumer's confidence and loyalty, leading to increased sales.
4. The nature and characteristics of the purchase situation
The circumstances surrounding the purchase situation sometimes influence the purchase decision-making process. Among them are the time available for making the purchase and the socio-economic conditions of the purchase context. For example, if the purchase time is short, the consumer will take his decision without having sufficient information, and will cut down on effort of searching for alternatives. Ultimately, the outcomes in these circumstances will be different from the ones resulting from a decision taken in normal circumstances. Thus, the process of making a purchasing decision is greatly influenced by the characteristics of the consumer himself. For instance, age is considered one of the factors which influence the speed of the decision. Due to his lack of experience, an older consumer may not take a long time to make a decision, while a younger one is likely to take a longer time to make the same
Consumer Behavior
103
Chapter 3
decision. Age may also have an influence in the opposite direction. For example, the younger consumer tends to be more impulsive and, therefore, goes through the decision-making stages faster, while an older consumer is likely to be more careful. In general, the kind of influence depends on the nature of the product desired, which fits the categories of Copeland who classifies products into special, shopping and convenient ones.(28) Buying special products (e.g., buying a house), requires careful deliberation at each decision-making stage, for the risk factor is high, and the possibility of correcting a mistake is limited. In contrast, when buying a convenient product (e.g. a magazine), the consumer may skip some steps, for the risk involved is low. A high-income consumer will spend less time and effort on making his purchasing decisions, because he has the financial ability to buy again if he is not satisfied with the purchased product. Also, people who are naturally calm and who prefer not to take risks are likely to go through a deliberate decision-making process, while those who do not have enough time are likely to skip some steps. Thus, purchase decision-making varies according to the nature of the product. There is a big difference between buying toothpaste or a camera and buying a car. Naturally, the more complex the decision, the more participants are involved, and the more time and deliberation are needed.
3.2.2 Types of Purchasing Behavior
It is possible to distinguish three types of purchasing behavior that correspond to three types of decision: (a) repeated or routine solution behavior; (b) specific / limited solution behavior; and (c) extended solution behavior. (29)
104
Consumer Behavior
The corresponding decisions are: (a) routine decision; (b) limited decision; and (c) extended (broad) decision These decisions are taken in the following ways:
1. Making a routine decision
The consumer makes this decision when he makes his usual, routine purchases, in which case he skips several steps in the decision-making process. For this reason, he does not need much time for shopping because he simply repeats buying the same goods and brands, and the matter becomes a simple routine for him. Given the superior experience he has with such purchases, which are usually cheap, the risk factor is often low. The most important step in this process is becoming aware of the problem when the consumer feels that he needs a product he has never got before. Then, he takes the initiative to buy it again. As for collecting information, identifying and evaluating alternatives, and even for post-sale behavior, they all become less important steps, in comparison with their importance in the cases of limited and extended purchases. In fact, the consumer will ignore these steps as long as he is satisfied with the previous purchasing process, and he may not even realize he is going through it. In this kind of decision, the characteristics of the consumer have very little influence. All that matters is that feeling the presence of a problem immediately leads to making a decision. For this reason, it is of utmost importance that the goods and services be made accessible. This can be done, for instance, by locating them in the best sale points, for the longest working hours, and in the most obvious displays, as well as by completing the sale as quickly as possible. Examples of this type of purchase include buying a daily newspaper and other convenient goods.
Consumer Behavior
105
Chapter 3
This type of buying behavior requires those responsible for marketing to work towards satisfying the anticipated needs of the target consumers for goods and services through the provision of good quality and service in the products themselves, as well as attracting new buyers of the same goods or services by presenting them with new features and advantages.(30) It is also necessary that the prodcut be available at all possible sales outlets, for the consumer is likely to go for rival convenient alternatives, if the required brand is not available.
2. Making a limited decision
The purchasing decision becomes more complicated when the consumer is presented with unfamiliar brands or new services. In the case of such a decision, he needs to reflect, even if in a limited way, for the consumer knows the product, but not all its brands or the advantages of each.(31) Thus, the limited decision occurs when the consumer goes through each step of the decision-making process without having to spend much time on each step. However, the limited decision takes longer than the repeated decision. The consumer's characteristics have less influence on limited decisions than on extended ones. Since the consumer has more experience with the product to be purchased, the risk factor will be low. The consumer's characteristics in the limited decision have more influence than in the routine decisions, and the purchase risk is higher. However, income and purchase motives play an important role in the decision-making process. This type of decision includes such activities as buying goods and services which the consumer has already bought before, but not repeatedly. Although this decision-making process relies mainly on the customer's past experience, which he uses to evaluate alternatives he is familiar with according to his own parameters, collecting information on such alternatives remains an important issue. For
106
Consumer Behavior
this reason, this process takes longer than the previous one. An example of this type of decision-making is buying shopping goods, particularly for the second time or more.
The extended decision occurs when the consumer follows all the steps in the decision-making process and spends enough time collecting information and evaluating alternatives prior to actual purchase. There is a the high likelihood that the actual This and the expected performance of the purchased product do not match to a large degree after purchase has been made. product category includes all kinds of special and durable goods, such as cars, jewelry, personal computers, etc., particularly if purchased for the first time, or when the customer's experience in this area is limited, which maximizes the risk factor. In extended decision-making, the consumer can stop at any step because the process involves the purchase of sophisticated and highly priced products, which require some experience for the evaluation of alternatives. In this case, the characteristics of the customer (such as his age, level of education, income, social and marketing decision. Therefore, it is necessary for the marketer to play a major role in following up the consumer throughout the shopping stages and to provide him with sufficient information, good personal selling and an adequate demonstration. He should not limit his role to completing the sales deal. Instead, he should extend his effort to dissipating any sense of doubt, reluctance, or even dissonance characteristics, etc.) have significant impact on the
Consumer Behavior
107
Chapter 3
which may follow the purchasing act. This can be done by employing various promotional strategies, including publicity and personal contact. It will assure the consumer that he has made the right decision by choosing this alternative from among available ones.
108
Consumer Behavior
109
Chapter 3
3.3.1 Concept of Newness
Newness is the trait that a product has to possess in order to be called ``new''. It is what differentiates between new products and old, familiar ones. It has always been difficult to determine a scale for newness due to people's varied perceptions of what they consider new. There are always attempts to set parameters for newness. Four bases for measuring newness can be identified: D The first basis draws a distinction between complete newness of a product in comparison with existing products on the one hand, and sheer modernization (the modification of an existing product to make it perform a new vital function) on the other hand. D The second basis takes the period for which the product lasts on the market as a measure for the extent to which the product is considered new. D The third basis takes the degree of the product diffusion into the market as a measure of newness. Diffusion means the degree of market saturation with the product. The measure is the ratio of consumers who have adopted the product to the total number of target consumers. The ratio indicates that the product remains new so long as adopters do not reach 10% of the expected consumer population. D The fourth basis uses the consumer's perception as a measure of what is considered new; for a product is considered new as long as the consumer considers it so, and vice versa. An American study has defined a new product in the eyes of the consumer as something with which he is not already familiar. As for the product itself, the matter could involve a totally new product, new packaging, the addition of a new element or part of a familiar product, a simple redesign of the product, perhaps its introduction in a new market, or even using a new distribution method (such as electronic sales). In such studies, some
110
Consumer Behavior
distinguish three levels of newness: (a) there is no disagreement on the product's newness, as in the case of introducing television sets for the first time; (b) the product is partly new, as in the case of introducing a steam iron; and (c) there is a limited degree of newness, such as the introduction of a television set with a remote control device. Apparently, many organizations have begun to reduce involvement in price competition with rivals, in favor of competition through innovation. This means the improvement of existing products and the introduction of new ones in a way that reduces easy replaceability by rival alternatives, while enabling the organization to achieve profit margins and increase sales to a degree rivals cannot reach(35).
3.3.2 Diffusion
Change operations usually take place gradually, yet they can be sudden, as in the fashion industry. Society's acceptance of this change is called diffusion, which refers to ``the spread of new ideas, products and applications through culture''.(36) The diffusion of new products sometimes encounters rejection and resistance from society members. Also, there may be several attempts to stop it, even if it brings about beneficial developments, as in the case of PCs currently. Such attempts continue until diffusion becomes complete; hence, the new product is said to be adopted. The following example illustrates initial resistance to innovation. A study (37) was carried out on 100 ladies in Boston in the 1930s, in order to know their impression about instant coffee, when it was first introduced. Most of the women responded that they did not use it because it tasted different from normal coffee. They even accused women using instant coffee of being lazy, careless and unqualified to run their homes. When the study was repeated in 1968 - instant coffee had been long in the market - most of the
Consumer Behavior
111
Chapter 3
housewives responded that the women using it valued time, speed and effort. The change in response is attributed to the fact that instant coffee had been accepted by society during the period between both studies. In addition, the American society had gone through cultural changes during that time. Resistance to change varies in its intensity according to the values prevailing in the society undergoing change. In some societies, diffusion of innovation is easier and less complicated. Also, the intensity of resistance varies, depending on the type of innovation.
3.3.3 The Adoption Process Model
The process of adopting a new product is gradual, and it goes through a number of stages. The first stage is the perception of the innovation, as the consumer realizes that an innovation, such as a product or an idea, has been introduced in a particular area. At the second stage, that of knowledge, the consumer begins to learn something about this new product or idea, and progresses in understanding its features, strengths and weaknesses. With increased knowledge, the third stage is reached, where the consumer likes or dislikes the innovation. The nature of this feeling relies heavily on the extent to which the consumer feels that the product will fulfill his needs. At this stage, the consumer sometimes experiences, a sense of risk and uncertainty. This brings about the stage of trial and testing. The consumer attempts to test for further information. Then comes the stage of evaluating the use of the product. The more positive the evaluation results are, the more likely the adoption of the new product. The time factor is considered of utmost importance in this process, since some consumers go through the stages very rapidly, while others take a long time. Also, some consumers may even abandon the process at one of the stages. In some cases, the consumer may skip some intermediate stages, between the perception and adoption. In this regard, personal recommendations and the skills
112
Consumer Behavior
Consumers vary regarding the speed with which they adopt new products. While some are already within the market of a particular product, others are still outside. Marketing focuses on identifying to which group consumers belong so that marketers can provide an appropriate mix for the target group. In general, consumers can be classified on the basis of the speed with which they adopt innovation into five categories in the following descending order:
(a) Innovators
Innovators constitute a very small minority of the market. They are those who buy a new product very early. They are distinguished by their ability to pay the high price which usually comes with new products. Their incomes are often high, and they obtain
Consumer Behavior
113
Chapter 3
information about innovations from newspapers and international media. They have wide connections with various parts of the world. On the psychological level, members of this category are
distinguished by their tendency to risk taking and adventure, and to dealing with innovations in all domains. In addition, they are selfdirected, i.e., they do not rely on others' judgements on
innovations. It may not be appropriate to focus the marketing policy on the category of innovators, because they are a small percentage of the total buying force. In addition, they are not considered a buying model that can effectively inf luence the purchasing behavior of the rest of society.
considered the target of marketing strategies. They have some of the innovators' characteristics, such as love for change and risk taking. Yet, unlike innovators, they are more local and have a greater
interest in and greater ties with their community and its grassroots. For this reason, other consumers tend to imitate them and to be inf luenced by their purchases. Thus, this category represents the opinion leaders for other consumers, hence their importance for marketing. This requires various marketing programs to focus on them, because, in most cases, they represent the link between
114
Consumer Behavior
As the number of innovation adopters increases, the novelty of the innovation decreases. At this point, a new group enters the market, making up the late majority. These customers are more influenced by publicity than by the opinions of others. Their being late to join adopters may be explained by several factors, including their low income, old age, or lack of interest in innovation.
(e) Laggards (conservatives)
Laggards form the last category, and they are the ones who adopt a product after it has been widely accepted and when the risk factor has decreased a great deal. These customers may obtain the product at a time when innovators and opinion leaders are moving on to another product with more advantages, and taking greater risks and paying higher prices. The classification of adopter categories is near to the normal distribution, which is bell-shaped: innovators represent a small percentage (about 2.5%); it is followed by the early adopters (13.5%); then comes the early majority (34%), matched by the late majority (34%); and finally comes a minority of laggards and conservatives (16%), which(39) represent a category that is not keen on adopting every innovation. Figure 5 shows a diagram of the percentages of adopter categories.
(40)
Consumer Behavior
115
Chapter 3
As shown in the diagram, with the exception of innovators, early adopters, and laggards/conservatives (who become interested only when the innovation grows older), the majority of consumers (68%) need some time to adopt a new product. New products vary in terms of the speed with which they are adopted by consumers. In the case of consumer goods, the speed increases. In fact, some products saturate the market, and are then totally forgotten within one week, such as song records in Western countries. Other goods may take years to be totally accepted by the target market.(41)
3.3.4 Development of the Diffusion of Innovation Model
Given the importance of this model, it is useful to shed more light on its development and mechanisms. Since the publication of Ryan's and Cross's studies in the 1940s, and the later modifications proposed by Wilkening, Leon Berger, Beal, Rogers and Bohlen in the 1950s, the model has undergone improvements and additions by large research teams, sometimes with the support of some universities and governments in several American states. The basic reference of this model was Diffusion of Innovation, by Evertt Rogers. It was first published in 1962. It was reprinted several times, the last of which was in 1995. The model, as presented in the book, in the 1971 edition, included 114 general rules about consumer behavior towards innovative (42) products, together with field results testing the validity of the rules.
Components of the model
The speed with which the consumer adopts any new product depends on many factors that have to do with the product itself. These factors are: D The reward that ensues from its use,
116
Consumer Behavior
The amount of investment in the product, D Easy use, and D Possibility of use on a small scale (possible trial) The clearer the product's rewards, the more user friendly, and the smaller the investment in it, the faster it is adopted by a large number of consumers.
D
b. Adopter's characteristics
The consumer adopting a new product is a person or a group taking a decision to adopt it as soon as it is first launched. The larger the group, the more complex the decision to adopt a new product becomes.
c. Time
It is the time the adopting consumer takes to move from the product identification stage to the purchase decision-making stage.
d. Social system
The social system can facilitate or even hinder a new product's adoption, depending on physical and economic structures. The more in harmony the new product is with the existing social system, the faster its adoption is, and vice versa. The available communication channels within the social system may speed up or hinder the adoption process, particularly if the system has an expilcit stand towards the new product.
e. Change motivator
The motivator is usually a person who is influential in making others hasten to adopt new products. This is due to the motivator's technical knowledge as well as his outstanding social role.
Consumer Behavior
117
Chapter 3
Endnotes of Chapter 3
(1) Al-Hinnawi,
Strategies,
Mohamed
Salih,
Soliman, A.,
Al-Hinnawi, M. S.,
Abdul-Fattah, Mohamed Sa'eed, Marketing, Beirut, Dar Al-Nahdhah Al-Arabia for Printing and Publishing, 1983, p. 44.
(5)
Al-Jeraisi, Khaled A., "Analysis of Consumer's Decision in the Purchase Process", Ph. D. dissertation, Kensington University, US, 2003.
(6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) (21) (22) (23) (24) (25) (26) (27) (28) (29) (30)
Marketing Management, Eective Marketing, Marketing Management, Eective Marketing, Marketing Management, Eective Marketing,
Obaidat, Mohamed,
Principles of Marketing, Marketing Management, Eective Marketing, Marketing Management, Eective Marketing, Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice, Marketing Management, Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice, Eective Marketing,
op. cit., p. 146. op. cit., p. 147. op. cit., p. 148.
Idrees and Al-Ghais, Obaidat, Mohamed, Stanton, William J., Abdul-Hameed, Assulami, Ali,
Marketing Management, Principles of Marketing, Fundamentals of Marketing, Eective Marketing, Marketing Research, A Behavioral Approach, Marketing Management,
118
Consumer Behavior
(31) (32) (33) (34) (35) (36) (37) (38) (39) (40) (41)
Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 158. Stanton, William J., Fundamentals of Marketing, op. cit., p. 118. Hassan, S. A. Marketing: Principles and Strategies, op. cit., pp. 153-173. Wilkie, William L., Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 356. Wilkie, William L., Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 361.
Ibid., p. 362. Ibid., p. 362.. Hassan, S. A.
Marketing: Principles and Strategies, op. cit., p. 162. Communication of Innovations: A Cross-Cultural Marketing Management, vol. 1, pp. 294-295.
(42)
Ba-Zar'ah, M. Saadiq,
Consumer Behavior
119
Chapter 4
Social Factors Aecting the Purchase Decision
Chapter Topics
4.1 Culture 4.2 Social Class 4.3 Reference Group 4.4 Age 4.5 Educational Level 4.6 Gender
As a social being, man is greatly affected by his environment. For example, he often buys the products that enhance his image before others. This chapter analyzes a number of factors associated with the surrounding environment, and a number of demographic and personal factors associated with the consumer.
Consumer Behavior
123
4.I. Culture
Culture is considered the most comprehensive external social determinant of human behavior. It can be defined as ``a combination of symbols and human artifacts invented by a given society and transmitted across generations in order to determine (1) and regulate human behavior.'' Some symbols may be abstract like trends, values, language, and beliefs. Others may be concrete, such as architectural styles, tools, products, and works of art.(2) It is the interaction between the individual and culture that determines human behavior. The interaction contributes to modifying and directing behavior. With regard to the consumer, he is influenced by his culture at every shopping activity in the market. Culture determines the required criteria and regulations. It also rewards those who abide by them and penalizes those who violate them. The behavior of (3) the consumer is, thus, nothing but the outcome of that very culture. From a consumption perspective, culture is considered the social heritage of the community. It includes ``common characteristics, such as values, habits, traditions, beliefs, ethics, and prohibitions, which the consumer acquires.''(4) Culture presents a way of life that generations learn and pass on, from one to the next. It does not include instinct-driven behavior, but works out ways to satisfy instincts. Man experiences hunger; what he eats, the way he eats, and the types of meals he consumes vary in accordance with the culture to which he belongs. In general, cultures have the following characteristics: (5)
Consumer Behavior
125
4.1.1 Definition
Chapter 4
The main function of culture is to satisfy man's needs, and any cultural value that does not satisfy a particular human want or desire does not often last long.
b. Learnability
A child learns the symbols of his native culture from his family members, mates, and teachers(6). This is how culture is transmitted from one generation to another; it has a tremendous effect on the individual's behavior, including thoughts, beliefs, reactions, sensitivity to issues around him, and analysis of what affects him.
4.1.2 Culture Components
Material culture consists of tangible objects in the individual's environment, hence the name `external culture'. They are what the individual observes, comes into physical contact with, and makes use of in his everyday activities. They provide means for artistic selfexpression, such as sculptures and paintings, for self-protection, such as clothing and buildings, and for leisure activities, such as literary works and sports equipment. Culture provides ways that enhance the performance of bodyfunctions, such as eating and sleeping comfortably. In addition, material culture provides means for the division of labour, whereby each individual exercises a particular profession and exchanges the products he makes for products made by others. This eventually contributes to raising the community's living standards.
Intellectual culture
Consumer Behavior
shared by the majority of a given society. It is represented by knowledge systems, such as language and science, value and belief systems, such as religion, politics and social philosophy, and codes of behavior and directives that make up the prescriptive social system. Norms are codes of behavior approved for particular situations or in the performance of certain activities. They include ways of thinking, expression of feelings, customs, conventions, and laws that facilitate cooperation and coexistence. function as deterrents of contraventions.
(7)
Directives and
different life stages, have a strong impact on his knowledge of the world around him. They also play a tremendous role in affecting collective opinions, aspirations, and beliefs and in determining the socially acceptable goals, as well as the approved individual values and habits. Cultural influences differ from one society to another;
(8)
what is
acceptable in a given context may not necessarily be in another. Marketing management has to be aware of the cultural symbols a society tolerates and the extent to which the marketed product stands in terms of harmony with those symbols. The big failure of Nestle Company, when it tried to market powdered milk, as an alternative to natural milk in Africa, is a case in point. Not only does culture affect the individual's material requirements, but it also affects his ways of understanding and learning, as well as
Consumer Behavior
127
Chapter 4
his lifestyle and motives(9). Therefore, cultural influence is considered to have a great deal of power. Norms of behavior are held by a particular society and are approved of by most of its members. In general, the individual's behavior and his observance of the rules and laws of a given society depend on the relative power that society enjoys. They also depend on the individuals' reliance on others to satisfy his wants; the more his social power and independence increase, the lesser control the cultural norms have on him. Human behavior is determined by the interaction of the individual and culture; this interaction adjusts the person's behavior and channels it. Research(10)1has confirmed that the individual, who is strongly attached to the culture and the society to which he belongs, follows thoroughly its rules, principles, and behavioral patterns. To convince him to purchase a given product is easier if the product is presented as being socially acceptable, and does not engender negative reactions from other members. As stated earlier, culture is not in a state of inertia. The following factors are related to cultural change: a. Technological changes b. Demographic changes c. Changes in values d. Inter-culture contact.(11)
4.1.4 Sub-culture
Mention can be made of what is often referred to as sub-culture, which exists in all societies. It is defined as ``the culture that contains values and beliefs, and constitutes behavioral patterns for a determined group within the main culture of the whole society.''(12) The sub-culture ``becomes part of the main culture due to immigration or temporary work stay. Members of the sub128
Consumer Behavior
culture have values, beliefs, and behavioral patterns that distinguish (13) them from members of the main culture.'' A nation's cultural elements can be grouped into two basic categories, general and specific. General or main culture is shared by most members, regardless of their subdivisions. Specific culture or sub-culture is shared by a number of specific groups within a (14) Members of the sub-culture embrace the values given society. and beliefs of the general culture, while preserving their distinctive values, beliefs, and traditions. The significance of members of a sub-culture rises for at least one of the following reasons: when members of a sub-culture represent a large section of the society; when they have their own marketplaces; when they have a distinct lifestyle or consumption rate of a particular product; when they have favourite shopping (15) zones or show preference for an advertisement medium . A subculture of this sort requires its own products and purchasing patterns. The presence of sub-cultures within a given society requires that marketers be aware of the impact of the sense of belonging on consumers' behavior. Such behavior may be markedly different from that of the general culture consumer. It must be always borne in mind that consumer's ethnic background is present throughout all his decision-making stages.
Consumer Behavior
129
Chapter 4
4.2.1 Definition
Consumer Behavior
housing.(19) (3) The social class can be defined geographically, as members of the same class often tend to live in particular residential areas. (4) Belonging to a particular social class dictates a particular pattern of consumption behavior. This makes the social class a major index for the analysis of consumer behavior. (5) Members of different social classes have different reactions to the same marketing program, depending on the difference among classes. Several sociologists classify society into classes, defining each class in terms of a number of common traits related to culture, income, aspirations, interests, and consumption behavior.(20)
4.2.2 Social Stratification and Consumer Behavior
There is no standard categorisation of society, and there is lack of field studies conducted in the Arab world in this domain.''(21) However, there are three major social classes into which society members can be grouped. They are:(22)
a. The upper class
It includes well-established wealthy families, major entrepreneurs, the nouveaux riches, and professionals.
b. The middle class
It usually includes relatively successful businessmen and owners of medium-sized companies. At the upper part of this class are highlyeducated and ambitious individuals. The lower part is made up of white-collars, i.e. office clerks, teachers, most tradesmen, technicians, and owners of small businesses. They are highly selfconfident, and are willing to take risks in order to reach a higher social class.
Consumer Behavior
131
Chapter 4
adopted as the sole criterion for defining social class. In some countries, a family's reputation and history are among the criteria that can be used for classification. Yet, the importance of this criterion is significantly reduced, due to more educational opportunities and the redistribution of wealth in many countries. Thus, a person's competence and ambition can make it possible for him to reach a social position higher than that of his parents. The class to which a family belongs no longer prevents its members from climbing the social ladder. There are however, those who prefer to remain where they are (i) because they do not want to risk the peace, stability and sense of belonging which their social class provides (ii) and because they are afraid of running the risk of reaching for a higher class where they think they may not fit.
(24)
132
Consumer Behavior
used in making social classifications. They include educational level, occupation, and place of residence, which are the bases of modern classification of social classes. It is also worth stressing the importance of the social class to consumer behavior, as every class determines the social milieu of its members. They are obliged to follow the patterns of behavior and traditions of their class if they want to belong to it and if they depend on it for satisfying their various needs. Research conducted in many countries has shown that members of the same social group tend to live together in the same area, and they communicate - as much as possible - only with the members of their social class. By so doing, they create a cultural unity and convergence in attitude and thought. Therefore, members of a given social class often express themselves in symbols reflecting their social status, as in buying particular products associated with their social status.(25) For example, they pay particular attention to having clothes and accessories bearing their designers' initials, and cars with distinct plate numbers. Field studies conducted in industrialised countries have shown significant discrepancies in consumer behavior across social classes. Members of the upper class often consider buying furniture as a psychologically fulfilling symbol of prestige. As for members of the middle class, they are interested in functional furniture, which is expected to make their living conditions comfortable. When choosing electric products, upper-class members pay attention to brand and color, while middle-class and lower-class members pay attention to reliable performance.(26) In general, several studies confirm social class differences in behavioral patterns with respect to a number of issues:(27)
a. Type of shop
Certain types and names of shops are frequented only by members of the upper-class, for the shops are compatible with their social
Consumer Behavior
133
Chapter 4
and financial status. In contrast, members of other classes tend to avoid those shops for various reasons: (i) they think they may be treated unceremoniously; (ii) they may be embarrassed due to prices they could not afford, or (iii) they feel awkward in the presence of a high-status clientele.
Consumer Behavior
Attitudes towards prices vary among classes. For example, lowerclass consumers do not have enough knowledge of product prices or service charges. Because they know little about product specifications, they tend to rely on the price as a quality index. As for upper-class members, they tend to rely on their past experience to weigh available prices of the products they want to buy. (30) Class members do not share the same style of communication. They do not have the same pattern of interaction, nor do they use the same vocabulary. One study has shown that upper-class speakers tend to maintain a quiet and balanced sound-pitch and intonation pattern. They also tend to validate their decision by relying on detailed information more than their middle-class or lower-class counterparts. Low-class members are easily influenced by rumors and gossip. Upper-class rely on symbolic and idiosyncratic manners to express their goals. Identification of social classes, their characteristics, and their percentages has a vital role in designing marketing plans and strategies. It represents an effective criterion for market segmentation. It allows for the production of goods that correspond to consumers' desires, needs and finances, relative to each and (31) every class. Classes tend to be homogenous and affect their respective members' consumption style. Each class determines various levels of social interaction, consumption rates, predictions, aspirations, and different (32) demographic and psychological characteristics of its members. Furthermore, goods and services vary in accordance with the social status (33) they have come to symbolize, and symbols change with time. The presence of electric appliances in a given household used to point to the outstanding position their owners occupy on the social scale. Now, they are common domestic equipment. When planning their
Consumer Behavior
135
h. Language of communication
Chapter 4
policies, marketers have to be aware of the importance of social classes. They are selling not just a good or a service, but also a social status symbol. However, the social class remains a complex determinant of consumer behavior. This is due to difficulty of defining ``class'' in the first place, and the rapid changes in society. In comparison with other less complex factors, such as the income factor, reliance on social class is very costly in terms of market research. Furthermore, there are many products and shops where the social class has no significance, as in the case of convenient products and medications. There are also shopping centers that people from all social classes frequent. Thus, program designers need to define the factors that most strongly affect their product marketing. They need also to determine if market segmentation is to be based on the income factor alone or on a variety of factors representing the social class.
136
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 4
a. Membership groups
Membership groups may be official bodies. They could be small local council representatives or large unions of medical doctors or engineers. They are often referred to as normative reference groups because they provide their members with values and norms of behavior. Members take opinion leaders as representative models of behavioral patterns and values. The family, friends, and neighbours are illustrative examples.
b. Spontaneous groups
They are the groups that people join spontaneously according to certain criteria, such as age, social status, gender, nationality, and income. Personal or other relationships hardly play any role in their grouping. The significance of this type of group derives from its influence on its members' social expectations, for they have a clear impact on the types of goods and services the members buy.
c. Aspiration groups
They are the highly motivated and inspired groups which individuals aspire to join. These groups influence the behavioral pattern of individuals aspiring to improve their social status. Their influence extends to purchasing decisions related to clothes, cars, and recreation facilities.
d. Negative groups
Negative groups provide the values and behavior that the individual does not like or respect. The individual does his utmost to dissociate himself from them, and avoids becoming one of their members. Thus, reference groups can be organic groups to which the individual belongs and directly interacts with, e.g. the family, workmates, and schoolmates. The individual could also associate himself with a reference group with which he does not directly
138
Consumer Behavior
information. The individual considers this information reliable and treats it with great trust.
endeavours
hopes,
expectations
preferences. In return, he wins the group's respect and sympathy. So, one's reference group becomes more important than other groups or individuals.
group
voicing them. This is, indeed, how the individual is accepted and integrated into the group. The informational function of the reference group is reflected in the so-called ``consumer advice'' which the individual receives from his group. The advice, together with the information it includes, has a strong effect on consumer behavior. That information can be summarised as follows:
(39)
Consumer Behavior
139
Chapter 4
of information more reliable than the commercials, which the consumer presumes to be at the service of the company behind the advertisement. Furthermore, consumption advice builds up information through open and friendly discussions among reference group members. These discussions consolidate consumer behavior, for when this advice is met with approval, the consumer receives from his interlocutor confirmation of his own point of view and support for his own behavior. (b) Consumption advice is conducted in an interactive and bidirectional way, which is not the case with one-way television commercials or other advertisement media. The two-way communication provides the opportunity for the consumer to receive answers to his questions. It allows him to produce explanations and pursue matters that fall within his interest. The two-way communication is characterised by flexibility; it is open-ended, but it comes to a close if one party wants to stop discussion. The audio or visual commercial is limited in time and is not as rewarding as faceto-face discussion. (c) The exchange of real experience contributes to the effectiveness of consumer advice. A person may obtain theoretical experience on a particular product upon watching a commercial. Such experience is supported by asking reference group members who have tried the product. If the members recommend the product, a new customer emerges as a result of trusting the practical experience of others. 4.3.4 The Consumer Social Integration Concept The consumer social integration concept is extremely important for understanding communication behavior and consumer recommendations. Four consumer types can be identified in the consumer social integration system. They are the following:
140
Consumer Behavior
The socially integrated are those who achieve a high rating on opinion leadership and information search.
b. The socially independent
The socially independent are those who achieve a high degree of influencing others, but a low degree of being influenced. Both a and b, above, make up society's opinion leaders.
c. The socially dependent
The socially dependent are those who do not achieve a high degree of influence on others, but follow other people's opinions. They could be called opinion followers.
d. The socially isolated
The socially isolated are those who neither influence nor are influenced much by people around them. These are least prone to listen to advice. It is worth mentioning that a consumer may be categorized as socially isolated for a particular range of products, and the same consumer may be classified as socially approved for another range of products. The following figure represents consumer categories and their respective degrees of opinion leadership and information search:
(40)
Consumer Behavior
141
Chapter 4
Obviously, the reference group and its means of interaction are a mixed blessing for marketing. Marketers can benefit from reference groups' positive influence on consumer behavior. This can be done by directing marketing and promotional efforts to opinion leaders and to the members of ambitious reference groups, who, in turn, positively influence other consumers. Marketers show those influential individuals in advertisements as consumers of their products. For example, a sports champion or a film star can be shown in a commercial using a particular product, and getting satisfaction from it. In such an advertisement, the quality and characteristics of(41) the consumer are emphasized more than those of the the product. However, reference group advice may have a negative effect on a particular product if negative opinions about it prevail among reference groups and influential opinion leaders. The marketer should pay attention to such negative opinions circulating among the individuals of those groups. To curtail negative opinions, the marketer should use varied marketing techniques to stress positive opinions instead. In general, marketers need to define their target consumer. This involves identifying the reference group which he belongs to or aspires to join. By making use of the appropriate consumer group, marketers are on the right track to achieving consumer satisfaction. Oftentimes, when a product carries a brand name, its price rises dramatically, in comparison with a similar product without the name; consumers choose brand products because they want to associate themselves with a certain aspiration group. Clothes and accessories bearing international brand names are a case in point.
4.3.5 The Bearden-Etzel Model(42).
The Bearden and Etzel's study emphasizes the influence of reference groups on consumer behavior regarding particular products. The study distinguishes between: (a) general luxury
142
Consumer Behavior
products, (b) specific luxury products, (c) basic products for general use, and (d) basic products for special use. It investigated (i) whether reference group influence applies to a given category of products or is limited to a trademark within that category and (ii) if reference group influence varies according to whether the product is of type a, b, c, or d, above. Figure nine (7) illustrates the Bearden and Etzel's model.
(43)
Consumer Behavior
143
Chapter 4
(c) Public necessities
The reference group does not influence the decision to purchase public necessities, but it has a strong impact on the choice of brand, for almost all consumers realize their need for them. In this case, it is the brand that clearly matters. For example, all people wear clothes, but the choice of design and brand name is influenced by the reference group. This applies to other necessities, such as most basic household electric appliances (e.g. television sets, fridges, and washing machines).
(d) Private necessities
In the case of private necessities, the reference group has no noticeable influence on the purchase decision or choice of brand, as in canned food and detergents. It is worth mentioning that what is considered necessary in some societies may be a luxury in others. This is due to changing needs.
144
Consumer Behavior
4.4 Age
Age plays an important role in defining a person's behavior as well as the factors that influence his behavior. The significance of those factors and their types vary according to age. Motives for purchasing products that satisfy the needs of those growing old and reaching a high social status are important. The older one is, the greater the role of the social status becomes. Old age is related also to the increase of motivation influence on human needs for comfort and (45) boasting. Consumers' age range can be divided into three basic stages: a. Stage one, or the youth stage b. Stage two, or the maturity stage c. Stage three, or the advanced stage Compared to the above-mentioned stages, childhood and adolescence have a relatively smaller role in consumption, and are therefore overlooked. At the childhood and adolescence stages, the individual barely has any influence on other than the purchase of his personal things.
Stage one: the youth stage
The youth stage ranges from 25 to 34 years old. Members of this category tend to seek independence and self-fulfilment. Their good health and active life make them good consumers of food. They are characterized by their inclination to speed, and to the utilization of their time in what they consider appropriate. They also tend to be risk-takers and innovative. They give priority to their own interests, especially if they are bachelors. They are inclined to buy fashionable
Consumer Behavior
145
Chapter 4
goods and to pay more attention to labels than to product quality. Those at the youth stage have relatively limited financial resources, and that affects their purchase decisions. They tend to be more influenced by various promotional activities, such as advertisements and personal selling.
146
Consumer Behavior
reaches a point when it becomes difficult for him to change his attitude towards certain products and brands.
There is a direct correlation between social status motives and advancing age, regarding ready-made clothes, furniture, leather goods, makeup and jewelry. The love of acquisition motive becomes less influential as age advances. Young people have more desire for acquiring new products than older ones do, particularly regarding ready-made clothes, leather goods and electric appliances. When young, ladies are more likely to be influenced by new fashions and products. Later, the majority of them focus on the well-being of their husbands and children. The older a lady grows, the more associated with social status and with higher quality consumer goods her boasting motives become. As women advance in age, they seek products that give them more comfort, particularly regarding frozen and tinned food, shoes, leather goods, stationery, detergents, cleaning materials, and electric appliances. The study also shows that preference factors for certain products are closely linked to age. As age advances, the concern with quality becomes a major reason for product preference. Second comes the brand fame, while seeking modern fashions comes third. The price factor gets less important as a major reason for preference.
(47)
In general, the attitudes of individuals of various ages towards the product quality and shape are clearly varied, and so are their preference of sales outlets. Also, they respond differently to
Consumer Behavior
147
Chapter 4
advertisements. Therefore, advertisements have to be carefully designed to suit the target consumers, because the advertisement's influential elements vary according to the individual's age and reference group.
2.
3.
Consumer Behavior
broad framework for product distribution. The studies help marketers set up a more effective and profitable product distribution strategy, by delivering the products to final consumers at the right time, and within suitable conditions. 4. Market segmentation may affect the role of promotion. For the selection of the advertising means, it is necessary to study the behavior of consumers at different age stages (children, youth and elderly). This helps identify the ways that are most suitable and acceptable to each of the target market segments. In brief, market segmentation studies largely contribute to identifying consumers' satisfied needs and desires and unsatisfied ones. They also enhance the development of new products, and the modification of existing ones, in order to meet changing needs, desires and tastes. The segmentation of the whole market into sub-groups on the basis of age is simple and can be easily applied by industrial and marketing organizations. Underlying this is that consumer needs are determined according to age range. Therefore, some producers provide certain products and brands suitable for particular age ranges. For example, there are products meeting the needs and desires of children of certain ages, products associated with new university graduates, and products for elderly people.(50) Finally, it is necessary to study the conditions the individual experiences at each age stage. Conditions, such as profession, leisure time, and family circumstances, affect his income, and subsequently his purchase decisions. (51)
Consumer Behavior
149
Chapter 4
Education is considered one of the major factors that affect an individual's behavior, cognition and motives. It heightens his aspirations, reinforces his knowledge, and opens up new avenues for him. Education also affects the individual's consumption behavior. It is rightly argued that an educated person tends to have more rational motives and is less impulsive in his purchase decisions.(52) He shows great interest in product quality, reliability, and potentials, but less interest in seeking attention or prestige, which he regards as secondary. Education also provides the individual with selfconfidence and endows him with the power to resist superfluous social traditions. In addition, it makes the individual so unique that he does not often use particular possessions to enhance his social image. Furthermore, a high educational level broadens the individual's knowledge and awareness of world events as well as new developments related to materials, production methods, and products. It also enables him to read articles and bulletins and obtain more information on the products that interest him. Contact with peers at, more or less, the same level of education and culture provides the individual with an information source that makes him extensively aware of new quality products. As such an educated individual is better-informed of product details, (as constituents, properties and advantages as well as disadvantages), he will approach products with greater awareness. In general, the educated person is more inclined to follow his peer's advice when purchasing a particular product. Yet, he hardly trusts
150
Consumer Behavior
advertisements, and he does not have confidence in or loyalty to any product unless he, himself, checks it, or unless it is recommended by someone he personally trusts. Thus, he approaches products and brands on the basis of trial or of the information he obtains from, for example, articles and researches by people he trusts.
The following are the major advantages education has for consumers:
1. Higher education gives the consumer - in addition to the advantageous social status - self-confidence and courage, which make him express his personal opinion frankly on the products he buys. He can also reach the media more easily to express his critical views on products. In one incident, a university professor, disenchanted with the bad performance of his Buick, a prestigious car, suggested that its name, ``Road Master'', become ``Road Disaster'' instead, because of the great trouble (53) he has had with it. . A high educational level often brings about mobility to higher social classes. It is a determining factor in social stratification. Moving to a higher social class is reflected in the individual's behavior in general, and in his consumption behavior in particular, for the new class has its own criteria and lifestyle. The educated tend to imitate advanced societies, by adopting a lot of their behavior patterns. This is reflected in their lifestyle and the types of products they use. Education is one of the contributing factors that guide the consumer's purchase decisions. The success of marketing policies depends on their influence on the consumer's awareness of those policies. This awareness is originally dependent on the consumer's learning abilities. The educated person is often more aware of the woman's role in the family, and is therefore more inclined to get her involved
151
(54)
2.
3.
4.
5.
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 4
in most purchase decisions. Also, her high level of education has a strong inf luence on purchase decision-making. In fact, she often plays leading roles. Evidently, her education enhances her awareness, culture and knowledge, and hence utilizing her skills in family decision-making, consumption included. 6. The higher the consumer's level of education,
(55)
the
more
attention he pays to product quality and fame, and the less attention he pays to price or color. 7. Regarding the wide range of goods, the higher the consumer's level of education, the more attention he pays to the quality of food items, furniture, internal design, and household electric appliances. 8. The
(56)
educated to
individual visit
is
more and
inclined
than
the
less
and
attend
lectures to his
cultural
Such
activities to his
general
awareness,
in
turn,
consumption behavior.
152
Consumer Behavior
4.6 Gender
4.6.1 Gender Consumer Characteristics
Human behavior differs according to gender. There are obvious differences between women's behavior and men's in various situations, conditions and times. With respect to consumer behavior, gender greatly influences the marketing mix strategies for most companies. For example, women are the main users of make (57) up items, while men are the principal users of shaving products. Men's purchase motives seem to be more rational, while women's motives are considered rather impulsive. Women are said to give much importance to boasting, seeking attention, distinction, and imitation of peers, workmates or neighbours. However, these are not necessarily true in all cases. It is often difficult to change a man's attitude towards a particular product, but it is easier with women, for they tend to be quick at adopting new things. Also men and women have different perceptions. For example, whereas men seem to concentrate on the product per se, women seem to pay attention to details, scrutinising its various aspects. This is reflected in women's shopping behavior. A woman takes long inspecting a product, identifying its advantages, and comparing them with other products. In contrast, a man who enters the same shop at the same time as the woman does will have already taken the purchase decision, paid the price, and left the store, but she will still be there. Men tend to go through the purchase decision stages more quickly than women do. Such a trait among women shoppers takes great time and effort from salesclerks. This requires patience, persuading skills and experience on the part of the salesclerk in order to deal sucessfully with women shoppers.
Consumer Behavior
153
Chapter 4
In addition to being hesitant, and interested in details, women find pleasure in visiting several shops, browsing around, asking questions and getting information on new and distinct products, regardless of the purpose of shopping. Women also enjoy buying things, even if not necessary. Therefore, regardless of their education level, they can be easily influenced by advertisement and promotion efforts. They enjoy trying products they read or hear about.''
(58)
It is worth mentioning that women are greatly influenced by personal advice from colleagues
(59)
adopting their views, especially as women have a typical tendency to imitation. They are also more inclined than men to adopting new products, changes and exchanges. Women tend to bargain and discuss prices.
(60)
on displayed goods. Being aware of these traits, some salesclerks develop ways to give women customers the impression that the price was reduced just for them. In reality, the salesclerks start with a high price first, then give a 'discount', going back to the real price. Because of their interest in discounts, women are fond of sale seasons, an excellent opportunity to buy what they want and at a `good price'. As for men, they tend to buy larger quantities, and they do not bargain as much as women do. Due to recent changes in Arab societies and cultures, attitudes towards women's education and work have changed. Women have such a status that their influence as purchasers has become
(61)
powerful. They are now engaged in a lot of activities, professions and businesses as men are. In addition to their leading role in the family, women are playing an active role in their society. They are actively communicating with the world, are aware of up-todate events, and are playing a positive part.
154
Consumer Behavior
Endnotes of Chapter 4
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) (21) (22)
Fundamentals of Marketing, op. cit., p. 118. Abdul-Hameed. T.A., Eective Marketing: Fundamentals and Practice, op. cit. p. 121. Mohammad, M. F. and A. M. Al-Sherbini, Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 172
Stanton, et al., Ibid., p. 173.
Principles of Marketing: A Behaviorist Approach, op. cit. pp. 80-81. Wilkie, W. L. Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 349. Hanna, N., Marketing Principles, Dar Al-Merrikh Lin-Nashr, Riyadh, 1985, p. 124. Muhammad, M. F. and A. M. Al-Sherbini, Consumer Behavior, op. cit., pp. 180-191. Hanna, N., Marketing Principles, op. cit., p. 123. Ba-Zar'ah, M. S., Marketing Management. Part I. op.cit., p. 308. Al-Ghadeer, Hamad and Al-Saed, Rashad, Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 158. Obaidat, M., Principles of Marketing: A Behaviorist Approach, op.cit, p. 81.
Obaidat, M., Ibid., p. 325. Al-Ghadeer, Hamad and Al-Saed, Rashad, Obaidat, M., Ibid., p. 283. Al-Ghadeer, Hamad and Al-Saed, Rashad, Obaidat, M. Ibid., p. 82.
Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. Principles of Marketing: A Behaviorist Introduction, op.cit, p. 82.
175.
Consumer Behavior, op. cit., Principles of Marketing: A Behaviorist Approach, op.cit, p. 82.
p. 296.
(23) (24) (25) (26) (27) (28) (29) (30) (31) (32)
Marketing : From Producer to Consumer, op. cit. p. 56 Al-Ghadeer, Hamad and Al-Saed, Rashad, Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 313. Obaidat, M., Principles of Marketing, op. cit., pp. 83-84. Obaidat, M., Consumer Behavior: A Behaviorist Approach, op. cit., pp. 284-288. Stanton and Others, Fundamentals of Marketing, op. cit., p. 120 Hanna, Nassem, Marketing Principles, op. cit., p. 122. Ba-Zar'ah, M. S. Marketing Management. Part I. op.cit., p. 310.
Al-Haaj, T. et. al., Ibid., p. 310. Obaidat, M.
Stanton, W. J. Obaidat,
Principles of Marketing, p. 302. Fundamentals of Marketing, op. cit., M., Principles of Marketing, op.cit, p. 84.
p. 122
p. 122. 82.
Consumer Behavior
155
Chapter 4
Marketing Management. Part I. Fundamentals of Marketing, Marketing; from Producer to Consumer, Marketing from a Comprehensive Perspective, Principles of Marketing, Fundamentals of Marketing, Consumer Behavior,
op. cit. p. 122. op.cit, p. 86. op. cit., p. 279. .op. cit. pp. 255- 257. op. Cit. p. 48-3437. op. cit. p. 438.
(39)
Hinnawi,
Fundamentals of Management, Marketing Management, Consumer Behavior, Consumer Behavior, Principles of Marketing, Consumer Behavior, Principles of Marketing.
-
among Saudi and non Saudi Women in the City of Jeddah, Eective Marketing, Principles of Marketing,
Marketing Principles,
op.cit., p. 59.
10463,
(54) (55)
Assaaf, M.,
Fundamentals of Marketing,
-
among Saudi and non Saudi Women in the City of Jeddah, Principles of Marketing.
op. cit, p. 133.
(59)
(60) (61)
Assaaf, M.,
among Saudi and non Saudi Women in the City of Jeddah, Marketing Principles,
op. cit., p. 60.
Ibid., p. 60.
156
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 5
Purchase Decision Interaction Within the Family
Chapter Topics
5.1 Concept of Family in the Saudi Society and Economy 5.2 Family Functions 5.3 Family Patterns 5.4 Functions of the Family Decision 5.5 Family Members' Roles in the Purchase Decision Stages
Consumer Behavior
159
The family is known to be the first human organization and the nucleus of any society. As a social institution that is as old as man, the family is based on marriage. The notion of marriage derives from human instinct, and is prescribed by legal systems.(2) It is the cornerstone of society's foundation, and is the means of holding the social structure together. The family can be defined as a social institution or unit comprising a group of people living together, bound with basic relations, and living on a common income, as the family's common resource. The family represents the foundation basis of society and the link that keeps it coherent. The family can be also defined as ``a social unit comprising two or more persons legally united in wedlock and dwelling in one household with the possibility of having offspring''. (3) Others consider the family as a social phenomenon, as old as man. As a functional unit, it consists of a husband, a wife and children, and they are bound with blood relations and common goals. When performing its functions, the family interacts with the wider social system. In evolutionary terms, the family is the first human community `cell'. From a number of families was formed a large one. Together, the families made up the community. The communities, in turn, formed society, a group of individuals with a common goal and a specific end. Thus, the concept of family embodies the earliest
Consumer Behavior
161
Chapter 5
human gathering, forming the first community. In other words, it is the basis of reproducing and socializing the next generation. It is also the origin of cooperation as well as competition regarding the satisfaction of the needs for love, security and social status. (4) As a new concept of family, the household refers to those individuals living together in the same residence without necessarily being blood related, e.g. students living in one house. According to this concept, a single resident represents a household. As far as marketing is concerned, these individuals represent an important purchasing power that should be targeted. In light of the household concept, Wilkie defines the family as a group of two or more individuals who are related by blood or marriage or who share residence.(5) However defined, the family is responsible for making the economic decisions for its members. It is the consuming and spending unit in society, hence its significance for marketing research. From that perspective, let us concentrate on the concept of family as adopted by the present study, in terms of type and characteristics.
[B] Family types
Throughout his life, the individual generally associates with two types of family: birth family and marriage family.
(a) Birth Family
The birth family is where the individual is born and significantly affected. Socialization takes place through interaction within that family, where the child learns ways of living and dealing with others. When being educated by its parents, the child learns the family values and principles, which are expected to guide its behavior. In addition, the conduct of parents and relatives affects the child's behavior and conceptions of its environment. Basically, this type of family defines the child's values, beliefs and attitudes.(6)
162
Consumer Behavior
The marriage family has the direct and strongest influence on the individual purchasing behavior. Therefore, marketing gives it great attention. The structure of the marriage family implies much consumption of various products. For example, the family needs a house, furniture, kitchen utilities, cleaning equipment, airconditioners, and possibly a car. The bigger the family, the greater its demands are, hence the greater the purchases. The satisfaction of such needs necessitates dealing with several vendors.(7) The present study focuses on the marriage family, while taking into account the impact of the birth family on consumption behavior. The individual's behavior after marriage is influenced by the values, beliefs and concepts acquired while living with the birth family. There will be further details pertaining to family structure when dealing with ``Family Patterns'' and ``Family Life Cycle''.
[C] Family characteristics
Among the various family characteristics are the following : (1) The family is a social phenomenon basic to all societies. (2) The family undertakes the most significant social function social upbringing or socialization of the young. Through socialization, culture, with its customs, beliefs, etc., is passed on from one generation to another. The family is the source of norms and behavior. (3) It is the means of satisfying man's physical, social and emotional needs. (4) Unlike other institutions, the family has a unique way of assigning its members duties towards each other. This creates within them such a strong sense of belonging to the family that they cannot evade their obligations towards it. (8)
Consumer Behavior
163
Chapter 5
As the basic unit of the social structure in Saudi Arabia, the family is the core where individuals acquire behavior patterns and other qualities like boastfulness, vaunting one's lineage and tribal belonging. These provide the individual with a sense of stability and security. The extended family was the prevalent pattern in the Saudi society. Findings of various studies conducted on the Arabian Gulf area, including Saudi Arabia, indicated that in the period prior to oil exploration, 50% of families dwelled in the same vicinity, and were blood-related. This rate came down to 37% in the mid- seventies due to the tendency towards moving to cities and the separation of the offspring from parents to live independently. The Saudi society consists basically of three segments, Bedouin, rural and urban. This is reflected in family characteristics. Rural and Bedouin families are both complex and extended, due to widespread polygamy. As for the urban family, it is a nuclear one. Whereas there is a decline in the rate of polygamy and multiplicity of offspring (as an indication of power) in urban areas, rural and Bedouin communities still retain the same family pattern that once prevailed, as part of their social heritage. However, polygamy and multiplicity of offspring is apparently declining gradually in rural and Bedouin areas due to changing conditions, e.g. migration of Bedouin and village youth to cities for employment opportunities; contact with neighboring and foreign communities; modern economic patterns; and the government's assuming of security responsiblities throughout the country. Despite the presence of large numbers of Bedouins and rural migrants in cities, the urban family is predominantly nuclear (husband, wife and children). Until recently, the extended family was the most predominant pattern in the city. It underwent some changes due to changes in family relationship. This is attributed to
164
Consumer Behavior
(9)
The Saudi community is moving towards the city family pattern at the expense of the Bedouin and rural ones, as a result of migration to cities. While the Kingdom's population growth rate is around 3.7% per year, Riyadh's population grows at a rate of 8%. In addition, Bedouins and villagers are inclined to imitate urban living patterns, since their children, relatives and friends migrate and live in cities. The cultural change and its resultant socio-economic development in Saudi Arabia have contributed in various ways to changing the traditional family pattern, giving way to a modern one. This is typical of societies undergoing socio-economic changes, which entail structural and functional changes in the family. In the case of the Saudi society, the discovery of oil and the subsequent cultural and socio-economic changes have had long-term impact on the structure and functions of the Saudi family.
The following are the most important family changes: (10) (1) Family structure change
Various studies conducted on the Saudi family show tendencies towards the small family pattern and towards providing children with education and social care.
Consumer Behavior
165
Chapter 5
particularly in the family pattern. The extended family is declining, while the nuclear family pattern is gradually on the rise.
(4) Independent family residence
Saudi Arabian cities have been recently witnessing huge construction developments. Residential complexes comprising small units are replacing the separate house accommodating one large family. Also, on getting married, male adults are increasingly inclined to separate from their families.
(5) Expatriate manpower influence
Evidently, contact with foreign communities and the existence of expatriate manpower in the Kingdom have greatly impacted the family structure and functions. Their employment in homes, e.g. housemaids and governesses, has added a new dimension to the social relations inside the family, due to difference in languages, customs, beliefs and even religions. Research reveals that they have had long-term effects on the behavior of children, who acquire alien cultural patterns and habits. The employment of housemaids and governesses in homes of non-working mothers is explained in terms of indicating the employer's prestigious social status.
(6) Obstructive family values
Like other societies where social changes are taking place rapidly, the Saudi society encounters conflict of values between generations, the old and the new, due to the differences in experiences. Initially, the old generation is stronger, because of its cultural heritage and dominant values, customs and traditions, which can be obstacles to change.
166
Consumer Behavior
Nowadays, the assignment of roles and responsibilities among family members regarding financial support has changed in many societies. The traditional role of the father, as the family's source of income, and that of the mother, as a housewife taking care of the children, are no longer functional in maintaining a proper economic standard for the family. A high percentage of wives now hold jobs outside the home in order to contribute to family income, while many husbands participate in performing household tasks and taking care of children. For example, the husband in the Jordanian family is responsible for managing his family economic affairs, as he provides whatever the family needs, in the form of financial monthly allocations. In collaboration with the husband and grown-up sons, the wife allocates finances to the necessary spending aspects as dictated by priorities. The employment opportunities offered to the Jordanian wives has allowed them to contribute to family spending, particularly in the middle and low classes, due to the rising number of the two classes, and the increasing difficulties and social obligations.(12) Thus, the nature of financial support for the family has radically
Consumer Behavior
167
Chapter 5
changed in the last few years. The financial roles played by husbands and wives have markedly changed in the Arab Region including the Saudi society. A large percentage of married and single working women have joined the labour force and significantly impacted the consumer purchase decision-making (13) process in the family. 13 However, this attitude is still relatively confined to medium-income families.
(2) Emotional Support
The family provides social care and support to its members. This function is important for achieving their psychological stability, and healthy social relationships. This can be done in a variety of ways, the most important of which are participation and debate that help the individual overcome problems. If the family fails to perform this function properly, the psychological and social stability of its (14) members will not be achieved. 14 Thus, the family plays a vital role in providing its members with necessary moral support. This helps them overcome the personal and social problems facing them at successive stages of growth. No wonder, the absence of such support in some families creates a lot of psychological problems, affecting their personalities, and (15) posssibly leading to delinquency. 15 (3) Providing Proper Livelihood and Lifestyle The family, particularly parents, instill in the children living patterns and lifestyles through dealing with and directing them, and providing them with life experiences and aspirations, individual and collective. The family impact remains with the offspring, even after marriage, with respect to, for example, beliefs, attitudes, hobbies, aspirations, personal interests, recreational activities and (16) places. 16 Evidently, the lifestyle of a family influences its financial obligations, and is influenced by them. For example, the family lifestyle determines its living standard, which, in turn, determines
168
Consumer Behavior
its consumption patterns. These patterns determine the family's financial obligations. Finally, family resources influence both its financial obligations and lifestyle. For example, a middle class family may hold views that make it aspire to adopt a higher-class living standard. This family's
consumption patterns will definitely differ from those of its middle class counterparts that do not adopt the lifestyle of a higher class. The adoption of more ambitious consumer patterns on the part of the family will affect its financial obligations as a result of
involvement in some extraordinary activities like club membership, purchase of a PC and some software for domestic use, or traveling abroad for tourism. On the other hand, the family may decide to reduce some
unnecessary expenditure once it finds its financial obligations too high to balance its resources. This will definitely entail giving up some activities characteristic of higher-class segments, such as
traveling abroad for tourism or taking renowned club membership. Accordingly, increase in financial obligations could lead the family to change its lifestyle to `make ends meet'.
(1 7)
Adoption of a specific family lifestyle or pattern could extend to include time allocation, and consumption patterns. For example, the employment of a woman will inevitably affect the time she allocates to household duties and increase her
(18)
demand
for
Moreover, the
working woman is more inclined to retain economic and practical appliances that make her life easier.
modifies
and
redirects
behavior.
Therefore,
socialization
this
regard requires that parents set a good example in all culture related
Consumer Behavior
169
Chapter 5
activities since children often learn through perception and imitation (20) of the behavioral patterns they encounter. Socialization of children is considered one of the family's basic functions. It involves encouraging them to acquire the values and behavior norms of their society. This, in turn, implies personality development, change in dressing habits, ethics, job selection, etc. Such social skills could be acquired either directly through parental guidance, or indirectly through observing the conduct of parents and adults. Socialization is related to consumer behavior. Through the process of socialization, children acquire skills, knowledge and attitudes that help them behave like consumers. Many studies indicate that children acquire consumer skills from their parents at the early stage of life since they take their parents as a model of consumer behavior. Consumer socialization is also used by parents to modify the behavior of their children. They reward their children financially when they behave well and deprive them of some necessities if they misbehave. Also, parents pass consumer behavior to their children when they accompany them to the market for shopping, and when they assign them the duty of selecting and buying some materials, particularly those of interest to them. In this way, they teach their children the fundamentals of shopping and the ability to select from among various alternatives on the basis of economic considerations. In addition, they teach them to behave and think realistically and not to aspire to things beyond their financial capabilities, and to be ready to set a system of priorities in which less important desires are sacrificed for the sake of more important ones.
170
Consumer Behavior
aspect is not directly related to consumption, and it includes such aspects as feelings towards some commodities associated with a particular age stage, e.g. an adolescent's feelings when buying shaving razors for the first time. Though both aspects are considered important, researchers give more attention to the second aspect, for it helps interpret and forecast consumer behavior. Finally, behavior socialization is not limited to childhood, but it is a life-long process. For example, the early days of a newly wed couple constitute a socialization process of the new family because of the changes that take place in the consumption patterns of the (21) couple. In general, marketers design all marketing promotional incentives associated with the brands of goods or service in a way that best affects the attitudes of family members believed to be influential in (22) the purchase decision process.
Consumer Behavior
171
Chapter 5
and
(24)
this applies to all cultures. The nuclear family is sometimes called the ``simple family''; it is the foundation of complex families. Individuals normally experience known as the guiding family. two nuclear it, families in their they acquire the
lifetime. One is the birth family, in which they were born, and it is Through fundamental social values and concepts. The other type is the marriage family, for which the individual leaves his original family. In this new family, concepts already acquired from the original family are maintained, while new ones are acquired as a result of the new partnership.
(25)
172
Consumer Behavior
The extended family includes, in addition to a nuclear family, some blood relatives, such as grandparents or uncles.(26) ``Extended'' means that the family includes members of several generations, which, in turn, include a number of simple families. This is not due to polygamy, but to the existence of several families, belonging to sons and grandsons that are living within one context. Consequently, one individual can belong to two families, in each of which he plays a specific role and performs a distinctive function. For example, a boy is a son in his father's family; he is a husband and father in his own nuclear family, which he forms by marriage. This is different from the compound family, where belonging to two families does not entail any change in role or function. The husband is the husband of all his wives, and is the father of all his children from his wives.(27)
(4) The nest family
The nest family comprises a husband and a wife.(28) It is the early kind of family after marriage and before having children. It also includes the couple whose children have separated, forming a new family by marriage. In Western countries, ``the family'' refers to the nuclear or direct family, whereas the extended family is a feature of developing countries. In addition, family size influences the desired size of house, furniture and other items. It is administratively easy to transfer the father of a small family from one place to another locally or nationally, but it is difficult in the case of a big family. So, the effect of financial incentives in the case of big families is different from the case of small ones. The incentives are more effective when given to a small family. Family size also plays a significant role in determining the member to be entrusted with making the family's purchase decision. (29)
Consumer Behavior
173
Chapter 5
The following are the findings of a study conducted in Riyadh showing that fundamental differences exist between nuclear and extended families: (30)
1. Family type
The nuclear family constitutes two thirds of the sample size (69%), and the extended one constitutes one third (31%).
2. Education
The level of education of a nuclear family is higher than that of the extended family.
3. Working women
The percentage of working women is higher in the nuclear family than in the extended one.
4. Father's income
The father's average income is higher in the nuclear family than in the extended one.
5. House ownership
Nuclear families mostly live in apartments, whereas the majority of extended families live in villas or single buildings.
6. Age
D Father's age
The father's age category (31-50 years old) is high in the nuclear family, but the percentage of those below 31 and over 50 is high in the extended family.
174
Consumer Behavior
The mother's age is inversely related in the nuclear family category, whereas the percentage of those below 31 is high, but it is positively related in the Extended family.
D
Mother's age
The percentage of elders is lower in the nuclear family than in the extended one.
Percentage of elders
The average number of children is lower in the nuclear family compared to the extended one. The ratio of retired members is lower in nuclear families compared to extended ones.(31)
Managers attach much importance to the family life cycle because of the direct and strong impact its stages have on the family's consuming and purchasing behavior. Therefore, the marketing plan should be based on full perception of the nature, characteristics and needs of the target market at each stage.
At this stage, the consumer starts his life alone with a limited income. However, he does not assume any family obligations, so, his remaining net income is relatively high. The bachelor consumer spends part of his income on purchasing a car, basic furniture - if he lives away from his family - a lot of clothes and dining at restaurants. In addition, he spends a large amount of his earnings
Consumer Behavior
175
Chapter 5
Second: New marriage This stage is considered one the most financially demanding stage for the groom, particularly in the Saudi society. Gifts and financial donations by friends on the wedding day might reduce this financial burden. In the course of time the couple's financial state improves, particularly when the wife has a job. She spends a large part of her earnings on cars, clothes, journeys and other recreational activities. Typical of this stage is the highest rate of purchases, especially of durable items, compared to other family types. In addition, newly wed couples are mostly and promptly influenced by advertisements. Third: Complete marital home stage It is marked by the existence of the couple and children in the family and can be classified into three sub-phases as follows:
1. The first phase is characterized by the birth of the first child in the family. 2. The second phase starts when the youngest child is six years old. 3. The third phase is when children join the university. Let us deal with each of the above stages in some detail:
(1) The first phase of complete marital home It starts with the arrival of the first child. This may cause the mother to leave her job. Consequently, the family income will decrease, and new consumer problems will arise, calling for a change in the expenditure pattern. This stage continues until the youngest child reaches school age. At this stage, great care is given to furnishing the children's rooms and obtaining new electric appliances if not bought before, and many other things for house
176
Consumer Behavior
cleaning and maintenance purposes. Also, there is a growing demand for natural and processed infant milk, for drugs and for toys. The family is likely to think of buying a large car to accommodate the new family size. In these conditions, family savings decrease significantly due to the sums spent on the above items. Facing such pressing financial needs, the parents are likely to get worried.
(2) The second phase of the full marital home:
In this phase the youngest child should be six years of age, and all children will have joined school. The father's income is likely to rise, and the mother will have gone back to work. As a result, the family's financial position will improve, influencing the family consumption pattern, particularly regarding children's demands. For example, there will be increased purchases of foodstuff and cleaning materials, in addition to bicycles, electronic games and PCs.
(3) The third phase of the full marital home
In this phase, the eldest child will have joined the university. Also, the family's financial position will have been improving as a result of the increase in both parents' income and possible part-time employment of adults. The family will replace the old furniture, buy a new car and some electric appliances and spend a lot on children, particularly in education and dental care.
Fourth: Empty marital home:
The most common feature of this phase is the children's independence for reasons related to finance, new residence, marriage or employment. This phase can be divided into two subphases:
First sub-phase
Consumer Behavior
177
Chapter 5
employment. The family will be satisfied about its financial position and savings: parents work and children live separately in terms of spending and dwelling. The parents often make some changes and improvements at home, buy more property and spend a large part of their income on holidays, journeys and recreation.
Second sub-phase:
It starts with the father's retirement, and hence, both parents suffer a significant drop in income. Most spending is done on medical care as a result of getting older.
178
Consumer Behavior
(1) The family life cycle combines various important variables in one parameter: age, income, marital status and family size. (2) Because of the availability of the family size, income, and member jobs data available through the Census Department, marketing managers can readily use the family life cycle
(3) The life cycle's various stages are measurable. It is possible to determine, with a very high degree of accuracy, the number of families at each stage after having collected relevant data. (4) The cycle's main stages and sub-stages are so varied that it is possible to divide the whole market into distinctive segments in a scientific way. (5) Promotional messages can be sent through media to families at every stage.
Results of studies conducted on the family life style generally indicate the following:(34)
(1) There is a relationship between the family life cycle and family spending on energy, leisure time, services and food. (2) The family life cycle is a better indicator than father's age alone for forecasting expenditure on food, durable items, housing and family holidays. (3) There is a relationship between sports and recreational
activities and the family life cycle. Individuals do a lot of sports and recreational and new activities in the the stages of
bachelorhood
marriage.
During
parenthood
stage, parents devote a larger part of their time to children at the expense of these activities. (4) Changes that occur in the family like divorce, retirement, the death of one parent or the arrival of a new member often
Consumer Behavior
179
Chapter 5
results in spontaneous changes in the family's preference for brands. Finally, given the family as the basic unit of society, and as an important segment from the marketing point of view, its life cycle is an important typical analytical tool for marketing studies and plans.
180
Consumer Behavior
The function of pattern maintenance involves taking family decisions to preserve family values and reinforce dedication to these values among its members, and to deal with the tensions facing them. The family does that together with other institutions, such as education and the media, which contribute to the spread of values that help preserve the pattern. The preservation function encounters the problem of reconciling the family's social norms and any member's personal demands that may arise from belonging to some group. These demands may also arise from the multiple roles a family member has in society. For example, association with a particular club or group can result in the violation of social norms.
(2) Integration
The integration function means taking family decisions with the aim of defining and allocating each member's rights and duties. This involves the definition and assignment of such responsibilities as authority and finance. The decisions are meant to ensure
Consumer Behavior
181
Chapter 5
coordination and understanding among family members. The integration function derives from the unity of criteria (social values and norms) that guide the behavior of family members. Religious values and teachings are the most salient features that unite family members. In the case of Saudi Arabia, Islam is the religion from which values and norms are derived. Islamic values and norms are a guide to all aspects of daily life, and they are emphasized in the mass media and schools. In other words, Islamic teachings are the frame of reference for decision-making, including family decision-making.
(3) Goal Achievement
This function involves taking family decisions systematically in order to provide family members with social and material resources for the achievement of specific quality objectives sought by the family. The family needs to define its goals and the means to achieving them, as embodied in the family decision-making process. This is to be carried out by the concerned family members who strive to achieve the family interests and goals through their decisions. For example, a father may decide to send his children to a private school because it teaches foreign languages. Also, the parents may decide to save for building a new house to satisfy their needs.
(4) Adjustment
Adjustment is an important function in all social contexts, the family included. It helps in coping with the changes inside and outside the family context. This function is concerned with the family decisions for the acquisition of resources that can be utilized in meeting family demands. It includes such decisions as providing the wife with the opportunity to work. This enables her to earn an income, which can help satisfy her family's wants.
182
Consumer Behavior
Adjustment also takes place through marriage and reproduction, providing society with members to replace lost ones. It can also be achieved through the work of family members inside or outside the family context. They can make use of the surrounding resources to satisfy their needs, such as food, drinks and housing.
Consumer Behavior
183
Chapter 5
D D D
The son may be the initiative taker in buying a recorder. The husband may be the initiative taker in buying a car. The wife may be the initiative taker in buying a dish washer.
184
Consumer Behavior
This is done by the person who takes the final decision to buy the product or the brand in particular. The parents often share the decision-making authority. This depends on such factors as the nature and importance of the product, and the financial and moral authority each parent has within the family. When making a final decision, as a whole or in parts, the purchase decision maker has to answer to all or some of the following questions:(38) Will the product be bought or not? What will be bought? Will it be paid for in cash or installments? When will it be bought? From which sales outlet will it be bought?
4. Actual buying
This is done by the person who is directly involved in the act of buying the selected product. His role is limited to carrying out the decision already made, regardless of whether he has participated in decision-making or not. He is merely a tool that implements the decision made by the purchase decision taker. The findings of a study (39) conducted in Riyadh indicate that the husband in the Saudi family plays the main role in purchasing foodstuff. He does the buying in 76% of the cases, whereas the wife does it in 4%. The two parents share doing the buying in 12% of the cases. The whole family does the buying in 5%, and the housemaids in 3% of the cases.
5- Product use / Consumption
This role is done by the person or persons who use or consume the product. For example, in the case of purchasing household appliances, for example a refrigerator, all family members will be
Consumer Behavior
185
Chapter 5
the end users. In the case of clothes, each individual member is the end user of his own items. The end user may be the purchaser and decision-maker. For example, one person takes the decision to buy toothpaste, and then he does the buying and the consuming too. Also, the buyer may be different from the decision-maker and from the consumer, as in buying durable goods, which are to be used by more than one family member. Consider the following scenario:
D D D D D
One of the children may propose the purchase of a PC. Another child may persuade his parents to buy it. The father, mother or both may decide to buy a specific brand / from a specific vendor. The father may do the actual buying. The PC will be used by all family members.
The understanding and analysis of the above-mentioned roles help marketers promotion design the most for effective marketing and for programs the and campaigns individuals purchasing
process. As mentioned earlier, success demands that the role and influence of each family member regarding the purchase process be defined. Although one family member may play all or some of the roles in the purchase process, the most significant role is that played by the decision maker. Taking the purchase decision is considered the major role, on which other roles depend. It is worth the significance that marketing attaches to the consumer. In fact, it is the focus of all marketing activities.
186
Consumer Behavior
3. Common decisions
In this case, both the husband and the wife share making the purchase decision. In other words, they negotiate the purchase terms, such as the product type, price, vendor, method of delivery, etc. Good examples of these decisions are those concerned with travelling abroad for vacation and purchase of durable household appliances. After negotiation comes agreement between them.
4. Individual decisions
This type of decision provides freedom for each in making the purchase decisions independently, as in buying sweets or light tools for home use.
5.5.3 Factors Related to the Influence of Husband and Wife on Purchase Decision-Making
The influence of husband and wife in the purchase decision process depends on several factors. The following are some of them:
Consumer Behavior
187
Chapter 5
husband. So, he has more influence than the wife regarding gathering information on new cars, technical details, service and maintenance aspects and finalizing the deal. The wife used to be responsible for taking purchase decisions related to food, children's clothes, bedclothes and medicine.Today, the husband has begun sharing such decisions more than before. The wife, too, has a bigger role now in choosing the pharmacy to buy medicine from. There are some products the purchase decision of which is not completely in the hands of either spouse. According to one study,(41) the Saudi wife plays an important role in defining the family's basic food needs. She may do that on her own or with the rest of the family. The husband plays a big role in defining the family's non-basic food needs.
(b) The couple's attitudes towards roles
Families adopting couple equity tend to make the purchase decision on an equal footing as much as possible. Consultation between them is greater, while dispute is minimal. The family philosophy regarding the role of each spouse in financial and purchase decision-making is the outcome of a number of factors, which can be summed up in the following:
D The couple's education level
Published studies on the Saudi market indicate that a high level of education leads to the wife's increased participation in making purchase decisions. Also, the higher the Saudi father's education is, the more significant the wife's role in defining the family's food needs, and the more the couple do the purchasing together.
D The couple's values
Fundamental values vary from one society to another. Studies conducted on the consumers in developed and developing countries confirm that the roles played by men and women in
188
Consumer Behavior
purchase decision-making is related to the values they acquire from their society. For example, in Anglo-Saxon American families, common decisions prevail. In Mexican American families, the husband takes most of the purchase decisions. Also, husbands in developing countries largely take more independent decisions than their counterparts in developed countries.
D Family religion
The religion a family embraces greatly affects the purchase decision maker's personality. For example, fathers of pious Catholic families are said to have more influence than their wives on purchase decision-making. Also, husbands in Jewish and non-pious families let their wives take part in decision-making. In Islam, husbands are entrusted with the affairs of their families, including purchase decision-making, and wives can give advice and opinions within a context of mutual affection. Since consultation among Muslims is a command from Allah, it must be more deserving between husband and wife.
(c) Wife's employment The wife's employment has changed her traditional role in the family. Her role has become so different that it is not easy to predict which family member will buy a particular product. Undoubtedly, the employment, high educational level and increased income of Saudi women reinforce their participation in family decision-making. This does not necessarily mean the complete disappearance of the traditional roles of husband and wife. It indicates the increasing influence of women on decisionmaking.
According to the findings of a study on Saudi working women,(42) personal motives behind their employment appear stronger than material ones. The Saudi woman basically seeks to prove herself and achieve social prestige. Also, the higher her personal motives, the higher her education is. Her decision to work is not only meant
Consumer Behavior
189
Chapter 5
to occupy her leisure time, but to make good use of her education. The above findings emphasize the modern Saudi woman's desire to participate more in making family purchase decisions. Therefore, marketing managers should conduct studies regularly on how spouses allocate purchase responsibilities nowadays. The findings of another study on Saudi families show significant increase in wives' participation in making family purchase decisions. The findings include:
(43)
The Saudi housewife has a significant impact on making purchase decisions related to all the products the family needs. The children's influence on buying convenience products varies according to type, and it is almost lacking in the case of the durable goods.
Today, the husband plays a significant role in selecting the brands of household appliances, including the food products, which used to be the housewife's responsibility.
Finally, the available data indicate that the couple's participation in purchase decision-making varies according to the decision process phase and type of product. The roles played by the members of the modern Saudi family have undergone remarkable change over the past years. This is attributed to many factors. Girls' education rate is growing. The number of working wives is multiplying. In fact, some of them now have their own private companies. As women's contribution to the family financial obligations has increased, their participation in purchase decision-making wife. Findings of studies conducted on Saudi families confirm the above conclusions and indicate that some changes have recently occurred in the roles of men and women in the purchase decision-making process.
190
has
increased.
In
addition,
the
promotional
Consumer Behavior
The author of this book has conducted a study on the relative contribution of the Saudi family members to the decision-making of buying personal computers. Table (8) shows the study findings.
According to the findings, the father's role in all the buying stages is overwhelmingly dominant. It greatly surpasses the combined roles of the other family members in all the stages, with only limited exceptions. In no less than 55% of the cases, and sometimes reaching up to 80%, it is the father who does the following: collects information; proposes alternatives; chooses the buying time, brand, features, store and means of payment; makes the buying decision; pays the price; and actually does the buying.
Consumer Behavior
191
Chapter 5
This role goes down to 30% only in two situations: showing the need for the device and using it intensively. In these situations, other relatively important players, such as the children, mother or the whole family, gain some prominence in decision-making. The prominent role of the father may be due to the social and psychological role he plays in the Saudi family, whether in terms of how he sees himself as the family leader, or how the family members themselves see him as a leader. This central role of the father may have an impact on his dominant behavior. The Table also shows that the mother's participation has always been limited, except for showing the need for the device. In fact, she rarely takes joint decisions with the father - their joint role is not more than 2% to 3%. As for the children's role, it is clear at the stages of creating the need for the device and using it intensively, as individuals or as participants in the family. This role for the children is predictable since they generally do not interfere in the technological or economic aspect of the decision, except within the limits of creating the need for the device and satisfying it through its use. The father's dominance over making purchase decisions in most Saudi families that own PCs may be due to - in addition to what is previously mentioned - the following reasons: a. The father is still the main financial provider for the family the families with working mothers represent only 28% of the study sample. b. Given his educational, professional and social profile, the father is more exposed to the use of computers than the mother and the children. This makes his interest, and subsequently his role, more prominent. c. The mother may be more interested in the home
192
Consumer Behavior
management devices - e.g. the washing machine, vacuum cleaner, oven, mixer, and even television and video sets than in devices with complex professional, technological and scientific dimensions, such as PCs, which are not in her domain of interest. d. The Saudi male remains at the center of most family purchase decisions, especially those that require the collection of information from male-dominated markets, as in the case of cars, real estate, garden equipment, paints, medical devices, and computers. As for the female, it is easier for her to intervene in decisions that require relevant information from markets frequented by females. This is obvious in the case of clothes, perfumes, supermarket products, furniture and home appliances, and this is (44) what has been confirmed by a field study of the Saudi market. It is necessary to highlight the relative weight of the husband and wife in the decision to buy a PC. The study shows that there is an obvious behavior bias for the Saudi husband, against the wife in making the decision to purchase a PC. However, relevant literature on the same topic in the US shows that the wife's work outside the home does not necessarily result in (45) relieving her of any household chores . It also shows that equality of authority between husband and wife is not true. Though she may gain some power from the husband, but not enough to make her equal. Other studies show that in 33% of the cases the husband dominates the buying decisions in American families of Mexican origin. His role rises to 54% when buying a car. As for families of Anglo-Saxon origin, the whole family participates in the car buying decision in 66% of the cases. However, in both family types, collective decisions are taken when buying furniture, home appliances, housing, insurance, and the annual holiday.(46)
Consumer Behavior
193
Chapter 5
In brief, these results indicate the different roles played by the family members in terms of their relative participation in the purchase decision. The father's role is prominent, whereas the children's roles are limited, and the mother's is weak.
194
Consumer Behavior
Endnotes of Chapter 5
(1) (2) Al-Haaj, T. et. al.,
Ujaimy, Laila M. H., "The Role of the Makkan Wife in Decision-Making in Choosing Family Clothes and Accessories", The Girls' College of Education in Makkah, 1989, p.23.
Obaidat,
M. Principles of Marketing,
Ujaimy, Laila M. H., op. cit., p. 23. Wilkie, William L., Al-Musaa'id, Z. K., Ibid., p. 142. Al-Turky, S.A.,"
Decision-Making
the
Saudi
Family",
College
of
Social
Sciences, Imam Mohamed Ibn-Saud Islamic University, Riyadh, 1407H., p. 89. (9) Al-Khateeb, Fatima Abdullah, "Social and Cultural Changes and their Impact on the Urban Saudi Family", College of Arts, Alexandria University, 1995, pp. 105107. (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) Ibid., pp. 107-109. Obaidat, M. Ibid., p.42. Soliman, A., Obaidat, M. Soliman, A., Obaidat, M. Soliman, A., Ibid., p. 812. The Jeddah Chamber of Commerce Research Center,
Principles of Marketing,
Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice, Principles of Marketing, Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice, Principles of Marketing, Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice,
op. cit., p. 42. op. cit., p. 240. -
Obaidat, M.
among Saudi and non Saudi Women in the City of Jeddah, Principles of Marketing,
op. cit., p. 142. Ibid., p. 241. Ibid., p. 142. Soliman, A.,
Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice, The Role of the Makkan Wife in Decision Making,
-
Ujaimy, Laila M. H., "The Role of the Makkan Wife in Decision-Making", op.
Consumer Behavior
195
Chapter 5
cit., p. 26. (28) (29) (30) (31) (32) (33) (34) (35) (36) (37) (38) (39) Obaidat, M. Principles of Marketing, op. cit., p. 239. Ahmad, A. Abdurrahman, Introduction to International Business Management, Dar AlMirreekh for Publishing, Riyadh, 2001, p. 193. Al-Obaidi, I. M., "Factors Related to the Family Pattern in Riyadh", Gulf and
Arabian Peninsula Studies, Issue No. 81, Year: 21, 1996, pp. 23-95.
Soliman, A., Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice, op. cit., p. 216. Ibid., pp. 233-237. Ibid., pp. 241-242. Ibid., p. 242. Al-Turky, S.A.," Decision-Making in the Saudi Family", op. cit., pp. 103-107. Mohamed, M. F. and Abdul-Fattah, M. A, Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 41. Ibid., p. 42. Ibid., p. 42. Alawi, H. M., and Al-Misri, M. A., "Behavioral Characteristics of the Saudi Buyer at Self-Service Stores: a Field Study in Riyadh", Research Center, King Saud University, Riyadh, 1983, pp. 50-51. (40) (41) (42) Soliman, A., Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice, op. cit., pp. 222-226. Alawi, H. M., and Al-Misri, M. A., op. cit., pp. 50-51. Al-Nimr, S. M., "The Working Saudi Woman: a Field Study on a Sample of Working Saudi Women in Riyadh", Research Center, King Saud University, Riyadh, 1988. (43) (44) Soliman, A., op. cit., Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice, pp. 226-227. Qreitam, Abdulhadi, Abu-Rokba, Hassan, and Al-Eesawi, Ibrahim, ``The Saudi Family: Role and Change and their Impact on Decision-Making'', Research Center, College of Economics and Administration, King Abdul-Aziz University, Jeddah, 1401 H. / 1981. (45) (46) Pleck, Joseph H., Working Wives/Working Husbands, Sage Publications, Beverley Hills, 1986, p. 15. Imperia, G., "Family Purchasing Decisions Among Mexican and Anglos", Ph.D. dissertation, The University of Texas at Austin, 1982, p. 219.
196
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 6
Psychological Factors Aecting the Purchase Decision
Chapter Topics
6.1 Motives 6.2 Learning 6.3 Perception 6.4 Personality
Many studies in the field of behavioral sciences have dealt with the internal factors that shape human behavior. With respect to the consumer, specialized studies have extensively covered the factors pertaining to purchasing behavior. They show that the individual's purchasing choices are influenced by a number of psychological factors. This chapter will deal with the following psychological factors: (1) motives; (2) learning; (3) perception; and (4) personality. They are frequently used by researchers and marketing personnel in the field, when describing, explaining and predicting consumer behavior.
Consumer Behavior
199
6.1 Motives
Identifying motives of behavior is considered the first step in the analysis of human behavior in general. Motives pinpoint the underlying causes of behavior. There are various definitions of the term ``motive''. The following are some of them:
6.1.1 Definition
The motive is generally defined as ``the internal energy that drives a person to behave in a certain way in order to achieve a certain objective.''
(1)
needs and desires that he has to satisfy by acting in a certain way. In relation to the consumer, motives are defined as ``the internal forces that make the consumer act in a purposeful way.''
(2)
Motives are sometimes defined as ``the individual's internal needs, wants and instincts, which drive him consciously or unconsciously.'' Being internal, they differ from incentives, which are considered external stimuli. Incentives ``refer to the rewards that the individual expects as a result of doing his job.'' They can be material or non-material rewards, normally in the form of increased authority or promotion.
(3)
In his theory on motives of behavior, Freud maintains that ``every human behavior has a motive, conscious or unconscious, and therefore, has a purpose to reach.''
(4)
Thus, the motive is considered the hidden force which initiates behavior, provides it with energy, reinforcement, and directs or even stops it. It is also considered the link between the need and response, i.e. the need and the behavior of the consumer. This implies that marketers have to identify consumers' motives and understand motivation.
(5)
their
motivational
behavior
and
responses
to
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 6
certain tension and reach the state of balance, which the individual seeks in all daily activities. The human nervous system does not endure the tension arising from feeling that the actual satisfaction is less than the desired satisfaction. Therefore, the system spontaneously seeks to get rid of all types of tension, physiological or psychological, resulting from unsatisfied needs. Thus, such tension acts as a motive that drives the individual in the direction of need satisfaction. Once satisfaction occurs, the state of tension is removed and is replaced by a state of ease. In that sense, the motive is considered a system of tension arising from the movement of the individual in a certain direction in order to (6) remove tension and achieve satisfaction. For example, hunger is some kind of tension in the human body due to lack of necessary nutrition, and it represents a motive for searching for food in order to reduce tension and reach a state of balance. As the founder of the modern school of human psychology, (7) has put forward a theory of motivation based Abraham Maslow on needs, arranged into his well known hierarchy of needs. The following are its basic assumptions: 1. 2. 3. Human needs are numerous and varied. The motive results from an unsatisfied need. Once satisfied, the need does not create a motive. Needs have an ascending hierarchical system, whereby the human being does not feel the needs at the second level until the first level needs are satisfied. This applies to all the five hierarchical levels. Social circumstances tend to obstruct the fulfillment of a lot of human needs. Such unfulfilled needs remain a major motivation of behavior. The environment is considered an extremely crucial factor in identifying which needs are effective for the individual at a
4.
5.
202
Consumer Behavior
certain time. For example, in the technologically and socially advanced countries, physiological and security needs are satisfied to a great extent. There, social needs and the needs for recognition and self realization are the prime movers of human (8) behavior.
Figure (9), below, represents a hierarchy of needs put forward by (9) Maslow.
According to Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs , the first level represents the physiological aspects of life's basic needs, such as home, clothing and food. Therefore, when hungry, the individual will focus on nothing but hunger. Once hunger is satisfied, the motive of hunger satisfaction ceases to be the individual's main aim, and then emerges another motive, namely, security need. When the individual feels insecure, his attention is not directed to satisfying other needs, such as his social status. For instance, when people buy anti-burglary alarms, they do not mean to satisfy the need for social prestige. So, it would be unwise to promote the alarms, claiming that they achieve some kind of social prestige. The third level of needs represents the need for belonging, which results from surrounding social pressure. Therefore, marketers
(10)
Consumer Behavior
203
Chapter 6
should
not
neglect
linking
their
marketing
programs
to
the
individuals or groups whose behavior the public approves and seeks to imitate. The fourth level in the hierarchy represents the needs for
recognition and achievement of a social status. By satisfying these needs, the individual gains a sense of competency and selfconfidence. If they are not satisfied, he feels useless and worthless. It may be claimed that the need for a social status is not that important. The fact of the matter is that the satisfaction of the first three levels of need is necessarily followed by the desire to attain social prestige, which emerges as a strong social motive for buying a lot of products and services. However, social prestige differs in definition from culture to culture and from market to market. This demands that marketers do their utmost to identify indicators of social status for a particular public or market. Reaching the top level of needs, self realization, means that the individual has already achieved a lot throughout his life: enjoys a high level of respect and recognition; relies on his achievements; is known, loved and valued by others; and may have reached a good state of security, protection and health. Even though the majority of people do not often attain self realization, many believe or are convinced they have reached it. This level, as Maslow believes, cannot be completely attained, for the individual becomes driven by abstract values, such as beauty, justice and truth. In addition, the individual's aspirations for self-realization have no limits. However, real life shows more flexibility than Maslow's Hierarchy; the individual seeks to fulfill needs at various levels simultaneously. It would be practically impossible to have rigid levels of needs, and rarely would an individual ever wait till all his needs at one level are satisfied in order to move to the next one.
(11)
Maslow's Hierarchy has not been taken for granted. It has been a controversial topic in behaviorist psychology. Yet, it has provided a recognized
204
view
with
considerable
importance
for
studying
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
205
Chapter 6
6.1.3 Motive Functions
The following are three functions of motives: 1. Activating behavior. It is an internal state resulting from an imbalance and need for a particular thing or expectation. 2. Directing behavior. Motives direct the individual's behavior towards a specific target that is defined and reinforced. 3. Stabilizing Behavior. By reinforcing a particular behavior, the motive can stabilize it.(14)
6.1.4 Categories of Consumer Motives (15)
Categories of consumption motives vary due to the varied parameters of classification. The following are four major categories.
6.1.4.1 Physiological /Biological and Psychological Motives
[A] Physiological / Biological Motives
They result from biological needs, such as those for oxygen, food and sleep. They are determined by the body, yet they are affected by specific social and cultural conditions. Each type of food has nutritional value for the body, but the choice of type depends on social considerations and individual taste. Not all types of food are acceptable in all societies, nor are they compatible with all tastes.
[B] Psychological Motives
They result from the needs created by the individual's social context. They start in childhood, as the child feels the need for its parents. The older it grows, the more aware it becomes of surroundings, and the greater the needs it develops for success and acquisition of knowledge necessary for social prestige.
206
Consumer Behavior
They include the purchase reasons related to the expected material performance of the product. They rely on logic and reason rather than emotions. Price, effectiveness and reliability of the product are examples of rational motives, which are typical of purchasing industrial products.
Rational motives are evident in the following cases:
D D
The consumer establishes product priorities after having investigated the importance of each product and its potential to bring about the desired satisfaction. The consumer selects the brand after having compared the advantages and disadvantages of available brands. The consumer chooses a potential store to buy from after having compared the advantages and disadvantages of several stores.
They are the reasons related to psychological and social aims of the purchasing process. They are not subject to logical reasoning. Instead, they follow a particular emotion, such as love for appearances and boasting. However, some argue that buying things for the purpose of boasting is not necessarily an emotional decision, but a rational one, for it aims at satisfying one's need for recognition and respect.
Emotional motives are evident in the following cases:
The consumer determines product priorities without rational investigation or consideration of his financial state. He is only imitating his neighbors or acquaintances, or expressing love for appearances and boasting.
207
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 6
The consumer selects the brand or model without comparing available alternatives. He chooses it only because he likes its shape, appearance or color. D The consumer deals with any shop without investigation of its advantages and disadvantages in comparison with other shops. Thus, if based on investigation and analysis of available alternatives, the consumer's behavior is considered rational. If not, i.e. if based only on impulse, it is considered emotional. However, the consumer may establish product priorities rationally while selecting the model on an emotional basis. Such behavior is the result of a mixture of rational and emotional motives. Emotional motives, as some studies suggest, are associated mostly with women's purchasing behavior, whereas rational motives mostly with men's. This finding is not true for all men and women. There are women whose behavior is predominantly rational, and there are men whose behavior is predominantly emotional.
D
The following factors are said to contribute to the rational and emotional classification of motives:
D D D
the consumer's level of income in general, men or women; the consumer's level of education; and the material value of the product to be bought.
They drive the consumer to buy a particular product or set of products regardless of brand or shop. If the consumer does that, his motive is said to be primary. For example, a family feels the need for a car, and the head of the family decides to buy one without determining type or make. In this case, the decision is the
208
Consumer Behavior
result of primary purchasing motives, such as economy in fuel consumption and availability of spare parts.
[B] Selective Motives
They make the consumer select a particular type or brand that satisfies his basic needs. The type or brand may possess certain advantages, such as popularity, size and price. In general, selective motives follow primary ones. Therefore, marketing efforts should target those with primary motives for purchasing a particular product, while giving preference to the selection of a particular type or brand rather than another.
[C] Patronage Motives
Patronage motives drive the consumer to choose a particular store or shopping center to buy from. His choice is based on certain qualities characteristic of that store. Such qualities include reputation, good service, reasonable prices, suitable sale conditions and the availability of a wide range of goods. Therefore, businesses normally seek to establish a particular image in the consumer's mind regarding their reputation, and quality of service as well as unique sale incentives. Among the incentives are a wide range of selections, good prices and additional services, such as home delivery and post-sale maintenance.
6.4.1.4 Conscious and Unconscious Motives
Some motives of behavior are obvious, whereas others are not, and are, therefore, difficult to identify. In terms of their awareness of their purchase motives, consumers are classified into the following three sets. (A) The first set includes the consumers who are aware of their purchase motives and express them clearly. It is easy for marketers to define the motives of that set, and consequently can deal with them easily. However, the consumer cannot
Consumer Behavior
209
Chapter 6
define the relative importance of each motive, and, therefore, cannot define which one has more influence on his purchasing decision. (B)The second set includes the consumers who are aware of their purchase motives, but they do not admit them. They give unreal excuses and analyses for their purchasing behavior. By so doing, consumers mean to hide their real motives, believing that the motives are not acceptable to others. They may also believe that they reveal personal traits that should preferably be hidden. For example, price is an important factor to most consumers. Yet, that type of consumer feels somewhat shy when dealing with money matters. For example, if asked, he may give a motive other than price as the most important one in determining his choice of product. He often tends to ``rationalize'' some emotional motives that drive him to a particular behavior, thinking they are socially unacceptable, or will show him different from what he likes to be seen. In general, each individual seeks to give rational justifications for his behavior. (C) The third set contains the consumers who do not know their real motives for buying; the motives are in their subconscious, and they are not aware of them. For example, when buying clothes, the consumer may be aware that the material quality is good, the price is suitable and people will admire them. Yet, he may not be aware that he is buying the clothes to imitate others or look distinct. The second and third sets represent a problem for market researchers concerned with defining the real motives of buying. It is not possible to know the consumers' real motives by asking them. On the one hand, the consumer may be aware of his motives, but tends to hide them, or give other motives. On the other hand, he may not be aware of the motives at all.
210
Consumer Behavior
Thus, the importance of motive-related research lies in attempting to identify why the consumer behaves in a certain way. In other words, they ``are concerned with identifying real reasons or motives underlying the consumer's behavior.''(16) Motive-related research has several names. It is popularly known as psychological consumer research. It is also called intensive interview research, as it makes use of in-depth interviews. It is defined as the study of the relationship between the consumer's personality and the product's traits. In fact, some view motive-related research as the use of the investigative techniques of psychology, seeking insight into the human psyche in order to identify consumers' motives. Among the several techniques it uses are intensive interviews and sentence completion. However, unlike psychology, motive-related research does not aim at any psychoanalysis or treatment of the consumer. It aims at identifying the motives of consumer behavior and exploring direct and indirect means by which the marketer can control, change or modify the motives, using modern marketing methods. For instance, through motive-related research, the researcher may identify the consumer's favorite color of a product. Then, marketing management can make use of only that piece of information in decision-making, without having to look deeper into causes of the consumer's choice of that particular color. In addition, motive-related research does not seek to identify a particular consumer's motives, but to gather information on the behavior motives of groups of consumers.(17) In general, motives are determined by internal or external stimuli. Underlying the motive can be a need the consumer himself feels, e.g. hunger. The stimulus can be external, and it is known as the incentive, where conditions outside the consumer create a motive within him for something. The advertisement is an example of such
Consumer Behavior
211
Chapter 6
conditions - this will be dealt with in detail later. When the motive is reflected on a particular behavior, the latter is determined partially by external conditions and partially by internal conditions. Also, each individual consumer has a unique mixture of motives, which influence his purchasing behavior in a variety of ways in various situations. The consumer may not know which of his motives has had the strongest influence on the purchase decision. An influential motive in one situation may have less influence, as it is replaced by another. Sometimes, one motive can be satisfied by varied behaviors, and various motives can lead to one type of behavior. Motive-related research benefits the development of realistic ideas for promotion campaigns, by approaching the consumer's consciousness and stimulating latent needs positively. It can also contribute to the modification or development of a new product brand, through the feedback from consumers towards ideas for new brands, or innovative designs for visual advertisements and printed matter. Done prior to making the new product and launching its promotional campaign, such activities help avoid possible costly mistakes. In addition, research provides practical implications and parameters for quantitative marketing studies that can be (18) conducted on larger samples representative of the target market. The reasons behind buying a PC can be grouped in two categories: (a) internal motives related to the family making the purchase decision; (b) external motives, incentives provided by PC marketers to persuade the decision-maker to buy such ``an important'' product. Table (10) shows means reflecting the importance of the reasons for purchasing a PC in general.
212
Consumer Behavior
As shown in Table (10), when the sample members, including those who owned a computer and those who did not, were asked about the reasons for buying home computers, it became clear once again that quality and price were the two factors that prompted buying among a large majority. Then, there were the factors of post-sale service as well as balancing the wishes of the family members relative to the features required in the device. As for other factors, such as the place of purchase, the terms of sale and the sales agent's style, they were next, although they were still important for some. Regarding purchasing incentives, including advertisments, gifts and discounts, they were at the bottom of the list, even though they too were important factors in the purchasing operation. The above results should lead home computer marketers to know those consumers' motives, and to design a set of appropriate marketing strategies to persuade them to buy. First among these strategies would be a strategy for product development, pricing,
Consumer Behavior
213
Chapter 6
competition, post-sale services, and the information that helps to make a good choice. It is also necessary to design programs of marketing communication with the clients through these incentives in a way that guarantees positive interaction between consumers and marketers.
214
Consumer Behavior
6.2 Learning
All consumer behavior comprises the responses the individual acquires through learning. He acquires knowledge of available types of products and their brand names and prices by experience. A lot of his ideas, beliefs and views are the result of learning. He may learn from family and friends, academic institutions or the social context at large, including all types of media. Learning can be defined as ``the process of changing the individual's responses as a result of experience or training.'' This definition does not apply to temporary changes in responses to temporary stimuli, such as the effect of medications. Learning is concerned with long-term changes. In that sense, learning refers to the change(19) in behavior as a result of previous experiences in similar situations. Learning is also defined as ``all the procedures by which current patterns of behavior are changed and new ones are developed.'' (20) From the marketing point of view, learning can be defined as ``all the regular and systematic procedures and processes - intentional as well as unintentional - of providing the individual with the knowledge and information he needs for buying something available now or in the future.'' This definition implies that learning takes place through stages or processes, and involves continuity and change. Also, learning can be intentional or accidental, and it can occur through reflection, observation and (21) practical experience.
6.2.2 Learning Concepts 6.2.1 Definition
Chapter 6
thought. One considers learning as knowledge, and the other considers it as behavior. Let us examine each view in brief.
on
the
logical
analysis in
of
alternatives,
take
necessary
decisions
various
view is assuming that the consumer will go for the product on the basis of his previous level of satisfaction and on the basis of his knowledge that the product is the best in comparison with others. A number of approaches follow that view, such as those based on the studies of Kohler, a Gestalt psychologist. some of those approaches.
(23)
216
Consumer Behavior
a reflection of his past experience. Accordingly, if the consumer's previous experience of a particular brand is negative, e.g. his previous PC was not of the desired quality, it will affect his current purchase decisions; he is likely to avoid the same brand. Not only the negative experiences, but also the positive ones play a part in determining current and future direction of the consumer's behavior.
(C) The contextual pressure approach
According to this approach, the behavior of the individual is the end product of all the pressures on him at one particular point. The pressures on one person vary from time to time. They also vary from one person to another. The pressures can be economic, social, environmental, etc. They include a person's hopes, aspirations and desires. All those pressures affect his behavior, which changes when they do. This means that a particular stimulus does not necessarily bring about the same response at all times. Responses vary according to the strength or weakness of the various pressures on (24) For example, an the individual at that particular point. advertisement on air conditioners is likely to have a greater response from the same viewers during the summer time than the winter time. This is attributed to the change in pressures on the viewer, i.e. the change in weather conditions.
6.2.2.2 Learning as behavior
This view focuses on the stimulus and the response, and considers learning as associations between them. It does not consider situations or internal mental factors to have great effect on learning. The following are two approaches adopting that view: (a) the stimulus-response approach; and (b) the reward-punishment approach.
(A) The stimulus-response approach
Consumer Behavior
217
Chapter 6
physiologist Ivan Pavlov. It maintains that learning occurs when the individual is exposed to a particular stimulus and responds to it. If the stimulus is repeated, the response is repeated too, as there is a connection between them. Developing his pioneering experiments, Pavlov tried to generalize their underlying concepts, emphasizing the relationship between behavior and the nervous system. Other researchers tried to apply that learning approach to human behavior. Analysis reveals that this approach has four main elements: 1. An internal driving force ranging from a physiological need to a good social position or reputation. 2. A stimulus originating from the external environment and affecting the individual's response to the driving force, such as advertisements. 3. Response to the stimuli coming from the external environment. 4. Reinforcement of positive responses, leading, in turn, to repeating the response or behavior if the stimulus is repeated, resulting in habit formation. Marketers can benefit from the stimulus-response approach in a variety of ways. For example, attention should be focused on strong external stimuli.(25) As the approach emphasizes repetition and stimulus-response proximity in space and time (26), advertisements of a particular product should be put where it is being sold. Also, the advertisement's desired benefit can be realized if the product is available while the advertisement is on.
(B) The instrumentalist approach
This approach is based on the research findings of B. F. Skinner(27), the behaviorist psychologist, who observed that the behavior of an organism depended generally on its results in terms of reward or punishment. If a particular behavior is rewarded, it will stay on and
218
Consumer Behavior
grow strong till it becomes a habit. Similarly, if the behavior results in punishment, it will eventually stop. In other words, behavior reinforcement, positive or negative, is the major factor in determining its growth or extinction. The reward is either material (28) For example, if the consumer responds to a or non-material. particular stimulus (an advertisement), but the product he buys turns out to be not as good as expected, he feels dissatisfied and unsettled. In this case, learning is negative. Learning also occurs if the same right response is given to the same stimulus.
Stimulus-Response-Related Concepts
Related to the stimulus-response approach are the following concepts: 1. Motive. It is a strong internal need or tension that drives the individual to perform a particular act, as when one feels hot weather. Stimulus. It is an external incentive in the organism's context, and it determines the type of response and how and where behavior occurs, as in the case of advertising electric fans or air conditioners. Response. It is the reaction to the connection between the motive and the stimulus, as in the case of acting towards buying an air conditioner in response to an advertisement so as to satisfy the need for getting rid of heat. Reinforcement. It is what occurs if the result is satisfactory and right. For example, if the air conditioner is satisfactory, works efficiently and its quality is high, the consumer is likely to prefer it to other brands in future purchases, or recommend it to others. Reinforcement is said to have occurred when the satisfactory response is repeated in reaction to the stimulus, i.e., when the association occurs between the stimulus and the
2.
3.
4.
Consumer Behavior
219
Chapter 6
(29)
response.
consumer, it can deny him the opportunity of better or cheaper alternatives. There is also the risk of missing the advantages of alternative brands. Regarding the marketer, loyalty to a particular brand denies competitors the opportunity to increase their share in the market and to attract consumers away from that brand.
(30)
Brand loyalty has various forms, among which are the following: 1. Emotional loyalty. It is attachment to the product quality in terms of uniqueness and potential remembrance and the pressures it exerts on the consumer. All these drive him to try the product. Marketers try to build good reputation for their
220
Consumer Behavior
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
brands and improve their image through regular revision of their market position. Name loyalty. It represents loyalty to a particular name that is associated with consumers' respect and that becomes part of them, as in the case of loyalty to National appliances. This type of loyalty protects the brand from attack, yet it needs management wise enough to control long-term expansion. Distinctive Quality Loyalty. It reflects the link between consumer loyalty and the perceived value of certain distinctive qualities of the product. Easy learning and use are examples of this type of loyalty. Therefore, the only way to win customers' future loyalty is to make them try the product. Association loyalty. It results from the consumer's feeling that keeping buying particular products gives him additional advantages he cannot get from buying varied products. This is common in the case of convenience products and services, and in the relationship between wholesale and retail dealers. However, this type of loyalty can be easily grabbed by competitors. Cost-return loyalty. According to it, the consumer will remain loyal to the brand so long as the cost of choosing another alternative does not have a suitable return. An example of this type of loyalty is that to a particular type of bank or computer. In this case, it is easy for competitors to attract consumers so long as there are sets of policies to facilitate buying and reduce the costs of brand transfer. Long-term familiarity loyalty. It is the result of the accumulative stability of the name or components of a particular product for a long time as a result of familiarity with use. Examples are the cola brands (Pepsi-cola and Coca-cola), certain types of soap, industrial detergents and home electrical appliances. Regular promotional efforts have a direct impact on fixing loyalty.
221
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 6
7. Comfort loyalty. It derives from making the purchase convenient and comfortable for consumers. Examples of this type are making products available at places near consumers, and distributing them through the telephone. This type of loyalty can be destroyed if competitors increase sales-outlets and raise the standard of their services. (31)
222
Consumer Behavior
6.3 Perception
The way the consumer perceives things affects his decisions. It starts with the perception of an encountered problem or situation, and concludes with the perception of how successful he is in choosing the potential solution. To understand the role perception plays in determining consumer behavior, marketers have to know the following: characteristics and secondary operations of perception; the factors affecting consumer perceptions; and the factors leading to changing them. (32)
6.3.1 Definition
A person is said to have perceived something if he translates and transfers it from the external physical world to the internal mental one. In other words, he gives the stimulus he gets through his five senses a meaning based on his previous experience. Perception is defined as ``the feeling, selection and interpretation of the stimulus which the consumer receives from the external world.'' (33) It is also defined as ``the process of organizing, and comprehending the information and sales incentives received through the five senses.'' (34) From a marketing point of view, perception is considered the process of forming mental impressions in response to a particular object within the background knowledge of the consumer, who gives a lot of meaning to what he sees and observes. The meaning he gives depend on his personal experience, beliefs and memory.
6.3.2 Perception Factors
Chapter 6
(A) Stimulus characteristics
They include material characteristics of the stimulus, such as size, color and movement. In this regard, marketers are concerned with identifying which of the product characteristics attracts the consumer's attention more. Since marketers can control the characteristics that help perception, their job is to reinforce it.
(B) Consumer characteristics
They refer to the workings of the consumer's physical and cognitive system on the perceived stimulus and on how it is perceived. The perception of one particular thing differs from person to person, for a person's beliefs, thoughts and impressions come from his background and experience with the thing itself. Also, perception varies in terms of clarity and complexity. Some people's impression of something may not be clear, while others' may be clearer. People can be compared in terms of the number, accuracy and complexity of their perception dimensions. (35) It can be said that consumer characteristics differ from one person to another, and they include several factors, such as experience, needs memory, personality, health, intelligence and observation. All these characteristics interact with those of the material stimulus, resulting in perception. For example, on watching a TV advertisement, the consumer receives with his own eyes and ears the visual and audio material waves from the TV set. Then, they are sent to the brain, which uses memory in interpreting the images, words and music in order to perceive and know their meanings. The perceived meanings may be different from the actual stimulus characteristics. Receiving images and sounds represents sensing, the first step of perception. The interpretation of the sensation by the brain with memory's help represents the second and essential step. Interpretation adds new meanings derived from the individual's own background and experience.
224
Consumer Behavior
Thus, perception comprises sensing and interpreting. Sensing includes the physiological and nervous operations, by means of which information goes to the perceptive system via the five senses. As for interpreting, it involves mental operations of registering, classifying, analyzing and interpreting information in order to form meanings, concepts and impressions; these may differ from reality, and they result in a behavioral response. For example, some consumers may consider a particular shop to be distinct and better than other shops, whereas other consumers consider it ordinary. A third set of people may consider it very bad. Thus, even though the same shop is the object being received through the consumers' senses, each consumer perceives it in his own way under the influence of his particular needs, motives, educational and cultural background and previous experience. (36)
6.3.3 Sense Perception
The relationship between sensing and interpreting, as described above, is known in psychology as sense perception. It has three elements, which can be summed up as follows:
1. Selective perception
According to it, consumers perceive stimuli around them in such a selective way that suits their needs, views and previous experiences as well as their demographic and psychological characteristics. Selective perception, thus, explains why two individuals or more differ in their perception of one stimulus.
2. Sense perception organization
Most consumers encounter tens of stimuli in one day. This makes the consumer organize the flow of stimuli to suit his needs, objectives and priorities. There are several principles that help the consumer arrange or organize the stimuli he receives via various senses. The first principle involves the classification of incoming information into sets, facilitating information processing faster and
Consumer Behavior
225
Chapter 6
more effectively. The second principle involves the integration of stimuli; the consumer perceives varied stimuli, from a variety of sources, as one integrated whole. This comprehensive view of things has implications for advertising. A particular advertising message should represent an integrated whole, comprising the picture with its information and interacting elements, towards achieving the desired effect.
3. Interpreting and organizing selected stimuli
These processes rely on the consumer's beliefs, and mental and psychological abilities as well as his previous experience and present (37) goals.
6.3.4 Perception Process
Due to the great speed of the perception process, it is very difficult to divide it into distinct phases. Obviously, all decision theories do not deal with facts, but with how the consumer perceives these facts. For example, the concept of risk reduction is concerned with how the consumer perceives the risks associated with the purchase (38) decision and its consequences. The consumer may face a number of risks, the most important of which are those related to performance, body, finances, social conditions, psychological conditions and time. The degree of risk differs from consumer to consumer. Some have great readiness for risk, and their risk degree is high. There are those who do not care about financial risks. There are also those who do not care about bodily risks, such as mountain climbers and race drivers. Social risks may matter little to some people who dress differently despite their social affiliation. Also, risk degree differs from one set of products to another. Naturally, some sets are generally high-risk products, and this explains the differences in the consumer's assessment of purchase risk. For example, risk involved in buying a car is higher than in buying a book, as the former
226
Consumer Behavior
includes most types of risk, which may have a negative effect on the consumer.
(39)
perception process definition, three phases can be identified. They are: (a) sensing external stimuli; (b) selection and focus on a
particular stimulus; and (c) interpreting the stimulus and giving it meaning.
them, he can be described as relatively insensitive. In fact, his total perceptions are only a small fraction in comparison with the
potentials of other creatures in the same environment. For example, some animals can hear sounds that man cannot because their wave frequency is beyond the ability of the human ear. Psychophysics reveals how limited the five senses are with regard to realizing minor differences that may exist in the characteristics of the products the consumer normally buys. Very often, the taste or smell of a food product changes, yet the change is too slight to notice. This has important implications for the marketers who are concerned with how the consumer perceives changes in product characteristics, and with the resulting changes in his behavior.
Consumer Behavior
227
Chapter 6
[B] Stimulus selection and focus
Both stimulus characteristics and personal factors are important for attracting and directing attention. On the one hand, the stimulus with distinct characteristics can halt other intellectual and information operations occurring in the perceptual system. Such a stimulus is capable of changing focus of attention. On the other hand, personal factors are simultaneously prepared to receive that type of stimulus. Therefore, the stimulus spontaneously becomes the focus of attention. Suppose there is one person in a group of people at a party, and they are talking aloud. He is busy talking to a friend. All of a sudden, amidst the crowd and noise, someone in a corner utters the person's name. At that point, his perceptual system spontaneously takes the direction of the place or individual who has uttered his name. Then, he may either talk to him or ignore the matter and continue his original conversation. The previous example shows the stimulus with the important characteristic (the person's name) is able to dominate all other stimuli in the person's context. It attracts his attention because his perceptual system is ready and prepared to pay attention to the name. The example also shows that attracting the attention and retaining it are two independent operations. While the stimulus characteristics and the personal factors work for attracting attention, the personal factors have a stronger impact on attention retention. This is evident in the case whether to follow up the utterance of the name or to ignore it. Regarding the consumer's perception, selection is a sensitive issue. While shopping, the consumer comes across a lot of products and brands. He also notices a large number of advertisements, audio, visual or written. Naturally, he would not be able to perceive such a great deal of stimuli. Therefore, his sense system allows him to receive a certain amount of the stimuli while ignoring the rest.
228
Consumer Behavior
Thus, he selects only a portion of the stimuli for perception. This explains why each advertiser competes hard to have his own message, rather than others', continuously remembered by the receiver. This demands marketers to realize the importance of making their products distinct, having the type of characteristics that can interrupt other mental operations occurring in the consumer's perceptual system. They also have to make the shape and name so attractive that they can get the most attention compared to the tens of competitive products. No wonder, there are a lot of strange advertisements and methods of promotion, unique designs and unfamiliar names. All these things show how hard marketers compete for the consumer's attention. They try to make their product's name, image and brand create a special impact on his mind. Each wants the consumer to focus on his own product, thus denying others the opportunity of attention.
[C] Stimulus interpretation
When the consumer senses a stimulus, he makes an effort to interpret it, i.e. to give it some meaning. The stimulus is selected from among large numbers of stimuli received by the senses. Having selected some stimuli, he puts them into homogenous groups, and then tries to interpret them. The consumer's interpretation derives from his past experience, memory, values, beliefs and several other personal factors. They play an important role in defining the meaning of the received stimulus in the consumer's mind. However, the given meaning may not be the same as the received stimulus. This has important implications for the marketer. He should present his product in such a way that it can have an interpretation compatible with his interest and desire to give a suitable impression about his product.(40)
Consumer Behavior
229
Chapter 6
Unlike the earlier views, maintaining that perception is the result of two factors, stimulus characteristics and the individual's characteristics, the Gestalt view (42) adopts an integrated approach. According to Gestalt psychology , perception and behavior are to be studied from the perspective of the organism's response to integrated units or images, forming a functional whole with characteristics that cannot result from the parts individually. Gestalt psychology also emphasizes the equivalence of psychological and physiological acts, while denying the breaking down of(43) stimuli, percepts and responses into scattered elements. The perception process is an integrated dynamic whole creating impressions that are very different from those expected from each part of the stimulus on its own. In other words, perception is not about separate parts, but about one whole.
The following are some important Gestalt principles related to perception: (A) Spontaneous completion of incomplete stimuli
The individual tends to complete an incomplete event or stimulus, for perception is based on a perfection system. Accordingly, the individual tends to remember the incomplete stimulus more than the complete one. That is why some advertisers put up a picture showing only half the product, or make inquisitive advertisements asking a question about the product without mentioning its name. Sometimes, the name of the new product is mentioned without descriptions. Also, a space may be left in an advertisement in order to motivate the consumer to guess what can complete it. Such things reinforce the consumer's recollection of the advertised product.
(B) Expectations
Perceiving a particular stimulus is strongly related to its position in the order of stimuli. Accordingly, a previous stimulus leads to a different perception in comparison with a later stimulus. Therefore, the producer seeks to present his product in the best form when launching it. The product's success may depend in the long run on how it is initially perceived. This implies that launching a new product demands a great deal of insight and extensive investigation in order to enhance its desired image.
Consumer Behavior
231
Chapter 6
6.4 Personality
Personality plays a vital role in directing consumer behavior. Therefore, understanding behavior requires the study and analysis of personality in order to identify its types, the characteristics of each and their impact on behavior.
6.4.1 Definition
There is no fixed definition of personality in psychology. However, it can be viewed as ``an intricate complex of behaviors and reactions to life's various occurrences.'' (44) The complex consists of a set of abstract permanent traits that interact with each other and determine the individual's responses to objects and situations in the surrounding context, hence responses to various consumer situations. (45) Personality is also defined as a set of internal psychological components that determine the way the individual behaves or acts towards stimuli in his environment as well as towards new situations. (46) In light of the above, personality can be viewed as a dynamic complex of psychological and physical systems that determine the individual's thoughts and behavior. In other words, it is a model of traits determining his responses. For example, we speak of the individual as self-confident, flexible, shy, effective, aggressive, etc. These personality traits affect his responses to the various daily life conditions he faces. Even though it is agreed that personality traits affect consumer perception and purchase behavior, the behavior of a particular personality cannot be definitely predicted. There are other factors, in addition to personality traits, that affect purchase decisions. (47)
232
Consumer Behavior
One of the relatively modern concepts in marketing is that certain products suit specific types of personality, and marketers try to match the product with its personality type in the target market. For example, the car can be matched with these personality types: elitist and distinct, elegant and aristocratic, young and athletic, family-oriented, practical and economic, popular, powerful and (48) gigantic. Through all these personality types, related target markets can be approached.
6.4.2 Personality Types
In terms of traits, personalities can be classified into three types: compliant, aggressive and secluded.
(A) The compliant personality
A compliant person loves people and prefers to interact with them and to be associated with groups. He seeks friendships, cares about others' opinions of him, and likes to see that they love, accept and respect him. Such a person tends to depend on others' opinions and advice when taking a purchase decision. He also tends to buy the products that make him look good in their eyes. In dealing with community members, he behaves positively and kindly. He would readily offer advice on products he is familiar with, even if not asked. He is influenced by the advertisements that focus on the image of the individual scene accepted by others. His motives for buying are dominated by the need for belonging and love.
(B) The aggressive personality
This type of person has an aggressive attitude towards others. He prefers to stay away from people, and seeks authority, power, and respect. With regard to advertisements, he tends not to believe them. In fact, he strongly believes that they provide exaggerated, if not false, information. He trusts no opinions on the product but his own experience. He is likely to suspect the information a salesperson gives him. Instead, he explores markets thoroughly
Consumer Behavior
233
Chapter 6
prior to purchasing. Strangely, he likes to offer advice to others, thinking that it should be taken for granted. He does his utmost to satisfy his need for recognition and respect.
(C) The secluded personality
The secluded person prefers to be aloof, but, unlike the aggressive type, he is too submissive. He tends to be indifferent to various obligations, and is not interested in influencing or being influenced by others. Such a person prefers not to consider others' opinions, and he takes his decisions independently. He does not express his opinion to others, but prefers to keep it for himself for fear of consequences unto himself. Regarding others' experiences, he does not seek to know them, but he tends to rely on his own search, investigation and experience as well as information derived from neutral sources. There are other personality traits that play a role in shaping consumer behavior. For example, the rational consumer displays reasonable motives, whereas the emotional person tends to seek the satisfaction of emotional motives, such as appearances and boasting. As for the shy person, he is too embarrassed to bargain or ask the salesperson ''too many questions'' regarding the product and its advantages. In contrast, the bold forthcoming person tends to search, investigate and bargain till he gets the best alternative at the lowest price. Also, unlike the self-confident consumer, the hesitant person takes too long looking for information, weighing alternatives and taking his final decision. Yet, he suffers more postpurchase dissonance and dissatisfaction. This demonstrates how personality affects the time spent on taking the purchase decision. In addition, the consumer seeking distinction tends to go for unique products, and to adopt new ones, particularly clothes. How generous a person is plays a significant role in deciding the quantity and quality of the products he buys. Even though each individual has a mix of those tendencies, only
234
Consumer Behavior
one of them dominates the others, and controls the personality as a whole, giving it its own typical trait. Research findings show that personality traits cannot provide a clear explanation for behaviors at all times, nor can they be considered the only determinants of consumer behavior. There are other variables that affect personality. Suppose, two consumers have the same personality trait, but they belong to different generations. Difference in age between them will result in different preferences of product sets. Also, differences in social class, economic conditions and gender will result in varied purchase behavior, even if the two personalities are identical in nature.(49) The afore-mentioned findings demonstrate that personality traits are not the only factors determining consumer behavior. Together with other factors, the traits determine the individual's pattern of consumer behavior. 6.4.3 Consumer Values and Self-Concept
6.4.3.1 Definition
Values are considered concepts related to personality and they control a lot of its traits. As defined by Henry Morray, values are mental representations of man's real needs. It is worth mentioning that value research focuses on aims and ends man seeks to reach, while personality research focuses on causes of differences among individuals.
6.4.3.2 Value types
Two basic types of value can be identified. They are terminal and instrumental. Terminal values are the beliefs the individual has regarding the final goals he seeks to reach, e.g. happiness, wisdom and self-realization. Instrumental values are the beliefs regarding desired behavior methods that help the individual reach his terminal values, namely means-to-ends, e.g. shouldering
Consumer Behavior
235
Chapter 6
responsibility and behaving honestly. Since values are transmitted across cultures, including sub-culture to be discussed later - the majority of culture / society members adopt them. This explains why certain values are dominant in one society, but are not in another. Also, the importance of each value varies from one individual to another in the same society. While some members hold certain values as important, other members give priority to other values.
(50)
Marketers can benefit from the two-type value classification, by identifying the terminal values prevalent in the target society. They can also emphasize the role of instrumental values in promoting their products. For example, if love for self-distinction is the dominant value in the target society, the marketer should stress it in his promotional and advertising campaigns. He should stress the importance of relevant instrumental values, such as encouraging distinct consumption and patronage of special types of stores and brands. The higher the degree of welfare in a society, the more important those values are. Also, values change with the passage of time, the development of culture and social, economic and technological changes.
6.4.3.3 Self-concept
One of the basic concepts in personality studies is self-concept, i.e. the image the individual visualizes for himself and believes others see him that way. In that regard, psychologists distinguish between realistic self-concept and ideal self-concept. Realistic self-concept refers to the image the individual actually has for himself. Ideal selfconcept refers to the image by which he desires to be seen by others. The individual's self-concept is affected by his psychological and physical needs, innate and acquired. It is also affected by economic, social and demographic factors. Marketing
236
studies
have
revealed
that
consumers
prefer
the
Consumer Behavior
products, brands and stores that are in harmony with their realistic or ideal self-concepts. In fact, there is normally similarity between product characteristics and those of their respective consumers. The individual tends to buy the product that expresses his realistic or ideal personality. Making use of the ideal self-concept, marketers seek to give the consumer the impression that if he chooses a particular product, he will gain certain personality traits. The marketers already know that the traits are acceptable to him and fulfill his self-image. A very clear example is that of cigarette advertisements. They try to persuade the consumer to believe that smoking a particular type of cigarettes will give a manly, authoritative and distinct image. Similarly, some advertisements portray the female consumer of a particular product as a modern lady. Certain research findings related to self-concept emphasize that it is the consumer's realistic self-concept that affects his behavior. Yet, others ascertain that the ideal self-concept is the most influential. However, related studies in general conclude that the consumer's self-concept combines both the realistic and ideal concepts of self.(51) It is this combination that influences purchase decisions. Also, the influence of self-concept varies from product to product.
Consumer Behavior
237
Chapter 6
Endnotes of Chapter 6
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) Ba-Zar'ah, M. S.,
op cit, p. 298.
Mohamed, M. F. and A. M. Al-Shirbeeni, Al-Ghadeer, Hamad and Rashad Al-Saed, Abdul-Hameed, T. A.,
Harold
(1908-1970)
Philosopher. He was known for his theory that maintains that self integration is the highest aim of psychiatry. One of his well-known works is Motivation and Personality, N. Y., Harper & Row, 1954. In it, he suggests that the individual has a heirarchy of needs, and once he satises one level, he moves to the next.
Hanna, Naseem,
the Purchase Behavior of Saudi and non Saudi Women in Jeddah, Management Principles, Marketing Principles, Consumer Behavior, Consumer Behavior: An Integrated Approach),
op. cit., pp. 22-23. Dar Al-Qalam, Dubai, 1987, p. 326. op. cit., p. 90. op. cit., p. 123-124. Ba-Zar'ah, M. S.,
Analysis of
(15)
the Purchase Behavior of Saudi and non Saudi Women in Jeddah, Consumer Behavior: Marketing Research: Consumer Behavior: Principles of Marketing, Marketing Principles,
op. cit., p. 80. op. cit., pp. 290-292. Obaidat, Mohamed, Hanna, Naseem, op. cit., p. 80. Obaidat, Mohamed, op. cit., p. 93.
Analysis of
238
Consumer Behavior
Obaidat, Mohamed,
Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 83. Obaidat, Mohamed, Marketing Principles, op. cit., pp. 93-94.
There will be more on Gestalt Psychology in the section on the modern perception theory.
Hanna, Naseem,
Principles of Marketing, op. cit., pp. 109-110. Obaidat, Mohamed, Principles of Marketing, op. cit., p. 93. Hanna, Naseem, Principles of Marketing, op. cit., pp. 108-109.
B. F. Skinner (1904-190) is an American Psychologist, and belongs to the behaviorist school of psychology. He was inuenced by the works of the Russian physiologist Pavlov. Basic to his theory is that human behavior constitutes
(28) (29) (30) (31) (32) (33) (34) (35) (36) (37) (38) (39) (40) (41) (42)
(Encyclopedia Britannica, p. 10/865). Hanna, Naseem, Principles of Marketing, op. cit., p. 109. Stanton and others, Fundamentals of Marketing, op. cit., p. 129. Wilkie, W. L., Consumer Behavior, op. cit., pp. 283-287. Abdul-Hameed, T. A., Eective Marketing, op. cit., pp. 110-111. Mohamed, M. F. and A. M. Al-Shirbeeni, Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 97. Wilkie, W. L., Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 205. Abdul-Hameed, T. A., Eective Marketing: op. cit., p. 112. Al-Musaa'id, Z.K., Marketing from a Comprehensive Perspective, op.cit., p. 124. Mohamed, M. F. and A. M. Al-Shirbeeni, Consumer Behavior, op. cit., pp. 98-99. Obaidat, Mohamed, Principles of Marketing, op. cit., p. 92. Mohamed, M. F. and A. M. Al-Shirbeeni, Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p.100. Al-Ghadeer, Hamad and Rashad Al-Saed, Consumer Behavior: op. cit., pp. 89-91. Wilkie, W. L., Consumer Behavior, op. cit., pp. 207-215. Hanna, Naseem, Marketing Principles, op. cit., pp. 104-106.
the surrounding environment. Gestalt psychology is a behaviorist school that emerged in Austria and the South of Germany in the late 19th century. It advocates that an absolute object as a whole is greater than its individual parts, and the characteristics resulting from the object as a whole cannot be obtained from analyzing its parts individually. Gestalt principles go back to Johann Goethe (1749-1832), the German literary gure and philosopher. Among the founders of the Gestalt school of psychology are Max Wertheimer, a Czech by birth (1880-1930) and Wolfgang Kohler (1887-1967), a German scholar. "Gestalt" is a German term, which has no English synonym, and it means the way by which a thing develops as a whole. 5/226).
(Encyclopedia Britannica,
Al-'Ilm
p.
(43)
Al-Ba'albakki,
Munir,
Al-Mawrid Dictionary,
Beirut,
Dar
Lil-Malaayeen,
Consumer Behavior
239
Chapter 6
1991, p. 386. Wilkie, W. L., Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 150. Mohamed, M. F. and Al-Shirbeeni, A. M. Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 146. Al-Ghadeer, Hamad and Al-Saed, Rashad, Consumer Behavior: An Integrated Approach, op. cit., p. 113. Stanton and others, Fundamentals of Marketing, op. cit., p.130. Mohamed, M. F. and Al-Shirbeeni, A. M., Consumer Behavior, op. cit., pp. 146-147. Wilkie, W. L., Consumer Behavior, op. cit., pp. 151-158. Wilkie, W. L., ibid., p. 159. Stanton and others, Fundamentals of Marketing, op. cit., p. 131. Wilkie, W. L., Consumer Behavior, ibid., p. 156.
240
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 7
Income Impact on the Purchase Decision
Chapter Topics
7.1 The Concept of Income 7.2 Impact of Income Change on Consumer Spending
The individual's socio-economic conditions determine his consumption behavior pattern and how he takes his purchase decisions. In this respect, income is clearly one of the major factors that influence consumption. It plays an essential role in defining the individual's consumption and purchasing behavior. To desire something does not in itself result in consumer action. One desires, for example, to have the best house, the best car, etc. ``Desires do not translate into consumer behavior unless they are backed by a purchasing power.''(1) The consumption process is based on two factors: the purchase desire and the buying power. The purchase desire is determined by psychological motives and social motives, e.g. reference groups and social classes. It is also determined by marketing motives, e.g. advertisements. As for the buying power, it is under the strong influence and control of the income factor.(2) In order to define the relationship between income and consumption, we need to explain the following: (1) income and (2) the effect of income change on consumer spending.
Consumer Behavior
243
income,
(b)
disposable
income,
and
(c)
(a) Accrued income is the total income, from wages, salaries, rent, interest, non-fixed values, benefits, and pensions, before deduction of taxes, and duties. (b) Disposable income is the accrued income minus taxes and duties. It is what the consumer spends to satisfy his needs, and from which he extracts his savings. (c) Consumer discriminatory income is the disposable income minus the costs of basic needs, like food, clothing, accommodation, transportation, and minus any fixed duties, such as insurance installments, debts, and house mortgage. It is what the consumer spends on non-essential items.
periodically. Real income is the amount of goods and services which the individual can buy with his money income. It is also defined as the
Consumer Behavior
245
Chapter 7
buying power of income, and it is usually affected by the existing inflation rate. Psycho-income is the individual's perception of his own money income and real income. It is usually affected by his surrounding environment. It increases or decreases according to the individual's personal assessment of the surrounding conditions, e.g. how far the place of work is from family and friends, and the financial and psychological costs.
3. National income
Because income affects consumption, marketers study the national income of the country where they pursue their activities. The national income expresses the total buying power of a country's population. It helps identify the general context and size of consumption. The national income is the total of all the incomes due from the factors of production (capital, labour, land, administration and organization) that contribute to production in the country over a particular period of time, which is regularly one year.(4) Dividing the national income by the population number gives the annual income average. Yet, it does not refer to something real; it is only a criterion for measuring the general buying power. The individuals' income may be higher or lower than average. Rarely do we find people whose income is exactly equal to the income average marketers are interested in the income that is available for spending, i.e. the real income, for the individual does not consume except within the limits of the income he can spend. 7.1.2 Real Income and Consumer Behavior In light of the aforementioned, the real income has a significant relationship with consumer behavior. This relationship is manifest in the following:
246
Consumer Behavior
The rich have more ability to put up with risk. This is why their purchase decision-making is faster, and why sales agents and service promoters look for them to lead purchasing. Because the rich have high quality needs, they require high quality products, especially ones that need little maintenance and are uniquely strong and durable; the rich do not have enough time to get products exchanged or repaired. The more a particular brand is known, the readier they are to purchase its product.
2- Product search
Consumers follow the stages that lead to the correct purchase decision. They may opt for a renowned product on friends' advice, or they may rely on catalogues. Due to the ever-growing speed that characterizes modern life, consumers do not have enough time to search for products. The more the customer's income rises, the more he seeks faster ways of doing his shopping. He also becomes more interested in additional services like what restaurants or planes offer. Indeed most of his decisions depend on the quality of the service.
3- Product use
Even though high-income people normally purchase multi-purpose high quality products, they learn only some simple functions related to operation. Products are thus under-utilized. This is very common with household electric appliances. Given the importance of instructions related to use and security, appliances and tools the rich class own require more post-sale service, preferably at customers' homes. This is to emphasize the high performance and quality of products. High income people value time greatly and become impatient if they have to wait for necessary services. This requires speed and attention to the organization's concept of service, particularly as the products are used by others, such as servants. As for the middle class, consumers are more concerned
Consumer Behavior
247
Chapter 7
High-income customers seek quality standards. They look for a quality with these clear specifications: reflecting wealth and prestige; showing high performance; distinguishing owners from others; and increasing their enjoyment of leisure time. For example, they want televisions and computers with big screens and want expensive hunting or sports equipment. Their high income allows them to aim high in terms of quality.(5)
248
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
249
Chapter 7
family increases by a certain amount, its consumption pattern will be greatly affected. If a rich family gets the same amount of increase, its consumption pattern will not change much.
(7)
Not only does income influence the quality of the purchased product, but also its quantity. High income people can afford to buy the quantity and quality of products they want, whereas limited income ones cannot. In other words, the increase in income enables the consumer to obtain higher quality products, because quality and price are often related. The increase facilitates the purchase of more up-to-date and more sophisticated products.
(8)
In general, income rise creates various motives. Individuals tend to fulfill needs related to social status and social class - income is a significant manifested indicator in high of social class
(9)
definition. who
This prefer
is
clearly
income
individuals
imported
outlets whose customers are almost exclusively high class, and whose products none can afford but high income people. With respect to negative change in income, sudden fall is
significant in stopping purchase decisions in their last stages, as in cases of money loss, confiscation or sudden unemployment. Yet, income rise, as stated earlier, facilitates the purchase decision process. High financial power reduces the purchase risk, for the consumer can always afford to buy a better product. Also the decisions considered extended for low income consumers are considered limited for high income consumers. The impact of income rise on consumer behavior is reflected also on increased spending on luxury products. Sometimes, luxury products become necessary. Also, the impact of income fall on consumption behavior can make basic needs look luxurious. For example, an air-conditioner is considered a necessity for some people, but a luxury for others.
250
Consumer Behavior
The following are some findings of field studies on the impact of income rise on consumer spending:
a. Impact of income rise on European families
Engel's study on the effect of income on consumption patterns of some European families has led to what is known in the literature as Engel's laws. Below is a summary:
Increase in family income leads to:
D D D D
Increased spending on food, by a percentage less than that of the increase in income. Increased spending on clothes, by a fixed proportion from the income. Increased spending on housing by a fixed percentage of income. Increased spending on such areas as education, leisure and culture, by a percentage higher than that of the increase in income.
The following are the findings of similar studies conducted on American families.
Increase in family income leads to: D Increased spending on food,
D D
income increase percentage. Increased spending on clothes, by a fixed percentage from the income. Increased spending on housing, by a higher percentage than
251
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 7
Increased spending on other items, by a higher percentage than that of income increase.
The above-mentioned findings of research on American families are consistent with Engel's laws except the third law. This may be due to the fact that income increase may make the American family move to a larger accommodation, hence the increased spending on housing by a percentage higher than that of increase in income.
D D D
Increased spending on food, by a percentage higher than that of the increase in income. Increased spending on clothes, by a fixed percentage of income. Increased spending on other items, by a percentage higher than that of the increase in income.
However, the research on the Egyptian family shows no increased spending on housing, as expected according to Engel's laws. This may be due to the housing crisis in Egypt. A normal income increase cannot lead the Egyptian family to move to a new house. Moving to a new house requires a huge increase in income. Apart from the housing factor, the Egyptian findings are consistent with Engel's laws, except the first law. This may be attributed to the subsatisfaction level of basic needs, such as food. This leads to spending the increase in income on satisfying those basic needs, but by a percentage higher than that of the increase.
252
Consumer Behavior
Endnotes of Chapter 7
(1) (2) Mohamed, M. F. and Al-Shirbeeni, A. M., Engel, J. F., Kollat and Blackwell, 1968, p. 43. (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9)
Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 206. Consumer Behavior, Chicago: the Oryden
Press,
Consumer Behavior, op. cit. p. 205. Principles and Strategies, op. cit., p. 78. Mohamed, M. F. and Al-Shirbeeni, A. M., Consumer Behavior, op. cit., p. 209. Abdul Hameed, T. A., Eective Marketing: op. cit., pp. 126, 129. Mohamed, M. F. and Al-Shirbeeni, A. M., Consumer Behavior, op. cit., pp. 212-213. Assaaf, M., Marketing Principles, op. cit., p. 64. The Chamber of Commerce Research Center, Analysis of Purchase Behavior among Saudi and non-Saudi Women in the City of Jeddah, op. cit., p. 90.
Wilkie, W. L., Hassan, S. A. Marketing: Ibid., p. 102. Mohamed, M. F. and A. M. Al-Shirbeeni
(10) (11)
Consumer Behavior
253
Chapter 8
Marketing Factors Aecting the Purchase Decision
Chapter Topics
8.1 Inuence of Salespersons 8.2 Advertising 8.3 Product 8.4 Price
Consumer Behavior
257
Chapter 8
encounters a consumer in order to introduce him to the qualities (1) of a product and persuade him to buy it.'' Personal selling is an art and special skill that a salesperson acquires. It enables him to convince others to buy products he wants to sell. Studies of the nature of personal selling no longer focus on one party of the transaction; both salesperson and customer contribute to its conclusion. The outcome of this transaction depends heavily on how each party views and reacts to the other. The interaction between the two parties follows three stages: the orientation stage, the evaluation stage, and the consumption (2) stage.
260
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
261
Chapter 8
One fundamental reason for the success of the selling transaction is the consistency between the customer's social status and the type of store he patronizes. A customer who enters a store that corresponds to the social class he belongs to feels comfortable and selfconfident. Another reason for the success of the selling operation is the presence of some shared traits and dispositions between the customer and the salesperson, e.g. age, religion, level of education, and especially social attitudes or political standpoints. The latter seems to be the most important. The presence of other characteristics in the salesperson contributes towards his success. Consumers trust more the salesperson who gives the impression that he is in control and that he can solve all their potential problems with the product he is selling. Indeed, despite the prevalence of material values in our life, the consumer remains a human being with much subjectivity. He likes to be nicely looked after and hates to be treated as a fleeting face among those unidentifiable faces. He likes to have his desires and needs identified and his queries answered, but he hates to be cheated or exploited. The feeling that the salesperson is after the money in his purse makes him feel insecure and distrustful. On the other hand, any special treatment the customer receives, no matter how little it is, makes him feel important and willing to buy.
c. The purchase decision-making stage
When the consumer reaches the purchase decision-making stage, he has already made up his mind concerning the product he intends to buy, its brand and its model. In his completion of the purchasing process, the client negotiates (i) modalities of payment, (ii) availability of home delivery, and (iii) possible time for product delivery. The business transactions the salesperson concludes successfully are quite indicative of his ability to achieve better profits for the producer and the marketer whom he represents and works for.
262
Consumer Behavior
This stage does not represent the end of the client-salesperson encounter. That encounter may be the beginning of a long-lasting loyalty. The salesperson should not overlook the stages that bring the sale transaction to its completion. These stages include warranty procedures, repair service, and any trouble-shooting at the early stages of operating the appliance. Personal selling efforts are crucial in winning over consumers and in inducing them to buy goods and services. There are many consumers who hesitate to opt out of old products for new ones with which they are not very much familiar. To be encouraged, they need to be informed about the advantages of the new products or services and the incentives that come with them. They need to see the products tried before their eyes. They also need expert account on the product's constitution, operation, and maintenance. In the marketing chain, the salesperson represents the last crucial link with the customer, and this requires outstanding marketing efforts on his part. He provides the customer with products, services, and information. The successful salesperson devotes himself to the service of his company, and watches and records all that happens around him for better marketing performance.(3)
8.1.2 The Successful Salesperson
In general, it can be said that the more a line of products gains in technical sophistication, and the more experienced customers become, the stronger the need is for a highly intelligent salesperson. The skills a salesperson is required to have are very much dependent on the nature of the product and its use. Selling construction equipment requires mechanical and architectural skills while selling decoration services requires a high level of artistic attributes.
Consumer Behavior
263
Chapter 8
b. Knowledge
The level and quality of the salesperson's training depends on the technical sophistication of the product and the knowledge consumers have of that product. Three types of knowledge are required for any selling post: General knowledge: This type includes a basic knowledge of the market and competition. The general knowledge required for the salesperson is closely related to the degree of knowledge of current and potential customers. Knowledge in the business field: This type of knowledge is related to the nature of customers and their views on the line of products. Technical knowledge: The type of technical knowledge a salesperson has to have varies according to the nature and variety of the products he sells.
c. Communication skills
The salesperson's communication skill depends on his ability to choose the suitable words and style to get his ideas across. It also depends on his eloquence in fulfilling his mission in a clear and honest manner.
d. Skills of identifying other people's reactions
Obtaining basic information from customers depends on the salesperson's ability to understand their reactions. Asking customers adequate questions and listening carefully to them, while paying attention to their posture and gestures are very effective. In addition to the above-mentioned qualities, a salesperson should have the following attributes: D the ability to manage time; D honesty in financial and non-financial matters;
264
Consumer Behavior
D D D
showing reassuring self-confidence through taking care of one's appearance; eagerness, initiative, and loyalty towards one's company; and competent performance, patience, and diplomacy.
(4)
its
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 8
characteristics. The salesperson follows the steps, starting by giving the customer a detailed account on the characteristics, qualities and advantages of the product. Then, he gives the customer the opportunity to express his needs and desires. Taking those expressed needs and desires into consideration, the salesperson proceeds to the persuasion step. This method is followed in many retail stores, which sell TV sets, cars, personal computers, and other apparel. It is very common in personal computer marketing that the salesperson explains the characteristics of the product, gives the customer the chance to express his needs, and then persuades him of the superiority of the PC he wants to sell in meeting those needs.
c. The need satisfaction method
According to the consumer need satisfaction method, the salesperson discovers the consumer's needs by giving him the opportunity to talk. Once the needs and product-related problems are identified, the salesperson helps the buyer look at those needs and problems from a new perspective. At the same time, he tries to convince him that the product he is selling can solve his problems and meet his needs in a very effective way. This is a rather advanced method; it does not rely on customized or memorized speeches. Rather, it relies on the salesperson's experience in understanding customers' behavior. The method requires well-qualified people who comprehend customers' behavioral motives and respond to them in the correct way. Since consumers have different motives, needs, and problems, salespersons are required to have the ability to think and act fast.
d. The AIDA method
This method is based on four factors: (i) getting the customer's attention (Attention), (ii) showing him, and triggering, his interest (Interest), (iii) arousing his desire for a particular product (Desire), and (iv) directing him towards making the decision to buy (Action). This method is characterized by its logical simplicity and by its
266
Consumer Behavior
suitability for various marketing situations. Furthermore, marketing project designers find little difficulty training salespersons to adopt this method. The AIDA method is detailed below:
(i) Attention
Getting the consumer's attention is an individual act that depends on the salesperson's personality and natural or acquired ability. What works in attracting one person's attention may not work with others. Attention getting techniques differ according to the selling situation. They also depend on whether the customer is new or regular. Furthermore, attention getting has psychological reasons; it can be a way of getting the consumer out of the state of mind he is in and directing his interest toward what the salesperson plans to achieve. Whatever the means the salesperson adopts to capture his
customer's attention, the procedure has to take place according to the acceptable, legal, and logical ways; otherwise, things will not go according to plan.
(ii) Interest
Salespersons listen to the consumer's needs and product-related problems. They show particular interest in the problems they can help the consumer solve. People, whoever they are, enjoy other people listening to them and sharing their thoughts with them. Interest-showing techniques give customers the chance to provide a detailed description of their needs and worries. Salespersons may rely on pictures, catalogues, and other means to interest customers in products.
(iii) Desire
Desire arousing is a step that precedes the decision-making step. It requires a good persuasion skill, for the customer often questions
Consumer Behavior
267
Chapter 8
what the salesperson offers and expresses his doubt about the satisfaction the product will provide for his needs. The salesperson's task is to persuade the customer that his objections and doubts are not very well founded and that the product really satisfies his needs. The salesperson may find it appropriate to produce concrete evidence to support his case; he may refer to previous customers' satisfaction.
(iv) Action
Here the salesperson starts by giving a summary in which he stresses the supremacy of the product in satisfying his customer's needs and its role in solving his problems, inciting all along his client to move towards the decision-making step. In order to avoid the client's refusal to acquire the product, the salesperson may avoid asking the customer whether he is about to buy the product or not. Instead, he may go ahead and start filling in the customer's order, ask him about the quantity he requires, enquire about the delivery date that suits him, or any other tactics that make it difficult for the customer to refuse to buy. It is worth noticing in this context that many people find it difficult to rush into making decisions. The salesmen's tactics spare such customers the trouble of any further hesitation and encourage them to place an order for the product.
8.1.4 Consumers' Views on Selling
Studies conducted by marketing specialists have investigated the selling process and focused on two major issues: (i) the strategies salespersons follow and (ii) the management of salespersons. The present section concentrates on the former issue. It is devoted to the steps salespersons follow to positively affect customers and the mounting influence they exert on their consumer behavior. The salesperson derives his power to control the selling process from two sources: reference power and expertise power.
268
Consumer Behavior
Reference power has its source in the personal qualities of the salesperson. The more his qualities resemble the consumers' qualities, the closer to success the selling process is.
b. Expertise
Expertise power is deeply rooted in the salesperson's long career. The longer the salesperson's career in the field, the more successful his mission is. There are studies on how salespersons conceive of the selling process. There are also studies on how consumers conceive of the sale operation. The latter are the subject of our discussion, below. Consumers rely on three principles when engaging in any purchase operation. These principles give them power. They are:
a. ``Knowledge is power''
The more information a consumer has on a selling transaction, the more powerful he is when he engages in that transaction. Information is related to the product and its price, the market, and the salesperson.
b. Price differences
That consumers have an idea about the price differences of similar products in the market is a prerequisite. It allows them to purchase the best at the smallest price and avoid any cheating. Consumers should also negotiate prices and gather relevant information.
c. Purchase strategies
Consumers ought to prepare their buying strategies in advance. The more knowledge they have about the product they intend to buy, and the more price discussion they engage in, the more likely they will acquire a good product at a reasonable price.
Consumer Behavior
269
Chapter 8
8.2 Advertising
Advertising is one of the basic tools organizations use to communicate with the public. For Stanton et al., ``Advertising consists of all activities involved in presenting to a group a nonpersonal, oral or visual, openly sponsored message regarding a product, service, or idea; this message is called an advertisement, is disseminated through one or more media and is paid for by the (6) identified sponsor.'' Stanton et al. add that two major factors are involved in advertising: the marketers who are the senders of the message and the consumers who are the receivers. Marketers decide which advertising campaign they want to be involved in, while consumers (7) represent the true and essential reaction to advertising campaigns . Advertising has been known to man for ages, and its techniques have developed with developments in all walks of life and in the means of communication. Advertising has also been influenced by the developments in other scientific fields; it has benefited from those advances intelligently and rapidly. The major aim of advertising has always been to positively influence consumer behavior.
8.2.1 Definition
The word advertising itself is derived from ``ad'' which means ``change'' and ``vert'' which means ``direction.'' Advertising has many definitions, which vary in their wording and comprehensiveness. Each definition reflects the viewpoint and experience in media communication of its author. For Behms, advertising is a form of producing an intentional effect exercised by the advertiser on the listener or viewer, to achieve a specific goal. Haseloff defines advertising as a purposeful and planned
270
Consumer Behavior
communication act advertisers perform by transferring to their audience information on a product or service they manufacture or market. They seek to trigger purchasing motives among the (8) individual in order to increase their market share. Hoxitfeld defined advertising as a non-personal communication operation from the seller to influence the buyer through the (9) advertiser, who reveals his identity in the available mass media . Assaf defines advertisement as ``all the various activities that lead to the publication or broadcasting of visual, audio, or printed messages to the public to induce them to buy a given product or service, or to appreciate the ideas of people or institutions that are (10) advertised.'' According to Al-Sulami, ``Advertising is a non-personal communication operation conducted through the mass media by advertisers who pay an amount of money to communicate certain information to certain consumers; advertisers reveal their identity (11) in the advertisement.'' As for Ba-Zar'ah, advertising is ``a non-personal communication means to present and promote ideas, products and services through (12) a known medium for a paid price.'' The American Marketing Association gives a very similar definition: ``Advertising is a non-personal means to present ideas, (13) products, or services through a known body and at a paid price.'' The above definitions share the following characteristics:
D It is paid for. D It comes from a known and clearly defined advertising body. D It is meant to promote an idea, to convey a piece of
information, or to market a product.
Consumer Behavior
271
Chapter 8
What matters most in advertising is the attempt to influence, through the advertiser's effort, the consumer and to direct his market behavior in a way that meets the aims of the organization. In this context, a distinction can be drawn between: a. Informational advertising: It essentially aims at providing information for the consumer without attempting to influence him directly. b. Impact advertising: It aims at producing a direct and rapid impact on the consumer. The difference between a and b is a difference in degree of effect and not of type. The informational advertisement achieves the same aims(14) as its counterpart, but at a lesser speed and in an indirect way.
8.2.2 Basic Concepts of Advertising(15)
It is crucial at this point to provide basic factors, concepts and means that seek to make advertisement influence consumer behavior.
8.2.2.1 Basic factors of advertising
These factors are known as the seven Ms of Advertising: (1) Merchandise: the product to be advertised. (2) Markets: to whom the product is directed. (3) Motives: what drives consumers to buy. (4) Messages: the most effective advertising messages. (5) Money: the price paid for the advertisement and the time of payment. (6) Media: the time and place of communicating with the target consumer. (7) Measurements: aims at increasing the efficiency of the above
272
Consumer Behavior
factors, and involves making good use of consumer research, hence using its results in improving advertising campaigns.
(16)
This simplified model does not provide an adequate representation of how communication is a actually works. The In sender most cases, a communication two-way process. transmits
message to the receiver, who, in turn, sends a message back to the original sender. Both participants take turns in being senders or receivers as the communication event proceeds. Examples of this two-way process include interviews, meetings and information exchange through personal advice among consumers or between the consumer and the salesperson. One-way advertising does not have the advantages of two-way communication. The latter gives room for discussing matters of importance to the consumer. It captures his interest, and he realizes that he has to be cooperative and forthcoming. Furthermore, the sender receives feedback from the target consumer, who will have to maintain the communication channel, express his opinion, and show his understanding of the message. This allows the marketer to
Consumer Behavior
273
Chapter 8
adjust his message or explain it further. Personal sale is a good illustrative example in this respect. The marketer has the possibility of turning a one-way communication type into a two-way type. This is usually achieved through advertisement research that seeks to obtain consumer reactions to a certain product or through direct reactions that come through the phone, the post, the Internet, etc. On the other hand, one-way communication, including advertising, has a number of advantages. One of them is that the sender transmits one message through many communication channels to a large number of receivers. This reduces the individual receiver's share of the fixed price for the advertisement. The effect of the advertisement increases through reliance on marketing and consumer research findings. The latter help in determining the place and time of the advertisement and contribute towards making it more attractive and effective for as many consumers as possible. People are exposed to a huge quantity of messages; some of them pass unnoticed. According to a recent study, the average citizen is bombarded daily with more than 1000 messages. Some of the messages which he does not react to go to his short or long memory; they are stored, modified, or eventually erased. The modified or stored messages are used to build up one's experience or to back up other new messages. Advertising is, thus, a communication process that seeks to persuade consumers to buy a good or a service. Persuasion is the fundamental step towards realizing a positive reaction to the stimuli that the advertising (17) message conveys.
Consumer Behavior
communication system. There are three stages on the advertiser's (sender's) side, corresponding with three stages on the consumer's (receiver's) side.
(18)
A brief explanation of the above stages is given below. Stage I: Advertising goals (19)
Stage I defines the goals of the advertising campaign. The goals depend on the market share, competition, and the nature of the target consumers.
(a) Persuasion: it is convincing the customer of the superiority of the advertised trademark. (b) Reinforcement: it is underscoring the positive post-purchase product evaluation.
(c) Reminding: it seeks to maintain the trademark in consumers' memory. (d) Purchase encouragement: in order to encourage customers to purchase the advertised trademark as fast as possible, the
Consumer Behavior
275
Chapter 8
advertiser declares the end of the offer, the remaining quantity on offer, or the amount of discount. The advertising goals differ according to the stage through which the advertised product is going. The effectiveness of all the goals is closely linked to the reactions of the consumer. The equality symbol (=), located between the goals and reaction and responses (Figure 12, above), indicates that the ideal communication system results in a consumer behavior that perfectly meets the advertising campaign goals.
276
Consumer Behavior
At the perception stage, the tangible advertisement transmission accompanies the actual advertisement treatment. The latter, because it is linked to the cognition system, can be complex. The equality symbol (=) in Figure 12, above, indicates that the advertiser hopes that the consumer receives the message and comprehends it as intended, conceived, and transmitted. In general, the clearer the message, the better and the faster consumers comprehend it.
Stage VI: Reactions or responses
The reaction stage includes any ensuing ideas or behaviors consumers may adopt in the aftermath of the advertising act. The perfect communication system is realized if the consumer's reactions and responses correspond to the goals defined at Stage I, above. This is represented by the equality symbol (=) in Figure 12, above. Response assessment is done by measuring sale rise following the advertisement. Sale rise takes place when positive ideas develop towards the advertising message and when consumer behavior reflects those ideas in product purchase.
8.2.2.4. Communication system in practice (20)
Advertisers encounter communication conditions that are inconsistent with the theoretical model, above. This represents a big problem. Advertisers are keen to make their message reach the largest number of receivers and future consumers, while increasing profit and reducing each individual's share of the fixed charges on the advertisement. Yet, reality is different. A single advertisement does not achieve complete success among a large audience whose members vary in terms of level, interest, and type. What may be very attractive for a family member may not have the same degree of attraction for another. It may even be judged as a bad advertisement. Attempts to win over a maximum number of consumers through one advertisement may be unrewarding. Market segmentation has, therefore, a great importance. Here, the marketer
Consumer Behavior
277
Chapter 8
divides the prospective consumers into relatively sizable sub-groups, where each group shares certain characteristics, like age or social class. These divisions make it possible for the marketer to introduce product specifications that suit the segmentation he has made, and allows him to reach each group in a more effective way. Although advertisement variation, which suits the different market sectors, may be very effective, lacunae remain. That may justify the ideal communication system. These lacunae include: (a) The advertising strategy may fail to achieve the goals of the advertising campaign. There are three possible causes (i) unrealistic goals, (ii) unclear goals, and (iii) ineffective strategies or advertising messages. (b) A second misgiving can result from the thousands of tactical decisions an effective advertising campaign requires. Consequently, some mistakes are bound to creep in this huge enterprise. Mistakes may appear in the advertisement itself or in its inadequacy to the campaign's goals. (c) A third misgiving may be in the concrete transfer of the intended advertisement. The latter may divert from its original aims. Some technical mistakes, such as the choice of colors or sounds, may affect the advertisement's features. The advertisement may fail to reach its target; the consumer may be busy or involved in other activities. The most effective remedy for this problem may consist in advertisement repetition. (d) The consumer may misperceive the message the advertiser has designed. It is important that the consumer understands the language of the message and its symbols. The consumer's interest in the advertised product affects his concentration on and perception of the advertisement. Finally, consumers' interpretations of the message depend on their previous experience and relevant background knowledge.
278
Consumer Behavior
(e) There is the likelihood that the advertising message fails to achieve the expected reaction that the advertiser was seeking.
For the advertising message to lead to the anticipated behavior, the following have to take place:
(i) The consumer stores the transmitted message and may be able to retrieve it completely or partially from memory. This depends largely on the effect of the message on the
consumer. (ii) The advertisement succeeds in having a strong positive effect on the consumer and in winning him over. An advertisement may trigger its recipient's memory of another product that won him over. Rival products play a significant role in directing the consumer's behavior attempts against an advertiser's motivate desire. a Also, many to buy advertising a product
intended
to
consumer
requiring a change in his purchase habits may fail, unless strong effective techniques are used; consumers often defend their habits and personal convictions. Therefore, any advertisement of new
products, especially those that require a change in the individual's purchasing and consuming habits, must contain an educational program that helps the potential consumer to use or consume the new product.. Advertisers have to reduce all the aforementioned problems to a minimum. They also have to take them into consideration when planning advertising campaigns. This helps make campaigns as realistic as possible and tackle possible obstacles.
Consumer Behavior
279
Chapter 8
method, called sales promotion. Sales promotion can be defined as doing various activities to invigorate, distribute and market a particular project's goods and services. As a kind of non-personal selling, it aims essentially at increasing sales in(21) the short run within given boundaries in a given geographical area. Sales promotion contributes to the rapid prosperity of the successful firm. It is a reliable means to measure the producer's capability. Sales promotion includes ``fairs, sampling, sales coupons, (22) sales gifts, catalogues and promotion offers.'' Consumers often think that they have the right to sales promotion. They do not value the additional expenses companies incur, but think that, because they have been paying the original price for products all along, they are entitled to those sales promotions. Consumers may even refuse to buy products at their original price. They wait for gifts, reductions, and coupons. To influence the consumer in the most efficient and cost-effective way, marketers have to choose between: (i) relying on the advertisement as a long-term method, or (ii) on sales promotion as a short-term method. Sales promotion is closely dependent on the cooperation between advertising and personal selling; all this(23) aims at raising consumer demand and improving overall marketing. Thus, it can be said that it is the role of the whole promotion program (advertisement, personal selling, sales promotion, etc. with its products, price policies, and promotion means and distribution methods) is not only important but also essential in influencing consumer behavior. If a product is deficient, no advertising campaign, whatever its sophistication level may be, will succeed in persuading customers to buy it. If a product is excessively expensive, no advertisement, whatever its power and effectiveness, can stand the chance of attracting consumers. Consumer characteristics play a significant role in responding to advertisements. Personality traits, education level, and the
280
Consumer Behavior
As stated earlier in this work, advertisements affect women more than men. Also, age plays an important role in this respect. Some studies show that advertisements have more inf luence on women and children.
(25)
The role of advertising increases in facing personal selling with regard to the kind of goods and services. Advertisement has a much significant concerned, role and effect as far as consumer in products are over
while
personal
selling
gains
significance
advertising when it comes to industrial products and services. In conclusion, advertising has a great impact on consumer
behavior. It is thanks to advertising that most products and brands make high profits. That is why giant companies around the globe depend on it.
Consumer Behavior
281
Chapter 8
8.3 Product
8.3.1. Definition and Dimensions
A product is that which has certain characteristics that make it satisfy a particular need of an individual, a group or an organization, and it is, therefore, marketable.(26) Thus, the product is either (a) a good, with specific concrete characteristics, or (b) a service that joins together concrete and non-concrete dimensions. Every product has three dimensions (27):
(a) Technical dimension
The technical dimension refers to the product's ability to perform certain functions. The function can be mechanical, as in the case of a car, a fridge, or a computer. It can be chemical, as in the case of medication, food, or detergents. Company experts determine the technical structure of such products and their respective functions.
(b) Performance dimension
It is the product's capacity to fulfill the function or functions it has been conceived for, e.g. the car's transportation ability, the fridge's ability to maintain a low temperature, and the computer's information processing or calculation capacity.
(c) Shape dimension
Shape is related to the product's external appearance, which may or may not have a role in the performance dimension. A product's shape often fulfills psychological or social needs. A car's external shape satisfies a psychological need, and has important social significations for the consumer. 8.3.2. Product Classifications(28)
282
Consumer Behavior
In addition to the aforementioned product distinction between goods and services, there is another distinction based on the benefits a product offers to the consumer:
(1) Consumer goods
These products concern the last person in the marketing chain, i.e. the person who buys the product in order to satisfy his own needs or family needs. Consumer goods, themselves, include season goods, shopping goods, and luxury goods.
(2) Industrial goods
Industrial goods are products, which are bought to be sold or manufactured for a profit. However, products are neither consumer products nor industrial products by nature. One may buy a sugar bag for home use; this makes the sugar a consumer good. One may buy a ton of sugar in order to make sweets; here sugar becomes a manufacture good. What applies to the sweets producer applies to the merchant who buys a ton of sugar to re-sell it, or the government, which buys sugar for its citizens' consumption in schools, hospitals, or for the army. The distinction here is between markets and consumers. A purchaser may be a final consumer, or a link in the market-chain or the manufacture-chain. Another product's product duration distinction for is worth is mentioning at the here. of The this
consumption
(29)
basis
distinction. Products are classified as non-perishable, long-lasting products and perishable products perishable products. Personal computers may be categorized, along the definition above, as durable or non-perishable consumer goods when families and individuals buy them for home use. When companies, institutions, or organizations purchase computers, the computers become . A soft drink is a perishable product, while the fridge is a non-perishable product that preserves
Consumer Behavior
283
Chapter 8
manufacture goods. Computers are also shopping goods. Shopping goods are those products which the consumer buys after having gathered, analyzed, and compared information. Consumers look for the best available alternatives and seek to make the best gains.
8.3.3. Product mix
A product mix is a group of products that a company decides to offer on the market. Every company defines its objectives when deciding on the product mix. This is done on the bases of how the company perceives its existence, its growth, and market competition prospects. Some companies prefer to specialize in one product, while others prefer to vary their products. Specialization provides product characteristics and performance improvement potential. It also enables the company to offer consumers high quality services. Product variation attracts different customers, achieves complementarities in satisfying their needs, and saves them time. The choice of specialization or variation (mix) is a matter of strategy that may go back to the early days of the institution or may take place at a given stage of its history.
Product mix has two dimensions:
(a) The width dimension refers to the number of products in the mix, where every product is called a product line. (b) The depth dimension refers to type, shape, and color variation in every product line, where every product is called an item.
284
Consumer Behavior
Like a newborn baby, when a new product comes to existence, it needs a name that distinguishes it from its peers. The brand for a given product may be a name, a symbol, a design, or a combination of the three. Brand distinction has many advantages; it eases product promotion, fosters customer loyalty, and facilitates product storage, transportation, and display. For the consumer, the brand becomes a source of information that allows him to differentiate between products. It may even be the sole criterion he applies to compare the quality of products unknown to him. It spares the consumer time and energy when he does his shopping. Branding encourages producers to compete in order to improve the quality of their products, and build up the best image in the minds of their clients. Indeed, some personal computer brands win their market share and enjoy a good reputation among customers. This is due to an established mental association that has developed between the brand and the high technological quality of the product itself. IBM is a case in point. A trademark or a brand name is a private legal right that preserves the right for production and promotion and denies others the use of that right.
8.3.5. Product Development
Product development is the act of launching a new product in the market or introducing significant improvements on an existing product by modifying its characteristics. Product development
Consumer Behavior
285
Chapter 8
derives from (i) the need to ensure better consumer satisfaction, (ii) competition for customers among producers, and (iii) the need to avoid price competition. The latter ensues from consumers' feeling that rival products do not have any significant difference. The consumer and his needs are central to the product development process; product designers' ingenuity is not enough. Many a time, these wizards produce an artistically outstanding design, which turns into a marketing catastrophe, because they overlooked the consumer's needs, capacities, and circumstances. One should not wonder why new products' failure rate ranges from 33% to 98% in the market. (30)
8.3.6 Product Life Cycle (PLC)
The need for product development has largely to do with what is called product life cycle (PLC). Market products have a life cycle similar to that of humans. It starts with birth, then growth, then maturity, then old age, and then extinction. Because every product ends by leaving the market if it reaches ``old age'', it is necessary to rejuvenate it from time to time. This is achieved through improving it, or by exchanging it for a new product that meets the same needs. Figure 14, below, represents the product life cycle and stresses the importance of product revitalizing research.
286
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
287
Chapter 8
3. The Growth stage
At this stage, the sales rate of the new product increases substantially, and competitors start to emerge, providing rival alternatives, which compete strongly for gaining a large stake of the market. At this stage, advertising focuses on the advantages of a particular brand in comparison with its rivals.
4. The Maturity stage
The maturity stage is reached when (i) the majority of customers have tried the product and got used to it, or (ii) the sale growth has become very slow because of market saturation. More reminding advertisement and price reductions may be needed at this stage to maintain customer loyalty and a high sale rate.
5. The Regression stage
At the regression stage of the product's life cycle, due to technological and needs developments, a large number of consumers move to alternative products and adopt new consumer patterns. Sales start to fall systematically, and the product ceases to yield profits. If the producer failed to implement a life cycle extension, the product's departure from the market becomes imminent.
288
Consumer Behavior
Price has till recently been the index that measures demand. That was logical when products' qualities were similar at the levels of shape and performance. But, modern marketing has given many firms the chance to avoid price competition, which means that winning any larger market share depends on price reduction. It is possible that price competition, in the event of a product's identical characteristics, forces competitors to organize their competition, or even join organizations, as in the case of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC). In fact, many companies avoid competition by introducing certain differentiations among identical products to lure consumers.(32) Nowadays, difference in quality has become a requisite to justify price difference. This poses a clear problem for the technologically mature industry, because quality difference between products is often lacking, i.e. there is nothing to offer in terms of the products' performance or its basic
Consumer Behavior
289
Chapter 8
needs' satisfaction. Therefore, marketers have resorted to tricks, such as styling or changing the product's shape, adopting clearly distinct features for the product, and reshaping it so that it becomes a fashion product. The latter trick is obvious in the car industry and clothes industry. New car models appear annually while new clothes models appear quarterly, i.e. at every new season. Marketers also resort to a multiplicity of advertisements and other promotion techniques in order to produce a strong mental image of the product rather than superficial differential characteristics in consumers' minds. This leads to fairs organization, sales agents training, and the discovery of additional services, like home delivery, information providing, customer training, and deferred payment. All this is done to obtain higher prices, and to escape from the price competition dead-end.
8.4.2 Price and Consumer Division
Price divides consumers into various categories. There are those who can afford it and there are those who cannot. Some markets differ from one another, even when it comes to the same product. There are markets for the high-income class (who can afford high prices), markets for the middle-class (who can afford average prices); and markets for the low-income class (who can afford only low prices). One may claim that some companies grade their products into different levels of quality and price to offer each class what it aspires to acquire within its financial limitations, as Figure 15, below, indicates.
290
Consumer Behavior
Prior to any pricing, firms investigate their own strategic position because price is an obvious weapon for the consumer and the competitor, as well as other influential parties in the market. Factors like the firm's position in the market, its market share, and its history are taken into consideration. This allows for the adoption of the appropriate strategy to launch an advertising campaign and to ward off possible fierce competition. The firm may choose to sell its products only to the rich. It may opt for the skimming strategy or the penetration strategy. In conclusion, it is worth saying that firms have to be cautious when making their choices so that they can avoid any detrimental consequences.(33)
Consumer Behavior
291
Chapter 8
The present study includes a thorough consumer analysis. It analyses types of consumers, (i.e. those of consumer goods or industrial goods), their financial power (high, medium, or low), and their social and economic backgrounds that determine their behavior. The study also includes a thorough analysis of competition; it focuses on whether competition is direct (i.e. between two brands of the same make, e.g. Dell and IBM) or indirect (i.e. between alternatives, e.g. PCs, mobile phones). It is important for the firm to know the competitors' schemes and degrees of marketing mix in order to identify its opponents' strengths and weaknesses. Finally, the study covers the market's other forces, e.g. brokers, relevant government agencies, and even consumer protection organizations and the mass media.
2. Pricing and marketing mix
A firm has to set the relationship between the price that it fixes and the marketing mix, in order to better its competitiveness. It is a fact that market forces are not influenced by particular sectors in the marketing mix; the consumer's decisions, for instance, reflect that mix, and competitors plan their reactions in the light of the strength of the product that the firm offers. The repercussions of any mix extend to brokers and other market forces. The components of the marketing mix, including price, product, dissemination, and promotion, are competition weapons and represent ways of attracting consumers. The more the mix is balanced, the more it ensures the firm's relative strength in facing competition, and the more it appeals to consumers. It is inconceivable for a firm to set a high price for low-quality products, or in the absence of an adequate dissemination or promotion.
3. Pricing methods
A firm may price a product in different ways; some methods are traditional and some are modern.
292
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
293
Chapter 8
8.4.5 Discount (36)
Firms offer various discounts as common practice. They also offer discounts to achieve specific marketing goals. Types of discount include:
a. Trade discount
Trade discount is for traders only; it is in exchange for undertaking marketing functions on behalf of the producer. This is why trade discount is sometimes referred to as functional discount.
b. Cash discount
Cash discount accelerates payment and increases cash flow rate and capital in the firm.
c. Quantity discount
Firms use this method to encourage consumers to purchase larger quantities of products. Quantity discount aims at increasing the firm's market share and product circulation. It is offered at each sale exchange or on a number of sale exchanges over a fixed period.
d. Seasonal discount
Seasonal discounts are suitable clearances or occasions. Firms rely on seasonal sales to dispose of current products or to recover some capital that they may lose.
e. Promotional discount
Producers offer distributors promotional discounts in exchange of particular promotional or stimulating activities, such as product advertisement or fair organization.
8.4.6 Product Mix Pricing
(37)
Some firms may resort to establishing a link at the level of pricing between products that complement one another. Firms have
294
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
295
Chapter 8
Endnotes of Chapter 8
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) Hanna, Nassem, Al-Ghadeer, H. and Assaed, R., Abdulhameed, T. A.,
(7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) (21) (22) (23) (24)
Ba-Zara'h, M. S.,
Idrees, T. A. and Al Gaiss, M. R., Al-Ghadeer, H. and Assaed, R., Wilkie, W. L.,
Marketing Principles, Consumer Behavior, Effective Marketing, Market Management, Marketing Principles, Fundamentals of Marketing, Fundamentals of Marketing, Consumer Behavior, Fundamentals of Marketing, Marketing: Essentials and Principles, Advertisement, Fundamentals of Marketing, Marketing Management, Marketing: Essentials and Principles, Market Management, Consumer Behavior, Consumer Behavior, Market Management, Consumer Behavior, Consumer Behavior,
op. cit., p. 269. op. cit., pp. 529-530. op. cit., pp. 274 -280. op. cit., p. 452. op. cit., pp. 506-507. op. cit. p. 243. op. cit., p. 12. op. cit., p. 294. op. cit., 1990, p. 523. op. cit., p. 526.
Al-Abdalli, Q. and Al-Allaaq, B., Ibid., pp. 275-277. Harb, B. H., Kaamel, A.,
Fundamentals of Marketing,
"How to Protect
Misleading
Information,"
Majallat Al-Mustahlik, Issue No. 2, Year 3, 1995, p. 6. (25) Okaaz (newspaper), Issue No. 11778 (Date 15-2-1996), "The Focus of Consumer Spending on Women and Advertisements", Riyadh, 1996., op. cit., p. 5. (26) (27) (28) Kotler, P. H., Hassan, S. A.,
(29)
Abdulhameed, T. A.,
296
Consumer Behavior
Ibid., p. 337. Hassan, S. A., Ibid., p. 195. Ibid., p. 196. Ibid., p. 200. Ibid., p. 205.
Review,
Harvard Business
Consumer Behavior
297
Chapter 9
Implications of Studying the Saudi Family's PC Purchase Decision
Chapter Topics
9.1 Scientic Implications 9.2 Practical Implications
This chapter deals with the academic and practical implications of the Saudi family's decision to buy a PC. It also analyzes the attitudes and behavior of the Saudi family, when buying a PC. The analysis includes the following aspects: D the diffusion rate of the PC in Saudi families; D favorite PC brands; D how the family views the advantages of owning a PC; D PC ownership motives; D the intensiveness of PC use at home; D technological change impact on the speed of purchase decisionmaking; D the time and the effort the family puts into the pre-purchase phase; D sales-outlets the family visits for purchasing; D the roles of salespersons at sales-outlets; D the major difficulties of the purchase process; D the Saudi family's attitude towards innovativeness and opinion leadership; and D the relative roles played by the family members throughout the phases of the purchasing process.
Consumer Behavior
301
The use rate of PCs in average and high income Saudi families is approximately 75% (Figure 16): one third of them owns more than one PC for domestic use (Figure 17). The other two thirds are keen to acquire well-known trademark computers, like IBM, HP, Dell, and Compaq (Figure 18) as an indication of their adherence to specific quality standards and avoidance of the risk of buying unknown brand computers. Also,
Consumer Behavior
303
Chapter 9
one third is keen to upgrade their system capabilities in order to keep up with latest developments (Figure 19). The results indicate that families keep their personal computer for five years in average (Figure 20). Twenty-five percent of the families keep their PC for over five years. At the same time, four out of five Saudi families have added printers to their personal computers and established Internet connections, and half of them have acquired scanners (Figure 21). Approximately, 70% of families who do not own a personal computer are expected to own one within a year. Demographic factors affect the time span of retaining a PC in a Saudi Family. These factors, with the exception of family size and spouse job-type, have a strong bearing on the initiative to buy a PC. One remarkable observation the study has revealed is that the more educated parents are and the higher their income is, the more likely they are to acquire a PC. This observation seems to apply more to families in the Eastern and Western Provinces than to those in the Northern and Central Provinces. Results also indicate that PC owners differ dramatically in their demographic qualities from non-owners (p<0.03). Owner families
304
Consumer Behavior
tend to be residing in villas in the Western, Eastern and Central Provinces. They are high income, small to medium-sized families where the wives are enjoy more opportunities of employment. and possibly PC Husbands the most normally middle-aged (35-45) that
professionals or businessmen. The study has revealed clearly that significant demographic factors determine ownership are income, education, type of residence and family size. The tendencies of multi-PC owners are influenced and by their
demographic
background
(p<0.05).
Material
educational
superiority is a discriminating variable in this respect. Multi-PC owners are mostly small size families living in villas in the Central Region and enjoy high incomes. Fathers in these families are of average age holding graduate and postgraduate degrees. Wives in these families often hold jobs outside their houses. Income, family size and type of residence have been found to be the most
influential demographic variables that explain variance between owners of multi PCs and owners of a single PC. Families who are keen to upgrade their PCs capacity or speed differ demographically with regard to family size. Large families are
relatively keener on expanding their PC system capabilities. Such families normally enjoy higher
are yet to purchase a PC, is highly dependent on their demographic background. It has been found
with the financial capability and the educational (Figure level 22). of the Some
parents
Consumer Behavior
305
Chapter 9
significant
differences
exist
within
the
non-owners
category.
Potential buyers (within one year) have a positive attitude towards the product as compared to those who do not intend to buy a PC soon. Families who are in the process of making plans to buy a PC in the near future consider the PC instrumental in solving their work problems, planning family expenses, helping with children's education, providing a source of information, and being an incentive for distinction and high productivity. They even regard it as a necessity, contrary to the other category, which is viewed as an unjustified investment, a source of problems, and a technology that benefits only professionals and businessmen. Families expected to buy PCs soon due to high involvement in the purchase process are very much aware of the importance of: quality, specifications, trade mark, sale terms and conditions, after sale services, retail store, and salesmen approaches.
members. However, the negative attitude towards the PC, as shown in the study findings, is based on the assumption that it wastes time
306
Consumer Behavior
and secludes family members and makes them less interested in practicing sports. Even though the majority of the study sample believes in the utility of the PC and maintains a positive view of the useful functions it can perform at home, positions vary from one family to another according to the demographic background. Results show that family positions are highly affected by such factors as region, family income, and level of parents' education and occupation. Positive attitude towards this product as being a means to solve work problems depends on family income, type of residence and wife's education. As an important means of information, the PC is positively associated with income and father's qualification. However, its use as a means of entertainment is associated with factors like cultural background, income and family size. Families that live in big houses, where wives hold high degrees - compared to uneducated mothers who are members of small families - take into consideration the negative effects of owning a PC. They consider it a potential time-waster (Figure 24). Perceiving the PC as an unjustified investment is lower in the case of high income and small size families. In the case of families where wives are working women, they are less likely to perceive or consider PC addictive.
Consumer Behavior
307
Chapter 9
of others, and keeping pace with the social class of the family concerned (Figure 25). The above motives depend on the family's demographic background. Furthermore, high income and father qualifications enhance the need for the PC, particularly in the case of working wives. In addition, the introduction of the Internet, and the use of e-mail are significant motives in the case of high income and small sized families. 9.1.4 Purchase Decision Factors
1. Constant Specification Developments
The majority of Saudi families realize the impact of rapid technological change on the PC purchase decision time. Taking one's time in making the PC purchase decision brings about benefits to the buyer. These may be at the following levels: speed, memory capacity, size, weight, and even price.
2. Purchase Decision Motives
The purchase decision is affected by two sets of motives: personal and external. The personal motives are particularly manifest in reconciling the conflicting wants of family members and in the absence of previous experience in purchasing a PC. The most important external motives are particularly manifest in quality, price, trust in the retail store, sale terms and conditions, salesperson's conduct, and marketing incentives, such as advertising, discounts, and bonus gifts (Figure 26).
308
Consumer Behavior
Evidently, families differ in perceiving the above factors according to their demographic backgrounds, let alone the variables of income, family size, father's age and occupation. Income and father's age account for the income variable. Low income, together with young age, makes price a significant variable in the purchase of a specific PC. High income makes quality significant among small size families living in the Western and Southern Provinces. The significance of the brand/trademark is emphasized in the case of fathers who are young businessmen in large households. Residents of small and medium size households are more concerned about the PC specifications, while the post-purchase services are greatly emphasized by high income, small size families. The salesperson's conduct is of significance to small size families with uneducated mothers. Residents of the Central and Northern Provinces, as well as low income population, reflect the influence of advertising. Young, uneducated fathers are also greatly interested in the bonus gifts and discounts offered by retail stores.
Chapter 9
Also, previous experience is related to the father's education, wife's employment and accommodation type. Also, friends and colleagues' recommendations are negatively related to the father's level of education, while a wife's employment implies more concern about privileges, such as guarantee and maintenance offered by vendors.
B. Preference of Specific Sales Outlets
The most important reasons for selecting a particular sales outlet when buying a PC are mainly related to post-purchase services, the good conduct of the salesperson, previous experience with the outlet, and prices. These variables are greatly consistent with the Saudi family motives to own a PC and the obstacles they face in the purchase process. The present study indicates that the preferred traditional PC sales outlet is the specialized agent and the department store.
C. PC Replacement
The purchase decision may not necessarily be for a new PC, but merely for upgrading a present one. The reasons that mostly motivate the Saudi family to upgrade their PC are new releases of hardware and / or software and the incompatibility of the existing system with new task requirements. In addition, the family should be able to afford the costs of upgrading. These objective reasons are considered more important than social motives, such as bragging and imitation (Figure 28). The difference in recognizing these reasons lies in particular in the demographic background of the family. Replacement due to new specifications depends on
310
Consumer Behavior
parents' education and spouse's employment type. As for affording the costs of PC upgrading, it is related to such factors as family size, father's age and spouse employment. Recognition of the system malfunctioning is related to spouse education and employment. Imitation of others is influenced by all the factors mentioned above, except geographical location and father's age. As for the family's general reasons for exchanging a PC, they are related to such factors as geographical area and spouse occupation. It should be noted that the impact of these variables is not equal since the income variable explains more some social motives associated with PC upgrading such as imitation and bragging as in the case of low income population. Rational motives for changing computers, such as the introduction of new systems, are largely influenced by the mother's employment. The capability to afford a PC replacement seems higher among small size families. The family desire to replace a PC appears higher among families where the father has a profession or a business, and the mother is employed.
9.1.5 Pre-Purchase Activities
The technical complexity of the product as a durable commodity that represents a highly important asset drives the Saudi family to take some logical steps before buying (Figure 29): a. The Saudi family visits 3-4 showrooms prior to the purchase process to get the best offer as to specification, price and terms of payment. This reflects a high sense of risk-taking. b. The Saudi family takes a period of one to two weeks in the
Consumer Behavior
311
Chapter 9
search process and selection taking before
the purchase decision. Some families may take more time (Figure 30). c. The retail stores which Saudi families visit are primarily distributors specialist professional and departments
in department stores. Furthermore, concern about collecting more information through visits to as many showrooms the as possible process and is proceeding by painstakingly through selection influenced
variables like geographic area, income, spouse job, and husband qualifications. The husband's high education level often results in further visits to showrooms.
field. As for subjective obstacles, they are related to the difficulty in satisfying family members' desires and the feeling of time pressure to make decisions.
312
Consumer Behavior
Awareness of the above obstacles is related to the demographic background of the family, including type of residence, wife employment, income, and family size. Families with wives holding government or private sector jobs undergo some confusion and hesitation due to the technological changes in addition to the insufficient help on the part of the salesperson and the time limit to take the purchase decision. Family members of businessmen and professionals feel that their desires are difficult to reconcile within a limited time for decision-making. Fathers, with a modest education level, complain about not receiving proper technical advice and feel they lack experience in purchasing computers.
9.1.7 Sales Outlet Preference Motives
Once the Saudi family enters the next phase in the purchase process, it gives preference to the sales outlet that offers a good post-purchase service and reasonable prices, as well as to the salesperson's expertise and good behavior. These results are consistent with the findings on the obstacles the family faces in the purchase process and the need for assistance in taking the proper decision. Families have been found to prefer the renowned outlets recommended by professionals and friends, whereas other factors such as location vicinity, terms of payment and advertising have some significance still (Figure 32). Included in the preference process is the role the salesman plays in recognizing the customer's needs and assisting him to take the appropriate decision. The additional information the salesman provides is decisive since it may lead to the selection of a specific trademark. Accordingly, buyers attach high importance to the salesperson's qualities like
Consumer Behavior
313
Chapter 9
tactfulness,
eloquence, honesty
welland
informedness,
integrity (Figure 33). The demographic background of sales the concerned preference in area, on the the like Factors families of the the Saudi influences society.
outlet
residence basis of
type, income, parents' education, and wife employment affect the familiarity. At the same time, the type of residence, geographic area and father's job are associated with the choice of a specific sales-outlet on the basis of its proximity to family residence. In addition, the geographic area, father qualifications and type of wife employment play an important role in selecting the outlet that offers a wide variety of products at reasonable price. The findings of the present study also point type out of that some
demographic
variables,
especially
income,
residence,
geographic area, family size, father's qualifications and type of wife employment, explicate the above differences more than others. Of all these variables, income and wife employment are the most significant. Making a purchase decision on the basis of familiarity with a specific outlet is significantly associated with father's age and education, contrary to making that decision on price basis. Low income families prefer the installment sale system. The post-
purchase service effect was found to be associated with income and wife employment factors.
314
Consumer Behavior
family (Figure 34). All variables, except for the type of residence, area, and income have an impact on the incongruity of these roles from one family to the other. They include family size, parents' education, mother's employment, and occupation and age of father. The variables that best expound the variability among these roles are father's age, education, mother's employment and family size. Mother's occupation and father's age and education are decisive factors in taking unanimous or unilateral decisions as regards the need for a PC. The role the mother or children individually play in data collection is noticeable in families living in large houses with young educated parents. Collective decisions are sometimes taken as regards purchase timing in small size families and where the mother is highly educated and the father of old age. The mother's role in defining the alternatives is clear, particularly when the father is young and his wife holds a high degree. However, all members participate in selecting the PC trademark and specifications in the small sized families where the father is young, highly educated, in business or the professions, and the mother is a housewife. The small-size, low income families, with a highly educated father and an employed mother, are consistently concerned about terms of payment, particularly the installment system. Highly educated parents and young fathers always take collective purchase decisions. The high income families with highly educated mothers and young fathers working as businessmen or professionals set a good example of the common use of the PC. They participate collectively in the actual purchasing. In small-size families, the parents do the actual purchasing, especially if the father is young and highly educated and his wife has an occupation.
Consumer Behavior
315
Chapter 9
The description and analysis of the Saudi family behavior associated with PC use is one of the significant contributions of the present study. The average daily use of a home computer in Saudi Arabia is found to be 3-5 hours. Field investigations show that 55% of the families use PC for 3 hours or more per day, and 10% use it for 6 hours or more per day. The father's use of the PC is the most intensive compared to the children's and the mother's. The mother's use, however, falls way behind (Figure 35). Also the family's demographic background is found to influence the PC use. Except for family size, spouse education and type of parents' employment, all other variables affect the use rate of the PC. Results indicate that some demographic variables are discriminating factors among families in this regard, as in the case of high income families who use the PC for longer periods particularly in the Eastern, Western and Southern provinces. This state of affairs stands in comparison to the Central and Northern provinces. PC use difference among family members is related to family demographic background variables, such as residence, geographic area, family income, and father's age and occupation. Furthermore, the wife's use of the PC is influenced by the family size, and type of her occupation. However, the children's PC use rate is affected by all the demographic variables investigated in this study. Some demographic variables are found to be more significant than others in explaining the variability of PC use within the family: employed fathers tend to use the PC more than unemployed ones.
316
Consumer Behavior
The older the father, especially in the Western and Eastern Provinces, the more his use increases. The small-size families with employed mothers make much use of the PC. Children of large families who live in large houses tend to use computers excessively, especially if the mother is uneducated and the father is young.
9.1.10 Recommending to Others to Buy the Same PC
From a theoretical standpoint, recommending a specific PC to a third party may be taken as a sign of customer satisfaction and an indication of the recommending party's role as a source of information and a guide to relatives and acquaintances. Findings indicate that 42% of the sample population has always been ready to recommend the same PC to others, and 47% have been potential volunteer advisers when asked for advice.
9.1.11 Behavioral Characteristics of the Study Sample
1. Tendency to innovate and to adopt new products
The distribution of the innovativeness quality in Saudi families matches the findings of earlier studies on the normal distribution of this quality in societies in general (Figure 36). Innovators have been found to be 22% compared to 16% in earlier studies; the pioneer innovators represent 47% compared to 50% in studies. Looking more closely into the results, we find that those lagging behind in acquiring new products amount to 52% compared to 50% in earlier studies. Accordingly, it can be concluded that the study sample shows a slight increase in attitude towards innovativeness. This attitude is an expected behavior of the sample. Saudi families did, indeed, make a rush for PC acquisition.
Consumer Behavior
317
Chapter 9
The family's demographic background is found to correlate significantly with innovativeness and possession of new products. Dwellers of the Southern, Central and Eastern regions are found to be the most innovative. Also, high income families living in large houses are found to have a positive attitude towards innovativeness. Moreover, highly educated parents, especially computer science specialists, have exhibited a growing interest in innovation. The income variable is found to be the most discriminating factor in the innovativeness attitude among families. Using innovativeness as an independent variable that explains the family behavior on making the PC purchase decision has proved effective in various cases. Innovators are more positively interested in PCs because they assist in solving work problems and planning family expenses. They also give their purchasers a feeling of success and a sense of distinction. The findings also indicate that innovators never postpone the purchasing process for the sake of obtaining technological or economic advantages; they run after buying new products as soon as they appear on the market (Figure 37). They are always pioneers in buying a PC, and this explains the fact that they possess a PC ahead of all others. In general, they use PCs for longer periods and are less hesitant than others in selecting specifications. Also, technical assistance and purchase experience or timing are insignificant to them, and so is the proximity of the sales-outlet. They never deal with a particular distributor merely for feasible sale conditions, or on an acquaintance's advice or even an expert's recommendation. Finally, innovators are less inclined to replace their PCs just to satisfy their
318
Consumer Behavior
family members' desires. As for non-innovators, they are more concerned about issues of price, vendor, sale conditions, bonus gifts, and discounts.
2. Opinion leadership
The sample population shows a balanced attitude towards opinion leadership in society. Some give advice to their neighbors, while others seek advice before making the purchase decision. They prefer to shop with trustworthy friends and, in most cases, follow the advice of others, even when it conflicts with their own
viewpoint. According to the and present spouse study, the geographic are area, the father most
qualifications,
employment
among
significant demographic variables influencing the readiness to lead or to be led. As for shopping in the company of a trusted person, it is affected by all variables, except family size and spouse
employment. It should also be noted that consumers in the Eastern and Western Provinces are more inclined to leading others. Also, parents' low level of education makes them more prone to
following others' opinions, by accompanying those they trust when shopping, or by accepting their opinions, even if conflicting with their own. The study shows that opinion leaders have a positive attitude towards the PC as a means of help in: solving work problems, being a source of information and useful entertainment, feeling up-todate and superior to others, and increasing productivity. They are, therefore, early owners of PCs, and they have had them much longer than others. They tend to take collective purchase decisions within their families, especially at the stage of expressing the need for a PC. The families of opinion leaders use PCs more intensively than others. However, opinion leadership implies more confusion when making
Consumer Behavior
319
Chapter 9
trademark-related decisions. This may be due to the diversity and plethora of information, which they have mustered and which offers them various options. Compared to others, opinion leaders are more ready to replace their PCs as soon as new specifications appear on the market. In addition, they can financially afford to buy new ones.
320
Consumer Behavior
Consumer Behavior
321
Chapter 9
its
characteristic
techniques
and
interaction
The PC high penetration in the Saudi households implies renewed supplementary markets for the purchased PCs to back up the hardware and software maintenance, and to supply spare the to parts, peripherals, desire and to accessories. upgrade and their These PC's Some constitute very profitable potential markets. The present study highlights capabilities customers' ensure high capacity speed.
consumers apply this viewpoint in a different way, by delaying the purchase decision pending updated technical devices and available economic offers. Thanks to the nature of PC manufacturing, a technology that is constantly in progress, and thanks to the planned obsolescence strategies practiced by some manufacturers, the computer industry has become very promising and represents an ever-developing market that could accommodate new enterprises in various domains, including software, accessories, training services, and Internet services. 4. The fact that one of every four households in Saudi Arabia is a PC non-owner denotes a potential marketing opportunity to change these prospective customers into actual owners. This will largely require a new strategy on the part of marketers to cope with this sector, especially that the reasons behind delaying the purchase of a PC include such factors as high price, unfamiliarity with the nature and the positive role of the PC in family life, or perhaps social and cultural reservations as to their possible negative and unsafe uses. Delayed acquisition has nothing to do with the inherent nature of the product itself. A further proof is furnished by the fact that the Saudi
322
Consumer Behavior
family hastens to acquire such products as cars, as well as home and personal appliances. A parallel, equally lucrative market for personal computers could easily develop. 5. It should be noted that the growing integration of some
interrelated technologies including computer, information, and communications as well as the recreation industry will create a new generation of integrated computers, mobile phones and some household appliances, like TVs, with the aim of performing personal and domestic tasks. This will also require the integration of completely new software and accessories to support such a trend that will entail new marketing techniques and strategies. 6. In making a decision like to buy a PC, HP, the LG were Saudi and family
experiences a sense of high risk. Thus, it prefers to turn to famous brands IBM, DELL, Compaq, geared particularly when their prices have become reasonable and competitive nowadays. Saudi families more towards some low-priced assembled computers. These made it possible for more families to acquire their PCs. The recent turn towards the well-known brands in the PC purchasing process will help eliminate the sense of risk, especially and regarding brands product capabilities, have post-purchase reasonable are services and
other consumer benefits. The high performance of established whose prices and become whose performance price. 7. PC marketers will find the way paved for them for marketing their products since the current and target consumers have a positive attitude towards the PC in general. In spite of the fact that the attitude of the present consumers towards PCs is more positive than that of potential consumers, there is an overall tendency to consider the PC with clear enthusiasm. Such a post-purchase services satisfactory
explain the rising demand for them despite their relative high
Consumer Behavior
323
Chapter 9
positive interest might be adduced to considering the PC as one of life's necessities due to its influential role in information, entertainment, education and the economy. As an indispensable commodity, the PC will be less affected by price fluctuations. This, in turn, will ensure a reasonable sales rate. Marketers should take this fact into consideration when planning such marketing strategies as prices, promotion, distribution, and services. 8. The success of computer brands depends mainly on their economic competitiveness as viewed by customers, particularly with regard to price, post-purchase services, and product quality. Customer calculation of risk factors associated with the purchase process makes such variables as familiarity with brands and advice from friends or acquaintances more significant than the advertisement provided by the brand marketers. Consequently, the proper handling of the marketing communications process requires more emphasis on developing a product image suggestive of high quality and technical reliability. 9. PC marketers should make every effort to provide customers with as much information as possible to help them make a wise decision. Customers will definitely visit many showrooms to obtain information before taking the purchase decision. This implies the need of PC marketers to use accessible media with rich content, such as printed material and Internet sites. Marketers also need to train salespersons to provide the right information to those seeking it and interested in buying. The attitudes towards the pursuit of relevant information vary according to the demographic background of the family, especially parents' education. Data collected show that Saudi families face problems in taking purchase decisions. Also, families need assistance when choosing from among brands and specifications, particularly those unfamiliar with computer technology, have no previous experience with the PC, are
324
Consumer Behavior
facing purchase pressure, and need to balance the desires of family members. This reflects the significance of knowledgeable and technically skilled salespersons and the availability of suitable information for the purchase process. It should be noted that the purchase process difficulties vary according to the previous experience, technical expertise and education level of the head of the family. 10. The emergence of the Internet and e-mail as modern means of communication motivates customers to own a PC.
Therefore, a derived demand for PCs and their accessories turns out to be an indicator of a new interaction between the need for PCs as such and the need for information and communication technology. Other motives that encourage
customers to possess PCs include entertainment, learning assistance, and house management. In addition to these socioeconomic factors, marketers should adopt other strategies in their advertising campaigns to promote a sense of distinction, modernity, and association with the family's social class. The urgency degree of those needs depends on the demographic background of the family. High income families are more concerned with using the system for information purposes, while families with working parents are interested in its use in learning and work productivity. 11. Rapid technological advances in computer capabilities can be exploited to promote the sale of PCs. This applies more to families of higher income and higher education. 12. PC marketing strategists should take into consideration the viewpoint that the Saudi family purchase decision is influenced by quality and price in the first place; then comes the influence of vendors' reliability, sale terms, post-purchase services, salespersons' behavior; last comes the influence of advertising,
Consumer Behavior
325
Chapter 9
discounts and bonus gifts. This will help marketers design a marketing mix suitable for each market segment. For example, price represents an incentive to young fathers and low income families; quality is considered significant by those in the southern and western provinces; it is also considered significant by high income, small-size families with working mothers. 13. To the intensive use of the PC for long hours in the family corresponds a growing need for such equipment, its accessories and software. PC marketing opportunities targeting such families will also increase according to factors such as family size and income and father's age and employment. 14. When developing their marketing communication strategy, PC marketers may find it necessary to classify their target consumers into distinct categories. They should lay emphasis on the category of opinion leaders and innovators because of their influence on prospective customers. PC owners, who have positive attitudes towards the product, are very likely to relay their attitude to others, and thus contribute to promoting the products and influencing decision-making. This reflects the importance of the word-of-mouth in decision-making. 15. The study findings reveal the significance of recruiting friendly salespeople who are capable of providing technical assistance and adequate information, which help alleviate customers' anxiety and sense of risk and facilitate their decision-making. Sales outlets should make available a sufficient variety of alternatives and provide easy sale conditions and adequate post-purchase services. It is also important to build consumers' confidence and loyalty to the brand and sales outlet so that they become regular customers. In this respect, marketers should take into consideration consumer categories. For example, low income and wife employment may entail an interest in an installment-sale system, while a husband's high qualification may imply a desire to choose from a wide range of products.
326
Consumer Behavior
16. Analysis of the Saudi family members' differential roles in the purchase decision process reveals fathers as being the most influential and significant. This can be interpreted in light of the cultural context, in addition to the nature of the target product itself. However, it is of vital importance to marketing strategists not to overlook the children's role in the decisionmaking process, as their voice for the need for a PC (for purposes of entertainment, education, information, etc.) can be loud and clear within the family. Children also participate in gathering information and setting alternatives, specifications and purchase time. Furthermore, the mother's role is somewhat significant, particularly in expressing the need for the PC, collecting information, and setting the purchase time, specifications and alternatives. The above separate roles do not preclude a unanimous decision in many cases, where demographic background of the family influences the roles of its members in this process. This might have some implications in the area of marketing communications, salespersons' training, and product development. 17. The widespread use of PCs by Saudi families makes it one of the most important means of advertising, sales promotion, public relations and publication in future. Its significance will rise particularly in the field of marketing consumer goods. Integration of the PC with other related ones, e.g. TV and mobile phones, enhances its significant role. Consequently, marketers are required to develop more ingenious messages that match those changes. 18. Computer systems, accessories and software industries might require allocating more funds to research & development (R&D) in order to produce items that satisfy the family requirements as a computer market distinct from the market of computer systems developed for business, education, or government. The PC industry is still in need of further development to overcome its shortcomings in meeting family
Consumer Behavior
327
Chapter 9
needs and providing new advantages that make the PC more useful to the family. Development can be directed towards producing low price PCs that require lesser maintenance while being reliable. 19. It might be in the best interest of PC manufacturers and marketers to subsidize computer literacy programs or training centers. This will undoubtedly lead to an increase in demand for PCs and their accessories, particularly family PCs.
9.2.2 Implications for the Information and Communication Industry in Saudi Arabia
1. The widespread use of PCs in Saudi households indicates that more consideration should be given to developing information and communication services to foster even further the strong appeal customers have for PCs, which gives the Saudi family access to the up-to-date technologies. This necessitates the existence of sufficient Internet services and fast communication networks. 2. The interface of PC's and various information and communication services implies growing opportunities to sell more of these services, as long as producers are aware of the modern advances in the PC world as regards configurations, accessories and software. 3. The findings reveal that the integration of the PC industry with other information and communication industries is inevitable. Future households are expected to have one central system for all purposes: entertainment, education, communication and information. 4. The aforementioned underscores the need for an integrated government role in the fields cited above to ensure proper control and customer protection. The concerned departments
328
Consumer Behavior
could include Ministries of Commerce, Education, Information, Planning, Saudi Telecom and The King Abdulaziz City for Science and Technology. 5. Consequently, research centers and universities interested in computer science, information and communication applications may have to be engaged in further related research projects. The use of PCs as an e-commerce channel will give rise to issues related to type of services rendered, providers' credibility, and the role of e-commerce in consumer welfare and national economy development. The potential use of the PC as an alternative means to accomplish tasks at a distance or transfer work sites to households will eliminate the barriers of time and place in carrying out business. This might entail a change in the economic system and, consequently, there will arise a demand for developing new products and services to keep pace with such radical changes.
6.
7.
2.
Consumer Behavior
Chapter 9
problem of information validity and source reliability. As the computer gives access to unlimited sources of information, the individual will likely become confused as to what information to believe and what source to trust. Therefore, the individual needs a means by which he can establish the reliability of sources and the validity of information. In this regard, educational institutions have major responsibilities. They have to adopt specific objectives emphasizing the development of suitable study skills, such as: how to search for particular information; how to weigh the validity of information, and how to establish the reliability of the source. 3. The recommended objectives, as well as the effective and efficient use of the PC, require mastery of language skills, particularly reading and writing. Therefore, school curricula have to be revised so as to give priority to the skills of critical reading and writing. Emphasis is to be laid on Arabic. Once mastery of Arabic is ensured, then foreign languages can be introduced, particularly English, because of its significant use worldwide. 4. In order to protect PC users from harmful influence, particularly from Internet sources, there is great need, more than ever before, to equip potential users at an early age with a furqaan (criterion that distinguishes between right and wrong, good and evil). The Qur'an and the Sunnah embody the required furqaan. Equipped with the furqaan, the individual can deal with all sorts of problems successfully. Thus, educational institutions have to maintain their Islamic aims and curriculum, with particular emphasis on the practicalities of Internet problems. 5. The family as a consumer should be protected from possible exploitation by electronic trade channels. For example, there has to be coordination between the legal authorities in the
330
Consumer Behavior
Kingdom with those of other countries in order to establish proper procedures of dealing with disputes that arise in ecommerce. 6. The positive cultural aspects of the PC should be put to use to enhance the right social and religious values. The responsibility for this task will be laid upon the Ministry of Information and that of Awqaaf (Endowments). 7. Both Ministries of Education and Higher Education will need to develop their curricula and teaching methods to adapt to the modern technological advances in the PC use, since electronic alternatives could emerge, like distance learning or educational integration of home, school and university. 8. The cultural and educational implications of the PC might extend to include the government role in subsidizing it to make it within the reach of low income citizens. Computer literacy has become a modern requirement to the extent that computer illiterates are regarded as underdeveloped. In that regard, the government has great responsibilities towards the poor, who need computer literacy as much as they need food, clothing and medicine.
9.2.4. Economic and Protective Implications
The growing role of the PC in the family and individual's life will involve daily productivity and quality decisions as regards the household and office PC integration. In the long run, society is expected to have a high productivity rate of goods and services at a low cost, enhancing family and individual welfare. Due to the clear difference between the salesman and the buyer in technical and information capabilities, the PC market will need business rules as regards customer protection from manipulation and post-purchase service excessive costs. Consumers will find it difficult to judge service quality and costs. Also, protection can be
Consumer Behavior
331
Chapter 9
also provided by ensuring the availability of spare parts; appliances become valueless in case the production of their spare parts is brought to a halt. Without spare parts, consumers find themselves compelled to buy new expensive brands, benefiting manufacturers and marketers, regardless of consumers' interest. Customer protection can also be extended to provide a variety of purchase alternatives and eliminate market monopoly. A wide range of alternatives is in the best interest of the consumer, who will exercise his right to make the choice he sees fit. Consumers' freedom of choice is considered a consumer welfare parameter. The authorities responsible for macro-economic planning in Saudi Arabia, especially in the field of industry, might need to develop indigenous computer industry, in total or in part. This will contribute to the increase of GNP, and provide employment opportunities for capable Saudis. The government may find in the PC a direct, positive, and low-cost channel to address its citizens effectively regarding matters of information, security and politics. It can also provide effective government services related to passports, traffic, civil registry, commercial or industrial registry offices, driving licenses, permissions, and customs and quality certifications. Computer literacy might turn to be a national duty for both the private sector and the government. The role the PC plays in our family lives is growing day by day so much that computer illiteracy has come to supplant traditional illiteracy. Diligent efforts to prepare more people to use computer technology are an important boost to the country's economic capabilities in terms of added value that labor contributes to the GNP.
332
Consumer Behavior
References
References
(1)
(2).
Marketing,
Beirut,
Dar
Al-Nahdhah
Al-
Arabiyyah for Printing and Publishing, 1983. (3) Abdul-Hameed, Tal'at As'ad,
(Arabic),
Dar Al-
Mirreekh for Publishing, Riyadh, 2001. (5) Alawi, H. M., and Al-Misri, M. A., ``Behavioral Characteristics of the Saudi Buyer at Self-Service Stores: a Field Study in Riyadh'', Research Center, King Saud University, Riyadh, 1983. (6) Al-Abdaly, Qahtan and Al-Allaq, Basheer,
(Arabic),
Amman, Dar Zahran for publishing and distributing, 1999. (7) Al-Ba'albakki, Munir, 1991. (8)
Al-Mawrid
Al-Eqtesadiyyah,
Date: 25/10/1993),
``Marketing Is Not a Selling Activity'', Riyadh. (9) Al-Fawzan, A. M., ``Road Master or Road Disaster,''
(10)
Al-Ghadeer, Hamad and Al-Saed, Rashad, (Arabic), Amman, Dar Zahran, 1997.
(11)
Al-Haaj,
Amman,
Safa'a
Mohamed Salih, Marketing Management: Introduction to Systems and Strategies, (Arabic), Dar Al-Jami'aat Al-Misriyyah, Alexandria, 1984. Al-Jeraisy, Khaled A., ``Analysis of Consumer's Decision in the Purchase
(13)
Process'', Ph. D. dissertation, Kensington University, U.S. A., 2003. (14) Al-Khateeb, Fatima Abdullah, ``Social and Cultural Changes and their Impact on the Urban Saudi Family'', College of Arts, Alexandria University, 1995, pp. 105-107. (15) Al-Musa'id, Zaki Khaleel,
Zahran for Publishing and Distribution, 1997. (16) Al-Nimr, S. M., ``The Working Saudi Woman: a Field Study on a Sample of
Consumer Behavior
333
References
(17) (18) (19) (20) (21) (22) (23) (24) (25) (26) (27) (28) (29) (30) (31) (32) (33) (34) (35) (36) (37) Working Saudi Women in Riyadh'', Research Center, King Saud University, Riyadh, 1988. Al-Obaidi, I. M., ``Factors Related to the Family Pattern in Riyadh'', Gulf and Arabian Peninsula Studies, Issue No. 81, Year 21, 1996. Al-Turky, S.A.,'' Decision-Making in the Saudi Family'', College of Social Sciences, Imam Mohamed Ibn-Saud Islamic University, Riyadh, 1407H. Askar, S. M., Management Principles, Dar Al-Qalam, Dubai, 1987. Assaaf, M., Fundamentals of Marketing, Dar Al-Nashir Al-Arabi, Cairo, 1972. Assaaf, M., Fundamentals of Advertisement, Dar Al-Nashir Al-Arabi, Cairo, 1975. Assael, H., Consumer Behavior and Marketing Action, 2nd edition, Boston, Kent, 1987. Assulami, Ali, Marketing Research, A Behaviorist Approach (Arabic), 2nd. ed., Cairo, Dar Al-Ma'aarif, 1969. Ba-Zar'ah, M. S., Marketing Management, Volume II, Dar Al-Nahdha Al Arabiyya, Cairo, 1985. Cooper, L. G., and Akihiro Inoue, ``Building Market Structure from Consumer Preferences,'' Journal of Marketing Research, 33, No. 3, August, 1996. Donnelly, J. H., and John M. Ivanovich, ``Post-Purchase Reinforcement and Back-Out Behavior,'' Journal of Marketing Research, August, 1970. Encyclopedia Britannica. Engel, J. F., Kollat, D. T. and Blackwell, R. D., Consumer Behavior, N. Y. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Inc., 1968. Hanna, N., Marketing Principles, (Arabic), Dar Al-Mirreekh for Publishing, Riyadh, 1985. Harb, Bayan Hani, Principles of Marketing (Arabic), Amman, Al-Warraaq Publishing Establishment, 1999. Hassan, S. A., Marketing: Principles and Strategies (Arabic), Riyadh, King Saud University, 1995. Idrees, Thabit Abul-Rahman and Al-Ghais, Mona Rashed, Marketing Management: A Strategic Applied Approach, Kuwait, Al-Falah Bookstore, 1994. Imperia, G., ``Family Purchasing Decisions among Mexicans and Anglos'', Ph.D. dissertation, The University of Texas at Austin, 1982. Kaamel, A., ``How to Protect the Customer from Misleading Information,'' (Arabic), Majallat Al-Mustahlik, Issue No. 2, Year 3, 1995. Kotler,P., Marketing Management, UpperSaddle River,N.J.,Prentice-Hall,Inc.,2000. Kotler, P., Armstrong, G., Principles of Marketing, 9th. edition, Englewood Clis, N.J., Prentice-Hall Inc., 2001. Malhotra, N. K., ``Approach to Measurement of Consumer Preferences Using
334
Consumer Behavior
References
(38) (39) (40) (41) (42) (43) (44) (45) (46) (47) Limited Information,'' Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 23, February 1986. Marn, M. V. and Rosiello, R. L., ``Managing Price Gaining Prot,'' Harvard Business Review, Sept.-Oct., 1992. Maslow, A., Motivation and Personality, N. Y., Harper & Row, 1954. Mohamed, Mahmoud Fouad and Al-Shirbeeny, Abdul-Fattah Mustafa, Consumer Behavior, (Arabic), Cairo, 1993. Murphy, P. E., ``Classifying Products Strategically,'' Journal of Marketing, vol. 50, no. 3, July 1986. Obaidat, Mohamed, Consumer Behavior: A Behaviorist Approach, (Arabic), Amman, Future for Publishing and Distribution, 1995. Obaidat, Mohamed, Principles of Marketing: A Behaviorist Approach, (Arabic), Amman, Middle East Printing Company, 1989. Okaaz (an Arabic daily newspaper, Issue No. 10778, Date: 26 / 9 / 1416H (15 /2/ 1996)), ``The Focus of Consumer Spending on Women and Advertisements,'' Riyadh. Omar, Hussein, Encyclopedia of Economic Terms, Cairo, Maktabat Al-Qaahirah AlHadeethah, 1979. Pleck, Joseph H., Working Wives / Working Husbands, Sage Publications, Beverley Hills, 1986. Qreitam, Abdulhadi, Abu-Rokba, Hassan, and Al-Eesawi, Ibrahim, ``The Saudi Family: Role and Change and their Impact on Decision-Making'', Research Center, College of Economics and Administration, King Abdul-Aziz University, Jeddah, 1401 H. / 1981. Research Center of the Jeddah Chamber of Commerce and Industry, ``Analysis of the Purchase Behavior of Saudi and non-Saudi Women in Jeddah'', 1992. Rogers, E. M. and Shoemaker, F., Communication of Innovations: A Cross-Cultural Approach, N.Y., Free Press, 1971. Schaninger, C. M., and Danko, W. D., ``A Conceptual and Empirical Comparison of Alternative Household Cycle Models,'' Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 19, March 1993. Soliman, Ahmed Ali, Consumer Behavior between Theory and Practice with a Focus on the Saudi Market (Arabic), Riyadh, Institute of Public Administration, 2000. Stanton, William J., Fundamentals of Marketing, 4th. ed., N.Y.: McGraw Hill, 1975. Stanton, William J., Etzel, M. J., Walker, B. J., Fundamentals of Marketing, 9th. ed., N.Y., McGraw Hill, 1991. Ujaimy, Laila M. H., ``The Role of the Makkan Wife in Decision-Making in Choosing Family Clothes and Accessories'', The Girls' College of Education in Makkah, 1989.
Consumer Behavior
335
Book 3: Daily and Nightly Prayers Book 4: Teaching Qur'anic Recitation Book 5: Self-Ruqya Treatment Book 6: Legal Ruqya Book 7: Fasting is Protection Book 8: The Guide to Umrah Book 9: The Guide to Hajj Book 10:
(Arabic - English - French) (Arabic) (Arabic - English) (Arabic) (Arabic - English) (Arabic - English) (Arabic - English)
The following Arabic reference books jointly investigated - co-investigator: Dr. Saad Ibn Abdullah Al-Humayyid:
29. Kitaab Al-'Ilal (Book of Defects of Hadith Evaluation) by Ibn Abi Hatim 30. Mu'jam Al-Tabaraani: Part of Vol. 21, in Musnad Al-Nu'man Ibn Basheer 31. Vol. 13, Mu'jam Al-Tabaraani 32. Su'aalaat Assulami Liddaara-Qutniy (Questions put by Assulami to AlDaara-Qutniy) 33. Ibn Al-Jawzi's Aafat As-haab Al-Hadeeth (The Problem with Hadith Researchers)
D D D D D
Was born in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, in 1384 H (1964 AD). Holds a Ph. D. in Business Administration, from Kensington University, USA - doctoral dissertation on marketing philosophy. Holds another Ph. D. in Business Administration, from Al-Awza'iy University in Lebanon - doctoral dissertation: Types of Leadership Behavior from Islamic and Administrative Perspectives. Holds a master's degree in Business Administration, from Al-Imam Al-Awza'iy University in Lebanon - master's thesis on: "Time Management from Administrative and Islamic Perspectives". Holds a BA in Islamic Studies, from the College of Arts and Humanities, King Abdul-Aziz University in Jeddah. Has been the Executive President of the Riyadh House Company, the well-known Saudi leading business organization, since 1993. Has written several books on various religious, social, historical and administrative issues. Is the founder and supervisor general of alaluka website (www.alukah.net).
Is member of the following academic societies:
The Saudi Management Association - headquarters at King Saud University. The Society of Arab Managers - headquarters in Cairo. The Saudi Economic Association - headquarters at King Saud University. The Union of Arab Economists, headquarters in Baghdad. The Saudi Historical Society, headquarters at King Saud University. The Union of Arab Historians - headquarters in Cairo.